Our Taste Test of Soy Sauce
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 апр 2019
- Jack and Bridget discuss the best soy sauces at the supermarket.
Buy our winning soy sauce: cooks.io/2Gra9SM
ABOUT US: Located in Boston’s Seaport District in the historic Innovation and Design Building, America's Test Kitchen features 15,000 square feet of kitchen space including multiple photography and video studios. It is the home of Cook’s Illustrated magazine and Cook’s Country magazine and is the workday destination for more than 60 test cooks, editors, and cookware specialists. Our mission is to test recipes over and over again until we understand how and why they work and until we arrive at the best version.
If you like us, follow us:
americastestkitchen.com
/ americastestkitchen
/ testkitchen
/ testkitchen
/ testkitchen
I once forgot about an unopened bottle of soy sauce for 5+ years. I knew they were made from fermentation so I figured it was still ok to use. Literally the best soy sauce I’ve had in my entire life.
Hahahah! That's awesome! Thanks from Texas.
Oh wow! How great!
I have watched this show for years.....love both Bridget and Julia so much.....but also I really really like Jack! He seems to be the nicest man and always so pleasant. Just wanted to give him the recognition. Thanks!
Yeah, he looks like a patient man. Good stuff. Thanks from Texas.
Bridget is my sweetheart! I love her dearly. 💟
If you have an Asian supermarket near you, there is a much wider and better selection! The sauce aisle is a treasure trove for any of you who love Asian food.
Yeah if you are lucky enough to live near one, I bet it's a treasure trove of goodies.
Chinese .... Korean .... Japanese .... Filipino ..... Thai ..... You can literally be overloaded by the variety.
It's coconut aminos for me.
We have an H Mart... Wonderful place to shop!
I will not buy from China
Japanese: Kikkoman Whole Bean Fancy (imported from Japan)
Chinese: Pearl River Bridge (for light or thin soy sauce)
Korean: Seimpio Naturally Brewed Soy Sauce Yuginong Premium
Look for "Naturally Brewed" and few ingredients and get it from an international market if you can (more choices and less expensive)
Golden Mountain should be mentioned in this list.
“And the winner is Kikkoman”
Oh, so, I’ll just keep doing what I’m doing then.
Haha right, I was thinking isnt that already the most popular one.
Soy Sauce makes you fat. Just so you know. It stimulates your Insulin production which tells your body to store fat! So when you use it while consuming carbs, and that is really mostly what people usually use it on you are packing on the pounds. Scientists that need fat mice and rats use MSG to make them fat first, then labs perform tests on them.
I love a few splashes of a high quality soy sauce on a rice dish. But just know. If you are on a diet avoid Soy Sauce like the plague. You would be better off having a bowl of ice cream and that is not a joke.
Guided Meditation that is pseudo science bs. Sodium can make you bloated but it won’t make you gain weight if you limit your calories and take lots of it. I couldn’t find any study or links confirming what you are saying, but if you provide one I would gladly change my mind.
@@guidedmeditation2396
That's some of the biggest nonsense I've ever heard. Lol
Meanwhile, some of the countries with the highest concentration of soy sauce use have the lowest obesity rates. lol If it "made you fat", that would not be the case.
The idea that rice and soy sauce will make you fat (anything eaten in massive quantities, even healthy food, could theoretically make you fat) is laughable.
And you're also pushing the BS that MSG is bad? LOL You're just pushing racist pseudo-science.
@@OpiumBride That's the lower sodium version
Bad soy sauce costs about $3 a bottle. Good soy sauce is about $3 a bottle at the Asian mart and WILL CHANGE YOUR LIFE. It's worth finding good soy sauce. Lee Kum Kee makes a Premium, a Mushroom, and a Dark that are all EXCELLENT >.
That's where I buy it..im very surprised kikkoman won in this taste test 😰
@@iillylabrat Same. I always kind of lumped it in with La Choy. It's liquid salt with no real depth.
Absolutely agree. I'm lucky enough to have access to an asian market and I usually buy my soy sauce from there. But I do have the low sodium kikkoman. It's the best of the bunch from the supermarket.
Not only that, there are so many different variants on soy sauce. You have light soy sauce and dark soy sauce. It really does change how the dish tastes.
