Great to see an economist like Sharad interview Sanjeev. It made the conversation much more focused and meaningful. Sanjeev himself has been bringing attention to the need of Process Reforms (extremely underrated) for quite some time. Removing the cobwebs and rent seekers by improving the process itself is a shortcut to reducing corruption. We urgently need reforms in revenue collection agencies to reduce harrassment of corporates and small business owners as well.
lol the ruling party and their clowns started the negative sentiment against FDI. now that they made a mess of India's economic growth they are crawling back like shameless fools since FDI is the only hope for economic development. Rest of us were saying this since last 10 years. You don't need a phd in economics to see such basic things. All a bunch of clowns. BYD was ready to manufacture in India many years ago, but these clowns were going behind Tesla and Tesla deserted them and now they will shamelessly go back to BYD😂😂😂
I always get amazed to hear from Sanjib Sanyal. As always he is putting out the fault lines in our system. Ease of living for people which are not even addressed by any Govt. Always mesmerized by his ideas. Thanks 👍 Sanjib Sanyal Sir.
@@ashupal4605u trust Indians too much. I agree with Britisher when they say every Indian is corrupt to his core. If an exception exists he should be given the whole power so that the larger corrupt population don’t even get a chance to prove Britishers right.
Bureaucracy just needs to be taught to think on first principles. Redesigning any process, just needs reordering the sequence of questions we ask about it. Start with why, followed by what and then how. Instead we are too busy figuring out only how. First principles zindabad..
Simple government answers to complex business questions seldom get past the third hurdle, minus the investors money, if experience teaches us anything.
Bureaucracy is smart enough to know about First Principles. The question rather is what non-conventional factors stop the bureaucracy to actually implement first principles. Until we address the elephant in the room, there is no point talking about first principles.
Been to Delhi to deal with a contract … the way the deal with company owners is disgusting … don’t compare with China at any cost … the Chinese are business friendly even to Indians that deal with them … the British raj culture is shit that should change .. especially centrally in Delhi…
Sanjeev Sanyal is one of the underrated person in the modi cabinet He has more intellectuality than piyush goyal and nirmala sitharaman I follow him in Twitter and he always share very good knowledge ❤
But he is an advisor….he will be promoted to be a FM or commerce minister if he wants to in future terms as BJP dirty work (PM HM Defense) are done by lowly politicians and they do recruit great talent for FM CM and EAM…So Sanjeev Sanyal wants be he could be those things but he will be tortured by opposition if he is a Finance minister
@@ashupal4605 lol, I was supposed to write the same, infant I did, but removed..ki kora jaye aar..you get leaders you deserve. Bekele holei "Adda"..I will NEVER hier someone from Kolkata in my company made the mistake once, never will repeat it.
😂😂 Bengalis are already past intellectualism now they are just bunch of communists…Do u know the fall of Bengal industry started when the great Aditya birla stripped by communist goons and he made to walk entire 2 kms with workers throwing eggs and spit on him while he walks in under wear for 2km…..He went to office changed and pulled all his companies in 6 months and never came back and one by one all left Bengal and now Bengal is a competitive to become jr Bihar
talking about grants from center to WB, no amount of grant can do anything good in the current thugocracy because resource is the not the problem to start with. Resource will automatically flow where there is potential and environment to flourish it, u don't need to beg to anyone.
Yeah,China has become what it is today becoz of Western Capital for the last 40 years,So,Basically What's wrong with having Chinese capital invested in India and pay Indian Employees
Phr apke sath bi wai hga jo aaj china ke sth ho rha hai western jase china se dheere shift ho rha hai wase hi china krega. Or uska reaction tb indian economy per bht hga
China has done way better than India because of the great leaders & merit based political system they have!! The colonial western copied so called democracy in India brings a load of BS & even fails to protect our society, polity, culture & economy and must be thrown in the dustbin of history!!
West Bengal has chronically suffered from lethargic and incompetent leadership . Sadly the people have put up with it without realizing the harm it is doing to them .
You are being too generous and possibly even too ignorant by calling WB's leadership as just lethargic and incompetent!! I can't find harsher words than criminal, anti national, communal & corrupt leadership!!
@@abhishekagrawal3822 lol see the tone change in these clowns. for the last 10 years they were speaking against them. now the ruling party has made a mess of Indias economic growth they have no other choice. Shameless clowns
Please make some process improvements so that people should not be able to get forged/ fake aadhar card or birth certificate etc. Using technology to stop people from entering and living illegally in India
Nope , it doesn't need a improvement because it can't happned . Aadhar card required a Address and Date of birth proof and both this accept a Sign copy of Village head or Block head . Which means if a west bengal Block want to give voting rights to certainly individual from Bangladesh he only need to sign on their paper and they can give this paper as a proof for aadhar . I think this was the best flaw in aadhar .
This is what you get when you focus on Merit and not Caste. Thank God that people like Sanjeev Sanyal are there in the Economic Advisory Council to the PMO
Learn from Vietnam. There merchandise exports rely hugely on chinese players, who had innvested billions in vietnam and they export a lot of merchandise to US and other western countries.
