This was the first time the Soviet Anthem was played as the Russian anthem. And the last time Patriotic Song was played as anthem of Russia, this is a pretty sad day for me... But of course for the history's sake. This video is here with a 20 years anniversary!
Patriotic song was not so powerful and didn`t represent the power of russian state. But reality is also, that russian state had no power in the years after collapse of USSR, the whole structures of statehood were demolished. Because Russia was never a democracy and it was clear that everything will go wrong with decision to destroy a soviet system and replace it with a bad replica of western democracy. Now Russia is a stabilized totalitarian state again and soviet anthem goes really well with this direction.
Нет, Ельцину, как минимум, надо было ещё год сидеть. Досиживать свой президентский срок. За год многое могло произойти и случится. Он сглупил. И подложил большую свинью России и делу своей жизни.
2:26: Славься, славься, родина-Россия! Сквозь века и грозы ты прошла И сияет солнце над тобою И судьба твоя светла. Над старинным московским Кремлём Вьётся знамя с двуглавым орлом И звучат священные слова: Славься, Русь - Отчизна моя!
I understand how some people prefer the patriotic song, its truly a beautiful song, no complaints at all....But in all seriousness I prefer the original Soviet Era Tune because it establishes a sense of continuity between the USSR and the RF despite the fact that they are two different countries. The fact that it preserves Soviet tradition in the new modern era is truly beautiful to me. I can imagine that the Russians who lived through the hard 90s must've been happy and nostalgic to see their historic anthem making a strong comeback!
Does it preserve the Soviet tradition, or keep (some of) the people entrapped in it? The anthem should most ideally be Grechaninov’s Anthem of Free Russia, or even, indeed, The Patriotic Song.
@@joonaa2751 lots of Russians identify with the Soviet Union and take great pride in it's achievements to this day, I know this from living in Russia for a while so your western analysis is incorrect. Furthermore a whopping 75% of Russians regret the fall of the USSR, you can lookup that statistic
@@losabias4723 not sure that you're in a position to be making those statements. like any average person from the west you're repeating what western media outlets have been telling you your whole life, or you may have heard a defector saying that the USSR was hell and that they hate communism, those people represent a very small percentage of public opinion and aren't trustworthy sources .plenty of the other republics suffered greatly after the fall of the USSR and still aren't as economically robust as they once were, a strong chunk of the public opinion in those republics also suggests that living standards were better under communism , but you wouldn't know that because western mainstream media has been telling you the opposite narrative your whole life.
@@losabias4723 Speak for yourself, please. My mother is an ethnic Russian from Ukraine, she emigrated her to Slovenia (back then, it was still Yugoslavia) in the late 1970's, we've visited modern Ukraine multiple times, and she says the place was better under the USSR. This myth that everyone in every ex-USSR country other than Russia loathes Russia is just that - a Western myth. Also, there's plenty of people in the West right now who loathe NATO and the EU.
This is not the Duma. State Duma is the lower house of Parliament. Here - Federation Council (upper house of parliament). But yes - State Duma also voted for new/old anthem. 379 yes, 51 against. Those you call democrats have occupied a marginal position since 1993, in Duma has always been dominated by Communist Party or Liberal Democrats (actually imperialists).
Democracy is an illusion for fools, elected politicians are puppets of unelected elites and oligarchy and never make decisions against will of elites and for people. Especially in the West. At least in Russia people know Putin is really in charge and not a puppet, since his decision to invade Ukraine was definitely against will of elites who in 2022 lost everything in the West where they kept their money, business, properties and families
@douglasmacarthur8482 US will release its sanctions on Russia at some point whether it becomes democracy or not. And they will prob release some sanctions faster if Russia becomes a true democracy since they will be less likely to start another war. Your opinion could have been true if you were talking about China but prob not on Russia. Russia is no longer a superpower. It's just a strong nation with fascist dictatorship.
@@leonhardhoffman9881 Ah with democracy you surely mean transgenderism and LGBTQP+ as well as minorities rioting in the streets. And of course bans on gas stoves, incandescent light bulbs and conventional cars plus climate taxes on beef.
When im hear this Russian Federation Anthem now is like going back to 1944 in Soviet times during WW2 . That Anthem winned the Biggest War in Human History . And prefer the 1944 version over the 1977 , i like both but when we think Ww2 1944 is the Best , because it makes sense when we play Ww2 games or something like that .
