Justin's version was the first version I heard and its still my favourite! He really expresses the emotions of someone trying to pour their heart out at a karaoke session
@@donaldneo4317 I saw that part. Although tiger is the writer ,how come Justin version is released earlier which was in 2007. And tiger ‘s version was in 2008. How to define the original singer ?
@@Cccccca2 I just searched, Tiger release the Album in 2007 Septemeber, Justin release in 2007 November and confirm Tiger wrote the song but not the lyrics.
Love 小肥 and 側田’s version!!! 側田’s voice is beautiful, and I love 小肥’s delivery. Both sound raw and real ❤️🩹 曹’s version is too performative and busy😅. Jj and Tiger are having fun and not really delivering the mood/meaning of the song so I can’t compare. BTW, 小肥’s 喜愛夢遊 album is my all time favorite. Wish more people would listen to it ❤
I agree what teacher said, 曹格 sound so planned but not well plan, kinda sound like a robot. (Could be the show ask him to do that, you know chinese singing competition show always ask singer to do so 😂) 小肥 didn't show off much but sound more natural. And JJ's part , they use multiple technique but in a good way, so sound more natural and artsy. About Justin, is it not a recent video? If so I can understand that, I guess he may perform better now? P.s. 小肥 is also my 2nd choice ~
There's a description that might be suitable to describe Gary's performance - too oily. It's like a food that is nice to eat but you can't have too much of it.
Agree with Rozette, all 4 strong performances, it s really interesting to see Rozette shuttering at last😂. I m surprised I prefer SiuFay’s over Justin in these videos.
Cantonese is just different. We have to ‘close’ every word before speaking another word. That’s the language! But of course we can put effort to make it sounds more fluent. And we treasure the meaning of the lyrics very much while singing Cantonese songs. This song is about a lonely man in the karaoke room, so fancy arrangement just makes it worse for audience to relate.
Justin has used a completely different singing style in recent years. (I think it is largely influenced by Leslie Cheung) He has done much better in the past. More touching, smooth, powerful, freedom and grooving: ruclips.net/video/R5rZ63kIaCU/видео.html He also doing well singing duet with Tiger Hu: ruclips.net/video/dAu8DMzBPRw/видео.html
JJ is my most favorite singer among the five singers here. However, I really don't like JJ version with Tiger Hu maybe because the song doesn't sound smooth enough after all the changes they made, there are actually quite few places I found weird when listening it the first time. And I prefer Justin's full version then Sifau's medley version more than Gary's one although I like Gary's voice on other songs. Btw, all five are good well-known singers no matter what. Thanks for the interesting video.
Whenever there is JJ, someone will come in to say he’s oily. Don’t understand what he meant, must be a person who has no music knowledge or maybe a hater. But there are many more who likes him .
They will take every opportunity to do this. Look at those traditional Chinese writing, you will know they are mostly from where. And in their eyes, only their own country's (not sure whether I can say it is) singers are the best. Small heart, cannot accept that there are better singers elsewhere. Brainwashed by their media, not a party. Sour grapes!
Same with Gary Cao, always people saying he's oily, but it's just that their musical tastes and technical ability tend to show flair, and this would be really good with some songs, but the issue with Chinese and Cantonese songs is that they are 99.9% emotional, so some people end up thinking that singers must all sing emotionally with less flair.
@@bluerose2345 yes , either TW or HK. Very biased. They are mostly amateurs. Don’t have much musical knowledge, only blind fans supporting their own kind.
Agree too! They simply refuse or cannot accept ‘other’ singers with true talents, leading their non thinkers to follow. But thankfully, there are many more intelligent and mature fans who know better…. Kudos to them!
I understand for a foreigner who does not speak Cantonese or Mandarin, you have to listen the song confine to "technique", but most if not all Chinese listen a song both technically and emotionally. Its o.k. you appreciate the skill but not buying an art.
First time was mentioned on your show!!😱
Thank you very much!!!!
Wow 小肥本尊現身！
@ 🥹
Keep it up Terrence, u have a nice voice ❤
@@amyg1073 Thank you very much!
Like it! 👍
我就比較喜歡側田唱這歌,因是唱出這歌的情緒。
老師始終聽不懂廣東話,只憑歌的節奏去欣賞,始終語言上是有盲點，側田是完全融入表達出這歌的意思,令人產生寂寞共鳴感覺👍🎉🥳
Justin's version was the first version I heard and its still my favourite! He really expresses the emotions of someone trying to pour their heart out at a karaoke session
@@CC-zc9uj Couldn’t agree more
Justin’s version always touches my heart
我都係喜歡側田的唱法，這時候的他聲音有些沙，而且不像以前那種好打動人心的感覺，但首歌最適合他唱，他唱出一個男人孤獨的味道，縱使技巧沒其他人好、純熟，但有力的唱法是很受落的，這個你們可能不是很明白～
男人的唏噓女人更不明白，何況佢致敬老歌。
小肥is an underrated singer in Hong Kong. Sometimes it’s not talking about just the technical skills shown, but the emotion delivered just enough.