@@vofficial170Thats not how manufacturing works. You can't just "move out" so easily. They've been trying to move out of China and its been very difficult. We need to make it easy for any and all investment to come here, with rare exceptions, and then grow fast enough that everyone grows dependent on us.
@sanjeev Sanyal Very refreshing to see you have identified a sweet spot and your strength through which you can drive change consistently & effectively. Power of process transformation is the most underrated lever of progress and growth from a Govt processes perspective yet can bring a profound impact when executed well. Very happy to see you come of ages and make meaningful direct contributions to lives of common people and businesses . Hearty Congratulations to you. 🎉
What an excellent session for public to get some light on it. Processing reforms altogether!!! Processing reforms in the existing service sectors Processing changes in existing criteria on Chinese investments through finding a balance between two critical matters ie Security and more FDI. Processing reforms in government sectors and PSUs by introducing a feedback system and periodic reassessment of the effectiveness of the program. Sanjeev Sanyal sir is a real genius whose approach is some sort of indigenous and must continue be an integral part of our national economical governance body I love it.
In non governmental parlance, this is called Service Design. Traditionally, the public sector ducks at this because there is no cost involved for them and there is no competition.
America and China are not friends. I am a foreigner working in China. This morning, I had my breakfast at McDonald, drove my Tesla to office, work at my HP computer with Intel CORE i7 and intel iRIS graphics plus B&O sound system. I had my lunch in Pizza hut and bought a cup of Latte from Starbucks. If China could allow all theses, what is the problem of India allowing Chinese company working in India?
Because of capital inflows & outflows. All the activities like pizza hut, star bucks, tesla create wealth & capital formation inside China where as allowing Haier, xiaomi which bring in goods from China will take away capital from India to our detriment
The answer is Boundry . US and Japan both doesn't shared a boundry with China and China also need them as a market because even though China is manufacturing hub the money they earn is from West . Second think I can say is Indian company willing to do what Chinese company did back . We have Mahindra and Tata both are most unliable brand . Range Rover and Jagur is probably the most unriable vehicle you can ever find . You have to be creative and risk taker . Indian are not known to vee both . They can Become a great CEO but not great Owner ?? Look at all the CEO they gain the experience and open their own shop but Indian just stick to their Job . Most of US company is run by Indian but they will not start their own company .the mindset is the problem . People used to laugh at vivo for their over bright camera and Xioami for copying apple . Vivo is the most sold mobile phone in Indian and Xioami is beating Apple in the no. While we were busy laughing at them they were innovative and learning from their mistake and now they are laughing at us .
Makes you remember ' Yes Minister ' . Bottleneck easing in process has to be periodically done as bottleneck changes , The commitment to process improvement will slowly make you the most productive nation. Kudos on good job. 👍
Equalisation of coal and steel prices destroyed the economy of eastern India. Left Front led labour unrest drove heavy and labour intensive industry away. Now we need financial support for education and self employment in starting up MSME and agri-horticiltural processing industries to make value added exportables. Start-ups and cooperative society based production units employing youth and women need to be encouraged with money and marketing support of local GI-certifiable products.
Our JULY-AUG electrical power bill amounted 11,000 progressively AUG-SEPT amounted to 2500 and SEPT-OCT amounted 2700. With such a disparity how easily could we live? We have one Milch Cow, could we install an electrically operated milking machine in such an unfriendly environment?
Is there an email or web site wherein a feedback can be shared with Sanjeev Sanyal, so that the reoccurring frictions of government can be shared by common citizens
Process reforms at state level badly needed. How can Center facilitate or even force States to do this? The least BJP Govt can do is to force the states it controls to undertake process reforms. We need a Sanjeev Sanyal in every BJP ruled state. Once citizens see the interaction with state has dramatically improved with lower rent seeking by corrupt babus BJP will gain politically. Other states will also start doing these same reforms. One reform I can think of is to centralize all IT infrastructure that states provide. For example, the IT that RTO uses or citizens use to pay local corporation tax or apply for an electricity connections, these need to be on the same software centrally maintained. This way best practices and features of a good state propagates to all states automatically.
@@shubhammayankshah He is not the chief economic advisor. Just a member of Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister. But on the other hand, if he can just focus on and implement all what he is talking about here with backing from PM, then it's much better.
Even though I agree with you but the problem is like some IAS has said "corruption is grease of this country " if you take away that the Bureaucracy will not run . Do you really think govt. Not know that ?? Do you really think a IIT gradute who will work hard to get a Job will gonna work for 80k per month salary ??? their median Salary is 17 lakh per annum and here we are talking about the best candidate so if govt. Will pay the same amount then they will but if not very few talented people will choose to do get into it . Take Singapore as an example they pay 1mil singapore dollar to their politician and have very strict rule for corruption and even the govt. Official think it's good to risk the job the pay and the jail time for some extra money when we are getting million as a pay ?? Majority will be satisfy and willing to do the work but if you pay 60 thousand Indian rupees for. The same work will they do it ?? The answer is nope .
