खबरों से दूर क्यों रहती हैं महिलाएं? [Why do women avoid watching news]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- मीडिया में महिलाओं से जुड़े मुद्दों पर चर्चा इतनी कम क्यों होती है? गंभीर मुद्दों पर चर्चा करने के लिए टीवी चैनल अपने पैनल पर पुरुषों को ही बुलाना क्यों पसंद करते हैं. महिलाओं की पत्रकारों से क्या अपेक्षाएं हैं? ऐसे ही और सवालों पर @mojostory की बरखा दत्त और @newslaundry की मनीषा पांडे के साथ डॉयचे वेले की ईशा भाटिया सानन की बातचीत. कमेंट कर के हमें बताएं कि आप किस तरह का कंटेंट देखना पसंद करते हैं.
In this video:
01:00 Isha Bhatia Sanan in roundtable conversation with Barkha Dutt and Manisha Pande
02:00 Why are newsrooms considered toxic?
04:15 The story of Prabha Dutt - India's first woman war correspondent
07:02 Barely five percent of newsroom leadership roles in newspapers are held by women
07:50 Why are women in media not able to reach leadership positions?
10:00 Do female anchors feel compelled to behave like their male counterparts?
12:30 What do Indian viewers want from mainstream media?
13:25 Are women's themes confined to cooking gas and onion prices?
16:00 Do Indian women not like to discuss geopolitics?
17:40 Female voters were important for political parties in the 2024 elections.
19:30 Exit polls were wrong because they could not capture women's sentiments.
20:45 Why do women not comment on social media videos?
25:00 Have media panels turned into manels?
26:00 Why is there special coverage on women for women's day?
27:00 Girls are still skipping college because of a lack of toilets.
30:15 It will take 75 years to reach gender parity according to UNDP.
31:15 Do female anchors feel pressured to look a certain way?
37:00 Is it necessary to have make-up on to become a television anchor?
![बॉलीवुड में #MeToo: सिल्वर स्क्रीन की मटमैली दुनिया [#MeToo in Bollywood] | DW Documentary हिन्दी](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XE0vEa5bYgE/mqdefault.jpg)
![दुनिया को बदल देने वाली कंसल्टेंसी कंपनियों का काला सच [Consultants Hidden Influence Over Our World]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yTH8G2jPPxg/mqdefault.jpg)
आपके चक्कर में सेहत टॉक कितनी बार देख लिए
Isliye to berojgar ho😂
Shi khel gya😂😂😂
बिल्कुल सही कहा
मुझे भी सेहत की टॉपिक में दिलचस्पी है लेकिन कोई खूबसूरती के साथ हो तो और ज्यादा अच्छा लगता है बसरते वो झूठ नहीं बोल रही हो ,....
😂😂
Exactly 😅😅😅
बहुत अच्छा पॉडकास्ट है हालाकि मैं एक पुरुष दर्शक(male viewer) हूँ मुझे यह भी पता है कि नीचे जो कॉमेंट आये है उसमें से अधिकांश कॉमेंट पुरुष के होंगे। मैं इस पॉडकास्ट को कई महिला दोस्तों के साथ शेयर करुंगा। काफी सूचना से भरा विषय है। धन्यवाद @DW हिन्दी
Male Commenter: You three are so wonderful. Thanks for such a nice talk. I shared it with many of my family members and friends. I watch newslaundry regularly and love Manisha's TV newsense series. I never actually came across mojo stories but I'll check it out and I've watched few topics on sehat talk but not a regular viewer. Anyways great conversation and I am hopeful to see such talks in future as well. I wish you three great health and well-being.
अचार्य प्रशांत जी को show पर बुलाइए। महिलाओं से ज्यादा वो महिलाओं के सशक्तिकरण पर बात कर रहे है।
❤
Yes, Absolutely, Acharya Prashant❤
महिला सशक्तिकरण केवल महिलाओं का मुद्दा नहीं है, यह पुरुषों के लिए भी एक राहत की बात है कि उनके आस पास की महिलाएं independent , secure , capable हों।..
