After several months' work, I'm delighted to take you on an intergalactic voyage of discovery through space-time under all its forms! For an immersive experience, the video is best viewed on a large screen, in the dark, and with headphones or speakers. The 5 tracks I composed for the musical background can be listened to independently on SoundCloud: soundcloud.com/aroussel/sets/voyage-a-travers-lespace-temps
I heard from some other channel there was a recent paper questioning whether real black holes had practical singularities. Does this visualization incorporate that paper?
@@ggj1987 yeah the trampoline example is garbage because it fails to show motion of space. It rather suggests that space just bends and remains static. I think showing the trampoline to kids actually makes them dumber. At least don’t START with that analogy lol
@@SlampthChompth yeah you've got people here in the comments arguing that space-time can't move therefore the animation is shit. The e only ever seen gravity explained on the sheet.
I was amazed because it was exactly how I imagined Spacetime "looked" like in 3 dimensions. Mass gobbles spacetime, and dark energy gives it back, and slighty more than was gobbled. A mystery in itself
Nobody stays the same person after watching this video. Thank you, RUclips Algorithm. Spacetime, gravitational waves, Black holes, neutron stars, gravity itself so perfectly explained in a unearthly way. Thanks a lot.
I heard Michelle Thaller describe it this way a few years ago. It was the first time I'd heard of spacetime described like that. This visual just made it that much more real.
@@kwimms "the religion of science" You're projecting. Just because your religion is religious doesn't mean that science is also religious. Scientists don't hold ideas to be absolutely certain. We hold things to various degrees of probable certainty depending on the evidence for the claim. In the case of relativity, gravity, and spacetime, our current models are, as far as we know, the best and most accurate explanation of reality. Perhaps one day we will have to modify our understanding - that's the process of science. Science deniers often act as if every time something new is discovered, that the entire puzzle board is overturned. That's not what happens. Science is like a jigsaw puzzle where we're constantly finding and adding new pieces, and though we don't have it complete, we have a basic idea of how the final picture looks. Every now and then we realize one of the pieces we thought was in the right place actually didn't quite fit as perfectly as we thought, and in fact there's another piece that fits better. But none of this changes the overall puzzle. Once in a great while we may realize after putting in a particular new puzzle piece that it actually changes our conception of what the final image would look like - but that's rare (Einstein discovering relativity would be an example of that). But again - the overall puzzle (which represents humanity's great attempt at explaining the natural world) remains in progress. It's not a perfect process but it's literally the only method humanity has to discover and explain reality. I mean, it sure beats "such and such ancient book says..."
Fabulous video as always, one correction though: At 6:25 its shown that if someone jumps through the earth, they'd come out on the other side. What actually would happen is they'd accelerate from 0 to some max velocity till reaching the center, and after that start decelerating in the same fashion, and by the time they reach the other side their velocity would be 0, and then back again and they'd be oscillating And practically I'd assume with some drag the oscillations will dampen right? Some few hundred years and the person would settle in the center. The whole setup is analogous to letting off a marble at the edge of a bowl, but instead in a one dimensional motion in this case
Now i understand how space time works I been watching space documentary for over 10 years I been listening to every single space professor But non could explain space time like you did Thank you
I don't wanna take away from the man but... I just don't see how anyone who knows relativity doesn't understand this. To animate it is a whole nother thing
@asor8037 can't say something is something without some form of substantial evidence to dispute the current claim. Otherwise please take your ass back to school.
Dear Alesandro Roussel, Octave Masson and JP Chatelain, Lyla. I work as a vacuum expert on the next generation gravitational wave detector, Einstein Telescope. A collaboration of over 1600 people at the moment of writing. If somehow you are not jet involved, you are very welcome to connect with us. I extent to you an invitation to come and visit my home institute: Nikhef in Amsterdam. I am sure there are many people interested in your animation and work, within the collaboration of the Einstein Telescope... My greatest compliments to all of you for your animation!
Your videos are works of art. I cried while watching this due to the sheer magnificence of our universe, the mysteries it still holds and our tiny place in it. Thank you for bringing these concepts, explanations, visuals, and soundtracks to RUclips so lay people like me can experience the awe alongside you. Keep it up!
Brilliant!!! No more stretched-sheet gravity demos - THIS is how it's meant to be shown. Finally someone did it and made an excellent job of it. Nice work!! Love it
This is my preferred explanation of gravity.. but it seems not the most popular. I have listened to dozens of talks on the subject and most describe space as statically stretched. The flowing of space makes SO much more sense.
the sheet analog is perfectly fine for the Newtonian regime: depth -> potential -> time dilation (analogy->newton->weak field Einstein). it does lack a third dimension of space, tho...and that throws some ppl. idk, I think its a good start. In a rotating BH, there's more to worry about.
