@ginaang8446 yup, no one forced her to listen. Just fade away...... Some people just want to take every opportunity to put down negative comments about those that they unlike. It's ridiculous and absurd how they live with such temperament.
I think Rozette should differentiate between a 'more technical' singer and a 'better singer'. JJ is a great technical singer, but he doesn't always draw you in emotionally, and a singer's ability to engage the listener emotionally? I'd say that constitutes what makes a singer 'good' or 'better'. I honestly think Rozette should listen with English subtitles. JJ often does things that are over-the-top and not suitable for the lyrical context of the songs, yet she praises him to high heavens for his 'artistic' and 'musical' choices. I think melody and techniques are only 1 half of the story. The other half is how effectively you are able to convey a message told through the lyrics. JJ falls short in that regard, IMO.
Really depends on what songs are you referring to, there are many covers in shows he did was re arrange to meet with the show's rule. Not set by him and so its not fair to say he does things that does not adhere to the feel of the lyrics. Just sayin she did say that he is a great technical singer before but thats the reason she loves him so much.
JJ always draws me in emotionally. I don't really pay attention to songs. But many songs after sung by JJ, makes me interested in that song because he really makes many songs sound so nice. People always talk about him being technical, technical doesn't equate to good, but JJ is really good. Many great vocal coaches actually were amazed by his voice.
Yes QQQ is here for Jay Chou. He is everywhere whenever there is JJ’s video. That’s why he got no subscribers. Shame on him . Go n tell your idol JC to polish his singing skill
持續留言~希望看到JJ的34屆金曲表演!!😍
+1
ruclips.net/video/u3ktw-zX-Vk/видео.htmlsi=EyaCGlY-N9tl80uG
我们这个碗敲了超久。哈哈。我相信！🎉🙏
看老师的点评，真实自然，不吹不黑，也让我们这些素人了解到些音乐知识，懂得好在哪里。不像国内某内某些歌唱比赛的评委外行装专业。
Jj has always been a polished singer. He has perfected his vocal skill as years go by. Now he is more versatile n a all rounded artist ❤
希望可以有更多周興哲😊
JJ小迷妹又出現了😂
林俊杰👍👍👍
王力宏這場是我的最愛！太藝術太有氛圍感了！🤩期待shallow!!
9:22 踏馬這是JJ在唱嘛!!? 哈哈哈 老師好可愛 翻譯也好可愛 XDD
JJ和王力宏的演唱会我都看过，而且都看过至少两次以上。现场来说的话，我觉得JJ就是很稳，确实很厉害，不然也不会叫行走的cd！然后王力宏的现场就是，这。。。这。。。这。。。真tm的牛逼。。。
我也聽過他們兩個的演唱會，王力宏雖然也很厲害，但是他的高音沒有厚實感，十分尖銳刺耳，令人招架不住，也許是免費音樂會的關係，現場觀眾一直都是來來去去。反觀林俊傑演唱會現場都是大熱門歌曲，而且他唱功了得，現場絕對比CD更好聽，不管演唱會門票多貴，聽完還想一聽再聽～
王在A4以上就不用任何的胸声技巧了，基本是纯头声，如果状态好的话会有很明亮的感觉，但是缺点是力量感不足。个人觉得王的技巧路线练到顶大概是Sam Smith，但是Sam的天生条件好太多了，基本是男高的条件唱男中的歌，王是男中的音域通过头声技巧去唱很多男高的歌。
看过两个感觉力宏演唱会超有创意、真的是一个视觉听觉盛宴、看得出真的很用心去做。JJ一听他声音我就沦陷、无话可说！
I’m just curious anyone coming here trying to inform 橘老師 JJ is coming to Toronto next year? Yes he is, he just made an announcement 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
老師可以多對比看看jj早期跟現在的唱法還有音色😂 RUclips 上就有很多他早期在各地的簽唱會影片
支持老師隨自己的自由意志評論喜歡哪個歌手，以及喜歡或不喜歡什麼樣的歌唱技巧或情感表達方式，都予以尊重，愛看又愛罵老師偏愛誰的玻璃心觀眾不要再來說三道四😊
For a while, I thought I was being pampered with a back-to-back upload of reaction to JJ. Ahaha. I got scammed 😂
建议老师去看一下陈永馨在中国好声音盲选唱的版本，我觉得这首歌最好的版本。
13:34接着我们看天气笑死我了
王力宏確實很厲害！JJ是我的最愛但這首歌我還是聽原唱最有感覺但不是這個改了很多唱法的版本！JJ也很好聽。他獨有的嗓音就是很吸引我！周興哲還好但他的歌很悶然後唱多了聽多了易感到厭倦
Wang Leehom is the only one who can wrestle with Jay Chou's wrist
想聽周興哲❤
JJ這首歌唱的太油了 情感很難被喚起共鳴。
终于看到一个说他唱歌油腻的留言😂找到共鸣的人，我实在听不下去他唱歌，比五花肉还油腻
@@QQQ-yf6zj Don’t force yourselves to listen then. Just slip away.
