Maulana ishaq also said triple talaq said in one setting is counted as one! But because of the misleading information on the topic many women are sitting in their homes and suffering sadly
I can see why Muslims, especially Muslim women who don't study Qur'an, are confused. We should just obey Allah 1st by studying the actual Revelation (Qur'an) Then, when we read others' thoughts, opinions, and commentaries - no matter who they are- we'll have the True Guidance to compare it to. One Allah, one last Prophet, one Divine Revelation = peace and a beautiful - the life of the Sincere Believers. Alhamdulillah! As Salaamu Alaikum.
@@FatimaHf-t3m batain kitabon ki and reality 100% difference Talaq salasa ke masla peh ahl hadees Quran o Sunnah se hazaroon mile door IBN tammiyaah r.a ko follow kerte he This is fact
This is why women have to study the Quran (Allah's Guidance not man's) on their own. Men who do this 3 times in one breath, are simply throwing a tantrum and need to sit down if they're standing or lie down, if they're sitting. There's a 3 month waiting period and Allah says divorced women are to be provided for in Surah 2, verse 241. Men who fear Allah will obey Allah first and foremost. But, women, if you don't study and learn what Allah says, you will continue to be mistreated and misled.
Yeah you are true brother proves 3 mean 3 but if someone gives 3 talaq in one breath how would you fit ruju in that case....we need to focus on whole topic where it clearly explain after 2 talaq you can do ruju...how can someone do ruju in one breath ... please can someone explain....And if looking at logical basis providing some time husband can regret what he has done in anger...
@@fais2021 1) he was angry thats HIS problem. Non muslims ALSO get angry they do not have the word talaq to say. Muslims get angry and STILL they don’t say the word talaq. In both cases they use swear words so the man that did say talaq has NO excuse. 2) Allah has defined the process of talaq which includes iddah. He commanded men to break a nikah with one talaq. When a man OPTS to not follow Allahs commands *ALLAH DOES NOT BEND THE RULES TO SUIT HIM* exactly the same was as the courts do not bend the rules. Therefore by default, three talaqs are three, exactly in accordance with mathematics. Anyone that lives together after three talaqs are committing zina, and any child born will be haram. And haram children do not get their fathers name nor do they get his inheritance
@@razamughal9095 As Salaam Alaikum. There is no place in Quran that justifies depriving children of care and support because of the sins of the parents. It seems as if you're saying because a man commits fornication or adultery and fathers a child, Allah excuses the man and woman by punishing the child by depriving the child of support and care? Do you teach, also, that the man and woman shouldn't get 100 lashes? Or are you saying that only the woman and child are punished when a man and woman commit zina?
@@emeraldstarr4643 you are being confused somewhere. Three talaqs is THREE. A divorce has NEVER caused a loss to the child. A childs relationship with their parents is not dependent on them being married. Every person has an exclusive relationship with another person, be that your father or be that four wives. *The father will continue paying for the child and the child will sleep in his fathers house and his mothers house* and he will grow up happy and healthy. When it comes to zina, the fornicator does NOT get the child. He does not inherit from the child if the child dies first and the child does not inherit from him. He is deprived from giving the child his name, which would have otherwise been a cause for respect. The child inherits from his mother and his mother inherits from him. And he takes his mothers name. A child, particularly a son is an asset , and the fornicator is deprived of this asset . That does not mean that the child would not grow up happy. In this day and age people ignore islam and he would still be in contact with his biological father.
Sahih Muslim 1472 a Ibn 'Abbas (Allah be pleased with them) reported that the (pronouncement) of three divorces during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and that of Abu Bakr and two years of the caliphate of Umar (Allah be pleased with him) (was treated) as one. But Umar b. Khattab (Allah be pleased with him) said: Verily the people have begun to hasten in the matter in which they are required to observe respite. So if we had imposed this upon them, and he imposed it upon them.
Aajkal log urdu translate padhke mufti ban gaye hai wo ye bhi check karne ke lyak nhi hai ki jo translate wo padh rahe hai uska wo mtlb hoga bhi nhi Hadees ne mashoor 4 zamane ka zikr kiya charo zamane me log 1 hi kaam kar rahe the magar ye kah rahe hai hazrat umar r.a ne dekha ki jis kaam me logo ko sahulat di gayi thi us kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhane lage magar kis kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhayi ye pure sentence me samajh me nhi aa raha hai Ye jis kaam ki zikr kar rahe hai wo to charo zamane me ho rahi hai or agar ye maan li jaye ki hazrat umar r.a ke zamane me ye kaam bahut hone lagi thi to problem kya hai jab 1 majlis me 3 talaq ko sumar 1 hi hoti hai to mtlb kaam to 1 hi hua Jab sumar 1 hi hona hai to fhir sahulat bhi baqi hai or shariyat ka mazaq bhi nhi bana
@@razamughal4582you may disagree but not shout degree degree degree ... most muftis are staunch spokesperson of their sect and all of them reject each other
Thank you for your explanation. The question is whether Muslims should follow the Quran and Hadith or the thoughts of schools? Whatever Umar and other Sahabas are human. They changed the Talad fatwas. As you said Muahmmad S.A.V and Abu Bakr said trippe talaqa in one sitting is counted as one talaq. So. If Muhammad S.A.V said like this. Why Muslims follow Umar's fatwa?
Agree because even in Al - Qur'an Allah never said you can divorced your wife three times in one talaq, as we know woman are really protecting in islam. In umar time if a woman get talaq three times in one sit, umar will take care of those woman that were left by theirr husband.
do you take cheap drugs?? USE COMMON SENSE. there is NO WAY ON EARTH hazrat Umar could change the shariya and there is no way on earth that the sahaba would have ALLOWED HIM TO CHANGE THE SHARIYA. jahalat se bahir niklo. Dr naik is totally wrong aur aurat ko rakhel banaty banaty mar jayga. the fact that Hazrat Umar gave capital punishment to those that gave three talaqs is PROOF that three talaqs *took effect*. it is PROOF that the Prophet saw, and ALL FOUR caliphs ACCEPTED that three talaqs is three. The fact that there is NO fatwa from hazrat Uthman and hazrat Ali is PROOF that they agreed with hazrat Umar. sari zindagi jahil na raho. CLEARLY you have no idea what madhab is or who the four imams were.
Umar (R.A.)'s fatwa was made in anger; that's why we should always follow the words of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) if the words of the Sahabah go against the words of the Prophet, but in most Muslim countries, three talaqs are counted as three talaqs. This means women need to understand their religion and include talaq e hasan in their marriage contract. Then, men will not be able to divorce them three times at once, both Islamicly and legally.
Understand this. It's not the religion that teaches what comes across as hurtful and disrespectful to women. But there are people who, they themselves lack proper regard for women, who do these things. And women don't study as they should, so they allow themselves to be mistreated and disrespected, then blame others. This goes on in all religions, if you're honest about it. Women are treated as Jezibel in the Bible. Eve is blamed for Adam's weakness, etc.
Sir in pakistan after divorce only once it is refer to the family court automaticaly now n within two to three month certifact issued by family court of this talaq .which is considered ful n final .give ur opinion abt this issue
Which type of divorce paper? There are three types of divorce in Muslim countries. If he sends the divorce papers of talaq e bidah, then according to law and the majority of Muslim scholars, he cannot do anything unless he was not conscious or the divorce papers were not sent by him and someone took his signature by fraud. However, if he sends different types of divorce papers, then there is a waiting period for ruzu (iddah). If that passes and only one divorce has taken place, then he can remarry her with a new mehr.
Then what about this hadith? Mishkat al-Masabih 3293 Malik told of hearing that a man said to ‘Abdallah b. ‘Abbas, “I have divorced my wife, uttering the divorce a hundred times, so what do you think I have made myself liable for?” Ibn ‘Abbas replied, “She was divorced from you by three utterances, and by ninety-seven you have made a mockery of God’s verses.” He transmitted it in al- Muwatta’. وَعَن مَالك بلغه رَجُلًا قَالَ لِعَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَبَّاسٍ: إِنِّي طَلَّقْتُ امْرَأَتِي مِائَةَ تَطْلِيقَةٍ فَمَاذَا تَرَى عَلَيَّ؟ فَقَالَ ابْن عَبَّاس: طلقت مِنْك ثَلَاث وَسَبْعٌ وَتِسْعُونَ اتَّخَذْتَ بِهَا آيَاتِ اللَّهِ هُزُوًا. رَوَاهُ فِي الْمُوَطَّأ [Classified as hasan]
In this hadith Malik says "he heard" that Ibn e Abbas said so, he didn't give any references that who told him or who reported that hadith, on the other hand the Hadith of sahi Muslim about Ibn e abbas considering 3 talaq as one is mentioned with proper reference.
@@ameerabdullahtiwana ok now you tell where hazrat IBN Abbas uses word "one majlis" Aur is hadees main aik zamane ka zikar he yeah kaha likha ke Rasool Allah teen ko samjhhte thay ya hazrat Abu bakar Sadiq teen ko aik samajhte thay??? Aur Kon si teen talaq ko aik samjha jata tha 1. Aik majlis ki? 2. Teen majlis ki? 3. Aik kalma ki ?? Ya 4. Ghair madkhola ki?? IBN Abbas ki hadees main in main se kis talaq zikar he dhoond ke deekhao??
@@Onlymuslimworld @No.1-leader مسلم شریف کی حدیث نمبر 1472 پڑھ لیں حَدَّثَنَا إِسْحَاقُ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، وَمُحَمَّدُ بْنُ رَافِعٍ، وَاللَّفْظُ لِابْنِ رَافِعٍ، قَالَ إِسْحَاقُ: أَخْبَرَنَا، وَقَالَ ابْنُ رَافِعٍ: حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الرَّزَّاقِ، أَخْبَرَنَا مَعْمَرٌ، عَنِ ابْنِ طَاوُسٍ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، قَالَ: كَانَ الطَّلَاقُ عَلَى عَهْدِ رَسُولِ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ، وَأَبِي بَكْرٍ، وَسَنَتَيْنِ مِنْ خِلَافَةِ عُمَرَ، طَلَاقُ الثَّلَاثِ وَاحِدَةً، فَقَالَ عُمَرُ بْنُ الْخَطَّابِ: إِنَّ النَّاسَ قَدِ اسْتَعْجَلُوا فِي أَمْرٍ قَدْ كَانَتْ لَهُمْ فِيهِ أَنَاةٌ، فَلَوْ أَمْضَيْنَاهُ عَلَيْهِمْ، فَأَمْضَاهُ عَلَيْهِمْ اس میں صاف طور پر "طلاق الثلاثہ" لکھا ہے۔ آگے لکھا ہے کہ حضرت عمر نے کہا کہ "لوگوں نے اس کام میں جلد بازی شروع کر دی ہے جس میں ان کےلیے تحمل اور سوچ بچار ضروری تھا" اب آپ بتائیں کہ جلد بازی (التعجلوا فی امر) کا لفظ حضرت عمر نے استمال ہی کیوں کیا اگر طلاق ایک ہی مجلس میں میں نہیں دی جا رہی تھی۔اگر باقاعدہ طریق کے مطابق دی جارہی تھی تو اس لفظ کا کوئی تُک ہی نہیں بنتا تھا۔اس کے بعد انہوں نے مزید کہا کہ "اگر ہم اس کو(اکٹھی تین طلاقوں کو) ان پر نافذ کر دیں" اور بعد میں کر بھی دیں تاکہ لوگ باز آ جائیں
@@katwithanC when we have an authentic hadith with proper reference in sahih Muslim that three divorces were considered as one in the period of Prophet Muhammad PBUH, in the period of Abu Bakar RA and in the 1st two years of Hazrat Umar's Khilafa (R. than why would we prefer Imam malik's saying in which he clearly said "he told of hearing "?
