I really believe in this theory and I believe it applies to all the characters. An important question is this: why were these people drawn to the city? Simple, they are all reincarnations of past lives and they all must have some event in common where they were connected by some common karma. This may explain the moment in the series where knowing the Origin of this karma is the only way to free oneself. They are the children themselves who need to be saved. They need to remember where they came FROM.
@@cristinalima2455 aaaah I love this so much, all of my theories this one is my favorite. There’s so much proof and no coincidence in this show 🙏🙌 thanks for the comment
@@RahYisrael99 it still is believed they were once human. For all we know the baby in Fatima that wants to eat rotten food and blood can be them as a baby. Just theories.
The one thing that Harold said that really stuck with me was that when the writers were pitching the show, he said “they pitched it with the ending of the show”. They are building to something big
Well let's hope they mapped out a great story with a mind blowing reveal. Or it could be like lost where writers later admitted they were making up stuff as they go.
OK but that would be the word for word line to hook the Lost audience that was upset about the way it ended. Im not saying he's lying but its exactly what someone would also say to gain the most following for their new show. People today wont even start the show Lost because the last couple episodes are not great. Its crazy.
My theory is, every cycle Anghkooey wants seven children to be ultimately sacrificed. The children are the souls of the current random characters from a past life, and these characters need to find out who they are and where they come FROM to ultimately save themselves. Meanwhile, the kid in white is ONE of the seven children from the previous cycle who was saved by Miranda, and he decided to stay to help save the kids from the next cycle. Tabitha is likely one of the children herself. And Christofer might have been Anghkooey, which might now be reincarnated as Jade.
Based on my theory, Fromville can be understood as a seemingly inescapable, cyclical entity-a place bound by a mysterious script that forces its inhabitants to repeat roles and events. It's not just a physical town; it's a controlled environment where every individual brought in must fulfill a specific purpose, often mirroring someone who came before. The town seems almost sentient, with an uncanny awareness of each person's actions, adjusting and influencing situations to ensure that the narrative it has in mind stays intact. Fromville appears to operate through cycles, where new arrivals essentially "replace" individuals from previous cycles, taking on the same tasks, challenges, and even tragedies as those who came before. This makes the town feel like a stage where the same play is acted out over and over, with slight variations. People like Victor, who have seen more than one cycle, understand that these repetitions are inevitable, and Victor’s insights suggest that he knows everyone's fate is predetermined within this repeating loop. The creatures that stalk the town serve as a force that ensures people stay within their roles-whether by killing those who step out of line or by generating enough fear to keep everyone obedient. Boyd’s act of killing a monster disrupts this, possibly leading to changes in how the town functions, suggesting that the "script" isn't entirely unbreakable. This indicates that while Fromville might prefer a specific order, the residents do have some ability to affect change, albeit with unpredictable consequences. Ultimately, Fromville could be described as a purgatorial construct-an entity designed to test, trap, and make individuals relive the past until some unknown condition is met. Whether the goal is to save the children, end the suffering, or simply continue the cycle remains unclear. It’s a place where destiny feels imposed, yet acts of rebellion-like Boyd’s-hint at the possibility that the loop might be broken, either by defiance or by fulfilling a predetermined yet elusive requirement.
Thanks for the amazing analysis! I especially love your point about the creatures acting as enforcers, keeping everyone in their roles, and Boyd's defiance disrupting that order breaks that.... interesting!
If it is purgatory it's basically Lost but not in an island. That'd be awful since the shows share the writers. I hope that it's anything other than a purgatory. Also, "everyone" being important and having a role seems wrong, since some people just arrive there to die quickly.
I think the bracelet paradox can be explained with reincarnation: 1. Tabitha created bracelet_1 based on what she remembered from her previous lives -> it was lost by Jim. 2. Miranda created bracelet_2 based on what she remembered from her previous lives and gave it to Henry -> it was left with Henry and found by Tabitha in his car. 3. Miranda was pulled into Fromville and in Fromville she found and carried bracelet_3 which had been already created by yet another previous incarnation. -> this bracelet was later found by Tabitha in Fromville after Miranda died. So all the bracelets are actually almost perfect copies as each incarnation remembers the original design and recreates it. The original bracelet apparently had defect/imperfection so all incarnation are recreating it. This would actually explain how Miranda gave the bracelet to Henry but had it at the same time in Fromville.
That's a clever way to explain the bracelet paradox using the reincarnation theory! The idea that each incarnation remembers and recreates the bracelet, with slight imperfections passed down through time, is really mind blowing! Thanks for the comment!
I’m not married to any one theory, but I had an interesting thought. What if the show is called from because The Town is where everyone is originally FROM. Meaning their souls or spirits could be reincarnated and sent back out at intervals for whatever reason. Maybe it’s to give them hope so they can be tortured again. Maybe there’s something else. Idk.
reincarnation might also explain Elgins dream as he entered. He seemed to know this place before getting there "like a dream he cant remember" (or tried to forget.)
Riffing off this, maybe the townspeople made a deal with the entity for the their lives, e.g drinking the blood from the skull, and sacrificed their children. Maybe some from that primal group disagreed but they got trapped anyway and are still trying to find a way out, to break the curse and save the children.
Yup, that's pretty much my take on it as well. The monsters are probably the ones who sacrificed the children and people keep getting there in order to free the children's souls or something like that. The monsters are cursed to an eternal life of hunting people by some mother of the children or someone in the town who didn't agree with the sacrifice. Also, I don't think most people there are important in any way shape or form. Maybe Tabitha is, Viktor and a few others. But if the main point is to free the children some entity will keep getting people until it's done. I'm just very bothered by that Martin (I guess that was his name) guy that Boyd got the "monster virus" from. They seem to have closed that door already, and that seemed like an interesting path to understand some stuff. If only they made Boyd's script believable, he'd have asked all the questions he could instead of worrying about saving some random dead guy from a wall lol
This is what the Code means: The code generates a random number between 0 and 400. If the number is less than 9, one of the surpriseTitles (which is one of the massacre years) is set as the page title. the page randomly displays one of the surprise titles or the default title. Additionally, there is a small chance (1 in 1000) that a secret image will be displayed on the page, replacing all the content.
I don't think it's reincarnation because Victor being alive throws a wrench in that theory. I think it's more of "roles" in each cycle and each "role" failed at a certain part or is bound to fail. I think Boyd managing to break free the three other people and killing a monster changes the cycle a bit. Maybe Boyd is the guy in yellow.
I think Tabitha and miranda are the ones being reincarnated, not everyone else. If anything it has to do with everyone's family tree... their ancestors did something.
Right Victor has been there for 40 years. But my question is when did the monsters begin? Especially since Victor's mom was called there? They need to have scenes with other people who have been there since Victor or directly after.
for me this is definitely it. Souls born entirely for the amusement of the town entity and reborn to be kept at bay. Maybe the children to be freed are the original souls that were sacrificed to keep the entity controlled within that place, with the condition that their souls will be trapped there forever. The fact that other people start coming into the town just shows that the entity needs more life, more souls to be content, or maybe showing the connection between the different inhabitants of the town and that the town only takes people that are the children reincarnated and their close ones. this explains the "this is the only way" quote from the boy in white. He needed Tabitha to reincarnate so that she comes back as a new soul and tries again.
Man, what a wild ride! We're out here spilling our souls in discussions, while those townies barely even grunt about "happenings" to each other. Like, are the showrunners lurking in our convos, taking notes, and crafting the show based on our responses and be like "Oh! really nigga??".
agreed with all your theories, i also believe Tabitha and Jade are analogs of Miranda and Christopher. with regards to the number three, i believe Elgin is the third chosen person. he, similar to Miranda, had dreams of Fromville before getting there. the raven hitting the window as Fatima asks about her baby, and it dying at Elgin’s feet has me believing this banshee he’s seeing is an omen for the pregnancy.
Elgin is the baby being born in fatima it is why once she found out she was pregnant he had the drawn dream and spit out water ever since its why he see a dead fatima because she is dying with him inside its why she coming to him in his head for help
Fromville is basically a Room of Requirement (Harry Potter) A place that changes to match the inhabitants wishes, hopes, fears... Miranda is most likely the origin of the current nightmare they're in...
@@BEYONDPREMIERE I have a whole case on that theory. Just see how everything in Fromville happens according to the inhabitants needs. Boyd found the talismans, the animals, Jim found the vegetables when the townspeople started to starve... I think that Miranda, on her acid trip, somehow connected to "something" that triggered her obsession... I believe the paintings in her house's basement are not visions, but the actual origin of the things happening in the town... Like, she painted them and they materialized in the town, and not backwards. Basically she built the current nightmare they're in, and since she felt like she was chosen, needed to fulfill a mission but failed, her distorted psyche lured more and more people to the town in order to finish what she started. Think how in the caves we saw many objects that felt randomly placed down there, including a sticker that we also see in Victor's dad's PC, appliances, toys, almost as if the caves were a reflection of someone's distorted memories (Miranda's) and it happens in the town also, with the bottle trees, the dogs, the bracelet Miranda made for Víctor's dad... If you think about all the fortuitous events and "coincidences" happening in the town, it makes more sense that the whole thing is a sort of a living dungeon crafted after someone's distorted desires...
@@calwakerzInteresting idea. But when Victor showed Jade the car graveyard (the violin scene) he tells Jade that there are more cars behind the hill that were already there when he and his family got there. Wouldn’t that indicate the town has been around longer than his mom’s acid trip?
@@calwakerzyeah but then what? Would they all be living in a parallel world created by one drugged woman and somehow they can't get out? What kind of ending would we have with this origin story?
