Abi Tulabot he almost did hahaha. But Nikki shook her head but afterwards he started suspecting her and so that’s when she finally agreed to kill him off
@@hersheyqueen1015 if you run the mouse through the bottom of the video if you watch on a computer you can see the deadbox scenes in the preview that pops up
I think even if Josh didn't call out as nurse, Jen still wouldve been next just because of him being a wildcard. Mafia will always want Josh close to the end.
They bring him in because he makes the game more interesting. Without him mafias would be nonexistent in this channel Views would suck. And then all the fans complain because it not played anymore.
If Mafia fell for Josh’s bait and Jenn picked up on what he was doing and saved him, Josh’s plan would have been the greatest play I’ve ever seen in Mafia
@diodgaming totally agree!!! Too bad his execution for the play wasn’t convincing. I don’t think mafia especially Nikki and Antoinne would have killed him off even with Jenn understanding his move
Mafia Spoilers below (don’t read unless you’ve watched) Nikki is OP, please nerf. The reason Nikki is MVP here and every game is because she has the ability to gain trust from other players, a skillset I’ve lost because I’ve burned so many people. Nikki carried Mafia this game, and not because of any ONE big play, but several very small and nuanced ones. She da real one. Ya’ll better recognize.
Nikki really did carry the game, but it was pretty obvious that she was Mafia, since she was pointing fingers like nobody's business. You were more subtle, in my opinion. Really though, Hoolia almost KILLED the game, in a good way, when she pointed out you and Sean.
Also, I really like your comments after Mafia games. I think it would be really cool if you guys did a commentary video where some of you talk over an old game and explain what you were thinking, why you made the plays you did, etc
Josh: This is the first time i have ever tried this in MAFIA history, and nobody has done it Me: . . . Well, there is a reason to why no-one have ever tried it.
I mean... if Jenn hadn't said he was wrong, the mafia would have tried to kill Josh. Jenn could have saved Josh and that would let everyone know both Josh and Jenn were safe.
He made sense in a way on why he always picks her. Since he's very familiar with her habits, he will pick her first to see how she acts so that he can confirm if she civ or maf on that game
Cameron Gorr So that’ll include Niki, Steve, Antoine, Gina(was pretty good the past couple games) & Joe(been kinda rusty but he could still have it). The silent killers that just watch the civilians accuse each other; Sean, Julia, Tiff, idr the other names but yeah that’d be cool. Imo mafia does pretty well without Geo’s presence but Bart always flips the switch even if he’s innocent you know
@@lillyfrancis4706 u can Google it anytime bruh. There are loads of definitions of this word in the internet. Trust me buddy, I ain't lying, I saw it with mah own eyes
Josh should have done this move whilst Joe was playing as civ. Here's why. Out of everyone, Joe understands Josh's moves and way of thinking. Antoine understands the move he made but he was mafia. Josh got really unlucky that the guy who would actually listen to him was mafia, and the nurse didn't understand the move he was trying to pull. What mafia starts randomly with "this could duck up the game" or comes out as being nurse with the preface of outwardly saying he's trying to make a play? Josh for once actually played a good game imo. He just played that move in the wrong game with the people that don't know how he plays.
Yessssssssssssss it makes me so mad that no one understood what he was trying to do! And no one tried to sit back and try to understand why josh admited to bring a nurse!!! Not even people in the comments no shade lololololol
I think Wong Fu inst as experienced because she didn't understand what Josh was trying to do and they were saying in the deadbox that the cop should have came out early in the game, which experienced players would know is a bad move
yeah but this strategy would have NEVER worked, because you can't just throw in a bluff like that. Antoine tried it one time and also failed. first you need to be sure you KNOW who the nurse is, or whatever role you wanna use as bait. second you need to somehow COMMUNICATE to the nurse: "I'm about to do something, please don't jump on me, don't out yourself, just play along." You need to be sure the nurse is IN ON IT. and this is really really hard to pull off! jenn didn't know what he was doing, so she just outed herself as nurse for mafia to kill. it's not possible to just bluff like that and hope that everyone will automatically understand your move.
@@frozenwintershitty Thats what i'm saying. His bluff was so obvious that the nurse should have known what he was doing. Had he played this move with more people that understand his play style instead of just calling him a wildcard, this would have been a solid move. Josh didn't help things by clearly giving away who the real nurse is in the process. I can close to guarantee if Nikki and Antoine weren't mafia here, they would pick up on it. He just did it with the wrong people on his team.
Editors note is so true. I’ll defend Josh all day on this one. If it had worked out he’d be a mastermind and if not, which it didn’t, he’d be blamed for throwing. I think there’s a greater way to play this game than just playing your role. I believe this is a form of Game Theory. If you are 6v3 it would be better to be 5v3 rather than 4v3 in the next round, by this logic you have a greater chance of picking a mafia, and you’ll have the benefit of more information (Assuming everything goes right of course). So, was Josh right? Definitely not the right way to pull off the fake nurse card. However, I think there was good logic behind it. It also has to be mentioned that Josh is playing versus Nikki & Antoine, two of the best current players and his teammates are Jenn, Julia and Wes who are definitely not par (Though Julia is getting better).
This is all sound reasoning except when it comes down execution. Josh is the last person you want implementing this strategy based on his gameplay history. Believability is key and no one believes Josh in mafia.
@JB Yeah, she just goes 100% by emotion. You can tell at about the one hour mark, had to scrub ahead over that because it was so bad. She was dropping f-bombs at people, and telling others to shut up. She wasn't going by logic, she was going by emotion at that point.
