Diana Ankudinova - In My Huge City AUDIO ENGINEER REACTS
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 мар 2024
- #DianaAnkudinovaReaction #ДианаАнкудинова #DianaAnkudinova
Today on Audio Engineer Reacts I am checking out In My Huge City by the incredible Diana Ankudinova!
I have Memberships! Some of the perks are early access to videos and I will be doing member only content and more!
/ @harmonicchaos1337
Check out the original video:
• Диана Анкудинова - В о...
Intro and Outro Song:
Prove Myself - H3 Music
• *FREE FOR PROFIT* NF "...
Instagram - h3_music
Soundcloud - h3_music1
RUclips - h3music 
Развлечения
Лично я не слышу никаких отключений, искажений, но и не берусь судить, возможно, мнение специалиста! Но за реакцию, на это великолепный трек Дианы, спасибо большое!!!
Диана Анкудинова Богиня Эмоций!!!
Спасибо за реакцию. Песня очень классная.
Для меня, эта песня, в исполнении Дианы ---- шикарна, . Очень часто, её слушаю. У реакционераи---- свое мнение, все допускаю
Ибо на вкус и цвет...
Разное восприятие и это нормально---- каждый из нас, по своему--- индивидуален
Красивая грустная песня!
И великолепный вокал со стороны Дианы!
Диане - браво, а за реакцию - лайк!
Beautiful sad song!
And great vocals from Diana!
Bravo to Diana, and like for the reaction!
Thanks for the reaction! For me, this knock is the sound of an old mechanical clock with a pendulum, at night they sound more clearly louder than during the day, the clock constantly reminds us of the time allotted to us...
Мне кажется, что у разных звукорежиссёров могут быть свои предпочтения и своя "профессиональная деформация" :)
Возможно, другое решение дало бы лучший или иной результат. Мне тоже кажется, что можно было смягчить перкуссию. Но авторское решение, есть авторское решение. Это как сейчас предъявлять претензии Малевичу, что чёрная трапеции была бы более динамична, чем его знаменитый чёрный квадрат =)
Спасибо за реакцию 👍
Спасибо за реакцию. Диана лучшая певица. Браво Диана❤❤❤❤❤❤
This Song was actually from a POET. The lyrics are about her inability to sleep “INSOMNIA” so she walks through her city and the invisibility she felt. The poem is over a CENTURY OLD. During DIANA’s participation of the RUSSIAN MASKED SINGER competition…she also covered another beautiful poem “ I’ll Win You Back” by the same POET. The clicking I also believe is suppose to be a clock 🕰️.
Очень красиво получилось!!!браво Диана!!!спасибо за реакции
Greetings from Scotland! Great analysis from a sound engineer perspective. The song is intentionally like this because it was intended to have an old style sound. If you are an insomniac, you may spend a lot of time walking around at night when everyone else is tucked up asleep, at home in their beds. Basically, that's the story she tells here. Beautifully sung by Diana in that naturally deep, chocolate toned, silky voice of hers. Set to music by Brandon Stone who knows his stuff.
Originally from a poem by the famous Russian Poet, Marina Tsvetaeva way back in July 17, 1916.
Insomnia. In my enormous city it is - night...
Just by way of a little background info on the original writer of the poem's sad ending:-
On 31 August 1941, while living in Yelabuga, Tsvetaeva hanged herself. She left a note for her son Mur: "Forgive me, but to go on would be worse. I am gravely ill, this is not me anymore. I love you passionately. Do understand that I could not live anymore. Tell Papa and Alya, if you ever see them, that I loved them to the last moment and explain to them that I found myself in a trap."
According to the book "The Death of a Poet: The Last Days of Marina Tsvetaeva", the local NKVD department tried to force Tsvetaeva to start working as their informant, which left her no choice other than to die by suicide.
Hi Peter,
I don't have anything to say.
I just haven't said 'hi' for a while.