@@Henrique.Souza0601 as many things indicate, that world's purpose is to keep things trapped inside... A loop... People, items, memories... So I believe that whatever entity is trapped in there, is using people to help it to escape; this entity must be using that world's properties to manipulate reality, creating sort of "dungeons" or "quests" with the goal of ultimately releasing it. That's why Miranda's hallucinations became her reality; while she was drugged under the tree, she must have entered in contact with this entity that is probably connected through trees, roots, like some fungi network connecting trees in a forest (the symbol Jade is obsessed with looks like the roots of a tree if you ask me and we already saw them in the shape of roots) Anyways This entity used Miranda's hallucinations about kids trapped in a tower and everything else she saw (probably still consuming acid at Henry's back) to design the perfect stage for her to help this entity to be released, however, as we saw with the townsfolk and the cicadas, your own dreams can kill you, so Miranda's hallucinations became a reality that eventually killed her before she could fulfill her mission, so because of that the town's entity continued to draw in more and more people in a attempt to find someone fitting enough to finish what Miranda started. They're basically living an acid-driven nightmare created by the distorted desires and hallucinations of an artist that crafted these horrible things we all see... And ending for this, could be that they find the exit, the faraway tree leading to the outside world but that also caused people to enter the town (so that's why there's a tree in the road) something that probably Victor knows about but can't remember given his previous knowledge about faraway trees and the map we saw he used to find the case in the previous episode, maybe there's a map for the "from tree", but someone (maybe Boyd or even Victor) will stay behind to cut the tree, so this entity can't leave and no more people can enter the town. From tree: brings you FROM the outside to the town, takes you FROM the town to the outside. FROM whenever you are.
If this seasons ends with more questions , no answers and another big cliffhanger I’ll be disappointed smh i hope they aren’t trying to treat this show like lost
I am really curious what the deal is with Jade's having so many visions (dead people) that seemingly don't relate to the story so far. Plus, why was there a painting of the Civil War soldier in Henry's basement that was basically the same pose as in Jade's vision? And what's the deal with Sara, are the voices 'finished' with her and have moved on to Jim with the phone calls?
Those, my friend, most likely will be unanswered questions even after the ending of the show 😂 what about Martin, the guy with the "monster virus"? Completely forgotten already. They just do this to filler up the seasons, not thinking about any specif purpose for that stuff.
Wow Christian! A lot of deep thoughts that will cause me to rewatch! The large red on the cave wall-could that be the fallen tree? And 11 letters in everyone’s name! You are at a whole other level now 😅Excellent deep thoughts as always, and this one is deeper!
You're right, that big red mark in the cave drawing could very well be the fallen tree, acting as a kind of symbolic representation of the town's gateway. And the 11-letter name thing? Totally wild! It's like the writers are dropping those breadcrumbs for us to find. Thanks for the comment! - BP
Jim said the answer in the first season. The answer is 12. Jim came to the answer after writing the problem. Sometimes, and I’ve had this happen to me, when a person looks at a problem, they automatically know the answer before solving said problem. I think that’s what happened.
It could also just be Tabitha is actually Victor's brother. Maybe that's why she has spent a fair amount of screen time with Victor and meet's and brings back Victor's, and therefore her father.
Harold P would not sign on to do the show UNLESS he could see the progression and all being tied up at the end of the show. He did not want to become part of the problems incurred by LOST. You can look this up. So do not fear there will be a solution at some point. If you find everything wrong then please stop watching. Find something more your mind can handle.
I think she is Victor's sister. She was probably traumatized by the town and forgot but subconsciously remembers certain things about her mother. Such as favorite song and making the bracelet.
@@BEYONDPREMIEREmight be an adoptive mom and that pointless scene was there just to distract us. It served no purpose besides saying "Tabitha has a mom" if you really think about it.
Very interesting theory! However, the online article about the missing Mathews family says that Jim and Tabitha are both in their mid 30s, so Tabitha couldn’t have been born when Miranda died.
Reincarnation doesn’t have to necessarily happen the minute you die. As long as Tabitha wasn’t born before Miranda died then it’s possible. I don’t believe in this theory but ya never know, could be right.
Well the missing article for the Matthews said they were both in their mid 30's which means Tabby isnt 43 or born in 78....i don't know if they are reincarnated but i do think those "chosen" share some kind of connection that helps them see old memories...or maybe the place is just messing with Tabby
Honestly i think making this show a time travel thing, will ruin it. It’s such an overused trope that it just kills the unique aspects of the show. And, being time travel does not give us a single clue to what the “entity” is, how it started, who the kids are , etc. it just adds an extra layer of stupid
It'll be more than time travel. Likely parallel dimensions and alternate realities and humans are trapped here along with monsters. Kinda like stranger things where monsters escapes into the human world but here the humans are trapped in a monster world and can't get out and the ghosts 👻 we see are past victims of from land offering guidance to get out. The boy in white is like a help avatar giving Tabatha and Victor clues to escape this nightmare dimension. The backstory to where these monsters come from and what they want will hopefully be revealed.
Heres a comment someone else posted that ive expanded on and i fully believe it was the core inspirstions for the shows concept "It's Carcosa, more closely, the Dreamlands from Lovecraft and Eldrich lore. Symbol is that of Atlach Nacha, evil spider god that links dimensions. The walkers are ghouls, and Hastur is the big bad controlling the entire realm." Hastur per the original writings was know as the king in yellow. We see so many uses of the color yellow in the show. Even certain scenes filmed with a yellow filter. We see a painting of a man in a yellow suit in the basement. Atlach nacha was a spider god that "resides in a cave system and it spins a great web, forming a great bridge between the Dreamlands and the waking world."
Don't you think Hastur is, indeed, a good entity? Maybe Atlach Nacha is the bad one, and Hastur might take the form of the kid in white, or just being a good etity in general?
I love this theory SO MUCH!!! I made a similar connection to the possibility of this being some sort of cycle or soul harvest in a Reddit post not too long ago, but this is next level by x1000!!!! This is the best, hands down!!!
Ok I don’t think the Fromland or the entity is causing the reincarnation process. I believe that it’s the original spirit/soul that was there from the beginning is forcibly choosing women to be reborn into or enter, in order to end the entire cycle and save the children. I’ll add on the other theory I have about the children being born in the area and sacrificed to/claimed by this entity. The spirit that’s choosing these woman is probably the first woman who had her child sacrificed to the entity, which gave it strength enough to start the cycle and create Fromland. After that it receives a sacrifice or claims another child that’s born there and grows even stronger spreading its influence. This is why I think the same test is going to happen with Fatima’s child and why I believe the Kimono lady is one of the mothers who had her child sacrificed to/claimed by the entity and is trying to warn her through Elgin somehow. Maybe Elgin has some kind of 6th sense that makes it easier for her to reach out to him.
Just off topic, I find it interesting that lots of characters dont have family, or lived with Grandparents. Elgin lived with his Grandmother. Jade said he lived with his Grandmother in france until she died, then lived with an uncle. and Fatima said her Dad and brother i think she said were killed. and Sara said her brother Nathan was only person she had left, implies she has had bereavement. perhaps there's a link. maybe not. just thought it was interesting. maybe its just how the town picks people, so there isnt too many people looking for them.
Hey @blake8366! Thanks for the kind words! I'm glad you appreciate that the Robert number theory is finally getting some attention. It's awesome to see so many fans connecting with these ideas! Thanks for the comment! - BP
Here's my theory i think that the town and the jungle and everything present in there like the monsters, animals like crow, spiders, boy in white basically everything is controlled by someone lets name him god. The people of that area who lived in jungle whose House we saw in the recent episodes used to pray to that god and they also used to do some rituals to make him happy which we saw in drawings in the tunnels, i think those are made by the tride that lived there but victor said that paintings were made by the monsters which i don't think is the truth because the monsters sleep during day and comes out at night so they don't have time to draw and all. I think that the god is somehow trapped, he wants to be free thats why he trap people from outside world so that they can free him and by making him free i mean from earth not from the village as many people says that by breaking light in lighthouse will make him free and he will control outside world, i think that he can already control the outside world as we saw victor's mom had dreams about that place when she was outside so he was able to control her and thats how he gets people in fromville amd whoever the god is i think he want people to go out in jungle and find answers and i think that's how he will be free as we have seen multiple times in the series that whenever someone went to jungle they have found something good like boid found animals, talismans , lighthouse, Tabitha went outside too with the help of lighthouse which is present in jungle and in recent episodes the asian sheriff found vegetables in the jungle, i think the god grew these vegetables for them he wants them to be alive so that they try to get free from fromville and make him free and we have also seen that the god doesn't want them to discover anything in the town because when tabitha tried to dig hole in the house the house collapsed and when her husband tried to build tower storm came and destroyed bulbs which is the gods power he can control everything there and I think the talisman can't do anything in front of god as we have seen him destroying tabithas house which had a talisman and he can kill people in daytime too as we saw him killing that girl in her dream that too in day time in house with talisman I think he wants them to be alive and he want's them to be afraid so that they try to escape and make him free thats why monsters are there so that they can make people afraid and i don't think there is any way to leave this town , they can only leave when they make him the god free and i think the monsters were people who made this town and we also see their furniture which is in Tunnel with them they must have failed to make the god free and died and i think that the god controlles Tabitha and victors mom and they keep getting dream about freeing children i think that means to free the god and the boy in white is also controlled by him just to foll people that there is someone helping them as we saw when all the people from town died he was smiling and playing and the lighthouse will play an important role in freeing the god
This kind of still falls in the line of time travel, but with the conscience time-traveling this is a great theory one of my favorite so far, Remember we got time travel in lost with Desmond Desmond's conscience going from the past to the present.
It’s Ran-Dey-Move, a play on words like Rendezvous (Ran-Dey-Voo) which means to meet as planned. So moving company has something to do with people meeting up in Fromville
ETHAN IS VICTOR IN THE SAME TIMELINE AS TABITHA, SO IT'S POSSIBLE THAT VICTOR WILL DIE AT THE END OF THIS SEASON IF THE TOWN'S CURSE IS NOT BROKEN. The town from has been fulfilling the same role for generations, so don't be surprised if, upon killing the next monster, another one appears with the same appearance from this same timeline, meaning someone they know but from the dark side. Just like a tragic ending where ETHAN is the only one to survive from the entire town as Victor did in his time if they fail to achieve the goal of freeing the children from the lighthouse
@@BEYONDPREMIERE are you saying someone else time traveled there or Boyd in another time? Because I think it was the entity that threw the music box but it could be Boyd later in series goes back and throws it for himself. Also I kind of think Martin is Boyd’s passed life or maybe his future life
Honestly, after rewatching Lost recently, this theory makes a lot of sense... I also keep thinking the symbol looks like roots or timelines overlapping or colliding. Maybe the two vehicles with chosen people crashing? Would definitely like to see more analysis on the creepy children and rituals, feels like there's something big to unpack there.