@@SOHELKHAN-mo7kz The ayah that says to keep women after giving talq either 'in fairness or part with them in kindness'. This is talking about what to do with them after their iddah is over because women observe their iddah in all cases in their ex husbands home. here is the KEY point: There is UNANIMOUS agreement amongst all the muslims that the man *CANNOT* retain a woman in fairness in the iddah following the *third* talaq. there is no disagreement on this point. a couple are forbidden from reconciling in the iddah of the third talaq and there are other scenarios where they are forbidden from reconciling in iddah which proves that Allah has not set the iddah for reconciliation in all cases, only some. I can list examples of that seperately if you need me to. This proves that in this ayah Allah is not talking about the third talaq, he is talking about the first and second talaq. The word marratan also means two. This tells us that the concept of three talaqs does not exist in islam. Yes- three seperate nikahs could be broken with one talaq each and that adds to total of three- this is not the same thing as saying a tripple talaq concept exists because one talaq is sufficient to break a nikah forever. Since the word marratan means two it tells us that breaking a third nikah with a talaq was simply a FORMALITY. the same as when someone signs a resignation letter or stamps a document. They do it to complete a formality. That particular talaq was *fatal* there is no coming back from saying it. So Allah gave two chances at reconciliation, not three, on the basis that men follow the sunnah method of breaking a nikah with ONE talaq. now that we have established that a 'three talaq' concept does not exist then one has no basis to say that 'three talaqs equal one' because three talaq does not exist as a single unit in the first place. misguided muslims are turning islam in to the christian trinity by saying that three things can be one. This goes against mathematics when it was the arabs that gave the world maths. So what does all this prove? it tells us that that WHERE ONE TALAQ IS SUFFICIENT TO BREAK ONE NIKAH, then the 'value' assigned to a talaq is ONE. where 1=1 then 3=3 . This is proof that the *criteria* for a talaq is for the man to *SAY* it, not the Iddah. the iddah is not the criteria. so when a man says something once its one, when he says something twice its two, when he SAYS something three times its three. Ignorance is not an excuse anywhere in the courts in the world. If a man did not know that its his problem. it was HIS job as an adult male to learn his OWN religion. Finally in the scenario where a couple ARE allowed to reconcile in iddah and the man reconciles he reconciles with his *divorced* wife. talaq happens on the spot then after that iddah starts. so she is a divorced woman but she can carry on living as a wife. she cant live as a wife when he gave three talaqs on the spot. talaq cannot be reversed. so the analogy is that when a man is sacked by his employer, he sometimes can use the services of a union to get his job back.he reconciles with the employer. If the employer decides to give him his job back *we do not say that the man was never sacked. He WAS sacked but after a process of reconciliation the employer re instated his job* similarly the woman is divorced forever but she can continue living as a wife if the man does not SAY the word talaq more than two times. There is beshumar evidence to prove that three talaqs are three. Here I have only explained the concept because its the concept that people do not understand. Its a very serious matter for women who are ckmitting zina by saying that three talaqs are one. Any pregnancy after will result in an illegetimate child and illegitimate children do not get their fathers name or their fathers inheritance.
Dr sahab apni knowledge badhaa lijiyega Talaq ke mozu par.... Base less or bewakoofon jaise bat mat kijiye. 4 imam agar teen talaq par muttafiq hain to uski wajah hadeesen or Sahaba ke fatwe hain....
@@media983 4 aaimma Actually khuli khuli hadeeson se he bat sabit hai ki ek sath 3 ki niyat se 3 talaq di jayengi to 3 pad jayengi... Umar razi wali bat ye log out of context pesh karte hain.
Ok wait, so what’s is the 3 months waiting period for when the man says 3 times talaq? In the Quran says in the 3 months if the husband and wife come together than the talaq is void, so how does this make sense now? That contradicts the Quran.
@@MeerAsmat-85in this ayat there no how many time will considered in one sitting ,,this only a procedure,,,,, 3 talak consider as 3 ,,,,,,in hadith,,,, Show one hadith that property said 3 r one???
Sahih Muslim 1472 c Abu al-Sahba' said to Ibn 'Abbas: Enlighten us with your information whether the three divorces (pronounced at one and the same time) were not treated as one during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and Abu Bakr. He said: It was in fact so, but when during the caliphate of 'Umar (Allah be pleased with him) people began to pronounce divorce frequently, he allowed them to do so (to treat pronouncements of three divorces in a single breath as one).
Aajkal log urdu translate padhke mufti ban gaye hai wo ye bhi check karne ke lyak nhi hai ki jo translate wo padh rahe hai uska wo mtlb hoga bhi nhi Adv Hadees ne mashoor 4 zamane ka zikr kiya charo zamane me log 1 hi kaam kar rahe the magar ye kah rahe hai hazrat umar r.a ne dekha ki jis kaam me logo ko sahulat di gayi thi us kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhane lage magar kis kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhayi ye pure sentence me samajh me nhi aa raha hai Ye jis kaam ki zikr kar rahe hai wo to charo zamane me ho rahi hai or agar ye maan li jaye ki hazrat umar r.a ke zamane me ye kaam bahut hone lagi thi to problem kya hai jab 1 majlis me 3 talaq ko sumar 1 hi hoti hai to mtlb kaam to 1 hi hua Jab sumar 1 hi hona hai to fhir sahulat bhi baqi hai or shariyat ka mazaq bhi nhi bana
As Salam o Alykum Sir my brother in law has divorced my sister for 3 times like he has sent her divorce notice 1st and 2nd notice after a month and next month he has sent 3rd notice next month so is it considered as one divorce or divorce has happened and here is no way to ruju.Please guide us regarding what we suppose to do now.
four Imams never said their rulings are final they had told if their any ruling become wrong in the light of Sunnah and Quram will considered to be wrong
@@sohrabkhan3296 the generation DIRECTLY after them cleared any mistakes they may have made. NO ONE IN THE 21st CENTURY HAS BEEN LEFT WITH ANY MISTAKES TO RECTIFY
Why are we giving these great four Imams, who deserve our respect, more importance than the Qur'an, Prophet Muhammad (SAW), and Sahih Hadith in matters of divorce?
I find Dr Zakir Naik a very competent and authentic source of Islamic teachings but the Hadith 3763 he quoted in this video is not the one he's referring to. It is actually 3673. Can be a human error but still wanted to clarify it.
@@Malapo958 he said ‘I divorce you three times’ so it is obvious his intention was three talaqs. But he did not use the word talaq so in this case you should make an appointment with a good mufti. Because talaq does happen even when the word is not used but see a mufti. See mufti tariq masoods ‘kinaya ilfaz’ video if you can understand urdu.
my wife said me 3 -4 times that i need a divorce in a fight and in one fight i said "go away... divorce divorce divorce every time u saying divorce im just done hearing this" i have no intension to give he divorce is divorce occures or not? i was just saying everytime u saying this...... please help me
Mufti tariq masood ye khte h k Dr.zakir naik ka muaqqif change ho gaya h ab ek majlis ki teen tslake 3hi hoti h... meri guzarish h k agar aisa h to ummat ki rehnumai farmaen aur ek video iss par bhi banae ...jazakallah 🎉
@@iam_ayumangalik your belief is wrong. You do haram things every day, and they all take place, yet in talaq you become a beggar. This is hypocricy and munafaqat. Talaq was ALWAYS easy. Yet there are men all over the world who get angry but dont give talaq or when they do they give one. Thats why when a man gives three, when others don’t he wont be shown any mercy.
Assalamu alaikum , Dear brother, but if you go through Ibn Abbas's (RA) fatwas, you will see that he has given rulings on triple talaq as 3 talaqs, so can you explain this. The Sahaba's know the Quran and Hadith more than everyone.
The answer is that ibn Abbas was MISTAKEN. That can easily be proven because there is NO other hadees from anyone else saying three are one. Not a single one.mufti tariq masood is RIGHT in everything he says: there is also a similar hadees by someone named jubair (i think) R.A.that muttah was allowed by the Prophet and it was only hazrat Umar who banned it. yet everyone agrees that muttah is haram. It was not hazrat Umar who banned mutah or talaq. Its just that the correct news had not reached these people. Three talaqs was always three and all hazrat umar did was implement a punishment which was whipping/lashing.
@naseerrafiq913 dont know about that but the hadees about the muttah PROVES that the one by ibn abbas ra is a mistake. It was the Prophet that banned muttah NOT hazrat Umar ra but news did not reach the people. Similarly the Prophet saw ALWAYS considered three to be three and hazrat Umar being a well wisher of women enforced capital punishment for any manwho went against the sunnah and gave three in one go
AAP ko Allah madad ka reah ga Inshaa Allaah dua kareah Allah madad kareah ga iss dunya meah Orr akhirath meah , Allah protect you my beloved sister ameen.
Yeh teen hain. Mufti tariq masood ne sabit kar dee hain bat. Engineer ali mirza bhi teek kehty hain. Dr israr ahmed bhi, talaq ki wazahat video, aur ulamah tayyib nashqbandi. Sab k sab teek kehty hain teen teen hain
Rabbe kaba ki qasam, Allah ki izzat ki qasam talaq waqai ho chuki hai us mard k sath rehna aap keliye haram hai, charo Imam is par muttafiq hain balke shia hazrat bhi is par muttafiq hain ke talaq waqai ho gayi. Masle muftiyan e ikram aur ulma e ikram se pucha karen doctors aur engineers se nhi, warna jo hoga uski zimmedar aap hongi, Qayamat k din jawab nhi de sakengi Jab Allah puchenge ke masla puchne doctor k paas kyun gayi thi.
For those in comments worried that can we disagree with 4 imams in front of quran and sunnah? IT'S YES Prophet (saw) ordered us to follow Quran sunnah & salaf especially 4 khulafa rashidoons. (Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 6429, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2533, Sunan Ibn Mājah 2363, Sunan Tirmdhi 2165) And what do you think how 4 madhabs developed? >>Oldest was hanafi and hambali was last one. Imam malik went against imam hanafi then maliki madhab developed. Imam shafi disagreed with imam malik then shafi madhab developed. Imam ahmed disagreed with imam shafi then hambali madhab developed. So, the great imams disagreed with each other & now people are making complusory on everyone? Since there are some diagreements among 4 fiqhs so we should go back to quran and sunnah. Quran 4:59 O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.
😅This is the argument of the ignorant.The madhabs are four schools of law derived from Quran and Hadith.The differences of opinion among them are based of interpretation based on Quran and hadith.Judges differ in their verdict even thu the law is the same, that doesnt mean that the judges are wrong.
