ANATOMY OF A FALL: Killing The Editing
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июн 2024
- Check out the Bonus Scene Breakdown: thisguyedits.com/anatomy
Hitchcock would have been proud. Anatomy of a Fall is a four-time Oscar-nominated film that won the Cannes Palm d'Or 2023. It is my favorite film of the season.
#anatomyofafall #filmediting
00:00 Intro
01:34 Lawyer Crime Scene Investigation (Hitchcock Homage)
11:57 BONUS: Car Scene (thisguyedits.com/anatomy)
12:40 The Fight
THIS GUY EDITS (TGE) is a RUclips channel by film editor Sven Pape, an A.C.E. award nominee whose credits include work for directors James Cameron, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, and Sundance filmmaker Mark Webber.
Music by Epidemic Sound. Get a free trial: thisguyedits.com/epidemic
★- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ★
Want More THIS GUY EDITS? ☆Connect With Me:☆
➜ MY FREE MINI-COURSE-
secreteditinghacks.com
➜ ONLINE EDITING COURSE-
thegotoeditor.com
➜ PATREON MEMBERSHIP-
patreon.com/ thisguyedits
➜ MY EDITING SETUP-
kit.co/thisguyedits
★- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ★ 
Кино
Check out the Bonus Scene Breakdown: thisguyedits.com/anatomy
Very engaging (raw) performances.
In an interview, the editor said the director would require to always pick the strongest performance shots in isolation, and build from that, no matter what - instead of building a scene with what might feel right.
Something that stood out to me was a strong zooming on the judge in one shot. We don’t see much aggressive zooming in modern cinema: it seems to be frowned upon.
I think the Zoom on the house when they were re-enacting the fall, while she went for a walk, was remarkable aswell
Scene breakdown recommendations:
1. "Always with water"- Beau is Afraid
2. Soccer field- Pacifiction
3. Crash- Ferrari
4. "Slow her down some"- Killers of the Flower Moon
5. Lisbon dance- Poor Things
6. Bar scene- Past Lives
7. Cute Yellow Fiat- Dead Reckoning Part One
8. First contact- Asteroid City
9. Intervention- Across the Spider-verse
10. Funeral- Love Life
Some of the most believable, naturalistic performances I’ve ever seen in film
The camera freezes during the outburst and when waiting for the husband's reaction just like how some react after a gigantic shock. I really hope you can consider making a video about Burning (2018), because it is up there with this movie.
Thanks so much for this, Sven. A really great break-down.
Although I have already made The Go-To Editor course, I love your scene analysis.
I did watched it, and thought it was robbed. This movie deserves better.
I think this was one of the best films of 2023. Performances were astonishingly good, all of them. The wife, the husband, the kid, even the dog!
Fantastic analysis Sven! Anatomy of a Fall was easily one of my favorite films from last year as well.
Would love to see you breakdown the first scene in The Ship from Poor Things, the one where Bella and Duncan meet Harry and Martha. It'd also be fantastic if you can breakdown the Hitler studies scene in White Noise.
Tooooootally agree! Top notch filmmaking. Brilliant writing and editing.
I will give it a watch, thanks.
I think what you call "pure cinema" is actually just proper filmmaking.
From the sequences you showed, it has too many mid-to-MCU-to-tigther shots which I think is a sickness of cinema for the past 40 years. It's a good general bias for television, wrong for the cinema. Using handheld to express something has also been far too overused and doesn't have the impact or convey the emotion as it once did.
I'll revisit this movie in Premiere Pro to see all the things you've pointed out. Right now I'm busy using this method on Killers of the Flower Moon. As you can understand, that's taking a while. But Anatomy has stuck with me so I'll be interested in going back to it.
How is it that you can review a film such as this one in Premiere Pro so as to study the editing etc?
I did watch this and I listen to PIMP all the time btw
I agreed! This was my choice for best editing.
