🎫Purchase Your Ticket to the Annual Asayama Ichiden Ryu Training Camp in Japan: www.patreon.com/c/lets_ask_sekisensei/shop ⚔Join the Online Kobudo Training with Seki Sensei⚔ Sign Up HERE (One Lesson FREE): www.patreon.com/lets_ask_sekisensei Interested in taking lessons directly from the 22nd headmaster of Kobudo Asayama Ichiden Ryu, Seki sensei? Sign up to learn authentic samurai skills with 400 years of history with perfect English interpretation from Let’s ask Shogo (ruclips.net/user/LetsaskShogoYourJapanesefriendinKyoto). ❶ No previous martial arts experience is required; you can catch up anytime ❷ Every lesson will be RECORDED and will be available to rewatch anytime ❸ You can ask Seki Sensei questions about the techniques and samurai culture/history ❹ You can join even if you belong to another Ryuha style ❺ You can receive OFFICIAL DAN RANKS by taking exams online (and opening a DOJO in the future) 🛍Purchase the Equipment You Need for Training: tozandoshop.com/letsaskshogo🛍 🗡Iaitō (training katana): tozandoshop.com/collections/habahiro-heavy-weight-iaito/products/byakko-tenryu-semi-custom-iaito?variant=34479502164101 *🗡Bokutō (wooden katana) with plastic Saya (scabbard): tozandoshop.com/collections/iaido-bokuto/products/the-nyumon-iaido-beginners-set 🥋Dōgi and Hakama: tozandoshop.com/collections/kendo-uniform-sets/products/basic-synthetic-kendo-uniform-set-1?variant=39417538216069 🥋Inner Obi (any color): tozandoshop.com/collections/iaido-obi/products/cotton-kaku-obi?variant=34282096230533 🥋Outer Obi (must be WHITE): tozandoshop.com/collections/aikido-obi/products/white-aikido-obi?variant=34120442413189 🦯Short Jō staff: tozandoshop.com/collections/polearms/products/4-21-shaku-jo?variant=39604823195781 🦯Long Jō staff: tozandoshop.com/collections/polearms/products/5-shaku-bo?variant=34073586106501 🧐Frequently Asked Questions About Our Online Lessons: Q❓: I have no experience with katana. Will I still be able to catch up? A💡: You don’t need any previous katana martial arts experience to participate in our lessons. Seki Sensei, the instructor of the online lessons, will carefully instruct you on how to handle the katana regardless of your level. You will also be able to access all the videos of the past lessons so you can watch what every other student has learned. You can also send us videos of your progress, and Seki Sensei will be happy to give you feedback. Q❓: What is the right length of the Iaito (zinc alloy training katana) I should use? A💡: Please purchase an Iaitō at least two blocks longer than the standard length. The standard length for Seki Sensei is about 177cm, so he should use a 2.45 Shaku long katana. However, he uses a 2.6 Shaku-long katana that is supposed to be used by someone 190cm tall. If the katana is too short, it becomes too easy to draw, which is not good for training. Q❓: Can I join even if I belong to a different Ryuha style? A💡: Yes, it’s not a problem at all. The Seki Sensei himself has trained in more than five styles and various other weapons. If you don’t want others to know that you are participating, you can join the online lessons with your camera off. To have the Sensei check your progress, you can send us a video of you practicing. 🗡Join the Online Iaido Training with Seki Sensei🗡 Sign Up Here (One Lesson FREE): www.patreon.com/sekisenseiiaidotraining Interested in taking Iaido lessons directly from the 8th Dan Iaido Master with 40 years of experience in Musō Shinden Ryu, Seki sensei? Sign up to learn authentic samurai skills with perfect English interpretation from Let’s ask Shogo. ❶ No previous martial arts experience is required; you can catch up anytime ❷ Every lesson will be RECORDED and will be available to rewatch anytime ❸ You can ask Seki Sensei questions about the techniques and samurai culture/history ❹ You can join even if you belong to another Ryuha style 💻Seki Sensei's Official Website💻 sekisensei.com/ 🎵Original Opening Theme Song "Hyakuren"🎵 Performance: Hanafugetsu (Singer/Suzuhana Yuko, Shakuhachi/Kaminaga Daisuke, Koto/Ibukuro Kiyoshi) Compositions & Arrangements: Suzuhana Yuko Mixing & Mastering: Watabiki Yuta ❓What is Asayama Ichiden Ryu? / Who is Seki sensei?❓ ruclips.net/video/2aBKmWmJpJw/видео.html 📱Instagram📱 instagram.com/lets_ask_sekisensei/ *Please ask us questions through the DM here #katana #iaido #kenjutsu #kobudo #asayamaichidenryu
I think it is a pity he has very few good movies. I can only name The Last Samurai and Twilight Samurai. His skill is absolutely top level. No doubt about that :-) !
In the Twilight Samurai he shows his skills at combat beautifully! It is closer to reality in my mind, using the reduced space against the katana blade in
@@benwagner5089 sadly it's not only them that behavior is everywhere just give a look at social media and you can see it clearly. The problem in my opinion is that many people have lost their sense of dignity what in the old times was called honor.
He definitely did the best he could do with the role...though I've always wondered how Christian Bale would have done in the role? Seemed like he was built for a role like that, and he takes martial arts training very seriously for his more physical roles.
I think that from a character standpoint, the fact that Tom Cruise's character has zero experience or training would lead Sanada-san's character to perhaps do moves that he would never dream of doing against an experienced opponent (the high kicking etc.), 'showboating' a little bit if you will, to assert his dominance and/or humiliate Tom Cruise's character who, don't forget, was captured alive as a prisoner, something very much looked down on at the time.
