Learn Historical "Big Knives" pt 1: Intro
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 июл 2024
- Want to train with us from anywhere in the world? Check out our online program! - www.bloodandiron.ca/online
Check out our Patreon if you'd like to support our work :) - / bloodandironhema
Mountain Walk by Alexander Nakarada
Link: filmmusic.io/song/6382-mounta...
License: filmmusic.io/standard-license
OMG BIG KNIVES! A VIDEO I DIDN'T KNOW I NEEDED TODAY BUT AM SUPER EXCITED TO SEE!
Medieval Germans be like : "That's not a knife , *THIS IS A KNIFE."*
LET ME SHOW YOU ITS FEATURES!
Pulls out kriegsmesser
@@jonburgart8649 no no, it's the "big knife" video, so it's the Grosse Messer.
"Das ist kein Messer,
*DIES IST EIN MESSER* "
Messer
I've been curious about knife fighting for a while now. Great to see this type of content on the channel.
Awesome. And very useful in today's world....for the use of recreational purposes only. Thank you
I was legit thinking this video was going to be on messers.
Messer means knife, in some german dialects a small knife is called Kniep or Kneip ( our languages are related).
You guys should get on Lbry or Bitchute. Make sure you have back ups for the next time RUclips purges weapons or historical or martial arts channels.
Wait when did RUclips purge weapon videos????
yay, i just read dune and i was pretty intrested in knife combat, so this came at the perfect time.
AWESOME JOB!
What about navaja fighting and esgrima criolla? IIRC, there was a translation of Manual del Baratero in english. Not very accurate one, but it was there.
I'm only on my 2nd online live training session w/ Lee & Steve and I feel very very priviledged. Legit. I feel I'm in expert "hands". Haha. I'm with my group, Forge Pioneer in the Philippines. Yay.
This was a cool as hell intro.😎🤠
“This is for academic and sport purposes only” *cues heavy metal music*
Sweet!
It'd be interesting to see the HEMA take on defending the grab and stab we see in many modern knife attacks.
There's afew responses that vary in fiores flower of battle, based on where you were grabbed
@@TaoistSwordsman I was about to mention Fiore, he does have some good ones.
I love this, I'd love to learn to fight with a Scottish Dirk.
how would you stop someone who is forward knife presenting from just slashing the hell out of your "shield" arm? I understand that in a knife fight you are going to get cut, but that just seems like its giving them your arm. Excited to see the next few parts to see if there's an answer.
I can answer that right now. The concept here is that the outer arm or shield arm contains mainly flesh and bone. all life threatening bits of the arm are located on the inner arm in line with the palm. My defending action isn't necessarily to allow my shield arm to get mangled but rather that if i am going to get cut somewhere it is preferable to be cut there rather then being cut somewhere more vital. That being said I am also not going to simply block my opponents slashes with the flesh of my arm but rather attempt to control or defend the more fvital points with the purpose of exploiting a vital point of my attacker. The purpose is to mitigate life threatening injuries while dispatching my opponent. Many of the plays in Meyer's treatise involve controlling my opponents weapon before exposing a vital point with which i can take advantage of them. There is more detail to this from a modern standpoint as well but i will not get into detail about this because it does involve more then one instance with which someone does lose their life. at any rate. please contact us if you are interested in further conversation. cheers
Do you guys still teach Mac’s Bowie knife stuff? I bought both his books after seeing your review. Mac’s research seems to indicate a combination of Italian rapier sources and Meyer’s dussak material when thinking about the use of big blades. What do you think?
knife fighting seems a lot riskier than sword fighting. even when it's done successfully, it looks way too close for comfort.
Nobody is going to comment about how many utility blades from the 18th century look... a lot like a big kitchen knife of today?
I want to ask about something somehow historical, I'm just not sure it is right channel ... When arming a poorman in a 14 century better choose pole weapons (if yes, then spears, gizarms, polaxes ore chalabards, or what other) or cheap 1h weapon + shield (if yes then, falcions, cavalarymans picks, short swords, maybe some bland weapon or what?)
It's not big if it fits under the coat 3:)
Hey there Raskolnikov
As a Texan who regularly wears a 9.75” Bowie (for work and political purposes) I’ve looked long and hard for accessible knife fencing techniques that don’t dwell on KDF rondel fighting. It’s hard to come by. Thank you guys!
"Political purposes" excuse me what ?
I thought it would be a video about grossmesser
These knives are not big! A Kriegsmesser is big.
Lmao no
I've been teaching knife defense since about 2012.
Close your "shield arm" hand or those fingers are coming off.
I always teach blade arm lead cause while sure, your blade arm is more exposed and in danger of what we call "defanging the snake", you give up way too much precious reach.
And why the hell would you go for their opposite shoulder...? Crossing on someone is so dumb if they know what they're doing. Are they supposed to let you stab them and not use their "shield arm" (lol) to prevent you from that awkward and clumsy cross body stab?
Idk, I know everyone has a different fighting style and all that... but I dont think theyre all equal. Been teaching knife work for a long time, and practicing it for even longer.
This reminds me of the flawed system my old teacher, Joseph simonet, tried doing a while back. Looks cool, but yeah left lead isnt good and I showed him why lol
Its historical knife fighting chill the fuck out that is 3 mins long.
Yes you can check that stab and it gets into grappling.
As if half the Filipino stuff works either...
I would say that context is everything. I too prefer to have my weapon hand forward, but this technique broken down slowly seems to be demonstrating an armored left arm via cloak ( as mentioned ). The short video simply isn't long enough to get the details or context of the technique in order to judge it's validity.
@@torstenscott7571 it's also very rude for this guy to do this and also to randomly both name drop and diss some other Sifu
@@sauceforce9623 I disagree with his approach, like I said, I think he ignored context. However, he does make some valid points. I for one will reserve judgements until I've seen a more in depth presentation.