So you might be reluctant to start an unfinished series, that's understandable. However, right now is a great time to discuss the many questions and theories regarding The Kingkiller Chronicle before the third book comes out. And discussion is half the fun! Feel free to discuss the books over on my Discord server: discord.gg/uKdnVXY or on The Crockery (Kingkiller fan-server): discord.gg/uKdnVXY *ALSO check out my new channel merch!:* teespring.com/stores/captured-in-words
Sometimes I worry we won't ever get the ending of this story. Patrick Rothfuss has said this is just a prequel, im assuming that means Kvothe isn't finished after the 3rd book. Hopefully he leaves the Inn!!!!
The Name of the Wind was the first book I've ever bought, back in 2010. I remember the first time I read the "Tarbean arc" I thought it was so sad that I skipped it the second time I read the book. This is one of my favorite books. It shares the top spot with Mistborn and Stormlight Archive. I simply can't choose between them.
The story was beautiful, and so intricate, and so easy to read. I love Kvothe (a very controversial opinion abut what can I say, he’s cool). I don’t necessarily like school settings but seeing it through Kvothes eyes you see that the school is more of a tool and not the complete focus of the characters mind. The whole atmosphere was so intriguing and full of mystery. I can’t wait to reread it in summer!
This series is BY FAR my favorite ever and I couldn't agree more about everything you just said. Even if the 3rd book never comes out everything that the characters and the lore gave me will be meaningful and will stick to me forever.
Kingkiller chronicles are by far my most re-read books, I love them so, so much. And for me they lose nothing of their value just because the series aren't finished yet. They are beautiful and heartbreaking, and hope inspiring and warm and intricate, and I'm very grateful to have them in my life.
I absolutely love this series. The way the story seems to grow with each re-read with the intricate secrets Rothfuss has hidden in the pages is just great. I'm not much of a re-reader but I've lost count of the amount I've re-read these books. Anytime I find myself getting too busy or drifting away from reading for enjoyment I always come back to the comfort of Temerant and it reminds me why I love books.
@@philipvalley1914 yeah read them a lot, I'm currently writing a novel my self, I love Rothfuss' style. I just started the storm light series. And I'm collecting the wheel of time books. I'll check out your recommendation though it's much appreciated 😎
Love the content brother. I JUST started this hobby with my first Fantasy Trilogy ever. And videos like this help guide me through endless browsing at bookstores and bad spending for mid tear books. Keep up the great work! I'm inspired to read through several of these.
My reading experience of the Name of the Wind was so special and I can’t wait to reread the series again- I began reading this book in 2018 after several disappointing YA books in a row. I was frustrated, tired and almost in a slump but had seen this book around a LOT lately. I decided to be safe and to read the sample on kindle before committing to another book. I only read the prologue and chapter one before buying this book and my love for reading came back to me full force. After the first big event of the book (😭) I knew I needed to talk to someone about it but none of my friends were really readers. So I searched my podcasts app for the Name of the Wind and found *The Duke and Duchess Podcast* 💖 A husband and wife duo that felt like old friends as soon as I clicked play. They labeled themselves as a fantasy loving podcast currently covering the Kingkiller Chronicle 4-5 chapters per episode. They do a super deep dive and catch details and hidden elements that I never caught on to. He’s reading the book for the very first time and she’s already read the series several times. It’s a fantastic setup and hilarious when he makes tinfoil predictions. To date they’ve covered the Kingkiller Chronicle, the Gentlemen Bastards (Lies of Locke Lamora series), the Stormlight Archive and now Gardens of the Moon. I hope I can pass this experience on to another person because the books that they chose to read have become lifetime favorites because of this podcast. If you love taking time with a good book, this might be for you 🌾🍻⚔️
I really liked his character development in NotW. Kvothe's zealous and impatient pursuit of knowledge was so well portrayed, which is why I would agree that he is not really due the "Mary Sue" criticism in that book. He puts in a lot of work, and he's really smart. In addition to that, his life in Tarbean and the loss you mentioned make him almost greedy when it comes to success, and I believe Rothfuss wrote that convincingly w/o making Kvothe overpowered and thus boring to follow. Now in Wise Man's Fear, that is a very different story. He is introduced to concepts entirely foreign to him (sex, naming, Adem sign language to an extent, Adem martial arts) and almost immediately masters them, without any real effort. Granted, the Adem stuff takes him a while, but he is still considered a prodigy by the Adem for how quick he picks both of them up, DESPITE Kvothe himself stressing time and again how challenging they are. That is where Rothfuss lost me with Kvothe. Love the first book, love how well the unreliable narrator is used, love love love the prose, but man did the second book fall short of the first one for me.
I actually just finished the Wise Man’s Fear for the first time this morning. Great video, and great summary of everything there is to adore about these books. The questions left are pressing, but even if book 3 never comes out I’ll still be happy for the experience. A riveting experience.
Ok, you convinced me! The name intrigued me, so I was gonna read it one day anyway, but after watching your video I am gonna buy it now! Great editing!
Every time I think of this book I feel sad that I've already read and wish for this series to never end. This is the best series I have ever read only rivalled by Magician
Excellent video as always! Can't stand the "book 3 isnt coming" crowd. There's a reason why they liked the books so much in the first place, Rothfuss puts in the time and effort to create ART not just another story. Saying he doesn't care is just blatantly false. When the series is finished it will be remembered as one of the greatest fantasy trilogies ever written, no one will care about how long it took to write.
This was such a great video! I remember reading The Name of the Wind for the first time like...9-10 years ago now?...and it’s still one of the most beautiful, well-written books I’ve ever read. I am hopeful that Rothfuss is taking his time to give us, and Kvothe, the ended he deserves. 👏🏼 love all of your videos - they are so well done.
Don't do it. Not worth it. The first book os great, the second much less so, but it still leaves you wondering about the conclusion and waiting for more. It has been about a decade since I first read the books and it is still on my mind. Not a nice feeling, knowing that I Might never see the conclusion.