Interestingly Cruise´s character also shows no knowledge of actual saber techniques which would at least give him a sence of distance and also some more protective stances against his opponent.
"captured alive as a prisoner, something very much looked down on at the time." No not necessarily. To my understanding to the Japanese it was shameful to surrender; and if I remember correctly Cpt Algren never actually surrendered.
@@henninghesse9910 I was wondering about that too, and all I could really come up with is that maybe Cpt. Algren was experienced with a saber while mounted, but had never really practiced with it on foot.
@@henninghesse9910 Might also go to show that the Union army he was with didn't train their soldiers worth squat, so all he knows is from actual battlefield experience fighting (and massacring) the Native Americans. Which then implies that he assumed the job would be a farce at the beginning, training peasants to barely point a rifle the right way and his "they aren't ready" scene was really more about his death wish than their actual readiness...
This man has dedicated his life to his Art and yet he is magnanimous in his praise of an actor highlighting his skills right up to the end of the recording, respect for someone who has obviously dedicated his time to learning the art of Bushido. Massive respect.
@@mattdekker5693by that logic everyone who plays sports for a living, is an artist or musician is wasting their lives. And apparently so are historians. He's preserving an art and is engaged in a sport. What's wrong with that?
I believe Sanada San was Godan in Kendo at the time of filming. So, he's definitely skilled. It shows easily as you say with his grip and his Jodan no Kamae as well. I'm impressed with how well these scenes held up under close scrutiny from Seki Sensei. Ron Howard (the director) would surely take pride in this all these years later. We all know it's dramatised but they generally did a very good job trying to respect Japanese Martial arts.
@@JuandelaCruz001he's pretty skilled in various martial arts.... His mentor was the late Shinichi aka Sonny Chiba and he was a member of Sonny Chiba's Action Club... Sonny Chiba himself was a student of Kyokushin Karate founder Mas Oyama
Something I've always liked about Hiroyuki Sanada is that not only is he a great and intense actor, but he is actually a very skilled martial artist. If I recall correctly, he is trained in Karate (I think Kyokushin) as well as some form of actual Japanese swordsmanship (I'm not sure which school or style) and I think I remember reading somewhere that he is also trained in Judo as well. He may have even more training and experience beyond that, but I'm not sure. I've seen him in many films spanning from his early career to the present and I always love watching him in both action and drama scenes as I feel he excels in both very well, especially when he plays a Samurai. He pulls off the iconic film Samurai-esque stoicism so well! I really wish I could learn traditional Kenjutsu, Iaido, or even Kobudo, but I'm disabled and now that I walk with a cane full time lately and I can't really strike, takedown, throw, or fight on the ground anymore, I've been learning Chin Na (Chinese term for joint locking techniques) and also how to fight with a cane. I'm actually only 30, but I've had debilitating and worsening back and hip problems for almost a decade now that has affected my martial arts training slowly in a negative fashion. I have prior training with basic knife fighting, so I also keep a folding knife in my pocket as a last resort that I hope to never have to use.
I hope you are still alive and well and haven’t given up but all I have to say is even the slowest simplest moves the the most affective and used well enough with less energy is even more beautiful learn moves that suit your body with less ache and less energy spent this is ip man’s technique I wish you well lone ronin may your warriors journey be a glorious one
Brilliant 👍 Love the expressions on Master Seki's face. And Sanada San is fantastic in this and many other movies, great actor!! Really cool of Master Seki to do this. It's good fun! Thanks Shogo San 🙏 Take care. Stay safe 🙏 John and Kate
I'm just so psyched for this entire channel. Seki Sensei was always in my favorite AskShogo videos and this content about the martial art is so addicting.
As a student of Aikido, I was taught to block the drawing of the bokken and as the decades pass I am more comfortable without a weapon. I have used my skills on a number of occasions during my lengthy stay in West Africa, including putting to an end, two kidnapping attempts. I began my martial arts training at 12 with Shotokan. When I belted I moved on to Aikido and from the start, used my feet as Sensei does. More stability and a better way of centering oneself. Domo arigato.
That, and he know that Algren had no chance against him so he likely took more risks knowing he wouldn't be countered. It allowed Ujio to "go big" to show Algren who's boss.
I love that you explain what the master says after he speaks. I'm listening to this more than watching so i can't read it and that's greatly appreciated.
Great post. I think Sanada-san did improve the fight scenes and did help Tom Cruise with the scenes. I'm certain he was aware of the mistakes in the choreography of sword fight scenes. But had no control over all of it since it was the director's call. Who probably wanted the scenes be more dramatic especially for a Western audience. As always I love Seki-Sensei's insights. ❤
Yeah, Sanada is a monster. The bonus material in the DVD/Blu Ray shows him giving praise to Tom Cruise in the way that he took to the sword training like a natural, and that Cruise prepared for the role by learning Japanese prior to filming, so that they could shoot the US version and the Japanese version simultaneously. Ol' Tom's a crazy bastard, but he does go all in on these things....
@@mjhopgoodswe I've not seen it myself, but was told that all the dialogue was in Japanese. The British, American, and Canadian actors' lines got a Japanese dub voice over, but Tom actually wanted his real voice, speaking real Japanese.
My sincere respect to the Sensei who took time to give his opinion on these scenes. It is always amazing to listen to such amazing teachers who are a sea of knowledge and still so humble.
Thank you both for uploading this! It was interesting, informative, and well presented. I also appreciate the tone - honestly critical of its faults but willing to note the good aspects as well. 10/10
I love how willing Seki Sensei is to explain the reasons behind the movements of each step in the kata, and the sharing of the history of the techniques utilized both within and outside of his Ryuha.
