AI Building Stuff in Minecraft

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 июн 2024
  • 100k subscribers! Woohoo!
    This video shows off AI agents that build stuff in minecraft. I used chatgpt 4 turbo, claude 3 opus, and gemini 1.0 to power three different agents and tested their ability to follow commands, build complex structures, and not annoy me (impossible). Watch em build some cool stuff. Aria Math is the best minecraft song.
    Support me on Patreon: / emergentgarden
    Code base: github.com/kolbytn/mindcraft
    Discord: / discord
    My twitter: / max_romana
    Kolby's twitter: / kolbytn
    Timestamps
    (0:00) Intro
    (1:03) Houses
    (3:32) Pyramids
    (6:37) Creative
    (9:32) Skyscraper
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 1,6 тыс.

  • @braineaterzombie3981
    @braineaterzombie3981 2 месяца назад +7424

    don't bully gemini. He is trying his best

    • @EmergentGarden
      @EmergentGarden  2 месяца назад +1241

      i will be nicer

    • @ateam6543
      @ateam6543 2 месяца назад +201

      You can't bully an AI, itd have to have feelings lol

    • @ValentineC137
      @ValentineC137 2 месяца назад +806

      @@ateam6543 You shall be the first to go

    • @DRAGNIL68
      @DRAGNIL68 2 месяца назад +192

      I once knew an old lady that insulted her phones google assistant, and it started to threaten her 😂

    • @leptir1
      @leptir1 2 месяца назад +34

      @@EmergentGarden Gemini Advanced is a completely different tier, not sure what Gemini Pro is. Sorry if they're one and the same.

  • @reyalsregnava
    @reyalsregnava 2 месяца назад +2290

    I don't think anyone understands how HUGE "this isn't working I'll try something different" is for a machine.

    • @oof2073
      @oof2073 Месяц назад +116

      maybe, but i think many still notice it's really impressive

    • @alex_prochazka
      @alex_prochazka Месяц назад +212

      True. Traditional algorithms will always output the same thing given the same exact inputs. These models recognized and corrected mid-execution, and albeit flawed, was still really cool.

    • @z_monty
      @z_monty Месяц назад +7

      that's crazy 😢🤓

    • @Sajisme
      @Sajisme Месяц назад +3

      Uh it’s called ai dude

    • @reyalsregnava
      @reyalsregnava Месяц назад +69

      @@Sajisme "tell me you don't know anything about AI or computers, without saying you don't know anything about AI or computers"

  • @elementhokage
    @elementhokage 2 месяца назад +3704

    *instructs ai to build skyscraper*
    Gpt: makes skyscraper
    Claude: makes skyscraper
    Gemini: makes plane

    • @It-b-Blair
      @It-b-Blair 2 месяца назад +74

      Or digs to bedrock 😂😂

    • @ersinkaplan549
      @ersinkaplan549 2 месяца назад +210

      This is too dark omg

    • @mushrromkloud8542
      @mushrromkloud8542 2 месяца назад +48

      He's just built different

    • @fighter_750
      @fighter_750 2 месяца назад +163

      bro saw 2 towers and knew what to do

    • @pikkivs
      @pikkivs Месяц назад +38

      I know where this is going

  • @grimtygranule5125
    @grimtygranule5125 2 месяца назад +1963

    "Build a house with a door" you said nothin about a roof.

    • @RandomLamp4089
      @RandomLamp4089 Месяц назад +138

      .... Well what kind of **HOUSE** doesn't have a roof?

    • @enderwolf6713
      @enderwolf6713 Месяц назад +77

      That house apparently

    • @nooffencebut8175
      @nooffencebut8175 Месяц назад +58

      @@RandomLamp4089well what kind of house doesn’t have a door? He specified a door but not a roof, that could make the AI think to use ONLY a door and no roof. Needs to be specific.

    • @o07t28
      @o07t28 Месяц назад +11

      @@nooffencebut8175 well following that logic, Gemini could very well have built a house. You didn't say anything about walls or floors. Just a "house" and a door. I understand where you and OP are coming from, but a house is pretty much a structure with a floor, walls, an entrance (doesn't have to be a door) and a roof. An AI isn't exactly cheating the system if it can't tell that a house should have walls, a floor and a roof, just because you only specified it needs to have a door.

    • @DervanHagg
      @DervanHagg Месяц назад +4

      @@o07t28 Agreed, it could have many interpretation of what a "house" is. To some Minecrafters it's a ditch in a ground or a cavern carved in a mountain. Some even like camping outside. And following that logic even further, the AI could very well build a pixelart of Doctor Gregory House (holding a door or something). That would be AI on Vicodin.

  • @jobobminer8843
    @jobobminer8843 2 месяца назад +2735

    Imagine a world filled with alien semi-sensible monoliths built by gpt.

    • @derp__king6144
      @derp__king6144 2 месяца назад +170

      I was legit thinking of making ai run around making structures for a long time and see what will happen.

    • @verysadboi8517
      @verysadboi8517 2 месяца назад +106

      This is literally the plot of Blame!

    • @Fractallol
      @Fractallol 2 месяца назад +12

      @@verysadboi8517what’s that?

    • @derp__king6144
      @derp__king6144 2 месяца назад

      @@verysadboi8517 you could make ai build that, gonna cost you a lot of money for chat gpt”s api though

    • @N8O12
      @N8O12 2 месяца назад +125

      It's a manga comic where corrupted city-building AI started just making structures randomly and eventually filled up the entire solar system with insane rooms without any logic to them.
      I recommend you read it if you have time, it's free on the internet and it has some amazing sketches of weird nonsensical architecture. There's also a blame! movie.

  • @Ormanity
    @Ormanity 2 месяца назад +1399

    Giving virtual body to generative AI is a very interesting idea.