Right
@@nilimamisra3819 khtam kr degi
Phle family system
Than country
Kyuki sbse choti ikai privar h
बस एक बात ही बोलुंगा
एक शिशु को नहीं पता होता कि वो लड़की है या लड़का
पर मां ही उसे बताती है कि उसके लिए क्या ठीक है
फिर बताया जाता है कि लड़की को सुंदर दिखाना जरूरी है।
और इस तरह से उसे कोमलता का लिवास पहना दिया जाता है
एक पुरुष को कठोरता का लिवास पहना दिया जाता है।
क्यों विज्ञान और बायोकेमिस्ट्री , बायोलॉजी को झुठला रहे हो भाई? उनका शरीर देखो और पुरुष का देखो , क्या फर्क साफ नहीं है? कितना भी कोशिश कर लो औरत पुरुष कभी नहीं बन सकती!
महिलाएं पैदा नहीं होती महिलाएं बनाई जाती है:-साइमन द बुआ
न तो पुरुष स्त्री बन सकता है
और न ही स्त्री, पुरुष बन सकतीं हैं
लेकिन दोनों की क्षमताओं को सीमित नहीं कर सकते हैं
समाज को दृष्टिकोण सही रखना होगा 🙏
Great video! The insights were really helpful and well-presented. Looking forward to more content like this. Keep up the good work!
First for equality is start from home because female and male work are not same Strongly female have more burden the home responsibility is not right .
I am a truck driver in United States Drive from California to New York. Your videos are amazing . I like listening your podcast while driving.
Please don't use Phone while driving 😢😢
That's USA. Rules and practices are different there. It's normal there as they use Bluetooth and handsfree technology while using phone during driving.@@Darpanjoshi123
@@sharmisthapurakayastha9563 Driving needs concentration more than anything....
Isha 'Bhatia' 'Sanan'!! Isn't it hypocrisy? How can you talk against male domination while bearing the burden of husband's surname! Why don't you have your original one only??
Hi Isha, please make an episode on Gender pay GAP scenario and its reasons. And what actions are being taken globally to fill this GAP.
I gone through the whole comment section but didn't find that comment about Maternity Leave (40:00).
Is this only for sensation and to look extra feminist.
स्त्री ...... Author - Acharya Prashant
❤आचार्य प्रशांत
गोदी मीडिया को सिर्फ़ अज्ञानी मानव देखता है ज्ञानी मानव सरकार से सवाल करने वाला न्यूज देखता है, महिला रहे या पुरुष कोई मतलब नहीं है, गोदी मीडिया का view बहुत नीचे चला गया है
As a male, i think female related topics should be on the show, because still now in 21st century females are underrated.
As a female commenter I want to say that news matters to us as much as it matters to Men. Isha mam I really like the way you present every topic.glad to see women like you in media
good evening Isha mam
I am a regular follower of you,Palki Sharma mam,Dhruv Rathee sir,etc
I am a boy(19) but i hate this patriarchy society
Yes i just come across a similar situation yesterday
One of my uncle (my grand pa younger brother last son)is in army.
Yesterday he watching a vedio on my mobile,when the vedio end the next vedio play where i record the vedio of my two older sister (cousin) making roti in front of my mother,where she can't flip the roti correctly.
So watching that he just arrogantly said they are of age of marriage can't make roti properly.
So I just reply so what you know to make roti perfectly but you never enter the kitchen grand ma still doing that .
he then reply why should we do that let the female do our work then we cook.
then i angrily replied ya your job can be replaced by Ai & robotics, only for the lazy government you are still in job.
he then got angry and go away
yes I agree i told him rudely the ai & robotics statement as he is an indian army
but it is wrong a educated army (only age of 30)also said patriarchy statement like that then what the normal people thought about patriarchy.
we are not from any low village
we are in developing city our home is located side of a state highway
दोनों स्वतंत्र पत्रकार हैं पर दोनों में एक कामन कमी है कि अपने महिला viewership के लिए हिंदी में काम नहीं करती है।
दूसरे लगातार महिला की समस्या ,बातों को उनके साथ बात कर नहीं उठाती।
जब आप popular और सबके चहेती बनना चाहती है तो समाज , राजनीतिक की ग्रांउड रियलिटी पर बेबाक प्रोग्राम करें और उनके बीच में जाकर बात कर प्रोग्राम करें।
निधि राजदान भी सशक्त महिला एंकर है ।
आप में से किसी “एक “ ने किसी एक दलित आदिवासी महिला को अपने क्षेत्र में लाने का प्रयास किया है
Fantastic conversation👏
Three favourite women in one frame ..❤
At 37:38 manisha is talking about INDRA NOOYI
We always talk about education of girls and boys because their age is to learn and afterwards earn, but why don't we talk, find a way, and implent the strategies to educate old parents, now parents and would be parents especially in india , because it is likely said in india that your first guru is mother and father and then afterwards friends and teachers and so the teachers are also likely to be the same kind of parents we have ?...