Years ago I was practising aikido and while watching sensei's movements and listening to his comments it reminded me my trainings. Regards from Poland Mark.
As someone who is practicing with weapons for actual fighting, Seki-sensei's explanations are irreplaceable. The amount of knowledge and skill he has is awe inspiring, and I hope I can learn from him in person some day. I actually was curious if he would be willing to watch some Gintama fights, and give his thoughts on them. Considering the subject matter of the serious part of the series, it would be interesting to see how accurate it is.
I must admit I really enjoy Seki Sensei and his open minded outlook. He critiqued where it was needed and complimented at other locations. I must say that you are fortunate to be able to question and be so open with your questions. I had a Shotokan master in the past Master, Kazumi Tabata Sensei, who was very well versed in the Samurai Sword but to my knowledge never taught it. While he was a very busy man I often wondered why he never taught the sword. Years later I studied the Korean Sword and reflect on the absense of his choice not to instruct the sword. Somehow I feel I missed out on such valuable instruction. Sir to you and Seki Sensei, I thank you for sharing.
I love that you share your experience with your master, and I love how wonderful how your teacher, master is with learning things and trying new things he is clearly open minded and eager to learn and adapt..
I really enjoyed the way they portrayed cruises character. He was a seasoned warrior in the west but his Japanese martial arts skills were still new to him, so his fighting in that way is portrayed very raw.
I'll just take this opportunity to bring attention to the late Seizo Fukumoto (who plays samurai "Bob" in the Last Samurai), and a film called "Uzumasa Limelight" about the profession of being an extra in samurai cinema who is trained to "die" during sword fighting scenes (Fukumoto was one in real life) - released in 2014, it is a shame the film is not so well-known.
I felt that the "too big" attacks in the second sequence were a reveal of the anger the two characters had towards each other at that point in the film. They were each a little out of control and "swinging for the fences"
I love the amount of respect that you all show to others. Yes, much of what we see in movies is exaggerated. I have enough martial arts training to tell if someone is actually knowledgeable in what they do or not, but Seki Sensei's knowledge is at a level I will never reach. Keep up the good work!
I just found out about this channel and I'm really enjoying every video. Can we please get a video that's not about technique but that instead talks about the philosophy and ethics of Kobudo Asayama Ichiden Ryu? And maybe talk/explain the myths behind Bushidō. Thank you for the great videos!
I absolutely love the last samurai I still watch it from time to time and I’d love to be in Japan one day learning how to use the ancient art of the sword
So good of the honorable master to lend his knowledge! Thanks to both Seki Sensei and Shogo for this respectful and informative review. I have always loved this film and Sanada San was brilliant in this! Please consider reviewing Shadow!
Question: For the sparing scene could it have been the character Hiroyuki was playing meant to show the skills of a master swordsman’s vs that of a novice. He mentioned the wild swings on the part of Tom Cruise, but I noticed Hiroyuki was making the short quick movements he spoke of. Maybe that scene was meant to show how a swordsman’s would have to adapt to an inexperienced novice, which would explain his ducking.
perhaps also the swordmaster held resentment in his heart towards cruise's character, and sought not only to teach and show off his swordplay, but also to beat the stuffing out of him as well.
The big swings are standard for a US Cavalry Saber in the Civil War. They were not as sharp as a katana and need the momentum. They also had to withstand hitting a heavy solid infantry rifle and so were heavier.
Sensei Seki's advice to start with small movements when closing to the bind is something I will try out in HEMA. This is something I want to really test.
one of the more interesting parts of tom's character is that he uses a cavalry saber, so when he wields a katana he holds it like a one-handed curved sword instead of a two handed one
Just came across your channel and this was really quite interesting. Seki Sensei describes what is good and what is not, and does so in a respectful way!
I wonder if Sanada Hiroyuki was a descendant of Sanada Yukimura and Sanada clan in general. If he was, it would be a peak entertainment if one day he plays Tokugawa Ieyasu, Sanada clan’s greatest enemy.
It was the Ujio character that made me a fan of Sanada. Without any backstory or confirmation needed you can tell hes one of if not THE best swordsmen in the entire group to the point he is leading training sessions
I would love to see your opinion on my favourite samurai film 'Twilight Samurai'. I didn't even realise until now this is the same actor, very talented.
This is great. But a couple of things worth pointing out. In the sword training scene I think the reason Cruise swings like a baseball is the fact his character is American and its meant to be a "bad habit" . Also I thought that scene was meant to be only sword training so they were avoiding non-sword techniques but further than that, the two had a bit of a rivalry so there was a kind of ego battle happening. In the 4 v 1 scene the attackers are not samurai so their sword play would be poorer than you would expect, hence the bad technique for attacking a grounded opponent
That is a very interesting concept, the idea that it is a taboo if you can make a move that will end and win you the fight and you don't, that's viewed as a lack of courage. It gives a new perspective to how much precision and decisiveness are important for a samurai. Thank you for this insight
6:27 I agree, it's like what Miyamoto Musashi said that you cannot rely on training the sword alone, you need to also train the other aspects of martial arts (hand to hand)
Also knowing how other weapons handle as well as having an idea of what other budo styles approaches, mind sets and philosophies to combat are was very invaluable, especially in the the heyday of Edo period dueling. " know thy enemy, know thy self" - Sun Tzu
@@michael3088 yes that's also something Musashi mentioned, that you shouldn't favor one weapon over another and you should use the best tool for the job
years ago I was taking Aikido lessons and the first time I got bokken training it was easter holidays and it was just the sensei the most senior student and myself. I got a few bruised knuckles but the tuition was fantastic and got pretty good by the end. Sadly life got in the way and I wasn't able to continue the training, still a great regret. Awesome channel +1 new subscriber.