I rarely comment on RUclips videos, but this is by far one of the best spacetime explainer videos out there; finally, someone is able to show spacetime in 3D. Hats off to the animator and the entire team for creating this. I'm so happy I found this channel!!!
@@mat.se57 He is no showing the 4th dimension, space-time is space with moving object within, as if there was not time and only space, everything would be static, the 4th dimension is iconically shown in Interstellar, such as a library where you can see frames of existence in different times all at once.
Such a shame that you don’t do longer length videos as your seriously on topic and your voice is soothing aswell. You’d easily be up there amongst the best of space RUclipsrs.
Wow. For 40 years I could never get my head around what this stuff is, gravity, spacetime and their relationship, why planets don’t fly off. This was just incredible. What’s more, it shows just how easy it is to understand, it’s so frigging simple. Kudos to you all for this. Beautiful.
I’m no Carl Sagan; in fact, Astronomy was the only course in which I ever received an F on an exam (didn’t read the chapter on stars-when I told the professor my Scantron _looked_ like a Red Giant, he was unmoved for a bonus point). I digress … I’ve just binged about two hours here and can go on forever! This is soothing, educational, entertaining, and HIGHLY informative! “Ya listenin, RUclips?!” 👌👍🤟😮💨
The work you put into these videos is phenomenal, and provides new intuitive ways to approach visualizing these scientific phenomena. As always, well done!
the quality on this one is top tier on what's currently available on the internet. my biggest congratulations man, this is absolutely brilliant and deserving all the praise
This is hands down the most incredible space/science channel on the platform. The commentary, visuals, and quality is light years beyond what I’ve seen from other channels, including channels with millions of subs. I’ll never stop recommending these videos to my friends. We all love them.
Your videos and the knowledge shared with us, simple humans, is another level of empathy and appreciation for the science. This will remain here forever. Humbly I thank you to share parts of this wonderful universe, in simple words, with all of us.
@@oldtimer2192 it doesn't make sense to me. They display the grid as a coordinate system but the points in the grid moves with gravity. So even though you stay on the same coordinate you are still moving. That seems like a paradox to me
@@jonaskarlsson5901in freefall, you are not moving per se (relative to local spacetime), only moving compared to objects that are resisting gravity. The ground is actively counteracting gravity through the normal force at +9.8m/s^2. To a person in freefall, it is not them that is moving, but rather the ground accelerating upwards to meet them. Perhaps I may be inaccurate on a few parts since I am not an expert, but this is my explanation to the best of my understanding.
Truly mind blowing, awesome animations too. I can't even begin to imagine an event happening a billion years ago and we just felt the vibrations from it. Wow.
I've never seen the fate of stars and gravity illustrated and described with such simplicity and eloquence. I understand these things a lot better now. Thank you so much for making this video!
You've no clue how anxiously I wait for your videos!! This among other channels have motivated me to learn higher mathematics and physics. I firsly understood general relativity 3 years ago at 16 years old when I saw your videos explaining it.
I absolutely love this channel. It’s what has pushed me to go into the Space Sciences field. This video is incredible and I will definitely be watching it again.
Yeah, that's the best way to visualise spacetime I've ever seen! He has a video introducing the model in a more detailed way, from a few years ago. What gives it even more weight is that it's physically accurate (the "river model" of spacetime).
Your vids helped me finally understand how space-time works. The "classical" representations didn't speak to me, I struggled with them without success. You gave me the CLICK I was looking for. On top of this, your videos are masterpieces in terms of execution. Thank you so much!
This channel deserves way more views and subscribers. Those animations and explanations are awesome. Unlike a lot of other sources that try to dumb down the information to be approachable this channel succeeds by making stunning animations to explain complex concepts on a more intuitive level. It's like the perfect combination between PBS SpaceTime and 3B1B. Thank you so much for your channel and the time you put in.
I once did research on physics for a school work... This was the visualization I had in my head all these years, and it is good to see it represented here, just as I imagined it when I was a teenager...
This is absolutely phenomenal! The way you visualized the fabric of spacetime is incredible. Not to mention, the accurate representation of gravity and how it actually works, with the fabric being pinched and pulled inwards instead of the infamous ball-on-a-sheet example which is kind of misleading, other than the fact it's 2D. I've also never an animation so accurately depicting the formation of black holes. Take a bow!