Great video! I read the books so many times and they always bring me joy. This story is a constant companion in my life for almost 10 years now and I am excited for the Doors of Stone, however long it takes to come out. I also love the artwork you included in your video :)
These are some of my favorite books. His writing style is definitely part of the reason I love the books so much. I also agree with you: I can't wait for the third book, but even if it doesn't come out (unlikely), I will still be glad that the first two and the novella exist. I will happily reread them.
these books have been on my tbr for ages, but when you described the time in your life when you picked them up, I immediately had to get a copy from my library. I just lost my dad a couple months ago and I'm still overwhelmed with work and college, so I really appreciate this recommendation and especially the timing more than words can even explain
Every time I watch one of your videos on The Kingkiller Chronicles it just reignites my passion for the series. I also had a very similar experience when first reading them and have since re read them many times. While I’m sad the 3rd book isn’t out yet I’m so thankful to have something in my life that gets me this excited. I genuinely feel like a kid waiting for Christmas when anticipating the next book. Thank you for making these videos ❤️
I'm glad I can help reignite your passion! I've reread these books so many times and still enjoy them each read through. I'm sad the 3rd one isn't out yet too, hopefully it won't bee too much longer. I'll be making many more Kingkiller related videos this year 😀
ok, so you might not like this one but I have to get this out. I love KKC. I have signed books and have been there since pretty much the beginning. Read/listened to the books multiple times. Traveled through KKC theory forums on reddit and watched all of your stuff and most other quality content on youtube. Your analysis is pretty spot on for most of us that have dived deep. Now to the point of my major skepticism. Follow his blog... I think that Rothfuss has fundamentally changed as a person over the past 10 years and that will reflect in book 3. I think he now feels personally responsible for making a societal "change for good" through the fame of his books, instead of just continuing the story as planned. "Those with great power have great...".. Yeah we get it with him pretty much devoting himself to Worldbuilders for the past few years. Also, I hate to bring this up as a point of blame but, Oot(his son) will also play a part here. From his blog entries, it seems that Pat is a very large role model to his son, loves him to the nth degree, and has to be the personal shaper of his sons morality etc. That's natural, that's part of being a father. Now though, we have a different lens of the world that Pat is writing(or re-writing) from. Kvothe as a character has always been.. not amoral but rides a "fine line" sometimes. Reactive violence in particular is also a major aspect of Kvothe's response to conflict, as also it is to the world in general. This is not dissimilar to us and our own world to a certain degree and that's(IMO) a large reason as to why so many readers identify with the character. Kvothe is very human(with a photographic memory at least...). I think that Pat is currently struggling with that moral "fine line" now though. With such a large current audience, does he stay true to the original nature of the character that he created over a decade ago or does he modify the story to represent his current concerns in life that were propagated by his success and parenthood? My guess is the latter so I don't have a lot of hope for book 3 as being true to the story that started brilliantly when he was a struggling a bit. He will resolve the mysteries but at the same time, I feel it will be more like TSRFST than NOTW or WMF. Or I could be all wrong and he just never had a good ending to the book from the get go? He will sell you a bunch of KKC Merch or solicit you for donations on his website though b4 he loses a lot of fans after book 3 realease(as he's been doing for years)...
I am currently reading Kingkiller Chronicles for the first time, I am about 150 pages into the Name of The Wind. To be precise I am on the part where Kvothe decides to go to hillside to beg for the first time and is beaten by the guards and the head demon of Midwinter Paegentry helps him. That part was so moving. Rothfuss’ Prose is so immersive and enchanting that I am not able to put down the book. It really has one of the finest prose I have seen, and everything feels so intentional that I am not able to understand what I have to remember and what not? It’s just amazing. BTW excellent work, your editing skills are quite good.
Just two days ago i finished reading the books and i enjoyed them a lot. I hope we get news from the next book soon and that Rothfuss doesn't take much longer to publish it. Greetings from Argentina
‘I got a problem!’ We’ve all been there Jay. Favourite books or movies that one slips back into reading or viewing, even though you know them like the back of your hand. Also can quote or recall favourite parts to others. Favourite books/movies are like comfort food because they can remind you of a time when things were different, simpler or easier. They can make you feel better or worse depending what you need, whether it’s comfort, reassurance, guidance or a reminder of ones youthful times. It can also remind people about those they have like a gifted book from a parent or friend, that when the book takes on a meaning that only that person knows. Beyond a favourite book it can become a treasure or a family heirloom something of true value to pass down the generations of one’s family.
Oh yeah I know how required reading can potentially rid a person of their desire to read for enjoyment as I’ve been to university twice so six years of it and learn plus school before those stages of my life. It’s crazy 😜 to think I want to go back again that’s another story. But needless to say I never lost my love of reading or the enjoyment of it because I found a way to seperate from non fiction to fiction and fantasy. I always kept reading both without it I might have wanted to give up reading. It’s worth learning about the real world and created ones to keep things fresh. Otherwise reading can be lost to some people.
Keep up the good work! The videos are always informative and wonderfully edited. So sorry to hear of the ongoing struggles you and your family have to endure. Hopefully the enjoyment people get out of your videos is a small bonus and brings a smile to your face.
Your editing is still my absolute favorite thing 👏🏻 Also: I always found Kvothe to be very similar to Odysseus as he retells his story to the Phaeacians in (I think?) Books 9-11 of the Odyssey. The magical encounters, the possibility of an unreliable narrator, how arrogant they both are. the importance of music and story telling, themes/motifs of travel, family ties, revenge, etc. Not sure if this is intention, but I’m thinking about putting together an essay / video essay on it when Doors of Stone comes out
I came to this story when I was 14 y.o. I since then I loved the world. Truth be told I started reading them in Spanish but since then I have read each book over 9 times each both in Spanish and English and the are still my adoration.