The actual guy that was the last samurai was not American but French. His name was Jules Brunet. He was an artillery expert in the French army and had received the Légion d'Honneur - France's highest military award for valor during the French Intervention of Mexico between 1862 and 1864.
There was a number of foreign experts invited to Japan, as well as different sorts of fact-finding missions sent from Japan and into the wider world. A lot of them technical experts, translators etc. During their last stand, the rebels had lost a lot of their artillery train while retreating and evading government forces to reach their home provines.
First video I've ever seen that mentions that sword fights in movies are a unique marital art on their own and distinctive from real life. Thanks for the respect and education!
This is so great! Btw, considering the sakabato video, it would be so great to see a Kenshin reaction, I'd gather the movies, rather than the anime? I would really love it if Seki-sensei could comment on the scenes where Kenshin's master is teaching him the ultimate technique before the final fights with Shishio Makoto & Co.
I’m no master by no means but I’ve trained/tried many systems and teach a mix of 10 from jkd to Bjj to even Bujinkan budo taijutsu and from what it looks like to me is that he was learning their kenjutsu but being a westerner using their saber and such type of fighting against the Native American, he was simply being natural as a mix of the two. Would some of those end a little badly for him depending, yes like he said, he should have thrusted and not cut downwards. My favorite weapon in “ninjutsu”/kenjutsu was the sword and shuriken especially when used together.
I always thought the uke crossing his legs was to protect the crotch/femoral artery using the shin armor since many of the attacks are aimed at weak spots of armor
🎫Purchase Your Ticket to the Annual Asayama Ichiden Ryu Training Camp in Japan: www.patreon.com/c/lets_ask_sekisensei/shop
⚔Join the Online Kobudo Training with Seki Sensei⚔
Sign Up HERE (One Lesson FREE): www.patreon.com/lets_ask_sekisensei
Interested in taking lessons directly from the 22nd headmaster of Kobudo Asayama Ichiden Ryu, Seki sensei? Sign up to learn authentic samurai skills with 400 years of history with perfect English interpretation from Let’s ask Shogo (ruclips.net/user/LetsaskShogoYourJapanesefriendinKyoto).
❶ No previous martial arts experience is required; you can catch up anytime
❷ Every lesson will be RECORDED and will be available to rewatch anytime
❸ You can ask Seki Sensei questions about the techniques and samurai culture/history
❹ You can join even if you belong to another Ryuha style
❺ You can receive OFFICIAL DAN RANKS by taking exams online (and opening a DOJO in the future)
🛍Purchase the Equipment You Need for Training: tozandoshop.com/letsaskshogo🛍
🗡Iaitō (training katana): tozandoshop.com/collections/habahiro-heavy-weight-iaito/products/byakko-tenryu-semi-custom-iaito?variant=34479502164101
*🗡Bokutō (wooden katana) with plastic Saya (scabbard): tozandoshop.com/collections/iaido-bokuto/products/the-nyumon-iaido-beginners-set
🥋Dōgi and Hakama: tozandoshop.com/collections/kendo-uniform-sets/products/basic-synthetic-kendo-uniform-set-1?variant=39417538216069
🥋Inner Obi (any color): tozandoshop.com/collections/iaido-obi/products/cotton-kaku-obi?variant=34282096230533
🥋Outer Obi (must be WHITE): tozandoshop.com/collections/aikido-obi/products/white-aikido-obi?variant=34120442413189
🦯Short Jō staff: tozandoshop.com/collections/polearms/products/4-21-shaku-jo?variant=39604823195781
🦯Long Jō staff: tozandoshop.com/collections/polearms/products/5-shaku-bo?variant=34073586106501
🧐Frequently Asked Questions About Our Online Lessons:
Q❓: I have no experience with katana. Will I still be able to catch up?
A💡: You don’t need any previous katana martial arts experience to participate in our lessons.
Seki Sensei, the instructor of the online lessons, will carefully instruct you on how to handle the katana regardless of your level. You will also be able to access all the videos of the past lessons so you can watch what every other student has learned. You can also send us videos of your progress, and Seki Sensei will be happy to give you feedback.
Q❓: What is the right length of the Iaito (zinc alloy training katana) I should use?
A💡: Please purchase an Iaitō at least two blocks longer than the standard length.
The standard length for Seki Sensei is about 177cm, so he should use a 2.45 Shaku long katana. However, he uses a 2.6 Shaku-long katana that is supposed to be used by someone 190cm tall. If the katana is too short, it becomes too easy to draw, which is not good for training.
Q❓: Can I join even if I belong to a different Ryuha style?
A💡: Yes, it’s not a problem at all.
The Seki Sensei himself has trained in more than five styles and various other weapons. If you don’t want others to know that you are participating, you can join the online lessons with your camera off. To have the Sensei check your progress, you can send us a video of you practicing.
🗡Join the Online Iaido Training with Seki Sensei🗡
Sign Up Here (One Lesson FREE): www.patreon.com/sekisenseiiaidotraining
Interested in taking Iaido lessons directly from the 8th Dan Iaido Master with 40 years of experience in Musō Shinden Ryu, Seki sensei? Sign up to learn authentic samurai skills with perfect English interpretation from Let’s ask Shogo.