Amazing sir! Business process re-engineering will win elections. You have to sell these process reforms to political parties. We need such reforms in how citizens deal with police, courts, Road transport office, ration office, Passport office (mostly done), Gas Cylinder booking, Electricity meter connection and so on and on....and the wow factor it creates will win elections. For example getting Covid vaccination certificate on mobile generated the wow factor!
7 states of south and west India which is 1/3rd of total population of our country which is 48 crore contributes 2.1tr of the 3.9tr Indian economy which is 54% total. This is equivalent to and 1.5 times that of Indonesia. The remaining 2/3rd population of north, centre, east and north east India with population of 96 crore contributes 1.8tr to Indian economy which is 46% of the total. Looks like these two need to be seen separately now as these two regions are in different stages of development..
@@karunasagarmallela6065 Even Orissa, West Bengal have coast but till now they are at par with other part of the country than south and west. So it’s not necessarily because of coast. Haryana, Punjab, Delhi, Sikkim, Himachal are also land locked but they have better hdi and gdp pc.. I think it has got to more with local politics, population density, higher rural population..
The question is, after 2020 clash, India has adopted aggressive measures towards Chinese captials, such as banned hundreds of Chinese apps, force Vivo to sell half od the equity of its India's subsidy, Ardani refused to pay 8 billions payment to Shanghai Electricity, refuse BYD's 10 billions investment etc. From top to down, very few Chinese want to invest in India. India always alure foreign investrors with its big market, however, if histroy shows no one could make money out of India, this market become meaningless for them. Since China generally has very good relationship with Asean countries, Chinese business men are more inclined to invest there. The Asean countries are true competitors to India, if someone consider the real FDI trend.
AI application must be introduced linking with govt website so that process reforms, easy adoption, automatic changes in descriptions just thru basic feeding info. Size ofvfobd and firmating and description will be common
Sanyal ji, why can’t we engage Private agencies in big cities to identify properties not yet assessed for property tax by technology, investigative visits and surveys? Huge untapped revenue generation for corporations exists here.
More than that will argue to engage private sector for tax invasion or black money . I have seen multiple time when someone transfer multiple lakh without any job and the bank or Tax department did ask or even notice it .
If India is importing parts, why not allow China to make in India. That is to keep the spies out! Employment for Indians. Small companies in India can make them, China is out.
Exactly, India should be following the Chinese playbook. India must do this to the West, China and Russia. Best to copy everything just to catch up and then once we have critical mass then we can do our own innovations
Hopefully sensible views will prevail and not the politically motivated chest thumping against China. In reality, China will create jobs for the unemployed youth in India.
How about process reforms in road construction in municipalities. One which allows citizens to raise issues of pothols and fixing the responsibility. Mumbai is richest municipality but has worst of the roads!
Unlike other states in India, in TN we only discuss solutions. Our dear leader Mr. Stalin encourages everyone to actively participate in the governance process. A school student can also call and discuss solutions with our dear leader, and he listens and implements the solution. It is a community driven process where everyone is a stack holder.
@@ashupal4605 Then why GoI blocks Chinese FDI investments in India ❓..For example MG EV wanted to make huge investment in India but still pending with GoI. Maybe if MG would have avoided JV with JSW and that joined hands with the Adanis, the project would have been approved long ago. And if the plant spurts in.Gujarat, all objections would be waived off. Funny GoI.
Once they dominate the market they start dictating. So it should be be a ltd company with majority equity with India ( either by shareholders or FII or govt share of the company. Directors 2 are to be from one government nominated and one FII nominated
As a proud Tamilian who's state TN is well on track to become 100 trillion USD economy by 2030, under the blessing and guidance of visionary statesman Mr. Stalin, I strongly feel we should separate and form our own independent Tamil homeland.
BYD wanted a plant in telangana. Modani gujju selfish traitors opposed the investment . They would want to divert the investment to that state with no top engineers or talent
Whats the point of talking about this next level ideas, why dont you get the basics right first? That will fix 80% of your problems. India's per capita GDP is still rockbottom compared to the rest of the world. You only need to achieve the bare minimum to grow the economy tremendously. Please try not to get ahead of yourself with this next level marketing ideas??
This man doing all sorts of things other then real economy work, he declared himself another and new GOD who building culture and not just economy. There is no shortage of feku in Modi government that’s for sure. In just few months back in one of his interviews when asked a question of ED raid to almost whosever they want to do without any proof or anything the answer he gave was if you are innocent then why all citizens are worried so in shorts he declared everyone guilty until they themselves proof innocent in ED or CBI office until then keep queued up in these agencies office.
Indian economy is growing at the fastest rate in the world thanks to accepting free market which economist like him have vouched for. But you won't understand since you are a mediocre IQ being who at most can understand leftist rhetorics.