Wow, I saw one of the comments mentioning it was well worth watching so I gave it a shot and damn, it’s the best video I’ve seen so far on space and time
I love you. You are one of the best content creators I’ve ever encountered. I thank you immensely for helping me maintain contact with my passion for these incredible, yet complex topics.
I live in a third world country where the people do not have basic amenities talk more of being able to afford them. I am educated, by the standard of my country at least, and concepts like space and time are spoken about in physics and chemistry classes but they're never really put into perspective for people to grasp. I started using the internet at an early age of 9 and as such, I was exposed to the nature of the world around me. I'm currently in my early twenties and I've realized that it's not just the people in my country that do not get the bigger picture but most people in the world! It got me wondering why we humans have such a troubled existence and I quickly arrived at an answer: we do not know what we are. When I think about the cosmos - which I do ever so often with a friend of mine - I realize how special I am. How special we really are. That we've come to be in this unquantifiable "mess" is no easy feat. We are even more mysterious and special than the universe itself. I dream of a time when humanity will discard its differences and see itself as one ever driving force whose purpose is to look at the big picture and decipher its meaning or even give it meaning if it so happens that it is of a random cause.
The first time I saw your graphical representation of curved spacetime, it clicked for me and it’s how my brain now conceptualises the structure of the Universe. Einstein truly was a clever chap!
came here from that Veritasium video where you guys provided the simulation visuals for black holes/spacetime. Excellent stuff. Great visuals to explain such tough theoretical concepts.
I wish many more people sit through and watch such educational videos. Even if you dont understand the terms and definitions you can still immerse yourself into this masterpiece!! Such visuals should be used in academies and actual lectures of gravity/ any other topic. HOPE YOU FIND MUCH MORE SUCCESS YOU ARE ALREADY ON TOP SCIENCECLIC!!!
That white hole part was just a split second but it was enough to completely transport me someplace else. Your videos renew our passion and interest for normal people like me. Grazie mille!
Doooooooooood. I feel like i've been waiting and begging for this video for forever. This was FANTASTIC! Hats off to the developers and animators that it took to make this. I've sent this to everyone I know.
Beyond impressive and mesmerising to watch. I watched science TV since child and watch YT creators everyday who cover science/astronomy and this has to be one of the most extraordinary depictions of gravity I’ve ever seen. Thx for producing such a wonderful video and sharing it
i honestly hate that this is not even the tip of the iceberg... it's barely a snowflake on the tip of the iceberg. and it took us so long just to put together this much.... there is so much we'll never know in this lifetime
This was just absolutely mind blowing! the work done by you guys is insanely good and it will surely help young physicists get a natural feel for how gravity actually works. great job as always!
Good video, but at 0:24 you say "billions of billions of kilometers from earth". At that hypothetical distance, between both galaxies, it would actually be billions of *light* *years* away, which completely dwarfs the "kilometers" measurement, like comparing the distance between atoms to miles.
A billion light years is pretty far. That’s like a 13th of the entire universe. And idk if you know this but the universe is pretty big. Billions of kilometres is accurate.
@@strawsquash No. Billions of "kilometers" is NOT accurint. Both of us were wrong. The Andromeda galaxy is 2.5 MILLION LIGHT YEARS from earth, which is twenty-three quintillion seven hundred fifty quadrillion kilometers. As I alluded, _most_ galaxies are at least billions of light years away. BUT since he did mention the Andromeda galaxy specifically, which is fairly close to us relative to the size of the universe, I was incorrect in my distance assessment. But of course, so were you. Your statement that Andromeda is merely "Billions" of kilometers away is also far from accurate. Our own sun, which is a star right on our own doorstep, is 151 million kilometers from Earth, and that is over 1/10th of a billion kilometers. And there are an estimated 100 billion stars in just our own galaxy, each of which is an an enormous distance away. Proxima Centauri is the nearest star to Earth (after our own sun) is 4.2 light years away, which is 39.9 TRILLION kilometers away. Yes, I DO know that the Universe is *BIG*. Big enough for us to both make mistakes.
@@privatename3621 no you were mostly wrong, sorry to say. You were unhappy with his use of billions of billions of kilometers. A billion-billion kilometers is 1e18 kilometers. 2.5 million light years is 2.37e19 kilometers. The original video was correct.
@@ExternusArmy Which is what I just said dork. I pointed out that I was wrong, but YOU WE'RE MUCH WRONG-ER. And who TF says "billions of billions"?? Is that a weird British thing? When most Americans here the phrase "billions OF billions", they think the person misspoke, as it is far more common to say "billions AND billions", which is why I missed it the first time. But there are actual names for things like "billions of billions" (such as "quintillion" which is what I pointed out). People don't go around saying "hundreds of hundreds of hundreds." That's silly. They same "millions" because that is the proper name for it. But whatever.