❶ No previous martial arts experience is required; you can catch up anytime
❷ Every lesson will be RECORDED and will be available to rewatch anytime
❸ You can ask Seki Sensei questions about the techniques and samurai culture/history
❹ You can join even if you belong to another Ryuha style
💻Seki Sensei's Official Website💻
sekisensei.com/
🎵Original Opening Theme Song "Hyakuren"🎵
Performance: Hanafugetsu (Singer/Suzuhana Yuko, Shakuhachi/Kaminaga Daisuke, Koto/Ibukuro Kiyoshi)
Compositions & Arrangements: Suzuhana Yuko
Mixing & Mastering: Watabiki Yuta
❓What is Asayama Ichiden Ryu? / Who is Seki sensei?❓
ruclips.net/video/2aBKmWmJpJw/видео.html
📱Instagram📱
instagram.com/lets_ask_sekisensei/
*Please ask us questions through the DM here
#katana #iaido #kenjutsu #kobudo #asayamaichidenryu
would have suggested the battle scenes for it, First Fight against the untrained and later.
Awesome! Thanks for this vid! I love this movie!
@@letsasksekisensei online is nice if I had a tv screen, but on a cellphone???? DVDs would be good!
I love the praise for Sanada-san. He’s a great actor and brilliant swordsman!
💯 agree😊
I think it is a pity he has very few good movies. I can only name The Last Samurai and Twilight Samurai.
His skill is absolutely top level. No doubt about that :-) !
@@akarivn I also wish that Sanada had a bit more screen time during John Wick 4
In the Twilight Samurai he shows his skills at combat beautifully! It is closer to reality in my mind, using the reduced space against the katana blade in
@@akarivn- He had a decently big role in Bullet Train - but not necessarily martial arts.
Very respectful comments - I love how Seki manages to not disparage others while explaining how it is simply done differently in different schools ❤
It’s a Japanese thing. Others need not suffer. To make a point, right or wrong, etc. disparaging others isn’t necessary to elevate oneself
japanese people are always polite and an honorable man doesn't disparage others to elevate himself which is something so many people should learn.
I love that too. We have different lifestyles but there is one thing we do share together. Respect, be respectful.
@@littlemouse7066 Now if only our politicians and news channels can emulate this as well, instead of mud-slinging the opponent all the time.
@@benwagner5089 sadly it's not only them that behavior is everywhere just give a look at social media and you can see it clearly. The problem in my opinion is that many people have lost their sense of dignity what in the old times was called honor.
I have to give Tom credit for his role here. He dove into the character without any experience and listened to what they told him
Yo, shout out to Kavinski
Also a lot of the crits was on him, a character who had very little training too.
Not a fan of Tom Cruise, but he's definitely a very good actor.
Yes, it's the whole joining a cult thing that made me dislike him.
@@WhoThisMonkey its weird isnt it :) hes a spooky lunatic in real life but hes NEVER failed to entertain me :)
He definitely did the best he could do with the role...though I've always wondered how Christian Bale would have done in the role? Seemed like he was built for a role like that, and he takes martial arts training very seriously for his more physical roles.
I think that from a character standpoint, the fact that Tom Cruise's character has zero experience or training would lead Sanada-san's character to perhaps do moves that he would never dream of doing against an experienced opponent (the high kicking etc.), 'showboating' a little bit if you will, to assert his dominance and/or humiliate Tom Cruise's character who, don't forget, was captured alive as a prisoner, something very much looked down on at the time.
Considering cpt Algren killed samurai who underestimated him, he was wise not to repeat that mistake.
Interestingly Cruise´s character also shows no knowledge of actual saber techniques which would at least give him a sence of distance and also some more protective stances against his opponent.
"captured alive as a prisoner, something very much looked down on at the time." No not necessarily. To my understanding to the Japanese it was shameful to surrender; and if I remember correctly Cpt Algren never actually surrendered.
@@henninghesse9910 I was wondering about that too, and all I could really come up with is that maybe Cpt. Algren was experienced with a saber while mounted, but had never really practiced with it on foot.
@@henninghesse9910 Might also go to show that the Union army he was with didn't train their soldiers worth squat, so all he knows is from actual battlefield experience fighting (and massacring) the Native Americans. Which then implies that he assumed the job would be a farce at the beginning, training peasants to barely point a rifle the right way and his "they aren't ready" scene was really more about his death wish than their actual readiness...
This man has dedicated his life to his Art and yet he is magnanimous in his praise of an actor highlighting his skills right up to the end of the recording, respect for someone who has obviously dedicated his time to learning the art of Bushido. Massive respect.
I live my life in Budo. That bushido ending seems rough lol. But thank you for teaching me what magnanimous means (well u and google lol).
I’m amazed at how smooth his movement is. When he takes a step it’s like his body glides across the floor
why doesnt he dedicate his life to something usefull, whos he sword fighting right now?
@@mattdekker5693by that logic everyone who plays sports for a living, is an artist or musician is wasting their lives. And apparently so are historians. He's preserving an art and is engaged in a sport.
What's wrong with that?
Sanada is finally playing a lead role in an Samurai centered production in the series Shogun and he’s killing it! He is truly a master!
Not the first time he had the lead role in many japanese samurai movies like the Twilight samurai
@@Les_Carnets_de_Tom I’ll have to check that out
I love how Seki Sensei is a fan of Hiroyuki Sanada.
It just brings me a glimmer of joy
Same!
I have been a fan of him since I watched him first in Ninja in the Dragons Den.
who wouldn't be a fan
I am his big fan, too! 🥰💖👍✨
Well. I think everyone is fan of him...
This is quickly becoming one of my favorite channels. Love the way you bridge the gap between traditional and modern.
I believe Sanada San was Godan in Kendo at the time of filming. So, he's definitely skilled. It shows easily as you say with his grip and his Jodan no Kamae as well. I'm impressed with how well these scenes held up under close scrutiny from Seki Sensei. Ron Howard (the director) would surely take pride in this all these years later. We all know it's dramatised but they generally did a very good job trying to respect Japanese Martial arts.