@@franks9432 That's really kind of you Frank! Since my youngest son left us back in July, most people have gone pretty quiet. I understand though, it's a normal reaction, not knowing what to say or how to say it. I'm getting there slowly, it had a big effect on my health due to shock, but I'll be back to about 90% by the end of 2024 they said. I'm waiting for the next surprise from Diana! I love her surprises, she said a LOT was going to change - sounds interesting! 😊 Hope all is well with you and your family Sir! 🤝
супер
Thanks for the reaction! I have seen in other places videos talking about using clipping deliberately to achieve certain effects...maybe that's what's happening here? It's very hard to believe that Diana Ankudinova isn't aware of exactly how this song sounds.
Дианочка браво!!!!
Diana is a perfectionist. She would never release a "tainted product." If you hear distortions, then this is what Diana wanted and you need to look for the meaning of these distortions. The effect of an "old vinyl record" is too banal, but the effect of a "badly tuned radio receiver" with a "floating" wave is brilliant, it's like you stumbled upon an old abandoned, dust-covered grand piano in some forgotten theater.
Thanks for the reaction!
Диана супер !❤❤❤
In my Huge City is an absolute masterpiece.
(It is a pity that Diana's microphone is clipping throughout. If only she had competent sound engineers to work with.)
That different people like different songs does not make whether a song is or sounds good "subjective."
People disagree about the facts - e.g. how, where and why the virus C-19 originated - all the time.
But the facts are as they are whatever people think about them.
Thanks!
It's such a great song and performance.
Whether by choice or accident, it's a disappointment that parts of the recording were spoiled by that distortion.
Yeah, it sounds like the electronics were overdriven, to me too. However, I'm not a professional.
Diana is greatly loved by many, including myself. Hopefully, you won't be flamed too severely.
Thanks.
It is neither distortion nor clipping (well it is but it is also on purpose) it is the effect that old record players or old radio is making, this wants to pass the feeling of "oldness" in the track since the poem it self is about 100 years old and as for the dissonance of vocals with the music it has also been done intentionally since the lyrics talk about the heroine of the story being in a dream like state while awake because she is suffering from insomnia.
This poem describes a person that is not in a good mental state and so this is exactly what it tries to pass to the listener musically too.
You over analyzed and separated parts of the composition but you did not try to put them all together as a whole, it happens often to all of us especially if we are missing context, thus the saying missing the forest for the trees.
Saying that, i find it very odd that this is the first time you are listening to effects like that in tracks, especially since you are an audio engineer, in Europe there are a lot of tracks that use this in order to sound like old recordings, it is a very popular effect.
In the live version of the song Diana does the vocalizations or the second voice that sounds on the background "live" and the audio engineer still allows the "old distortion" to happen on the prerecorded Diana's voice who sings the couplet part of the song.
what live version of the song?
I believe you when you say that the distortion is intentional. It's impossible to believe that something that is obvious would be released by mistake.
What I can't understand is why it would be desirable to ruin such a great song and performance.
@@franks9432Because it is not ruined, the sound is perfect and the distortion happens only on the right spots strategically where it matters.
@@bloodyiceberg6827 The one she sings in her concerts.
@@Kwstas_Vagias Well, we disagree, The recording is most definitely ruined.
Dude! The "knock" that irritates you is an intermittent heartbeat, one of the main metaphors for the artistic content of the song, part of its meaning, the creative discovery of the authors! The "distortion" is a special sound "pinup" effect that imitates the soundtrack of the early 20th century, when these lyrics were written (1916). 😁
Go back and listen to what was said. He didn't complain about that sound. He only said that he thought that it was too loud.