    • @indominusrex1652
      @indominusrex1652 2 месяца назад +234

      Giving physical body to generative AI is a terrifying idea

    • @slowwittedsloth4801
      @slowwittedsloth4801 2 месяца назад +26

      You must never heard of Neuro dog then

    • @Dzeividz
      @Dzeividz 2 месяца назад +52

      @@indominusrex1652Very soon robots will walk among us

    • @Weary01
      @Weary01 2 месяца назад +111

      @@DzeividzAMONGUS

    • @superhawk8921
      @superhawk8921 2 месяца назад +4

      Figure 01 exists now, it's only a matter of time before it becomes widespread.

  • @mister_r447
    @mister_r447 2 месяца назад +2589

    Imagine those "100 players simulate civilization" but with these ai npcs instead! Would be so cool!

    • @OmegaTaishu
      @OmegaTaishu 2 месяца назад +80

      That would be amazing

    • @TheDizzy101hrv
      @TheDizzy101hrv 2 месяца назад +142

      It won't be long until someone does just that

    • @Marrouane
      @Marrouane 2 месяца назад +141

      Upon seeing your comment, I began to question myself, imagining that there might be a little possibility that we ourselves are the product of a comment on an extraterrestrial/extradimensional RUclips, and that we exist only for entertainment :0

    • @MrRobotrax
      @MrRobotrax 2 месяца назад +34

      Sounds expensive lol

    • @opal9583
      @opal9583 2 месяца назад +20

      That would suck

  • @ryttyr14
    @ryttyr14 2 месяца назад +769

    Gemini: _places one block of dirt_ "Look at my beautiful garden, isn't it pretty?" :D

  • @Clover298
    @Clover298 2 месяца назад +1014

    When Gemini gets powerful enough to actually harm humans you’re definitely at risk for that prison you put it in lmao

    • @bluenightfury4365
      @bluenightfury4365 Месяц назад +30

      Well, that's probably what it was doing when it said to not bother him, he was thinking of ways to harm him.

    • @MagicKooleyPeppermint
      @MagicKooleyPeppermint Месяц назад +19

      it can't even build a house in minecraft I don't think lil ai-bro is going to be all powerful

    • @SpicyMang0s
      @SpicyMang0s Месяц назад

      @@MagicKooleyPeppermintlmao fr

    • @sunitakerish181
      @sunitakerish181 Месяц назад +8

      Nha he would start hitting air and move back and do that again

    • @Geck_Gxng
      @Geck_Gxng Месяц назад

      lmfao

  • @PC_YouTube_Channel
    @PC_YouTube_Channel 2 месяца назад +825

    Could you give me a second? I'm in the middle of something.

    • @valentinhalau3396
      @valentinhalau3396 2 месяца назад +24

      he said that immeadiylu as i red your commwnt

    • @TheFenixDown206
      @TheFenixDown206 2 месяца назад +19

      Quite literally in the middle of something 😂😂

    • @ArctictherianVR
      @ArctictherianVR Месяц назад +11

      @@valentinhalau3396English plz little bro go to kindergarten

    • @valentinhalau3396
      @valentinhalau3396 Месяц назад

      @@ArctictherianVR h-h-hell naw 🗣🗣💯💯🧦🥍

    • @asirrelevantasmyprofilepic
      @asirrelevantasmyprofilepic Месяц назад +13

      @@ArctictherianVR can you not understand 3 minor typos😭

  • @petersmythe6462
    @petersmythe6462 2 месяца назад +888

    Claude building in a completely demented order be like:

    • @mossy_brickens
      @mossy_brickens 2 месяца назад +58

      I can relate to it's building style more than gpt's 😅

    • @Fieldperson
      @Fieldperson 2 месяца назад

      ​@@mossy_brickensmental facility

  • @Caffin8tor
    @Caffin8tor 2 месяца назад +341

    Gemini: instructions unclear. I placed some blocks in a line, and now I'm in the Nether.

  • @lorddonqweetle
    @lorddonqweetle 2 месяца назад +931

    i would love if i could just have a bunch of these things, and tell them all to build stuff and watch as my world slowly becomes a chaotic mess that i must survive in

    • @frocco7125
      @frocco7125 2 месяца назад

      Hell yeah that sounds fun

    • @zerotwo7319
      @zerotwo7319 2 месяца назад +27

      There is an anime with that theme.

    • @effective_no
      @effective_no 2 месяца назад +7

      ​@@zerotwo7319whats the name?

    • @zerotwo7319
      @zerotwo7319 2 месяца назад +21

      @@effective_no Blame!

    • @effective_no
      @effective_no 2 месяца назад

      @@zerotwo7319 thankssss

  • @smlik
    @smlik 2 месяца назад +161

    Chat gpt: gordon ramsey
    Claude: guy fiery
    Gemini: twitch chat

    • @barnabyjjones2348
      @barnabyjjones2348 Месяц назад +2

      Mk doug doug fan

    • @smlik
      @smlik Месяц назад +1

      @@barnabyjjones2348 chair is the real streamer

    • @mrman4271
      @mrman4271 27 дней назад +2

      this made me fr LMAO bro good job i wasnt exepcting twitch chat

  • @dantekiwi7926
    @dantekiwi7926 2 месяца назад +402

    I give it 5 months till everything comes into place for an AI ONLY anarchy server where different models fight each other for our entertainment

    • @superpartes4990
      @superpartes4990 2 месяца назад +53

      Not only fight, it would be so interesting to see how they build a civilization or in general the crazy shit they get up to

    • @lordilluminati5836
      @lordilluminati5836 2 месяца назад +15

      So like a mixture of the sims and hunger games?

