Sometimes I feel bad to see this judge..... although being a legal fraternity.... launguage is only a mode of expression and nothing else....if someone submits in Hindi it doesn't mean he is uneducated
@@v.satyanarayanaraju1777 how would u feel if u cannot fight your case in Tamil in Tamil Nadu high court? It's the same here! A judge when posted in different state is bound to deliver justice in the language of the state otherwise a translator should be provided by the hon' court. Judge when posted in Bihar not speaking in Hindi atleast should have deferred the case to a certain date when the translator is available. As a Indian i feel language should not be a barrier but an opportunity for different states to interact
Here in this video, this lawyer seems completely right on his stand and the way he put his point is splendid. This kind of behavior was not expected from the judge.
न्याय की क्या ही उम्मीद की जाय जब जज साहब को भाषा में रुचि है न्याय में नहीं हिंदी हमारी राष्ट्र भाषा है यह कह कर के किसी याचिका को खारिज कर देना की उनको हिंदी नही समझ आती बिलकुल ही न्यायसंगत नहीं है अधिवक्ता को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम की उन्होंने अपने बातो को इतने मजबूत तरीके से रखा
Hindi shouldn't be imposed. Hindi isn't our National Language. And no, it isn't permitted in the High Court, it is only in the lower courts. You may love your language, and I can love mine too. Perhaps stop your imposition and try to accommodate. If you have an issue with language used in court, feel free to file a writ.
@@hashpiper87 1965 as mentioned above, the use of Hindi was authorized in the High Courts of Uttar Pradesh (1969), Madhya Pradesh (1971) and Bihar (1972) in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
@@shrawankumar-yp4xs sabse jyada to hindi tum bhikhari or mansik gulam hi bolte ho ,phir bhi tum ye keh rhe ho ki desh aazad ha....Tymhara dimag kaam nhi karta ..isi liye unjustified inequality ko promote karte ho
सुप्रीम कॉर्ट को सबसे पहले चाईए कि इस जज को तुरंत बर्खास्त करे । जब वकील हिंदी में वकालत की पढ़ाई कर सकते है तो वकालत भी तो हिंदी में करेंगे । बिहार में हिंदी में ही चलेगी । लोग हिन्दुस्तानी , मुक़दमा भारत का , जगह बिहार का और बहस इंग्लिश में । इस जज को 21 जूते की सलामी देनी चाहिए , वो भी भगवान् के फजल से ।
@@SrikarMaddula 1965 as mentioned above, the use of Hindi was authorized in the High Courts of Uttar Pradesh (1969), Madhya Pradesh (1971) and Bihar (1972) in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
Kayeka rule ,Angrej bana kar gaye the . hindustan me rah kar hindi me ache se bahas kar sakte h.. I request to the bar council kick them out this judge from judiciary.he is incompetent
@@paribisht9085 What are you talking about? Patna High Court has allowed to file petitions in Hindi on April 30, 2019. Also refer to Article 348 (1). Knowledge tu kuch hai nahi, bas comment karne chale aate hai.
यही कारण है कि आज भी आम लोग प्रशासन और न्यायालय में जाना नहीं चाहते । यदि जाते भी है तो उन्हें खड़ी परेशानियों का सामना करना पड़ता है। हिंदी को राष्ट्रभाषा बनाए जाने पर ही आम लोगों की न्यायलय तक पहुंच बढ़ेगी। जय हिंद जय हिंदी जय भारत
Why this judge is posted in patna high court if he's unable to understand Hindi... Bihar is hindi speaking state and judge expect arguments in English... Such judges should not be in such hindi speaking state.
Haan they shouldn’t be posted in south India if they don’t know the language…Sometimes the emotions cannot be conveyed properly in a language the person is not fluent in properly.
If a civil servant whether in North or South doesn't understand the local language, they should not be posted there. Don't make it a issue. Judge is wrong in personal opinion and should submit resignation for the good of people.
एक जज के तौर पर आपको हिंदी जरूर जाननी चाहिए, अगर आप नहीं जानते तो भी ठीक है लेकिन आप कितने अहंकारी हैं कि कोर्ट से अनुवादकों को नहीं लेते। आप वकील की बात भी नहीं सुन रहे हैं, अगर वह अंग्रेजी अनुवाद प्राप्त कर सकता है, तो वह पहले स्थान पर अंग्रेजी में कॉपी जमा कर देता।
@@anshulsinghlodhi9901 संविधान अनुच्छेद 343 से 351 तक मात्र हिन्दी भाषा को प्रोत्साहित पर जोर है। भारत में 90% जनता हिन्दी भाषा बोलती आर समझती है। उक्त तथ्यों से स्पष्ट है भारतीय भाषा हिंदी से राष्ट्र को जोड़ना उचित है। चीन, जापान आदि अपनी राष्ट्र की भाषा से आगे बढे है।
This is Justice Bajanthri from Karnataka.. I think he is being unfair and is projecting his bias against Hindi. Even in a Hindi speaking Bihar state HC.
अंग्रजो की औलदे बैठी है न्यायपालिका सिस्टम में ...लग ही नही रहा कि ये भारत की अदालतें है ,इतना अन्ग्रेजी तो इंग्लैंड कोर्ट में भी नही बोलते होगें। इसी लिए भारतीय सविधान को वकीलों का स्वर्ग बोला गया है,और यहां तो वकील साहब को भी समझ में नही आ रहा है,आम जनता को क्या समझ में आयेगा।
@@Doyourbestdear लिपि भाषा की पहचान है, अगर हिंदी भाषा से लगाव है तो लिखावट भी हिंदी में होनी चाहिए, जज के सामने हिंदी बोलने की बात है तो सारे कागज़ अंग्रेजी में लिख के दोगे ?? जब लिखावट हिंदी नही रखोगे तो हिंदी को महत्व और प्रधानता कैसे दोगे ??
Judge was right. This country is multilingist , if some advocate files case in Tamil language to a Bengali origin Judge in Tamilnadu, judge has no ability to understand that. Judiciary should have accept English as common language. A advocate have to qualify LLB, and medium to Study LLB degree is in English all over India.
@@Agarwal_Manish why Hindi? Hindi is not National language of India. English because every States are able to understand this language unlike hindi. Our higher education of Professional degrees like LLB-LLM, BTech-Mtech, MSc, PhD, MBBS-DM or MS , MCom etc are studied in English.
