I have a question which only a Jewish scholar could answer. Background:Along time ago, I found out that the Jewish bible, calls the Armenians Khurrites. Hourites. The Armenians call the Jews Hurriah. To me, they both seem to mean Hurrian. Question: Why do the the Armenians and the Jews call each other by the same name? Question: Why do I have the Cohanim gene; JM267 and why are 12% of Armenians J1 and another 12% are J2. ?
@@eddemian Far more than 12% of Armenians are J2, almost all Armenians are J2/R1b as the earliest Armenians were a mix of Indo-Europeans, hence the R1b, and Hurrians, which is the J2.
Holy Jesus!!! Now I know where my Ashkenazi Jewish DNA comes from!!! And I'm mostly Armenian with Assyrian mix ! My second cousin's last names are also Abelian which further connects the dots!!! Thank you
Armenians revolted their own state collaborating with enemies of the Ottoman Empire like Russia France UK and US. They first started working with enemies underground but later openly taking part in the invading enemy armies as the Empire falling apart . They were traitors and fighting against Turkish army. What do you expect the Turks to do? Just sit and watch 😂
Когда доступным станут земли исторической Армении слой за слоем откроется вся историческая правда древнейшего армянского народа а так же дальнейшее изучение древнеармянского языка пролет свет зарождение многих индоевропейских народов и цивилизации вообщем
I can talk to this man for hours, one thing I don’t understand why is the oldest known Armenian manuscript from the year 861? What happened to all the other manuscipts written from 401 AD until 9th century?
A question to respected Dr Stone. When a crime is committed against a whole nation and the criminal does not acknowledge of the existance of the fact, then all the following generations of the victimized nation carry in their dna, or psychology, in the most subtle way, that pain, anger, victim mentality....you name it. Having lived in Germany I witessed every morning, programmes on the German radio where ordinary germans over and over again were apologising what they did to the Jewish people. Germans were deliberately marrying Jews to wipe the guilt that they felt for the wrong doings of their ancestors. Not once has Turkey apologised for the crime they committed against the Armenian nation. There is ONE proven fact, and that is --- WHEN A CRIMINAL ADMITS THAT THE CRIME WAS COMMITED AND MOST IMPORTANT- APOLOGISES, THEN AUTOMATICALLY HEALING TAKES PLACE AND THE FOLLOWING GENERATIONS DO NOT CARRY AND SUFFER THE PAIN OF THEIR FOREFATHERS. Would be very interesting to know as to why. For it is also well documented that no one lives on the territories where the massacres took place and the turkish people are very much afraid to settle on those lands because they carry the deeply inbeded fear and the guilt in their hearts of wrong doings of their forefathers. Maybe you can reveal something that spreads some light onto this ongoing problem and thus help to put an end to this? Thank you once more!💓
Before Christianity many Armenian towns were predominately Jewish and then they some how they disappeared after Christianity was excepted by waves of native Armenians..
Armenians have been living in Armenian highlands since the beginning of the recorded history dating back 12,000 years. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ughtasar_Petroglyphs
@@ArthaxtaDaVince777 Armenians weren't properly Zoroastrian. The Persians didn't recognize us as having the same religion as them. We also had our own beliefs, but lazy historians have identified them as Iranian when they are actually native Armenian. There were Jewish Armenians. Tigran the Great brought 10,000 Jews to Armenia, according to legend, and settled them around Lake Van. Those people assimilated but kept a few Jewish customs.
@@bobsmithradates7346 Yes, I know, we had an Armenian "variant" of the Zoroastrian faith, instead of the standard "Ahura Mazda" we had "Aramazd." But the Persians did indeed recognize us Armenians of having the Zoroastrian faith, they knew it was unique and different with Armenian elements, but its like the difference between "God" and "Allah." Before the Zoroastrian faith, Armenians worshiped Mithra and spread the faith to Rome, and even before that, during the Kingdom of Urartu, Armenians were Khalid, they worshiped a deity known in Hurrian as "Haldi" but in our Indo-European interpretation, he is Hayk, who was a warrior god and the King of the Armenian gods.
@@ArthaxtaDaVince777 The Persians apparently recognized us as Mazdaists, but something separate from them. By the way, Ormadz was Ahura Madza. Sometimes I doubt that some of these were Iranian loans at all--like Aramadz, and not a native Armenian variant of Aram (perhaps deified). Armenians are now believed to be as close to Indo-Iranians as we are Greeks/Phrygians, so it's likely that native Armenian beliefs had some similarities with Indo-Iranian beliefs from the get-go. Anahit is likely native and not an Iranian loan too (compare to Anat, Nane, Hani/Ani, etc). Mithra/Mher is an Iranian loan though, and equated to Khaldi. There was no Khaldi in Hurrian. Khaldi has nothing to do with the Hurrians. Originally, Khaldi was an "Akkadian" god. The cult of Khaldi wasn't worshipped by the Urartians until the 3rd-4th king, Ishpuini. A concept of Hayk likely already existed by this time. I will say, I do wonder if Khaldi is a version of Ardi, which would suggest an Armenian and not Akkadian origin (i.e. the Akkadians borrowed Ardi from Armenians).