Where I live, a bottle of 'organic' soy source can cost over $10. Never tried them. Nowadays, it's hard to get good soy beans. Without good soy beans, it's hard to have good soy sauce.
Lee Kum Kee is my favorite too. I didn’t realize the had a mushroom. Sounds fantastic. I always use the Premium. Thanks for sharing.
I recently watched a Chinese cook explain how they use soy sauces. They use a light (not necessarily low sodium) soy for flavour and dark soy for the colour when cooking. I broke down and bought a bottle of each of the more expensive sauces to try. They look the same colour in the bottle, but, if you bring some up into the bottle neck under a light, you can see the difference in colour. There is a definite difference in flavours as well.
Had a Japanese stepmum, so grew up with Kikkoman since I was a little girl. Have had to switch to low sodium (I am now an old lady). I now cook Japanese food for my widowed Father and he, too, prefers Kikkoman lo-so.
Back in the early 70’s Kikkoman couldn’t even give the stuff away to American grocery stores.
The salesmen begged them to try and when the purchasers tasted it they thought it was awful.
Finally a rep came up with the idea of convincing the supermarket of bringing in a frying pan and stove and cooking some meat marinated with the Kikkoman soy sauce.
The aroma attracted the attention of customers and people really liked it and that’s how it took off.
Instead of just salt and pepper try seasoning your steak with some soy sauce. Don’t think anyone will regret it.
Kikkomans soy sauce is the main ingredient on everything I grill, steaks, chops, chicken, ribs
Yes, Kikkoman for me too 🤩
Kikkoman low-sodium for me. That one is by far my favorite. Cutting down on the salt allows the other flavors to shine through.
Kikkoman paid them to do advertising for them...
Made in Walworth, Wisconsin, proudly! Pax
I prefer the low salt Kikkoman, but have not seen it here in the Philippines.
The regular to me is acidic and alcohol like. The low sodium tastes so much better. And mine came in a glass jar like theirs.
fyi: you're paying for expensive water. Dilute your regular sodium kikkoman with your own water and you now got low sodium.
The Ohsawa Nama Shoyu (made by Yamaki Jozo in Japan, traditionally aged in big _kioke_ barrels, for two years if I recall correctly) is definitely the way to go if you're drinking soy sauce. It's the real thing and has excellent flavor, and is now pretty easy to find in US upscale markets, sometimes along similar products like Mitoku Kanazawa Shoyu. But due to it's cost ATK is right that a cheaper mass-market soy sauce like Kikkoman or Yamasa is often the way to go for cooking that requires large amounts of soy sauce, like some chicken adobo recipes I've seen that call for a cup of soy sauce and a cup of rice vinegar. It wouldn't make sense to use the expensive ones.
However, Ohsawa can be quite reasonably priced if you're willing to buy a quart/liter jar at a time. It's usually sold for less than $20. If you're just using soy sauce for dipping then that generally means you only ever use a little at a time and big bottles really last. For that kind of use the higher quality "delicately flavored" soy sauces are really worth considering. A bottle might last you a year or more and you'll really taste it when you do use it.
Ohsawa Nama Shoyu is also lower in sodium than even the low-sodium versions of the big brands like Kikkoman, which I really like, and it's certainly not low on flavor. It just has more nuance and a better taste in my opinion. That comes from aging for a few years rather than a few months and the differences in fermentation practices and equipment. If you're more adventurous you can get some good Japanese labeled stuff not made for export at an Asian specialty food store or online. The best I've tasted is Yamaroku Tsuru Bishio from Shodoshima, very artisanal, but Ohsawa Nama Shoyu is almost as good, has less salt, is less expensive, is imported to the US and actually available in stores here, and is made in a similar traditional way. But if you're interested in artisanal soy sauce there's great footage of Yamaroku on Great Big Story and in Netflix's _Salt Fat Acid Heat._
Ohsawa Nama Shoyu is genuine high-end Japanese soy sauce imported by Ohsawa and available in US supermarkets, so don't feel like you have to import a bottle yourself from Japan. The flavor of Ohsawa is representative of and similar to the other high-end soy sauces I've tried. It's definitely the easiest and generally the least expensive way to buy such sauce in the US and so is the best value if you want to buy high-end soy sauce in the US.