The advocate is foolishly arguing before the judge. He needs to understand that the high court judges are appointed by the President and the high court & union judiciary have been given a common language for official purpose that is English. If a north indian judge goes to kerala, TN, Karnataka, Andhra, etc. And if the advocate presents his argument in native language before the north indian judge, how will he be able to understand what he is saying. For fast official working purposes English has been issued as a common language for judiciary and that's the only language court has to work on that linguistic line. The judge is completely right here in accordance with the constitution.
@@Karanbansal007 Yes what you are saying was read out from para 139 of the rule book, but it nowhere says that the lawyer must provide the translated copy. A lawyer can but he does not have to. It is the duty of translation department to provide translation and a judge can anytime ask for the translation from them. It can be found in para 79 of the rule book derived from a division bench judgment made in light of judgment on which para 139 is codified. If a lawyer can translate it then why will he submit his petition in Hindi in the first place? In patna high court lawyers have always submitted in Hindi and various non Hindi speaking judges have gotten the translation from translation department. He was transferred to Patna High Court in 2021 iirc, so he obviously doesn’t know the rules and tradition of Patna high court and that is fine, it can happen to anyone. But what astounds me is his level of arrogance and rudeness towards others.
Seeing the common people of my country being insulted by this anglophone judiciary pushes me towards the idea that this institution must be teared down. Enough is enough. These instances pushes me to hold such strong views , an application must be sent to Supreme Court to intervene and help strengthen the lawyers who don't know English. IT MUST BE THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS TO BE ABLE TO PRESENT VIEWS IN NON ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
Fck such constitution ,this don't serve people of India ,It is like British constitution imposed on us...mthrfckr Nehru ,congress ,BJPee and all other indian parties never changed it
Abey Gadhe! You should have studied the whole provision, you idiot. 1. Article 348(1) of the Constitution of India provides that all proceedings in the Supreme Court and in every High Court shall be in English language *until Parliament by law otherwise provides.* 2. A full bench consisting of *Chief Justice Amreshwar Pratap Sahi, Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad* held that petitions can be filed in Hindi language at the High Court along with their English translations. (30 April, 2019) Half baked intellectual.
These judges do everything except Justice, if something is pending in this country that is Cases , they don't even listen and gives next date , i have experience in one case, they don't even listen for 15, 20second, and skip to next.
This is quite interesting! Looking at the comments, I feel there is a need to put things in the right perspective. The Ld. Advocate has submitted the following: 1. A full bench of the Patna HC has held that Hindi/English as a language is elective and not exclusive for proceedings before Patna HC. However, where a party has produced the records in Hindi- A translated English version of the same needs to be supplied. (As per para 139). 2. A division bench, being aware of the full bench judgment has directed the translation department (in-house department in the HC) to supply the translated copies, instead of ordering the party/advocate itself to produce it. 3. The Ld. Advocate here has sought to rely upon the Division Bench order and seeks indulgence of the Hon'ble Court to pass a similar order and direct the translation department to supply the translated version of documents. 4. The Ld. Counsel has further contended that since the party as well as the counsel themselves are not adept in English Language, they cannot be directed to mandatorily provide the translated version. Especially given the fact that a translation department exists for this very purpose and an Order passed by the Division Bench of the Hon'ble Patna HC has also considered directing the translation department fit for the job, rather than the party/advocate. On the other hand, the Hon'ble Court had on an earlier occasion directed the Ld. Counsel to supply translated copies (which, for that matter, is a routine order). On finding that the earlier order has not been complied with, the Hon'ble Court deemed it fit to dismiss the matter. Personal opinion- In this case- I believe there has been a communication gap as neither the Ld. Counsel was able to entirely convey what was intended to be conveyed, nor was the Hon'ble Court able to fully appreciate the submissions. Clearly, owing to the level of discomfort with the concerned languages. P.S.- Firstly, these videos are for the purpose of learning and getting an insight as to how our Courts function. Such submissions and orders cannot and should not be judged as right or wrong. While the Counsel is 100% entitled to make his submissions (without any fear or judgment by anyone), the Hon'ble Court is empowered to proceed as it deems fit in light of the submissions made and records presented.