Why doesn’t he talk about the Hindi belt which BJP ruled for decades? It show poor BJP policies that UP , MP and Bihar are the worst performing state far behind West Bengal.
Aa gaya Bengali pride ka tattu.😂😂 Up hasn't been ruled by bjp for many years as well as bihar, mp has been ruled by bjp for last two decades and some evidence shows that mp has improved, gujrat has improved significantly look at up it's improving recently by bjp government.
lol! BJP has been in power in UP since last 7 years and it has been doing fantastically well. MP - has performed well on all parameters. Bihar - BjP has only been part of govt for some years , never it has govr in Bihar. it's been Nitish Kumar / JDU's since 2005.
Please don't talk about West Bengal. It's economic growth is pathetic. If you want to compare West Bengal, then you should compare with Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Telengana, Gujrat, Maharashtra, then you will feel the difference. Even Odisha, Assam is performing far far better than West Bengal. West Bengal is not ruled by BJP, then why the economic growth is pathetic? There is no policy, no vision for any economic development. That's the reason.
@@Badbadderbaddest aa gaya Bengali pride people.🤣🤣 Up hasn't been ruled by bjp significantly. Only last 7 up has been under bjp. Whenever up has gone under bjp it has performed better. Up is doing really well. Mp has been ruled by bjp and many evidence shows its doing well. When has bjp ruled bihar. when they have been under bjp-jdu alliance Gunda raj has decreased. Also bjp-shivsena alliance wiped out underworld from Maharashtra. And that time it was done by bjp minister. Look how bjp has reformed gujrat. Look how Assam performed better under bjp. Forget bjp bjd transformed odissa,TDP transformed Andhra. Only our commie people of WB and Kerala ruining good economy.
Great to see an economist like Sharad interview Sanjeev. It made the conversation much more focused and meaningful.
Sanjeev himself has been bringing attention to the need of Process Reforms (extremely underrated) for quite some time. Removing the cobwebs and rent seekers by improving the process itself is a shortcut to reducing corruption. We urgently need reforms in revenue collection agencies to reduce harrassment of corporates and small business owners as well.
lol the ruling party and their clowns started the negative sentiment against FDI. now that they made a mess of India's economic growth they are crawling back like shameless fools since FDI is the only hope for economic development. Rest of us were saying this since last 10 years. You don't need a phd in economics to see such basic things. All a bunch of clowns. BYD was ready to manufacture in India many years ago, but these clowns were going behind Tesla and Tesla deserted them and now they will shamelessly go back to BYD😂😂😂
I always get amazed to hear from Sanjib Sanyal.
As always he is putting out the fault lines in our system. Ease of living for people which are not even addressed by any Govt.
Always mesmerized by his ideas. Thanks 👍 Sanjib Sanyal Sir.
If BJP wins in WB, he should be made Finance minister of WB province
For ease of Living we need devaluation of power at municipal and panchayat level then only ease of living actually happen
@@ashupal4605 how are the roads in towns and cities look like under the devaluation of powers to mayors and municipal corporations?
@@ashupal4605u trust Indians too much. I agree with Britisher when they say every Indian is corrupt to his core. If an exception exists he should be given the whole power so that the larger corrupt population don’t even get a chance to prove Britishers right.
@@varun2250 He wont enter direct politics i feel.
Agree with him, I closed my Pvt Ltd company recently. Took about 60-70 days.
Why?
@@kumar.193 Because process reforms have been done in that area. Otherwise it would've taken 6 years.
Bureaucracy just needs to be taught to think on first principles. Redesigning any process, just needs reordering the sequence of questions we ask about it. Start with why, followed by what and then how. Instead we are too busy figuring out only how. First principles zindabad..
Simple government answers to complex business questions seldom get past the third hurdle, minus the investors money, if experience teaches us anything.
Bureaucracy is smart enough to know about First Principles. The question rather is what non-conventional factors stop the bureaucracy to actually implement first principles. Until we address the elephant in the room, there is no point talking about first principles.
Been to Delhi to deal with a contract … the way the deal with company owners is disgusting … don’t compare with China at any cost … the Chinese are business friendly even to Indians that deal with them … the British raj culture is shit that should change .. especially centrally in Delhi…
Sanjeev Sanyal is one of the underrated person in the modi cabinet
He has more intellectuality than piyush goyal and nirmala sitharaman
I follow him in Twitter and he always share very good knowledge ❤
But he is an advisor….he will be promoted to be a FM or commerce minister if he wants to in future terms as BJP dirty work (PM HM Defense) are done by lowly politicians and they do recruit great talent for FM CM and EAM…So Sanjeev Sanyal wants be he could be those things but he will be tortured by opposition if he is a Finance minister
Make him the CM candidate for WB, if he desires to. Bengal needs someone of his intellect at the helm 😅
Still bengalis vote mamta and doing randirona about their poverty and unemployment
Bongs will not allow it. They like left Jihadi begums.