Assalamualaikum sir plz kindly give me the answer "There is a woman here who has gone through a divorce. She was given three divorces (Talaq e hassan ) in one month, with one divorce paper being sent each month through the Union Council. However, during the signing of the papers, there was no one witness one time on present. The woman claims she didn't receive the papers and only found out about them five-six months later. She wants to know if the divorce is valid. If it is, is it considered one divorce or three? Can the couple remarry after five years?
Regret is not taken into consideration.she is divorced on the spot but she is not free to marry another man until her iddah is over.which means that you are free to take back your *DIVORCED ex wife* because you only gave one talaq. If you had given three taking her back would be FORBIDDEN.
Three are three. You said it so it is done. If you had written it three times, there could have been some scope but since you said it verbally and talaq is connected to saying it verbally. These are three. Also you clearly listened to your family more than your wife. Dr naik is totally wrong on talaq. He will die making haram women halal.
Your intention was not to give her talaq !! u were forced to give !!!! in islam intention matters the most !! islam also says u can if ur forced to do something unislamic then it's forgiven in the sight of allah- u can continue living with her !!! allah knows best
Come on…! Then why there its mentioned the times and other things. 2 times in quran. Mentioning once for durations and second time mentioning quantity of it
@@salmanqadeer6231 If you wanna use talak then use it properly and for safety only once and bring her back if you want within iddah (if you don't its over). If you don't want her then use 3 talak and its over. Using 3 options at once. Some men used 3 and then crying. Since they don't want her to go through another man, then say 3 means 1. You can say kobul in 3 times in 1 sitting and so will talak. Men need to know this before marriage. Use 3 to over and don't cry about it later. If use 3 talak and it's over and she has to go through another man, you like it or not it's the rule.
@@maesua4425 come on man..! For argument sake, you have mentioned saying three times makes it happen. What if a person in anger says 5 times. What about the rest?? You never give talaq when you feel romantic or in good mood. You say it when you are in bad mood aka angry? Similarly, you need atleast 2 witness for Nikkah, whereas as for talaq no one..! lolz. Ajeeb hai tamasha hai..? Well, if its as you say, then it was mentioned once. But its mentioned twice and you know why? Because of Numbers and sequence of Quran. All I know is, no matter how many times a person says it when in Anger, it happens once and can be rejoined again. Even its prohibited for remove her from your home, after talaq till her iddah is complete. Reason, at any point in time, you may take her back. I take Islam as pure as it was at the time of SAW. If that was the case, quote me a hadith where SAW said, if you give talaq 3 times at once, its all done. Similarly, at the time of hazrat Movia, even Jabrun (by force a talaq is valid), and Hazrat Ayesha AS said, it can not be. and for fact 3 times all done in 1 go was a rule set by Hazrat Umer i think to stop people from giving talaq, if it was the rule the way you are suggesting, it must have happened in the time of SAW. Quran and Sunnah All says again and again it should be all 3 times at 3 different occasions maximum. Else , one time is good if you do not continue and its valid just as three times. think with Logic, If one time is not valid as 3 times for the first time, then there was no time limit. 3 times means a guy has 2 chances. on third, its done. Time limit is the reason. its not th number of words. To divorce, you can say it once and no need to purse till the time. Its done. even if you give 3 times, a lady still can not do Nikkah again till completing of her IDDA. But if still if you think so, MAY ALLAH GUIDE US ALL
think with Logic, If one time is not valid as 3 times for the first time, then there was no time limit. 3 times means a guy has 2 chances. on third, its done. Time limit is the reason. its not the number of words. To divorce, you can say it once and no need to purse till the time. Its done. even if you give 3 times, a lady still can not do Nikkah again till completing of her IDDA. But if still you think so, MAY ALLAH GUIDE US ALL. For me apart from Dr. Zakhir naik said, I still say, as per quran and sunnah. No matter how many times you say, its considered one per time. last, for Nikkah, you need 2 witnesses, then why not for TALAQ??
Sahih Muslim 1472 b Abu Sahba' said toIbn 'Abbas (Allah be pleased with them): Do you know that three (divorces) were treated as one during the lifetime of Allah's Apostle (ﷺ), and that of Abu Bakr, and during three (years) of the caliphate of Umar (Allah be pleased with him)? Ibn Abbas (Allah be pleased with them) said: Yes.
The shocking truth is that Muhammad viewed women as domestic animals. In his farewell sermon Muhammad equated women to cattle. Tabari (IX:113) recorded (cited Winn, 2004, p. 557) “Treat women well for they are like domestic animals and they possess nothing themselves. Allah has made the enjoyment of their bodies lawful in his Qur’an.”
If I said my fine I will make u free from me now and I said continuously ur free now ur free now ur free now so is divorce happend or this divorce will be consider as first time as I was also not much aware about that and in a anger issue I said after that very day day I told her I accept her back and she also so we are husband and wife right ?
This is wrong.. Opinion of Ibn Abbas is very clear, its counted as 3! Also no sahabi at all held the opinion that its counted as 1, let alone majority.
@@razamughal9095 We have to live by Qur'an not the opinions of people. Allah says in Surah 54 that he made the Qur'an easy to understand. Opinions cause confusion and are, many times, hard to understand. But, "to you be your way. And, to me, mine". Surah 109.
@@emeraldstarr4643 following one of the four madhabs is COMPULSORY. Following them *IS following the Quran and the Sunnah* You coming along and telling us what the Quran says is not following the Quran and the sunnah. Each of the four imams were people and the salaf considered them to be adhering FULLY to the Quran and the sunnah. If they made any mistakes, the generation *directly after* them corrected their mistake. No body in the 21st century has the credibility to say that I am correcting something the people of the past 14 centuries failed to spot. Here is the key point, and the SECOND evidence I am giving you: *none of the four great imams EVER gave a fatwa that three talaqs are one None of the four madhabs has it documented anywhere that three talaqs are one*
@@MrFreeFire81 there cannot be a hadith. A hadith is the words and actions of the Prophet. After his death humans still had problems that needed a fatwa. Thats what the four caliphs gave, a fatwa and their fatwa cannot be wrong. Hazrat Umars fatwa that three talaqs are three CANNOT be wrong. Then after they died, it was necessary for the people from the salaf to study islam and write the hadith down and continue giving fatwas. Thats what the four imams did. They each studied islam to the level of a PhD and they issued fatwas. The people of the time, accepted that these imams were correct and so these four madhabs came into existance, which is compulsory to follow one of them. A fifth madhab was not created because the people did not believe that would add any value to the knowledge that these four imams had. If the imams made any mistake, or a hadith had not reached them *the generation directly after them corrected that mistake* NO ONE in the 21st century has the uqaat to say they have spotted a mistake that the original salaf, and the imams failed to notice. The likes of ghamdi, engineer Ali mirza are doing just that. Mufti rasheed official has a video on ghamdi and Ali mirza.
@@S.B90x if couple doesn't want to reconcile then they are divorced after 3 months of iddah. If husband takes back wife within 3 months then marriage holds.
Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said that three talaq at once is counted as one, and until 636 A.D., this was the law. However, Umar (R.A.), in anger, gave a fatwa mandating that men must adhere to their words, meaning that three talaq at once becomes three talaq. But will you follow Prophet Muhammad (SAW) or these four imams and Umar (R.A.)'s fatwa given in anger? Nonetheless, I believe men should never remarry their wives once they have divorced them three times at once, for precaution. Planned halala is definitely a major sin, but if a man wants to marry his former wife after three divorces at once, then we should allow him to marry her without halala because the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) has said that three divorces at once are counted as one.
@@educationworld9699 hazrat umer r a and four imams kis ko follow kerte thay Inka koi apna deen tha ya koi NAI sheryat thi ??? Ilm na ho itna lamba txt NAHI kerte first proof hazrat Muhammad s.a.w ne kis hadees main kaha three talaq is one?? Aur sahaba Karam r.a teen talaq ko teen ku mante thay?? Kia sub ne Rasool Allah ko chhoor kr hazrat umer r.a ka kalma perh Liya tha ??? Hazrat umer r a aaj dunya main hotay Jo ilzaam ap UN peh Laga rahy hain Kisi ahl hadees ki garden salamat na rehti ke unho ne Rasool Allah ke hukam ke khilaaf Kiya
@@razamughal9095Allah says there is a 3 month waiting period between each pronouncement and you're supposed to have 2 male witnesses or a male and 2 female witnesses to each pronouncement because marriage and divorce are contracts for future obligations and must be in writing.
@@emeraldstarr4643 no they must NOT. You think unlettered people centuries ago put things in writing?? You need two witnesses for a nikah, NOT A DIVORCE. The fact that Allah set a law out but people did not follow it, in *no way shape or form, does that mean that something does not happen* A talaq still occurs whether it is done in the wrong way or the right way. Thats because Allah has connected this word with saying it, one it is said it is DONE. Where 1=1 3=3. Simple mathematics. Where 1 may not have resulted in 1, then there was room for debate. However 1 DOES = 1 therefore three ARE three.
WHO THE HELL ARE YOU? YOU'RE JUST A LAYMAN, HE'S SHAH FAISAL AWARD WINNER 🏆 ND HE'S NOT GIVING FATWA HE'S QUOTING WHAT IS IN HADEETH'S, FATWA KYA HOTA HAI PEHLE MALUM KAR BHAI
theres a difference between giving peoples opinions and saying that thats an opinion that they adhere to and giving a fatwa ruling... he did not give a fatwa he simply agrees with that view thats not a ruling
Talaq is ALWAYS counted. Which proves that three talaqs are THREE. the iddah is extended to when the pregnancy ends. And if he gave three talaqs in one go, then they cannot reconcile in iddah.
@@ShovasDiary_He did not say anywhere that three are three. there is no hadees. in hazrat rukanas case that fatwa was exclusive to his scenario only after the prophet saw got him to swear an oath. thats why you do not find any other fatwa by anyone to say three are three
Kia is masly ko Charo imamo sy zia Kia AP NY Quran hadees ko Charo imamo sy zida samjha.charo imamo NY qurbania dy kar is Deen or shariyat ki hifazat ki ha.
Aajkal log urdu translate padhke mufti ban gaye hai wo ye bhi check karne ke lyak nhi hai ki jo translate wo padh rahe hai uska wo mtlb hoga bhi nhi Dr zakir ne mashoor 4 zamane ka zikr kiya charo zamane me log 1 hi kaam kar rahe the magar ye kah rahe hai hazrat umar r.a ne dekha ki jis kaam me logo ko sahulat di gayi thi us kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhane lage magar kis kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhayi ye pure sentence me samajh me nhi aa raha hai Ye jis kaam ki zikr kar rahe hai wo to charo zamane me ho rahi hai or agar ye maan li jaye ki hazrat umar r.a ke zamane me ye kaam bahut hone lagi thi to problem kya hai jab 1 majlis me 3 talaq ko sumar 1 hi hoti hai to mtlb kaam to 1 hi hua Jab sumar 1 hi hona hai to fhir sahulat bhi baqi hai or shariyat ka mazaq bhi nhi bana
This is against Quran, so wat The so called Aayeemmah said, No, 3 talaaq is valid. Let me ask u a question Sir, How can be talaaq valid without passing through menses.