After several months' work, I'm delighted to take you on an intergalactic voyage of discovery through space-time under all its forms! For an immersive experience, the video is best viewed on a large screen, in the dark, and with headphones or speakers. The 5 tracks I composed for the musical background can be listened to independently on SoundCloud: soundcloud.com/aroussel/sets/voyage-a-travers-lespace-temps
I dunno what software you use to create these breathtaking renders, but this is phenomenal work
It is a masterpiece, the music, the animations, the content, it is a pleasure to learn from your hardworked videos.
I heard from some other channel there was a recent paper questioning whether real black holes had practical singularities. Does this visualization incorporate that paper?
Very nice visuals, also top notch music well done
Well worth the effort. Your channel is magical.
Wouldn’t forgive myself if I didn’t take this moment to acknowledge the best visuals for a black hole accretion disc ever made. Magical.
Glad you liked it 🙏
Yeah it's genuinely so good instead of just the same old flat disk everyone makes
I was like omg when i saw the disc 🙏
fr@@ScienceClicEN
@@ScienceClicEN liked it is an understatement this changed my life lol
This has gotta be one of the best animations I’ve seen for gravity.
Yes. Usually they show the trampoline example but that’s just in one plane. This is in all directions, much more realistic visualisation
@@ggj1987 yeah the trampoline example is garbage because it fails to show motion of space. It rather suggests that space just bends and remains static. I think showing the trampoline to kids actually makes them dumber. At least don’t START with that analogy lol
@@SlampthChompthyou're saying everything I came to the comments to say :)
@@SlampthChompth yeah you've got people here in the comments arguing that space-time can't move therefore the animation is shit. The e only ever seen gravity explained on the sheet.
@@ggj1987the trampoline always bothered me but I could never say why. I just knew intuitively it was a bad representation.
Finally, a 3D depiction of gravity, not the trampoline example.
I was amazed because it was exactly how I imagined Spacetime "looked" like in 3 dimensions.
Mass gobbles spacetime, and dark energy gives it back, and slighty more than was gobbled. A mystery in itself
Imagine being able to just see this in your head and then figuring out how to describe it using pen and paper. Very humbling.
Nobody stays the same person after watching this video. Thank you, RUclips Algorithm. Spacetime, gravitational waves, Black holes, neutron stars, gravity itself so perfectly explained in a unearthly way. Thanks a lot.
Finally someone animated spacetime like a river flowing to the centre of mass rather than depressed sheet
I heard Michelle Thaller describe it this way a few years ago. It was the first time I'd heard of spacetime described like that. This visual just made it that much more real.
Dialec is another You Tube site that portrays gravity as a river and has very good animation.
exactly y did it take so long for this form of visualization to be more common?
@@ratchethoe Because it's harder to do. A sheet is a 2D version of the same idea.
@@kurtwinslow2670 but Dialec doesn't understand acceleration.
I cannot believe that this video is free! You guys always keep the bar very high. Imo you join the likes of Lemmino with amazing quality of content.
This should be nominated for academy awards, best animation.
Fr among with kurzagast
Should be nominated for best nonsense animation of the religion of science.
@@kwimms what!?!? you out of mind!?
I think it deserves higher acclaim than that filth where academy awards are given to people who slap the host on the same night.
@@kwimms "the religion of science" You're projecting. Just because your religion is religious doesn't mean that science is also religious. Scientists don't hold ideas to be absolutely certain. We hold things to various degrees of probable certainty depending on the evidence for the claim. In the case of relativity, gravity, and spacetime, our current models are, as far as we know, the best and most accurate explanation of reality. Perhaps one day we will have to modify our understanding - that's the process of science.
Science deniers often act as if every time something new is discovered, that the entire puzzle board is overturned. That's not what happens. Science is like a jigsaw puzzle where we're constantly finding and adding new pieces, and though we don't have it complete, we have a basic idea of how the final picture looks. Every now and then we realize one of the pieces we thought was in the right place actually didn't quite fit as perfectly as we thought, and in fact there's another piece that fits better. But none of this changes the overall puzzle. Once in a great while we may realize after putting in a particular new puzzle piece that it actually changes our conception of what the final image would look like - but that's rare (Einstein discovering relativity would be an example of that). But again - the overall puzzle (which represents humanity's great attempt at explaining the natural world) remains in progress.