Democracy never existed except small Greek city states in the first place. Today it's just an illusion for fools, while real power belongs to unelected oligarchic elites who fund and control all puppet politicians and manipulate public opinions through their media. You're naive if you don't see that
Very true man, mayby it will be the anthem again sometime? But I'm thankful for the 10 years it got. And you could always go back and listen and read about the time period 1990-2000. Wich is pretty fun. Allthough the year 1990 is'nt really much and 1999 and 2000 are pretty sad years.
The music of the Patriotic Song is now the national anthem of my fictional Minecraft nation of Novekia! 2:28 O-VOMANI THUN PEPOLA(Here Come The People)
@@Maréchal_John_Gaming, maybe because for Russians the old anthem was associated with a drunkard president and an era of lawlessness? (I’m speaking in general, I myself have a neutral attitude towards the Yeltsin era)
Does the Federation Council meet in the Gosduma building off Manezh Square or is this a nearby building or in the Mossovet? It almost looks like The Duma Hall but believe this looks smaller. Anyone? Thank you.
The old anthem reminds me of Catherine the Great, Faberge eggs and Russia on the right side of history. The USSR anthem reminds me of Stalinism, the molotov ribbentrop pact with the Nazis, and sadness.
The temporary non-aggression pact between the Soviet Union and Germany came after numerous efforts by the Soviets to deal a defense agreement with Britain and France. Therefore, being under the continuous threat of the expanding Nazi army and in order to prepare itself for an extensive war, the Soviet state forced to sign the non-aggression pact with Berlin. What bourgeois historians and apologists of Imperialism call an “alliance between Hitler and Stalin” was in fact a necessary diplomatic maneuver by the Soviet Union in order to gain time and prepare effectively for a full-scale war. Even bourgeois historians admit that the Soviet policy was complete realistic, given the then circumstances and the danger of a German attack (F.Dulles, The road to Tehran, New York, 1944, p.203-207).
I prefer Bozhe tzarya krani and Patriotic song than the USSR and modern federation anthems. Current anthem's music is good for a patriotic song. If they added lyrics into the 1990 - 2000 anthem it would be the Russian anthem until now.
@@Desertfox18 , без слов оно даже лучше. Как испанский "Гренадерский марш", например. Есть некие достоинство и стать в отсутствии открывания рта, и в выслушивании национальной мелодии с закрытым, а не открытым ртом 😌 "Патриотическая песнь" М.И.Глинки воплощает русский национальный мотив, и хороша именно как мелодия ☝️ Часто слова, искуственно приделанные, приляпанные к мелодии, когда они не рождаются вместе с мелодией, как цельное произведение, как цельная песня, а потом искуственно приляпывается - только портят, опошляют, вульгаризируют мелодию ☝️ 😌 Есть русские гимны со словами - "Коль славен", например. И национальная мелодия - мелодия Глинки. Без слов. Отсутствие слов - это не изъян, а достоинство, "изюминка", особенность её, не баг, а фича ☝️😌
![Boris Yeltsin 1st Inauguration 10 July 1991 Slav'sya [Remastered]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vqNzx7hPt3w/mqdefault.jpg)
![Boris Yeltsin 1st Inauguration 10 July 1991 Slav'sya [Remastered]](/img/tr.png)
This was the first time the Soviet Anthem was played as the Russian anthem. And the last time Patriotic Song was played as anthem of Russia, this is a pretty sad day for me... But of course for the history's sake. This video is here with a 20 years anniversary!
Ну произведение Глинки патриотическая песнь действительно очень здоровская и трогает до глубины души, но в качестве гимна не очень.
@@leonidkozlov1842 Думаю, да, это было в 1991 году как гимн
2000
They brang it back
Patriotic song was not so powerful and didn`t represent the power of russian state. But reality is also, that russian state had no power in the years after collapse of USSR, the whole structures of statehood were demolished. Because Russia was never a democracy and it was clear that everything will go wrong with decision to destroy a soviet system and replace it with a bad replica of western democracy. Now Russia is a stabilized totalitarian state again and soviet anthem goes really well with this direction.
0:52 *sad Yeltsin noises
*2000 Yeltsin in retirement 😖😥
@@BarberJ95 It was a blessing
@@herushiii true, Yeltsin sucked ngl
@@magnadolosfs2707 Your 100% correct
Нет, Ельцину, как минимум, надо было ещё год сидеть. Досиживать свой президентский срок. За год многое могло произойти и случится. Он сглупил. И подложил большую свинью России и делу своей жизни.