香港人既共鳴點同老師絕對不同、絕對支持側田
+1
啱啊，改到亂七八糟
小肥好聽❤❤
No one sings better than Justin himself for this song
以下連結是側田2022年演唱會Live version，唱法比較「連貫」 ，應該比較符合老師口味～ 我自己也覺得這個version是我近年來最喜歡的！從容自在，收放自如。聲音很放鬆，聽起來很舒服～～～
ruclips.net/video/2fIEyNw_xSI/видео.htmlsi=PthlaK63XDzpkqFQ
不論以前或現在，還是側田最能把歌詞中那份孤寂感唱出，亦最能唱到我的心窩裏！香港人/愛廣東歌的人應該大多都很有共鳴的～ 小肥也唱得很好 兩個都喜歡！💗
以前都想講了，你地根本唔明白粵語口音對感情的影響
2025.02.15 JJ will hold a concert in Toronto! ! !
They really need to go!
I am coming🎉
太棒了🎉🎉
Any songs🎼covered by🤴🏻Jj❤, will became hit🥇songs❣🙏🏻✌🏻🥰👍🏻
如同老師說的，這幾位都是實力派歌手，最終就是看個人的口味喜歡哪種唱法和風格。
個人感受是：
- 小肥：聲音厚、很有男人味。技巧好、情感豐沛。風格是典型的粵語歌唱法。沒什麼缺點，但記憶點不深。
- 側田：聲音有磁性、鬆弛得來有力量。共鳴聽起來遼闊大器。技巧極好、情感豐沛。但有時咬字過硬。
- 曹格：技巧極好但過度運用，每一句都不放過。應該收斂時也還在炫技。導致聽起來油膩、疲勞。甚至有點老氣。
- JJ 和 胡彥斌：技巧極好但又恰到好處、收放自如。唱法聽起來流暢、風格比較現代。但可能不符合老一輩華人聽眾的胃口。
評論的幾位都是有目共睹的歌手，但是我小的時候聽到阿側田的原來的版本有表達出男人唱k的那個獨孤感之類的，也很肯定其他歌者唱得很優秀卻沒有給我這樣的感覺。
The original singer is Justin. And the culture of Cantonese is actually like what jay said, it's the pattern when the hk singer sing.
Already mention original singer & writer is Tiger, Justin bought the rights to release a cantonese version.
@@donaldneo4317 I saw that part. Although tiger is the writer ,how come Justin version is released earlier which was in 2007. And tiger ‘s version was in 2008. How to define the original singer ?
@@Cccccca2 I just searched, Tiger release the Album in 2007 Septemeber, Justin release in 2007 November and confirm Tiger wrote the song but not the lyrics.
老師是林俊傑的迷妹粉絲，鑒定完畢！
Tiger, JJ and Hins were the very first singers to bring me into pop musics back in 2000
Time flies...
側田❤
直接讓老師聽一下JUSTIN唱的英文歌吧，那就知道是語言問題還是個人歌唱技巧問題了。
其實應該搵一次講吓小肥，佢真係一個被低估嘅歌手
Justin is the best
Justin’s technique n singing skill is not up to standard. But his tone is quite good.
@ @ I agree that JJ's skill is better, but Justin's voice can touch me more.
I super agree all teacher CZ comments...🙏🏻👌🏻🥰👍🏻
有機會，可以欣賞下， 曹格 ， 寂寞先生、 very good song
Love 小肥 and 側田’s version!!! 側田’s voice is beautiful, and I love 小肥’s delivery. Both sound raw and real ❤️🩹
曹’s version is too performative and busy😅. Jj and Tiger are having fun and not really delivering the mood/meaning of the song so I can’t compare.
BTW, 小肥’s 喜愛夢遊 album is my all time favorite. Wish more people would listen to it ❤
More reviews on Justin please!! Love it!
Too many on him already, Please comment on someone else please!!!
I see JJ, I click
终于等到曹格了😂😂想听曹格唱的那首(我想有个家和寂寞先生)等等等等。。。。很多很多他的歌😂😂
@@Howard87 我想要有個家+1
還是最愛他的 愛到最後一秒也不委屈 😂
曹格確實需要來一集，好歹他也是流行歌金曲歌王
@@cydia6758 我都不明白博主为什么现在才放他的歌😂😂😂
视频里的唱法，明显不是那么討橘老师的喜爱，缺少了自然性的唱法，唱法的选择上也不是那么入老师的法眼，被认为设计度、刻意性和蓄力上的唱法有点多.