I just rewatched Lost too! Man, that show is phenomenal. I see interesting similarities. The random pregnancies with Sun and Fatima, the importance of numbers.. ahhh! What a great show they've created with From.
Lost started great but then the story was all over the place and writers later admitted they were making up stuff as they go. The stories didn't always make sense and sci-fi explanations was ridiculous. Still lost deserves credit as one of the best mystery box shows even if the ending was a letdown. I'm pretty sure writers for this show have a big story mapped out and they're teasing us with lots of mysteries but no answers yet.
This is one of the bes shows on in a long time when it comes to philosophy, horror, drama, thriller, and so much more it’s itself it’s own category of a show/movie when shows have a movie level budget nowadays with streaming. Harold peraneu was amazing as manny in Constantine which only got 13 episodes cuz it was literally the year before streaming shows started getting 2016, that itself was a crime to cancel. Matt Ryan and Harold Paraneu are great Matt Ryan is John Constantine, watch it if you like Harold u won’t ne disappointed with the show but u will that they cut the show NBC made a mistake, so glad FROM , got it’s chance and grows with every episode to be better and better much like Constantine was…
I totally agree! FROM is in a league of its own. It blends so many genres, into something truly unique. I'm loving how FROM keeps getting better and more intense with every episode! Thanks for the comment!
Same with Elgin I think he’s to got flashbacks from he’s previous variations, and monster in this flashbacks it’s what Fatima variation became back than
Elgin’s character in Fromville stands out as particularly enigmatic, with many clues suggesting that he has a deeper connection to the town than most other recent arrivals. His role seems to be one of a harbinger-someone who knows more than he consciously understands, carrying an inexplicable awareness of the danger the town presents. 1. Arrival with Premonitions Elgin’s introduction is notable because even before he arrives in Fromville, he displays signs of unease. On the bus, he has an instinctual, almost primal fear about where they’re going. This makes him unique among the newcomers, as he seems to have a kind of forewarning about the place. It’s almost as if he’s either been there before in another form, perhaps in a past cycle, or he has a connection to the previous residents. His instincts set the tone for his character as someone attuned to the supernatural undercurrents of Fromville. 2. The Flood Dream Elgin’s dream about the flood is one of the most significant pieces of his character development so far. The flood could symbolize a reset, destruction, or a cleansing event tied to the end of the current cycle in Fromville. The fact that Elgin dreams about it suggests that he might either be reliving someone else's past experience or having a vision of what’s to come. This kind of prophetic insight aligns him with other characters like Victor, who also has knowledge that exceeds that of the typical resident. It implies that Elgin is either destined to play a critical role when this event comes to pass or that he is carrying the memories of someone who lived through a similar catastrophic event in the town’s past. 3. Potential Role as a Replacement If the theory about Fromville being cyclical and each new arrival replacing a past figure is correct, Elgin might be a replacement for a character from a previous cycle-perhaps even someone who died during the last iteration of the flood. His dreams could be echoes of experiences lived by that person, indicating that Elgin is meant to take on their role. This replacement idea suggests that Elgin's importance may become more evident as the cycle progresses, particularly if the flood he envisions comes closer to becoming reality. 4. Intuitive Understanding of the Town Throughout his time in Fromville, Elgin shows a deeper level of intuition than many other newcomers. He quickly adapts to the strange rules and behaviors needed to survive, almost as if he already knows what’s required. This intuitive knowledge sets him apart and suggests that Elgin’s connection to Fromville might be more profound than mere coincidence. He could be tapping into a collective memory or consciousness that exists within the town, similar to how the voices influence Sara. This connection might make him crucial to understanding how to either navigate the dangers or possibly break free of the town’s control. 5. Catalyst or Key Player? Elgin’s role seems to be gearing up towards something pivotal. Whether his presence is a catalyst for a major event, like the flood, or he himself is the key to changing or breaking the cycle remains to be seen. His character feels like one that will have a major impact, either by directly taking action that shifts the town’s fate or by serving as a bridge to understanding its deeper mysteries. His ability to sense danger, his prophetic dreams, and his intuitive grasp of the town’s supernatural rules all suggest that Elgin is not just another resident-he’s a potential game-changer. 6. Connection to the Town's Energy Elgin might also be sensitive to the energy or force that drives Fromville. Characters like Sara hear voices, Victor has his drawings, and Boyd experiences unique phenomena, and Elgin seems to have his own connection through dreams and intuition. If Fromville is a place that pulls on people’s fears, hopes, and emotions, then Elgin’s connection to the flood might symbolize a broader link to the town’s essence. He could represent the impending change or chaos that the flood symbolizes-a force that disrupts the current order to allow for something new to begin. Conclusion Elgin’s character is still unfolding, but he is clearly positioned as someone with a deep, possibly supernatural connection to Fromville. His premonitions, intuitive understanding, and potential as a replacement for someone from a previous cycle all suggest that he is far from an ordinary newcomer. Instead, Elgin feels like a character who embodies change-perhaps a harbinger of the flood or a key player who could either trigger a reset or help navigate its consequences. As the story progresses, Elgin’s role may become crucial in revealing whether Fromville is destined to repeat its cycles endlessly or if there’s a possibility of breaking free from its grip.
@@MichaelSmith-lm5sl Elgin has visions like a psychic but he doesn't exhibit anything unusual. Tilly acts a little creepy at times too but I think they're both red herrings. Elgin likely can see the future as he has weird visions when he sleeps. I'm thinking from land is a nexus of parallel dimensions where humans and monsters and time travel all converge. The tree on the road is a Venus fly trap and portal in and the lighthouse is a portal out and the ghosts 👻 are spirits of past victims trapped in from land. The boy in white is giving clues to Victor and Tabitha how to get out. So this is kinda like stranger things where monsters from another dimension escapes into the human world but in this case humans are trapped in a monster world. The show keeps us guessing which is what makes a good mystery box show. Hopefully writers aren't cooking up stuff as we go and they have a nice story mapped out.
I really like this theory. What if all the souls that reincarnate into the town are from the original dwellers of that town. Maybe they all got caught there during a rough winter in the past and took on the wendingo curse which manifested all of their worse nightmares to come true within a spirit realm that doesn’t exist in our dimension. And the only way the wendingo curse will be lifted is if all the nightmare curses are broken one by one. What if Boyd can not be physically harmed by any nightmare manifestation now because he broke the music box nightmare curse. Maybe Victor broke a curse that we don’t know about which is why he is still alive. And maybe now perhaps Tabitha has broken a curse. There could be a nightmare curse for each person in town to solve. The nightmare curse entity wants Boyd to lose hope along with his mind because he seems to be a force to be reckoned with, he found the talismans, created civilization, and broke a curse. The town likes Victor because he is so childlike and complacent while Boyd is coming strong and strategic.
Going on the reincarnation theory makes sense. Given Smiley dies in season 2 ep6 and Fatima finds out she is pregnant close to end of season 2. It could be Smiley reincarnated would explain the spoilt food she is eating given smiley wasnt alive but a trapped soul.Thoughts people?
Just like how Aang in avatar the last airbender, used artifacts to connect with his past lives, I think Tabitha’s discovery of Miranda’s paintings, the dress she finds and the bracelet is key to understanding her own connection to Fromville. What do you guys think? Is reincarnation playing a role in From? Let’s discuss! PS This is actually one of my favorite theories, I research so I really hope is true.
Do you have a Instagram? I found out something interesting about the site and my comment seems its getting (b)locked as i log out and its gone. maybe it will pop up.
I just figured out how to show the hidden image, i had to type 6 lines in console and then it popped up and its a drawing of victors and its a house with the date very scribbly 1597 over the roof with a line through the roof and chimney puffing smoke and looks like two creatures on both sides of the house. I have so much info right now but code and shortcuts dont seem to take in comments and get blocked.
rendezmove.com/secret-01.jpg this link should bring you to the secret image. I opened in a separate tab after i found bookmarked and then opened bookmark and brought me to the image only. so seems to work if does not disappear. Sorry so many messages i am in sherlock homes mode!
I rewatched the tarot card scene and idk if this means anything but when they were shuffling Tilly said the cards told her about this place (fromland) if she knew how to read the signs right… then when asked does she know how to read them now she said yea a lot better than she used to… how long has Tilly been there to all of a sudden be a tarot reader? Unless she was referring to the first time she was there compared to this time and when the crow hit the window Tilly was unbothered and even tried to get Fatima to ignore it…Tilly is suspect!
What if the boy in white was supposed to be one of the kids that were sacrificed but somehow escaped and his soul isn’t trapped but helping others to break the cycle. Maybe that is why now every circle one kid gets to be saved. That was Victor in the previous circle. Maybe now it’s going to be Ethan.🤷♀️
I have heard a lot of theories about the show. Been watching since the beginning. I believe they are on a level of the astral plane. I’m just throwing this out because I haven’t heard anyone bring it up. There are levels in the plane that mimic our world but are basically inescapable. And these places can feed off our emotions.
Hey there! I understand your frustration with the reincarnation and time travel theories. It's true that these concepts can sometimes feel overused. However, many viewers find these ideas to be interesting ways of explaining the mysteries and repetitive patterns in From. My goal is to explore different interpretations and create discussion among fans. Whether or not these theories are ultimately "true" within the show's is something we'll have to see as the season unfolds! Thanks for sharing your perspective!
I don’t think that’s the case, if Miranda had the visions before entering into the town, and Tabatha is her again, why Tabatha doesn’t had the vision’s before entering into the town too?
I don' see grounds for this theory. The web article Victor's father finds about Tabitha's family going missing says she's in her mid 30s. According to the series timeline we are in year 2021 and she's been missing just for 21 days. When the actress filmed S1 she was 39. The iterations mean there's a repeating cycle throughout the time, but that doesn't mean it has to involve reincarnation.