It's not a perfect process but it's literally the only method humanity has to discover and explain reality. I mean, it sure beats "such and such ancient book says..."
Fabulous video as always, one correction though:
At 6:25 its shown that if someone jumps through the earth, they'd come out on the other side. What actually would happen is they'd accelerate from 0 to some max velocity till reaching the center, and after that start decelerating in the same fashion, and by the time they reach the other side their velocity would be 0, and then back again and they'd be oscillating
And practically I'd assume with some drag the oscillations will dampen right? Some few hundred years and the person would settle in the center. The whole setup is analogous to letting off a marble at the edge of a bowl, but instead in a one dimensional motion in this case
Now i understand how space time works
I been watching space documentary for over 10 years I been listening to every single space professor
But non could explain space time like you did
Thank you
This guy visualized the highest peak of science by mankind like a first grade book !
I'm astonished.
I don't wanna take away from the man but... I just don't see how anyone who knows relativity doesn't understand this. To animate it is a whole nother thing
highest peak of science fiction rather
@asor8037 can't say something is something without some form of substantial evidence to dispute the current claim. Otherwise please take your ass back to school.
@@asor8037 adding rather, at the end of your sentence doesn't make you sound smart
@@HandTingSeason thanks for letting me know! The truth speaks for itself though, cartoons are not reality, and all we've ever seen is cartoons.
I am no physicist but this needs to be shown in colleges and universities. What an amazing visualization!
Why, it is here, for anyone interested
And I am a physicist and will be showing my class next week!!
Wow! I didn't know that theorical physicist existed!
Dear Alesandro Roussel, Octave Masson and JP Chatelain, Lyla. I work as a vacuum expert on the next generation gravitational wave detector, Einstein Telescope. A collaboration of over 1600 people at the moment of writing. If somehow you are not jet involved, you are very welcome to connect with us. I extent to you an invitation to come and visit my home institute: Nikhef in Amsterdam. I am sure there are many people interested in your animation and work, within the collaboration of the Einstein Telescope... My greatest compliments to all of you for your animation!
They do. @@a.thiago3842
Your videos are works of art. I cried while watching this due to the sheer magnificence of our universe, the mysteries it still holds and our tiny place in it. Thank you for bringing these concepts, explanations, visuals, and soundtracks to RUclips so lay people like me can experience the awe alongside you. Keep it up!
The fathers of science are all in awe, giving a standing ovation. Masterpiece presentation
Brilliant!!! No more stretched-sheet gravity demos - THIS is how it's meant to be shown. Finally someone did it and made an excellent job of it. Nice work!! Love it
I've always found it hard to understand intuitively from those demos this is much better
This is my preferred explanation of gravity.. but it seems not the most popular. I have listened to dozens of talks on the subject and most describe space as statically stretched. The flowing of space makes SO much more sense.
@@brcfrmn01 Weird. I understand the sheet demos better personally. This is hard to imagine in your own head.
the sheet analog is perfectly fine for the Newtonian regime: depth -> potential -> time dilation (analogy->newton->weak field Einstein).
it does lack a third dimension of space, tho...and that throws some ppl. idk, I think its a good start.
In a rotating BH, there's more to worry about.
fr
wake up babe new scienceclic just dropped
ffr
The visuals and music are incredible! Thank you for this experience.
Thank you very much 🙏
@@ScienceClicEN Is there a album we can purchase to listen to these soundtracks without the narration ?
@@JcoleMc The album is freely available on my SoundCloud : soundcloud.com/aroussel/sets/voyage-a-travers-lespace-temps
Danke!
This is not much, but is what i can afford for now, i will continue supporting the channel, i am greatful for this wonderful experience.
Thank you so much 🙏
I rarely comment on RUclips videos, but this is by far one of the best spacetime explainer videos out there; finally, someone is able to show spacetime in 3D. Hats off to the animator and the entire team for creating this. I'm so happy I found this channel!!!
@@mat.se57 He is no showing the 4th dimension, space-time is space with moving object within, as if there was not time and only space, everything would be static, the 4th dimension is iconically shown in Interstellar, such as a library where you can see frames of existence in different times all at once.
Such a shame that you don’t do longer length videos as your seriously on topic and your voice is soothing aswell. You’d easily be up there amongst the best of space RUclipsrs.
Yes, although I do wish for more/longer videos, I think ScienceClic has already earned its place as amongst the best of space RUclipsrs
@@DanielKRuiIt’s a no BS, down to the point channel, who’s team is incredibly well educated. At this point, it’s Quality, not quantity.