@JB Julia is a good mafia with how easily she can win people's trust and play under the radar. But as a civilian, her deductive skills need a little work. She falls too easily to basic mafia manipulation and trusts too easily (hence, Nikki this game).
Cat Bat it was a Fourth of July one at Bart & Geo’s old house. I think they uploaded it on their vlog channel and maybe Joe did as well on his channel.
i kinda understand josh's decision there. since he was so unsure who to vote for he didnt want mafia to have 2 kills. he didnt vote and claimed nurse i feel he was tryna draw the attention to himself as nurse for mafia to kill him and have the nurse realise that and save him. but he didnt communicate that very well. jen also didnt pick up on it and instead accused him of lying and mafia caught on to that.
It's a 50/50 coin flip because Jen knowing he's not nurse came out and said something along the lines of yeah he's not the nurse and Julia even stated it and an Op player like Antoine and Nikki would of picked up on it and killed her anyway. But i digress.
@@ezequielgreen6663 yea agreed. like some1 already said, execution. josh is NOT the right person to make that kinda play. he didnt even set it up or even have it as a back up plan. he just randomly thought of it last minute. and tbh i dont think he actually thought it out as much as my comment did. his explaination at the end was just "i was sacrificing myself so the nurse would have more info" like what info? that hes civilian and now dead?. Nikki is too op tho she already won the game before the last round lol. Antoine aswell he knew he was fucked so he made josh look hella shady LOL.
I understand Josh's move, have done it myself before, but such only tends to work if you say it while holding eye contact with the actual nurse, to make the actual nurse hopefully understand what you're doing. Josh did it while knowing who the nurse was, but the execution and timing of it was just terrible. You don't just go "I'm the nurse" 3 or 4 times in a row, that will come over as "Please kill me instead". This is why I love this game, mind games for days.
yeah but this strategy would have NEVER worked, because you can't just throw in a bluff like that. Antoine tried it one time and also failed. first you need to be sure you KNOW who the nurse is, or whatever role you wanna use as bait. second you need to somehow COMMUNICATE to the nurse: "I'm about to do something, please don't jump on me, don't out yourself, just play along." and this is really really hard to pull off! jenn didn't know what he was doing, so she just outed herself as nurse for mafia to kill.
I disagree. First morning with no information priority should be kill Josh. He's going to fuck things up no matter what side he's on. Better safe than sorry.
For the people hating on Josh, he actually made sense and was logic, if they didn’t kill a mafia the round that Shawn got killed and nurse didn’t save any1, it would be game over. Fortunately for the town, but unfortunate for Josh, Shawn got killed and was revealed as a mafia. Josh’s play of coming out as nurse was a good play, if he was on the chopping block, which he wasn’t, and didn’t do it all smiley with 0 pokerface. He would’ve extended the towns life that way, but it was the wrong moment. Josh isn’t bad, just look at the previous game where the town was stuck and he came up with the idea to do a round of top 2 suspicions. Josh is just inconsistent like a mofo, hence a wild card.
this strategy would have never worked with josh executing it because you can't just throw in a bluff like that. first you need to be sure you KNOW who the nurse is, or whatever role you wanna use as bait. second you need to somehow COMMUNICATE to the nurse: "I'm about to do something, please don't jump on me, don't out yourself, just play along." and this is really really hard to pull off! it would've never worked.
The fact that people don't understand what Josh was trying to do towards the end....lol it's just that Jen accidentally thwarted that tactic and revealed herself before that night.
We understand what he was tryna do. We've seen it before. He was tryna sacrifice himself for nurse. But the fact that he was already fucc'n up the game earlier wasnt helping his play. For 2 rounds he didnt want to kill anyone but in the 1st round he was responsible for putting all 3 on the chopping block, yet not one of the 3 were mafia
When Nikki and Antoine are civilians, they would 100% try to fish out who the mafias are and be passionate about it, talk about so and so's strategy of their game/role. When they are unsure and say 'I don't know' and not really providing any kind of input, that's when you know they're mafia. Great game guys! I love it when Wongfu is on!
I know that's the worst part. If the nurse was like atoine or Nikki it would have worked out so much better because they both had the capacity to understand Josh's play.
Josh was actually making sense until the end. He kept pointing out the odds and was tryna stop them from killing Wes. If he didn't claim to be nurse or beef with Julia and voted with her it would have been a good game for him
what? Josh accused her first and went back and forth on it with no logic. She actually had good reason to accuse him because he did it first and was acting suspicious the whole time.
I'm down for the JKxWF cast and crew mafia! They could set the cameras up like they do on jknews so we can see everyone. Or have them all hold vlog cameras on themselves.
Or we could have an experimental 360 Mafia game, where we, as viewers, can rotate ourselves, so it's like we're at the center. The JKNews format would be cool too, but sometimes one person can't see the person on the other side, on JKNews, so if there were like 4+ cameras at everyone's eye level, they wouldn't be able to see each other, or their view would be partially obscured. Same problem with a large 360 camera. It would only work if they didn't use those large RED cameras, had cameras below eye level, or had overhead cameras, which I'm all for. But, ya know, their current setup is far simpler. Just have large couches, several cameras for different angles, JKCrew behind the camera panning and zooming, and the usual editing.
Yall remember a few years ago when Julia was always saying shes a bad civilian. Now here she is reading Antoine's game for filth. Julia has been getting better. Antoine is better as a civilian. Everytime he is mafia he plays the same way which is why he has been getting caught lately. Nikki is very intelligent. Every game she plays she just kills it it. Everyone does sleep on her.
she was the only one calling out Antoine the whole time wtf?? She also wasn't sure it was Josh. She said even if he's civilian she is targeting him because he was acting weird the whole time.