I think what he was trying to say is that the recommendation is that if it becomes necessary, is that the man should only issue the talaq after one menstral cycle in which there was a period of purity, meaning a period in which he did not have any intercourse with her. Also there's ikhtilaf on the point whether three counts as one. It all depends on how you interpret the evidence. Some scholars such as Ibn Taymiya says that if talaq is given three in one, it only counts as one, others say it isn't. The reason for this difference is becuse of a hadith in which it says that in the time of Abu Bakr and the first two years of Umar's rain, a three in one was counted as one. Then Umar Radiallahu anhu says that the people are taking divorce too lightly, therefore from now on, a three in one counts as three in three.
@@MuhammedDenix ibn tayimah is wrong because NOBODY ever counted three talaqs as one. During the Prophets time three were ALWAYS considered three, which is why Hazrat Umar IMPLEMENTED the shariah.
See this hadith, hence why there is a difference of opinion: It has been narrated that Sayyiduna Rukana divorced his wife three times. The Prophet ﷺ was informed of this and Rukana said: “By Allah, I only intended one.” The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: “By Allah, do you only mean one divorce?” Rukana replied: “By Allah, I only intended one.” The Prophet ﷺ returned her to him. (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi, Ibn Majah, Sunan al-Darimi) Also in sahih Muslim, there is a hadith that says in the time of Rasullullah, three divorces were counted as one, but Umar radiallahu Anhu decreed that three would be counted as three.
@@MuhammedDenix there is NO such hadith. There is no way that Hazrat Umar would change the shariah with the sahabah sitting there like lemons letting it happen. Absolutely no way. He had no authority to do that, which in itself proves that three were ALWAYS three. All he did was implement it. The fact that the Prophet asked him ‘how many did you intend’ PROVES that had the man replied I intended three, then the Prophet would have declared it to be three.
I've just given you the references. The ahadith I mentioned di does not mean that he changed the rulings of the Shariah, rather he acted according to the circumstances in his time. You should check the references I gave you. Especially if it is in a book like sahih Muslim, as all of the ahadith in there are authentic according to the majority of scholars. Yes, you are right, the first hadith I mentioned does also indicate that three talaqs could be counted as three. But it also indicates that three in one sitting could also be ccounted as one. @@razamughal4582
Sahih Muslim 1472 c Abu al-Sahba' said to Ibn 'Abbas: Enlighten us with your information whether the three divorces (pronounced at one and the same time) were not treated as one during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and Abu Bakr. He said: It was in fact so, but when during the caliphate of 'Umar (Allah be pleased with him) people began to pronounce divorce frequently, he allowed them to do so (to treat pronouncements of three divorces in a single breath as one).
Totally WRONG translation. Only a psychotic idiot would dare to say that hazrat Umar, the second CALIPH of islam would do something against the Quran and the Sunnah. OBVIOUSLY if hazrat Umar said three are three *than three talaqs were ALWAYS three* That needs *no* explanation.
My husband sometimes after fight says he Doesn't want me, or he says "I leave you" or "I will leave you". Does it mean talak or not? Sometimes I tell him also to leave me and give him paper to sign. He then becoming frustrated by me (in anger) tells "ok go away". Is our relationship still ok or not? What should we do in This case? Thanks
He has not used the word talaq. So its not a talaq. Search mufti tariq masoods ‘talaq k kinaya ilfaz’ The next step is to decide if the words chor diya are talaq because in kinaya talaq, the husbands intention is taken into account. Mufti rasheed official has said chor diya is a talaq. Search mufti tariq masoods chor diya talaq video. So it all depends, the criteria is, when someone says ‘chor diya’ or someone says ‘tum azad ho’ do the general public associate these words with talaq or not?
The Prophet, Allah's peace be upon him, warned us about getting angry. That if you're standing, sit down. If that doesn't help you to calm down, then lie down. No where in there does he suggest that we open our mouths to say anything. So, follow the guidance.
G yeh bol rahy hain k joh log 3 ko 1 count krty hain un ka opinion zada theek hai or Dr zakir k mutabik b aik bar mein joh 3 time bolty hain woh aik count ho gi
Khabardar k tu ne ainda apny shohur k kartoot islam ya ulamah peh daly. Doh taqy ki aurat. Hindu maa se tarbiyat lee aur yeh hain waja k zindagi tabah hue hain
![Origin of Instant Triple Talaq [Divorce in Islam] | Javed Ahmad Ghamidi](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1cuN5fnRMHQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Maulana ishaq also said triple talaq said in one setting is counted as one! But because of the misleading information on the topic many women are sitting in their homes and suffering sadly
Any solution I am also a victim
Bilkul Sahi Kaha Aap Ne
Talaq Waley Issue Per Ustad Dr Zakir Naik Sahab, Ustad Maulana Ishaq Marhoom, Ustad Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Sahab Ka Point Of View Same Hai
@@muhammadkeewanhaider4305 sab k sab ghalat hain. Sirf mufti tariq masood, engineer ali mirza air dr israr ahmed talaq k bary meh teek hain
@@razamughal9095 Piyaray Bhai Aap Ko Jo Follow Karna Hai Aap Us Ko Follow Karein ,Mai Apna point of view aap per zabardasti musalat nahi kar raha
Informative ❤ Love from India
I can see why Muslims, especially Muslim women who don't study Qur'an, are confused. We should just obey Allah 1st by studying the actual Revelation (Qur'an) Then, when we read others' thoughts, opinions, and commentaries - no matter who they are- we'll have the True Guidance to compare it to. One Allah, one last Prophet, one Divine Revelation = peace and a beautiful - the life of the Sincere Believers. Alhamdulillah!
As Salaamu Alaikum.
Walaikum assalam
We follow Hazrat Muhammad(S.A.W) and Quran...❤❤
Then paindoo, Muhammad saw did NOT command you to follow unqualified scholars. Jahil a marty hain 🙄🙄
And not Ali (as)?
@@FatimaHf-t3m batain kitabon ki and reality 100% difference
Talaq salasa ke masla peh ahl hadees Quran o Sunnah se hazaroon mile door IBN tammiyaah r.a ko follow kerte he
This is fact
Yaha moulvi nikkah ko mushkil bna rhy hen or talaaq ko asan ..tabhi zina aam hai Pakistan main..Dr.Zakir Naik is a light to Pakistan
yeh GHALAT bata rahy hain
May Allah Give Long Life To Ustad Dr Zakir Naik Sahab Till The Time Of Arrival Of Hazrat Imam Mahdi A.S.Ilahi Ameen.
If anyone is still confused then there is a video of zaid patel on talaq of about 1hr 21 mins
Inshallah every doubt will be cleared
I have proved you wrong, and yet you are confuses as ever. LEARN YOUR OWN RELIGION. Its clear you have a hindu mahul at home.
Best work is done by Mufti Kamran Shahzad
He has said there is no ijma.
May Allah bless you Sir Ameen
This is why women have to study the Quran (Allah's Guidance not man's) on their own. Men who do this 3 times in one breath, are simply throwing a tantrum and need to sit down if they're standing or lie down, if they're sitting. There's a 3 month waiting period and Allah says divorced women are to be provided for in Surah 2, verse 241. Men who fear Allah will obey Allah first and foremost. But, women, if you don't study and learn what Allah says, you will continue to be mistreated and misled.
The ayah PROVES THAT THREE TALAQS ARE THREE. Break a nikah with ONE talaq.
Yeah you are true brother proves 3 mean 3 but if someone gives 3 talaq in one breath how would you fit ruju in that case....we need to focus on whole topic where it clearly explain after 2 talaq you can do ruju...how can someone do ruju in one breath ... please can someone explain....And if looking at logical basis providing some time husband can regret what he has done in anger...
@@fais2021 1) he was angry thats HIS problem. Non muslims ALSO get angry they do not have the word talaq to say. Muslims get angry and STILL they don’t say the word talaq. In both cases they use swear words so the man that did say talaq has NO excuse.
2) Allah has defined the process of talaq which includes iddah. He commanded men to break a nikah with one talaq. When a man OPTS to not follow Allahs commands *ALLAH DOES NOT BEND THE RULES TO SUIT HIM*
exactly the same was as the courts do not bend the rules.
Therefore by default, three talaqs are three, exactly in accordance with mathematics. Anyone that lives together after three talaqs are committing zina, and any child born will be haram. And haram children do not get their fathers name nor do they get his inheritance
@@razamughal9095 As Salaam Alaikum. There is no place in Quran that justifies depriving children of care and support because of the sins of the parents. It seems as if you're saying because a man commits fornication or adultery and fathers a child, Allah excuses the man and woman by punishing the child by depriving the child of support and care? Do you teach, also, that the man and woman shouldn't get 100 lashes? Or are you saying that only the woman and child are punished when a man and woman commit zina?
@@emeraldstarr4643 you are being confused somewhere. Three talaqs is THREE. A divorce has NEVER caused a loss to the child. A childs relationship with their parents is not dependent on them being married. Every person has an exclusive relationship with another person, be that your father or be that four wives. *The father will continue paying for the child and the child will sleep in his fathers house and his mothers house* and he will grow up happy and healthy. When it comes to zina, the fornicator does NOT get the child. He does not inherit from the child if the child dies first and the child does not inherit from him. He is deprived from giving the child his name, which would have otherwise been a cause for respect. The child inherits from his mother and his mother inherits from him. And he takes his mothers name. A child, particularly a son is an asset , and the fornicator is deprived of this asset . That does not mean that the child would not grow up happy. In this day and age people ignore islam and he would still be in contact with his biological father.
Sahih Muslim 1472 a
Ibn 'Abbas (Allah be pleased with them) reported that the (pronouncement) of three divorces during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and that of Abu Bakr and two years of the caliphate of Umar (Allah be pleased with him) (was treated) as one. But Umar b. Khattab (Allah be pleased with him) said:
Verily the people have begun to hasten in the matter in which they are required to observe respite. So if we had imposed this upon them, and he imposed it upon them.
Aajkal log urdu translate padhke mufti ban gaye hai wo ye bhi check karne ke lyak nhi hai ki jo translate wo padh rahe hai uska wo mtlb hoga bhi nhi
Hadees ne mashoor 4 zamane ka zikr kiya charo zamane me log 1 hi kaam kar rahe the magar ye kah rahe hai hazrat umar r.a ne dekha ki jis kaam me logo ko sahulat di gayi thi us kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhane lage magar kis kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhayi ye pure sentence me samajh me nhi aa raha hai
Ye jis kaam ki zikr kar rahe hai wo to charo zamane me ho rahi hai or agar ye maan li jaye ki hazrat umar r.a ke zamane me ye kaam bahut hone lagi thi to problem kya hai jab 1 majlis me 3 talaq ko sumar 1 hi hoti hai to mtlb kaam to 1 hi hua
Jab sumar 1 hi hona hai to fhir sahulat bhi baqi hai or shariyat ka mazaq bhi nhi bana
Very well explained Sir.
To know if there is ijma or not And how to take this issue. Watch Mufti Kamran Shahzad. Best explaination ever for Urdu speaking people.
he is TOTALLY WRONG on talaq. people like him make women mistresses
Well explained
No better explanation can be done! Wonderful! Thanks Brother ♥
he is totally wrong
Perfect answer also Javed Ahmed ghamdi same answer
Yes.On The Topic Of Talaq ,The Point Of View Of Ustad Dr Zakir Naik, Ustad Maulana Ishaq And Ustad Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Sahab Is Same.