Oh I love that you’ve appeared in my suggestions. I was searching for some Kingkiller theory videos and couldn’t believe how many were negative. I’ve read both books a couple of times and have just lent them to someone while I listen along to the audio version. It’s like a little book club, but I obviously don’t want to spoil anything for him, so wanted to did other people who have read them to talk theories with! I remember I had loads by the end of NotW, but can’t remember what they were 🤣
As for Kvothe being a reliable narrator; or not. There has always bwen one part that stood out to me. Though it haa been so long since I read the book, I could not point out where to find it. But it was where he was telling his story, and the way it was worded made me think that what we read, was not what he was telling the Chronicler. That entire part made me not question what the reader read, but if what Chronicler was told to be what we were reading. Wish I could remember which book and where, but it has been 3 years...
"And I ended up re-reading both books again.. I got a problem" I felt personally attacked by that :D but I can only completely agree with your points! I've recommended this book to so many people basically based upon the points you mentioned here
I have to say that I largely agree with you on everything. I read it twice in book format and listened to it once on audiobook. The second read was better than the first because I could pay attention to a lot of smaller details, and when i listened to the audiobook i literally got chills when i realized so many of the lines rhymed or had a prose to them. While i also agree that this series has it's flaws, it does hold a place in my heart because it was the first book I read for fun in nearly 4 years (all of high school I didn't read and I picked this up right after graduating), and it had rekindled my love for reading. also whenever people say that kvothe is a mary sue i think they're not understanding that he's the one telling the story. Of course he's going to make himself sound close to perfect and that everything came easy to him, because memories of how hard learning stuff fades. and he also reminsces on his mistakes and flaws a lot and at least on the second read i noticed that he's not perfect at all and he's just a guy telling his life story and focusing on the little things which had an impact. anyways sorry for the little rant in the second paragraph, great review. this is the book i most recommend when people ask me for recommendations so there is that :)
When I first read the books I couldn't believe the range and intensity of emotions it made me feel... I remember getting chills, having tears in my eyes from the beautiful prose, laughing HYSTERICALLY, sobbing HYSTERICALLY, vibrating with excitement, and just generally being compeletely addicted to reading these books. I would finish The Wise Man's Fear and just go right back to the beginning of The Name of the Wind. I'm going to patiently wait for the final book. Fans may be disappointed right now, but I know we won't be disappointed when we finally get to read Doors of Stone. I find myself raving about these books to anyone who asks me for a recommendation.
I found this book through a podcast (my brother my brother and me) and purely based off my trust of those guys I read it. They are now my favorite books of all time.
I'm not sure how many times I have read this books and each time I love them more and got desperate waiting for the third one. However, I never get bored at all.
Thanks for a cracking video! You summed up everything I've felt is great about the books. Myself and my wife have particularly enjoyed your various theory videos on the series. Best wishes and prayers to your mum. Thanks again, keep up the good work.
These books are undoubtedly a masterpiece. I'm upset that the third book hasn't been published yet, but I'd rather Rothfuss take the time to make them as perfect as he can make them. These books are impeccably written. They made me realize how few words we use in normal day to day life. I fell in love with the marvelous subtleties of the English language because of these books. There is not one word out of place. It's his Magnum Opus, his perfect storm, a once in a millennium masterpiece. I eagerly await more.
Well. I watched this to gain inspiration to finish the name of the wind. I started about a month ago and have only reached 237. Watching some reviews I was shocked to see how highly it is regarded. Although I I finally getting interesting at the university, I find it dull. Sorry. That is my opinion. I had no preconceptions about this book having never heard of it. I was given it by a friend for summer reading. So far the world is superficial, deep I not something I would refer to it. I do hope I enjoy it more soon, but I cannot see myself ever reading this again. Never mind the second book. I do understand you love it, but it seems it is not for everyone. So far. To be continued..... maybe
Thank you for making another video on the series. Please continue to make more 😀. I know there are lot's of us that watch these video's religiously. I just listened to this series for the third time over the last 2 weeks and change. You should try listening to them on audible. I picked up on more and different things while listening. You also get to hear the proper pronunciations for words.
I honestly haven't been THIS invested in a fantasy world since Kate Elliott's Crown of Stars series completed. Sure I've been drawn in by her other works, and from other authors, but there's just something extra about Kingkiller Chronicles! I have a hard time putting the books down; I'm smack in the middle of Wise Man's Fear right now.
Great books. MC never meets his parents killers again. Instead he helps an old guy get married, goes to school, doesn't finish learning anything, while moving at a snails pace. Slice of life rubbish without any higher stakes at all. We're just told of them & told of world ending consequences, then shown the MCs love life + lies. Be warned of anyone selling this to you as a revenge story or hyping up the Chandrian. All lies. No real payoff. A few poems & writing skill doesn't overcome the core problem. He can't pace a story or maintain importance in the primary goal/enemy.
Made a deal with one of my professors who is also a huge fantasy nerd. I would read The Name of the Wind if he began the third book in the Stormlight Archive (one of my favorite series). Your video has hyped me up excited to start it in the next week!
One of my favorite series of all time! Your video is fantastic, and an inspiration so that one day I can create content as good as you! 😊 Looking forward to the next video, Jay!
"And with no release date for the 3rd book, I decided to take a break from even thinking about it.....anddd I ended up rereading both books again." Dis me😂 Read them both 3 times in 4 years so far
Books are pure fire, amazing and I was hooked after first few pages. It is no wonder it was a best seller. I just read them few days ago and honestly while writters should have take time to do a story they could be transperant more so we know what is going on. If he says it will take me at least 5-10 years more, am 33% finished that would be totally ok but it sucks to know the latest information about the book rn is a radio scilence after he never delivered a promised chapter for which he got over a million dollars for his charity. Kind of sucks. I get it tho, had something similar happen to me but what got me out was simply being open.
I found these books 4 years ago, I wait patiently for the third book but I have many other books to read through so I'm not too concerned. The thing that struck me most with these books is how easily they come to life your mind. Some book series take almost the entire first and second book to have a full picture of the world but within the first few paragraphs of the Name of the Wind you can already see the world that Patrick has created.