Nikki made a move she didn't need to make and risked losing the game. Then Josh saved her. Josh actually made some good points before claiming Nurse. It's nice to see him keep track of team numbers and calculate when Mafia will equal Non-Mafia. During the day you need to factor in what happens if town kills a civilian, because at Night Mafia are going to get another kill. They always say "Mafia get a free kill if we don't kill anyone", but if that's true then that means if town kills wrong person then Mafia gets 2 free kills. Sometimes it's better to not kill anyone and wait for more info. I think pretending to be Nurse like Josh can make sense in the right situation (like if you have been cleared by cop or saved by the nurse), but this definitely wasn't it. And even in the right situation it can be risky especially to outright claim it like Josh. If the Mafia believes you they might be hesitant to kill you since they might think you are baiting them and you're going to protect yourself so instead they try and kill someone else (which with few players left) could be the real nurse.
This was very good gameplay from josh probably one of his best games and here is why. 1. He made very sound choices and points in his explanations. 2. He made a similar wildcard stunt that paid off in an old video because joe was there to catch on and save him. 3. Had mafia taken the bait and he got saved he would’ve been the hero no doubt so you can’t try and say he was throwing. 4. Julia let her emotions blind her after he made the play and it failed. 5. He was up against arguably the two best mafia players in the group so they aren’t gonna bite but he doesn’t know they’re mafia, so you gotta shoot your shot sometimes. 6. My BIGGEST point is Josh has gotten good when he doesn’t tunnel Julia, but because of his history people just blow him off and laugh at him like he’s the court jester even when he is making sense or good points.
You would think Josh would have a basic understanding of how the game works given the amount of games he's been in. As a rule of thumb, he should always be voted off first. Even as a Civilian he always ends up helping the Mafia, that's why the Mafia keeps him alive every game.
They keep him alive because they know that he and julia can't help themselves and will eventually turn on eachother because they think they know each other's play.
OH MAN. Before coming in here I went and watched the Hidden Roles version's first round and I made my suspicions. I got the mademan and nurse SPOT ON!! (Sean and Jen) I thought Antoine was Cop and West was Mafia. Antoine still ended up being something so I'm stocked haha!
Josh surprised me with that nurse play , that's the first time I think I've ever seen him play the long game and strategize. With the right people, that shit coulda worked if he had a good nurse.
What Josh did was kind of smart. Because if mafia believed him then went after him nurse would have been saved but they aren't familiar with that tactic so the execution was poor.
Steve explaining exactly how it always goes 1:17:00. As soon as everyone decided Josh has to die. That's the end of the game. It happens every single time. Learn..just learn from previous games please
HOOLIA i love u and josh, but like if josh pointed u out as a mafia, doesn’t necessarily mean that josh is 100% mafia 🤗 das all. like im kinda annoyed how mafia gets a plus point every goddamn time both of em accusing each other out, but they both r jus civilians. mafia has always been my favorite, but i really wanna see u guys playing more salem with boze bart and steve! i think i always said this😂 love you all! ❤️🥳
Nikki is probably always one of the best players on JKParty! She either breaks things down to find the culprits, or to make everyone favor her (while she’s a culprit herself) in the game so that she wins. She’s really really good!
Josh actually did the town a favor by not voting off Wes, by calling himself out as nurse. But yah, it's hard when you're in their shoes to actually follow what the other person is doing. Wes is a really smart player. I don't know if Antoine is really lucky or what, but his guesses and kills were pretty much what got him to win. Someone also bring back the old crew, with the new ones. Like David and Byron. Y'all should have an ultimate Mafia game with all the best players. Which according to me includes Byron, Antoine, Julia, Nikki, Benson, Wes, Bart maybe. Think about it! This game was great, hats off to Bchoii and everyone behind the camera also. Love :)
Maybe it's just me, but when they say not killing on the block gives mafia a free kill, I feel that sometimes that's not necessarily true. If you don't have enough to go off of and feel like no one on it is suspicious enough, then don't vote them off. If anything, it buys them more time than they'd have if they would've gotten someone on the civilian team. But I'll admit it is awesome when people can get it off of a hunch, and some people are good at that, however, in the first chopping block there is nothing like that going on and maybe too early to start playing risky. Edit: JOSH YES JOSH GO
Josh's play actually makes sense if it was played right. He was sacrificing himself so that the nurse could survive but Antoine picked up Jenn's comment on Josh not being the nurse. Man he could have been the hero of the game if his tactic worked hahahaha
Yes, totally agree, but it was wrong timing on his part as well, because he wasn't on the chopping block being accused. Could have won it for the town if Jenn picked up on it and went on the d/l.
Yeah honestly if you go back to there very first Josh was extremely talented. But went down the hill honestly I think because of comments. And honestly on his channel that he really Doesn't like playing mafia. Just like tiff. Remember not everyone likes Mafia.
The most underrated part of mafia is bchoi being in the background just doing bchoi things.
Haha, he should start playing😂
He's the Three-Eyed Raven of Mafia.
Yeah, I enjoy the silly things he does during his "breaks" as moderator.
Bchoi is LOL dem looks 👀
Its true 😂
an hour and 20 mins of mafia but Benson solved it in 13 mins lol
The real G, omg I 😭😭
facts
Shame he died so soon
He did the same during wong fu play if the game lol
Poor Benson
Steve missing a writers meeting for mafia and then getting killed 😂😭💀
congrats to steve for giving his brown loafers a break 👞👞👍
Abi Tulabot he almost did hahaha. But Nikki shook her head but afterwards he started suspecting her and so that’s when she finally agreed to kill him off
trollin the troll lol
When you like roles hidden, but you also like deadbox banter.