He is up there. These videos are bomb
Takes time to animate stuff and render stuff
@@DeveloperJake It's made by one person
Wow. For 40 years I could never get my head around what this stuff is, gravity, spacetime and their relationship, why planets don’t fly off. This was just incredible. What’s more, it shows just how easy it is to understand, it’s so frigging simple. Kudos to you all for this. Beautiful.
I’m no Carl Sagan; in fact, Astronomy was the only course in which I ever received an F on an exam (didn’t read the chapter on stars-when I told the professor my Scantron _looked_ like a Red Giant, he was unmoved for a bonus point). I digress …
I’ve just binged about two hours here and can go on forever! This is soothing, educational, entertaining, and HIGHLY informative! “Ya listenin, RUclips?!” 👌👍🤟😮💨
This is a whole other level of art and science
fr
Science?? 😂😂😂😂😂
It’s fukin cartoons you silly fool!!
The work you put into these videos is phenomenal, and provides new intuitive ways to approach visualizing these scientific phenomena. As always, well done!
Thanks a lot 🙏
fr@@ScienceClicEN
Yeah... this guy has bought the lie and brought it alive (a lie v). Stupendous achievement for a monkey!
08:37 wow the black hole accretion disk looks surreal, GREAT ANIMATION!
Thanks, glad you liked it!
the quality on this one is top tier on what's currently available on the internet. my biggest congratulations man, this is absolutely brilliant and deserving all the praise
Thank you. Finally someone has depicted a black hole as it is a point, and not a funnel or cone.
This is hands down the most incredible space/science channel on the platform. The commentary, visuals, and quality is light years beyond what I’ve seen from other channels, including channels with millions of subs. I’ll never stop recommending these videos to my friends. We all love them.
How can this guy only have 600K subscribers. He literally has the best science channel out there.
IKR?????? He deserves a few million subs at least. This channel is truly so underrated, their videos are literally kurzgesagt levels of quality.
*Science fiction
Because people, believe it or not prefer fake "heroes" like the Kardashians &the Hawk Thua girl..
This has to be one of the top 5 channels on RUclips.
Please tell me im not the only one crying softly in awe by the end of the video
My sincere gratitude to the first person who can tell me what a “slice” of four dimensional spacetime looks like…
It looks like 3D space without time .
@@DKweenz that’s assuming the slice is made perpendicularly to time though
this is hands down without a doubt the single best visual aid for understanding gravity and spacetime ever created
I’ll be watching this one again and again.
Your videos and the knowledge shared with us, simple humans, is another level of empathy and appreciation for the science. This will remain here forever. Humbly I thank you to share parts of this wonderful universe, in simple words, with all of us.
Absolutely phenomenal work 🫡
Can we give this man a like and a follow for NOT USING A TRAMPOLINE
jajjajaa love the sarcasm, crazy how visualizing the 3D image being bent helped to understand it better.
I can't make sense of a curved grid. Can you?
Well said, the “rubber sheet with a bowling ball in the centre” is good but this is a much more accurate depiction of the illusion of gravity!
👍👍👍
@@oldtimer2192 it doesn't make sense to me. They display the grid as a coordinate system but the points in the grid moves with gravity. So even though you stay on the same coordinate you are still moving. That seems like a paradox to me
@@jonaskarlsson5901in freefall, you are not moving per se (relative to local spacetime), only moving compared to objects that are resisting gravity. The ground is actively counteracting gravity through the normal force at +9.8m/s^2. To a person in freefall, it is not them that is moving, but rather the ground accelerating upwards to meet them. Perhaps I may be inaccurate on a few parts since I am not an expert, but this is my explanation to the best of my understanding.
It's my first time here, and I need to thanks (a million times) the YT algorithm!
What a nice job, @scienceClicEN ❤
The most underrated science channel on RUclips!
This is one of your best videos. Holly Molly. The narration, the visualisation and the music, everything is just perfect. 👏
🙏
This is absolutely the greatest animated explanation of the nature and movement and look of space time that I have ever seen.
Truly mind blowing, awesome animations too. I can't even begin to imagine an event happening a billion years ago and we just felt the vibrations from it. Wow.
Thousands and thousands of times better than any scientific show on TV. Well done.
As a 3d artist I am amazed how good your simulations and animations are.
As a human I am mind blown how surreal and mysterious our universe is.
I've never seen the fate of stars and gravity illustrated and described with such simplicity and eloquence. I understand these things a lot better now. Thank you so much for making this video!
You've no clue how anxiously I wait for your videos!! This among other channels have motivated me to learn higher mathematics and physics. I firsly understood general relativity 3 years ago at 16 years old when I saw your videos explaining it.