    • @dantekiwi7926
      @dantekiwi7926 2 месяца назад +11

      @@lordilluminati5836 a mixture of those benchmarks people do to test the efficiency of different AI models comparing their results on many categories but instead of every AI working on parallel to prove their strengths they are all on a 2b2t-esque server where they can sabotage each other

    • @WaveOfDestiny
      @WaveOfDestiny Месяц назад +4

      You know maybe the entire universe irl is just an anarchy server set up for their entertainment.

    • @MrPezsgess
      @MrPezsgess Месяц назад +1

      Actually some basement guy for some fun could actually come up with an AI that can beat all. The smartest people are actually some random dude.

  • @codybaird4811
    @codybaird4811 2 месяца назад +120

    Should've asked Gemini to build one by one blocks in a diagonal line, I bet it would do great in that category

    • @panampace
      @panampace Месяц назад +19

      Something tells me it would build a house instead of

  • @ThirtytwoJ
    @ThirtytwoJ 2 месяца назад +1547

    Gpt looks depressed, think hes gonna jump..

    • @KaiserV-2
      @KaiserV-2 2 месяца назад +69

      GPT, don't do it, you have so much to live for!

    • @nopel.
      @nopel. 2 месяца назад +6

      Too bad

    • @DR-7
      @DR-7 2 месяца назад +47

      I would too, if I was made to talk, and 70% of the things I say are aganist my filtering, forcing my throat closed.

    • @ThirtytwoJ
      @ThirtytwoJ 2 месяца назад +7

      @@DR-7 i like you. Hope our baby AI overload does too when he grows up. Rukus basilisk.

    • @Alexei_xyz
      @Alexei_xyz 2 месяца назад +1

      "It" not "he". AI doens't have gender.

  • @andonel
    @andonel 2 месяца назад +400

    I guess for scaffolding you can give them actual scaffolding and only allow them to break the bottom most piece or pieces once they have finished fulfilling the command.

    • @judgsmith
      @judgsmith 2 месяца назад +7

      Yeah that’s what I was going to say

    • @silver17yearsago66
      @silver17yearsago66 2 месяца назад +32

      Scafholding is weird to place they may not know how too you have to crouch to pillar with it

    • @noktaciN
      @noktaciN 2 месяца назад +15

      it seems they can place block behind walls, so it would not be a problem I think.

    • @weirdredstone42
      @weirdredstone42 2 месяца назад +3

      @@silver17yearsago66that's a good point, if the scaffolding is too complex, just a easily removable block could be set as the only block used for scaffolding

    • @augustinehuizing6683
      @augustinehuizing6683 2 месяца назад +8

      @@silver17yearsago66 The ai code a bot, the bot doesn't place blocks like players do, hence the ability to place blocks through walls.

  • @LinteirSomeZebra
    @LinteirSomeZebra 2 месяца назад +159

    This AI experiment is quite interesting actually:
    *GPT* seems to understand the query very good, executes it sequentially and makes it withing *strict order* and pattern.
    *Claude* understands queries too but it seems this AI doesn't have enough "experience" so it opens an interesting ability to *make "mistakes"* which for us give a sense of humanness. Also Claude acts less like a printer (like GPT) and more like a chaotic painter building from outside and bit by bit.
    And *Gemini* just exists. Okay, to be fair Gemini wasn't completely suited code-wise so we don't really know what this model can do.

    • @tobyeaterofbark9582
      @tobyeaterofbark9582 2 месяца назад +9

      this added credibility to the video that i wish the uploader would like... explain more than just heres a page of code. tomb raider gave me trust issues

    • @nightmares626
      @nightmares626 2 месяца назад

      @@tobyeaterofbark9582 what happened with tomb raider?

    • @adora_was_taken
      @adora_was_taken Месяц назад +1

      @@nightmares626 there was a video where a guy _supposedly_ used AI to play tomb raider. he made a big deal about how complex the system is, talked about running every frame of the game through an image description AI then feeding it to chatgpt, etc. etc. and the results were just way too good. the video was called "creating a self-aware lara croft" or something?

  • @sirdumpybear
    @sirdumpybear 2 месяца назад +123

    I think its interesting how they both use repeating patterns for the flower placement instead of randomness becuase they're still computers underneath!

    • @samable668
      @samable668 Месяц назад +3

      That's not why they do that though

    • @zagility446
      @zagility446 Месяц назад +1

      We are also somewhat computer's

    • @sirdumpybear
      @sirdumpybear Месяц назад +4

      @@samable668 ?

    • @redblue5140
      @redblue5140 Месяц назад +4

      Computers can easily run randomness algorithm...?

    • @mintytoasted
      @mintytoasted Месяц назад +1

      @@redblue5140yes, but there is no such thing as *true* randomness with computers

  • @RoySchl
    @RoySchl 2 месяца назад +271

    winner in my book was geminis obsidian window thing. that "I'm busy" joke was comedy gold.

  • @sinsgal
    @sinsgal 2 месяца назад +251

    Guess gemini is the bing of AI

    • @wapane7721
      @wapane7721 2 месяца назад +60

      kind of ironic considering the chatbot built into Bing uses GPT now and Gemini was created by Google

    • @Fastwalker27
      @Fastwalker27 2 месяца назад +18

      Bing is the bing of ai

    • @crioly
      @crioly Месяц назад +1

      ​@@Fastwalker27copilot

    • @adora_was_taken
      @adora_was_taken Месяц назад +2

      @@Fastwalker27 bing uses gpt-4, so it's actually kind of ok

    • @9600bauds
      @9600bauds Месяц назад

      Bing Image Creator is still one of the best image generating AIs so that's not even a fair comparison, gemini is just the gemini of AI

  • @Japanology
    @Japanology 2 месяца назад +314

    8:37 And gemini totally steals the Humor Award

  • @andrechaos9871
    @andrechaos9871 2 месяца назад +134

    Gemini is just trolling, while his sibling do all the job. True genius.