*मुख्य न्यायाधीश जी ने प्रधान मंत्री जी को पत्र लिखा है कि सर्वोच्च न्यायलय में न्यायाधीशों की संख्या और बढ़ाई जाए!* *माननीय न्यायामूर्ति जी, आपको हमारे सुझाव जनता और आम नागरिकों की तरफ से हैँ :* *1. आप सारे न्यायाधीश प्रातः दस बजे आते हो, 2 से 3 बजे के बीच भोजन और फिर 4 बजे के बाद घर वापसी करते हैँ! ऐसा कब तक चलेगा??* *2. प्रातः 8 बजे आइये और रात 8 बजे तक काम कीजिये, जैसे डाक्टर, इन्जीनियर, पुलिस कर्मी, ब्यूरोक्रेट्स तथा कारपोरेट जगत के व्यस्वासई नागरिक करते हैं!* *3. शनिवार और रविवार को भी काम करिये!* *4. आप 1947 से 1 जून से 30 जून तक की गर्मी की छुट्टियाँ व्यतीत करते हैँ! पूरा न्यायलय सेंट्रलाइज्ड AC है, तो जून में गर्मी की छुट्टियां क्यों??* *5. प्रत्येक न्यायमूर्ति वर्ष में मात्र 15-20 दिन की छुट्टी लें!* *6. जानबूझकर जल्लिकुट्टु, दहीहंडी में अपना समय क्यों नष्ट करते हैँ आप??* *7. कुछ गिनती के पेशेवरों द्वारा दायर सैकड़ों फालतू की PIL सुनकर अपना समय क्यों नष्ट करते हो आप??* *8. EPFO vs pensioners बाल बराबर केस में भी 3 न्यायाधीशों की पीठ, 5 न्यायमुर्तियों की पीठ बेंच क्यों बनाते हैँ आप? एकल न्यायाधीश को भी काम करने दें! Why Ex CJI Decision Review??* *9. देश के गद्दारों के लिए रिव्यु, और फिर रिव्यु, और फिर आधी रात में भी न्यायलय क्यों खोल देते हो???* *10. जनता के करों से ही करोड़ों का वेतन और सुविधायें लेते हो, लेकिन जनता के प्रति जवाबदारी या उत्तरदाई शून्य है!* *11. AC बंगलो में रहते हो, शानदार गाड़ी से चलते हो, घर पर खाना भी नौकर पकाता है, न्यायादीश की मेज पर पानी भी कर्मचारी पिलाता है, तो जी तोड़ मेहनत क्यों नहीं करते हो ??* *12. आप सबको केंद्रीय मंत्री मण्डल के मंत्री की सुविधायें मिलती हैँ!* *निवृती आयु बढ़ाने की कोई आवश्यकता नहीं है! जो सर्वोच्च न्यायलय, एक वर्ष में सिर्फ 168 दिन काम करता हो, उसके कार्यदिवस बढ़ा कर न्यूनतम 300 दिन कर देना चाहिये!* *जब प्रधान मंत्री 365 दिन काम कर सकते हैं, तो न्यायमुर्तियों को 300 दिन काम करने मे कोई कठिनाई नहीं होनी चाहिये!* *गरीब देशभक्त जनता अब और सहन नहीं कर सकती! न्यायतंत्र सड़ गल चुका है! इसमें सुधार लाने की अविलम्ब व महती आवश्यकता है!* *कम से कम पांच समूहों मैं अवश्य भेजें!* *कुछ लोग नहीं भेजेंगे!* *लेकिन मुझे भरोसा है आप अवश्य भेजेंगे!* 🙏🇮🇳💪🏼😃🙂👖
गुलाम मानसिकता हम भारतीयों की विशेषता है. हमारे देश में गौरी चमड़ी और गौरे की भाषा को अपने से श्रेष्ठ समझा जाता है. अँग्रेजी नहीं आती ये शर्म की बात नहीं है बल्कि आजादी के 75 वर्ष बाद भी न्यायालय हिन्दी न सीख पाया ये शर्म की बात है!
People are telling not knowing English doesn't mean he is uneducated. But, people should also understand that not understanding Hindi doesn't mean he is arrogant.
In india our national language is Hindi first prefer,,,,second is English...we are not foreigner,,,we are not England we are indian we should proud Hindi National language then English....
English is the official language of the high courts as per constitution. Blaming judges for lack of knowledge of English by the concerned advocate is incorrect.
अब बोलो कहो कि हम आजाद है सोचो हम लोग अपने ही हाईकोर्ट और सुप्रीम कोर्ट में हिंदी में कोई दलील नहीं दे सकते अपनी मातृभाषा में कोई दलील नहीं दे सकते और हम अपने आप को आजाद कहते हैं गजब की हमारी सोच है
Interpreter shall be provided in court. What will happen if a person who cannot afford advocate shall fight the matter in PIP and doesnt knows English ?
CM Stalin also wants Tamil language priority in Highcourt and supreme court bench in south, but the dilemma is, the hegemony of English language is very strong and regional language is in endangered.
If Hindi is allowed in that court, If the judge cannot understand Hindi, then he is unfit to be judge, he should resign and go to home. Common logon ka issue in ko mazak ban gaya hai
मेरे बच्चो को मैं अंग्रेजी ही सिखाऊंगा चाहे उसे भारत की भाषा कोई ज्ञान न हो पर अंग्रेजी आनी चाहिए। नही मेरी तरह उसे भी मूर्ख कहा जायेगा। भारत में इज्जत से रहने के लिए अंग्रेजी जरूरी है। - हजार सालों से गुलाम भारतीय
The judge could simply request for the transfer of this particular case to another seat who could understand the Hindi language instead of cancelling the petition directly. If honourable Justices aren’t able to understand the language of almost 80 crore of his fellow countrymen, then he should separate himself from this case or at least look for the possibilities. This thing seems little ironic that after 75 years of independence, till this date, Indians don’t have a common consensus on one single indigenous language of communication throughout the country. And this country dreams about topping the world. Will never happen.
I agree that the judge should have been more nicer. But at the same time I would like to remind you and help you out of the Hindi speaking myth, less than 30 % people of India have Hindi as mother tongue and less than 47% are native speakers. We need to stop saying assi crore ki aabadi hindi bolti hai… sab ko bad Lagta hai but Aisa nahi hai.
Mr. Chappati, before speaking about South Indians, educate yourself that English is the official language of India. Just because you know Hindi, it doesn't mean entire India should speak Hindi.
That judge deserves strict action n Govt should amend the constitution to discontinue English as language of High Court. If someone dont understand / read/write hindu; got no right to remain on chair...
They are 26 official languages in India.Hindi is one of them how come judge from Maharashtra or Andhra read and write Hindi judgement it's not about hearing you need to write judgement usual orders will consist of hundreds of pages some times it cross 1000 pages 🙏
If the parliament is also said to continue its preceedings in English I don't think all the politicians could speak and explain in English then why it is happening only in court especially in india where major population is Hindi speaking and not English speaking. And I have written in English so that all can understand who don't know Hindi and getting attracted towards the western culture. अगर संसद को भी अंग्रेजी में अपनी कार्यवाही जारी रखने के लिए कहा जाता है, तो मुझे नहीं लगता कि सभी राजनेता अंग्रेजी में बोल सकते हैं और समझा सकते हैं, तो यह केवल अदालत में क्यों हो रहा है, खासकर भारत में जहां बड़ी आबादी हिंदी भाषी है और अंग्रेजी नहीं बोल रही है। और मैंने अंग्रेजी में लिखा है ताकि सभी समझ सकें जो हिंदी नहीं जानता और पश्चिमी संस्कृति की ओर आकर्षित हो रहा है।
Glad you also wrote in hind, the advocate should have also provided the translations which he failed. English is a middle ground, otherwise every regional language will fight.
Hindi is not national language. It's the lawyers job to file the translated copy to the bench. He's arrogant to tell the judge to get the judge to get the translation and when the Advocate is not able to satisfy the judge he brings up Hindi out of context. He's lucky he is suffering contempt proceedings. Also people don't mistake in to thinking that the judge is objecting to filing in Hindi but problem is with not filing translation. Hindi being local language in Bihar Filing in Hindi there is correct but when judges from other States come it's for the Advocate to file English translation for the convenience of the bench. I will try to get the judgements being referred to in this video. That Advocate's tone while telling the judge to obtain a translation which itself is appalling and the tone in general is certainly not right.