I did. At a movie theather. Haven't felt such emotional weight on my chest on the way out in a long time. Spoke a lot to me about sharing a life with a partner. And yeah, the spotlight on the fight scene is well-deserved. (After seeing the movie, I am not so sure if one should see it here beforehand, to me it's one of the most essential sequences of the entire film, feels like a spoiler).
Anyway, as an editor myself, I couldn't help noticing they cut back to the court right before it revealed "too much", keeping the ambiguous atmosphere untouched. Fantastic, yet subtle choice.
I hate that I haven't seen this movie yet and so I can't watch this video yet either 😩
Still want to know how to get film files as Mp4s to review
I loved that movie!!
Hey ! I watched that movie !
...
OK, I'm french, it helps, still, I watched it and enjoyed this masterpiece
There's never truly a definitive "best-edited movie of the year" when all the nominees were brilliantly edited. After seeing Anatomy of a Fall, I'm happy Oppenheimer won but this film is brilliant on every level and definitely should've been seen more.
I am so happy for your shoutout, I absolutely LOVED this movie, and personally, I really think Triet deserved the Director-win far more.
No
@@buladdd well aren't you an articulate fella
🎉
Some people choose a title and thumbnail for their video before they upload. Those people are cowards.
Una película que me atrapó mucho y eso es difícil. El Oscar fue vencido por la ideología, no lo necesita para ser una gran película que cumple con la narrativa, diálogos, conducción de los personajes, la misma fotografía! Muy bien 👌🏻. La recomiendo y también este canal 👏🏻👏🏻
Putting this above Oppenheimer is wild ngl. (Referencing the thumbnail, unless it’s clickbait then I get it lol)
Not really, Oppenheimer is more flashy but there's nothing that indicates to me it has objectively better editing
Why do you keep changing your thumbnail and title ? I know you're not the only one to do so, but I usually unsubscribe from these channels, as it feels clickbaity and desperate for attention. Is there a logical explanation for this practice ?
We are running continuous a/b testing to optimize a video's performance. It can take several days before a video can strike the right balance between click through rate, watch time, and viewer watch experience. If one of those elements falls short, RUclips will stop sharing the video.
I don't know what I didn't understand about this film but for me it was a real pain to follow it to the end. The procedural part above all never grabbed me and I got to the end cursing for it to end as soon as possible. I think Hitchcock is really called into question in a very forced way in this case. I like all Hitchcock's films, even the silent ones, but the only one I've never liked is Rebecca. I don't know, maybe it could be a curious coincidence. For me this year has been particularly negative, cinematically speaking. Both this film and Hoppenheimer (whose analysis I saw with great satisfaction on this channel) I didn't like very much. I'm not saying they're bad films, but they're films where I don't give a damn about what happens to the characters. Perhaps the only good film I saw was The Holdovers, although I understand that it could be a classic style film. Maybe I just don't like this new avant-garde.
I did watch it and it wasn't the best in my opinion. Great, but not the best. (because it's the internet i feel like i must emphasize that it's my opinion)
Update: OP has changed the title of the video and therefore my comment no longer makes any sense.
Are you happy to elaborate, please?
@@DrRussell i liked Oppenheimer (and its editing) more. What else do you want to know?
@@MionwangThank you, is it that this film is more dialogue-heavy and Oppenheimer had more relevant spectacle? (I’m sorry I’m probably oversimplifying)
@@DrRussellmore dialogue heavy than Oppie? That doesn't seem posible
@DrRussell I typically hate montage sequences, but Oppenheimer somehow tells a majority of its story through montage sequences, while throwing a large amount of information at you both through dialogue over these sequences and shots that last as short as a breath, all the while being instantly comprehensible. That is just one thing I'm fascinated by with the editing, but I'm also someone who just watched movies. It might not be as impressive as I think it is
I really don't give a flying crap about whatever this video have to say after seeing that thumbnail. I understand that creators have to play by the algorithm rules from time to time, but chose go to this extreme or be taken seriously. You can't have both.
What are you on about?
@@hoodyboody He's refering to the fact creators seem to change the title and thumbnail all the time to keep showing up in algorithms
Its boring
Naaaaaaaaaaan