Yeltsin: *oh* *no!*
Stalin: *oh* *yes!*
Lenin: oh yes,I love it!
Putin:Oh yeah!
@@redvietnam6541 but..Lenin had never heard this song.
@@sashazhang6239 yeah
He DOES ever heard this song, it's either a Bolshevik anthem
@@thechessindonesia16 the Hymn of the Bolshevik Party was written in 1938. Lenin(sadly) died in 1924.
Yeltsin thought it was finally gone for good, but it came back.
That's exactly what happened man :/
@@RSFSR-Anthems lol
@@herushiii For me personally as you may know. This was a pretty sad day...
@@RSFSR-Anthems the anthem of the russian federation with the soviet melody restored the pride of the Russians
yeltsin: why do i hear boss music?
The West must've been pretty pissed the Soviet melody came back, but it's the prettiest one it makes me feel patriotic even tho I'm not Russian.
2:26:
Славься, славься, родина-Россия!
Сквозь века и грозы ты прошла
И сияет солнце над тобою
И судьба твоя светла.
Над старинным московским Кремлём
Вьётся знамя с двуглавым орлом
И звучат священные слова:
Славься, Русь - Отчизна моя!
Россия - священная наша держава,
Россия - любимая наша страна.
Могучая воля, великая слава -
Твоё достоянье на все времена!
Славься, Отечество наше свободное,
Братских народов союз вековой,
Предками данная мудрость народная!
Славься, страна! Мы гордимся тобой!
Красненько...
Russian (Soviet) Anthem 0:52
Patriotic Anthem 1990-2000 2:26
facts : this version of "new" russian anthem is still used in Federation Council
Yay.. Soviet isn't dead.. it just sleeping..
I understand how some people prefer the patriotic song, its truly a beautiful song, no complaints at all....But in all seriousness I prefer the original Soviet Era Tune because it establishes a sense of continuity between the USSR and the RF despite the fact that they are two different countries. The fact that it preserves Soviet tradition in the new modern era is truly beautiful to me. I can imagine that the Russians who lived through the hard 90s must've been happy and nostalgic to see their historic anthem making a strong comeback!
Does it preserve the Soviet tradition, or keep (some of) the people entrapped in it?
The anthem should most ideally be Grechaninov’s Anthem of Free Russia, or even, indeed, The Patriotic Song.
@@joonaa2751 lots of Russians identify with the Soviet Union and take great pride in it's achievements to this day, I know this from living in Russia for a while so your western analysis is incorrect. Furthermore a whopping 75% of Russians regret the fall of the USSR, you can lookup that statistic
@@tunuitahitianfire9875 yeah, Russia, not the other countries forced to "join" that loathe the USSR
@@losabias4723 not sure that you're in a position to be making those statements. like any average person from the west you're repeating what western media outlets have been telling you your whole life, or you may have heard a defector saying that the USSR was hell and that they hate communism, those people represent a very small percentage of public opinion and aren't trustworthy sources .plenty of the other republics suffered greatly after the fall of the USSR and still aren't as economically robust as they once were, a strong chunk of the public opinion in those republics also suggests that living standards were better under communism , but you wouldn't know that because western mainstream media has been telling you the opposite narrative your whole life.
@@losabias4723 Speak for yourself, please. My mother is an ethnic Russian from Ukraine, she emigrated her to Slovenia (back then, it was still Yugoslavia) in the late 1970's, we've visited modern Ukraine multiple times, and she says the place was better under the USSR. This myth that everyone in every ex-USSR country other than Russia loathes Russia is just that - a Western myth.
Also, there's plenty of people in the West right now who loathe NATO and the EU.
Here's a thought - what was going through the minds of those who had voted "no" to changing the anthem?
I would have been pretty disappointed, it wasen't alot of them who voted no but that was cool of them
The russian antham has the best entrance
Incredibly sad.
Agreed Jon, thanks for your oppinion. A pretty sad day for me also
The duma voted on it? I never knew that. Also wow back when the duma seemed to actually be a democratic body.
It was rigged
This is not the Duma. State Duma is the lower house of Parliament. Here - Federation Council (upper house of parliament). But yes - State Duma also voted for new/old anthem. 379 yes, 51 against. Those you call democrats have occupied a marginal position since 1993, in Duma has always been dominated by Communist Party or Liberal Democrats (actually imperialists).