I do recommend buying a bottle of Ohsawa if you want to try a step up from the cheaper mainstream brands produced using modern industrial methods with less aging. It's like a higher-quality olive oil or balsamic vinegar. It can be worth it when you're tasting it, but when used in cooking some dishes it will not always make a significant difference. It's not objectively an expensive food item, just expensive relative to Kikkoman. Small bottles of Ohsawa I see at health food stores for like $6. Bigger bottles give you more ounces per dollar.
Ohsawa also imports from Yamaki some tremendous miso that blows away the domestic miso I've tried. You can get it made from brown rice, soybeans, or barley. Maybe more varieties than that. I've only had the brown rice miso but I'm curious about the barley. I'm about to buy more for my miso soup and many sauces, dressings, and broths their excellent miso has worked it's way into in my kitchen. If you want an appeal to a famous authority, Japanese cookbook author and food writer Nancy Hachisu recommends the Ohsawa soy sauce and miso. She's a fan of their supplier Yamaki Jozo and we're all glad that such quality is now available in the US.
You TOTALLY work for them lol
@@XMetalChefX No, I'm just enthusiastic. Nowadays I buy relatively cheap Trader Joe's reduced sodium soy sauce, which I think tastes great for the price and surprisingly traditional (it is in fact aged for several months). I use that for cooking, and then have a bottle of more expensive imported Japanese soy sauce just for dipping my food in (or pouring over rice sometimes). That only requires about a spoonful per meal. A pint lasts me about a year for one person, so I don't think it's expensive to use and I don't buy the big bottle of Ohsawa anymore (I used to get a quart from Whole Foods), which I still recommend as a better value. The imported Yamaroku Tsuru Bishio has really gone up in price since they started getting internationally famous. When I first started buying them, they were more competitively priced. I may try some other brands someday, but I like what I have and using a little at a time I don't mind spending less than $30 annually on one bottle of really good soy sauce. I really taste it in my food. It's worth the extra cent or two per meal.
It's all on Amazon. Well, not the Trader Joe's sauce, that's at Trader Joe's. Great value, and you can get it in low sodium unlike the fancier sauces.
The big difference is between the brands that you'll find in takeout soy sauce packets (Kikkoman, Yamasa, etc.) and traditionally aged soy sauce. That's a big difference. The differences between the higher quality soy sauces are minor. You can taste the difference side by side, but it's not a huge difference. Generally, the cheapest soy sauces are hugely different from the good ones. You don't have to pay much more. More expensive give diminishing returns. The biggest difference is from the low-end to middle-end. High-end soy sauce is a luxury, and if you're pinching pennies you can live without it just fine. It also depends on your diet and how you use soy sauce.
If you're cooking with it, you won't taste a difference. Like how I cook with the cheapest extra virgin olive oil I can find, but have better ones to eat raw or only slightly cooked. If you're buying expensive foods like sushi that you're going to dip in soy sauce and really taste the sauce, it makes sense to buy really good sauce. With strongly flavored foods, the quality of the sauce may not matter much. And how often you use soy sauce will also factor into whether quality matters to you.
Thanks for the marketing BS corporate shill
This is the fourth 'test-video' I've seen from this channel, and they've all been good : useful, not too long, to the point, trustworthy and well produced. Thanks !
I'm always using America's Test Kitchen/ Cook's Illustrated recommendations for products I'm shopping for. Between this and the equipment reviews, I feel my annual subscription is justified.
It's also good when the tester gets it 'wrong' since it gives more information. It's like a movie critic, perhaps you like where they are coming from in terms of taste, etc.
Their test videos are better when they stick to something they know about, which is western food. Japanese and Chinese soy sauces are fundamentally different, and they should have noted that. There are major differences even among Chinese soy sauces, with light and dark being the most commonly known. So very poor review all the way around, starting with ignorance of cultural qualities.
barkebaat - I also like the taste test segments. They are short because they are taken from the half hour shows. And their equipment reviews are always helpful. I have bought several things because of their recommendations. Lisa McManus is also great at reviews. One does not need a subscription to get the information.
I always buy kikoman for basic soy sauce needs. I have a general distaste for all la-choy products.