I think you really capture excitement with that video, i started the series a few days ago and this video is hyping me up even more. However i stopped at the three minute mark, cause of some light spoilers already (at least till page 300 there is no word of kvothe being responsible for the skale creatures). Great video tho, i'll Look forward to watching it after I've caught up :)
One unique thing about Rothfuss's style is that he uses interlacing metaphors. He describes magic through music, music through taste, love through song, and so on. A question for more experienced readers. Why do characters sometimes speak in rhyme? Does it signify anything? Maybe Kvothe embellishes the facts when he makes people in his memory speak in rhyme...
I've reread it twice But wanna reread it thrice After watching this video. Maybe this will be the only book that I can reread a lot of times until the 3rd book is published and so on.
The seven words thing also happens with the "then words to break a strong man's will", specially during the conversation witht the Cthaeh. I've compared both the original books with the Spanish translation to make sure this kind of sentences are not just a coincidence of the translation, and I can tell you the phrasing in both situations is compleatly intended to have this number of words!
I'll definitely give these books a try when Doors of Stone gets a release date. After A Song of Ice and Fire I don't want to start a series that has no end in sight. These books do sound good, I just would rather consume them all at once than have to wait who knows how long to finish the story.
I am curious about this series, but since I am still waiting on a song of ice and fire, I think I will start this when the third comes out. This video really makes me want to read it right now though 😂
Omg! You made me want to reread these books so bad, and I never reread books. I forgot most of the things that happen in the story, so I will reread them for sure, but I want to wait a bit longer for the 3rd book to be out. By now I still have so many books to read. Great video!
I got about halfway through the first book and had the feeling that it wasn't really leading anywhere and so I stopped. Im not a very analytical reader, I don't look for clues nor do I ever reread a book once Ive completed it. On the other hand, I did enjoy his writing style. Given all the praise it keeps getting, I've exceptionally put it back on the reading list for a reread. Maybe as you said, it's more enjoyable upon rereading.
Thoughts/theories about Auri and Bast? Was Bast rescued by Kvothe? How did Auri end up in the bellows? Why Elodin protecting her? What does he know about her past?
one thing i realised is that just like real life people, once i like/love a character, even though they make mistakes and showcase flaws, it generally doesn't take away from my love for them. it's the tolerance that comes through understanding, and i might even find myself agreeing with them too. so i feel like once i start this series kvothe will have me wrapped around his finger lol.
No idea when or if the series will be finished, but I do already own what's been published and I do plan on reading it eventually. No idea when that will be, but you definitely do a great job of hyping up the series.
Absolutely fantastic video as always :) Although I will admit the pace of the video was a bit too fast for me to keep up with at times. However I simply went back sometimes to rewatch. Still, amazing arguments and a great way of presenting them (not to mention the editing ^^).
So you might be reluctant to start an unfinished series, that's understandable. However, right now is a great time to discuss the many questions and theories regarding The Kingkiller Chronicle before the third book comes out. And discussion is half the fun! Feel free to discuss the books over on my Discord server: discord.gg/uKdnVXY or on The Crockery (Kingkiller fan-server): discord.gg/uKdnVXY *ALSO check out my new channel merch!:* teespring.com/stores/captured-in-words
We love you man!!! Thank you for your devotion .
Kingkiller is one of the few series that I could read over and over even if there is NEVER a book three.
Sometimes I worry we won't ever get the ending of this story. Patrick Rothfuss has said this is just a prequel, im assuming that means Kvothe isn't finished after the 3rd book. Hopefully he leaves the Inn!!!!
The Name of the Wind was the first book I've ever bought, back in 2010. I remember the first time I read the "Tarbean arc" I thought it was so sad that I skipped it the second time I read the book.
This is one of my favorite books. It shares the top spot with Mistborn and Stormlight Archive. I simply can't choose between them.
"Why You Should Read The Kingkiller Chronicle by Patrick Rothfuss"
me who have already reread 3 times and is a big fan- sounds intresting
same here!
I’m on my third re-read and here I am! Also, I plan to send this video to a lot of people
i've reread 8 times. i'm a simple man, if i see anything about The Kingkiller Chronicle i'll click it
Those are rookie numbers my friend
i feel like i re-read them both once a year since they came out and every time I find a new layer...it really is incredible
I don’t mind the story being unfinished. I’d rather Rothfuss take his time and deliver something he’s proud of
YES! I totally agree!
Agree.
Same. He spent like 13 years working on the first book? I figure book three is going to be stellar.
Entertaining, yes. He's a terrible author for his promises.
I don't think he is going to finish it, EVER
The story was beautiful, and so intricate, and so easy to read. I love Kvothe (a very controversial opinion abut what can I say, he’s cool). I don’t necessarily like school settings but seeing it through Kvothes eyes you see that the school is more of a tool and not the complete focus of the characters mind. The whole atmosphere was so intriguing and full of mystery. I can’t wait to reread it in summer!
This series is BY FAR my favorite ever and I couldn't agree more about everything you just said. Even if the 3rd book never comes out everything that the characters and the lore gave me will be meaningful and will stick to me forever.
They'll stick in your mind like shit on a shoe
Kingkiller chronicles are by far my most re-read books, I love them so, so much. And for me they lose nothing of their value just because the series aren't finished yet. They are beautiful and heartbreaking, and hope inspiring and warm and intricate, and I'm very grateful to have them in my life.
I absolutely love this series. The way the story seems to grow with each re-read with the intricate secrets Rothfuss has hidden in the pages is just great. I'm not much of a re-reader but I've lost count of the amount I've re-read these books. Anytime I find myself getting too busy or drifting away from reading for enjoyment I always come back to the comfort of Temerant and it reminds me why I love books.
Very well said! This is exactly why I love these books so much
I've reread the books at least 10 times each since I was recommend them 3 years ago
I've lost count. Similar timeline, perhaps that many rereads. Ive finished the second book, just to start the first book again right after before.