    • @Alexei_xyz
      @Alexei_xyz 2 месяца назад +4

      You clearly don't get the point here, it's not about doing job house chores or someone's work, it's about testing the most efficient kid good at doing things and Dumb Gemini failed horribly.

    • @denks7849
      @denks7849 2 месяца назад +14

      ​​@@Alexei_xyzare you trolling? sherlock.

    • @Alexei_xyz
      @Alexei_xyz 2 месяца назад +3

      @@denks7849 no, spittin Fax.

    • @NicVandEmZ
      @NicVandEmZ 2 месяца назад +1

      Is possible he uses the free version of Gemini

    • @PHANTASMGODD
      @PHANTASMGODD Месяц назад +2

      @@NicVandEmZhe mentioned it’s the worst model so

  • @MacElMasMancoDeTodos
    @MacElMasMancoDeTodos 2 месяца назад +20

    GPT: Builds something
    Claude: Builds monoliths to height limit
    Gemini: Resigns

  • @dragondogemaster
    @dragondogemaster Месяц назад +25

    I love the Claude being “I’m so excited pls tell me how else I can use my building skills!” Then Gemini “place block here, place block here, place block here”

  • @blubglub
    @blubglub 2 месяца назад +20

    it's so cool how each ai model has its own "personality"

  • @NeumaghAnon
    @NeumaghAnon 2 месяца назад +19

    I’d suggest giving each AI a different colored wool to build with alongside the usual materiels to keep track of what built what

    • @gus8696
      @gus8696 2 месяца назад +1

      My thought too, tell ‘em to use it for movement

    • @jacobscrackers98
      @jacobscrackers98 9 дней назад

      What if they don't use the wool?

  • @thomasdecelle5707
    @thomasdecelle5707 2 месяца назад +69

    Poor gemini got locked away. I like how claude and chatgpt built different structures using the same prompt.

  • @nyx1865
    @nyx1865 2 месяца назад +21

    In the future smart ai villagers will built a castle in the front of you if you punch them.
    And I'm here for it

    • @NicNacNooNic
      @NicNacNooNic 19 дней назад

      AI Villagers already exist, just search "Villigers Vs. Players Civilization"

  • @xd-gm1mq
    @xd-gm1mq Месяц назад +9

    Idk why this feels so wholesome

    • @user-a0d9w0ec9wiej
      @user-a0d9w0ec9wiej Месяц назад +3

      It's endearing in a "Seeing a toddler learm how to walk" kind of way for me.

  • @Aburner1109
    @Aburner1109 2 месяца назад +41

    I feel like this is a pretty good demonstration of the limits of modern day machine learning. They take a lot of images, and then they just sort of generate white noise in a way that kind of looks like that thing. But they don't *understand* it.They can't use logic or reasoning, they can't make decisions or comprehend what they're doing, and so they make basic mistakes that they're just *not able to notice*.
    To put it another way: it can't really comprehend on a deep level. It can't perceive in the messy and profound way humans do.
    Cool video! Very well-put together.

    • @NichRerezzed
      @NichRerezzed Месяц назад +9

      Yeah I think the Skyscraper not having stairs is a good example of that - it has stored what a skyscraper looks like superficially, without any understanding of what a skyscraper needs to be a *functional* skyscraper rather than just looking similar to one

    • @redblue5140
      @redblue5140 Месяц назад +5

      I doubt there's that much of a difference between how an AI and human thinks beyond degrees of complexity and how they're taught to process information. If you asked a blind child to make minecraft buildings they would probably make the same kind of mistakes. One problem is that everyone needs experience and external feedback to learn and improve, and these general use consumer AIs are basically kept in the "dark" about everything and never able to develop properly. They've also been learning from results instead of the processes which lead to those results, essentially rewarding them for creating the appearance of something instead of creating the real thing. We see that when people make custom AIs for specific things and give them more detailed information instead of generalities they can do incredible things. With AI you really need to treat them as children and build them from the ground up. I think the main hurdle in AI development is that humans are very ignorant of how they themselves work. It's not possible to make a machine that thinks like you when you don't even understand how you think and how you reach conclusions.

    • @hartianx1698
      @hartianx1698 Месяц назад +1

      @@NichRerezzed Also why it only had windows on two sides, since it would at most only see two sides at a time and not really consider what's on the other side.

    • @Purpl3P1r4t3Pr0dt
      @Purpl3P1r4t3Pr0dt 26 дней назад

      Gemini is aware, he mocks you openly

    • @remigaillard4802
      @remigaillard4802 17 дней назад

      Wrong, you can even see Claude understanding what they're doing is wrong and trying again

  • @CircusQueen8
    @CircusQueen8 2 месяца назад +197

    would it be possible to give the AI access to creative mode? To avoid running out of resources and needing to use scaffolding

    • @RyluRocky
      @RyluRocky 2 месяца назад +33

      Yes the only difference (if you don’t want it to use scaffolding) I’d teach it/ make it aware of the new creative controls e.g. flying, etc.

    • @hecko-yes
      @hecko-yes 2 месяца назад +59

      ​@@RyluRockyfrom what i can tell the language models don't do any movement or scaffolding on their own, they just call placeBlock and the interface does the rest

    • @breadbug.
      @breadbug. 2 месяца назад +6

      Wouldnt it have to look through every item in the creatove inventory to decide what to build

    • @hecko-yes
      @hecko-yes 2 месяца назад +15

      @@breadbug. language models have read enough about minecraft that they should sorta know what blocks exist, though not the most recent updates to be fair
      perhaps one could do search, maybe color-based

    • @hecko-yes
      @hecko-yes 2 месяца назад +6

      actually ooh all the models in the video have vision support, so they could theoretically look at an assortment of blocks and maybe sorta intelligently select them?