Actually, the director of this was Ed Zwick
He was also a genuine karateka (can't renember if JKA Shotokan or Kyokushin though?)
He's definitely very legit.
@@JuandelaCruz001 Kyokushin.
@@JuandelaCruz001he's pretty skilled in various martial arts.... His mentor was the late Shinichi aka Sonny Chiba and he was a member of Sonny Chiba's Action Club... Sonny Chiba himself was a student of Kyokushin Karate founder Mas Oyama
Mr. Sanada is one of my all time favorites, it's great to see him get more credit for his outstanding work.
Something I've always liked about Hiroyuki Sanada is that not only is he a great and intense actor, but he is actually a very skilled martial artist. If I recall correctly, he is trained in Karate (I think Kyokushin) as well as some form of actual Japanese swordsmanship (I'm not sure which school or style) and I think I remember reading somewhere that he is also trained in Judo as well. He may have even more training and experience beyond that, but I'm not sure.
I've seen him in many films spanning from his early career to the present and I always love watching him in both action and drama scenes as I feel he excels in both very well, especially when he plays a Samurai. He pulls off the iconic film Samurai-esque stoicism so well!
I really wish I could learn traditional Kenjutsu, Iaido, or even Kobudo, but I'm disabled and now that I walk with a cane full time lately and I can't really strike, takedown, throw, or fight on the ground anymore, I've been learning Chin Na (Chinese term for joint locking techniques) and also how to fight with a cane.
I'm actually only 30, but I've had debilitating and worsening back and hip problems for almost a decade now that has affected my martial arts training slowly in a negative fashion. I have prior training with basic knife fighting, so I also keep a folding knife in my pocket as a last resort that I hope to never have to use.
I hope you are still alive and well and haven’t given up but all I have to say is even the slowest simplest moves the the most affective and used well enough with less energy is even more beautiful learn moves that suit your body with less ache and less energy spent this is ip man’s technique I wish you well lone ronin may your warriors journey be a glorious one
@@vernalkallestewa9079 Thanks so much, I greatly appreciate your kindness and advice. I wish you the best in your journey as well. :)
Brilliant 👍 Love the expressions on Master Seki's face. And Sanada San is fantastic in this and many other movies, great actor!!
Really cool of Master Seki to do this. It's good fun! Thanks Shogo San 🙏 Take care. Stay safe 🙏
John and Kate
I'm just so psyched for this entire channel. Seki Sensei was always in my favorite AskShogo videos and this content about the martial art is so addicting.
As a student of Aikido, I was taught to block the drawing of the bokken and as the decades pass I am more comfortable without a weapon. I have used my skills on a number of occasions during my lengthy stay in West Africa, including putting to an end, two kidnapping attempts. I began my martial arts training at 12 with Shotokan. When I belted I moved on to Aikido and from the start, used my feet as Sensei does. More stability and a better way of centering oneself.
Domo arigato.
The sensei's reaction and demeanor is almost like it's out of a book I love the professionalism and the discipline.
I think the crossed wrists in the rain fight showed his complete contempt for his opponent. Which fits the scene very well.
That, and he know that Algren had no chance against him so he likely took more risks knowing he wouldn't be countered. It allowed Ujio to "go big" to show Algren who's boss.
I love that you explain what the master says after he speaks. I'm listening to this more than watching so i can't read it and that's greatly appreciated.
Great post. I think Sanada-san did improve the fight scenes and did help Tom Cruise with the scenes. I'm certain he was aware of the mistakes in the choreography of sword fight scenes. But had no control over all of it since it was the director's call. Who probably wanted the scenes be more dramatic especially for a Western audience. As always I love Seki-Sensei's insights. ❤
Yeah, Sanada is a monster. The bonus material in the DVD/Blu Ray shows him giving praise to Tom Cruise in the way that he took to the sword training like a natural, and that Cruise prepared for the role by learning Japanese prior to filming, so that they could shoot the US version and the Japanese version simultaneously. Ol' Tom's a crazy bastard, but he does go all in on these things....
@@LarsonPettyWhat is different in the Japanese version?
@@mjhopgoodswe I've not seen it myself, but was told that all the dialogue was in Japanese. The British, American, and Canadian actors' lines got a Japanese dub voice over, but Tom actually wanted his real voice, speaking real Japanese.
@@LarsonPetty That's insane. It really shows how invested Tom Cruise is in his work.
Oh man, excellent video as always Shogo and Seki-sensei
God I love this man! The traditions he preserves are so important. Practice, practice, practice!
I don't know how I found this channel but I'm so glad I did, fascinating stuff!
My sincere respect to the Sensei who took time to give his opinion on these scenes. It is always amazing to listen to such amazing teachers who are a sea of knowledge and still so humble.
Thank you both for uploading this! It was interesting, informative, and well presented. I also appreciate the tone - honestly critical of its faults but willing to note the good aspects as well. 10/10
I love how willing Seki Sensei is to explain the reasons behind the movements of each step in the kata, and the sharing of the history of the techniques utilized both within and outside of his Ryuha.
Over a 100k followers! Outstanding! Well deserved. 🙏
Years ago I was practising aikido and while watching sensei's movements and listening to his comments it reminded me my trainings.
Regards from Poland
Mark.
As someone who is practicing with weapons for actual fighting, Seki-sensei's explanations are irreplaceable. The amount of knowledge and skill he has is awe inspiring, and I hope I can learn from him in person some day. I actually was curious if he would be willing to watch some Gintama fights, and give his thoughts on them. Considering the subject matter of the serious part of the series, it would be interesting to see how accurate it is.