@ginaang8446 yup, no one forced her to listen. Just fade away...... Some people just want to take every opportunity to put down negative comments about those that they unlike. It's ridiculous and absurd how they live with such temperament.
@@QQQ-yf6zj他一直有这个问题，很容易油。有时候又不油。歌曲太多技巧可能就油腻了
@@peiyuw1022這首歌明明王力宏唱得更油，一堆莫名的轉音，轉得又很勉強，聽得很不舒服
反正王力宏在我眼里是最佳，没有可比性的最佳
希望可以讓老師聽看看 王力宏 FREE SHOW 同場表演的 shallow
Anyone notice there's no comment on Jeff Chang?
我也是想说 怎么没有评论张信哲😂
at this point, coach rozette is just a jj fan already😂🤣
Why this video is being uploaded again. What happened to yesterday’s video ?
Probably copyright violation in the first upload, and they had to take it down, censor the violation and re-upload. It has happened before.
Eric chou💕💕💕💕
What happened to yesterday’s upload? There were over 20k views.
重新上傳的嗎 ?
很期待shallow，是我聽過他唱最嘆為觀止的一次!
至於王，他早期誠懇表現自己才是最好的，現在或是稍早之前的他都有太多原音外加的東西。
ruclips.net/video/mrBg8PgaaLc/видео.htmlsi=5V6ZSuAPwzjlrSwU
這是非常早的一首，但聽起來可愛動人多了。
王力宏的轉音真的很鬼
JJ的唱法真的有麥克的影子 特地去查了 原來11年前JJ就花了18萬美金拍了一件麥克的演出皮衣 恩...確實是粉絲
希望可以請老師聽聽看張信哲的很多歌，推張信哲翻唱的雨天
+1
多点张信哲
完全忽视张信哲的存在😂
林俊傑的原音共鳴就已經很好，這是其他與他之間很大的差別。張信哲的溫柔依舊，也是特色。
Thanks, my mom walked in on me in exactly 6:00 .
Li Hong gliding a lot on his throat. anybody noticed that?
原唱王力宏唱的最好 詞曲也是他自己創作 超棒音樂人
老实说，我倒觉得是王力宏唱得比较好。
《學友在唱歌》🤣🤣
好久沒看到點評紫棋了
React to more Eric Chou! ❤
想看評測五月天阿信
我听见力宏的歌声，皮毛是站起来的，很特别的感受，很好听👍🏻
這是王自己作品、要怎轉音是他說的算。
想請問JJ的那兩段是什麼節目！
Can't believe..u didn't try to make a video on Aska Yang. Missed a good singer
何時可以點評下一戰歌手，持修👍👍
求評鄭元暢-忠於原味！！
Angela zhang please😢
我不确定是否有过度修音，推荐「飘向北方」。可作对比的有文慧如版；GEM+明志版；力宏+那吾克热版（展现超强快嘴Rap）。
I like 周興哲 cover ...