You make a valid point about the discrepancies in Tabitha's age and the timeline presented in the show. The information in the news article does conflict with the actress's real age and the timeframe established in the series. However, it's important to remember that the reincarnation theory is just that a theory. It's a possible interpretation of the clues presented, not necessarily a definitive explanation. Those discrepancies could be explained by the town's manipulation of time, memories, or even reality itself. From is a show where the impossible often happens, so a time-bending or reality-altering explanation for those inconsistencies cannot be ruled out. Let's see how things develop as the season continues. I have to add, thanks for always leaving a comment in the videos I appreciate it :D
@@BEYONDPREMIEREOf course, a theory as such has its strengths and weaknesses, otherwise it wouldn't be a theory, it would be an explanation. Besides, I understand the need to create new content. Apart from that, I think we all want the show to be a mix of sci-fi and supernatural elements, just like Lost (tho I refuse to think the show has a religious main plot). And despite that wish, I'm starting to be open to other possibilities. Miranda started having visions after a session with acid. Jade has visions and he was an addict. The song Blue is about drugs. We don't know anything about Tabitha and Jim's youth, but I'm starting to considerJim's theory about the whole thing being some kind of experiment, and in particular something like Project MK Ultra came to my mind.
I don’t know for the first 3 episodes they haven’t rlly showed Elgin that much i feel like he’s a lot more connected than we realize and could be the 3rd reincarnation
I don't agree with the idea of reincarnation because we know that Miranda had those dreams and visions about these paintings before she arrived in fromville. but Tabitha never had such kind of visions before coming to fromville. she was completely new to this world based on the behaviors she has while she was still in the village I believe in reincarnation here if in some scenes Tabitha declared that she saw this or that stuff but don't remember how
I knew it something was off, when i was watching episode 1,2 and 3 i knew it, i even though maybe Victor is Ethan, Victor's dad is Jim and Tabatha is Victor's mother but from different dimension or something like that, i know this sounds crazy but this is just my first draft of thinking, haven't refined yet, and then stumbled upon your video which is exactly what i needed to say. 😅😮
Concurrent incarnations are also a thing, with the same spirit being incarnated in different lives that may be living while another incarnation is living
Hey @dockaiju, that's a really cool idea! Concurrent reincarnations would make Fromville's influence even more messed up than we thought. If the same soul could be in multiple bodies at once, it would totally explain why we see similar people and personalities in Fromville across different times. Plus, it would make the town's messing with time and reality even crazier than it already is! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Maybe, the victims of the town who were massacred. Are the souls we see. And they are getting revenge on the people who killed them offsprings…in return making them suffer. Victors mom could be the one who set up this entire loop. With some sort of black magic, to claim revenge and possibly some sort of closure
In the desert star article it says that the parents are both in their mid-30s so Tabitha couldn’t be born in 1978. I’m in my early 30s and I was born in the 90’a
Julie, Mari, and Randall were chained to the wall and Boyd broke the curse. There were 2 skeletons next to Martin, I bet Randall is the Martin in the future and the two skeletons are Julie and Mari. Jade is a Christopher and Christopher ended up killing the town's people. Jade also see a tree of dead bodies hanging in Season 1 episode 6 and I bet the black soldier chasing Jade is past Boyd who is trying to kill Jade for killing the men in the trees. Reincarnations also don't have to be the same sex or race, so what if the monster who went into the bus and looked like it was remembering to drive the bus is actually Bakta the bus driver. I bet the women who Elgin sees in the when he was sleeping is a future Fatima.
@@BEYONDPREMIERE The place is a paradox with cycles. The present people that we know could be reincarnations of Martin, the monsters etc. I think the symbol with the 3 lines crossing represents different portal areas which are past, present, and future. So there's past, present and future versions of everyone.
I had the exact same thoughts about Tabitha being Miranda reincarnated, and that Miranda's visions of other "chosen ones" from the past are just her, over and over. I hadn't considered that Jade might be a reincarnation, but that makes sense with his visions! I do think that Fromville is in a cycle, but I think Boyd may have broken that cycle when he killed one of the monsters, because everything has escalated since then, and from the cast interviews I've seen, it's only going to get worse. I don't think the town has had to deal with anyone like Boyd before.
I really think you might be on to something here...and it could be inspired by Buddhist/reincarnation mythology where there are lots of different worlds or 'bardos' and some of them are hell worlds and populated by 'hungry ghosts'...demons which, when you think about it, sound a lot like the evil vampire things in From...
This theory might be correct Miranda had two children victor and his sister same as tabitha, victor and Ethan have some similarities. And we know Thomas died What if same thing happend miranda and she did some ritual in the park(where the bottle tree is in the real life) to bring his dead son back And she had to do something to do so ( releasing the children from the tower) Or what if the boy in the white is Miranda's son and he is trapped in the FROM TOWN because miranda failed and remember when sara said the boy in the white wants to help and he is trapped in here like us Jim also received a call from his son what if tabihta did the same and now Thomas is also trapped
Hey @Zubair-ahmad_! That's a really interesting take on the reincarnation theory! You've highlighted some HUGE connections: Miranda and Tabitha both having two children, similarities between Victor and Ethan. Thanks for the comment! - BP
Jade dosent see a pilgrim, look up the dress of what people were wearing during the American revolution. One of thr dates on lighthouse was for the Boston tea party.
Talismans were used by the people in the cabins (the people in red). This confirms they knew about the creatures and were trying to protect themselves. The caves are depicting events from the past. The drawings could be a historical record of the town's early days and the struggles of its first inhabitants.
Maybe the children they’re supposed to free are their own children, by ignoring the demon monster children, and leaving their own to survive, and some how no one mentions it or notices that these are some of the worst moms ever lmfao.
If Christianity is to be believed the human race started with the Garden of Eden, is everyone FROM here? Cycles and reincarnation seem the most plausible theory to date. Could the cycles expand the Garden of Eden/Fromville? Could it swallow the real world?
If they use time travel it will be very stupid and another shitty version of Lost. (Excuse my french) This series is good and they do NOT need to ruin it with freaking time travel again like they did with Lost.
I really believe in this theory and I believe it applies to all the characters. An important question is this: why were these people drawn to the city? Simple, they are all reincarnations of past lives and they all must have some event in common where they were connected by some common karma. This may explain the moment in the series where knowing the Origin of this karma is the only way to free oneself. They are the children themselves who need to be saved. They need to remember where they came FROM.
@@cristinalima2455 aaaah I love this so much, all of my theories this one is my favorite. There’s so much proof and no coincidence in this show 🙏🙌 thanks for the comment
Love it
I thought the monsters at night would be from past humans living in the towns.
@Maximus-kx3kg all the monsters are dressed like the 50s.
@@RahYisrael99 it still is believed they were once human. For all we know the baby in Fatima that wants to eat rotten food and blood can be them as a baby. Just theories.
The one thing that Harold said that really stuck with me was that when the writers were pitching the show, he said “they pitched it with the ending of the show”. They are building to something big
Well let's hope they mapped out a great story with a mind blowing reveal. Or it could be like lost where writers later admitted they were making up stuff as they go.
OK but that would be the word for word line to hook the Lost audience that was upset about the way it ended. Im not saying he's lying but its exactly what someone would also say to gain the most following for their new show. People today wont even start the show Lost because the last couple episodes are not great. Its crazy.
My theory is, every cycle Anghkooey wants seven children to be ultimately sacrificed. The children are the souls of the current random characters from a past life, and these characters need to find out who they are and where they come FROM to ultimately save themselves. Meanwhile, the kid in white is ONE of the seven children from the previous cycle who was saved by Miranda, and he decided to stay to help save the kids from the next cycle. Tabitha is likely one of the children herself. And Christofer might have been Anghkooey, which might now be reincarnated as Jade.
Based on my theory, Fromville can be understood as a seemingly inescapable, cyclical entity-a place bound by a mysterious script that forces its inhabitants to repeat roles and events. It's not just a physical town; it's a controlled environment where every individual brought in must fulfill a specific purpose, often mirroring someone who came before. The town seems almost sentient, with an uncanny awareness of each person's actions, adjusting and influencing situations to ensure that the narrative it has in mind stays intact.
Fromville appears to operate through cycles, where new arrivals essentially "replace" individuals from previous cycles, taking on the same tasks, challenges, and even tragedies as those who came before. This makes the town feel like a stage where the same play is acted out over and over, with slight variations. People like Victor, who have seen more than one cycle, understand that these repetitions are inevitable, and Victor’s insights suggest that he knows everyone's fate is predetermined within this repeating loop.
The creatures that stalk the town serve as a force that ensures people stay within their roles-whether by killing those who step out of line or by generating enough fear to keep everyone obedient. Boyd’s act of killing a monster disrupts this, possibly leading to changes in how the town functions, suggesting that the "script" isn't entirely unbreakable. This indicates that while Fromville might prefer a specific order, the residents do have some ability to affect change, albeit with unpredictable consequences.
Ultimately, Fromville could be described as a purgatorial construct-an entity designed to test, trap, and make individuals relive the past until some unknown condition is met. Whether the goal is to save the children, end the suffering, or simply continue the cycle remains unclear. It’s a place where destiny feels imposed, yet acts of rebellion-like Boyd’s-hint at the possibility that the loop might be broken, either by defiance or by fulfilling a predetermined yet elusive requirement.
Thanks for the amazing analysis! I especially love your point about the creatures acting as enforcers, keeping everyone in their roles, and Boyd's defiance disrupting that order breaks that.... interesting!
you nailed the genaral idea of the story .. excellent analysis .
If it is purgatory it's basically Lost but not in an island. That'd be awful since the shows share the writers. I hope that it's anything other than a purgatory. Also, "everyone" being important and having a role seems wrong, since some people just arrive there to die quickly.
I think the bracelet paradox can be explained with reincarnation:
1. Tabitha created bracelet_1 based on what she remembered from her previous lives -> it was lost by Jim.
2. Miranda created bracelet_2 based on what she remembered from her previous lives and gave it to Henry -> it was left with Henry and found by Tabitha in his car.
3. Miranda was pulled into Fromville and in Fromville she found and carried bracelet_3 which had been already created by yet another previous incarnation. -> this bracelet was later found by Tabitha in Fromville after Miranda died.
So all the bracelets are actually almost perfect copies as each incarnation remembers the original design and recreates it.
The original bracelet apparently had defect/imperfection so all incarnation are recreating it.
This would actually explain how Miranda gave the bracelet to Henry but had it at the same time in Fromville.
I'm fairly sure Henry said his grandfather gave it to him.
