Such a great songwriter. He had a way of choosing his songs for albums that worked really well for commercial success, but definitely left some killer tracks out from time to time. I'm glad there was a time and a place to release those b-sides.
So badly wish this song made the live rotation more. It's cool that they reinterpret it a bit here but man I would love just once to see it done live with JC faithfully recreating the recorded version.
My mum used to blast these guys when I was only a tot and it has never left me. Fucking love them now. This song really reminds me of those care free days as a child. This song creates the best vibe. Just such a great sound.
Gina P you just made me feel old....thanks....saw them in 94....3000 people with Garbage State theater down town Detroit...... first show at the Palace of Auborn Hills...secomd show was moved to a smaller venue
I think you highly undervalue music as a means of conveying emotion. You don't need to treat your life like a film to feel something in a song that you can't put words to.
@kevman5 - I was talking about actual music, not mastering methods. However, I know that in their purest forms, that analogue is superior to digital, but in practical terms, digital gives a better sound. It's only when you can afford a top of the line record player, playing a record in perfect shape, that you can get sound better than a CD or other digital format. You said that there are bits taken out of modern music, then "more is not better." So, you like modern mastering methods?
No I don't. I am just aware that because a song draws certain emotions from within you a certain way, that it may not do the same for another. It would be far more effective for this person to tell the other exactly how they feel because no song written by someone else will ever that. What I did once was write a letter for a person to read whilst listening to a particular song. It's more effective when someone is reading your own thoughts and not interpret those of someone you don't even know.
Well its not very hard. Its just 3 simple notes for the first part and then one added note for the chorus lol. I think your probably refering to the pedal hes using to get the sound.
feels perfect... i need an stranger's opinion please... you see, my boyfriend will break up with me sometime this weekend... and to "say goodbye" i'm planning to play this song for him... but i need to know what the song means to another person. would you play it for someone you loved?
I don't think you should treat your life like a film... Your probably better off telling how you feel rather than relying on the hope that he interprets this song the way you want him too. Take it from someone going through a nasty break up at the minute. This is no doubt 3 months too late though...
This is true, but if they both don't see the same thing from the song, then they don't connect on the level that the person thinks they should. It is a little fairy-taleish, thinking you'd have the same musical-emotional temperment as the person you're dating, but if you're a musical person, it's an important thing to consider. This is all my opinion, and I apologize for my earlier comment, I realized how rude that sounded after I'd already hit the Post Comment button.
This is absolutely my favorite pumpkins song…this live version is so epic to me. Absolutely amazing 🤩🫡😎
It baffles me that this song was left off both Siamese Dream and Mellon Collie. It's such an awesome tune.
Such a great songwriter. He had a way of choosing his songs for albums that worked really well for commercial success, but definitely left some killer tracks out from time to time.
I'm glad there was a time and a place to release those b-sides.
For real…this is my favorite song by smashing pumpkins and maybe my favorite song ever.
This song Is a journey to my youth.
Aeroplane Flies High did pretty good as a b sides compilation.
I love this song. I think it would fit better on Siamese Dream than on MCATIS. It just has that more dreamy, sleepy Siamese Dream vibe
That bass line is the hearth of this song with ghost notes on drum snare... amazing...
Its the drums....
And D’arcy played it. Yes.
@@megminor13 lol we all know who played the bass on these tracks.
@@srt4bThat's not Darcy, it's Ginger
I was here - I really couldn't believe my ears from the opening note...
Wow...jealous
Their most underrated song. Really encompassed that Pumpkins essence
takes me back to the 90's....listening to this song over and over again. soundtrack of my life :)
pretty much my favorite song in the world
very good sound quality. i love all the pumpkins songs but gems like this and other b-sides are incredible.
Hands down my favorite SP song and this live version is amazing. I miss Jimmy!!!
But Jimmy is alive and well and doing amazing! Don't miss him! Celebrate him!!
Heeessss back
THE. THE BEST DRUM TRACK. EVER. SO JAZZY
one of my favorite pumpkins songs, def has layers here
Set the Ray to Jerry is an awesome song. Defo, one of my favourite pumpkins songs. :)
So badly wish this song made the live rotation more. It's cool that they reinterpret it a bit here but man I would love just once to see it done live with JC faithfully recreating the recorded version.