I think it's one of the part of our (Indian) problem that we neglect the parental education.
Consider seriously my idea and produce as many shows on this topic.
As we know that roots are as important as the tree above ground.
What do you say about yourself....why did DW hindi hired you?
Have stopped watching TV since last few years. Am willing and interested to watch and discuss any topic because I consider myself first as a human being born with intellect and a woman next. Am a feminist in its true sense. Thanks for the program, the topic was interesting and insightful.
मैम जी प्रणाम, मैम जी अगला वीडियो अपनी यात्रा पर बनाइए वो कौन सा मोड़ था जिससे आप इस मुकाम तक पहुंचीं। क्योंकि आप भी मेरे लिए एक मार्गदर्शक है ,वो इसलिए क्योंकि आपकी हर एक बात एक नई दिशा और सीख देने वाली होती है। मेरा तो मानना है कि जिंदगी में कुछ बनो तो एक कायदे का नैतिक इंसान बनो चाहे कुछ हासिल हो या न हो कम से कम अगला इंसान आप से सहजता और सुकून से बात तो कर सकेगा यहीं जिंदगी की सबसे बड़ी सफलता है। मैम जी इस वीडियो के लिए आप का शुक्रिया।
You are talking about the women anchors on the TV Talk shows, but those women are absent in this discussion to get their view point. Is this discussion just about left leaning media ?
हमे तो लाइव न्यूज देखना ही बेकार लगता है क्योंकी वैसे ही स्क्रीन टाइम लोगों का बढ़ा रहता है , हम तो बस वही all india रेडियो आकाशवाणी इंजॉय करते है , वहां पर चंद्रिका जोशी जैसी पत्रकार के माध्यम से न्यूज सुनते है
Me too...aapke chakkar me padhai chhor kar aapka show dekne lge....
Madam, would you suggest that female news anchors and journalists could encourage more housewives to watch news ? And secondly do you think that voice of the female news anchor if presented in hoarse voice (similar to men's voice) is becoming a reason of popularity ?!
D W हिंदी का कोई भी एपिसोड हम मिस नहीं करते हैं ❤❤❤
Eeshaa sanon*Kriti sanon= B U T full ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Apko Lallantop se observe karna chahiye...they are doing good work
Very interesting conversation, please do another such episode on gender disparity in corporate sector in India we the women are considered "Paraya" there also
मेरा मानना है पुरुष के मुकाबले महिलाएं न्यूज़ कम कंज्यूम करती हैं वह ज्यादातर इंटरटेनमेंट देखना पसंद करती हैं इसलिए शायद
Aisa bilkul nhi hai i am a woman and i watch multiple news that too serious one
@@nashrafazalu may be an exception or from few exceptions otherwise what
He said is a fact.
You are absolutely right
Barkha is truly a gem. Every time I listen to her, my understanding of gender becomes clearer. Thank you for this podcast, DW!
Menstrual me bhi ज्यादा दिक्कत होती हैं, इस बारे कोई ध्यान नहीं दिया जाता है, न घर पर और न आफिस पर
@ 36:34 Journalist Manisha Pandey talks about the judgement passed on the female journalist, and the judge, or lack thereof, on male Journalist
This point has been brought out in a more deep and beautiful way by the directors of Final season of a TV series called Marvellous Mrs Miesel. There the father, of female protagonist Mrs Meisel, essentially hates good looking presidential nominee because, as per him, intellect requires a certain level of ugliness! But, then the times changed and Kennedy, became the president. The catharsis is amazing in that series.
And the breakage of that stereotype of a certain expectation of audience at a large.
Apka show bahot achha hai....
Lekin woman waha pe comment karti hai ya kisi bhi jagah to male immediately unhe troll karne lagte hai....