I like when I know the roles
I want them to post the deadbox highlights as a separate video. That way we can watch it after roles hidden instead of rewatching the whole thing. 🤷🏼
@@hersheyqueen1015 if you run the mouse through the bottom of the video if you watch on a computer you can see the deadbox scenes in the preview that pops up
@@xintheshower I watch on mobile not pc.
HersheyQueen u can still see by dragging the red dot
Too bad Joe wasn't playing, he would've totally flipped seeing how Josh played.
He would've probably gotten a prop knife and "killed" himself 😂🤦
Joe wouldve exploded in anger
he'd probs flip the sofa josh was on
I agree ahaha
I think even if Josh didn't call out as nurse, Jen still wouldve been next just because of him being a wildcard. Mafia will always want Josh close to the end.
Josh is always surprising me by finding new ways to lose the game😂
He’s so fucking bad like take him out. How can you play mafia that much and still have no idea what you’re talking about
They bring him in because he makes the game more interesting. Without him mafias would be nonexistent in this channel
Views would suck. And then all the fans complain because it not played anymore.
he likes to hear his own voice
i want what hes smoking
Josh is the heart and soul of JK party plus he’s a savage and unpredictable tactics never hurt
I want revenge.
Benson you called it as soon as you died
bensonq ur the real MVP. You literally solved it in 13 minutes!
man us too! We want a rematch 😂
yes please
Yes!! One more game
If Mafia fell for Josh’s bait and Jenn picked up on what he was doing and saved him, Josh’s plan would have been the greatest play I’ve ever seen in Mafia
DiodGaming period
@diodgaming totally agree!!! Too bad his execution for the play wasn’t convincing. I don’t think mafia especially Nikki and Antoinne would have killed him off even with Jenn understanding his move
Yea if mafia fell for it and jenn saved him to waste their kill and keep town alive wouldve been the sickest play in mafia history
Great idea. Poor execution 😅
But it didnt
Mafia Spoilers below (don’t read unless you’ve watched)
Nikki is OP, please nerf.
The reason Nikki is MVP here and every game is because she has the ability to gain trust from other players, a skillset I’ve lost because I’ve burned so many people. Nikki carried Mafia this game, and not because of any ONE big play, but several very small and nuanced ones. She da real one. Ya’ll better recognize.
Nikki needs a nerf
Nikki really did carry the game, but it was pretty obvious that she was Mafia, since she was pointing fingers like nobody's business. You were more subtle, in my opinion. Really though, Hoolia almost KILLED the game, in a good way, when she pointed out you and Sean.
Look at the poll in Roles Hidden. She has the least amount of votes.
Antoine you need an Oscar fr
Also, I really like your comments after Mafia games. I think it would be really cool if you guys did a commentary video where some of you talk over an old game and explain what you were thinking, why you made the plays you did, etc
If Josh/Julia accuse Josh/Julia everytime they're bound to be right at least once right?!
Probably😂😂😂
Nikki: Statically yes
😂😂
You ever read the boy who cried wolf lol?
The Josh that cried Julia!
@@isellnudes1233 LOL
WTF BENSON LMAOO HES SO GOOD
Also hot lol
IKR
Give a round of a applause for Nikki and Antoine.
They kill as civilians.
They kill as Mafia.
Yeah I agree
Rule no.1: kill Josh first. Rule no.2: when in doubt, refer to rule no. 1
😂😂😂
Dislike
@@niharikajaisudan ok😂
But guys where is the fun in that? 😂😂
If josh gets killed first every time, mafia wouldn't be as exciting to watch on JKparty. We need Joe back if Josh dies every game.
Josh: This is the first time i have ever tried this in MAFIA history, and nobody has done it
Me: . . . Well, there is a reason to why no-one have ever tried it.
Actually antoine has done it before it didnt work either
@@fosho331 haha
Ikr😂
Actually, Timothy did kind of do it when he first played with them, but when he tried again for another game, it worked against him.
I mean... if Jenn hadn't said he was wrong, the mafia would have tried to kill Josh. Jenn could have saved Josh and that would let everyone know both Josh and Jenn were safe.
Josh "usually I wouldn't suspect Julia at all"
Also Josh in the beginning "I think it's Julia"
LMAO what?
He made sense in a way on why he always picks her. Since he's very familiar with her habits, he will pick her first to see how she acts so that he can confirm if she civ or maf on that game
@@RalphelValentine
Lol yeah but he's wrong a lot of the times though 😂
@@EsmisAmazing because he also lets others sway his opinion and he doubts himself
@@RalphelValentine familiar with her habits yet he's wrong every time and flip flops the whole game?
They should make a Mafia Allstar where the fans get to vote for the best Mafia Players to play against each other
yes please. without josh!!
Cameron Gorr So that’ll include Niki, Steve, Antoine, Gina(was pretty good the past couple games) & Joe(been kinda rusty but he could still have it). The silent killers that just watch the civilians accuse each other; Sean, Julia, Tiff, idr the other names but yeah that’d be cool. Imo mafia does pretty well without Geo’s presence but Bart always flips the switch even if he’s innocent you know
Hayinas M I love Julia and steve but they arent all stars, and sean isnt all stars either
@@jamesp9893 what!?! NO! Josh MAKES mafia. It's never as interesting/funny without him and Joe. Josh is definitely an all star
Kat Shik josh ruins mafia get the fuck out of here
Ahh perfect timing. I just gave up on studying.
if this ain't the definition of reletable idk what is
@@lillyfrancis4706 u can Google it anytime bruh. There are loads of definitions of this word in the internet. Trust me buddy, I ain't lying, I saw it with mah own eyes
sean’s body language really screams “i am mafia, indeed!!! i am GUILTY!”😂
Ikr😂
Josh should have done this move whilst Joe was playing as civ. Here's why.