Armenian historian Gevorg Aslan wrote in his book "Armenia and the Armenians": "The Armenians did not have statehood. They are not bound by the feeling of the Motherland and are not bound by political ties. Armenian patriotism is associated only with the place of residence." The chimerical idea of recreating "Great Armenia", which has never existed as a state, is a nationwide concept that unites all the hays of the world.
They have had statehood and kings. They were always invaded by stronger neighbours. Last historic kingdom was Kingdom of Cilicia. There are about 4000 Armenian historic sites, castles, churches etc. in Eastern Turkey. Eastern Turkey was called Armenian Highlands/Armenian Kingdom.
@@tamarchristians8100 Here are your ancient cities, their remains, here are the tombs of the kings of your lands, the archeological evidence of every history, you don't have them, so don't write a false history
Iam jewish and I love and a dour armenian history and people and Armenia and we have a lots in common in every aspect . I love you Dear Armenia.
agree, a lot of history, for thousands of years..
The Amaleck name has been called on many people which is stupid, because according to the bible they were all wiped out!
Shalom! God bless you!
I have a question which only a Jewish scholar could answer.
Background:Along time ago, I found out that the Jewish bible, calls the Armenians Khurrites. Hourites. The Armenians call the Jews Hurriah. To me, they both seem to mean Hurrian.
Question: Why do the the Armenians and the Jews call each other by the same name?
Question: Why do I have the Cohanim gene; JM267 and why are 12% of Armenians J1 and another 12% are J2. ?
@@eddemian Far more than 12% of Armenians are J2, almost all Armenians are J2/R1b as the earliest Armenians were a mix of Indo-Europeans, hence the R1b, and Hurrians, which is the J2.
I love the Armenian people, keep up this great work.
These types of Historians are heroes in mankind.
What a treasure this man is having studied and published this valuable information and holding this incredible knowledge
Enjoyable interview -thank you
What a wonderful man, I hope he gets to live a long, beautiful life. God bless him!
I wish I could speak Armenian as well he can, unbelievable his accent and pronunciations are perfect
Thank you Dr. Stone
Hi Vano at what moment like what youtube minute / second is he talking Armenian i seem to have missed it?
Thank you very much for this informative programme. Very much hope to see Mr. Stone again with more of the same. 💓
Dr. Stone, respect and gratitude to you.
Wow I’m learning more and more of my family’s history in Tabriz and then I find this video it’s amazing thank you!
Bravo !!! Thank you Professor Michael
Hi Dr. Stone (: where can I hear/see the recording of this special dialect
Holy Jesus!!! Now I know where my Ashkenazi Jewish DNA comes from!!! And I'm mostly Armenian with Assyrian mix !
My second cousin's last names are also Abelian which further connects the dots!!!
Thank you
Every Armenian I know comes up with much Jewish DNA and there's a reason, :)
Armenians were massacred in their own land. That is the difference between Armenian Genocide and Jewish Holocaust.
Armenians revolted their own state collaborating with enemies of the Ottoman Empire like Russia France UK and US. They first started working with enemies underground but later openly taking part in the invading enemy armies as the Empire falling apart . They were traitors and fighting against Turkish army. What do you expect the Turks to do? Just sit and watch 😂
Когда доступным станут земли исторической Армении слой за слоем откроется вся историческая правда древнейшего армянского народа а так же дальнейшее изучение древнеармянского языка пролет свет зарождение многих индоевропейских народов и цивилизации вообщем
I can talk to this man for hours, one thing I don’t understand why is the oldest known Armenian manuscript from the year 861? What happened to all the other manuscipts written from 401 AD until 9th century?
Изучение армянских первоисточников поможет нам многое понять при решении проблем Ближнего Востока,Генри
Respects
A question to respected Dr Stone. When a crime is committed against a whole nation and the criminal does not acknowledge of the existance of the fact, then all the following generations of the victimized nation carry in their dna, or psychology, in the most subtle way, that pain, anger, victim mentality....you name it. Having lived in Germany I witessed every morning, programmes on the German radio where ordinary germans over and over again were apologising what they did to the Jewish people. Germans were deliberately marrying Jews to wipe the guilt that they felt for the wrong doings of their ancestors. Not once has Turkey apologised for the crime they committed against the Armenian nation. There is ONE proven fact, and that is --- WHEN A CRIMINAL ADMITS THAT THE CRIME WAS COMMITED AND MOST IMPORTANT- APOLOGISES, THEN AUTOMATICALLY HEALING TAKES PLACE AND THE FOLLOWING GENERATIONS DO NOT CARRY AND SUFFER THE PAIN OF THEIR FOREFATHERS. Would be very interesting to know as to why. For it is also well documented that no one lives on the territories where the massacres took place and the turkish people are very much afraid to settle on those lands because they carry the deeply inbeded fear and the guilt in their hearts of wrong doings of their forefathers. Maybe you can reveal something that spreads some light onto this ongoing problem and thus help to put an end to this? Thank you once more!💓
I have a news for you. There’s no crime to apologize. It’s your delusion just like that fake country of yours Fartsakh😊
👍
damn....