My favorite Pumpkins song and a testament to what this band used to be.
oh dear once upon a time...
this guy wrote just excellent songs.
Never stopped
He never stopped, but nowadays he just writes a large amount of bad songs in between.
Saw them play that year and my life was changed
The guitar is eerily stimulating. I love it. I wish I knew how to play guitar like that.
My mum used to blast these guys when I was only a tot and it has never left me. Fucking love them now. This song really reminds me of those care free days as a child. This song creates the best vibe. Just such a great sound.
Gina P you just made me feel old....thanks....saw them in 94....3000 people with Garbage State theater down town Detroit...... first show at the Palace of Auborn Hills...secomd show was moved to a smaller venue
Love this song. Love this performance. Love Billy. Nuff said.
Amen bro, the new solos kick ass, it really adds a fantastic new element to an already kick ass song. Long live billy corgan! \m/
Great performance, thanks for sharing.🖖🤘
This is such a jam..
Amazing. I can't believe they played this in my home state and I couldn't be there to witness it.
Totally awesome, love this song & this is a great version live- Thanks for uploading! ;)
I played this in the last week at least 20 times a day...
❤️
bella bella.... grazie per questo video..
I think you highly undervalue music as a means of conveying emotion. You don't need to treat your life like a film to feel something in a song that you can't put words to.
my fav!
Preciosa canción ^^
first ime hearing it live... yaya. :)
I love ittttt
god!!!
depois de tanto tempo ele stocam esse som maravilhoso ao vivo
I'l be seeing them live this upcoming august on there tour with greenday I and Im really hoping they play this song
awesome chooooon!!
touch you...
4:03 ufff
me too!!
It's clear that Billy was really feeling this just then...
Wow that solo was something else. Wish he dragged it out.
This bald dude has a great band!!!
He's God as far as your concerned
Jeff did a good job!
It looked like he was sleeping
esta se puede decir oficialmente como la ultima formacion ahora es billy corgan solista
ok!!!
After Adore when he started to have voice coaching to do that weird vibrato thing :(
yay!
video is off from the sound. but it still sounds awesome!
just a clue...it's not upper derby, it's upper darby.
Love this song!!! But I think Jeff may be off time with the rest of the band
Lol I hear it.
@kevman5 - I was talking about actual music, not mastering methods. However, I know that in their purest forms, that analogue is superior to digital, but in practical terms, digital gives a better sound. It's only when you can afford a top of the line record player, playing a record in perfect shape, that you can get sound better than a CD or other digital format. You said that there are bits taken out of modern music, then "more is not better." So, you like modern mastering methods?
temazo! mi tema fav del single de 1979
pero me carga esa bajista!
@BayviewFinch While I agree with most of that I will say that today's mastering methods take a bit out of the music. more is not better.
No I don't. I am just aware that because a song draws certain emotions from within you a certain way, that it may not do the same for another.
It would be far more effective for this person to tell the other exactly how they feel because no song written by someone else will ever that.
What I did once was write a letter for a person to read whilst listening to a particular song. It's more effective when someone is reading your own thoughts and not interpret those of someone you don't even know.
Well its not very hard. Its just 3 simple notes for the first part and then one added note for the chorus lol.
I think your probably refering to the pedal hes using to get the sound.
Nope that was D’arcy’s part. Can’t duplicate her. Sorry.
feels perfect...
i need an stranger's opinion please... you see, my boyfriend will break up with me sometime this weekend... and to "say goodbye" i'm planning to play this song for him... but i need to know what the song means to another person.
would you play it for someone you loved?
Hii 😅 this comment is so sad
Jimmy's rushing it a little but great in general
I don't think you should treat your life like a film...
Your probably better off telling how you feel rather than relying on the hope that he interprets this song the way you want him too.
Take it from someone going through a nasty break up at the minute.
This is no doubt 3 months too late though...
This is true, but if they both don't see the same thing from the song, then they don't connect on the level that the person thinks they should. It is a little fairy-taleish, thinking you'd have the same musical-emotional temperment as the person you're dating, but if you're a musical person, it's an important thing to consider. This is all my opinion, and I apologize for my earlier comment, I realized how rude that sounded after I'd already hit the Post Comment button.
lots of Molly MDMA during this time for them
#ZERO
i would do it for sure!!! it's a great song to be played in that kind of moments =)
❤️