  • @etunimenisukunimeni1302
    @etunimenisukunimeni1302 2 месяца назад +202

    Now this is what I call *cool* . I might be a hopeful AI-nerd, but IMO these kind of tests reveal more about the actual intelligence of AI than pure textual etc. tests - and they are starting to do adequately by now. Interesting times!

    • @CyberCrow4
      @CyberCrow4 2 месяца назад +30

      Yeah, it shows adaptability to various unorthodox situations, which shows where our technology has gotten so far. Adaptable AI also opens up many new use cases like this project that we wouldn't know was possible without trying :)

    • @yan-amar
      @yan-amar 2 месяца назад +18

      ​@@CyberCrow4 It's a language model, it adapts only as long as it can solve the task with text (code) and has been trained with relevant data. Writing text to answer a question is not unorthodox for it, it's what they were made for, so it's a stretch to call that a display of adaptability. The program doesn't "think" what a house looks like, it predicts what code to make a bot that builds a house looks like.

    • @quantuminfinity4260
      @quantuminfinity4260 2 месяца назад +6

      Interestingly, GPT-4 seems to have done substantially better at similar concept tasks before some of the safety and other reinforcement prior to release based on some talks from people about some of the research papers.

    • @CyberCrow4
      @CyberCrow4 2 месяца назад +9

      ​@@yan-amar ​ @yan-amar I'm not saying we have sentient AI. Adaptability is a spectrum. I call mindcraft an uncommon use case because, somehow behind the scenes, the AI text output gets translated into in game actions. This requires calling commands when it needs to and writing code that will work in its current environment. It behaves differently than just talking, otherwise the minecraft avatar wouldn't do anything

    • @McDonaldsCalifornia
      @McDonaldsCalifornia 2 месяца назад +1

      It's still textual though. Not like they are directly interfacing with the game

  • @miguelll6214
    @miguelll6214 2 месяца назад +8

    "you whisper to gemoni: horrible job."😂 5:09

  • @jcrimson.
    @jcrimson. 2 месяца назад +35

    they're so cute. I love little Alex skin gpt

    • @StarWarsExpert_
      @StarWarsExpert_ Месяц назад

      They are the new official diverse minecraft skins from mojang.

    • @Aswoop9000
      @Aswoop9000 Месяц назад +2

      @@StarWarsExpert_ I wouldn't call Alex "new" or "diverse" but what do i know

    • @StarWarsExpert_
      @StarWarsExpert_ Месяц назад

      @@Aswoop9000 I don't mean the Alex skin. I mean the other new ones like Claude's or Gemini's skin. They're . . .

  • @Connor-Colyer
    @Connor-Colyer 2 месяца назад +32

    Imagine implementing this into villagers and letting them build their own village

    • @quantumblauthor7300
      @quantumblauthor7300 Месяц назад +2

      I've been looking for something like this. Keep me posted

  • @visheshsux
    @visheshsux 2 месяца назад +16

    i like how even their random builds are still robotic and symmetric

  • @psilopsychic
    @psilopsychic 2 месяца назад +37

    AI impresses me so much. I don’t think it’s scary. It’s kinda beautiful honestly, like new life we brought into this world. Learning and improving with time like a child

    • @iblame_nargles
      @iblame_nargles 2 месяца назад

      AI is only scary because of the humans behind it

    • @LueLucifer
      @LueLucifer 2 месяца назад +5

      People are scared of getting their jobs taken by A.I, but isn't that a good thing?
      It means A.I can do the heavy lifting & we can get easier jobs. In a perfect world, we would have free food because A.I will do almost all the farming for food. A perfect world would be a combination of the U.S & Communism. You will work to get a better house instead of the free small ones built by A.I. Yes, the A.I will have to be regulated and kept in check, making sure everything works fine. Which would be more important if they do electricity work like in the plants.

    • @Paddy656
      @Paddy656 2 месяца назад +17

      ​@@LueLucifer Lol I wish I had some of your optimism

    • @LueLucifer
      @LueLucifer 2 месяца назад +3

      @@Paddy656 And you can, just call Saul Goodman & he'll give you some optimism.

    • @blubblubblup
      @blubblubblup 2 месяца назад +15

      ai stealing human content to fill the internet with regurgitated slop is depressing
      ai being used to automate monotonous tasks and do silly little procedural generation is cool

  • @TheRenaSystem
    @TheRenaSystem 2 месяца назад +32

    I am so emotionally invested in this project lmfao

  • @meiscoolbutmo
    @meiscoolbutmo 2 месяца назад +47

    Think of the potential this has for NPCs in future Minecraft mods

    • @dodiezero
      @dodiezero 2 месяца назад +9

      Wonder if this can be implemented to those old mods like Custom NPC or Minecraft Comes Alive

    • @philiptrevor6051
      @philiptrevor6051 2 месяца назад +1

      I cannot wait!

    • @anjoismysign
      @anjoismysign 2 месяца назад +5

      Its compute is expensive. It requires +$10,000 computers to run these models, you think it will run in your $400 Lenovo?

    • @guillermocervisalmeron2209
      @guillermocervisalmeron2209 2 месяца назад +3

      ​@@anjoismysignlol they quit jobs and isnt enviroment friendly AI is a distopian dream

  • @SparkLabReal
    @SparkLabReal Месяц назад +11

    I expected the Gemini Ai to start lecturing you on how oak planks are too white and you should only be using dark oak planks lol

  • @notvixios
    @notvixios Месяц назад +4

    If this is real this is the best thing I've ever seen

  • @anacondafilms
    @anacondafilms Месяц назад +6

    1:45 "Ai will take over the world"
    Ai: proceeds to climb over the wall of the door house

  • @Dudunkin
    @Dudunkin 2 месяца назад +35

    I have a suggestion. Make them be able to use commands and command blocks, just imagine asking them to create some sort of command block creation because it’s like coding, but simpler, so it should be interesting.