The Russian Assembly ceased to be a democratic body ever since Yeltsin deployed the tank in 1995 or so, imho.
Maybe because ussr anthem was russian for years
Democracy is an illusion for fools, elected politicians are puppets of unelected elites and oligarchy and never make decisions against will of elites and for people. Especially in the West. At least in Russia people know Putin is really in charge and not a puppet, since his decision to invade Ukraine was definitely against will of elites who in 2022 lost everything in the West where they kept their money, business, properties and families
2:26 goodbye to the half hearted attempt at democracy in Russia. 🇷🇺
USA will not release sanctions even when Russia becomes a real democracy
That's because the Yeltsin era has came to an end.
0:51
Welcome Home Soviet Union
@@douglasmacarthur8482sanctions wont work
@douglasmacarthur8482 US will release its sanctions on Russia at some point whether it becomes democracy or not.
And they will prob release some sanctions faster if Russia becomes a true democracy since they will be less likely to start another war.
Your opinion could have been true if you were talking about China but prob not on Russia.
Russia is no longer a superpower.
It's just a strong nation with fascist dictatorship.
That was for history's sake
0:55:
Россия - священная наша держава,
Россия - любимая наша страна.
Могучая воля, великая слава -
Твоё достоянье на все времена!
Славься, Отечество наше свободное,
Братских народов союз вековой,
Предками данная мудрость народная!
Славься, страна! Мы гордимся тобой!
When wonderful time will come, soviet anthem will be replaced to real democratic and amazing anthem again!
200
@@leonhardhoffman9881 Ah with democracy you surely mean transgenderism and LGBTQP+ as well as minorities rioting in the streets. And of course bans on gas stoves, incandescent light bulbs and conventional cars plus climate taxes on beef.
No other national anthem can stir the soul like the one that Russian people treasure.
Soviet Russia still alive!!
Ewww communism. Die!
Kolichestvennoye Golosovanie Otkrytoe.
When im hear this Russian Federation Anthem now is like going back to 1944 in Soviet times during WW2 . That Anthem winned the Biggest War in Human History . And prefer the 1944 version over the 1977 , i like both but when we think Ww2 1944 is the Best , because it makes sense when we play Ww2 games or something like that .
0:52 Soyuz nerushimy
respublik svobodnykh
Splotila naveki velikaya Rus'.
@@Mnrr6131 Da zdravstvuet sozdanniy voley narodnoy
Velikiy Moguchiy SOVETSKIY SOYUZ!!!!
STOP SAD MEN
El himno soviético y la versión actual le dan mil vueltas a la mediocre marcha patriótica de la deleznable época de Yeltsin.
Wait, what happened here? Is the “old ussr anthem” played here as the new anthem or the patriotic song i got lost
@@drogobartholy5532 well the patriotic song is also soviet
Brasil🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
The old ussr anthem was readopted as the anthem for Russia in the year 2000. The tune remained the same but lyrics changed.
Old Soviet anthem got re adopted, with different lyrics
At the end they played the Patriotic Song as a protocol when closing a meeting session. That’s the last one too.
I actually like the Patriotic song better
Thanks for saying that, it really warns my heart that some people still thinks that :)))
Both are beautiful as a matter of fact. The old one sounds monarchical, while the current one gives u the sense of power.
but soviet anthem is the best
Nah, USSR tune will always be the best. Much better than Yelstsin gay anthem
@@patricklewis2745 of course there's nothing more masculine than starving your people and forcing them to not leave hahahah
“The day democracy died in Russia”
Please highlight this comment for a reason
Sure dude you have a point there ;)
@@RSFSR-Anthems i think you might need to change now ;P
Already happened back in 1993
Democracy never existed except small Greek city states in the first place.
Today it's just an illusion for fools, while real power belongs to unelected oligarchic elites who fund and control all puppet politicians and manipulate public opinions through their media.
You're naive if you don't see that
А ЛЮБЛЮ РОССИИ 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺❤❤❤
The best and the worst anthems of the world in the same session
yes Russian Anthem is TRASH, Soviet Anthem is THE BEST
I think this day is sad for you
Very true man, mayby it will be the anthem again sometime? But I'm thankful for the 10 years it got. And you could always go back and listen and read about the time period 1990-2000. Wich is pretty fun. Allthough the year 1990 is'nt really much and 1999 and 2000 are pretty sad years.
@@RSFSR-Anthems You live in Russia now ?
That's true for many Russians
@@anhlethe7795 Not quite now
@@user-wo8lv8xc1f What is?