@@muhammadkeewanhaider4305 and none of them are qualified muftis and they are ALL WRONG.
@@razamughal4582 tu Sala apni bahen ka halala karwa aur Islam ka naan badnaam Kar Islam me Hala kuch nahi hai
@@razamughal4582 All they qualified Islamic scholars and not illliterate madrasa chap molvies
@@razamughal4582you may disagree but not shout degree degree degree ...
most muftis are staunch spokesperson of their sect and all of them reject each other
Thank you for your explanation. The question is whether Muslims should follow the Quran and Hadith or the thoughts of schools? Whatever Umar and other Sahabas are human. They changed the Talad fatwas. As you said Muahmmad S.A.V and Abu Bakr said trippe talaqa in one sitting is counted as one talaq. So. If Muhammad S.A.V said like this. Why Muslims follow Umar's fatwa?
Agree because even in Al - Qur'an Allah never said you can divorced your wife three times in one talaq, as we know woman are really protecting in islam. In umar time if a woman get talaq three times in one sit, umar will take care of those woman that were left by theirr husband.
do you take cheap drugs?? USE COMMON SENSE. there is NO WAY ON EARTH hazrat Umar could change the shariya and there is no way on earth that the sahaba would have ALLOWED HIM TO CHANGE THE SHARIYA. jahalat se bahir niklo. Dr naik is totally wrong aur aurat ko rakhel banaty banaty mar jayga. the fact that Hazrat Umar gave capital punishment to those that gave three talaqs is PROOF that three talaqs *took effect*. it is PROOF that the Prophet saw, and ALL FOUR caliphs ACCEPTED that three talaqs is three. The fact that there is NO fatwa from hazrat Uthman and hazrat Ali is PROOF that they agreed with hazrat Umar. sari zindagi jahil na raho. CLEARLY you have no idea what madhab is or who the four imams were.
Umar (R.A.)'s fatwa was made in anger; that's why we should always follow the words of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) if the words of the Sahabah go against the words of the Prophet, but in most Muslim countries, three talaqs are counted as three talaqs. This means women need to understand their religion and include talaq e hasan in their marriage contract. Then, men will not be able to divorce them three times at once, both Islamicly and legally.
Understand this. It's not the religion that teaches what comes across as hurtful and disrespectful to women. But there are people who, they themselves lack proper regard for women, who do these things. And women don't study as they should, so they allow themselves to be mistreated and disrespected, then blame others. This goes on in all religions, if you're honest about it. Women are treated as Jezibel in the Bible. Eve is blamed for Adam's weakness, etc.
Sir in pakistan after divorce only once it is refer to the family court automaticaly now n within two to three month certifact issued by family court of this talaq .which is considered ful n final .give ur opinion abt this issue
Someone give it Bengali voice please
What is the ruling on if someone sends a written devorce paper to his wife on force of his parents than later regrets and want to reconcile
Which type of divorce paper? There are three types of divorce in Muslim countries. If he sends the divorce papers of talaq e bidah, then according to law and the majority of Muslim scholars, he cannot do anything unless he was not conscious or the divorce papers were not sent by him and someone took his signature by fraud. However, if he sends different types of divorce papers, then there is a waiting period for ruzu (iddah). If that passes and only one divorce has taken place, then he can remarry her with a new mehr.
Then what about this hadith?
Mishkat al-Masabih 3293
Malik told of hearing that a man said to ‘Abdallah b. ‘Abbas, “I have divorced my wife, uttering the divorce a hundred times, so what do you think I have made myself liable for?” Ibn ‘Abbas replied, “She was divorced from you by three utterances, and by ninety-seven you have made a mockery of God’s verses.”
He transmitted it in al- Muwatta’.
وَعَن مَالك بلغه رَجُلًا قَالَ لِعَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَبَّاسٍ: إِنِّي طَلَّقْتُ امْرَأَتِي مِائَةَ تَطْلِيقَةٍ فَمَاذَا تَرَى عَلَيَّ؟ فَقَالَ ابْن عَبَّاس: طلقت مِنْك ثَلَاث وَسَبْعٌ وَتِسْعُونَ اتَّخَذْتَ بِهَا آيَاتِ اللَّهِ هُزُوًا. رَوَاهُ فِي الْمُوَطَّأ
[Classified as hasan]
In this hadith Malik says "he heard" that Ibn e Abbas said so, he didn't give any references that who told him or who reported that hadith, on the other hand the Hadith of sahi Muslim about Ibn e abbas considering 3 talaq as one is mentioned with proper reference.
@@ameerabdullahtiwana ok now you tell where hazrat IBN Abbas uses word "one majlis"
Aur is hadees main aik zamane ka zikar he yeah kaha likha ke Rasool Allah teen ko samjhhte thay ya hazrat Abu bakar Sadiq teen ko aik samajhte thay???
Aur Kon si teen talaq ko aik samjha jata tha
1. Aik majlis ki?
2. Teen majlis ki?
3. Aik kalma ki ??
Ya
4. Ghair madkhola ki??
IBN Abbas ki hadees main in main se kis talaq zikar he dhoond ke deekhao??
@@katwithanC
" Malik told of hearing" makes it clear that imam Malik didn't mention the person or persons whom he heard it from.
@@Onlymuslimworld
@No.1-leader
مسلم شریف کی حدیث نمبر 1472 پڑھ لیں
حَدَّثَنَا إِسْحَاقُ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، وَمُحَمَّدُ بْنُ رَافِعٍ، وَاللَّفْظُ لِابْنِ رَافِعٍ، قَالَ إِسْحَاقُ: أَخْبَرَنَا، وَقَالَ ابْنُ رَافِعٍ: حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الرَّزَّاقِ، أَخْبَرَنَا مَعْمَرٌ، عَنِ ابْنِ طَاوُسٍ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، قَالَ: كَانَ الطَّلَاقُ عَلَى عَهْدِ رَسُولِ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ، وَأَبِي بَكْرٍ، وَسَنَتَيْنِ مِنْ خِلَافَةِ عُمَرَ، طَلَاقُ الثَّلَاثِ وَاحِدَةً، فَقَالَ عُمَرُ بْنُ الْخَطَّابِ: إِنَّ النَّاسَ قَدِ اسْتَعْجَلُوا فِي أَمْرٍ قَدْ كَانَتْ لَهُمْ فِيهِ أَنَاةٌ، فَلَوْ أَمْضَيْنَاهُ عَلَيْهِمْ، فَأَمْضَاهُ عَلَيْهِمْ
اس میں صاف طور پر "طلاق الثلاثہ" لکھا ہے۔ آگے لکھا ہے کہ حضرت عمر نے کہا کہ "لوگوں نے اس کام میں جلد بازی شروع کر دی ہے جس میں ان کےلیے تحمل اور سوچ بچار ضروری تھا"
اب آپ بتائیں کہ جلد بازی (التعجلوا فی امر) کا لفظ حضرت عمر نے استمال ہی کیوں کیا اگر طلاق ایک ہی مجلس میں میں نہیں دی جا رہی تھی۔اگر باقاعدہ طریق کے مطابق دی جارہی تھی تو اس لفظ کا کوئی تُک ہی نہیں بنتا تھا۔اس کے بعد انہوں نے مزید کہا کہ "اگر ہم اس کو(اکٹھی تین طلاقوں کو) ان پر نافذ کر دیں" اور بعد میں کر بھی دیں تاکہ لوگ باز آ جائیں
@@katwithanC when we have an authentic hadith with proper reference in sahih Muslim that three divorces were considered as one in the period of Prophet Muhammad PBUH, in the period of Abu Bakar RA and in the 1st two years of Hazrat Umar's Khilafa (R. than why would we prefer Imam malik's saying in which he clearly said "he told of hearing "?
If person didn’t know that it’s counted as three not one and gave triple talaq in one second ? 😮
Its still three. Thats why one must think before he speaks
@@razamughal9095 can u please share reference
@@SOHELKHAN-mo7kz The ayah that says to keep women after giving talq either 'in fairness or part with them in kindness'. This is talking about what to do with them after their iddah is over because women observe their iddah in all cases in their ex husbands home. here is the KEY point: There is UNANIMOUS agreement amongst all the muslims that the man *CANNOT* retain a woman in fairness in the iddah following the *third* talaq. there is no disagreement on this point. a couple are forbidden from reconciling in the iddah of the third talaq and there are other scenarios where they are forbidden from reconciling in iddah which proves that Allah has not set the iddah for reconciliation in all cases, only some. I can list examples of that seperately if you need me to. This proves that in this ayah Allah is not talking about the third talaq, he is talking about the first and second talaq. The word marratan also means two. This tells us that the concept of three talaqs does not exist in islam. Yes- three seperate nikahs could be broken with one talaq each and that adds to total of three- this is not the same thing as saying a tripple talaq concept exists because one talaq is sufficient to break a nikah forever. Since the word marratan means two it tells us that breaking a third nikah with a talaq was simply a FORMALITY. the same as when someone signs a resignation letter or stamps a document. They do it to complete a formality. That particular talaq was *fatal* there is no coming back from saying it. So Allah gave two chances at reconciliation, not three, on the basis that men follow the sunnah method of breaking a nikah with ONE talaq. now that we have established that a 'three talaq' concept does not exist then one has no basis to say that 'three talaqs equal one' because three talaq does not exist as a single unit in the first place. misguided muslims are turning islam in to the christian trinity by saying that three things can be one. This goes against mathematics when it was the arabs that gave the world maths. So what does all this prove? it tells us that that WHERE ONE TALAQ IS SUFFICIENT TO BREAK ONE NIKAH, then the 'value' assigned to a talaq is ONE. where 1=1 then 3=3 . This is proof that the *criteria* for a talaq is for the man to *SAY* it, not the Iddah. the iddah is not the criteria. so when a man says something once its one, when he says something twice its two, when he SAYS something three times its three. Ignorance is not an excuse anywhere in the courts in the world. If a man did not know that its his problem. it was HIS job as an adult male to learn his OWN religion. Finally in the scenario where a couple ARE allowed to reconcile in iddah and the man reconciles he reconciles with his *divorced* wife. talaq happens on the spot then after that iddah starts. so she is a divorced woman but she can carry on living as a wife. she cant live as a wife when he gave three talaqs on the spot. talaq cannot be reversed. so the analogy is that when a man is sacked by his employer, he sometimes can use the services of a union to get his job back.he reconciles with the employer. If the employer decides to give him his job back *we do not say that the man was never sacked. He WAS sacked but after a process of reconciliation the employer re instated his job*
similarly the woman is divorced forever but she can continue living as a wife if the man does not SAY the word talaq more than two times. There is beshumar evidence to prove that three talaqs are three. Here I have only explained the concept because its the concept that people do not understand. Its a very serious matter for women who are ckmitting zina by saying that three talaqs are one. Any pregnancy after will result in an illegetimate child and illegitimate children do not get their fathers name or their fathers inheritance.