@@sciencewizard8805 I know the feeling, I recently got the audio books and have listened to them a bunch of times already xD
Wow that's wild. You alright ? I read them both 2 times but 10 wow. Check out the Gentleman Bastards series
@@philipvalley1914 yeah read them a lot, I'm currently writing a novel my self, I love Rothfuss' style. I just started the storm light series. And I'm collecting the wheel of time books. I'll check out your recommendation though it's much appreciated 😎
That's very cool. I think I got the series name right. It's Very good. The first book is the Lies of Locke Lamora
Re-reading the books *again* is my mood
Re-reading the books again is my spirit animal
how is re reading books a spirit? or a animal? why are you like this. plese tell me your a better person now.
@@anonymous-3695 you're*
@@lalazalomon03 so still fat then?
Love the content brother. I JUST started this hobby with my first Fantasy Trilogy ever. And videos like this help guide me through endless browsing at bookstores and bad spending for mid tear books. Keep up the great work! I'm inspired to read through several of these.
My reading experience of the Name of the Wind was so special and I can’t wait to reread the series again-
I began reading this book in 2018 after several disappointing YA books in a row. I was frustrated, tired and almost in a slump but had seen this book around a LOT lately.
I decided to be safe and to read the sample on kindle before committing to another book. I only read the prologue and chapter one before buying this book and my love for reading came back to me full force.
After the first big event of the book (😭) I knew I needed to talk to someone about it but none of my friends were really readers. So I searched my podcasts app for the Name of the Wind and found *The Duke and Duchess Podcast* 💖 A husband and wife duo that felt like old friends as soon as I clicked play.
They labeled themselves as a fantasy loving podcast currently covering the Kingkiller Chronicle 4-5 chapters per episode. They do a super deep dive and catch details and hidden elements that I never caught on to. He’s reading the book for the very first time and she’s already read the series several times. It’s a fantastic setup and hilarious when he makes tinfoil predictions.
To date they’ve covered the Kingkiller Chronicle, the Gentlemen Bastards (Lies of Locke Lamora series), the Stormlight Archive and now Gardens of the Moon.
I hope I can pass this experience on to another person because the books that they chose to read have become lifetime favorites because of this podcast. If you love taking time with a good book, this might be for you 🌾🍻⚔️
It's even better reading the first 2 before the third is done. You can look up theories without seeing spoilers.
I really liked his character development in NotW. Kvothe's zealous and impatient pursuit of knowledge was so well portrayed, which is why I would agree that he is not really due the "Mary Sue" criticism in that book. He puts in a lot of work, and he's really smart. In addition to that, his life in Tarbean and the loss you mentioned make him almost greedy when it comes to success, and I believe Rothfuss wrote that convincingly w/o making Kvothe overpowered and thus boring to follow.
Now in Wise Man's Fear, that is a very different story. He is introduced to concepts entirely foreign to him (sex, naming, Adem sign language to an extent, Adem martial arts) and almost immediately masters them, without any real effort. Granted, the Adem stuff takes him a while, but he is still considered a prodigy by the Adem for how quick he picks both of them up, DESPITE Kvothe himself stressing time and again how challenging they are. That is where Rothfuss lost me with Kvothe. Love the first book, love how well the unreliable narrator is used, love love love the prose, but man did the second book fall short of the first one for me.
Some books just seem to know when to find you.
As always, amazing video Jay.
i needed a book that fit in my pocket while i was traveling boy was in in for a treat name of the wind was just perfect in so many ways
I actually just finished the Wise Man’s Fear for the first time this morning. Great video, and great summary of everything there is to adore about these books. The questions left are pressing, but even if book 3 never comes out I’ll still be happy for the experience. A riveting experience.
Ok, you convinced me! The name intrigued me, so I was gonna read it one day anyway, but after watching your video I am gonna buy it now!
Great editing!
Don’t do it!
Every time I think of this book I feel sad that I've already read and wish for this series to never end. This is the best series I have ever read only rivalled by Magician
It's a new dawn, it's a new day, it's a new life for me. AND I AM FEELING GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD! The Boy is back!!
Excellent video as always! Can't stand the "book 3 isnt coming" crowd. There's a reason why they liked the books so much in the first place, Rothfuss puts in the time and effort to create ART not just another story. Saying he doesn't care is just blatantly false. When the series is finished it will be remembered as one of the greatest fantasy trilogies ever written, no one will care about how long it took to write.
I wish I didn’t think it was never coming out, but I do truly believe that as much as I don’t want to
@@Remixt I was feeling much more hopeful three years ago when i made this comment lol
This was such a great video! I remember reading The Name of the Wind for the first time like...9-10 years ago now?...and it’s still one of the most beautiful, well-written books I’ve ever read. I am hopeful that Rothfuss is taking his time to give us, and Kvothe, the ended he deserves. 👏🏼 love all of your videos - they are so well done.
I re-read this books all the time. Thats my "stone heart".
This is going to be my next go to series after I’ve finished The First Law. Can’t wait!
I'm currently making my way through First Law myself, love those books!
The First Law series is one of my favorites. All 6 books in the combined universe are good.
Don't do it. Not worth it. The first book os great, the second much less so, but it still leaves you wondering about the conclusion and waiting for more. It has been about a decade since I first read the books and it is still on my mind. Not a nice feeling, knowing that I Might never see the conclusion.
i read all 9 first law books, the last couple books were the best of the bunch.
@@damianziokowski8421 i thought the standalone books and age of madness trilogy was much better
This will definitely be the vid I send to friends when trying to recommend the series. I am in no way as articulate as you were here. Fantastic.
Great video! I read the books so many times and they always bring me joy. This story is a constant companion in my life for almost 10 years now and I am excited for the Doors of Stone, however long it takes to come out.