@@franks9432 Can you hear your heartbeat under normal circumstances? I guess not. But what if a person is under stress, under intense physical strain, or in a state of high nervous tension? This is exactly the state that the authors of the song are trying to convey to the listener with the amplified sound of a heartbeat! This is such an artistic device, such a creative idea of the author! In order to understand it, at least an understanding of the poetic text is required. This is not a technical parameter of the recording... For example, Pink Floyd - "The Dark Side of the Moon. Speak To Me Breathe In The Air" ruclips.net/video/R49d4f5sEs4/видео.html
Дианка❤❤❤❤❤
Что там у него под понятием обрезается не понятно.Может у него связь плохая или наушники чудят. Эта песня для меня как наркотик для наркомана и ни разу не слышал обрезание микрофона,думаю что каждый слышит что хочет.Наложение бек вокала есть но это голос Дианы запись студийная тоже понятно без бека песня была бы не полной.
Как по мне одна из лучших песен Дианы и Брендона, и не барабаны эти удары палочкой, метроном отсчитывает время сна.Ведь Марина написала стихи о ночи, а люди спят вокруг неё, только она не спит от переживания, от разрыва с любимым человеком.
This is a case where the translation is not accurate.
'Clipping' means that electronics are driven beyond their ability to reproduce a clean soundwave. The peaks of the soundwave are clipped off.
Thanks and like for reaction to a divine Diana!
It is always a pleasure!
Спасибо😍🥰😘
You dropped a lot of good insight in this video, especially about the audio spotlight and the subjectiveness of music. Keep up the good work!!
Thanks man, it always fun in a video when I get to go on about the more technical side of music!
Interesting take on mixing, I kinda agree with you. Can you also check "Baikal" from Diana? I'd like to hear your point on that song in terms of mixing, too. Always a delight to hear technical people's pov.
Слова Марины Цветаевой (1916). музыка Брендон Стоун
short video ruclips.net/user/shortsWm2VhyCU4QI
Стихотворение Марины Цветаевой 1916 г. "Ночь в моем огромном городе...", наполненное мистицизмом, воспоминаниями и нелюбовью к повседневной жизни, входит в цикл "Бессонница".
Thank you!
Professional reactions are really necessary.
There's 'something' sometimes in her tracks doesn't let enjoy her voice.
I don't see many "defensive" Diana fans here...most are pretty sophisticated, decent people. Russians are very straight forward people though...translations can make things look more toxic that it is intended. Both ways really. Enjoyed it.
That was probably a knee jerk reaction on my part, in the past when I have said anything close to criticism of an artist I would get torn to shreds. But it is nice to know that is not the case with Diana's fans!
All right! Agree!
Diana Ankudinova "In My Huge City"(jazz/rock version) Диана Анкудинова "B огромном городе"(джаз/рок)
ruclips.net/video/mWVU2DjSMCY/видео.html
Ещё раз, для тех "кто в танке" (упрямых и слабоумных): "ЭТО *СТУДИЙНАЯ ЗАПИСЬ,* СДЕЛАННАЯ АБСОЛЮТНО ТОЧНО В СООТВЕТСТВИИ С ХУДОЖЕСТВЕННЫМ ЗАМЫСЛОМ АВТОРОВ! БЕЗ КАКИХ ЛИБО ТЕХНИЧЕСКИХ ИЗЪЯНОВ И НЕИСПРАВНОСТИ АППАРАТУРЫ ЗВУКОЗАПИСИ! В НЕЙ И ГРОМКИЙ СТУК СЕРДЦА, И НАМЕРЕННЫЕ ИСКАЖЕНИЯ, И ДРУГИЕ ЗВУКОВЫЕ ЭФФЕКТЫ ЯВЛЯЮТСЯ *СПЕЦИАЛЬНЫМИ ТВОРЧЕСКИМИ РЕШЕНИЯМИ АВТОРОВ!* Ну чего не понятно?" 😁
Скорее это звук настенных часов-ходиков, которые были в моде в то время, они как метроном, отчитывают такт и проходящее время...