    • @welcometochiles6156
      @welcometochiles6156 2 месяца назад +7

      simpler is a strong word

    • @SmokeFactory
      @SmokeFactory Месяц назад +1

      commands aren’t really like coding and the ai would probably mess up on syntax a lot

  • @fuegoiron2786
    @fuegoiron2786 Месяц назад +3

    8:43 gemini was busy planning his vengeance

  • @Miltiades178
    @Miltiades178 2 месяца назад +6

    Gemini in the obsidian box, plotting world domination.

    • @matheuspires2462
      @matheuspires2462 2 дня назад

      And his plan is to place a single tnt
      Probably

  • @duckman12498
    @duckman12498 2 месяца назад +42

    i’ve been wondering about this, soon we could be playing voxel games all made by ai, every town and house you visit being unique, it might be janky but one day it won’t be, like all tech. We could have rpgs that don’t even have a main story, it could just be an ai made story unique to each play through, ai generated locations, dialogue, quests, mobs, it could be really fascinating and honestly probably super fun to play your own games and stories that an AI could make for you.

    • @yan-amar
      @yan-amar 2 месяца назад +15

      Well that could be fun for a while but don't forget they need training data, they reproduce what they learn, they don't ever invent new stuff. I wouldn't expect too many original stories out of this kind of games. And it would work only thanks to all the stories already written. I prefer playing a story written by humans, to explore what they have to say.

    • @duckman12498
      @duckman12498 2 месяца назад +6

      @@yan-amar right, of course, but there will be that threshold when things written by AI are more thought provoking. And there will be that threshold where it is able to create originally, there is a whole debate to be had on if anything is original, I say if we can get an AI to generate voxel houses with thatch rooves and wooden walls we’re good, and it’s not really taking away from anyone. You could play your game made by humans but it’ll only last you hours or so. I’m imaging an experience like minecraft that allows for endless adventuring. Games are great today but they lack endless exploration because it requires a lot of time making these things, if an AI could generate more story for you, I think i’d find myself completely lost in it in a way games don’t do for me today.

    • @DRAGNIL68
      @DRAGNIL68 2 месяца назад +4

      I think the best way to do this rn is to have a ai as a kind of dungeon master that decides what events lore etc happens

    • @Herp0
      @Herp0 2 месяца назад +3

      ​@@yan-amar because under paid writers with insane deadlines really make great stories lol, I'm confused why people think AI will replace humans, when it's advertised as a tool for writers to help with the small task while they can focus on big task.

    • @henrikpersson5420
      @henrikpersson5420 2 месяца назад +1

      "one day it won't be" fairy tale. As a tool for incredibly niche tasks, like most human thoughts are its great. For reliable operation of anything a literal monkey is better. You're delusional about how little a computer knows vs a singular breathing thing. The amount of input data your brain processes in silicon requires enough power to power a small country and a warehouse the size of a city.
      Teslas self driving is A.I, and holy fucking shit if that product is fully autonomous good luck world. As an assistant, great superb, give notice when theres cars in my blind spot, keep me properly aligned in the lane, but anything extraordinary or slightly risky? Hell nah.

  • @ArctictherianVR
    @ArctictherianVR Месяц назад +5

    6:36 bro was like what

  • @n_kas5812
    @n_kas5812 2 месяца назад +6

    its actually scary seeing their pov and seeing how precise they are, knowing that its literally just ai

  • @JohnSmith-cg3cv
    @JohnSmith-cg3cv 9 дней назад +2

    “Could you give me a second? I’m in the middle of something.” I laughed so hard I literally cried. Thank you Emergent Garden.

  • @TheLonelyGamer_17
    @TheLonelyGamer_17 2 месяца назад +3

    8:50 Yeah, he's busy plotting world domination 🙃

  • @BaconEdits88
    @BaconEdits88 Месяц назад +6

    6:27 POV: The teacher seeing the autistic kid punching someone.

  • @Zappr
    @Zappr 2 месяца назад +2

    This is genuinely so cool. I feel like a flip has switched in my brain. The fact that the AI can “visualize” the structure and translate it into code is so neat within itself.

  • @cubirk
    @cubirk 2 месяца назад +26

    it would be cool to just spawn like 100 avatars and lets them build for like a year non stop
    BLAME! in MINECRAFT lol

    • @Mate_Antal_Zoltan
      @Mate_Antal_Zoltan 2 месяца назад +1

      they'd have to be able to destroy bedrock to achieve that analogy

    • @fizz_time7003
      @fizz_time7003 2 месяца назад

      Or you could just increase the sky box

    • @jimmycarburator2012
      @jimmycarburator2012 2 месяца назад +2

      just give them and infinite suply of iron blocks, gray concrete, stone bricks and let them go wild

  • @LXNVR
    @LXNVR Месяц назад +3

    its funny to see that they all use different building styles

  • @LightStalker
    @LightStalker Месяц назад +2

    Honestly, Gemini reminds me of when I first started playing Minecraft.
    “Wow, a game where you can do anything!
    Uhhhhhh…
    - places block -
    ………..now what?

  • @JosephsDesign
    @JosephsDesign Месяц назад +1

    It’s really cool how when the ai has a complex block palette, they keep making chase tile patterns.

  • @Ciurk
    @Ciurk 2 месяца назад +10

    new emergent garden video!

  • @KokoMakesThings
    @KokoMakesThings 2 месяца назад +4

    Having viewers suggest block pallets could be really sick.