I also love the artwork you included in your video :)
These are some of my favorite books. His writing style is definitely part of the reason I love the books so much. I also agree with you: I can't wait for the third book, but even if it doesn't come out (unlikely), I will still be glad that the first two and the novella exist. I will happily reread them.
these books have been on my tbr for ages, but when you described the time in your life when you picked them up, I immediately had to get a copy from my library. I just lost my dad a couple months ago and I'm still overwhelmed with work and college, so I really appreciate this recommendation and especially the timing more than words can even explain
Every time I watch one of your videos on The Kingkiller Chronicles it just reignites my passion for the series. I also had a very similar experience when first reading them and have since re read them many times. While I’m sad the 3rd book isn’t out yet I’m so thankful to have something in my life that gets me this excited. I genuinely feel like a kid waiting for Christmas when anticipating the next book. Thank you for making these videos ❤️
I'm glad I can help reignite your passion! I've reread these books so many times and still enjoy them each read through. I'm sad the 3rd one isn't out yet too, hopefully it won't bee too much longer. I'll be making many more Kingkiller related videos this year 😀
Always happy to hear you talk about this book series :)
ok, so you might not like this one but I have to get this out. I love KKC. I have signed books and have been there since pretty much the beginning. Read/listened to the books multiple times. Traveled through KKC theory forums on reddit and watched all of your stuff and most other quality content on youtube. Your analysis is pretty spot on for most of us that have dived deep. Now to the point of my major skepticism. Follow his blog... I think that Rothfuss has fundamentally changed as a person over the past 10 years and that will reflect in book 3. I think he now feels personally responsible for making a societal "change for good" through the fame of his books, instead of just continuing the story as planned. "Those with great power have great...".. Yeah we get it with him pretty much devoting himself to Worldbuilders for the past few years. Also, I hate to bring this up as a point of blame but, Oot(his son) will also play a part here. From his blog entries, it seems that Pat is a very large role model to his son, loves him to the nth degree, and has to be the personal shaper of his sons morality etc. That's natural, that's part of being a father. Now though, we have a different lens of the world that Pat is writing(or re-writing) from. Kvothe as a character has always been.. not amoral but rides a "fine line" sometimes. Reactive violence in particular is also a major aspect of Kvothe's response to conflict, as also it is to the world in general. This is not dissimilar to us and our own world to a certain degree and that's(IMO) a large reason as to why so many readers identify with the character. Kvothe is very human(with a photographic memory at least...). I think that Pat is currently struggling with that moral "fine line" now though. With such a large current audience, does he stay true to the original nature of the character that he created over a decade ago or does he modify the story to represent his current concerns in life that were propagated by his success and parenthood? My guess is the latter so I don't have a lot of hope for book 3 as being true to the story that started brilliantly when he was a struggling a bit. He will resolve the mysteries but at the same time, I feel it will be more like TSRFST than NOTW or WMF. Or I could be all wrong and he just never had a good ending to the book from the get go? He will sell you a bunch of KKC Merch or solicit you for donations on his website though b4 he loses a lot of fans after book 3 realease(as he's been doing for years)...
I am currently reading Kingkiller Chronicles for the first time, I am about 150 pages into the Name of The Wind. To be precise I am on the part where Kvothe decides to go to hillside to beg for the first time and is beaten by the guards and the head demon of Midwinter Paegentry helps him. That part was so moving. Rothfuss’ Prose is so immersive and enchanting that I am not able to put down the book.
It really has one of the finest prose I have seen, and everything feels so intentional that I am not able to understand what I have to remember and what not? It’s just amazing.
BTW excellent work, your editing skills are quite good.
Ahh I love that scene! There's so many memorable moments through-out both books. Enjoy the read!
Woh! I didn’t think I would get a reply. I love your videos, please post more videos about Mistborn and Wheel of Time.
These books are so good. I can re-read it again and again.
Just two days ago i finished reading the books and i enjoyed them a lot. I hope we get news from the next book soon and that Rothfuss doesn't take much longer to publish it. Greetings from Argentina
‘I got a problem!’ We’ve all been there Jay. Favourite books or movies that one slips back into reading or viewing, even though you know them like the back of your hand. Also can quote or recall favourite parts to others. Favourite books/movies are like comfort food because they can remind you of a time when things were different, simpler or easier. They can make you feel better or worse depending what you need, whether it’s comfort, reassurance, guidance or a reminder of ones youthful times. It can also remind people about those they have like a gifted book from a parent or friend, that when the book takes on a meaning that only that person knows. Beyond a favourite book it can become a treasure or a family heirloom something of true value to pass down the generations of one’s family.
Oh yeah I know how required reading can potentially rid a person of their desire to read for enjoyment as I’ve been to university twice so six years of it and learn plus school before those stages of my life. It’s crazy 😜 to think I want to go back again that’s another story. But needless to say I never lost my love of reading or the enjoyment of it because I found a way to seperate from non fiction to fiction and fantasy. I always kept reading both without it I might have wanted to give up reading. It’s worth learning about the real world and created ones to keep things fresh. Otherwise reading can be lost to some people.
Edit like Those they have lost 😞
I never want to read a book more than when Jay dedicates a perfectly paced, artsy video to it
By far my favorite saga. Worth the wait for the third installment.
Keep up the good work! The videos are always informative and wonderfully edited. So sorry to hear of the ongoing struggles you and your family have to endure. Hopefully the enjoyment people get out of your videos is a small bonus and brings a smile to your face.
Thanks for another KKC video! I love these!
I can also recommend the audio book version of the books. The narrator, Nick Podehl, does a wonderful job!
Always love your videos on the Kingkiller Chronicles. I consider you the go-to when it comes to the series.
Currently on 3rd reread, love your videos!
Your editing is still my absolute favorite thing 👏🏻
Also: I always found Kvothe to be very similar to Odysseus as he retells his story to the Phaeacians in (I think?) Books 9-11 of the Odyssey. The magical encounters, the possibility of an unreliable narrator, how arrogant they both are. the importance of music and story telling, themes/motifs of travel, family ties, revenge, etc. Not sure if this is intention, but I’m thinking about putting together an essay / video essay on it when Doors of Stone comes out
Wow Kvothe really is similar to Odysseus! 🤔 Thanks for pointing that out! And glad you liked the video! :D
You've read the books so many times you're basically Kvothe at this point.