If it has "hydrolyzed soy protein" in the ingredients list, I don't want it. There is no replicating the special, wonderful flavors of a properly fermented sauce in just 2 days of manufacture.
La Choy is what my family always used when I was a kid, mainly because it was the only soy sauce on the shelf at the grocery store. As an adult I use Kikkoman's, but I think I'd like to try that $10 Japanese soy sauce just once. The sticker shock will probably keep me from seeking it out, however. Lol
They give me migraines. They even load up their bean sprouts in MSG.
@@HayTatsuko I found this very interesting from Samin Nosrat's Netflix show, this was the Salt episode - "Yasuo Yamamoto's traditional soy sauce factory: Yamaroku Soy Sauce. A fifth generation soy sauce manufacturer, Yasuo uses kioke barrels to ferment his product, sometimes leaving it for 2 years or more, compared to the average 6 months period used by larger manufacturers. Kioke barrels are the key tool, and ingredient, in the production of traditional soy sauce, because of the millions of beneficial bacteria that call the wood home, and help in the fermentation process. The barrels are an antique technique, and in the whole of Japan there exist only 2 manufacturers, at which Yasuo himself has apprenticed." the barrels alone are made by a very old company that makes it by hand, its such an incredible process.
Soy sause in asia has different purposes. There korean soy sauce which is byproduct of soy paste. Japanese ones are sweeter. They are very suitable for japanese food and dipping sauce. They are made with wheat or burley. Tamari is excellent for sushi. There is also tsuyu. This is more for sauce for udon and soba
I think you’re hurting people’s head here. So let’s not, for sake of non-Asians
sake
@@panglebangle9445:
You're making me think of putting a drop of soy sauce into a bottle of sake and just downing it all.
good comment as it shows they no zero about soy sauce
Tsuyu isn't soy sauce. It's the dipping sauce made from combining dashi stock with soy sauce. Also, Japanese soy sauce, like wine, varies considerably. Kikkoman is a good reasonably priced everyday soy sauce. But, there are many others that are brewed longer, much smoother, and more complex. They are superior and preferred as a finishing soy sauce for items like sashimi.
You ladies are so inspiring!! I really never enjoyed cooking till I started watching your videos. Keep up the great work!
I grew used to using/eating Aloha Shoyu from Hawai'i when I was stationed there. Less salty than most, plus they have a low sodium type also.
Just knew that Kikkoman was going to win. It's fairly affordable as well. However I would still stick with Lee Kum Kee as a personal preference, specifically with the deluxe gold version
As always, great show, great presentation from 'the best'. A big thank you to Jack & Bridget. 👍😎❤
Hello- love these type of videos. It helps me to buy without doing all the legwork myself. Thank goodness for this channel.
Three generations of Kikkoman Shoyu here! 🎌
Shoyu chicken yuppers!!
My choice is Pearl River Bridge Light Soy first then Kikkoman. Both are available readily in our local supermarket. Honorable mention goes to Aloha Shoyu which is made in Hawaii.
Aloha’s flavor is pretty good but tends to be a little weak for me in general.
I keep reading comments about this Pearl River. I will need to look for it. And I like their name, too. Thanks from Texas.
Pearl River Bridge is my favorite
(It’s Chinese, medium darkness)
KIMLAN BRO FIGHT ME
48956l
I’m glad you’ve found something you like.
But confrontational advocacy is the least effective way to attempt to influence my opinion. (And no, I don’t think I’ll rush right out to try it, either. Maybe eventually.)
PRB light is my favorite.
Kurtis Kroon how much do you even bench dude
I've tried them all and Pearl River Bridge is a clear winner in my estimation. My Hawaiian wife, who grew up on Shoyu and Kikkoman, also agrees.
Always nice when the brand you use is the winner.
8 different bottles and only 4 choices...
We all get used to ingredients and sometimes we want to expand our tastes. I appreciate seeing you try different sources and helping me narrow down what I should try next.
Thank you ladies....i follow all your tips.....i appreciate your lower cost.options on all products.....but I am grateful.
I think you'd find a different favorite if tested in Japan/Korea/China etc. with some testers wondering for WHAT purpose is the particular soy sauce being tested.