@@burtonmoore996 no, he said his wife made it for him
That's a clever way to explain the bracelet paradox using the reincarnation theory! The idea that each incarnation remembers and recreates the bracelet, with slight imperfections passed down through time, is really mind blowing! Thanks for the comment!
And the song that played in the car she said it was jim fav song and it was also victor mom fav song
I’m not married to any one theory, but I had an interesting thought. What if the show is called from because The Town is where everyone is originally FROM. Meaning their souls or spirits could be reincarnated and sent back out at intervals for whatever reason. Maybe it’s to give them hope so they can be tortured again. Maybe there’s something else. Idk.
That's an interesting theory!
Posted the exact same before reading yours. Great theory
That os what I thought.
Actually, I asked myself , where was Tabitha born ?
reincarnation might also explain Elgins dream as he entered. He seemed to know this place before getting there "like a dream he cant remember" (or tried to forget.)
How has nobody noticed the hawaiin dancer sticker on the suitcase in the tunnels was also on victors dads computer desk?
@@Huckle_Billy I show it in the video 🤣🤣 yes, that luggage I feel is Miranda and Tabitha was drawn to it
@BEYONDPREMIERE yeah I know you showed it i wasn't directing the comment at you, you're 1 of 2 youtubers I've watched to notice it
It actually was one person on twitter who noticed it first! I can't say now who was it but I guess you'll find them if you look it up
Riffing off this, maybe the townspeople made a deal with the entity for the their lives, e.g drinking the blood from the skull, and sacrificed their children. Maybe some from that primal group disagreed but they got trapped anyway and are still trying to find a way out, to break the curse and save the children.
Yup, that's pretty much my take on it as well. The monsters are probably the ones who sacrificed the children and people keep getting there in order to free the children's souls or something like that. The monsters are cursed to an eternal life of hunting people by some mother of the children or someone in the town who didn't agree with the sacrifice. Also, I don't think most people there are important in any way shape or form. Maybe Tabitha is, Viktor and a few others. But if the main point is to free the children some entity will keep getting people until it's done.
I'm just very bothered by that Martin (I guess that was his name) guy that Boyd got the "monster virus" from. They seem to have closed that door already, and that seemed like an interesting path to understand some stuff. If only they made Boyd's script believable, he'd have asked all the questions he could instead of worrying about saving some random dead guy from a wall lol
This is what the Code means:
The code generates a random number between 0 and 400. If the number is less than 9, one of the surpriseTitles (which is one of the massacre years) is set as the page title.
the page randomly displays one of the surprise titles or the default title.
Additionally, there is a small chance (1 in 1000) that a secret image will be displayed on the page, replacing all the content.
rendezmove.com/secret-01.jpg you can see it here also
I don't think it's reincarnation because Victor being alive throws a wrench in that theory. I think it's more of "roles" in each cycle and each "role" failed at a certain part or is bound to fail. I think Boyd managing to break free the three other people and killing a monster changes the cycle a bit. Maybe Boyd is the guy in yellow.
He does wear a yellow shirt or jacket a fair bit.
Although, he could have got those from lost and found. interesting.
I think Tabitha and miranda are the ones being reincarnated, not everyone else. If anything it has to do with everyone's family tree... their ancestors did something.
Right Victor has been there for 40 years. But my question is when did the monsters begin? Especially since Victor's mom was called there? They need to have scenes with other people who have been there since Victor or directly after.
for me this is definitely it. Souls born entirely for the amusement of the town entity and reborn to be kept at bay.
Maybe the children to be freed are the original souls that were sacrificed to keep the entity controlled within that place, with the condition that their souls will be trapped there forever. The fact that other people start coming into the town just shows that the entity needs more life, more souls to be content, or maybe showing the connection between the different inhabitants of the town and that the town only takes people that are the children reincarnated and their close ones.
this explains the "this is the only way" quote from the boy in white. He needed Tabitha to reincarnate so that she comes back as a new soul and tries again.
That's a chilling and really well-thought-out theory, @olafsriffs! Thanks for the comment, I have similar thoughts on it.
Man, what a wild ride! We're out here spilling our souls in discussions, while those townies barely even grunt about "happenings" to each other. Like, are the showrunners lurking in our convos, taking notes, and crafting the show based on our responses and be like "Oh! really nigga??".
agreed with all your theories, i also believe Tabitha and Jade are analogs of Miranda and Christopher.
with regards to the number three, i believe Elgin is the third chosen person. he, similar to Miranda, had dreams of Fromville before getting there. the raven hitting the window as Fatima asks about her baby, and it dying at Elgin’s feet has me believing this banshee he’s seeing is an omen for the pregnancy.
Elgin is the baby being born in fatima it is why once she found out she was pregnant he had the drawn dream and spit out water ever since its why he see a dead fatima because she is dying with him inside its why she coming to him in his head for help
Fromville is basically a Room of Requirement (Harry Potter)
A place that changes to match the inhabitants wishes, hopes, fears... Miranda is most likely the origin of the current nightmare they're in...
@@calwakerz ohhhh that would be amazing man 😭 share your theories before I do my videos haha
@@BEYONDPREMIERE I have a whole case on that theory. Just see how everything in Fromville happens according to the inhabitants needs. Boyd found the talismans, the animals, Jim found the vegetables when the townspeople started to starve... I think that Miranda, on her acid trip, somehow connected to "something" that triggered her obsession... I believe the paintings in her house's basement are not visions, but the actual origin of the things happening in the town... Like, she painted them and they materialized in the town, and not backwards. Basically she built the current nightmare they're in, and since she felt like she was chosen, needed to fulfill a mission but failed, her distorted psyche lured more and more people to the town in order to finish what she started.
Think how in the caves we saw many objects that felt randomly placed down there, including a sticker that we also see in Victor's dad's PC, appliances, toys, almost as if the caves were a reflection of someone's distorted memories (Miranda's) and it happens in the town also, with the bottle trees, the dogs, the bracelet Miranda made for Víctor's dad... If you think about all the fortuitous events and "coincidences" happening in the town, it makes more sense that the whole thing is a sort of a living dungeon crafted after someone's distorted desires...
@@calwakerzInteresting idea. But when Victor showed Jade the car graveyard (the violin scene) he tells Jade that there are more cars behind the hill that were already there when he and his family got there. Wouldn’t that indicate the town has been around longer than his mom’s acid trip?
@@calwakerzyeah but then what? Would they all be living in a parallel world created by one drugged woman and somehow they can't get out? What kind of ending would we have with this origin story?
@@Henrique.Souza0601 as many things indicate, that world's purpose is to keep things trapped inside... A loop... People, items, memories... So I believe that whatever entity is trapped in there, is using people to help it to escape; this entity must be using that world's properties to manipulate reality, creating sort of "dungeons" or "quests" with the goal of ultimately releasing it. That's why Miranda's hallucinations became her reality; while she was drugged under the tree, she must have entered in contact with this entity that is probably connected through trees, roots, like some fungi network connecting trees in a forest (the symbol Jade is obsessed with looks like the roots of a tree if you ask me and we already saw them in the shape of roots)
Anyways
This entity used Miranda's hallucinations about kids trapped in a tower and everything else she saw (probably still consuming acid at Henry's back) to design the perfect stage for her to help this entity to be released, however, as we saw with the townsfolk and the cicadas, your own dreams can kill you, so Miranda's hallucinations became a reality that eventually killed her before she could fulfill her mission, so because of that the town's entity continued to draw in more and more people in a attempt to find someone fitting enough to finish what Miranda started.
They're basically living an acid-driven nightmare created by the distorted desires and hallucinations of an artist that crafted these horrible things we all see...
And ending for this, could be that they find the exit, the faraway tree leading to the outside world but that also caused people to enter the town (so that's why there's a tree in the road) something that probably Victor knows about but can't remember given his previous knowledge about faraway trees and the map we saw he used to find the case in the previous episode, maybe there's a map for the "from tree", but someone (maybe Boyd or even Victor) will stay behind to cut the tree, so this entity can't leave and no more people can enter the town.
From tree: brings you FROM the outside to the town, takes you FROM the town to the outside.
FROM whenever you are.
If this seasons ends with more questions , no answers and another big cliffhanger I’ll be disappointed smh i hope they aren’t trying to treat this show like lost
I am really curious what the deal is with Jade's having so many visions (dead people) that seemingly don't relate to the story so far. Plus, why was there a painting of the Civil War soldier in Henry's basement that was basically the same pose as in Jade's vision? And what's the deal with Sara, are the voices 'finished' with her and have moved on to Jim with the phone calls?
@@ansizfark those are his past lives 🤔 maybe
Those, my friend, most likely will be unanswered questions even after the ending of the show 😂 what about Martin, the guy with the "monster virus"? Completely forgotten already. They just do this to filler up the seasons, not thinking about any specif purpose for that stuff.
Wow Christian! A lot of deep thoughts that will cause me to rewatch! The large red on the cave wall-could that be the fallen tree? And 11 letters in everyone’s name! You are at a whole other level now 😅Excellent deep thoughts as always, and this one is deeper!
You're right, that big red mark in the cave drawing could very well be the fallen tree, acting as a kind of symbolic representation of the town's gateway. And the 11-letter name thing? Totally wild! It's like the writers are dropping those breadcrumbs for us to find. Thanks for the comment!
- BP
Jim said the answer in the first season. The answer is 12. Jim came to the answer after writing the problem. Sometimes, and I’ve had this happen to me, when a person looks at a problem, they automatically know the answer before solving said problem. I think that’s what happened.
It could also just be Tabitha is actually Victor's brother. Maybe that's why she has spent a fair amount of screen time with Victor and meet's and brings back Victor's, and therefore her father.
Tabitha is a girl
@@RaneishaMorris edit: sister*
Harold P would not sign on to do the show UNLESS he could see the progression and all being tied up at the end of the show. He did not want to become part of the problems incurred by LOST. You can look this up. So do not fear there will be a solution at some point. If you find everything wrong then please stop watching. Find something more your mind can handle.
I think she is Victor's sister. She was probably traumatized by the town and forgot but subconsciously remembers certain things about her mother. Such as favorite song and making the bracelet.
So that means she got out got married had kids and now is back
I actually would love that but Tabitha has a real mom 🤔 maybe the reason for the call to confuse the audience
She made the bracelet as an adult not a child.