Im not normally a fan of reaction videos but this was excellent. Its clear the knowledge he has. The real deal.
Less of a reaction and more of a professional analysis
I must admit I really enjoy Seki Sensei and his open minded outlook. He critiqued where it was needed and complimented at other locations. I must say that you are fortunate to be able to question and be so open with your questions. I had a Shotokan master in the past Master, Kazumi Tabata Sensei, who was very well versed in the Samurai Sword but to my knowledge never taught it. While he was a very busy man I often wondered why he never taught the sword. Years later I studied the Korean Sword and reflect on the absense of his choice not to instruct the sword. Somehow I feel I missed out on such valuable instruction. Sir to you and Seki Sensei, I thank you for sharing.
It is amazing and truly great to see there is still masters that keep the sword arts alive❤
Very happy to see you guy achieved your goal of 100,000 subscribers!
Congratulations!
Thank you for the great videos.
=Kind regards from Texas=
I love that you share your experience with your master, and I love how wonderful how your teacher, master is with learning things and trying new things he is clearly open minded and eager to learn and adapt..
Also I think the samurai was trying to teach a lesson or many for the arrogant American..
Many respects to this grand Sensei for his time to comment the video. I bow to you, sir.
I really enjoyed the way they portrayed cruises character. He was a seasoned warrior in the west but his Japanese martial arts skills were still new to him, so his fighting in that way is portrayed very raw.
Excellent video !!!! Seki Sensei very clear in his explanations. Thanks Shogo-san too!
I appreciate their dedication to their craft and using that experience to further our understanding.
I'll just take this opportunity to bring attention to the late Seizo Fukumoto (who plays samurai "Bob" in the Last Samurai), and a film called "Uzumasa Limelight" about the profession of being an extra in samurai cinema who is trained to "die" during sword fighting scenes (Fukumoto was one in real life) - released in 2014, it is a shame the film is not so well-known.
This film is beautiful and it can be watched on YT at the Samurai vs Ninja channel.
Thank you for posting this! Absolutely praise is due to each of you for your individual expertise and art.
I felt that the "too big" attacks in the second sequence were a reveal of the anger the two characters had towards each other at that point in the film. They were each a little out of control and "swinging for the fences"
Great assessment. I totally agree.
Real samurai is taught not to get out of control
@@hollowjack8711 Musashi famously won duels by getting his opponents (other samurai) to lose their temper.
I love the amount of respect that you all show to others. Yes, much of what we see in movies is exaggerated. I have enough martial arts training to tell if someone is actually knowledgeable in what they do or not, but Seki Sensei's knowledge is at a level I will never reach. Keep up the good work!
This is one of my favorite movies. Such a masterpiece. The emotions, the cinematography and the story is incredible.
nominated but didnt win the oscars
Still holds up just as well on rewatch too. Very little was done digitally so it all looks beautiful.
That was alot of fun thank you. And very respectful of all the skill involved. The precision of everyone's movements is very amazing to behold.
My favourite film of all time. The Last Samurai with Tom Cruise and a fantastic Japanese cast❤
Very interesting remarks. Always a pleasure to hear from Seki-sama. His comments are always as precise as his blade!
Fun fact about Hiroyuki Sanada: at 11 years of he was trained by legendary martial artist/actor Sonny Chiba
Above everything, I appreciate the honesty of the analysis. It displays a seriousness about the craft and a keen delineation of what it is and isn't.
Great video review and praising a great actor.
This video is very insightful, and educational. I love the breakdown of the different fight scenes.
Really appreciate the overall approach of your channel. Thank you for sharing. Respect.
I'm always amazed a man of such distinction and skill would be willing to do stuff like this.
Very nice video! Always very great content!
Seki sensei is the coolest. He's always so chilled back. I love it.
I just found out about this channel and I'm really enjoying every video. Can we please get a video that's not about technique but that instead talks about the philosophy and ethics of Kobudo Asayama Ichiden Ryu? And maybe talk/explain the myths behind Bushidō. Thank you for the great videos!
I absolutely love the last samurai I still watch it from time to time and I’d love to be in Japan one day learning how to use the ancient art of the sword
So good of the honorable master to lend his knowledge! Thanks to both Seki Sensei and Shogo for this respectful and informative review.
I have always loved this film and Sanada San was brilliant in this! Please consider reviewing Shadow!
Question: For the sparing scene could it have been the character Hiroyuki was playing meant to show the skills of a master swordsman’s vs that of a novice. He mentioned the wild swings on the part of Tom Cruise, but I noticed Hiroyuki was making the short quick movements he spoke of. Maybe that scene was meant to show how a swordsman’s would have to adapt to an inexperienced novice, which would explain his ducking.
perhaps also the swordmaster held resentment in his heart towards cruise's character, and sought not only to teach and show off his swordplay, but also to beat the stuffing out of him as well.
The big swings are standard for a US Cavalry Saber in the Civil War. They were not as sharp as a katana and need the momentum. They also had to withstand hitting a heavy solid infantry rifle and so were heavier.
I appreciate the commentary and the expertise from where it came.
I'm learning a lot with this videos! thanks for sharing, much respect from Mexico!
登録者数10万人達成おめでとうございます！
This was a true treat to watch and very educational, thank you very much!
Never kick above the waist! Train kicking above your head but in combat you never kick above the waist unless the opponent opened up badly.
As someone who formerly studied aikido, I recognized many of the commentary provided by sensei. Thank you.
Sensei Seki's advice to start with small movements when closing to the bind is something I will try out in HEMA. This is something I want to really test.