@@ashupal4605 lol, I was supposed to write the same, infant I did, but removed..ki kora jaye aar..you get leaders you deserve. Bekele holei "Adda"..I will NEVER hier someone from Kolkata in my company made the mistake once, never will repeat it.
he is a thinker n a professional manager. not a rough n tough street fighting politician.
he will fail in WB.
😂😂 Bengalis are already past intellectualism now they are just bunch of communists…Do u know the fall of Bengal industry started when the great Aditya birla stripped by communist goons and he made to walk entire 2 kms with workers throwing eggs and spit on him while he walks in under wear for 2km…..He went to office changed and pulled all his companies in 6 months and never came back and one by one all left Bengal and now Bengal is a competitive to become jr Bihar
talking about grants from center to WB, no amount of grant can do anything good in the current thugocracy because resource is the not the problem to start with. Resource will automatically flow where there is potential and environment to flourish it, u don't need to beg to anyone.
After a long time on the print I have heard a positive Bharat discussion . Please make Bharat economically strong news portal
Yeah,China has become what it is today becoz of Western Capital for the last 40 years,So,Basically What's wrong with having Chinese capital invested in India and pay Indian Employees
Nothing wrong except some strategic sector like telecom, defence,banks
Phr apke sath bi wai hga jo aaj china ke sth ho rha hai western jase china se dheere shift ho rha hai wase hi china krega. Or uska reaction tb indian economy per bht hga
So technology jiski hgi apni wai raaz krega
No. Its because of their smart government. Not because of west
China has done way better than India because of the great leaders & merit based political system they have!! The colonial western copied so called democracy in India brings a load of BS & even fails to protect our society, polity, culture & economy and must be thrown in the dustbin of history!!
West Bengal has chronically suffered from lethargic and incompetent leadership . Sadly the people have put up with it without realizing the harm it is doing to them .
You are being too generous and possibly even too ignorant by calling WB's leadership as just lethargic and incompetent!! I can't find harsher words than criminal, anti national, communal & corrupt leadership!!
the question on the title.. why not "allow" them.. allow?? the mindset of ALLOWing investment rather than ATTRACT.
"allow" is there in the question, because we are talking about Chinese investments.
@@abhishekagrawal3822 lol see the tone change in these clowns. for the last 10 years they were speaking against them. now the ruling party has made a mess of Indias economic growth they have no other choice. Shameless clowns
Its just Indian English
Good progress on bureaucratic processes front! Need to keep up the work...
Please make some process improvements so that people should not be able to get forged/ fake aadhar card or birth certificate etc.
Using technology to stop people from entering and living illegally in India
Nope , it doesn't need a improvement because it can't happned . Aadhar card required a Address and Date of birth proof and both this accept a Sign copy of Village head or Block head . Which means if a west bengal Block want to give voting rights to certainly individual from Bangladesh he only need to sign on their paper and they can give this paper as a proof for aadhar . I think this was the best flaw in aadhar .
This is what you get when you focus on Merit and not Caste. Thank God that people like Sanjeev Sanyal are there in the Economic Advisory Council to the PMO
Learn from Vietnam. There merchandise exports rely hugely on chinese players, who had innvested billions in vietnam and they export a lot of merchandise to US and other western countries.
@@uzumakimodi493 Mexico also
When they start moving out of Vietnam then what would be the impact of that on its economy?
@@vofficial170Thats not how manufacturing works. You can't just "move out" so easily. They've been trying to move out of China and its been very difficult. We need to make it easy for any and all investment to come here, with rare exceptions, and then grow fast enough that everyone grows dependent on us.
@sanjeev Sanyal Very refreshing to see you have identified a sweet spot and your strength through which you can drive change consistently & effectively. Power of process transformation is the most underrated lever of progress and growth from a Govt processes perspective yet can bring a profound impact when executed well. Very happy to see you come of ages and make meaningful direct contributions to lives of common people and businesses . Hearty Congratulations to you. 🎉
that question needs a million dollar👏👏👏
What an excellent session for public to get some light on it.
Processing reforms altogether!!!
Processing reforms in the existing service sectors
Processing changes in existing criteria on Chinese investments through finding a balance between two critical matters ie Security and more FDI.
Processing reforms in government sectors and PSUs by introducing a feedback system and periodic reassessment of the effectiveness of the program.
Sanjeev Sanyal sir is a real genius whose approach is some sort of indigenous and must continue be an integral part of our national economical governance body
I love it.
In non governmental parlance, this is called Service Design. Traditionally, the public sector ducks at this because there is no cost involved for them and there is no competition.
Very instructive talk.🎉
Excellent solution by Mr Sanyal & Govt of Inda & PM MODI
Ok this guy is really really cool. Love listening to Sanjeev Sanyal talk
PDS and FCI , excellent problem to solve !!
Highly informative!
Where are those guys who were trumpeting that Hindi belt states were looted due to FEP by Western and Southern states instead of their own failures
Thank you to Shri Sanjeev Sanyal for these changes and to ThePrint for this video.