希望能看更多曹格！！！
JJ跟胡彥斌版本實在太強了
Preference is personal, but at high tone, Justin wins.
I agree what teacher said, 曹格 sound so planned but not well plan, kinda sound like a robot. (Could be the show ask him to do that, you know chinese singing competition show always ask singer to do so 😂) 小肥 didn't show off much but sound more natural. And JJ's part , they use multiple technique but in a good way, so sound more natural and artsy. About Justin, is it not a recent video? If so I can understand that, I guess he may perform better now?
P.s. 小肥 is also my 2nd choice ~
4th一定係曹格😂
JJ 背對背擁抱那句是他的歌 不是Jacky的吻別～
Jj❤ is producer for his all world🌎concerts...🙏🏻💪🏻🥰👍🏻
被酒耽誤的曹格⋯
想看看老师review 更多曹格！
深深在濛面歌手的真的愛你，老師一定驚艷
曹格在「歌手」節目裡的表現也很厲害
終於有曹格了！！！
JJ is still the best ❤
Yes!💜
Tiger is a good composer, he has a good ear for unusual melodies
那麼剛好排了側田和曹格，他們的新聞還歷歷在目。
《男人KTV》的原唱歌手應該是側田才對，這首歌收錄在他2007年發行的專輯《JTV》內。
最先原唱是胡彥斌的，也是他自己作的曲。側田是一聽就喜歡上，之後透過經理人找到胡，要了粤語版版權才變成jtv裡的主打的
應該看曹格唱自己的歌，才能展現自己的味道！
Justin is the original singer; Tiger is song writer.
There's a description that might be suitable to describe Gary's performance - too oily. It's like a food that is nice to eat but you can't have too much of it.
36:19 和 36:47 今天片尾好，讓我震撼。
36:19就超愛的，36:47前奏第一秒我就快噴淚了~
JJ fan here, the best singer for this song must be Tiger, only Tiger. Just on another level
Tiger’s voice is not very appealing
Gary Chaw is my favourite of Malaysia singer...
老師們忘了這個是蒙面歌王的節目嗎＠0＠？ 雖然曹格是很愛炫技的歌手，但這個節目是他刻意加強戲劇性演唱的原因之一
《Saving All My Love For U》Gary Chaw👍
Finally!you should heard Gary “My way”!
期待可以評論曹格
Finally Gary Cao is selected.... hope you guy's can listen to his other songs..
曹格很少唱假音的。記得以前看娛樂百份百，曹格就連「你把我灌醉」那句假音都能用真音再比原調高4個key唱上去😅 但在這五位當中，我覺得他反而是最沒有感情的那位，就是有點被技巧耽誤了
因為大陸節目你必須要show off😂
極端/理想的想法是技巧及唱商到巔峰時是可以駕馭任何歌，而現實中最基本/原點的概念是，每個人，不論唱功到哪個程度，也有他的最佳音域/歌路/sweet tone。 所以強如曹格，也不一定在某歌在某key表現出最好型態。
终于曹格了！ 应该听曹格自己的歌
我古啊Miss 成Q日想改既應該不是發口亦不是露字，
可能係刀斧痕太重。。 廣東話每一個字都要用陰力Suck 個字入支Mic度先會入mic
比其他癡埋一舊既語言人地咪 Suck 一野就支mic 收到就冇斷句
應該習慣左動圈Mic +廣東話就會有不停suck既Feel 俗稱“刀斧痕太重”
廣東話點解要字正腔圓清清楚楚
係因爲秦朝統一之後同‘’南越‘’現在的粵的一帶 方便溝通而設計出雅語
所以廣東是包涵了粵的地區方言的特質。
因爲方便‘’閩‘’‘’客‘’和‘’先秦‘’能夠同時聽得明白 所以粒粒分明
同時加上秦的樂器在廣東一帶產生了粵曲 ， 閩南話既歌仔戲，客家的鹹水歌等等民間音樂
才有了‘’雅俗共賞‘’
Agree with Rozette, all 4 strong performances, it s really interesting to see Rozette shuttering at last😂.
I m surprised I prefer SiuFay’s over Justin in these videos.
Please do more Jam! He's also been on tour and it would be great to see those reviews!
Please review Gary Chaw 曹格 song 背叛 😊
Absolutely agree what teacher said 35:10
喜欢看老师听歌时的反应^^ 有点好奇…老师听凤凰传奇的山河图的反应…
結果最勾我的音符是片尾預告的 直到世界的盡頭… 😂
Cantonese is just different. We have to ‘close’ every word before speaking another word. That’s the language! But of course we can put effort to make it sounds more fluent.
And we treasure the meaning of the lyrics very much while singing Cantonese songs. This song is about a lonely man in the karaoke room, so fancy arrangement just makes it worse for audience to relate.