Sayad isi vajah se famale comment nahi karti
Good subject, should be only discussed by women only... With BURKHA one can see through burkha... Poor girl now on tenterhooks...
Women ❌
Tomboy ✅
War, politics are such a feminine topics,right !!
Next video please discuss women in boxing 🥊 & construction 🚧 field.
They are confusing feminity & male stereotypes..
Discussing cooking isn't shameful.
Discussing about makeup 💄 isn't shameful.
Discussing motherhood isn't shameful.
Womenhood & feminine related topics should be celebrated.🎉
Today's news media is producer of news, if the product has some value ( price) it must be packed in BEAUTIFUL carton ( cartoon).. That is what business... Shouting..
Women's awareness topic is okay but men's awareness topics are also needed that time because je doesn't know about their hormonal changes and mood swings etc. Because Women can support of their mother sister and all but men can't talk openly for their body openly so he thought the things from different platform some times it's good but more over it's wrong or negative aspect thought by the different platforms so
Must be think about my comment
Barkhaji is 💯 right, in regional vernacular press , same was the scene till 1998, I started same year when Barkhji covered war. I left mainstream and opted better option where other new challenges were there.
Please also raise the issue of false dowry cases,false rape cases,false Sexual harrasment cases,false domestic violence cases being filled by nonsense women against men.
Yes they are wrong
But you 1st see the problem woman suffer due to male
They are far more than the fake case done by some wrong women
(Just for your clarity I am a boy)
Issue of False allegations? That too from Barkha Dutt. No sir, not at all. That's not a "Feminist" thing. Only selective feminism is allowed, when it comes to Barkha Dutt
the host is clearly trying to promote female victim card narrative, but kudos to Barkha for taking the neutral stand
When discussing science, medicine, biology, and human behavior, all our research is rooted in human evolution. It explores how human behavior links with evolution.
However, when discussing men and women, especially men's attraction towards women, we often overlook the biological factors that naturally draw men towards women. Instead, we criticize such behaviors as wrong. We say men shouldn't do certain things or act in particular ways.
In doing so, we completely disregard how natural phenomena operate. When men encounter women in settings like offices, markets, or through media, certain behaviors may naturally occur due to these biological processes.
Interestingly, women who seek to constrain men's behavior according to their preferences overlook the fact that biology also influences their own actions. Biology isn't confined to labs or when teaching about humans from an evolutionary perspective.
This show is far away from reality… and also against the nature…worldwide and from time immemorial males been bread winner going out from hunting to protecting the tribe and the burden of continuity of human race always been on women. The creator has given different qualities to both such as hardcore war participation (baring some exceptions) from ancient time to medieval to modern time been on males bcoz of male body struture and on the other hand females can produce carry babies for 9 months (here no exception), which itself is such a difficult job… and then bringing up the kids. There so many things which separates male and female suitable for different types of work
This whole podcast was:
Too far away from reality.
Too much engrossed in fictional concepts.
Our brave soldiers got martyred in Kargil war due to irresponsible on ground reporting done by Barkha Dutt. She should be the last person on this universe to be asked about role of women in journalism and on the present state of Indian news media. Once a senior politician from Bihar said that you're a brave man not lady on her face😂😂😂😂😂
Never forget, never forgive
बहुत अच्छा ❤
o god atleast me yese asleel chize nhi dekhta, i watched your videos just for information
Not only in college there is curfew issue after specific time but now a days in India few of fortune 500 companies also won't allow women employees to travel by there own vehicle after 8pm or so. She has to use office transport. If by any chance she don't use office transport after 8pm they revoke her office login access and she has to take permission next day while login. I can understand everyone thinks about women safety but in a way they are kind of punishing the women
Its better to look at a tree,then watching chest thumping Barkha Dutt & The junk standard of Journalism 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Woman power
It's all a game of hormones:Sorry Isha Bhatia is so beautiful and her voice is so beautiful that if other women or girls sit in front of her then those women or girls are not able to attract attention
those women are not at all good face to talk on women in media . Isha program is wasted
What you have talked about is the effect which began 2 million years ago with the invention of the fire suggested by Richard wrangham, " the book titled Catching fire,,.
What's the name of that pretty dw anchor I am following her since 2015 she used to come every Saturday on manthan but i still don't know her name😅
When more women participate with financial works they realise everything like inflation, taxes, income, expense management etc. Then they have to watch news or current affairs etc.