This might be right because
Victor said he never found his sister body and she went through the faraway tree
@@BEYONDPREMIEREmight be an adoptive mom and that pointless scene was there just to distract us. It served no purpose besides saying "Tabitha has a mom" if you really think about it.
Very interesting theory! However, the online article about the missing Mathews family says that Jim and Tabitha are both in their mid 30s, so Tabitha couldn’t have been born when Miranda died.
Reincarnation doesn’t have to necessarily happen the minute you die. As long as Tabitha wasn’t born before Miranda died then it’s possible. I don’t believe in this theory but ya never know, could be right.
@@jessn7034 True! Also, we don’t know for sure if Miranda died in 1978. It might be the year of a new cycle as opposed to the end of one. 🤷🏻♀️
Easily becoming one of my fav. Channel for tv
@@_VICK_ Thank you so much, I really appreciate it 🙏
Well the missing article for the Matthews said they were both in their mid 30's which means Tabby isnt 43 or born in 78....i don't know if they are reincarnated but i do think those "chosen" share some kind of connection that helps them see old memories...or maybe the place is just messing with Tabby
mmm interesting, didn't saw that detail. Maybe they're connected and can see their other chosen memories... :/
Honestly i think making this show a time travel thing, will ruin it. It’s such an overused trope that it just kills the unique aspects of the show.
And, being time travel does not give us a single clue to what the “entity” is, how it started, who the kids are , etc. it just adds an extra layer of stupid
It'll be more than time travel. Likely parallel dimensions and alternate realities and humans are trapped here along with monsters. Kinda like stranger things where monsters escapes into the human world but here the humans are trapped in a monster world and can't get out and the ghosts 👻 we see are past victims of from land offering guidance to get out. The boy in white is like a help avatar giving Tabatha and Victor clues to escape this nightmare dimension. The backstory to where these monsters come from and what they want will hopefully be revealed.
Let's think what way can they choose. Time travel, coma or something in mind one man like in movie Identity 2003. Would be something fresh?
It's more like 2 parallel universes colliding
They already have. The stone dungeon boyd was in was clearly in ruins
It's from the creators of lost there's literally a character named Eloise there is definitely going to be time travel😂
Heres a comment someone else posted that ive expanded on and i fully believe it was the core inspirstions for the shows concept
"It's Carcosa, more closely, the Dreamlands from Lovecraft and Eldrich lore. Symbol is that of Atlach Nacha, evil spider god that links dimensions. The walkers are ghouls, and Hastur is the big bad controlling the entire realm."
Hastur per the original writings was know as the king in yellow.
We see so many uses of the color yellow in the show. Even certain scenes filmed with a yellow filter.
We see a painting of a man in a yellow suit in the basement.
Atlach nacha was a spider god that "resides in a cave system and it spins a great web, forming a great bridge between the Dreamlands and the waking world."
Don't you think Hastur is, indeed, a good entity? Maybe Atlach Nacha is the bad one, and Hastur might take the form of the kid in white, or just being a good etity in general?
@@purva.ashadha I guess it could depend on which iteration of him is being used
I love this theory SO MUCH!!! I made a similar connection to the possibility of this being some sort of cycle or soul harvest in a Reddit post not too long ago, but this is next level by x1000!!!! This is the best, hands down!!!
thank you so much, I appreciate your comment :D I think is the way they're going hopefully is true.
Ok I don’t think the Fromland or the entity is causing the reincarnation process. I believe that it’s the original spirit/soul that was there from the beginning is forcibly choosing women to be reborn into or enter, in order to end the entire cycle and save the children. I’ll add on the other theory I have about the children being born in the area and sacrificed to/claimed by this entity. The spirit that’s choosing these woman is probably the first woman who had her child sacrificed to the entity, which gave it strength enough to start the cycle and create Fromland. After that it receives a sacrifice or claims another child that’s born there and grows even stronger spreading its influence. This is why I think the same test is going to happen with Fatima’s child and why I believe the Kimono lady is one of the mothers who had her child sacrificed to/claimed by the entity and is trying to warn her through Elgin somehow. Maybe Elgin has some kind of 6th sense that makes it easier for her to reach out to him.
Just off topic, I find it interesting that lots of characters dont have family, or lived with Grandparents. Elgin lived with his Grandmother. Jade said he lived with his Grandmother in france until she died, then lived with an uncle. and Fatima said her Dad and brother i think she said were killed. and Sara said her brother Nathan was only person she had left, implies she has had bereavement. perhaps there's a link. maybe not. just thought it was interesting. maybe its just how the town picks people, so there isnt too many people looking for them.
but we know very little about most of the chars backgrounds say for handful to know if they have more family
Another great video Christian - I appreciate that Robert's theory in letters is finally coming to light 🎉 yrs in the making
Hey @blake8366! Thanks for the kind words! I'm glad you appreciate that the Robert number theory is finally getting some attention. It's awesome to see so many fans connecting with these ideas! Thanks for the comment! - BP
Rende-moves is a play on the word rendezvous, which means a meeting at an Agreed time and place
It also means a haunt
It’s French as well
Here's my theory i think that the town and the jungle and everything present in there like the monsters, animals like crow, spiders, boy in white basically everything is controlled by someone lets name him god. The people of that area who lived in jungle whose House we saw in the recent episodes used to pray to that god and they also used to do some rituals to make him happy which we saw in drawings in the tunnels, i think those are made by the tride that lived there but victor said that paintings were made by the monsters which i don't think is the truth because the monsters sleep during day and comes out at night so they don't have time to draw and all. I think that the god is somehow trapped, he wants to be free thats why he trap people from outside world so that they can free him and by making him free i mean from earth not from the village as many people says that by breaking light in lighthouse will make him free and he will control outside world, i think that he can already control the outside world as we saw victor's mom had dreams about that place when she was outside so he was able to control her and thats how he gets people in fromville amd whoever the god is i think he want people to go out in jungle and find answers and i think that's how he will be free as we have seen multiple times in the series that whenever someone went to jungle they have found something good like boid found animals, talismans , lighthouse, Tabitha went outside too with the help of lighthouse which is present in jungle and in recent episodes the asian sheriff found vegetables in the jungle, i think the god grew these vegetables for them he wants them to be alive so that they try to get free from fromville and make him free and we have also seen that the god doesn't want them to discover anything in the town because when tabitha tried to dig hole in the house the house collapsed and when her husband tried to build tower storm came and destroyed bulbs which is the gods power he can control everything there and I think the talisman can't do anything in front of god as we have seen him destroying tabithas house which had a talisman and he can kill people in daytime too as we saw him killing that girl in her dream that too in day time in house with talisman I think he wants them to be alive and he want's them to be afraid so that they try to escape and make him free thats why monsters are there so that they can make people afraid and i don't think there is any way to leave this town , they can only leave when they make him the god free and i think the monsters were people who made this town and we also see their furniture which is in Tunnel with them they must have failed to make the god free and died and i think that the god controlles Tabitha and victors mom and they keep getting dream about freeing children i think that means to free the god and the boy in white is also controlled by him just to foll people that there is someone helping them as we saw when all the people from town died he was smiling and playing and the lighthouse will play an important role in freeing the god
This kind of still falls in the line of time travel, but with the conscience time-traveling this is a great theory one of my favorite so far, Remember we got time travel in lost with Desmond Desmond's conscience going from the past to the present.
It’s Ran-Dey-Move, a play on words like Rendezvous (Ran-Dey-Voo) which means to meet as planned. So moving company has something to do with people meeting up in Fromville
@@paulbuttita666 thanks for the comment Paul
ETHAN IS VICTOR IN THE SAME TIMELINE AS TABITHA, SO IT'S POSSIBLE THAT VICTOR WILL DIE AT THE END OF THIS SEASON IF THE TOWN'S CURSE IS NOT BROKEN. The town from has been fulfilling the same role for generations, so don't be surprised if, upon killing the next monster, another one appears with the same appearance from this same timeline, meaning someone they know but from the dark side. Just like a tragic ending where ETHAN is the only one to survive from the entire town as Victor did in his time if they fail to achieve the goal of freeing the children from the lighthouse
@@xSDxReaper uhsudhushds is ETHAMN NOT THOMAS MY ERROR
how? not one thing yo said makes sense
Do you really think they would kill their entire cast? lol
Why does no one talk about how Marvin “threw” a rope to Boyd while he’s chained up???? Who threw the rope????
@@Deanjacob7 mental time travel 🤔 someone from the future travels mentally to the past….
@@BEYONDPREMIERE but how was the rope thrown down the well? Martin was chained up?
@@BEYONDPREMIERE are you saying someone else time traveled there or Boyd in another time? Because I think it was the entity that threw the music box but it could be Boyd later in series goes back and throws it for himself. Also I kind of think Martin is Boyd’s passed life or maybe his future life
@@Deanjacob7 yes someone from the future travel mentally into this space, and gave Boyd the rope but who?
Maybe wall chain guy could manifest certain things, just nothing to feed or free himself
best theory yet great video
Thanks for the comment, I may do the opposite of this where Victor is Tabitha sister haha
I am a heavy believer that the light plays a huge part. Everything is based around fire and light, lowkey
Honestly, after rewatching Lost recently, this theory makes a lot of sense... I also keep thinking the symbol looks like roots or timelines overlapping or colliding. Maybe the two vehicles with chosen people crashing?
Would definitely like to see more analysis on the creepy children and rituals, feels like there's something big to unpack there.
I just rewatched Lost too! Man, that show is phenomenal. I see interesting similarities. The random pregnancies with Sun and Fatima, the importance of numbers.. ahhh!
What a great show they've created with From.
Lost maybe the best show ever but from season 1 was peak even tho pace in past season was horrible
Lost started great but then the story was all over the place and writers later admitted they were making up stuff as they go. The stories didn't always make sense and sci-fi explanations was ridiculous. Still lost deserves credit as one of the best mystery box shows even if the ending was a letdown. I'm pretty sure writers for this show have a big story mapped out and they're teasing us with lots of mysteries but no answers yet.