I came to this story when I was 14 y.o. I since then I loved the world. Truth be told I started reading them in Spanish but since then I have read each book over 9 times each both in Spanish and English and the are still my adoration.
I'm guessing I've reread the series at least 5 times - it never ceases to be enjoyable!
Loved the Slow Regard. Amazing look into the mind of one of the "cracked" and one of my favorite "side" characters
Oh I love that you’ve appeared in my suggestions. I was searching for some Kingkiller theory videos and couldn’t believe how many were negative. I’ve read both books a couple of times and have just lent them to someone while I listen along to the audio version. It’s like a little book club, but I obviously don’t want to spoil anything for him, so wanted to did other people who have read them to talk theories with! I remember I had loads by the end of NotW, but can’t remember what they were 🤣
8th time through Kings Dark Tidings. Should check it out, not as complex but still worth a read or listen. Love TKC, thanks for your work.
My friend gave me a copy of the 1st book. 😁 I’ll definitely read it.
As for Kvothe being a reliable narrator; or not. There has always bwen one part that stood out to me. Though it haa been so long since I read the book, I could not point out where to find it.
But it was where he was telling his story, and the way it was worded made me think that what we read, was not what he was telling the Chronicler.
That entire part made me not question what the reader read, but if what Chronicler was told to be what we were reading.
Wish I could remember which book and where, but it has been 3 years...
It’s easily one of my favorite series and even if it never ends I still really enjoy Kvothe’s journey.
"And I ended up re-reading both books again.. I got a problem" I felt personally attacked by that :D but I can only completely agree with your points! I've recommended this book to so many people basically based upon the points you mentioned here
I have to say that I largely agree with you on everything. I read it twice in book format and listened to it once on audiobook. The second read was better than the first because I could pay attention to a lot of smaller details, and when i listened to the audiobook i literally got chills when i realized so many of the lines rhymed or had a prose to them. While i also agree that this series has it's flaws, it does hold a place in my heart because it was the first book I read for fun in nearly 4 years (all of high school I didn't read and I picked this up right after graduating), and it had rekindled my love for reading.
also whenever people say that kvothe is a mary sue i think they're not understanding that he's the one telling the story. Of course he's going to make himself sound close to perfect and that everything came easy to him, because memories of how hard learning stuff fades. and he also reminsces on his mistakes and flaws a lot and at least on the second read i noticed that he's not perfect at all and he's just a guy telling his life story and focusing on the little things which had an impact.
anyways sorry for the little rant in the second paragraph, great review. this is the book i most recommend when people ask me for recommendations so there is that :)
I’ve got to read this book the name of the wind 💨 hoping to read soon.. thank u for this video 🎬📼📽📹 happy reading to u!! 😊📖📚
When I first read the books I couldn't believe the range and intensity of emotions it made me feel... I remember getting chills, having tears in my eyes from the beautiful prose, laughing HYSTERICALLY, sobbing HYSTERICALLY, vibrating with excitement, and just generally being compeletely addicted to reading these books. I would finish The Wise Man's Fear and just go right back to the beginning of The Name of the Wind. I'm going to patiently wait for the final book. Fans may be disappointed right now, but I know we won't be disappointed when we finally get to read Doors of Stone.
I find myself raving about these books to anyone who asks me for a recommendation.
I found this book through a podcast (my brother my brother and me) and purely based off my trust of those guys I read it. They are now my favorite books of all time.
Agree. The ebb and flow of the words, intermingled with dreams of coyote and loki stories, and of course All the Jacks and foxes. Great recommendation
I'm not sure how many times I have read this books and each time I love them more and got desperate waiting for the third one. However, I never get bored at all.
Thanks for a cracking video! You summed up everything I've felt is great about the books. Myself and my wife have particularly enjoyed your various theory videos on the series.
Best wishes and prayers to your mum.
Thanks again,
keep up the good work.
These books are undoubtedly a masterpiece. I'm upset that the third book hasn't been published yet, but I'd rather Rothfuss take the time to make them as perfect as he can make them. These books are impeccably written. They made me realize how few words we use in normal day to day life. I fell in love with the marvelous subtleties of the English language because of these books. There is not one word out of place. It's his Magnum Opus, his perfect storm, a once in a millennium masterpiece. I eagerly await more.
Well. I watched this to gain inspiration to finish the name of the wind. I started about a month ago and have only reached 237.
Watching some reviews I was shocked to see how highly it is regarded. Although I I finally getting interesting at the university, I find it dull. Sorry. That is my opinion. I had no preconceptions about this book having never heard of it. I was given it by a friend for summer reading. So far the world is superficial, deep I not something I would refer to it. I do hope I enjoy it more soon, but I cannot see myself ever reading this again. Never mind the second book.
I do understand you love it, but it seems it is not for everyone. So far.
To be continued..... maybe
Thank you for making another video on the series. Please continue to make more 😀. I know there are lot's of us that watch these video's religiously. I just listened to this series for the third time over the last 2 weeks and change. You should try listening to them on audible. I picked up on more and different things while listening. You also get to hear the proper pronunciations for words.
Im enjoying Wise Man's fear right now,there is no rush! ❤
I honestly haven't been THIS invested in a fantasy world since Kate Elliott's Crown of Stars series completed. Sure I've been drawn in by her other works, and from other authors, but there's just something extra about Kingkiller Chronicles! I have a hard time putting the books down; I'm smack in the middle of Wise Man's Fear right now.
Great books. MC never meets his parents killers again. Instead he helps an old guy get married, goes to school, doesn't finish learning anything, while moving at a snails pace. Slice of life rubbish without any higher stakes at all. We're just told of them & told of world ending consequences, then shown the MCs love life + lies.
Be warned of anyone selling this to you as a revenge story or hyping up the Chandrian. All lies. No real payoff.
A few poems & writing skill doesn't overcome the core problem. He can't pace a story or maintain importance in the primary goal/enemy.
Your videos are so good.
Made a deal with one of my professors who is also a huge fantasy nerd. I would read The Name of the Wind if he began the third book in the Stormlight Archive (one of my favorite series). Your video has hyped me up excited to start it in the next week!