@@ultrax2002 О творчестве Цветаевой спорят уже более 100 лет! -Пусть будут "ходики"...-
@@realityviewerXXI причем здесь поэт? Музыкальный выбор за автором музыки и звукорежиссёром студии звукозаписи - в данном случае это один человек, Стоун
@@ultrax2002 При том, что из песни слов не выкинуть! Музыка должна соответствовать лирике. Эти стихи под рок-н-ролл звучали бы странно...
PS Впрочем, "ходики" получились тоже странные - с рваным ритмом...
One of my favorite Diana performances! I don't hear any noise! And you: apart from talking about technical errors, you did not react in any other way! What exactly are you sitting down to react to: the performance or the technique! Shall we comment on your hat? you look like a ball of dough with it! But let's separate personal impressions from the main reason we are here! Luck
Honestly, I couldn’t watch the reaction to the end - you broke down the musical and song(!) work simply into musical components, destroying its integrity. As they say, learn the materiel - delve into the lyrics and then instead of “loud knocking sound, crackling sound”, etc. hear the beating of the pulse, heart, steps in a deserted night city, etc. At night all sounds and feelings intensify and become more acute... =It’s a pity, even though you tried, it turned out, no offense, the worst reaction (( In the finished work, the artist presents the image, and not the colors separately 😉🙂
Честно, не смогла досмотреть reaction до конца - разложил музыкально-песенное(!) произведение просто на музыкальные составляющие, разрушив его целостность. Как говорится, учите матчасть - вникайте в лирику и тогда вместо "громкого стука-звука, треска" и т.п. услышите биение пульса, сердца, шагов в пустынном ночном городе и т.д. В ночи все звуки, чувства усиливаются, обостряются... =Жаль, хоть и старался, но получилась, не в обиду, худшая reaction.В законченном произведении художник преподносит образ, а не краски по отдельности 😉🙂
От имени автора я приношу извинения за ваше разочарование такой реакцией.
Я специально попросил его проанализировать запись. Я беру на себя полную ответственность за ваше недовольство.
Искажение мешает мне наслаждаться этой замечательной песней и отличным исполнением.
Извините.
On behalf of the author, I apologize for your disappointment with this reaction.
I specifically asked him to analyze the recording. I take full responsibility for your displeasure.
The distortion interferes with my ability to enjoy this great song and great performance.
Sorry.
same song live with band ruclips.net/video/Sd8AZBE14H0/видео.html
Dude! *You are a very strange guy!* You are not the author of this music, are you? So why the hell are you criticising other people's work? Brandon Stone wrote the music and arrangement for that song. He made that sound what it is on this record. This is his authorial intent as he personally understands it. Maybe another composer would have done it differently, then the song would be different, not the same as you hear it now.
You criticise the recording as if you were standing next to the composer while he was writing the music, giving him advice that he did not follow.
*If you can compose music, write a song and offer it to Diana youself!* No joke! In this song, everything will be as you wish. 🙂
PS The "knocking" that irritates you is an intermittent heartbeat, one of the main metaphors for the artistic content of the song, part of its meaning, a creative discovery of the authors!
Вообще то произведение искусства не стоит разбирать по кирпичикам. Большинству людей, что смотрят Ваши реакции, совсем неинтересны Ваши профессиональные выкладки. Картину Джоконда уж как ни просвечивали, и как только не обсуждали, а загадка осталась. Чтобы было больше подписчиков, надо проявлять эмоции при прослушивании, а не знания. Бесплатный совет, однако
От имени автора я приношу извинения за ваше разочарование такой реакцией.
Я специально попросил его проанализировать запись. Я беру на себя полную ответственность за ваше недовольство.
Искажение мешает мне наслаждаться этой замечательной песней и отличным исполнением.
Извините.
On behalf of the author, I apologize for your disappointment with this reaction.
I specifically asked him to analyze the recording. I take full responsibility for your dissatisfaction.
Distortion prevents me from enjoying this wonderful song and excellent performance.
Sorry.