Thank print for this video.
Wow. Such an informative discussion. Please keep them coming.
America and China are not friends. I am a foreigner working in China. This morning, I had my breakfast at McDonald, drove my Tesla to office, work at my HP computer with Intel CORE i7 and intel iRIS graphics plus B&O sound system. I had my lunch in Pizza hut and bought a cup of Latte from Starbucks. If China could allow all theses, what is the problem of India allowing Chinese company working in India?
China must not be allowed to dump its product on us to kill our enterprises.
Because of capital inflows & outflows. All the activities like pizza hut, star bucks, tesla create wealth & capital formation inside China where as allowing Haier, xiaomi which bring in goods from China will take away capital from India to our detriment
They ego is big
The answer is Boundry . US and Japan both doesn't shared a boundry with China and China also need them as a market because even though China is manufacturing hub the money they earn is from West .
Second think I can say is Indian company willing to do what Chinese company did back . We have Mahindra and Tata both are most unliable brand . Range Rover and Jagur is probably the most unriable vehicle you can ever find . You have to be creative and risk taker . Indian are not known to vee both . They can Become a great CEO but not great Owner ?? Look at all the CEO they gain the experience and open their own shop but Indian just stick to their Job . Most of US company is run by Indian but they will not start their own company .the mindset is the problem . People used to laugh at vivo for their over bright camera and Xioami for copying apple . Vivo is the most sold mobile phone in Indian and Xioami is beating Apple in the no. While we were busy laughing at them they were innovative and learning from their mistake and now they are laughing at us .
Makes you remember ' Yes Minister ' . Bottleneck easing in process has to be periodically done as bottleneck changes , The commitment to process improvement will slowly make you the most productive nation. Kudos on good job. 👍
What happened to Bihar in the 90s ?
Lalu Prasad Yadav 90-97
Not till 97 but till 2004
@Print can you make the whitepaper available ?
Equalisation of coal and steel prices destroyed the economy of eastern India. Left Front led labour unrest drove heavy and labour intensive industry away. Now we need financial support for education and self employment in starting up MSME and agri-horticiltural processing industries to make value added exportables. Start-ups and cooperative society based production units employing youth and women need to be encouraged with money and marketing support of local GI-certifiable products.
Opening a small Kirana store or a shop is riddled with rent seekers from municipalities. Do something about it.
True.
Our JULY-AUG electrical power bill amounted 11,000 progressively AUG-SEPT amounted to 2500 and SEPT-OCT amounted 2700. With such a disparity how easily could we live? We have one Milch Cow, could we install an electrically operated milking machine in such an unfriendly environment?
Great conversation!
Is there an email or web site wherein a feedback can be shared with Sanjeev Sanyal, so that the reoccurring frictions of government can be shared by common citizens
Process reforms at state level badly needed. How can Center facilitate or even force States to do this?
The least BJP Govt can do is to force the states it controls to undertake process reforms. We need a Sanjeev Sanyal in every BJP ruled state.
Once citizens see the interaction with state has dramatically improved with lower rent seeking by corrupt babus BJP will gain politically. Other states will also start doing these same reforms.
One reform I can think of is to centralize all IT infrastructure that states provide. For example, the IT that RTO uses or citizens use to pay local corporation tax or apply for an electricity connections, these need to be on the same software centrally maintained. This way best practices and features of a good state propagates to all states automatically.
Just a fantastic guy, is Mr Sanyal. We are lucky he is working for us on economic processes & policies. And a true patriot.
when can we have him Modi cabinet as Finance Minister pl?
He is already the chief economic adviser
@@shubhammayankshah He is not the chief economic advisor. Just a member of Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister.
But on the other hand, if he can just focus on and implement all what he is talking about here with backing from PM, then it's much better.
Let The Print open a suggestion box for attracting suggestions for Govt. Process improving from citizens and forward to Sanyal for scrutiny
We have our own Chief of Dept of Efficiency!!
That stopwatch is not done by most of the govt officials
Good Stuff, I hope he makes the thinking institutional
Digitization will much reduce process reform..govt means inefficiency, wastages and corruption that only be reduced only by Digitization
Even though I agree with you but the problem is like some IAS has said "corruption is grease of this country " if you take away that the Bureaucracy will not run . Do you really think govt. Not know that ?? Do you really think a IIT gradute who will work hard to get a Job will gonna work for 80k per month salary ??? their median Salary is 17 lakh per annum and here we are talking about the best candidate so if govt. Will pay the same amount then they will but if not very few talented people will choose to do get into it .
Take Singapore as an example they pay 1mil singapore dollar to their politician and have very strict rule for corruption and even the govt. Official think it's good to risk the job the pay and the jail time for some extra money when we are getting million as a pay ?? Majority will be satisfy and willing to do the work but if you pay 60 thousand Indian rupees for. The same work will they do it ?? The answer is nope .
amazing guy i also watched him in the think school podcast and was fascinated by his thought process wish more people like him in the government .