Out of everyone, Joe understands Josh's moves and way of thinking. Antoine understands the move he made but he was mafia. Josh got really unlucky that the guy who would actually listen to him was mafia, and the nurse didn't understand the move he was trying to pull.
What mafia starts randomly with "this could duck up the game" or comes out as being nurse with the preface of outwardly saying he's trying to make a play?
Josh for once actually played a good game imo. He just played that move in the wrong game with the people that don't know how he plays.
Exactly. I said in previous post. Good idea bad judgment.
Yessssssssssssss it makes me so mad that no one understood what he was trying to do! And no one tried to sit back and try to understand why josh admited to bring a nurse!!! Not even people in the comments no shade lololololol
I think Wong Fu inst as experienced because she didn't understand what Josh was trying to do and they were saying in the deadbox that the cop should have came out early in the game, which experienced players would know is a bad move
yeah but this strategy would have NEVER worked, because you can't just throw in a bluff like that. Antoine tried it one time and also failed.
first you need to be sure you KNOW who the nurse is, or whatever role you wanna use as bait. second you need to somehow COMMUNICATE to the nurse: "I'm about to do something, please don't jump on me, don't out yourself, just play along." You need to be sure the nurse is IN ON IT. and this is really really hard to pull off! jenn didn't know what he was doing, so she just outed herself as nurse for mafia to kill.
it's not possible to just bluff like that and hope that everyone will automatically understand your move.
@@frozenwintershitty Thats what i'm saying. His bluff was so obvious that the nurse should have known what he was doing. Had he played this move with more people that understand his play style instead of just calling him a wildcard, this would have been a solid move. Josh didn't help things by clearly giving away who the real nurse is in the process. I can close to guarantee if Nikki and Antoine weren't mafia here, they would pick up on it. He just did it with the wrong people on his team.
Editors note is so true. I’ll defend Josh all day on this one. If it had worked out he’d be a mastermind and if not, which it didn’t, he’d be blamed for throwing.
I think there’s a greater way to play this game than just playing your role.
I believe this is a form of Game Theory. If you are 6v3 it would be better to be 5v3 rather than 4v3 in the next round, by this logic you have a greater chance of picking a mafia, and you’ll have the benefit of more information (Assuming everything goes right of course).
So, was Josh right? Definitely not the right way to pull off the fake nurse card. However, I think there was good logic behind it.
It also has to be mentioned that Josh is playing versus Nikki & Antoine, two of the best current players and his teammates are Jenn, Julia and Wes who are definitely not par (Though Julia is getting better).
I can't believe I just read all of this, but very true
This is all sound reasoning except when it comes down execution. Josh is the last person you want implementing this strategy based on his gameplay history. Believability is key and no one believes Josh in mafia.
@JB Yeah, she just goes 100% by emotion. You can tell at about the one hour mark, had to scrub ahead over that because it was so bad. She was dropping f-bombs at people, and telling others to shut up. She wasn't going by logic, she was going by emotion at that point.
@JB Julia is a good mafia with how easily she can win people's trust and play under the radar. But as a civilian, her deductive skills need a little work. She falls too easily to basic mafia manipulation and trusts too easily (hence, Nikki this game).
nah because he's such an obvious bait. mafia isn't that stupid
josh leading the conversation but always in the wrong direction. he is such a wildcard
Not a wildcard. He’s just bad
I wonder if he does it to stay in the game longer LOLLLL
I agree
Jen’s looking pretty cute this vid. The dude figured out 2/3 of the mafia at the beginning lol.
werd jen looking sexy
@@bobbychase5616 dat y she in the thumbnail
yeah that was Benson btw
Didn't he also guess right on cop? Nikki and Antoine disputed over who to kill, but I think Antoine made the right call.
She got legs for days
We NEED that 40 player mafia game!!!
Itd be so chaotic
I need a 100 ppl mafia game. I want a yakoza in the mix with the FBI.
I think there is one but on one of their vlog channels. Sorry I don't remember who this was probably 2 years ago
7 hour long video
Cat Bat it was a Fourth of July one at Bart & Geo’s old house. I think they uploaded it on their vlog channel and maybe Joe did as well on his channel.
i kinda understand josh's decision there. since he was so unsure who to vote for he didnt want mafia to have 2 kills. he didnt vote and claimed nurse i feel he was tryna draw the attention to himself as nurse for mafia to kill him and have the nurse realise that and save him. but he didnt communicate that very well. jen also didnt pick up on it and instead accused him of lying and mafia caught on to that.
Exactly. Julia was being a jerk about it too. But if they actually paid attention to what he was trying to accomplish it could’ve worked
@@711wild The fault here is execution. Coming from Nikki or Steve or Joe it couldve worked. Coming from Josh... yeah... we know how that's gonna end.
It's a 50/50 coin flip because Jen knowing he's not nurse came out and said something along the lines of yeah he's not the nurse and Julia even stated it and an Op player like Antoine and Nikki would of picked up on it and killed her anyway. But i digress.
@@ezequielgreen6663 yea agreed. like some1 already said, execution. josh is NOT the right person to make that kinda play. he didnt even set it up or even have it as a back up plan. he just randomly thought of it last minute. and tbh i dont think he actually thought it out as much as my comment did. his explaination at the end was just "i was sacrificing myself so the nurse would have more info" like what info? that hes civilian and now dead?. Nikki is too op tho she already won the game before the last round lol. Antoine aswell he knew he was fucked so he made josh look hella shady LOL.