为什么不让老师听听胡彦斌的红颜呢？那是他的巅峰
Here’s my guy Gary🎉
給老師聽楊宗緯.楊宗緯~~
胡彦斌可是能写出月光的那个男人！
建議老師評價一下楊宗緯合唱"若月亮沒來"這首歌
Justin has used a completely different singing style in recent years. (I think it is largely influenced by Leslie Cheung)
He has done much better in the past. More touching, smooth, powerful, freedom and grooving: ruclips.net/video/R5rZ63kIaCU/видео.html
He also doing well singing duet with Tiger Hu: ruclips.net/video/dAu8DMzBPRw/видео.html
Gary Cao❤❤❤🎉
I want Chinese subtitles.😅😅
JJ 唱到亂七八糟的，不懂。
側田，曹格，小肥可以！
好好唱一首歌很難嗎？
舉個例：生日會唱的happy birthday這歌，有人會把這歌來炫技嗎？在不適合的時間用不適合的技巧就變味了。
Maybe you could try reacting to Gary's Superwoman. The song that first made him famous.
Rozette 評過盧冠廷一生所愛嗎？
評過但評很差
Tigher是作曲原唱周深月光，那位所以不可能不喜欢
总于有曹格了。。。虽然我不是很喜欢这首歌。。。😅
應該會喜歡宋念宇
JJ is my most favorite singer among the five singers here. However, I really don't like JJ version with Tiger Hu maybe because the song doesn't sound smooth enough after all the changes they made, there are actually quite few places I found weird when listening it the first time. And I prefer Justin's full version then Sifau's medley version more than Gary's one although I like Gary's voice on other songs. Btw, all five are good well-known singers no matter what. Thanks for the interesting video.
Mine is,
1st- Jj❤ & Tiger
2nd- Terence
3rd- Gary Chaw
4ft- Justin...
我只是近來才看詰個頻道，感覺 Flo 很熟悉、及喜歡香港某些歌手及歌曲、原以為她是由香港移民到加拿大 !? 但聽今次這個影片中，聽到 Flo 重複唱某一段歌詞『沒有歌、怎 "敢" 說心事』，感覺 Flo 的粵語好像都不太地道，Flo 會否是台灣移民、或從小根本在加拿大成長華人 ... 所以說粵語還是有點口音 ? 🤔
她是新加坡人吧
侧田最后一个字的咬字怎么搞得像张学友和杨千嬅那种😂感觉怪怪的
Whenever there is JJ, someone will come in to say he’s oily. Don’t understand what he meant, must be a person who has no music knowledge or maybe a hater. But there are many more who likes him .
They will take every opportunity to do this. Look at those traditional Chinese writing, you will know they are mostly from where. And in their eyes, only their own country's (not sure whether I can say it is) singers are the best. Small heart, cannot accept that there are better singers elsewhere. Brainwashed by their media, not a party. Sour grapes!
Same with Gary Cao, always people saying he's oily, but it's just that their musical tastes and technical ability tend to show flair, and this would be really good with some songs, but the issue with Chinese and Cantonese songs is that they are 99.9% emotional, so some people end up thinking that singers must all sing emotionally with less flair.
@@bluerose2345 yes , either TW or HK. Very biased. They are mostly amateurs. Don’t have much musical knowledge, only blind fans supporting their own kind.
Totally agree!
Agree too! They simply refuse or cannot accept ‘other’ singers with true talents, leading their non thinkers to follow. But thankfully, there are many more intelligent and mature fans who know better…. Kudos to them!
Justin and terrence are best here
I understand for a foreigner who does not speak Cantonese or Mandarin, you have to listen the song confine to "technique", but most if not all Chinese listen a song both technically and emotionally. Its o.k. you appreciate the skill but not buying an art.
不知道什麼時候會輪到張韶涵～
許願張韶涵🙏🙏🙏
PLS REACT MARK MICHAEL GARCIA - (James Ingram Medley) 🇵🇭FILIPINO ARTIST 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
狂串樂基兒
还有，曹格在这里其实是被低估了…应该试试他巅峰时期的歌
原唱和作曲就是胡彦斌
曹格唱呢隻歌實在係加得太多味精，聽到反胃
如果拿蒙面的舞台来评，确实不准确的，因为歌手会为了不容易被认出，在演唱时会故意唱出其他风格。
衣服太高
Please react to Michael Pangilinan All or Nothing
希望老师评澳洲李安，逝去的爱ruclips.net/video/iM-aIDyTpCs/видео.htmlsi=vJjrnfiAOsxPn5DE
Cantonese is always better than mandarin
Comment on Yoyo Sham please.
要比老師聽下曹格D原唱歌先可以有點評，感覺今集有少少先入為主
再加上大陸嘅比賽係要show off 先得😂
@@JeffyMa I think so, the show must be asking singer to show off more for entertainment 😂