People should understand that judges of high court are transferred to different states. What would a judge from MP, who's a sitting judge in the kerala high court do? Speak in english or listen to the hearing in Malayalam.
सच में यही रोना है देश में की हिन्दी को राष्ट्रभाषा तो बना लिया पर वो सम्मान मिला नहीं जो मिलना चाहिए राष्ट्रभाषा को। आज अंग्रेजी बोलने वालों को सम्मान मिलता है और हिन्दी बोलने वालों को अनपढ़ समझा जाता है।
What stupidity ! What an arrogant judge. Not fit to be a judge in a Hindi speaking state. The learned counsel was right in his argument but the Judge was trying to muzzle his voice. Reminds one of the colonial era. Its disgusting in indepedent Bharat.
this judge is saying that he does not understand Hindi. court/ or he is responsible to get the English version, ironically he is not fluent in English too. his pronunciation is horrible. Did he came from England
People are defending lawyer for sympathy! But as per law the proceeding should be in English language only! Because southern parts of India has different languages so during 1965 they were fighting to get permit to proceed in regional language, But this was denied by the chief justice council. The reason was many judges are from different places it will be difficult for them to proceeding in Regional language, and there will be high probability of misleading or wrong decision by the judges. The judge could have used translator but he was arrogant because of his position
government ko high court supreme court mein Hindi English donon kar dena chahie jisko Hindi mein bolna hai Hindi mein bole English mein bolna hai to English mein bole judge Sahab ko language sahi dikkat hai kya nyaay karenge
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
One must have in mind.
the pinnacle
"justice must be delivered"
irrespective of language.
वकील बहुत धाकड़ है ये तो.....😯😯😯😯😯.....👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👍
Sometimes I feel bad to see this judge..... although being a legal fraternity.... launguage is only a mode of expression and nothing else....if someone submits in Hindi it doesn't mean he is uneducated
A new software system is required for judiciary.
That will help delivering it fast.
We are working on it.
He is from south indian,they can't understand the hindi written notes
@@v.satyanarayanaraju1777 how would u feel if u cannot fight your case in Tamil in Tamil Nadu high court? It's the same here! A judge when posted in different state is bound to deliver justice in the language of the state otherwise a translator should be provided by the hon' court. Judge when posted in Bihar not speaking in Hindi atleast should have deferred the case to a certain date when the translator is available. As a Indian i feel language should not be a barrier but an opportunity for different states to interact
Same dude. If some one is asking you to speak in english it doesn't mean they are rude. May be they don't know hindi
This same south Indian people ask us to speak in their local languages
Here in this video, this lawyer seems completely right on his stand and the way he put his point is splendid. This kind of behavior was not expected from the judge.
How can judge understand, if he speaks in Hindi? Are u trying impose Hindi on him?
@@nandanhegde8784
Or is he trying to impose English on him
@@nandanhegde8784 This is Patna not England
Only English is allowed in HC and SC
@@shanigods2495 english is the language of highcourt ..its the law.. and if judge dont follow law who will
न्याय की क्या ही उम्मीद की जाय जब जज साहब को भाषा में रुचि है न्याय में नहीं हिंदी हमारी राष्ट्र भाषा है यह कह कर के किसी याचिका को खारिज कर देना की उनको हिंदी नही समझ आती बिलकुल ही न्यायसंगत नहीं है अधिवक्ता को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम की उन्होंने अपने बातो को इतने मजबूत तरीके से रखा
Hindi shouldn't be imposed. Hindi isn't our National Language. And no, it isn't permitted in the High Court, it is only in the lower courts. You may love your language, and I can love mine too. Perhaps stop your imposition and try to accommodate. If you have an issue with language used in court, feel free to file a writ.
@@hashpiper87
Hindi is the national language.
Hindi is not the national language. Get your facts right :)
Hindi is not our national language, English is the only official language of high courts.
@@hashpiper87 1965 as mentioned above, the use of Hindi was authorized in the High Courts of Uttar Pradesh (1969), Madhya Pradesh (1971) and Bihar (1972) in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
Salute to this lawyer for fighting
Arrogance with Dignity and wit
मैं कई बार सोचता हूं, क्या वाकई देश से अंग्रेज़ शासन खत्म हो चुका है....!!!????🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Nahi abhi khatm nahi hua hai😭😭😭
Not from south i guess
Ho chuka hai....babua.....ye 2022 hai... तनिक निंदवा से उठ जाओ
@@shrawankumar-yp4xs sabse jyada to hindi tum bhikhari or mansik gulam hi bolte ho ,phir bhi tum ye keh rhe ho ki desh aazad ha....Tymhara dimag kaam nhi karta ..isi liye unjustified inequality ko promote karte ho
सुप्रीम कॉर्ट को सबसे पहले चाईए कि इस जज को तुरंत बर्खास्त करे । जब वकील हिंदी में वकालत की पढ़ाई कर सकते है तो वकालत भी तो हिंदी में करेंगे । बिहार में हिंदी में ही चलेगी । लोग हिन्दुस्तानी , मुक़दमा भारत का , जगह बिहार का और बहस इंग्लिश में । इस जज को 21 जूते की सलामी देनी चाहिए , वो भी भगवान् के फजल से ।
High courts official language is English and English alone. That is quite literally the law.
@@SrikarMaddula 1965 as mentioned above, the use of Hindi was authorized in the High Courts of Uttar Pradesh (1969), Madhya Pradesh (1971) and Bihar (1972) in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
@@SrikarMaddula just go and read the rules of Patna High court. South Indian hypocrite
Take a strong action on this judge.
doj.gov.in/use-of-hindi-and-regional-languages/
@@deveshverma3515 its not rule but its language of SC and HC
Kayeka rule ,Angrej bana kar gaye the . hindustan me rah kar hindi me ache se bahas kar sakte h.. I request to the bar council kick them out this judge from judiciary.he is incompetent
@@vinayparihar9327 court me Hindi ya English use kr skte hai mgr ye judge chutiya hai india me rah kr Hindi nhi smjh paa rha hai..
@@paribisht9085
What are you talking about?
Patna High Court has allowed to file petitions in Hindi on April 30, 2019. Also refer to Article 348 (1).