@@SOHELKHAN-mo7kz i typed a long answer and it did not go through
@@SOHELKHAN-mo7kzthere is no reference because it’s a lie and BS
A question, why do we hear this water like sound in most of his videos?
just Check the pots/jugs on his right side, you can see the water flowing. It is a kind of a show piece/aquarium type
He's on his period
Very Well Explained ❤❤😊😊
Dr sahab apni knowledge badhaa lijiyega Talaq ke mozu par.... Base less or bewakoofon jaise bat mat kijiye. 4 imam agar teen talaq par muttafiq hain to uski wajah hadeesen or Sahaba ke fatwe hain....
4 sahaba?
@@media983 4 aaimma
Actually khuli khuli hadeeson se he bat sabit hai ki ek sath 3 ki niyat se 3 talaq di jayengi to 3 pad jayengi... Umar razi wali bat ye log out of context pesh karte hain.
@@SundayIslamicQuiz mera ek masala hai...
@@media983 kya ?
@@SundayIslamicQuiz talaq ka
My husband give me 3 talak talak talak once Infront of people. And he said he warning me. My divorce happened or not. Please answer me.
Yes you cannot marry him again, sorry
It's counted as ONE. Which country are you in sister?
Swal whtap kry tafseel sy
please give whatsapp number 😢@@Muftisahbbeyan98
U can marry ur husband
Ok wait, so what’s is the 3 months waiting period for when the man says 3 times talaq? In the Quran says in the 3 months if the husband and wife come together than the talaq is void, so how does this make sense now? That contradicts the Quran.
I have checked the Sahih hadith vol 4 . no. 3763 it is not there what you have mentioned. Can you give the link or full reference.
@@MeerAsmat-85in this ayat there no how many time will considered in one sitting ,,this only a procedure,,,,,
3 talak consider as 3 ,,,,,,in hadith,,,,
Show one hadith that property said 3 r one???
Sahih Muslim 1472 c
Abu al-Sahba' said to Ibn 'Abbas:
Enlighten us with your information whether the three divorces (pronounced at one and the same time) were not treated as one during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and Abu Bakr. He said: It was in fact so, but when during the caliphate of 'Umar (Allah be pleased with him) people began to pronounce divorce frequently, he allowed them to do so (to treat pronouncements of three divorces in a single breath as one).
Aajkal log urdu translate padhke mufti ban gaye hai wo ye bhi check karne ke lyak nhi hai ki jo translate wo padh rahe hai uska wo mtlb hoga bhi nhi
Adv
Hadees ne mashoor 4 zamane ka zikr kiya charo zamane me log 1 hi kaam kar rahe the magar ye kah rahe hai hazrat umar r.a ne dekha ki jis kaam me logo ko sahulat di gayi thi us kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhane lage magar kis kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhayi ye pure sentence me samajh me nhi aa raha hai
Ye jis kaam ki zikr kar rahe hai wo to charo zamane me ho rahi hai or agar ye maan li jaye ki hazrat umar r.a ke zamane me ye kaam bahut hone lagi thi to problem kya hai jab 1 majlis me 3 talaq ko sumar 1 hi hoti hai to mtlb kaam to 1 hi hua
Jab sumar 1 hi hona hai to fhir sahulat bhi baqi hai or shariyat ka mazaq bhi nhi bana
As Salam o Alykum
Sir my brother in law has divorced my sister for 3 times like he has sent her divorce notice 1st and 2nd notice after a month and next month he has sent 3rd notice next month so is it considered as one divorce or divorce has happened and here is no way to ruju.Please guide us regarding what we suppose to do now.
its three.
Swal whtap kry tafseel sy
Jajakallahu khairan
It's hadith 3673
Very well explained
So this means we can disagree with four imams and their fatawas, please clear
Absolutely not. The fact that the four imams unanimously agreed that three are three leaves no room for doubt.
four Imams never said their rulings are final they had told if their any ruling become wrong in the light of Sunnah and Quram will considered to be wrong
@@sohrabkhan3296 the generation DIRECTLY after them cleared any mistakes they may have made. NO ONE IN THE 21st CENTURY HAS BEEN LEFT WITH ANY MISTAKES TO RECTIFY
Of course you can disagree. You have to agree with Quaran and Hadiths.
Why are we giving these great four Imams, who deserve our respect, more importance than the Qur'an, Prophet Muhammad (SAW), and Sahih Hadith in matters of divorce?
Husband and wife When two persons ALSO accepted diverse not a men
I find Dr Zakir Naik a very competent and authentic source of Islamic teachings but the Hadith 3763 he quoted in this video is not the one he's referring to. It is actually 3673. Can be a human error but still wanted to clarify it.
One setting gave
i divorce
i divorce
i divorce
Kya ye ab without hilala remaraige karsakta h plz infom about it
If u aay 3 times it counts only 1
Baqwas, tumhari maa behn sari zindagi talaqy sunti reh gaye hain, teen TEEN hain
@@razamughal9095if he say I divorce you 3 times and not saying thalaq thalaq thalaq it consider 3 or 1 🥺
@@Malapo958 he said ‘I divorce you three times’ so it is obvious his intention was three talaqs. But he did not use the word talaq so in this case you should make an appointment with a good mufti. Because talaq does happen even when the word is not used but see a mufti. See mufti tariq masoods ‘kinaya ilfaz’ video if you can understand urdu.
my wife said me 3 -4 times that i need a divorce in a fight and in one fight i said "go away... divorce divorce divorce every time u saying divorce im just done hearing this" i have no intension to give he divorce is divorce occures or not? i was just saying everytime u saying this...... please help me
Why say it three times? Go and see a mufti. Dr naik is not a mufti and gives wrong opinions.
Dr Zakir Naik is educated in the Quran & islamic history, hes opinions are no shrouded by culture
@@RizwanAli-hp9jb he is NOT a qualified mufti. He is low level.
Only one talaq is counted.
@@itx0072 teri maa behn sari zindagi talaqy hi sunti reh gaye hain
Mufti tariq masood ye khte h k Dr.zakir naik ka muaqqif change ho gaya h ab ek majlis ki teen tslake 3hi hoti h... meri guzarish h k agar aisa h to ummat ki rehnumai farmaen aur ek video iss par bhi banae ...jazakallah 🎉
Dont trust mufti tariq masood. He can say and he can do anything he wants.
How to contact with Dr Zakir Naik sir ?
Kindly tell me 3 divorce are 3 or counted as 1.. because i am victim of this and suffering at this time. I need guidance
Tripple is biddah it's only one talak as per order of Quran
@@samar7786baqwas.NOWHERE in the Quran does it say three are one. begairat
Sir, you have agreed on both, 3 times in one sitting is counted as one, and 3 times in one sitting is counted as 3. 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
He has no clue what he talks about
Watch again every thing was cleared
@@iam_ayumangalik no he cant. Allah has made it clear he does not forgive divorce.
@@iam_ayumangalik your belief is wrong. You do haram things every day, and they all take place, yet in talaq you become a beggar. This is hypocricy and munafaqat. Talaq was ALWAYS easy. Yet there are men all over the world who get angry but dont give talaq or when they do they give one. Thats why when a man gives three, when others don’t he wont be shown any mercy.
He tells us both views which is followed by Muslim but he says he agrees more on minoritiy scholars.
What if a person says in one sentence that i give you 3 talaqs it will qount as 1 or 3
It will be counted as 1
There is a video of zaid patel on talaq of about 1hr 21 mins
Inshallah every doubt will be cleared
Assalamu alaikum , Dear brother, but if you go through Ibn Abbas's (RA) fatwas, you will see that he has given rulings on triple talaq as 3 talaqs, so can you explain this. The Sahaba's know the Quran and Hadith more than everyone.
The answer is that ibn Abbas was MISTAKEN. That can easily be proven because there is NO other hadees from anyone else saying three are one. Not a single one.mufti tariq masood is RIGHT in everything he says: there is also a similar hadees by someone named jubair (i think) R.A.that muttah was allowed by the Prophet and it was only hazrat Umar who banned it. yet everyone agrees that muttah is haram. It was not hazrat Umar who banned mutah or talaq. Its just that the correct news had not reached these people. Three talaqs was always three and all hazrat umar did was implement a punishment which was whipping/lashing.
@razamughal9095 not mistaken, but the narrator of the hadith from ibn Abbas (RA) made a mistake.
@naseerrafiq913 dont know about that but the hadees about the muttah PROVES that the one by ibn abbas ra is a mistake. It was the Prophet that banned muttah NOT hazrat Umar ra but news did not reach the people. Similarly the Prophet saw ALWAYS considered three to be three and hazrat Umar being a well wisher of women enforced capital punishment for any manwho went against the sunnah and gave three in one go
JazakAllah
Muj 3 talaq di ek sath par m abi b pareshan hun hui h k ni shohar k sath hi rehti hun sb ny kaha ni hui par suni hisab sy hu gai
Plz help me
AAP ko Allah madad ka reah ga Inshaa Allaah dua kareah Allah madad kareah ga iss dunya meah Orr akhirath meah , Allah protect you my beloved sister ameen.
Koi solution nikla
Yeh teen hain. Mufti tariq masood ne sabit kar dee hain bat. Engineer ali mirza bhi teek kehty hain. Dr israr ahmed bhi, talaq ki wazahat video, aur ulamah tayyib nashqbandi. Sab k sab teek kehty hain teen teen hain
Swal whtap kry
Rabbe kaba ki qasam, Allah ki izzat ki qasam talaq waqai ho chuki hai us mard k sath rehna aap keliye haram hai, charo Imam is par muttafiq hain balke shia hazrat bhi is par muttafiq hain ke talaq waqai ho gayi.
Masle muftiyan e ikram aur ulma e ikram se pucha karen doctors aur engineers se nhi, warna jo hoga uski zimmedar aap hongi, Qayamat k din jawab nhi de sakengi Jab Allah puchenge ke masla puchne doctor k paas kyun gayi thi.
For those in comments worried that can we disagree with 4 imams in front of quran and sunnah?
IT'S YES
Prophet (saw) ordered us to follow Quran sunnah & salaf especially 4 khulafa rashidoons.
(Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 6429, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2533, Sunan Ibn Mājah 2363, Sunan
Tirmdhi 2165)
And what do you think how 4 madhabs developed?
>>Oldest was hanafi and hambali was last one.
Imam malik went against imam hanafi then maliki madhab developed.
Imam shafi disagreed with imam malik then shafi madhab developed.
Imam ahmed disagreed with imam shafi then hambali madhab developed.
So, the great imams disagreed with each other & now people are making complusory on everyone?
Since there are some diagreements among 4 fiqhs so we should go back to quran and sunnah.
Quran 4:59 O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.
😅This is the argument of the ignorant.The madhabs are four schools of law derived from Quran and Hadith.The differences of opinion among them are based of interpretation based on Quran and hadith.Judges differ in their verdict even thu the law is the same, that doesnt mean that the judges are wrong.
Jaakir sahab ka byan Hindi aur Urdu mein jab bhi record kare to de sawal
Al Hamdu Lillaah 🤲
Salla Allaahu Alayhi Wa Sallam
Radhi Allaahu Anhum
Jazak Allaahu Khayran
Allaahumma Aameen to all the Duas!