This is one of the bes shows on in a long time when it comes to philosophy, horror, drama, thriller, and so much more it’s itself it’s own category of a show/movie when shows have a movie level budget nowadays with streaming. Harold peraneu was amazing as manny in Constantine which only got 13 episodes cuz it was literally the year before streaming shows started getting 2016, that itself was a crime to cancel. Matt Ryan and Harold Paraneu are great Matt Ryan is John Constantine, watch it if you like Harold u won’t ne disappointed with the show but u will that they cut the show NBC made a mistake, so glad FROM , got it’s chance and grows with every episode to be better and better much like Constantine was…
I totally agree! FROM is in a league of its own. It blends so many genres, into something truly unique. I'm loving how FROM keeps getting better and more intense with every episode! Thanks for the comment!
Same with Elgin I think he’s to got flashbacks from he’s previous variations, and monster in this flashbacks it’s what Fatima variation became back than
@@yegor576 that’s really interesting, maybe the reason hhe was called to the brundles?
Elgin’s character in Fromville stands out as particularly enigmatic, with many clues suggesting that he has a deeper connection to the town than most other recent arrivals. His role seems to be one of a harbinger-someone who knows more than he consciously understands, carrying an inexplicable awareness of the danger the town presents.
1. Arrival with Premonitions
Elgin’s introduction is notable because even before he arrives in Fromville, he displays signs of unease. On the bus, he has an instinctual, almost primal fear about where they’re going. This makes him unique among the newcomers, as he seems to have a kind of forewarning about the place. It’s almost as if he’s either been there before in another form, perhaps in a past cycle, or he has a connection to the previous residents. His instincts set the tone for his character as someone attuned to the supernatural undercurrents of Fromville.
2. The Flood Dream
Elgin’s dream about the flood is one of the most significant pieces of his character development so far. The flood could symbolize a reset, destruction, or a cleansing event tied to the end of the current cycle in Fromville. The fact that Elgin dreams about it suggests that he might either be reliving someone else's past experience or having a vision of what’s to come. This kind of prophetic insight aligns him with other characters like Victor, who also has knowledge that exceeds that of the typical resident. It implies that Elgin is either destined to play a critical role when this event comes to pass or that he is carrying the memories of someone who lived through a similar catastrophic event in the town’s past.
3. Potential Role as a Replacement
If the theory about Fromville being cyclical and each new arrival replacing a past figure is correct, Elgin might be a replacement for a character from a previous cycle-perhaps even someone who died during the last iteration of the flood. His dreams could be echoes of experiences lived by that person, indicating that Elgin is meant to take on their role. This replacement idea suggests that Elgin's importance may become more evident as the cycle progresses, particularly if the flood he envisions comes closer to becoming reality.
4. Intuitive Understanding of the Town
Throughout his time in Fromville, Elgin shows a deeper level of intuition than many other newcomers. He quickly adapts to the strange rules and behaviors needed to survive, almost as if he already knows what’s required. This intuitive knowledge sets him apart and suggests that Elgin’s connection to Fromville might be more profound than mere coincidence. He could be tapping into a collective memory or consciousness that exists within the town, similar to how the voices influence Sara. This connection might make him crucial to understanding how to either navigate the dangers or possibly break free of the town’s control.
5. Catalyst or Key Player?
Elgin’s role seems to be gearing up towards something pivotal. Whether his presence is a catalyst for a major event, like the flood, or he himself is the key to changing or breaking the cycle remains to be seen. His character feels like one that will have a major impact, either by directly taking action that shifts the town’s fate or by serving as a bridge to understanding its deeper mysteries. His ability to sense danger, his prophetic dreams, and his intuitive grasp of the town’s supernatural rules all suggest that Elgin is not just another resident-he’s a potential game-changer.
6. Connection to the Town's Energy
Elgin might also be sensitive to the energy or force that drives Fromville. Characters like Sara hear voices, Victor has his drawings, and Boyd experiences unique phenomena, and Elgin seems to have his own connection through dreams and intuition. If Fromville is a place that pulls on people’s fears, hopes, and emotions, then Elgin’s connection to the flood might symbolize a broader link to the town’s essence. He could represent the impending change or chaos that the flood symbolizes-a force that disrupts the current order to allow for something new to begin.
Conclusion
Elgin’s character is still unfolding, but he is clearly positioned as someone with a deep, possibly supernatural connection to Fromville. His premonitions, intuitive understanding, and potential as a replacement for someone from a previous cycle all suggest that he is far from an ordinary newcomer. Instead, Elgin feels like a character who embodies change-perhaps a harbinger of the flood or a key player who could either trigger a reset or help navigate its consequences. As the story progresses, Elgin’s role may become crucial in revealing whether Fromville is destined to repeat its cycles endlessly or if there’s a possibility of breaking free from its grip.
@@MichaelSmith-lm5sl Elgin has visions like a psychic but he doesn't exhibit anything unusual. Tilly acts a little creepy at times too but I think they're both red herrings. Elgin likely can see the future as he has weird visions when he sleeps. I'm thinking from land is a nexus of parallel dimensions where humans and monsters and time travel all converge. The tree on the road is a Venus fly trap and portal in and the lighthouse is a portal out and the ghosts 👻 are spirits of past victims trapped in from land. The boy in white is giving clues to Victor and Tabitha how to get out. So this is kinda like stranger things where monsters from another dimension escapes into the human world but in this case humans are trapped in a monster world. The show keeps us guessing which is what makes a good mystery box show. Hopefully writers aren't cooking up stuff as we go and they have a nice story mapped out.
@@MichaelSmith-lm5slLooks AI generated.
@@addytv18I had the same impression right away.
I don't think there's any time travel involved. I think there's some Celtics stuff and curses going around
@@SilentTrip but who thew the rolls
I really like this theory. What if all the souls that reincarnate into the town are from the original dwellers of that town. Maybe they all got caught there during a rough winter in the past and took on the wendingo curse which manifested all of their worse nightmares to come true within a spirit realm that doesn’t exist in our dimension. And the only way the wendingo curse will be lifted is if all the nightmare curses are broken one by one. What if Boyd can not be physically harmed by any nightmare manifestation now because he broke the music box nightmare curse. Maybe Victor broke a curse that we don’t know about which is why he is still alive. And maybe now perhaps Tabitha has broken a curse. There could be a nightmare curse for each person in town to solve. The nightmare curse entity wants Boyd to lose hope along with his mind because he seems to be a force to be reckoned with, he found the talismans, created civilization, and broke a curse. The town likes Victor because he is so childlike and complacent while Boyd is coming strong and strategic.
If the town works in the cycles each person remembers their previous cycles 🤔
I never noticed the moving company... now you have me thinking
@@KorDawg91 and the Numbers! Is interesting man 🤔🤔🤔
@@BEYONDPREMIERE Yes!! Thank you man
@@KorDawg91 thanks for the comment appreciate the support 🍕
Going on the reincarnation theory makes sense. Given Smiley dies in season 2 ep6 and Fatima finds out she is pregnant close to end of season 2. It could be Smiley reincarnated would explain the spoilt food she is eating given smiley wasnt alive but a trapped soul.Thoughts people?
Just like how Aang in avatar the last airbender, used artifacts to connect with his past lives, I think Tabitha’s discovery of Miranda’s paintings, the dress she finds and the bracelet is key to understanding her own connection to Fromville. What do you guys think? Is reincarnation playing a role in From? Let’s discuss!
PS This is actually one of my favorite theories, I research so I really hope is true.
Do you have a Instagram? I found out something interesting about the site and my comment seems its getting (b)locked as i log out and its gone. maybe it will pop up.
I got way to show the hidden features.
I just figured out how to show the hidden image, i had to type 6 lines in console and then it popped up and its a drawing of victors and its a house with the date very scribbly 1597 over the roof with a line through the roof and chimney puffing smoke and looks like two creatures on both sides of the house. I have so much info right now but code and shortcuts dont seem to take in comments and get blocked.
rendezmove.com/secret-01.jpg this link should bring you to the secret image. I opened in a separate tab after i found bookmarked and then opened bookmark and brought me to the image only. so seems to work if does not disappear. Sorry so many messages i am in sherlock homes mode!
Rendez-Move -
much more Rendez-Vous
Interesting connections!!
Came here to say this. Yeah it’s even weirder with the definition of rendezvous: a meeting at an agreed time and place-is From the agreed place?? 6:34
@@PixelatedLindsyes! It complements these theories and perhaps I am merely stating the obvious, but I feel all over the place with ideas as well.
Every 47 years or something or other.
I rewatched the tarot card scene and idk if this means anything but when they were shuffling Tilly said the cards told her about this place (fromland) if she knew how to read the signs right… then when asked does she know how to read them now she said yea a lot better than she used to… how long has Tilly been there to all of a sudden be a tarot reader? Unless she was referring to the first time she was there compared to this time and when the crow hit the window Tilly was unbothered and even tried to get Fatima to ignore it…Tilly is suspect!
What if the boy in white was supposed to be one of the kids that were sacrificed but somehow escaped and his soul isn’t trapped but helping others to break the cycle. Maybe that is why now every circle one kid gets to be saved. That was Victor in the previous circle. Maybe now it’s going to be Ethan.🤷♀️
I have heard a lot of theories about the show. Been watching since the beginning. I believe they are on a level of the astral plane. I’m just throwing this out because I haven’t heard anyone bring it up. There are levels in the plane that mimic our world but are basically inescapable. And these places can feed off our emotions.
That's a really interesting perspective, @peacefulrain86! Thanks for sharing your theory. I'll definitely be thinking about this! 🤔
Ughhhhh. Please don't promote reincarnation and time travel nonsense. Pleaseeeeeee. It's almost as bad as promoting the idea that a "mole" exists.
Hey there! I understand your frustration with the reincarnation and time travel theories. It's true that these concepts can sometimes feel overused.
However, many viewers find these ideas to be interesting ways of explaining the mysteries and repetitive patterns in From.
My goal is to explore different interpretations and create discussion among fans. Whether or not these theories are ultimately "true" within the show's is something we'll have to see as the season unfolds! Thanks for sharing your perspective!
Wow, keep up the great work!
Thank you! will do.
Tabitha and Jim are in their mid 30s. Reincarnation is still possible. You don’t necessarily reincarnate the minute you die.
Thats what I thought too.
The kid that has a problem sleeping, that Raven broke in and hes been wearing a t shirt with a black bird on it this entire time
I don’t think that’s the case, if Miranda had the visions before entering into the town, and Tabatha is her again, why Tabatha doesn’t had the vision’s before entering into the town too?