Knowledge tu kuch hai nahi, bas comment karne chale aate hai.
जो जज हिंदी नहीं जनता हो उसे highcourt में जज नहीं बनाया जाना चाहिए..
What a great argument with decency so much effort👍👍👍
Brilliant rebuttal to the judge 💯💯
When lawyer said English nhi ata then judge is saying good...what a mindset...great...
माननीय वकील साहब को नमन
अंग्रेज चले गए पर इस देश में आज भी काले अंग्रेजों का लगता है शासन है.
Jidge sahab is saying GOOD when advocate saying I don't know English 😕
Bahut achha vakil sahb
यही कारण है कि आज भी आम लोग प्रशासन और न्यायालय में जाना नहीं चाहते । यदि जाते भी है तो उन्हें खड़ी परेशानियों का सामना करना पड़ता है। हिंदी को राष्ट्रभाषा बनाए जाने पर ही आम लोगों की न्यायलय तक पहुंच बढ़ेगी।
जय हिंद
जय हिंदी
जय भारत
Jai Bharath, Hindi isn't the language of India and High courts official language is English
@@SrikarMaddula and this is the problem
हिंदी भाषा का तो न्याय देवताने ईतना अपमान किया 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Why this judge is posted in patna high court if he's unable to understand Hindi... Bihar is hindi speaking state and judge expect arguments in English... Such judges should not be in such hindi speaking state.
By that logic no north Indiana Judge, officer or person should be posted anywhere in South India as well.
Haan they shouldn’t be posted in south India if they don’t know the language…Sometimes the emotions cannot be conveyed properly in a language the person is not fluent in properly.
If a civil servant whether in North or South doesn't understand the local language, they should not be posted there. Don't make it a issue. Judge is wrong in personal opinion and should submit resignation for the good of people.
@@doctorancient9233emotions have no place in court
एक जज के तौर पर आपको हिंदी जरूर जाननी चाहिए, अगर आप नहीं जानते तो भी ठीक है लेकिन आप कितने अहंकारी हैं कि कोर्ट से अनुवादकों को नहीं लेते। आप वकील की बात भी नहीं सुन रहे हैं, अगर वह अंग्रेजी अनुवाद प्राप्त कर सकता है, तो वह पहले स्थान पर अंग्रेजी में कॉपी जमा कर देता।
Judges should understand that they are not lords but are people who are responsible for listening people and doing justice.
Hindi is also one of the native language. It should not be used as an official language. English should be the mandatory language.
अंग्रेजो की गुलामी मानसिकता से ऊपर उठ कर भारतीय भाषा का सम्मान हो।
भारत में २५ से अधिक भाषाएँ है , किसे बनाओगे राष्ट्रीय ?
क्या अन्य राज्यों की सरकार स्पर्धा नहीं करेगी ?
हिंदी मुख्य भाषा हो सकती है , मातृभाषा नहीं ।
@@anshulsinghlodhi9901 संविधान अनुच्छेद 343 से 351 तक मात्र हिन्दी भाषा को प्रोत्साहित पर जोर है।
भारत में 90% जनता हिन्दी भाषा बोलती आर समझती है।
उक्त तथ्यों से स्पष्ट है भारतीय भाषा हिंदी से राष्ट्र को जोड़ना उचित है।
चीन, जापान आदि अपनी राष्ट्र की भाषा से आगे बढे है।
@@anshulsinghlodhi9901 अंग्रेजो के गुलामी मानसिकता से ऊपर उठने की जरूरत।।
@@brahmanandpandey414290% jantha hindi nahi bolti kaunsi duniya mai ho
This is Justice Bajanthri from Karnataka.. I think he is being unfair and is projecting his bias against Hindi. Even in a Hindi speaking Bihar state HC.
Remove justice from his name lol
@@pervert_kun do u think u people can remove him by commenting in social media
अंग्रजो की औलदे बैठी है न्यायपालिका सिस्टम में ...लग ही नही रहा कि ये भारत की अदालतें है ,इतना अन्ग्रेजी तो इंग्लैंड कोर्ट में भी नही बोलते होगें।
इसी लिए भारतीय सविधान को वकीलों का स्वर्ग बोला गया है,और यहां तो वकील साहब को भी समझ में नही आ रहा है,आम जनता को क्या समझ में आयेगा।
मजे के बात तो ये है की जितने लोग कॉमेंट्स में हिंदी हिंदी चिल्लाए है ना वो सारे के सारे लिख तो इंग्लिश में ही रहे है 🤣🤣🤣
Baat smjhne ki hai likhne ki nahi.
भाई, भाषा और लिपि में अंतर होता है
@@Doyourbestdear लिपि भाषा की पहचान है, अगर हिंदी भाषा से लगाव है तो लिखावट भी हिंदी में होनी चाहिए, जज के सामने हिंदी बोलने की बात है तो सारे कागज़ अंग्रेजी में लिख के दोगे ?? जब लिखावट हिंदी नही रखोगे तो हिंदी को महत्व और प्रधानता कैसे दोगे ??
भाग्य देश का ,ऐसे गैर जिम्मेदार जज नियुक्त होते हैं।
Judge was right. This country is multilingist , if some advocate files case in Tamil language to a Bengali origin Judge in Tamilnadu, judge has no ability to understand that. Judiciary should have accept English as common language. A advocate have to qualify LLB, and medium to Study LLB degree is in English all over India.
अंग्रेजी ही क्यों..?
@@Agarwal_Manish why Hindi? Hindi is not National language of India. English because every States are able to understand this language unlike hindi. Our higher education of Professional degrees like LLB-LLM, BTech-Mtech, MSc, PhD, MBBS-DM or MS , MCom etc are studied in English.
The advocate is foolishly arguing before the judge. He needs to understand that the high court judges are appointed by the President and the high court & union judiciary have been given a common language for official purpose that is English. If a north indian judge goes to kerala, TN, Karnataka, Andhra, etc. And if the advocate presents his argument in native language before the north indian judge, how will he be able to understand what he is saying. For fast official working purposes English has been issued as a common language for judiciary and that's the only language court has to work on that linguistic line. The judge is completely right here in accordance with the constitution.
You are the only one who is fool.
Actually Justice Bajanthri is From Karnataka so he will not able to understand hindi because hindi is not his native language.