没人超越原唱。我觉得
4:13 學友…？
pls react on Rosie live performance ❤❤❤❤ we need the real comments 🥹
想睇評 charice pempangco
感觉这个老师喜欢辨别技巧 对于我们完美声线的阿哲就no comment了 连我看的另一个业余乐评都看出来阿哲明显把表现的机会递给Eric 这个老师完全没听出来 或者因为她完全不认识 所以可能以为阿哲就是一个普通的唱和声的吧😅
她不是有說很棒嗎？而且第一組有開修音啊 很難評斷
@ 她對阿哲完全一句也沒說 只說了eric和整首歌 修不修音我聽不出來
@@denimch 張信哲幾乎都在和聲 至於修音 我認為肯定有修的 如果這是中國的節目
@@bear6536 所以我说的没问题吧？
只要JJ的部分 老师就变得不理性。这首歌JJ听感就是上气不接下气，便秘的很。
我不同意，技術分析才是理性的，但是黑粉的忌妒心才是不理性的
JJ唱的時候 那個背景就可以看出來了
是很久以前的台灣綜藝節目 所以這是現場直接唱的版本 沒有修音 所以會有喘氣聲 這才是正常的現場會有的瑕疵
第一組有修音 喘氣聲直接被修掉了
聲音乾淨到不合理
身為歌手的老師當然會更喜歡無修音現場
幫第一組修音根本沒有意義 周興哲的聲音本來就很乾淨 張信哲的聲音也很優美
真是多此一舉
这是原唱啊，所以为什么抓耳朵
@@xiz-n5b 還是覺得原唱的很靈活生動多了。
老師個人對她的偶像偏好。個人覺得林的聲音含糊不清唱歌喉嚨緊緊的。
沒人強迫你看耶😂
@ 當然！就好比沒人強迫你看我的留言🤣
@ no!當然，我也沒要你看我們的回覆
@ 你不用看我我回覆別人啊
陈永鑫唱的最好
I think Rozette should differentiate between a 'more technical' singer and a 'better singer'. JJ is a great technical singer, but he doesn't always draw you in emotionally, and a singer's ability to engage the listener emotionally? I'd say that constitutes what makes a singer 'good' or 'better'. I honestly think Rozette should listen with English subtitles. JJ often does things that are over-the-top and not suitable for the lyrical context of the songs, yet she praises him to high heavens for his 'artistic' and 'musical' choices. I think melody and techniques are only 1 half of the story. The other half is how effectively you are able to convey a message told through the lyrics. JJ falls short in that regard, IMO.
Really depends on what songs are you referring to, there are many covers in shows he did was re arrange to meet with the show's rule. Not set by him and so its not fair to say he does things that does not adhere to the feel of the lyrics.
Just sayin she did say that he is a great technical singer before but thats the reason she loves him so much.
@@FT-od4xv +1
I think the reason she didnt find it over-the-top is that she didnt understand the language.😅 But I really like her comments.
JJ always draws me in emotionally. I don't really pay attention to songs. But many songs after sung by JJ, makes me interested in that song because he really makes many songs sound so nice.
People always talk about him being technical, technical doesn't equate to good, but JJ is really good. Many great vocal coaches actually were amazed by his voice.
Technical singer is always superior 😊
林俊杰唱任何歌都油腻，大油王
You’re like a broken record. Why keep listening if you don’t like it? Ask yourself.
@@QQQ-yf6zj 不喜欢可以跳过不听，何必辛苦自己！ 我看你就是故意找话来贬低他的，每次都这样，活得很辛苦！我倒很想知道你的偶像唱得有多好。是不是那位声音退步了的天王啊？
Yes QQQ is here for Jay Chou. He is everywhere whenever there is JJ’s video. That’s why he got no subscribers. Shame on him . Go n tell your idol JC to polish his singing skill
所以你的偶像唱歌，又乾又澀，聲音不圓潤，這才是你的音樂審美的水平，真的很QQ
没關係，你只是繼續幫JJ推流量而已。黑粉也是有用的 😂
單說著四個表演王力宏還是比林俊傑好聽
我倒是觉得JJ唱得最有感情好听，其次周興哲也很好。
林俊杰是油王
@@QQQ-yf6zj 什么是油？ 凡是唱得好听，或是你们不喜欢的就是油吗？ 我相信老师的评论，你要说什么也改变不了欣赏他的人。各自有喜欢的歌手，何必要贬低别人？
@@bluerose2345 Fully agree.
其他人都是電視播出一定有修音的、而福利秀比較原音再說背景音樂還抽掉、這對實力不好的歌手必漏氣、但王卻很穩實力不在話下。
中文就是這種唱法 什麼鄉村唱法無言 不要用你的母語唱法來限制任何語言
只有王沒背景音樂、而前三個有音樂加分評論不公平
他們自己聽的版本是都是有伴奏的原始版本，只有在發影片的時候為了規避版權問題，會對部分有危險的地方進行背景音樂消音
@@LukeAli-r6o我知道！但對看這影片的觀眾誤導，但真正的唱歌不怕抽音樂
意思是有些人沒看原本的演出
助手每次講的都是錯的，好煩