I understand Josh's move, have done it myself before, but such only tends to work if you say it while holding eye contact with the actual nurse, to make the actual nurse hopefully understand what you're doing.
Josh did it while knowing who the nurse was, but the execution and timing of it was just terrible.
You don't just go "I'm the nurse" 3 or 4 times in a row, that will come over as "Please kill me instead".
This is why I love this game, mind games for days.
Oh y'all did not just surprise us with a Mafia video!! Legends.
I love the daily uploads
1:07:43 At least Antoine understood. Too bad he wasn't on Josh's team.
yeah but this strategy would have NEVER worked, because you can't just throw in a bluff like that. Antoine tried it one time and also failed.
first you need to be sure you KNOW who the nurse is, or whatever role you wanna use as bait. second you need to somehow COMMUNICATE to the nurse: "I'm about to do something, please don't jump on me, don't out yourself, just play along." and this is really really hard to pull off! jenn didn't know what he was doing, so she just outed herself as nurse for mafia to kill.
Always kill Nikki. She is beast mode 100% of the time.
I disagree. First morning with no information priority should be kill Josh. He's going to fuck things up no matter what side he's on. Better safe than sorry.
Nope, kill Josh. No wildcard.
@@bate_0o7 why would mafia kill josh?? He's the perfect scape goat if shit hits the fan and also easily swayable
Honestly thank you Brandon and Julia for uploading daily, I really do love these videos 🥺❤️❤️
Me too💕
Yaaaassss... Nikki and Antoine as mafia together... Two of the best.. !! 😍
They are so good at lying. I know they are mafia, buy still can't beleive it
@@Fourtune1 Yeah, Nikki is the best at mafia, MVP😂
Without josh this video wouldn’t be half as entertaining I love this guy 😂😂
Benson: “Ahh this is nice”
*while in the deadbox and guesses 2/3 mafia
For the people hating on Josh, he actually made sense and was logic, if they didn’t kill a mafia the round that Shawn got killed and nurse didn’t save any1, it would be game over. Fortunately for the town, but unfortunate for Josh, Shawn got killed and was revealed as a mafia.
Josh’s play of coming out as nurse was a good play, if he was on the chopping block, which he wasn’t, and didn’t do it all smiley with 0 pokerface. He would’ve extended the towns life that way, but it was the wrong moment.
Josh isn’t bad, just look at the previous game where the town was stuck and he came up with the idea to do a round of top 2 suspicions. Josh is just inconsistent like a mofo, hence a wild card.
Fr, if he went about it the right way they could've won. He deserves so much more credit for his thinking,
dang when julia kinda called out both sean and antoine im smiling ear to ear “go get em gurl!!!”👏✊🥳
Julia: I think it's Sean and Antoine🤔
Me: How did you know?!?!😫😂
Josh was definitely the MVP of the game, nice giving it to the mafia. 👏👏👏👏
토리조 to be fair they would have won anyway
What if Josh was a sleeper Mafia along and we/himself never knew.
😂😂 Joke
It would have been great play if it worked, it didnt work cuz everybody else were so stupid
@@partyboysify I agree with you. The way he did the play was wrong. Maybe a bit earlier and less panicky
Mafia : Kills best player and leave the weakest ones to fight among themselves.
Nikki and Antoine are on another level
nilkki and antoine on the same team again ? well we all know how this end .
Nobody : ...
Mafia Member : Yo should we kill Josh?
Everyone : LET'S DO IT!! *Raises hands like there's no tomorrow*
Haha😂
Josh made a really GOOD move, in a very BAD way!
Antoine MVP!!!
That was actually a next level move by Josh, just poorly executed. They same move can be done with the cop.
When I thoguht about it Josh play were really good. But the play was too many steps ahead so nobody have ever thought about it sadly enough. Wp Josh
R.I.P Josh
Righggghhtttt I feel so bad for josh! If his plan worked he wouldve been a hero period!!!!
this strategy would have never worked with josh executing it because you can't just throw in a bluff like that. first you need to be sure you KNOW who the nurse is, or whatever role you wanna use as bait. second you need to somehow COMMUNICATE to the nurse: "I'm about to do something, please don't jump on me, don't out yourself, just play along." and this is really really hard to pull off! it would've never worked.
Benson is the unknown mafia king. He figured that shit out real quick
The fact that people don't understand what Josh was trying to do towards the end....lol it's just that Jen accidentally thwarted that tactic and revealed herself before that night.
We understand what he was tryna do. We've seen it before. He was tryna sacrifice himself for nurse. But the fact that he was already fucc'n up the game earlier wasnt helping his play. For 2 rounds he didnt want to kill anyone but in the 1st round he was responsible for putting all 3 on the chopping block, yet not one of the 3 were mafia
Nikki is the best mafia player I have ever seen!!!! what a GOAT
She's too good
I want a game with Nikki, Steve, Antoine, joe, geo and Bart.
Julia and tiff got better so them too.
When Nikki and Antoine are civilians, they would 100% try to fish out who the mafias are and be passionate about it, talk about so and so's strategy of their game/role. When they are unsure and say 'I don't know' and not really providing any kind of input, that's when you know they're mafia. Great game guys! I love it when Wongfu is on!
All of you bagging on Josh but he took a risk and it was actually really smart had it worked.
Agreed.
@S Mac agreed! Too bad he didn’t execute the play properly and his body language showed he was lying :/ otherwise would have been a great move
Josh would've been the MVP if that tactic went according to plan LOOL
If Josh's bait was successful. They wouldn't have blamed him
I know that's the worst part. If the nurse was like atoine or Nikki it would have worked out so much better because they both had the capacity to understand Josh's play.