Thank you very much gentlemen. Cheers from the Philippines 🇵🇭 :-) Im glad Sensei dosent tire of these films
mr. Sanada is exceptional, trully a great actor and embassador of the spirit of old Japan. Much love from Hellas
really enjoy the attitude you both show for sharing your training and understanding
one of the more interesting parts of tom's character is that he uses a cavalry saber, so when he wields a katana he holds it like a one-handed curved sword instead of a two handed one
The look of sanada san ,his eyes , the way he looked ,made the role of a samurai truly amazing.
これらの賢明な観察に感謝します!
Just came across your channel and this was really quite interesting. Seki Sensei describes what is good and what is not, and does so in a respectful way!
I would love to see a reaction to "13 Assassins". It is one of my absolute favorite Samurai films of all time!
And Sanada is also there ;)
Seki Sensei is absolutely a man worthy of admiration. Just from the short time we spend with Seki sensei I can tell he would be an incredible mentor.
Simply beautiful
I'm so glad to have found this channel! A true master of his craft
this reminds me of the book of five rings where Musashi-san says " you must try and cut your opponent, not strike his blade"
Great stuff! I slomoed some of the movements, haha! And also skipped a bunch to replay.
I wonder if Sanada Hiroyuki was a descendant of Sanada Yukimura and Sanada clan in general.
If he was, it would be a peak entertainment if one day he plays Tokugawa Ieyasu, Sanada clan’s greatest enemy.
Mr. Sanada will be starring in Shogun and playing a character who is loosely based on Tokugawa Ieyasu (from what I have read). 😊
I love this critique. It is so enjoyable to watch. It is very informative .
It was the Ujio character that made me a fan of Sanada. Without any backstory or confirmation needed you can tell hes one of if not THE best swordsmen in the entire group to the point he is leading training sessions
I learn so much watching this channel. You just earned a subscriber.
I would love to see your opinion on my favourite samurai film 'Twilight Samurai'. I didn't even realise until now this is the same actor, very talented.
This channel and Weaponism, y’all bring it all home. Glad I found you!
Hiroyuki Sinada is such an underrated actor and he practices iado And other martial arts forms
I think you mean under utilized, nobody is underrating him. Definitely one of my favorite actors!
I liked this. After pointing something out, there was a demonstration and that visual was better than just an explanation alone.
This is great. But a couple of things worth pointing out.
In the sword training scene I think the reason Cruise swings like a baseball is the fact his character is American and its meant to be a "bad habit" . Also I thought that scene was meant to be only sword training so they were avoiding non-sword techniques but further than that, the two had a bit of a rivalry so there was a kind of ego battle happening.
In the 4 v 1 scene the attackers are not samurai so their sword play would be poorer than you would expect, hence the bad technique for attacking a grounded opponent
That is a very interesting concept, the idea that it is a taboo if you can make a move that will end and win you the fight and you don't, that's viewed as a lack of courage. It gives a new perspective to how much precision and decisiveness are important for a samurai.
Thank you for this insight
6:27 I agree, it's like what Miyamoto Musashi said that you cannot rely on training the sword alone, you need to also train the other aspects of martial arts (hand to hand)
Also knowing how other weapons handle as well as having an idea of what other budo styles approaches, mind sets and philosophies to combat are was very invaluable, especially in the the heyday of Edo period dueling.
" know thy enemy, know thy self" - Sun Tzu
@@michael3088 yes that's also something Musashi mentioned, that you shouldn't favor one weapon over another and you should use the best tool for the job
years ago I was taking Aikido lessons and the first time I got bokken training it was easter holidays and it was just the sensei the most senior student and myself.
I got a few bruised knuckles but the tuition was fantastic and got pretty good by the end. Sadly life got in the way and I wasn't able to continue the training, still a great regret.
Awesome channel +1 new subscriber.
The actual guy that was the last samurai was not American but French. His name was Jules Brunet. He was an artillery expert in the French army and had received the Légion d'Honneur - France's highest military award for valor during the French Intervention of Mexico between 1862 and 1864.
There was a number of foreign experts invited to Japan, as well as different sorts of fact-finding missions sent from Japan and into the wider world. A lot of them technical experts, translators etc.
During their last stand, the rebels had lost a lot of their artillery train while retreating and evading government forces to reach their home provines.
The actual last samurai is Katsumoto. Algren (the outsider) is not supposed to be the last samurai.
First video I've ever seen that mentions that sword fights in movies are a unique marital art on their own and distinctive from real life.
Thanks for the respect and education!
This is so great! Btw, considering the sakabato video, it would be so great to see a Kenshin reaction, I'd gather the movies, rather than the anime? I would really love it if Seki-sensei could comment on the scenes where Kenshin's master is teaching him the ultimate technique before the final fights with Shishio Makoto & Co.
Yes, another enjoyer of the live action!
oh yes yes yes yesss
the master shows great respect and humble....and his moves are like water....clear...
I’m no master by no means but I’ve trained/tried many systems and teach a mix of 10 from jkd to Bjj to even Bujinkan budo taijutsu and from what it looks like to me is that he was learning their kenjutsu but being a westerner using their saber and such type of fighting against the Native American, he was simply being natural as a mix of the two. Would some of those end a little badly for him depending, yes like he said, he should have thrusted and not cut downwards. My favorite weapon in “ninjutsu”/kenjutsu was the sword and shuriken especially when used together.
What a pleasure to get insights from a master of such experience.
i feel like this video definitely could have been at least double the length. more isn't always better, but in something like this, i'd say that it is
Appriciate greatly for sharing this.
Very nice ❤
Great Post. I enjoyed watching. Thank you for sharing.
I always thought the uke crossing his legs was to protect the crotch/femoral artery using the shin armor since many of the attacks are aimed at weak spots of armor
could be that as well