Hi Dr. Stone (: where can I hear/see the recording of this special dialect
շատ լաւ՜ ruclips.net/video/lgT7Kz0mAro/видео.html
A real historian, not a paid propagandist.
НЕ ЧИГО ОСОБЕНОГО ЭТОТ ЧЕЛОВЕК НЕ ГОВОРИТ....!
Ничего
Armenian is the same Aramean (Aramaic ) language
No it's not.
Thank you very much
Its weird because I always thought most jews dislike armenians.
The donmehs did the genocide, not turks, they were called d Young turks.
Such an intellectual interviewed by an absolute amateur, all the questions she asked were so hollow and stupid.
Before Christianity many Armenian towns were predominately Jewish and then they some how they disappeared after Christianity was excepted by waves of native Armenians..
Armenians have been living in Armenian highlands since the beginning of the recorded history dating back 12,000 years. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ughtasar_Petroglyphs
Armenians were Zoroastrian not Jewish.
@@ArthaxtaDaVince777 Armenians weren't properly Zoroastrian. The Persians didn't recognize us as having the same religion as them. We also had our own beliefs, but lazy historians have identified them as Iranian when they are actually native Armenian.
There were Jewish Armenians. Tigran the Great brought 10,000 Jews to Armenia, according to legend, and settled them around Lake Van. Those people assimilated but kept a few Jewish customs.
@@bobsmithradates7346 Yes, I know, we had an Armenian "variant" of the Zoroastrian faith, instead of the standard "Ahura Mazda" we had "Aramazd." But the Persians did indeed recognize us Armenians of having the Zoroastrian faith, they knew it was unique and different with Armenian elements, but its like the difference between "God" and "Allah." Before the Zoroastrian faith, Armenians worshiped Mithra and spread the faith to Rome, and even before that, during the Kingdom of Urartu, Armenians were Khalid, they worshiped a deity known in Hurrian as "Haldi" but in our Indo-European interpretation, he is Hayk, who was a warrior god and the King of the Armenian gods.
@@ArthaxtaDaVince777 The Persians apparently recognized us as Mazdaists, but something separate from them. By the way, Ormadz was Ahura Madza. Sometimes I doubt that some of these were Iranian loans at all--like Aramadz, and not a native Armenian variant of Aram (perhaps deified). Armenians are now believed to be as close to Indo-Iranians as we are Greeks/Phrygians, so it's likely that native Armenian beliefs had some similarities with Indo-Iranian beliefs from the get-go. Anahit is likely native and not an Iranian loan too (compare to Anat, Nane, Hani/Ani, etc). Mithra/Mher is an Iranian loan though, and equated to Khaldi. There was no Khaldi in Hurrian. Khaldi has nothing to do with the Hurrians. Originally, Khaldi was an "Akkadian" god. The cult of Khaldi wasn't worshipped by the Urartians until the 3rd-4th king, Ishpuini. A concept of Hayk likely already existed by this time. I will say, I do wonder if Khaldi is a version of Ardi, which would suggest an Armenian and not Akkadian origin (i.e. the Akkadians borrowed Ardi from Armenians).
Armenian historian Gevorg Aslan wrote in his book "Armenia and the Armenians": "The Armenians did not have statehood. They are not bound by the feeling of the Motherland and are not bound by political ties. Armenian patriotism is associated only with the place of residence." The chimerical idea of recreating "Great Armenia", which has never existed as a state, is a nationwide concept that unites all the hays of the world.
They have had statehood and kings. They were always invaded by stronger neighbours. Last historic kingdom was Kingdom of Cilicia. There are about 4000 Armenian historic sites, castles, churches etc. in Eastern Turkey. Eastern Turkey was called Armenian Highlands/Armenian Kingdom.
@@tamarchristians8100 i am sorry but this is wery big lie
@@alfablack1050 - Pls. go and read real history books, and Armenian Kings.
@@tamarchristians8100 Here are your ancient cities, their remains, here are the tombs of the kings of your lands, the archeological evidence of every history, you don't have them, so don't write a false history
@@tamarchristians8100 armenian kings🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