Is english anyone's native language
@@saurabh1931 actually in South Indian people's not like hindi. They teach only his mother tongue & english. South Indians normally hate hindi
Then if he doesn’t even want to get translation from translation department then he should resign.
@@qaz010wsx actually there is a full bench decision of this High Court that an advocate must submit translated copy to high court.
@@Karanbansal007 Yes what you are saying was read out from para 139 of the rule book, but it nowhere says that the lawyer must provide the translated copy. A lawyer can but he does not have to. It is the duty of translation department to provide translation and a judge can anytime ask for the translation from them. It can be found in para 79 of the rule book derived from a division bench judgment made in light of judgment on which para 139 is codified.
If a lawyer can translate it then why will he submit his petition in Hindi in the first place? In patna high court lawyers have always submitted in Hindi and various non Hindi speaking judges have gotten the translation from translation department.
He was transferred to Patna High Court in 2021 iirc, so he obviously doesn’t know the rules and tradition of Patna high court and that is fine, it can happen to anyone. But what astounds me is his level of arrogance and rudeness towards others.
Best discussion ever
Seeing the common people of my country being insulted by this anglophone judiciary pushes me towards the idea that this institution must be teared down. Enough is enough.
These instances pushes me to hold such strong views , an application must be sent to Supreme Court to intervene and help strengthen the lawyers who don't know English.
IT MUST BE THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS TO BE ABLE TO PRESENT VIEWS IN NON ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
ठीक उसी प्रकार जैसे आपने अंग्रेजो के फोन में कॉमेंट किया है
Amd what if the judge speaks only English and Kannada?? Judge will speak in Kannada and advocate in Hindi, wah bhai wah
"Article 348(1) of the Constitution of India provides that all proceedings in the Supreme Court and in every High Court shall be in English language"
Fck such constitution ,this don't serve people of India ,It is like British constitution imposed on us...mthrfckr Nehru ,congress ,BJPee and all other indian parties never changed it
Abey Gadhe! You should have studied the whole provision, you idiot.
1. Article 348(1) of the Constitution of India provides that all proceedings in the Supreme Court and in every High Court shall be in English language *until Parliament by law otherwise provides.*
2. A full bench consisting of *Chief Justice Amreshwar Pratap Sahi, Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad* held that petitions can be filed in Hindi language at the High Court along with their English translations. (30 April, 2019)
Half baked intellectual.
Constitution mein article hi galat hai
@@explorer.8636 thats what BIMARU state people think, maybe they can have a BIMARU Constitution only for them
These judges do everything except Justice, if something is pending in this country that is Cases , they don't even listen and gives next date , i have experience in one case, they don't even listen for 15, 20second, and skip to next.
This is quite interesting!
Looking at the comments, I feel there is a need to put things in the right perspective.
The Ld. Advocate has submitted the following:
1. A full bench of the Patna HC has held that Hindi/English as a language is elective and not exclusive for proceedings before Patna HC. However, where a party has produced the records in Hindi- A translated English version of the same needs to be supplied. (As per para 139).
2. A division bench, being aware of the full bench judgment has directed the translation department (in-house department in the HC) to supply the translated copies, instead of ordering the party/advocate itself to produce it.
3. The Ld. Advocate here has sought to rely upon the Division Bench order and seeks indulgence of the Hon'ble Court to pass a similar order and direct the translation department to supply the translated version of documents.
4. The Ld. Counsel has further contended that since the party as well as the counsel themselves are not adept in English Language, they cannot be directed to mandatorily provide the translated version. Especially given the fact that a translation department exists for this very purpose and an Order passed by the Division Bench of the Hon'ble Patna HC has also considered directing the translation department fit for the job, rather than the party/advocate.
On the other hand, the Hon'ble Court had on an earlier occasion directed the Ld. Counsel to supply translated copies (which, for that matter, is a routine order). On finding that the earlier order has not been complied with, the Hon'ble Court deemed it fit to dismiss the matter.
Personal opinion- In this case- I believe there has been a communication gap as neither the Ld. Counsel was able to entirely convey what was intended to be conveyed, nor was the Hon'ble Court able to fully appreciate the submissions. Clearly, owing to the level of discomfort with the concerned languages.
P.S.- Firstly, these videos are for the purpose of learning and getting an insight as to how our Courts function. Such submissions and orders cannot and should not be judged as right or wrong. While the Counsel is 100% entitled to make his submissions (without any fear or judgment by anyone), the Hon'ble Court is empowered to proceed as it deems fit in light of the submissions made and records presented.