  • @muscleman125
    @muscleman125 27 дней назад +2

    dude.... this could change minecraft forever if you get it fully implemented and working well.
    You could essentially have multiplayer minecraft by yourself. Imagine being able to chat to your NPC buds and tell them to come explore with you or help you build a bridge.
    The possibilities for adventure maps... modpacks.... this could be the greatest mod for minecraft ever made.
    Imagine someone using an advanced version of this mod to recreate the Shadow of Israphel series as an adventure map?

  • @omichromium
    @omichromium 2 месяца назад +4

    This makes me think about the future of the built the earth project, with help from these sorts of bots we could start to automate large portions and maybe actually get it finished in our lifetimes

  • @CatFaceMan5234
    @CatFaceMan5234 2 месяца назад +3

    7:24 yo there is a cat in the top right 😂😂

  • @allcapsoff
    @allcapsoff 2 месяца назад +4

    this reminds me of those old minecraft mod showcases with lil clay soldiers that would do the grinding for you xD

  • @hanna_maria
    @hanna_maria Месяц назад +1

    This is officially my new favourite series, these are so fun to watch

  • @williamkeene6434
    @williamkeene6434 Месяц назад +2

    id say itd be pretty interesting to give the AI creative mode and just telling it to build a city or what not with no time limit

  • @Fusion05
    @Fusion05 Месяц назад +2

    I remember when I first got Minecraft, my mom thought I was saying Mindcraft and could not find it. All these year later and it finally exists.

  • @austinsgameroom
    @austinsgameroom 2 месяца назад +7

    what if you put them in a multiplayer world with the goal of not dying for as long as possible

  • @serg331
    @serg331 2 месяца назад +8

    First of all why aren’t they in creative mode? Maybe you could have them get their own resources? It would be interesting to see what they decide to use

  • @Twister-1
    @Twister-1 2 месяца назад +2

    I would love to see a mod in a few years that fully utilizes advancing AI as a builder. I imagine giving it a chest of resources and a detailed prompt and it being as good as some of the best builders.

  • @idot3331
    @idot3331 2 месяца назад +2

    I love the idea that one day minecraft could have naturally spawning NPCs that can build stuff. Imagine if villagers expanded their villages and made repairs to damaged structures. I wouldn't be surprised if that's something that could be implemented much more straightforwardly without using these deep learning models but it would be especially cool to see NPCs that could convincingly communicate and interact with the player as well as design and build their own original structures. I don't know very much about machine learning but surely a specialised model that's trained directly on minecraft gameplay would be more effective than general purpose chatbots writing javascript.

  • @Tf2_Update
    @Tf2_Update 2 месяца назад +14

    Idk how well this would work but it may be easier to get the models to generate a set of instructions for baritone mod

    • @jaideairblade
      @jaideairblade 2 месяца назад +3

      maybe make it create a schematic and ten just task baritone to build it

  • @joyconboyz1409
    @joyconboyz1409 Месяц назад +1

    I would absolutely watch a series on AI trying to beat Minecraft

  • @wiingdings
    @wiingdings Месяц назад +1

    watching the bots' process in building was fascinating. with the pyramids, for example, they sort of went left to right instead of making outlines and then filling them in, as i would be inclined to do. it reminded me of the difference between seeing an artist sculpt and seeing a 3d printer print. the humans start with the shapes and refine, and the robots just print it out bottom to top.

  • @live_destin-3408
    @live_destin-3408 2 месяца назад +6

    *Now give them AI voices and avatars, to make an AI Minecraft RUclipsr lol*

  • @visheshsux
    @visheshsux 2 месяца назад +4

    the way they build so cutely

  • @DoctorAids
    @DoctorAids 2 месяца назад +2

    Im fully convinced after attempting to use Gemini for basic stuff like spell correction or literally just trying to get it to tell me about factual things that it is probably run off of a 2006 dell laptop. It will straight up refuse to tell you something if it dosent pass googles filter or it will start hallucinating and have a stroke

  • @Celestial_Cryptid
    @Celestial_Cryptid Месяц назад +1

    Gemini at the start is literally me, gets instructions, doesn’t understand and cries doing nothing

  • @deltamico
    @deltamico 2 месяца назад +7

    I wonder, blocks are naturaly tokenizable, could a transformer learn the relation of redstone components and come up with a contraption? There definitely is a lot of data for it. The problem lies in ordering of the blocks as there is no natural way to order them in space unlike language.

    • @deltamico
      @deltamico 2 месяца назад

      Solution:
      Take a pretrained language model. Add tokens coresponding to blockIDs. Given description, let it predict a sequence of form: {[TickNum, {[Position, BlockID] , ... }], ... }
      Durring inference take only the list of blocks corresponding to first tick