@@elBotillo I think she will 🙂↔️ but is going to be in a future episode, maybe. She doesn’t remember yet. 🤞
I don' see grounds for this theory. The web article Victor's father finds about Tabitha's family going missing says she's in her mid 30s. According to the series timeline we are in year 2021 and she's been missing just for 21 days. When the actress filmed S1 she was 39. The iterations mean there's a repeating cycle throughout the time, but that doesn't mean it has to involve reincarnation.
You make a valid point about the discrepancies in Tabitha's age and the timeline presented in the show. The information in the news article does conflict with the actress's real age and the timeframe established in the series.
However, it's important to remember that the reincarnation theory is just that a theory. It's a possible interpretation of the clues presented, not necessarily a definitive explanation. Those discrepancies could be explained by the town's manipulation of time, memories, or even reality itself. From is a show where the impossible often happens, so a time-bending or reality-altering explanation for those inconsistencies cannot be ruled out. Let's see how things develop as the season continues. I have to add, thanks for always leaving a comment in the videos I appreciate it :D
@@BEYONDPREMIEREOf course, a theory as such has its strengths and weaknesses, otherwise it wouldn't be a theory, it would be an explanation. Besides, I understand the need to create new content.
Apart from that, I think we all want the show to be a mix of sci-fi and supernatural elements, just like Lost (tho I refuse to think the show has a religious main plot).
And despite that wish, I'm starting to be open to other possibilities. Miranda started having visions after a session with acid. Jade has visions and he was an addict. The song Blue is about drugs. We don't know anything about Tabitha and Jim's youth, but I'm starting to considerJim's theory about the whole thing being some kind of experiment, and in particular something like Project MK Ultra came to my mind.
In other words, at this point we should ask ourselves why the showrunners have been throwing in so many things related to drugs.
@@nicocba2007 Thank you Nico, will use it in the next theory I do!
I don’t know for the first 3 episodes they haven’t rlly showed Elgin that much i feel like he’s a lot more connected than we realize and could be the 3rd reincarnation
I don't agree with the idea of reincarnation because we know that Miranda had those dreams and visions about these paintings before she arrived in fromville. but Tabitha never had such kind of visions before coming to fromville. she was completely new to this world based on the behaviors she has while she was still in the village I believe in reincarnation here if in some scenes Tabitha declared that she saw this or that stuff but don't remember how
I knew it something was off, when i was watching episode 1,2 and 3 i knew it, i even though maybe Victor is Ethan, Victor's dad is Jim and Tabatha is Victor's mother but from different dimension or something like that, i know this sounds crazy but this is just my first draft of thinking, haven't refined yet, and then stumbled upon your video which is exactly what i needed to say. 😅😮
I found more proof :D
Concurrent incarnations are also a thing, with the same spirit being incarnated in different lives that may be living while another incarnation is living
Hey @dockaiju, that's a really cool idea! Concurrent reincarnations would make Fromville's influence even more messed up than we thought. If the same soul could be in multiple bodies at once, it would totally explain why we see similar people and personalities in Fromville across different times. Plus, it would make the town's messing with time and reality even crazier than it already is! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
"Okay" is the key.
@@legitimatehumanbeing8746 play 🤔
Maybe, the victims of the town who were massacred. Are the souls we see. And they are getting revenge on the people who killed them offsprings…in return making them suffer.
Victors mom could be the one who set up this entire loop. With some sort of black magic, to claim revenge and possibly some sort of closure
In the desert star article it says that the parents are both in their mid-30s so Tabitha couldn’t be born in 1978. I’m in my early 30s and I was born in the 90’a
Julie, Mari, and Randall were chained to the wall and Boyd broke the curse. There were 2 skeletons next to Martin, I bet Randall is the Martin in the future and the two skeletons are Julie and Mari. Jade is a Christopher and Christopher ended up killing the town's people. Jade also see a tree of dead bodies hanging in Season 1 episode 6 and I bet the black soldier chasing Jade is past Boyd who is trying to kill Jade for killing the men in the trees. Reincarnations also don't have to be the same sex or race, so what if the monster who went into the bus and looked like it was remembering to drive the bus is actually Bakta the bus driver. I bet the women who Elgin sees in the when he was sleeping is a future Fatima.
Martin had a tattoo tho
@@BEYONDPREMIERE The place is a paradox with cycles. The present people that we know could be reincarnations of Martin, the monsters etc. I think the symbol with the 3 lines crossing represents different portal areas which are past, present, and future. So there's past, present and future versions of everyone.
Randall does seem like he had ptsd even before Fromville..like hes seen wartime
Goddamnit. This is what I’ve been thinking but didn’t want to happen. You made me see I can’t ignore the signs.
Anything but aliens will be fine with me😂
hahahaha I remember back in season 1, a lot of people said Aliens haha
Thanks for your comment Debbie :D Always nice to see your comment
I had the exact same thoughts about Tabitha being Miranda reincarnated, and that Miranda's visions of other "chosen ones" from the past are just her, over and over. I hadn't considered that Jade might be a reincarnation, but that makes sense with his visions! I do think that Fromville is in a cycle, but I think Boyd may have broken that cycle when he killed one of the monsters, because everything has escalated since then, and from the cast interviews I've seen, it's only going to get worse. I don't think the town has had to deal with anyone like Boyd before.
Amazing! You're totally on the same wavelength! The Miranda/Tabitha reincarnation theory is seriously interesting. Can't wait to see what happens. 👍
The article states that Tabitha and Jim are in their mid-30s sooo nope for the 1978 theory. Also, Boyd is the man in yellow.
I thought i was watching someone with 500k subscribers
That means a lot, thanks for the support to the channel!
this is the correct theory 100% this explains everything
She said a few things in last week’s episode that made me think this
There’s more proof I may do a part 2 , thanks for the comment man 🙏
I wonder what those toys and cards mean on the tower stairs
I really think you might be on to something here...and it could be inspired by Buddhist/reincarnation mythology where there are lots of different worlds or 'bardos' and some of them are hell worlds and populated by 'hungry ghosts'...demons which, when you think about it, sound a lot like the evil vampire things in From...
Anyone notice that the newspaper article writer's name is also Ethan
I love how my comments all disappeared on how to open the hidden image and how to see it and how i found it.
I notice that boy all dressed in white looks like ethan 🤔
5:40 Am I the only one who sees a tower in the symbol Jade keeps seeing?
I get it, it would make some sense, but Tabitha and Miranda would both have been alive at the same time
Hello, I’m Cecilia. Nice to meet you!
This theory might be correct Miranda had two children victor and his sister same as tabitha, victor and Ethan have some similarities.
And we know Thomas died
What if same thing happend miranda and she did some ritual in the park(where the bottle tree is in the real life) to bring his dead son back
And she had to do something to do so ( releasing the children from the tower)
Or
what if the boy in the white is Miranda's son and he is trapped in the FROM TOWN because miranda failed and remember when sara said the boy in the white wants to help and he is trapped in here like us
Jim also received a call from his son what if tabihta did the same and now Thomas is also trapped
Hey @Zubair-ahmad_! That's a really interesting take on the reincarnation theory! You've highlighted some HUGE connections: Miranda and Tabitha both having two children, similarities between Victor and Ethan.
Thanks for the comment! - BP
@@BEYONDPREMIERE ☺ love your videos and thanks for replying 😁
@@Zubair-ahmad_ thank you 🙏 I appreciate the support
What does chatgpt say about the website code?
6:52
so miranda would be seeing tabitha's life at fromville and it's just a infinite loop ♾️
That's the way I see it, the confirmation of this is the number's in the lighthouse.
Jade dosent see a pilgrim, look up the dress of what people were wearing during the American revolution. One of thr dates on lighthouse was for the Boston tea party.
My prediction is that Jade will end S3 ep10 saying, "i now finally understand everything. I now got it"😂🤣
What if the baby Fatima is having is Elgin? Because he has those weird visions of Fatima like woman haunting him and water would mean something
Elgin just needs to help that lady in the kimono, that's my theory
With these theory in mind, Boyd could be the reincarnation of Martin. "My blood is your blood"
“Dahbeetah” (Tabitha) I love it 😊
@@Jason_wears_stuff 🤣🤣🤣 is dahbeetah from now on 🫡
@@BEYONDPREMIERE 🤣🤣 bet ! It’s the Way you pronounce it 🤌🏾
@8:34 In the caves you can see the talisman fence at the cabins (the people in red)/scarecrows. protecting the crops
Talismans were used by the people in the cabins (the people in red). This confirms they knew about the creatures and were trying to protect themselves.
The caves are depicting events from the past. The drawings could be a historical record of the town's early days and the struggles of its first inhabitants.
@@BEYONDPREMIERE the red people are the scarecrows/voodoo tower you can see them surrounding crops
Maybe the children they’re supposed to free are their own children, by ignoring the demon monster children, and leaving their own to survive, and some how no one mentions it or notices that these are some of the worst moms ever lmfao.
If Christianity is to be believed the human race started with the Garden of Eden, is everyone FROM here? Cycles and reincarnation seem the most plausible theory to date. Could the cycles expand the Garden of Eden/Fromville? Could it swallow the real world?
@@kayellis4096 I think that what the symbol jade found like a portal 🤔
If they use time travel it will be very stupid and another shitty version of Lost. (Excuse my french)
This series is good and they do NOT need to ruin it with freaking time travel again like they did with Lost.
Great theory!
Wow, and they both have 2 kids - boy + girl.
Its all because of Gabriel (The Trickster)😄if you know you know...
@@margaritayoung hahaha true true
Boyd = Martin.
“Your blood, is my blood”. 😮
This can be a reach but on Tabitha’s forehead there is a 3 at 9:44
Not gonna lie I thought you was reaching but you can see it I didn’t want to see it but I did, I think this was done on purpose
I hope that’s not the case. But you make a convincing argument.
@@kim3295 I have more proof 👀🫣
IF reincarnation or some other similar device, the man in yellow = Boyd.
@@madamesherice that’s a nice observation 🤔🤔 excited to see how it connects
Good stuff
Glad you enjoyed
boyd was in the military too / hence the civil war soldier
@@MaximumBirddNutz Martin was also military but he was alive tho 🤔