Amazing sir! Business process re-engineering will win elections. You have to sell these process reforms to political parties. We need such reforms in how citizens deal with police, courts, Road transport office, ration office, Passport office (mostly done), Gas Cylinder booking, Electricity meter connection and so on and on....and the wow factor it creates will win elections. For example getting Covid vaccination certificate on mobile generated the wow factor!
7 states of south and west India which is 1/3rd of total population of our country which is 48 crore contributes 2.1tr of the 3.9tr Indian economy which is 54% total. This is equivalent to and 1.5 times that of Indonesia. The remaining 2/3rd population of north, centre, east and north east India with population of 96 crore contributes 1.8tr to Indian economy which is 46% of the total. Looks like these two need to be seen separately now as these two regions are in different stages of development..
That's because of sea coastal areas. Others are landlocked.
@@karunasagarmallela6065 Even Orissa, West Bengal have coast but till now they are at par with other part of the country than south and west. So it’s not necessarily because of coast. Haryana, Punjab, Delhi, Sikkim, Himachal are also land locked but they have better hdi and gdp pc.. I think it has got to more with local politics, population density, higher rural population..
@@karunasagarmallela6065 excuses... these states refuse to change themselves and actively involve in change, which the south states are doing.
china government just forbid key chinese company make key parts in india.
The question is, after 2020 clash, India has adopted aggressive measures towards Chinese captials, such as banned hundreds of Chinese apps, force Vivo to sell half od the equity of its India's subsidy, Ardani refused to pay 8 billions payment to Shanghai Electricity, refuse BYD's 10 billions investment etc. From top to down, very few Chinese want to invest in India. India always alure foreign investrors with its big market, however, if histroy shows no one could make money out of India, this market become meaningless for them. Since China generally has very good relationship with Asean countries, Chinese business men are more inclined to invest there. The Asean countries are true competitors to India, if someone consider the real FDI trend.
LOL AS IF CHINA NEVER DID THAT TOO FOREIGN COUTRY.
@@abhijitnandy1651 so you do understand why china will hesitate? A thief is more aware of safe places
To what extent performance of Gujarat and UP is influenced by federal tax dollars that’s been generously spent in those states.?
AI application must be introduced linking with govt website so that process reforms, easy adoption, automatic changes in descriptions just thru basic feeding info. Size ofvfobd and firmating and description will be common
So nobody gonna talk about how Jonny depp talking in Hindi?
Sanyal ji, why can’t we engage Private agencies in big cities to identify properties not yet assessed for property tax by technology, investigative visits and surveys? Huge untapped revenue generation for corporations exists here.
More than that will argue to engage private sector for tax invasion or black money . I have seen multiple time when someone transfer multiple lakh without any job and the bank or Tax department did ask or even notice it .
It's not as easy as you think.
If India is importing parts, why not allow China to make in India. That is to keep the spies out!
Employment for Indians. Small companies in India can make them, China is out.
allow chinese, learn/steal from them. Shadow ban them. in sequence.
Exactly, India should be following the Chinese playbook. India must do this to the West, China and Russia. Best to copy everything just to catch up and then once we have critical mass then we can do our own innovations
Amazing discussion. Thankyou
Shame of Bengal.
Jyoti Basu destroyed Bengal first for politics
now Sanjib Sanyal is trying to destroy Bengal for politics but in a different way.
RBI needs reform for petty issues
Learn to lot from China. How China developed its economies.
32:14 govt feedback is must
Hopefully sensible views will prevail and not the politically motivated chest thumping against China. In reality, China will create jobs for the unemployed youth in India.
You need to create a email or some website to get ideas for process reforms from citizens! You will have a lot ideas!
What federal policies are lacking in Eastern India before saying. Y innuendo that state subjects and policies could be improved
How about process reforms in road construction in municipalities. One which allows citizens to raise issues of pothols and fixing the responsibility. Mumbai is richest municipality but has worst of the roads!
Mumbai and Bangalore both are wealthy cities with poor infrastructure.
Why no Census till now..?
Unlike other states in India, in TN we only discuss solutions. Our dear leader Mr. Stalin encourages everyone to actively participate in the governance process. A school student can also call and discuss solutions with our dear leader, and he listens and implements the solution. It is a community driven process where everyone is a stack holder.
Fix epfo, every hard working midle class will be grateful
Does it suggest small States are better for improving economy
Bihar= system Curuption= bridge 🌉, Colaps infrastructure development project collapse economy, Curuption in political system!!!
Then why the GoI floods the Indian market with ₹10 cigarette lighters, crushing the cottage Match Boxes factories particularly in Tamil Nadu ❓
Because of WTO we cannot make custom duty on China alone
@@ashupal4605 Then why GoI blocks Chinese FDI investments in India ❓..For example MG EV wanted to make huge investment in India but still pending with GoI. Maybe if MG would have avoided JV with JSW and that joined hands with the Adanis, the project would have been approved long ago. And if the plant spurts in.Gujarat, all objections would be waived off. Funny GoI.