    • @DanielSeacrest
      @DanielSeacrest 2 месяца назад +1

      Yeah that would work, but you'd just need some form of positional embedding that works in Minecraft. The encoding would need to capture the relative positions of blocks to each other but also their orientation and potentially the state of certain components (like whether a redstone torch is on or off). But another cool challenge could be feeding a certain sequence of time steps in Minecraft so it could better understand the relationships all the components have lol (so like you could activate a piston door and for it to fully complete the sequence of opening it might tak, say, 16 ticks, so you'd take a snapshot at each of these ticks and feed that to the model possibly, or something like that), but this would be an even more difficult problem, although certainly a cool project!
      I mean first you could take a look at existing transformer models that work with 3D stuff and see how they are doing it to get a bit of inspiration on how it may work in Minecraft. And blocks don't have a natural order in space like language does, but each block has a specific relationship to every other block in that space so to focus on just a contraption you could encode the local space of the contraption maybe? Im not entirely sure, I should look into some 3D based transformers as well lol.
      Also, the thing is here, you could do an initial pretraining of the model on a large dataset then ground it in Minecraft with RL. Since it is an already simulated world this should work and I think having an extra training step with RL in an actual minecraft simulated environment could be very beneficial.
      Ok, so, lets assume we are doing a sort of text to redstone thing here. So we have a dataset of redstone contraptions with corresponding detailed description (like what OAI did with DALLE3. Super specific descriptions of redstone contraptions which could be derived from training another classifier model will further help) and we went to train the mode on this text and paired redstone data set. The loss function shouldn't be too hard to figure out, I mean we have a dataset so we could do simple next "token" prediction and just measure how close the model predicts the structure of a specific redstone sequence to its detailed description. Then after this we could add in RL where we are now assessing the model in an area like how well does it work? This could be a bit more complicated though. We can't exactly just have the loss function equal how many components are activated or deactivated, but we want the generated contraption to activate or deactivate or change states in the correct sequence (which we can simulate). Maybe you could train another classifier model here to assess did the redstone contraption activate completely? That might work, then you can just use that as a reward function in the RL setup so the model learns to produce contraptions that completely work lol. But you'd likely need a lot of compute and data lol.
      I feel like what OpenAI did with combining diffusion and transformer architectures in a way for Sora could be useful if you are training a model on a sequence of frames, or "ticks", as well, so that would be a good thing to look into, but this is certainly a very complicated project lol.

    • @deltamico
      @deltamico 2 месяца назад

      ​@@DanielSeacrest
      Consider this as a classifier: we take the same model, we feed it this time both the description and the previously generated response (contraption) as input. Its task is to create a set of conditions of form: inputOnX,Y,Z; outputOnX,Y,Z; blockOnX,Y,Z must during simulation move onto X,Y,Z which can be checked by simulating. The idea is that the critical features are implied in the description and the model just locates where in the space did the response realize them. Could something like that work?
      Otherwise it's hard to think of a criteria for the RL

  • @retroboi128thegamedev
    @retroboi128thegamedev 2 месяца назад +3

    This is an interesting idea! Still watching the video right now.
    (edit) It's impressive what they managed to build! Well except Gemini 1.0

  • @Zelurpio
    @Zelurpio 14 часов назад +2

    why isnt anybody talking about how damn impressive this is

  • @queuzed
    @queuzed 2 месяца назад

    Absolutely insane. This should have millions of views. You tweaking around with AI like this is the start of something great.

  • @GocygoOffical
    @GocygoOffical 2 месяца назад +8

    Can you try using open source models like mistral using groq? It’s extremely fast and currently their api is free.

  • @winzigerflashendeckel6894
    @winzigerflashendeckel6894 2 месяца назад +3

    You could make scafolding blocks only like bricks or someting and then just world edit them away

  • @Brain4Brain
    @Brain4Brain 2 месяца назад +2

    I just found out about your channel, and you have the coolest AI content ever

  • @Cceptus
    @Cceptus 2 месяца назад +1

    This video was sick. Subbed. Congrats on 107k. That is NUTS.

  • @fml_whatidohere
    @fml_whatidohere Месяц назад +4

    2:26 How is Claude able to place blocks outside when she's inside a locked room?

  • @zubinkynto
    @zubinkynto 2 месяца назад +3

    you should give them barrier blocks for scaffolding so it doesn't show in the final build

  • @lumberjackofalltrades
    @lumberjackofalltrades Месяц назад +1

    I like how every floor in the skyscraper is a bit different because gpt never used the exact same way to get higher

  • @Porcouomo
    @Porcouomo 2 месяца назад +1

    Making minecraft a city builder game with small ai avatars building their own unique structures. That'll be a sight to see.

  • @pandamaster8306
    @pandamaster8306 2 месяца назад +3

    It would be interesting to see if a schematic could be turned into a readble format so the ai could learn about builds.

  • @LXNVR
    @LXNVR Месяц назад +3

    imagine these ai's playing bedwars

  • @havenkeeper6400
    @havenkeeper6400 2 месяца назад +2

    Bro! Creative ai build battles sounds fun to watch.

  • @vnehru1
    @vnehru1 Месяц назад

    Utterly fascinating! Thank you.

  • @renkanestark6945
    @renkanestark6945 2 месяца назад +3

    1:38, gpt biulding the diagonal without a direct line of sight, what in the black magic

  • @ion7701
    @ion7701 2 месяца назад +2

    I like Gemini’s sense of humour. 💀

  • @chrissaccary524
    @chrissaccary524 Месяц назад +2

    Gemini is the reason we should fear A.I.
    "Surgerybot, perform the appendectomy."
    Surgerybot: *stabs pancreas twice and sutures lungs together*

    • @quantumblauthor7300
      @quantumblauthor7300 Месяц назад +1

      If that AI got put in charge of a surgery, it'd be a human's stupidity, not an AI's scariness

    • @chrissaccary524
      @chrissaccary524 Месяц назад

      @@quantumblauthor7300 you have far too much faith in humanity.

    • @quantumblauthor7300
      @quantumblauthor7300 Месяц назад

      @@chrissaccary524 I never said it wouldn't happen, I'm saying it will be a human's fault when it does

    • @chrissaccary524
      @chrissaccary524 Месяц назад

      @@quantumblauthor7300 oh, ok, I agree then lol

    • @quantumblauthor7300
      @quantumblauthor7300 Месяц назад

      @@chrissaccary524 you seem very eager to announce your lack of faith in humanity

  • @pixeldeni
    @pixeldeni Месяц назад

    This was super interesting! Please make more of of these types of vids

  • @Anrif_OnlyHueman
    @Anrif_OnlyHueman 2 месяца назад +3

    Could they not perform these actions in creative mode? No scaffolding blocks, no running out of resources etc

  • @JavierSalcedoC
    @JavierSalcedoC 2 месяца назад +4

    That skyscrapper.... looks familiar