One of my favorite series of all time! Your video is fantastic, and an inspiration so that one day I can create content as good as you! 😊 Looking forward to the next video, Jay!
3 years later,you are a living legend Petrik! 😊
I like the lightning tree better than silent things but like you I’m totally addicted.
Well, you’ve convinced me. This series has just shot up to the top of my TBR.
-T
"And with no release date for the 3rd book, I decided to take a break from even thinking about it.....anddd I ended up rereading both books again."
Dis me😂 Read them both 3 times in 4 years so far
I reread/relisten them every few months. I started reading The Name of the Wind in 2015. I am on my 16th or 17th reread/relisten.
@@alexmarkadonis7179 holy crap! Always amazes me when ppl read it that much. That's awesome!
I read them for the first time about 6 months ago and I've already reread them lol
@@Dovakinskywalker that's awesome! I just started rereading more in 2020. KingKiller is now a yearly reread for me
Books are pure fire, amazing and I was hooked after first few pages. It is no wonder it was a best seller. I just read them few days ago and honestly while writters should have take time to do a story they could be transperant more so we know what is going on. If he says it will take me at least 5-10 years more, am 33% finished that would be totally ok but it sucks to know the latest information about the book rn is a radio scilence after he never delivered a promised chapter for which he got over a million dollars for his charity. Kind of sucks. I get it tho, had something similar happen to me but what got me out was simply being open.
I found these books 4 years ago, I wait patiently for the third book but I have many other books to read through so I'm not too concerned.
The thing that struck me most with these books is how easily they come to life your mind. Some book series take almost the entire first and second book to have a full picture of the world but within the first few paragraphs of the Name of the Wind you can already see the world that Patrick has created.
Shoutout for your efforts 👍
With listening to them at work, I have to be in the top 90% or higher of having read it the most.
I think you really capture excitement with that video, i started the series a few days ago and this video is hyping me up even more. However i stopped at the three minute mark, cause of some light spoilers already (at least till page 300 there is no word of kvothe being responsible for the skale creatures). Great video tho, i'll Look forward to watching it after I've caught up :)
Hello. 1 week from now I Will probably start KKC.Can't wait❤
Awesome video 🙏
I have the books on my shelf. I'm going to read them
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
As soon as the third book is announced.
Smart choice, i really regret reading it when it come out ....
These books started my love of fantasy....God I love these books so much
One unique thing about Rothfuss's style is that he uses interlacing metaphors. He describes magic through music, music through taste, love through song, and so on.
A question for more experienced readers. Why do characters sometimes speak in rhyme? Does it signify anything? Maybe Kvothe embellishes the facts when he makes people in his memory speak in rhyme...
thank you for making this! I definitely want to check out this series after watching this video
I've reread it twice
But wanna reread it thrice
After watching this video.
Maybe this will be the only book that I can reread a lot of times until the 3rd book is published and so on.
Thank you! I have read this book so much need to buy a new copy soon!
The seven words thing also happens with the "then words to break a strong man's will", specially during the conversation witht the Cthaeh. I've compared both the original books with the Spanish translation to make sure this kind of sentences are not just a coincidence of the translation, and I can tell you the phrasing in both situations is compleatly intended to have this number of words!
I'll definitely give these books a try when Doors of Stone gets a release date. After A Song of Ice and Fire I don't want to start a series that has no end in sight. These books do sound good, I just would rather consume them all at once than have to wait who knows how long to finish the story.
in conclusion: one of the best stories one should hold till finished. because i love re-reading and see the clues
I am curious about this series, but since I am still waiting on a song of ice and fire, I think I will start this when the third comes out.
This video really makes me want to read it right now though 😂
I envision 3 books on the past, followed by 3 books on what kvothe does currently, then 3 books on the history of kvothe's future.
I've reread both books 4 times... It's that good.
I've read/listened to this series at least 15 times and I still find new things. It's always like visiting old friends...
Until next time!
Omg! You made me want to reread these books so bad, and I never reread books. I forgot most of the things that happen in the story, so I will reread them for sure, but I want to wait a bit longer for the 3rd book to be out. By now I still have so many books to read.
Great video!
Time for a reread 📚
I got about halfway through the first book and had the feeling that it wasn't really leading anywhere and so I stopped. Im not a very analytical reader, I don't look for clues nor do I ever reread a book once Ive completed it.
On the other hand, I did enjoy his writing style. Given all the praise it keeps getting, I've exceptionally put it back on the reading list for a reread. Maybe as you said, it's more enjoyable upon rereading.
Thoughts/theories about Auri and Bast? Was Bast rescued by Kvothe? How did Auri end up in the bellows? Why Elodin protecting her? What does he know about her past?
one thing i realised is that just like real life people, once i like/love a character, even though they make mistakes and showcase flaws, it generally doesn't take away from my love for them. it's the tolerance that comes through understanding, and i might even find myself agreeing with them too. so i feel like once i start this series kvothe will have me wrapped around his finger lol.
I’m going to reread them this year!
Awesome, enjoy the reread!
Let's be honest here: everyone watching this has already read the books. 😂
Not yet
Not me
You two in the comments, get on it. What are you doing? 😂
I expected telling me “sure bro”
But hey “a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one” you guys are lucky reading this for the first time
Not in any way shape or form.. yet !
No idea when or if the series will be finished, but I do already own what's been published and I do plan on reading it eventually. No idea when that will be, but you definitely do a great job of hyping up the series.
Absolutely fantastic video as always :)
Although I will admit the pace of the video was a bit too fast for me to keep up with at times. However I simply went back sometimes to rewatch.
Still, amazing arguments and a great way of presenting them (not to mention the editing ^^).
I love your vids! Thank you for making them! ❤️
I've had The Name of the Wind on my shelves for quite some time, but I don't want to start it when the third and final book isn't out yet :)))))
If you start now you can get through several re-reads and be well versed in all the little details and hints from the other two books.