Josh has very valid points on this game
RIGHT
Thank you Julia & Brandon for these amazingly entertaining and constant production of JKP videos!
Josh was actually making sense until the end. He kept pointing out the odds and was tryna stop them from killing Wes. If he didn't claim to be nurse or beef with Julia and voted with her it would have been a good game for him
We need another Mafia but Benson needs to live. I feel like he'd add so much to the game.
That joyous Mafia celebration between Nikki, Antoine and Sean at the end was so wholesome 😂
Every time Julia gets stuck on convicting josh she throws away logic
what? Josh accused her first and went back and forth on it with no logic. She actually had good reason to accuse him because he did it first and was acting suspicious the whole time.
I'm down for the JKxWF cast and crew mafia!
They could set the cameras up like they do on jknews so we can see everyone. Or have them all hold vlog cameras on themselves.
Or we could have an experimental 360 Mafia game, where we, as viewers, can rotate ourselves, so it's like we're at the center. The JKNews format would be cool too, but sometimes one person can't see the person on the other side, on JKNews, so if there were like 4+ cameras at everyone's eye level, they wouldn't be able to see each other, or their view would be partially obscured. Same problem with a large 360 camera. It would only work if they didn't use those large RED cameras, had cameras below eye level, or had overhead cameras, which I'm all for. But, ya know, their current setup is far simpler. Just have large couches, several cameras for different angles, JKCrew behind the camera panning and zooming, and the usual editing.
Damn I wish Benson got to play cos he was picked up on Mafia fast
Yall remember a few years ago when Julia was always saying shes a bad civilian. Now here she is reading Antoine's game for filth. Julia has been getting better.
Antoine is better as a civilian. Everytime he is mafia he plays the same way which is why he has been getting caught lately.
Nikki is very intelligent. Every game she plays she just kills it it. Everyone does sleep on her.
I knoww bro I'm so proud of of juliaaa she made all the right calls
Except for Nikki she's a beast
Then she goes and votes out Josh
Antoine’s strategy might not be the best but he’s a SUPER good actor
The fact that Julia said she knew it after being so sure josh was mafia genuinely grinds my gears
Precise M8 she said she knew it for Antoine only. She has been suspecting him for a long time
she was the only one calling out Antoine the whole time wtf?? She also wasn't sure it was Josh. She said even if he's civilian she is targeting him because he was acting weird the whole time.
Nikki made a move she didn't need to make and risked losing the game. Then Josh saved her.
Josh actually made some good points before claiming Nurse. It's nice to see him keep track of team numbers and calculate when Mafia will equal Non-Mafia. During the day you need to factor in what happens if town kills a civilian, because at Night Mafia are going to get another kill. They always say "Mafia get a free kill if we don't kill anyone", but if that's true then that means if town kills wrong person then Mafia gets 2 free kills. Sometimes it's better to not kill anyone and wait for more info.
I think pretending to be Nurse like Josh can make sense in the right situation (like if you have been cleared by cop or saved by the nurse), but this definitely wasn't it. And even in the right situation it can be risky especially to outright claim it like Josh. If the Mafia believes you they might be hesitant to kill you since they might think you are baiting them and you're going to protect yourself so instead they try and kill someone else (which with few players left) could be the real nurse.
The conversations after the game ended was GOLD
Yes. I was one of those that would get irritated when julia just ends the shoot immediately after end of game lol
Josh's "I'm the nurse." might just replace the iconic "We're at the beach." LOL
benson has HELLA good intuition! and only in a short time too dang. play more with him pls🥳
That is how it was with Julia's bf Nelson.
It’s so obvious when antoine is civilian he pushes people HARD to find mafia but when he’s mafia he eases up
Lmao josh just lives to frustrate julia.. Like shes out here trying to make plays but he just always denies her 😂
Lol you have Steve yelling at Josh towards the end like WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING than Taylor quietly gives Wes a hug
The dynamics are so different
Brandon in the background just swinging away 20:14
Haha, that's so funny😂
This was very good gameplay from josh probably one of his best games and here is why.
1. He made very sound choices and points in his explanations.
2. He made a similar wildcard stunt that paid off in an old video because joe was there to catch on and save him.
3. Had mafia taken the bait and he got saved he would’ve been the hero no doubt so you can’t try and say he was throwing.
4. Julia let her emotions blind her after he made the play and it failed.
5. He was up against arguably the two best mafia players in the group so they aren’t gonna bite but he doesn’t know they’re mafia, so you gotta shoot your shot sometimes.
6. My BIGGEST point is Josh has gotten good when he doesn’t tunnel Julia, but because of his history people just blow him off and laugh at him like he’s the court jester even when he is making sense or good points.
But the biggest blunder of them all which is how they were able to not take the bait was Jen saying anything about Josh not being nurse
An hour and 20 minutes of mafia.. Had a feeling mafia would be uploaded but I've been blessed with this much gameplay!
Josh's play was amazing. Everyone else just couldn't understand it, except for Antoine who always bases his opinions on logic.
You would think Josh would have a basic understanding of how the game works given the amount of games he's been in.
As a rule of thumb, he should always be voted off first. Even as a Civilian he always ends up helping the Mafia, that's why the Mafia keeps him alive every game.
facts
I’d argue there is actual logic behind Josh’s seemingly crazy shenanigans.
Josh just lacks the greater skill of conviction and speech.
But that's no fun
They keep him alive because they know that he and julia can't help themselves and will eventually turn on eachother because they think they know each other's play.