*मुख्य न्यायाधीश जी ने प्रधान मंत्री जी को पत्र लिखा है कि सर्वोच्च न्यायलय में न्यायाधीशों की संख्या और बढ़ाई जाए!*
*माननीय न्यायामूर्ति जी, आपको हमारे सुझाव जनता और आम नागरिकों की तरफ से हैँ :*
*1. आप सारे न्यायाधीश प्रातः दस बजे आते हो, 2 से 3 बजे के बीच भोजन और फिर 4 बजे के बाद घर वापसी करते हैँ! ऐसा कब तक चलेगा??*
*2. प्रातः 8 बजे आइये और रात 8 बजे तक काम कीजिये, जैसे डाक्टर, इन्जीनियर, पुलिस कर्मी, ब्यूरोक्रेट्स तथा कारपोरेट जगत के व्यस्वासई नागरिक करते हैं!*
*3. शनिवार और रविवार को भी काम करिये!*
*4. आप 1947 से 1 जून से 30 जून तक की गर्मी की छुट्टियाँ व्यतीत करते हैँ! पूरा न्यायलय सेंट्रलाइज्ड AC है, तो जून में गर्मी की छुट्टियां क्यों??*
*5. प्रत्येक न्यायमूर्ति वर्ष में मात्र 15-20 दिन की छुट्टी लें!*
*6. जानबूझकर जल्लिकुट्टु, दहीहंडी में अपना समय क्यों नष्ट करते हैँ आप??*
*7. कुछ गिनती के पेशेवरों द्वारा दायर सैकड़ों फालतू की PIL सुनकर अपना समय क्यों नष्ट करते हो आप??*
*8. EPFO vs pensioners बाल बराबर केस में भी 3 न्यायाधीशों की पीठ, 5 न्यायमुर्तियों की पीठ बेंच क्यों बनाते हैँ आप? एकल न्यायाधीश को भी काम करने दें! Why Ex CJI Decision Review??*
*9. देश के गद्दारों के लिए रिव्यु, और फिर रिव्यु, और फिर आधी रात में भी न्यायलय क्यों खोल देते हो???*
*10. जनता के करों से ही करोड़ों का वेतन और सुविधायें लेते हो, लेकिन जनता के प्रति जवाबदारी या उत्तरदाई शून्य है!*
*11. AC बंगलो में रहते हो, शानदार गाड़ी से चलते हो, घर पर खाना भी नौकर पकाता है, न्यायादीश की मेज पर पानी भी कर्मचारी पिलाता है, तो जी तोड़ मेहनत क्यों नहीं करते हो ??*
*12. आप सबको केंद्रीय मंत्री मण्डल के मंत्री की सुविधायें मिलती हैँ!*
*निवृती आयु बढ़ाने की कोई आवश्यकता नहीं है! जो सर्वोच्च न्यायलय, एक वर्ष में सिर्फ 168 दिन काम करता हो, उसके कार्यदिवस बढ़ा कर न्यूनतम 300 दिन कर देना चाहिये!*
*जब प्रधान मंत्री 365 दिन काम कर सकते हैं, तो न्यायमुर्तियों को 300 दिन काम करने मे कोई कठिनाई नहीं होनी चाहिये!*
*गरीब देशभक्त जनता अब और सहन नहीं कर सकती! न्यायतंत्र सड़ गल चुका है! इसमें सुधार लाने की अविलम्ब व महती आवश्यकता है!*
*कम से कम पांच समूहों मैं अवश्य भेजें!*
*कुछ लोग नहीं भेजेंगे!*
*लेकिन मुझे भरोसा है आप अवश्य भेजेंगे!*
🙏🇮🇳💪🏼😃🙂👖
गुलाम मानसिकता हम भारतीयों की विशेषता है. हमारे देश में गौरी चमड़ी और गौरे की भाषा को अपने से श्रेष्ठ समझा जाता है.
अँग्रेजी नहीं आती ये शर्म की बात नहीं है बल्कि आजादी के 75 वर्ष बाद भी न्यायालय हिन्दी न सीख पाया ये शर्म की बात है!
न्याय देवता ???
People are telling not knowing English doesn't mean he is uneducated. But, people should also understand that not understanding Hindi doesn't mean he is arrogant.
Hindi is not the concern here brother, but his behaviour is
This judge is very arrogant. Seems like he is not seating here for justice. 😢
Bhut thik kha aapne vakil shab
Evry1 knos both r understanding each other's language but their ego is not letting them to understand the language 😂😂😂😂
kudos to Lawyer
In india our national language is Hindi first prefer,,,,second is English...we are not foreigner,,,we are not England we are indian we should proud Hindi National language then English....
Baht sundar argument bro
English is the official language of the high courts as per constitution. Blaming judges for lack of knowledge of English by the concerned advocate is incorrect.
देश का दुर्भाग्य है ऐसे जज है तो
अब बोलो कहो कि हम आजाद है सोचो हम लोग अपने ही हाईकोर्ट और सुप्रीम कोर्ट में हिंदी में कोई दलील नहीं दे सकते अपनी मातृभाषा में कोई दलील नहीं दे सकते और हम अपने आप को आजाद कहते हैं गजब की हमारी सोच है
Best way to transfer the case to another court
Interpreter shall be provided in court. What will happen if a person who cannot afford advocate shall fight the matter in PIP and doesnt knows English ?
Judge is not wrong here
हिंदी है हम वतन है हिंदोसता हमारा हमारा सारे जहासे अच्छा हिंदोसीता हमारा ???????
What should someone if he doesn’t understand Hindi, why can’t the lawyer give it in English?
ये क्या बात हुई second part मे comment lock कर दिये है ....
वाह न्याय देवता ?????
CM Stalin also wants Tamil language priority in Highcourt and supreme court bench in south, but the dilemma is, the hegemony of English language is very strong and regional language is in endangered.
Judge must not go in pompous mindset.
As ultimately the justice seeker will suffer.
I can understand our judiciary 😆
Sahi kha jata hai
एक बिहारी सौ पर भारी।
😄😄😄😄
National language Hindi but pure hindi nhi ati but jo samanay case ho osko to solve Ku nhi karta
Now we know why so much cases r pending in courts..... intention is a matter of doubt
If Hindi is allowed in that court, If the judge cannot understand Hindi, then he is unfit to be judge, he should resign and go to home. Common logon ka issue in ko mazak ban gaya hai
Superb advocate .. he is full of knowledge ..judge ki ache se li ...sare chamche bnte
How now this lawyer read English language so that judge wanted to know about this lawyer
para eighty four
हुजूर पैरा उन्न्यासी
Kaash koi waqil US accent or British accent mein bolta.. Maza aa jata..😄
मेरे बच्चो को मैं अंग्रेजी ही सिखाऊंगा चाहे उसे भारत की भाषा कोई ज्ञान न हो पर अंग्रेजी आनी चाहिए। नही मेरी तरह उसे भी मूर्ख कहा जायेगा। भारत में इज्जत से रहने के लिए अंग्रेजी जरूरी है।
- हजार सालों से गुलाम भारतीय
Judge should stop their practice if he unable to deliver the judgement
The judge could simply request for the transfer of this particular case to another seat who could understand the Hindi language instead of cancelling the petition directly. If honourable Justices aren’t able to understand the language of almost 80 crore of his fellow countrymen, then he should separate himself from this case or at least look for the possibilities. This thing seems little ironic that after 75 years of independence, till this date, Indians don’t have a common consensus on one single indigenous language of communication throughout the country. And this country dreams about topping the world. Will never happen.
I agree that the judge should have been more nicer. But at the same time I would like to remind you and help you out of the Hindi speaking myth, less than 30 % people of India have Hindi as mother tongue and less than 47% are native speakers. We need to stop saying assi crore ki aabadi hindi bolti hai… sab ko bad Lagta hai but Aisa nahi hai.
@@moinuddeensmrk8938 hindi is world top 5 languages that is spkoen by the people
Only North Indians speak in Hindi. Hindi is not a national language or it is not my language. Nd I m proud Indian
English is also not my language... And i am proud indian.