Once they dominate the market they start dictating.
So it should be be a ltd company with majority equity with India ( either by shareholders or FII or govt share of the company. Directors 2 are to be from one government nominated and one FII nominated
As a proud Tamilian who's state TN is well on track to become 100 trillion USD economy by 2030, under the blessing and guidance of visionary statesman Mr. Stalin, I strongly feel we should separate and form our own independent Tamil homeland.
The sarcasm was top notch😅
Tamil Nadu aims 1 trillion dollars economy by 2030. Yours maybe a topography error.
@@rajkumarganesan9417 Maybe Rs. 100 trillion based on 1 usd = Rs. 100.
😂
😂😂😂😂😂
If it's made in China ...🇨🇳
Why call *Make in India*...🤦🏿♂️
Call it *China Made*...🙋🏾♂️
DMAIC
BYD wanted a plant in telangana. Modani gujju selfish traitors opposed the investment . They would want to divert the investment to that state with no top engineers or talent
Exactly! They shamelessly went behind Tesla to setup in Gujarat and Tesla also rejected them😂 Bunch of clowns!!!
Bjp should made him cm candidate of west bengal
29:33 bro tried his best not to mention the USA in this USA funded podcast 😆😆😆😆😆
"japan"
Is desh ki industry ka bhatta bureaucracy ne bathaya hai or ye belagaam hai neta inke hath ki kathputli mattar hain
Whats the point of talking about this next level ideas, why dont you get the basics right first? That will fix 80% of your problems. India's per capita GDP is still rockbottom compared to the rest of the world. You only need to achieve the bare minimum to grow the economy tremendously. Please try not to get ahead of yourself with this next level marketing ideas??
Exactly these people are clowns
Phd topics in public administration. Follow Mr. Sanyal !!! Definitely efficacious policy research material !!
bro just hates being with the print >< lol
Fake historian and part time economist
This man doing all sorts of things other then real economy work, he declared himself another and new GOD who building culture and not just economy. There is no shortage of feku in Modi government that’s for sure. In just few months back in one of his interviews when asked a question of ED raid to almost whosever they want to do without any proof or anything the answer he gave was if you are innocent then why all citizens are worried so in shorts he declared everyone guilty until they themselves proof innocent in ED or CBI office until then keep queued up in these agencies office.
Indian economy is growing at the fastest rate in the world thanks to accepting free market which economist like him have vouched for. But you won't understand since you are a mediocre IQ being who at most can understand leftist rhetorics.
@@harshitgupta5223 Even if a Giraffe was running India it will grow at the current rate because we have such huge domestic consumption.
Lo, ho gaya banta dhar print ka bhi. Ab print bhi band karna padega dekhna
@@Life.is.a.library tu mars pe Jake reh.🤣🤣
@@bhikariman-sigmamale I dont want to be indulge in anyway to a person whose username has 'sigmamale'
Tum New Mint hi padho
@@FromPlanetZX No, the wire only
@@Life.is.a.librarythe wire is a blessing for depressed liberals...
ruclips.net/video/QwYJ9ve5kFg/видео.html Can you be trusted ? 🤣
Why doesn’t he talk about the Hindi belt which BJP ruled for decades? It show poor BJP policies that UP , MP and Bihar are the worst performing state far behind West Bengal.
Go and check what is happenings at HP to understand
Aa gaya Bengali pride ka tattu.😂😂
Up hasn't been ruled by bjp for many years as well as bihar, mp has been ruled by bjp for last two decades and some evidence shows that mp has improved, gujrat has improved significantly look at up it's improving recently by bjp government.
lol! BJP has been in power in UP since last 7 years and it has been doing fantastically well. MP - has performed well on all parameters. Bihar - BjP has only been part of govt for some years , never it has govr in Bihar. it's been Nitish Kumar / JDU's since 2005.
Please don't talk about West Bengal. It's economic growth is pathetic.
If you want to compare West Bengal, then you should compare with Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Telengana, Gujrat, Maharashtra, then you will feel the difference. Even Odisha, Assam is performing far far better than West Bengal.
West Bengal is not ruled by BJP, then why the economic growth is pathetic? There is no policy, no vision for any economic development. That's the reason.
@@Badbadderbaddest aa gaya Bengali pride people.🤣🤣 Up hasn't been ruled by bjp significantly. Only last 7 up has been under bjp. Whenever up has gone under bjp it has performed better. Up is doing really well. Mp has been ruled by bjp and many evidence shows its doing well. When has bjp ruled bihar. when they have been under bjp-jdu alliance Gunda raj has decreased. Also bjp-shivsena alliance wiped out underworld from Maharashtra. And that time it was done by bjp minister. Look how bjp has reformed gujrat. Look how Assam performed better under bjp.
Forget bjp bjd transformed odissa,TDP transformed Andhra. Only our commie people of WB and Kerala ruining good economy.
communist anti Indians discussing like intellectuals hahaha
Print sucks
Dhoti