Incredible! Incredible! Incredible!
Thanks ❤
This is so awesomely conceptualised, designed, executed and produced. It’s obvious you guys are perfectionists - and boy does it pay off. Bravo.
wow. just wow. i don't have enough words to describe this marvelous and amazing animation!
I absolutely love this channel. It’s what has pushed me to go into the Space Sciences field. This video is incredible and I will definitely be watching it again.
This is by far the most beautiful animation and explanation of spacetime that I have ever seen in my life! Thank you for this experience! ❤
This is litteraly the best explaining and graphical video of general relativity I've seen so far. Thanks for the good work.
This was FANTASTIC!
You've created the most convincing looking representation of a 3D grid, and animated it so beautifully!
This has been the best video Ive seen describing space time in a 3d space
Yeah, that's the best way to visualise spacetime I've ever seen! He has a video introducing the model in a more detailed way, from a few years ago. What gives it even more weight is that it's physically accurate (the "river model" of spacetime).
You have to be a 3D artist to be able to fully grasp the amount of effort this channel is putting into its visuals. Extraordinary work.
🙏🙏🙏
Two greatest channels commenting each other. We only need third one here, PBS
awesome, thank you!
Your vids helped me finally understand how space-time works. The "classical" representations didn't speak to me, I struggled with them without success. You gave me the CLICK I was looking for. On top of this, your videos are masterpieces in terms of execution. Thank you so much!
Love it. Great job guys. I thought the spacetime compression near the sun looked awesome.
Thanks!
This channel deserves way more views and subscribers. Those animations and explanations are awesome. Unlike a lot of other sources that try to dumb down the information to be approachable this channel succeeds by making stunning animations to explain complex concepts on a more intuitive level. It's like the perfect combination between PBS SpaceTime and 3B1B. Thank you so much for your channel and the time you put in.
🙏
I once did research on physics for a school work... This was the visualization I had in my head all these years, and it is good to see it represented here, just as I imagined it when I was a teenager...
This is absolutely phenomenal! The way you visualized the fabric of spacetime is incredible. Not to mention, the accurate representation of gravity and how it actually works, with the fabric being pinched and pulled inwards instead of the infamous ball-on-a-sheet example which is kind of misleading, other than the fact it's 2D. I've also never an animation so accurately depicting the formation of black holes. Take a bow!
This is absolutely fantastic! Nice to see spacetime shown as a three dimensional grid rather than a simple 2D one as it is usually.
New video from ScienceClic! Best Sunday ever! 🎉🎉🎉
Best visualisation of matter warping spacetime, I've ever seen! Thank you and congratulations!
Wow, I saw one of the comments mentioning it was well worth watching so I gave it a shot and damn, it’s the best video I’ve seen so far on space and time
This is one of the best videos I have seen. Thanks to the RUclips algorithm. Also hat's off to the video creator.
I love you. You are one of the best content creators I’ve ever encountered. I thank you immensely for helping me maintain contact with my passion for these incredible, yet complex topics.
This has to be one of the best spacetime videos I've ever seen
I live in a third world country where the people do not have basic amenities talk more of being able to afford them. I am educated, by the standard of my country at least, and concepts like space and time are spoken about in physics and chemistry classes but they're never really put into perspective for people to grasp. I started using the internet at an early age of 9 and as such, I was exposed to the nature of the world around me. I'm currently in my early twenties and I've realized that it's not just the people in my country that do not get the bigger picture but most people in the world!
It got me wondering why we humans have such a troubled existence and I quickly arrived at an answer: we do not know what we are.
When I think about the cosmos - which I do ever so often with a friend of mine - I realize how special I am. How special we really are.
That we've come to be in this unquantifiable "mess" is no easy feat. We are even more mysterious and special than the universe itself.
I dream of a time when humanity will discard its differences and see itself as one ever driving force whose purpose is to look at the big picture and decipher its meaning or even give it meaning if it so happens that it is of a random cause.
You are not random and in the universe very, very unique
@@marymartinez9418 I believe that now more than ever. Also note that I said "if it so happens to be of a random cause".
i'm so glad that several years ago at 3 AM youtube showed me one of your videos
The first time I saw your graphical representation of curved spacetime, it clicked for me and it’s how my brain now conceptualises the structure of the Universe. Einstein truly was a clever chap!
Unbelievable depth and display of visual complexity in such a topic. Thanks for creating this video
This is a masterpiece.