Nice!
Ye South wali idli dosa logo ka pahle se natak hai 😂Hindi se leke Hindustani shastriya Sangeet Tak se taklif h in logo ko 😂
Oye... North panipuri guy learn to respect people/language.#stophindiimposition
Pani poori,bhelpuri
Mr. Chappati, before speaking about South Indians, educate yourself that English is the official language of India. Just because you know Hindi, it doesn't mean entire India should speak Hindi.
That judge deserves strict action n Govt should amend the constitution to discontinue English as language of High Court. If someone dont understand / read/write hindu; got no right to remain on chair...
They are 26 official languages in India.Hindi is one of them how come judge from Maharashtra or Andhra read and write Hindi judgement it's not about hearing you need to write judgement usual orders will consist of hundreds of pages some times it cross 1000 pages 🙏
Hindi is just a official language like other languages in India. Don't try to impose Hindi on US
#STOPHINDIIMPOSITION
You should be arrested for saying this
What an arrogant judge, no wonder justice is so fair 🙄 in there
salute to the advocate
देश की जनता की भाषा के हिसाब से देश की अदालतों की भाषा हो
April 30, 2019 - Petitions can be filed in Hindi at the Patna High Court.
ऐसे जजों को अंग्रेजी कोठों के दलाल नहीं कहें तो क्या कहेंगे।
Jurm karne wala bhar h jo nirdos h vo andar gel me hota h is waja se hahahhahahaH
Ye galat hai tab to jo Hindi medium se hoga uska sapna advocate banane ka hoga to nahi ban sakta is baat se to yehi sabit ho ta hai
If the parliament is also said to continue its preceedings in English I don't think all the politicians could speak and explain in English then why it is happening only in court especially in india where major population is Hindi speaking and not English speaking. And I have written in English so that all can understand who don't know Hindi and getting attracted towards the western culture.
अगर संसद को भी अंग्रेजी में अपनी कार्यवाही जारी रखने के लिए कहा जाता है, तो मुझे नहीं लगता कि सभी राजनेता अंग्रेजी में बोल सकते हैं और समझा सकते हैं, तो यह केवल अदालत में क्यों हो रहा है, खासकर भारत में जहां बड़ी आबादी हिंदी भाषी है और अंग्रेजी नहीं बोल रही है। और मैंने अंग्रेजी में लिखा है ताकि सभी समझ सकें जो हिंदी नहीं जानता और पश्चिमी संस्कृति की ओर आकर्षित हो रहा है।
Glad you also wrote in hind, the advocate should have also provided the translations which he failed. English is a middle ground, otherwise every regional language will fight.
the incompetence of the judge doesn't gave him the right to not listen the learned counsel and should have provided with the appropriate translator
Judge is egoistic he is more interested in language rather than the actual case
Why all the IAS Officers doesn't look like an IAS in the high court? Is it mind or their facial expression.
भारत सरकार को हिन्दी भाषा वाले राज्यों में हिन्दी भाषा बोलने व समझने वाले जज साहब
नियुक्त करें।।
Advocate sahi bol rahe hai
Hindi is not national language. It's the lawyers job to file the translated copy to the bench. He's arrogant to tell the judge to get the judge to get the translation and when the Advocate is not able to satisfy the judge he brings up Hindi out of context. He's lucky he is suffering contempt proceedings. Also people don't mistake in to thinking that the judge is objecting to filing in Hindi but problem is with not filing translation. Hindi being local language in Bihar Filing in Hindi there is correct but when judges from other States come it's for the Advocate to file English translation for the convenience of the bench. I will try to get the judgements being referred to in this video. That Advocate's tone while telling the judge to obtain a translation which itself is appalling and the tone in general is certainly not right.
People should understand that judges of high court are transferred to different states. What would a judge from MP, who's a sitting judge in the kerala high court do? Speak in english or listen to the hearing in Malayalam.
Puchnewala koun hai. Dono lawyer and judge time barbaad karo ek language ke chakkar me. Logon ka koi sun ne wala nahi hai bhai is Desh me 😂
जज की परीक्षा में 12th level ke hindi ki pareeksha jaruri hai....hindi bhasha क्षेत्र में जजों के लिए
सच में यही रोना है देश में की हिन्दी को राष्ट्रभाषा तो बना लिया पर वो सम्मान मिला नहीं जो मिलना चाहिए राष्ट्रभाषा को। आज अंग्रेजी बोलने वालों को सम्मान मिलता है और हिन्दी बोलने वालों को अनपढ़ समझा जाता है।
Aisa judges ki wajah se hi beksoor log suffer ya jail jate hai.
judge sahab soch rhe galat fase aj 😂
जब साहब हिंदी नही समझते तो न्याय क्या करेंगे
What stupidity ! What an arrogant judge. Not fit to be a judge in a Hindi speaking state. The learned counsel was right in his argument but the Judge was trying to muzzle his voice. Reminds one of the colonial era. Its disgusting in indepedent Bharat.
this judge is saying that he does not understand Hindi. court/ or he is responsible to get the English version, ironically he is not fluent in English too. his pronunciation is horrible. Did he came from England
He is not judge he is behaviour like attitude and also main shameless for us he don't know Hindi...😮 This is our country taking care of our launguage
Gawar hindi mei bata English tere se nahi ho payega
ये है असली वकील।
whether we like or not High Court business is carried out in English Language.
Looks like Honourable Judge is from Collegium System
People are defending lawyer for sympathy!
But as per law the proceeding should be in English language only!
Because southern parts of India has different languages so during 1965 they were fighting to get permit to proceed in regional language, But this was denied by the chief justice council.
The reason was many judges are from different places it will be difficult for them to proceeding in Regional language, and there will be high probability of misleading or wrong decision by the judges.
The judge could have used translator but he was arrogant because of his position
government ko high court supreme court mein Hindi English donon kar dena chahie jisko Hindi mein bolna hai Hindi mein bole English mein bolna hai to English mein bole judge Sahab ko language sahi dikkat hai kya nyaay karenge
जो लोग ज्ञान दे रहे है कमेंट मे, खुद तो अपनी मातृभाषा हिंदी मे लिखो। अंग्रेजी लिख रहे हो आपलोग