Really woman not participating in any risk work? Really woman have right for reproductive and how much ? Make these topics on videos
Isha mam your science helth video help a lot in my life
I am a student and I am follow dW class 6 or class 7
The hostess seemed biased and her male bashing comments were very grating and annoying….Generalising all men is not a good idea…she would be screaming bloody murder if the tables were turned
भाटिया दत्त पांडे - "indian feminism" 👌🏼👌🏼
Mujhe ye program bhut achha lga
Well-done esha
I never thought that u call Barkha Dutt in ur show. That’s ridiculous . I fellow DW 4 u shows
Bring Acharya Prashant sir
3 LEGENDS in one screen ❤❤❤😊😊😊😊🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Unfortunately we women support building an institution, but still face mesogenic bent of mind
Today's you're looking so beautiful 😍 you're voice is already so sweet
सेहत तक वाली दिदी आज इतनी सिरियस सब्जेक्ट लेकर आइ.... लल्लन टाप जैसा लगा....
Barkha should not be the guest of such topics.... She is case study of this...
आपका वीडियो बहुत अच्छा लगता है आप ऐसे ही वीडियो बनाती रहिए😊
After listening to you, I feel that our education is also like this.
AWESOME PODCAST 💐
You are beautiful isha but in shari you are looking more gorgeous this time...
Thoroughly enjoyed it. Awakening , informative, and enlightening
Podcast is good but Burkha was present here😂😂😂😂😂😂
36:34 Meenakshi Joshi on India Tv was a pregnant moderator in 2022.
बिलकुल सही कहा रही है दोनों मैम, जमीनिस्तर पर महिलाओं की यही हाल है
This conversation is wow
Were are u now day's weating for ur show and u looking amazing as like always.
Isha ji Thank you so much for coming back and your opening statement kuch waqt pehle ek comedy show mai jub female journalist ai toh une bhi yahi kaha gaya is really nice. samjne walo k liye ishara hi kafi hai. Brain is Important then Beauty. Stay Blessed Isha!!!!
Rick may jaoo.contruction may try Karo. ship may.hard work Karo sirf leder banna hay makap kar k
Women invited on the show says a lot Bhatiya JI.😂😂😂😂🤡🤡🤡
Watched this video to listen to manisha . Her sense of humor and satire is amazing.
Definitely, please invite Acharya Prashant! Acharya Prashant is fiercely talking about true Women empowerment, the choices a girl or a woman is allowed to make in Indian patriarchal society and how she can be free from that web to know herself…
Please read a book authored on women “Stree” by Acharya Prashant..
He is a social reformer not a so-called baba but a highly intellectual, intelligent person - who talks based on facts! It will be an enlightening interview for your wise viewers!!
Please consider!
वह अवार्ड मिलना चाहिए 🫡 बुलाया भी तो किसको बरखा दत्त और मनीषा पांडे । एक नंबर एंटी इंडिया और बेहूदा पत्रकार 😂😂
Please invite Aacharya Prashant Sir
ओहो कई दिनों के बाद दिख रही हो ईशा .... बहुत सारे लोग लोग चिंतित थे कि क्या हो गया ... दिख नहीं रही... ठीक तो हो?
आपका पूरा वीडियो सेहत टोक देखे हैं बहुत ही अच्छा❤
Manisha is Rockstar
I m fan of the way she roasts Gullu
Nice session about gender equality ❤
Saare priviledged cozy jobs me hain wo. Jaise kibaapöog mahila card khel kar dw tak pahuch gayi.
What about SC ST etc male female in journalism
लालू यादव ने बरखा दत्त से कहा था तुम फीमेल नही male ho😂😂
I didnt like the host..It seems like barkha and manisha are tolerating her questions..They both look so uncomfortable.but they are graciously giving the answers
Your comment is seriously a breath of fresh air.
आप भी बहुत खूबसूरत हो, मे भी आप को देखने के लिए ही वीडियो देखता हूं ❤❤
My favourite All three news anchors❤
42 minutes bahot kam hai 3 din ka kar do 😂😂
10:44 Palki Sharma has created her own niche
Kapil Sharma show 😅
Anjana om kashyap 😊 anchor
I would like to watch on climate change video