Assalamualaikum sir plz kindly give me the answer
"There is a woman here who has gone through a divorce. She was given three divorces (Talaq e hassan ) in one month, with one divorce paper being sent each month through the Union Council. However, during the signing of the papers, there was no one witness one time on present. The woman claims she didn't receive the papers and only found out about them five-six months later.
She wants to know if the divorce is valid. If it is, is it considered one divorce or three? Can the couple remarry after five years?
No they cant.papers have no meaning.he gave THREE talaqs
How can we contact you
Call him
Number
When I give one talaq to my wife and I regret it instantly is she divorced?
Regret is not taken into consideration.she is divorced on the spot but she is not free to marry another man until her iddah is over.which means that you are free to take back your *DIVORCED ex wife* because you only gave one talaq. If you had given three taking her back would be FORBIDDEN.
When you say but it means not following Allah.
Then what should we follow? 3 talaqs is counted as 3 Or 1 talaq?? Please answer me
its three. mufti tariq masood has proved it
@@razamughal9095mufti tariq to 4 shadio ka b kehty hen wo b krlo ja k
@@Sitarafatyma tum ne sari zindagi ek run mureed bap aur hindu maa hi dekhi hain
1
Whtap kry sawal
Zakir sir please tell abou kiniya talak
Is talaq e Hasan approved by hadiths?
Sir,my family forced me badly to say,talaq three times at once to my wife.what should I do. I love my wife so much and she also.
Three are three. You said it so it is done. If you had written it three times, there could have been some scope but since you said it verbally and talaq is connected to saying it verbally. These are three. Also you clearly listened to your family more than your wife. Dr naik is totally wrong on talaq. He will die making haram women halal.
Talaq given one time is considered as one listen to him after 10th minute
@@malikzeeshan660 no it is NOT. Tumhari maa behn sari zindagi talaqy sunti reh gaye
@@razamughal9095what if three talaq written in once and sent as message
Just talaq talaq talaq
And from now you are not my wife
Your intention was not to give her talaq !! u were forced to give !!!! in islam intention matters the most !! islam also says u can if ur forced to do something unislamic then it's forgiven in the sight of allah- u can continue living with her !!!
allah knows best
Yh old h bhai.....bayan
Asalamulikmm
Please muslim men, if you use talak use 1 or 3 means over. Do not risk akhira and do not want to be raised as parents of bastards!
Come on…! Then why there its mentioned the times and other things. 2 times in quran. Mentioning once for durations and second time mentioning quantity of it
@@salmanqadeer6231 If you wanna use talak then use it properly and for safety only once and bring her back if you want within iddah (if you don't its over). If you don't want her then use 3 talak and its over. Using 3 options at once. Some men used 3 and then crying. Since they don't want her to go through another man, then say 3 means 1. You can say kobul in 3 times in 1 sitting and so will talak. Men need to know this before marriage. Use 3 to over and don't cry about it later. If use 3 talak and it's over and she has to go through another man, you like it or not it's the rule.
@@maesua4425 come on man..! For argument sake, you have mentioned saying three times makes it happen. What if a person in anger says 5 times. What about the rest?? You never give talaq when you feel romantic or in good mood. You say it when you are in bad mood aka angry?
Similarly, you need atleast 2 witness for Nikkah, whereas as for talaq no one..! lolz. Ajeeb hai tamasha hai..?
Well, if its as you say, then it was mentioned once. But its mentioned twice and you know why? Because of Numbers and sequence of Quran. All I know is, no matter how many times a person says it when in Anger, it happens once and can be rejoined again.
Even its prohibited for remove her from your home, after talaq till her iddah is complete. Reason, at any point in time, you may take her back.
I take Islam as pure as it was at the time of SAW. If that was the case, quote me a hadith where SAW said, if you give talaq 3 times at once, its all done.
Similarly, at the time of hazrat Movia, even Jabrun (by force a talaq is valid), and Hazrat Ayesha AS said, it can not be.
and for fact 3 times all done in 1 go was a rule set by Hazrat Umer i think to stop people from giving talaq, if it was the rule the way you are suggesting, it must have happened in the time of SAW. Quran and Sunnah All says again and again it should be all 3 times at 3 different occasions maximum. Else , one time is good if you do not continue and its valid just as three times.
think with Logic, If one time is not valid as 3 times for the first time, then there was no time limit. 3 times means a guy has 2 chances. on third, its done. Time limit is the reason. its not th number of words. To divorce, you can say it once and no need to purse till the time. Its done. even if you give 3 times, a lady still can not do Nikkah again till completing of her IDDA. But if still if you think so, MAY ALLAH GUIDE US ALL
think with Logic, If one time is not valid as 3 times for the first time, then there was no time limit. 3 times means a guy has 2 chances. on third, its done. Time limit is the reason. its not the number of words. To divorce, you can say it once and no need to purse till the time. Its done. even if you give 3 times, a lady still can not do Nikkah again till completing of her IDDA. But if still you think so, MAY ALLAH GUIDE US ALL. For me apart from Dr. Zakhir naik said, I still say, as per quran and sunnah. No matter how many times you say, its considered one per time.
last, for Nikkah, you need 2 witnesses, then why not for TALAQ??
Nabi pak ka hukkam he shriyat h or Musilmanoo ka lyee nabi pak ka hukkam he shriyat h or teen ko nabi pak na ek Dya tu ya sunnat be h
Unho ne kabhi teen ko ek nai samjha
@@razamughal9095Acha Tum ko pata hai ??? Nabi Pak Kay zamanay Mai 3 aik thi is Hadees ki tasdeeq Mufti Azam Taqi Usmani bhi kar chukay hain
@@mohammadmehmood9267 tum log AAJ TAK ek hadees bhi la nai saky aur bat karty ho mufti taqi uthmani ki. EK BHI HADEES NAI HAIN K TEEN TEEN HAIN
@@razamughal9095 Ha Tum andhay Kay liye NAhi hain. Tumharay liye to Quran Mai biyan kia gaya Allah ka khulam khullah tareeqa bhi naa- kafi hai
Right opinion
Sahih Muslim 1472 b
Abu Sahba' said toIbn 'Abbas (Allah be pleased with them):
Do you know that three (divorces) were treated as one during the lifetime of Allah's Apostle (ﷺ), and that of Abu Bakr, and during three (years) of the caliphate of Umar (Allah be pleased with him)? Ibn Abbas (Allah be pleased with them) said: Yes.
The shocking truth is that Muhammad viewed women as domestic animals. In his farewell sermon Muhammad equated women to cattle. Tabari (IX:113) recorded (cited Winn, 2004, p. 557) “Treat women well for they are like domestic animals and they possess nothing themselves. Allah has made the enjoyment of their bodies lawful in his Qur’an.”
yet YOUR Doctor still refers to your sisters as fertile or infertile..Oops 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
If I said my fine I will make u free from me now and I said continuously ur free now ur free now ur free now so is divorce happend or this divorce will be consider as first time as I was also not much aware about that and in a anger issue I said after that very day day I told her I accept her back and she also so we are husband and wife right ?
Its obvious your intention here was a talaq thats why you kept saying ut
Just one is counted.
Correct opinion
No its not. Instead of embarrassing yourself and offloading haram children to planet earth, GIVE EVIDENCE.
the marriage is divorced by anger dr zakir naik
Ya kya Bol rhn hai ky 3 talaq Ek hoti h
Whtap kry sawal
Kya maa bacha ko pet karma ha to is what talaq ho jata ha ?
Talaq on the spot har halat meh ho jati hain lekin pregnant aurat ki iddat extend ho jati hain
Mai Dr sahab ko bohot chahta like karta ho lekin is masle mai Dr wrong hai
What if a person gives 1 talaq and after 3 moths gives 2 talaqa together..is it counted as one or two and is the women considered divorced or not ?
This totals three.
Dr fakir Naik sahib Mai aap se video call par baat karna chaeta hu
i want to talk u how do i contact u please. abdullah pakistan.
This is wrong.. Opinion of Ibn Abbas is very clear, its counted as 3! Also no sahabi at all held the opinion that its counted as 1, let alone majority.
Exactly.
@@razamughal9095 We have to live by Qur'an not the opinions of people. Allah says in Surah 54 that he made the Qur'an easy to understand. Opinions cause confusion and are, many times, hard to understand. But, "to you be your way. And, to me, mine". Surah 109.
@@emeraldstarr4643 following one of the four madhabs is COMPULSORY. Following them *IS following the Quran and the Sunnah*
You coming along and telling us what the Quran says is not following the Quran and the sunnah.
Each of the four imams were people and the salaf considered them to be adhering FULLY to the Quran and the sunnah. If they made any mistakes, the generation *directly after* them corrected their mistake.
No body in the 21st century has the credibility to say that I am correcting something the people of the past 14 centuries failed to spot.
Here is the key point, and the SECOND evidence I am giving you: *none of the four great imams EVER gave a fatwa that three talaqs are one None of the four madhabs has it documented anywhere that three talaqs are one*
@@razamughal9095in which Hadith it is compulsory to follow imaams ...?
@@MrFreeFire81 there cannot be a hadith. A hadith is the words and actions of the Prophet. After his death humans still had problems that needed a fatwa. Thats what the four caliphs gave, a fatwa and their fatwa cannot be wrong. Hazrat Umars fatwa that three talaqs are three CANNOT be wrong. Then after they died, it was necessary for the people from the salaf to study islam and write the hadith down and continue giving fatwas. Thats what the four imams did. They each studied islam to the level of a PhD and they issued fatwas. The people of the time, accepted that these imams were correct and so these four madhabs came into existance, which is compulsory to follow one of them. A fifth madhab was not created because the people did not believe that would add any value to the knowledge that these four imams had. If the imams made any mistake, or a hadith had not reached them *the generation directly after them corrected that mistake*
NO ONE in the 21st century has the uqaat to say they have spotted a mistake that the original salaf, and the imams failed to notice. The likes of ghamdi, engineer Ali mirza are doing just that. Mufti rasheed official has a video on ghamdi and Ali mirza.
What if husband gives triple talaq in one sitting. Is nikal remain valid or invalid.
The nikah is over. Three are three.
it is counted as one, wife should wait iddah
@@Soldier-Of-Mahdisorry can you clarify? If 3 is given, we wait until iddah and then what happens?
@@S.B90x if couple doesn't want to reconcile then they are divorced after 3 months of iddah.
If husband takes back wife within 3 months then marriage holds.
@@Soldier-Of-Mahdi Okay. So if both husband and wife are still living together then they just carry on continuing marriage?
Matlab hazrat umer n Allah k halal ko haram kardia (Allah maaf farmae).. sahaba(R.A) se ziada deen koi nahi samjh sakta.
If the 4 school of figh imams agree, then it is correct.
But if Prophet S.A.W said it's not, then it's not.
The Quran & Prophet Muhammed supercede any imams
Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said that three talaq at once is counted as one, and until 636 A.D., this was the law. However, Umar (R.A.), in anger, gave a fatwa mandating that men must adhere to their words, meaning that three talaq at once becomes three talaq. But will you follow Prophet Muhammad (SAW) or these four imams and Umar (R.A.)'s fatwa given in anger? Nonetheless, I believe men should never remarry their wives once they have divorced them three times at once, for precaution. Planned halala is definitely a major sin, but if a man wants to marry his former wife after three divorces at once, then we should allow him to marry her without halala because the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) has said that three divorces at once are counted as one.