El día en que Ru514 se fue al abismo. Saludos desde Chile.
The music of the Patriotic Song is now the national anthem of my fictional Minecraft nation of Novekia!
2:28 O-VOMANI THUN PEPOLA(Here Come The People)
I say make God save the Tzar with new lyrics the anthem and make Alexandrov's song the "Victory day" anthem!
Is it the referendum to change the anthem?
Yes this was it, they voted about the anthem at Duma also (same day) everything changed on December 20, 2000.
@@RSFSR-Anthems why did they change it?
@@Maréchal_John_Gaming, maybe because for Russians the old anthem was associated with a drunkard president and an era of lawlessness? (I’m speaking in general, I myself have a neutral attitude towards the Yeltsin era)
Does the Federation Council meet in the Gosduma building off Manezh Square or is this a nearby building or in the Mossovet? It almost looks like The Duma Hall but believe this looks smaller. Anyone? Thank you.
It's another building on another street
@@lirikperviy9837 ok. Thank you.
Славься Русь великая страна
Славься Русь свободна и сильна
We'll be back some day, sooner or later
Soviet remnants won't last forever
Who care some Korean hate Soviet.
I hope ussr returns one day as a democratic country
No ussr will be returned as a communist country. Ok
I hope we will see that day in the future
Communism Die!!
Типут тебе на язык 🤪
СССР не стало - Богу нашему слава!
It was democratic
It's not a sad day, it's a happy day!
There, there!
It's not a happy day, it's a sad day..
The slowly return to the USSR? what comes next? Ukraine gets annexed by Russia or.... Oh shit!
Venäjälle
SOVIET Venäjälle
Can I know what the speaker is speaking
Только патриотическая песня
The old one is better.
Can you add English subtitles?
러시아 여러분 욕해서 죄송합니다
I’m mad at all of russia
Hidup Soviet
Hidup💪💪💪💪👍👍👍
✊✊✊✊🏳🌈
The old anthem reminds me of Catherine the Great, Faberge eggs and Russia on the right side of history. The USSR anthem reminds me of Stalinism, the molotov ribbentrop pact with the Nazis, and sadness.
The Soviet anthem represents power, the old anthem is fearless.
The temporary non-aggression pact between the Soviet Union and Germany came after numerous efforts by the Soviets to deal a defense agreement with Britain and France.
Therefore, being under the continuous threat of the expanding Nazi army and in order to prepare itself for an extensive war, the Soviet state forced to sign the non-aggression pact with Berlin.
What bourgeois historians and apologists of Imperialism call an “alliance between Hitler and Stalin” was in fact a necessary diplomatic maneuver by the Soviet Union in order to gain time and prepare effectively for a full-scale war.
Even bourgeois historians admit that the Soviet policy was complete realistic, given the then circumstances and the danger of a German attack
(F.Dulles, The road to Tehran, New York, 1944, p.203-207).
lol right side of history ok
The saddest day in our modern history
So true, man
I prefer Bozhe tzarya krani and Patriotic song than the USSR and modern federation anthems.
Current anthem's music is good for a patriotic song.
If they added lyrics into the 1990 - 2000 anthem it would be the Russian anthem until now.
kenapa sedih
Happiest* You're not Russian
@@Desertfox18 , без слов оно даже лучше. Как испанский "Гренадерский марш", например.
Есть некие достоинство и стать в отсутствии открывания рта, и в выслушивании национальной мелодии с закрытым, а не открытым ртом 😌
"Патриотическая песнь" М.И.Глинки воплощает русский национальный мотив, и хороша именно как мелодия ☝️ Часто слова, искуственно приделанные, приляпанные к мелодии, когда они не рождаются вместе с мелодией, как цельное произведение, как цельная песня, а потом искуственно приляпывается - только портят, опошляют, вульгаризируют мелодию ☝️ 😌 Есть русские гимны со словами - "Коль славен", например. И национальная мелодия - мелодия Глинки. Без слов. Отсутствие слов - это не изъян, а достоинство, "изюминка", особенность её, не баг, а фича ☝️😌
Replaced the beautiful anthem of Russia with Soviet garbage
The Soviet Anthem represents power and the Russian Anthem will never come close to that anthem!
No
your're nuts
0:52 Autocracy takes over Russia 🇷🇺
2000 - Present
2:26 Democracy is still alive
1991 - Present
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦
🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦
🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
경제보복하지마세요