Julia: *loses the game, makes incorrect reads, kills Josh*
Julia after the game: "I FUCKING KNEW IT I KNEW IT" ??
*SEAN MADE THE BIGGEST MVP MOVE BY CONVERTING NIKKI*
He'd be dumb if he didnt convert her.
Antoine is the new joe in mafia seriously his acting skills as a mafia are awesome and his suspiscions as a town member are so freakin' ACCURATE!
OH MAN. Before coming in here I went and watched the Hidden Roles version's first round and I made my suspicions.
I got the mademan and nurse SPOT ON!! (Sean and Jen) I thought Antoine was Cop and West was Mafia. Antoine still ended up being something so I'm stocked haha!
And the MVP goes to Josh, for throwing the fucking game. Come on man
You guys should do a game where everyone is civilian but no one knows it... And the moderator can kill someone themselves every night.
That’s stupid
thats genius !
Add a nurse and a cop to confuse them even more
Being the moderator would be so fun...
Yes and too comment below how would that be stupid.
Josh surprised me with that nurse play , that's the first time I think I've ever seen him play the long game and strategize. With the right people, that shit coulda worked if he had a good nurse.
What Josh did was kind of smart. Because if mafia believed him then went after him nurse would have been saved but they aren't familiar with that tactic so the execution was poor.
Good idea bad execution.
This game of mafia legit made my day thank you guys❤️❤️
no one should ever underestimate Niki, she's the ultimate player for sure!
Definitely the MVP
Y'all are just surprising me with a Mafia Video out of the blue and its 1 and a half hours long!!!
I love you so much ❤
Steve explaining exactly how it always goes 1:17:00. As soon as everyone decided Josh has to die. That's the end of the game. It happens every single time. Learn..just learn from previous games please
love how the camera turns to the crew face palming to Josh talking 😂😂😂
Josh is always the wildcard. I love it because it makes it so fun to watch 😂
Also Sean was VERY smart to convert Nikki to the Mafia, she's a logical calculating player that you need on that side.
ABSOLUTELY NOBODY:
JOSH: I'M NURSE
LMFAO, this meme was made for Josh
I died of laughter when Antoine said “I feel like we have a mafia on the chopping block”
HOOLIA i love u and josh, but like if josh pointed u out as a mafia, doesn’t necessarily mean that josh is 100% mafia 🤗 das all. like im kinda annoyed how mafia gets a plus point every goddamn time both of em accusing each other out, but they both r jus civilians. mafia has always been my favorite, but i really wanna see u guys playing more salem with boze bart and steve! i think i always said this😂 love you all! ❤️🥳
I would’ve killed Josh anyway for the shit he pulled hahahaha
@@lalalinduhh Josh is the ultimate troll even when he isn't trying to be lol
Julia never accused him until he did the nurse move even though he was accusing her the whole game for no reason.
I was laughing a cheering so much during this video that my wife screamed me a rough "shut up".. loved it
Civi's always lose because of josh and julia
Julia is good literally it’s just josh
I'm tired of those 2 accusing each other off nun. It should be a rule to ignore them anytime they choose each other
I can understand Julia's frustration though lol
I feel like it's just Josh because he's always the one that starts the accusations and it always fucks up the game
Best Mafia moments of all time:
- Josh claiming to be nurse throwing everyone off
- Nelson as vigilante
Antoine lookin like a whole snack
Nikki is probably always one of the best players on JKParty! She either breaks things down to find the culprits, or to make everyone favor her (while she’s a culprit herself) in the game so that she wins. She’s really really good!
That has backfired on her before though.
More wong fu collabs !!!! Its cool to see Josh's other Family lol
Yassss
Josh actually did the town a favor by not voting off Wes, by calling himself out as nurse. But yah, it's hard when you're in their shoes to actually follow what the other person is doing. Wes is a really smart player. I don't know if Antoine is really lucky or what, but his guesses and kills were pretty much what got him to win. Someone also bring back the old crew, with the new ones. Like David and Byron. Y'all should have an ultimate Mafia game with all the best players. Which according to me includes Byron, Antoine, Julia, Nikki, Benson, Wes, Bart maybe. Think about it! This game was great, hats off to Bchoii and everyone behind the camera also. Love :)
Benson is so freaking smart! I wish they didn't kill him so fast
This was hella exciting! Great job guys!
Maybe it's just me, but when they say not killing on the block gives mafia a free kill, I feel that sometimes that's not necessarily true. If you don't have enough to go off of and feel like no one on it is suspicious enough, then don't vote them off. If anything, it buys them more time than they'd have if they would've gotten someone on the civilian team.
But I'll admit it is awesome when people can get it off of a hunch, and some people are good at that, however, in the first chopping block there is nothing like that going on and maybe too early to start playing risky.
Edit: JOSH YES JOSH GO
Josh's play actually makes sense if it was played right. He was sacrificing himself so that the nurse could survive but Antoine picked up Jenn's comment on Josh not being the nurse. Man he could have been the hero of the game if his tactic worked hahahaha
Yes, totally agree, but it was wrong timing on his part as well, because he wasn't on the chopping block being accused. Could have won it for the town if Jenn picked up on it and went on the d/l.
I have actually made Josh plays before but they work out. I just think no one trusts Josh.
Yeah honestly if you go back to there very first Josh was extremely talented. But went down the hill honestly I think because of comments. And honestly on his channel that he really Doesn't like playing mafia. Just like tiff. Remember not everyone likes Mafia.
1:16:26 i love how loud and wild the jk news casts are while you just see these two wong fu casts calm and hugging each other LMAO