@@educationworld9699 hazrat umer r a and four imams kis ko follow kerte thay Inka koi apna deen tha ya koi NAI sheryat thi ???
Ilm na ho itna lamba txt NAHI kerte first proof hazrat Muhammad s.a.w ne kis hadees main kaha three talaq is one??
Aur sahaba Karam r.a teen talaq ko teen ku mante thay?? Kia sub ne Rasool Allah ko chhoor kr hazrat umer r.a ka kalma perh Liya tha ???
Hazrat umer r a aaj dunya main hotay Jo ilzaam ap UN peh Laga rahy hain Kisi ahl hadees ki garden salamat na rehti ke unho ne Rasool Allah ke hukam ke khilaaf Kiya
Sir suppose i gave it over phone not infront of the wife out of anger will it be done?
Yes brother it counts but inshallah it counts just one
@@atalsardar872 its NOT one if he said it three times, simple mathematics.
@@razamughal9095Allah says there is a 3 month waiting period between each pronouncement and you're supposed to have 2 male witnesses or a male and 2 female witnesses to each pronouncement because marriage and divorce are contracts for future obligations and must be in writing.
@@emeraldstarr4643 no they must NOT. You think unlettered people centuries ago put things in writing?? You need two witnesses for a nikah, NOT A DIVORCE. The fact that Allah set a law out but people did not follow it, in *no way shape or form, does that mean that something does not happen*
A talaq still occurs whether it is done in the wrong way or the right way. Thats because Allah has connected this word with saying it, one it is said it is DONE. Where 1=1 3=3. Simple mathematics. Where 1 may not have resulted in 1, then there was room for debate. However 1 DOES = 1 therefore three ARE three.
Ye urdu me muje koi bata sakta h ye 3 ko1 bol rahe h ??
Whtap kry sawal tafseel sy
Yeh ghalat bataty hain. Teen teen hoti hain
@@razamughal9095 apko kesy pta
If I say three times, I divorce u I divorce u I divorce u, is it one or three? Can I take my wife back?
its THREE
Why you are giving fatwa ? Your own video you have said "I am not qualified for fatwa". You can debate others but for fatwa you need a qualifications.
WHO THE HELL ARE YOU? YOU'RE JUST A LAYMAN, HE'S SHAH FAISAL AWARD WINNER 🏆 ND HE'S NOT GIVING FATWA HE'S QUOTING WHAT IS IN HADEETH'S, FATWA KYA HOTA HAI PEHLE MALUM KAR BHAI
theres a difference between giving peoples opinions and saying that thats an opinion that they adhere to and giving a fatwa ruling...
he did not give a fatwa
he simply agrees with that view thats not a ruling
when the wife is in pregnancy and husband give talak to on this case talak counted
Talaq is ALWAYS counted. Which proves that three talaqs are THREE. the iddah is extended to when the pregnancy ends. And if he gave three talaqs in one go, then they cannot reconcile in iddah.
are u sure is it 3?? Then about Prophet Mohammed SAW said?? @@razamughal4582
@@ShovasDiary_He did not say anywhere that three are three. there is no hadees. in hazrat rukanas case that fatwa was exclusive to his scenario only after the prophet saw got him to swear an oath. thats why you do not find any other fatwa by anyone to say three are three
OMG’ I am so confused..
❤
Kia is masly ko Charo imamo sy zia
Kia AP NY Quran hadees ko Charo imamo sy zida samjha.charo imamo NY qurbania dy kar is Deen or shariyat ki hifazat ki ha.
Agar husband nok jhok mai ya mazak mai biwi say 3 bar talakh boli toh kya hoga?
Haan. Woh hai hi begairat.
This sound like water i think it's from fish aquarium tank
Nai it's from the vase decor ... It's a continuous water cycle
Aajkal log urdu translate padhke mufti ban gaye hai wo ye bhi check karne ke lyak nhi hai ki jo translate wo padh rahe hai uska wo mtlb hoga bhi nhi
Dr zakir ne mashoor 4 zamane ka zikr kiya charo zamane me log 1 hi kaam kar rahe the magar ye kah rahe hai hazrat umar r.a ne dekha ki jis kaam me logo ko sahulat di gayi thi us kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhane lage magar kis kaam me logo ne jald bazi dikhayi ye pure sentence me samajh me nhi aa raha hai
Ye jis kaam ki zikr kar rahe hai wo to charo zamane me ho rahi hai or agar ye maan li jaye ki hazrat umar r.a ke zamane me ye kaam bahut hone lagi thi to problem kya hai jab 1 majlis me 3 talaq ko sumar 1 hi hoti hai to mtlb kaam to 1 hi hua
Jab sumar 1 hi hona hai to fhir sahulat bhi baqi hai or shariyat ka mazaq bhi nhi bana
Kabhi aisa zamana nai aya jaha teen talaq ek ko samjha gaya ho. Nonsense aqal ki khilaf bat hain
@@razamughal9095chupkar arat ke dushman
first time seeing him without his glasses
This is against Quran, so wat The so called Aayeemmah said, No, 3 talaaq is valid. Let me ask u a question Sir, How can be talaaq valid without passing through menses.
I think what he was trying to say is that the recommendation is that if it becomes necessary, is that the man should only issue the talaq after one menstral cycle in which there was a period of purity, meaning a period in which he did not have any intercourse with her.
Also there's ikhtilaf on the point whether three counts as one. It all depends on how you interpret the evidence.
Some scholars such as Ibn Taymiya says that if talaq is given three in one, it only counts as one, others say it isn't.
The reason for this difference is becuse of a hadith in which it says that in the time of Abu Bakr and the first two years of Umar's rain, a three in one was counted as one. Then Umar Radiallahu anhu says that the people are taking divorce too lightly, therefore from now on, a three in one counts as three in three.
@@MuhammedDenix ibn tayimah is wrong because NOBODY ever counted three talaqs as one. During the Prophets time three were ALWAYS considered three, which is why Hazrat Umar IMPLEMENTED the shariah.
See this hadith, hence why there is a difference of opinion:
It has been narrated that Sayyiduna Rukana divorced his wife three times. The Prophet ﷺ was informed of this and Rukana said: “By Allah, I only intended
one.” The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: “By Allah, do you only mean one divorce?” Rukana replied: “By Allah, I only intended one.” The Prophet ﷺ returned
her to him. (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi, Ibn Majah, Sunan al-Darimi)
Also in sahih Muslim, there is a hadith that says in the time of Rasullullah, three divorces were counted as one, but Umar radiallahu Anhu decreed that three would be counted as three.
@@MuhammedDenix there is NO such hadith. There is no way that Hazrat Umar would change the shariah with the sahabah sitting there like lemons letting it happen. Absolutely no way. He had no authority to do that, which in itself proves that three were ALWAYS three. All he did was implement it. The fact that the Prophet asked him ‘how many did you intend’ PROVES that had the man replied I intended three, then the Prophet would have declared it to be three.
I've just given you the references.
The ahadith I mentioned di does not mean that he changed the rulings of the Shariah, rather he acted according to the circumstances in his time.
You should check the references I gave you.
Especially if it is in a book like sahih Muslim, as all of the ahadith in there are authentic according to the majority of scholars.
Yes, you are right, the first hadith I mentioned does also indicate that three talaqs could be counted as three. But it also indicates that three in one sitting could also be ccounted as one.
@@razamughal4582
Al-Ham-Do-Lilla
Ata bangali hobe na
Alhamdulillah
Sahih Muslim 1472 c
Abu al-Sahba' said to Ibn 'Abbas:
Enlighten us with your information whether the three divorces (pronounced at one and the same time) were not treated as one during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and Abu Bakr. He said: It was in fact so, but when during the caliphate of 'Umar (Allah be pleased with him) people began to pronounce divorce frequently, he allowed them to do so (to treat pronouncements of three divorces in a single breath as one).
the hadith number changed ? because zakir naik is saying some other number
@@AsifIqbal-dd5yd yes because its international number of hadith
Totally WRONG translation. Only a psychotic idiot would dare to say that hazrat Umar, the second CALIPH of islam would do something against the Quran and the Sunnah. OBVIOUSLY if hazrat Umar said three are three *than three talaqs were ALWAYS three* That needs *no* explanation.
Assalamu'Alaikum. If one talaaq is given and you reconcile and then later two talaqs are given in one sitting. Is it still counted as triple talaaq?
@@adilaessop.3242 its not triple. Its two talaqs. So 1+2. =3. You have given three talaqs. There is no reconciliation. Two talaqs in one go =2
My husband sometimes after fight says he Doesn't want me, or he says "I leave you" or "I will leave you". Does it mean talak or not?
Sometimes I tell him also to leave me and give him paper to sign. He then becoming frustrated by me (in anger) tells "ok go away".
Is our relationship still ok or not?
What should we do in This case?
Thanks
After 3 month if u want to again married so u should do married whith him because of surah baqrah surah 2 ayat 232
He has not used the word talaq. So its not a talaq. Search mufti tariq masoods ‘talaq k kinaya ilfaz’
The next step is to decide if the words chor diya are talaq because in kinaya talaq, the husbands intention is taken into account. Mufti rasheed official has said chor diya is a talaq. Search mufti tariq masoods chor diya talaq video. So it all depends, the criteria is, when someone says ‘chor diya’ or someone says ‘tum azad ho’ do the general public associate these words with talaq or not?
@@shahrozqureshi6477 surah baqarah makes it CLEAR that three talaqs are THREE.
The Prophet, Allah's peace be upon him, warned us about getting angry. That if you're standing, sit down. If that doesn't help you to calm down, then lie down. No where in there does he suggest that we open our mouths to say anything. So, follow the guidance.
Sir baaki imaam ki kya daleel hai wo bhi bata detry to baat clear ho jasti
Ap ne sirf apne nazariye ki daleel bataee hai
Its not fair
Yeh mufti nai hain, is ki knowledge boht limited hain. Haram aurat ko halal kar k marega aur apny bety ko bhi is kam peh laga diya hain
@@razamughal9095mat bol Aisa haram khor
Mashallah
Ye hadees jo aap bata rahe hai ye dukhul se pahle ki hai sun nissia ki hadees bhi padhe
Ye bol rhe 3 hota h ya 1 hame samjh mai nhi aa rha English mai bolte h
G yeh bol rahy hain k joh log 3 ko 1 count krty hain un ka opinion zada theek hai or Dr zakir k mutabik b aik bar mein joh 3 time bolty hain woh aik count ho gi
@mariamaria-vi3xv right inka y urdu me b h usme b yahi bayan h same words
Dr israr ahmad k Biyan ne meri zindagi tabah krdi h
Kyu kaya howa
Khabardar k tu ne ainda apny shohur k kartoot islam ya ulamah peh daly. Doh taqy ki aurat. Hindu maa se tarbiyat lee aur yeh hain waja k zindagi tabah hue hain
Q bahen
❤
Do baar ek saath di toh? Do count hngy ya ek?
Doh. Aur teen teen.
Ek count hoga
@@truthseeker1038 tu jahil hain
I wish yeh option hi na hota islam mai
Yeh option na hota toh sari zindagi aurat ko us hi mard k sat rehna hota aur sati ho jana ta