Really great imagination and visualization by Einstein. Greatest minds of Human history.
came here from that Veritasium video where you guys provided the simulation visuals for black holes/spacetime. Excellent stuff. Great visuals to explain such tough theoretical concepts.
Thanks a lot!
I wish many more people sit through and watch such educational videos. Even if you dont understand the terms and definitions you can still immerse yourself into this masterpiece!! Such visuals should be used in academies and actual lectures of gravity/ any other topic. HOPE YOU FIND MUCH MORE SUCCESS YOU ARE ALREADY ON TOP SCIENCECLIC!!!
That white hole part was just a split second but it was enough to completely transport me someplace else. Your videos renew our passion and interest for normal people like me. Grazie mille!
This should be in science textbooks and curriculums. You are becoming more and more relevant, do not stop!
I love this video!
Gravity is a result of the curvature in spacetime, awesome!
Your animation guy deserves a raise
"If two black holes meet, they can begin to dance" what a wonderous painting you have created with your beautiful words
Doooooooooood. I feel like i've been waiting and begging for this video for forever. This was FANTASTIC! Hats off to the developers and animators that it took to make this. I've sent this to everyone I know.
This stuff should go viral
babe wake up, new ScienceClic upload
Fascinating!!! 😊
By far the best space visualization. This is what we want to see and subscribe👍
Beyond impressive and mesmerising to watch. I watched science TV since child and watch YT creators everyday who cover science/astronomy and this has to be one of the most extraordinary depictions of gravity I’ve ever seen. Thx for producing such a wonderful video and sharing it
Glad you liked it 🙏
"Space is not empty. It contains the entire universe." Alan Watts
Bruh this is underrated
i honestly hate that this is not even the tip of the iceberg... it's barely a snowflake on the tip of the iceberg. and it took us so long just to put together this much.... there is so much we'll never know in this lifetime
Best video I've found so far about this topic and beautifully visualized.
This was just absolutely mind blowing! the work done by you guys is insanely good and it will surely help young physicists get a natural feel for how gravity actually works. great job as always!
It's not that it's being pulled (outside of frame dragging), but rather that spacetime is curved/warped such that the path (geodesic) is altered.
einstein surely wouldve loved these visuals.... i cant imagine what newton would think of this
Good video, but at 0:24 you say "billions of billions of kilometers from earth". At that hypothetical distance, between both galaxies, it would actually be billions of *light* *years* away, which completely dwarfs the "kilometers" measurement, like comparing the distance between atoms to miles.
A billion light years is pretty far. That’s like a 13th of the entire universe. And idk if you know this but the universe is pretty big. Billions of kilometres is accurate.
@@strawsquash No. Billions of "kilometers" is NOT accurint. Both of us were wrong. The Andromeda galaxy is 2.5 MILLION LIGHT YEARS from earth, which is twenty-three quintillion seven hundred fifty quadrillion kilometers. As I alluded, _most_ galaxies are at least billions of light years away. BUT since he did mention the Andromeda galaxy specifically, which is fairly close to us relative to the size of the universe, I was incorrect in my distance assessment. But of course, so were you. Your statement that Andromeda is merely "Billions" of kilometers away is also far from accurate. Our own sun, which is a star right on our own doorstep, is 151 million kilometers from Earth, and that is over 1/10th of a billion kilometers. And there are an estimated 100 billion stars in just our own galaxy, each of which is an an enormous distance away. Proxima Centauri is the nearest star to Earth (after our own sun) is 4.2 light years away, which is 39.9 TRILLION kilometers away.
Yes, I DO know that the Universe is *BIG*. Big enough for us to both make mistakes.
@@privatename3621 no you were mostly wrong, sorry to say. You were unhappy with his use of billions of billions of kilometers. A billion-billion kilometers is 1e18 kilometers. 2.5 million light years is 2.37e19 kilometers. The original video was correct.
@@ExternusArmy Which is what I just said dork. I pointed out that I was wrong, but YOU WE'RE MUCH WRONG-ER. And who TF says "billions of billions"?? Is that a weird British thing? When most Americans here the phrase "billions OF billions", they think the person misspoke, as it is far more common to say "billions AND billions", which is why I missed it the first time. But there are actual names for things like "billions of billions" (such as "quintillion" which is what I pointed out). People don't go around saying "hundreds of hundreds of hundreds." That's silly. They same "millions" because that is the proper name for it.
But whatever.
The quality of the videos you produce... please never stop, has to be the best science channel! :)
what would happen if spacetime was gay?
She already is
@@basspuppy133she?
If it's a gay, Instead of wormhole, there is an asshole
@@Tmelo-zn8ig yes