I think Chris K. picked Eden Shoyu Soy Sauce years ago, and I’ve been using it ever since. Everyone who tries it seems to love it
my thai wife has a whole cabinet full of soy sauces ie mushroom, light, dark, sweet, golden mountain, etc etc. she uses different sauces and combination of sauces for different purposes. along with fish and oyster sauces. there's a whole science going on there.. i'm a lucky man
Thank you for sharing! Best presentation video of Soy Sauce!
😊🤗😊🤗
I found so much more respect for this guy when I learned that he is much more to
ATK than the taste test guy.
ok so here in Canada we use a lot of China Lily and kikkoman. China Lily is very dark with such great flavor. I've never heard of any of these except kikkoman. thanks kids.
Until around 1990 I never knew that anything but La Choy existed as far as soy sauce. It took a ton of cooking shows and a whole food related tv network to wake everyone up to things like Kikkoman.
I grew up with kikkoman for almost half my life. But while living in hawaii, I found I preferred aloha soy sauce in the 70s. That still continues to be my go to now even though I now live in calif. So best to one is not best to others.
Love Aloha Shoyu.
Aloha is by far the superior soy sauce
It is always very interesting to see how people from a different culture see and evaluate soy sauce.
My favorite is Lee Kum Kee. Ive always found it to have the right balance.
The fact that it wasn't even in the pack was a let down for me. It is the light soy that even Chinese people choose.
Try Lee Kum Kee premium soy.
Interestingly enough, in an article on the Cook's Country website, they recommended Lee Kum Kee. www.cookscountry.com/how_tos/6467-getting-to-know-asian-condiments
I totally agree. It's my favorite as well.
@@halfthefiber Maybe because they are a sponsor of Cook's Country!
What a great way to spend my Saturday evening
Not surprised. my wife (who is Japanese) won't let me buy anything except Kikkoman.
Have you ever tried Kyoto shoyu?
La choy has added sugar which sucks.
I use the imported Japanese Organic Kikkoman. There is a reason you see a lot of the Asian you tubers use it, it’s a bit nicer and less processed tasting than the American kikkoman. That said, I’ve also got bottles of Korean soup soy sauce and two different Chinese soy sauces as well so I’ve got more options to compare it to.
and my Ex-Wife, who is Chinese, is always telling me I am using the wrong soy sauce for a particular application.
@@haroldellis9721 Yup, there are different types of soy for different applications. Japanese food gets Kikkoman. Chinese food I need at least 3 kinds. A dark, (I use for certain noodle dishes and meats) a regular, (most commonly used for dipping) and a light (for congee and soups), and for some applications even a super dark --but I don't make those dishes......they are not interchangeable at all. Using the wrong soy sauce changes the flavor of the dish. OH, and NEVER LA CHOY
I think putting Japanese style soy sauces vs Chinese style sauce as though they were the same thing makes about as much sense as including ketchup in a mexican salsa tasting.
This is apples and oranges guys.
they are more similar to each than apples are to oranges or ketchup is to salsa. But, yes, I do agree with the basic premise. The soy sauces are different in taste. However, I've never prepared the same dish side by side with, say, Yamasa in one & Pearl River Bridge in the other to see what the outcome is. Might be a fun experiment.
@@km6206 Iirc Kikkoman in Europe is manufactured in like the Netherlands or something, but it's the only Japanese brand I've tried, and it tasted just like the Chinese light soys I get (Pearl River Bridge, Lee Kum Kee), I was really shocked how similar they tasted side by side considering the Kikkoman is over 3 times the price. However I've started buying a type of Philippian soy sauce by Datu Puti which is called Toyomansi, which is a combination of soy with hints of Calamansi which is a Phillipian lemon (kinda tastes more like a cross between an orange and a lime to me) which makes it interesting and adds a nice sourness so you don't need to mess about with vinegars or whatever for your food.
Yamaroku aged 4 years soy sauce is the best tasting sauce in the world! Complex and rich umami flavor. Slight tingly sweet flavor note and rich fermented soy beans flavor. A real nice kick to the salty and savory flavor!
Higashimaru or Yamasa are better, in my opinion but you have to live near a Japanese specialty market. I also found that the kikkoman tamari (black and gold bottle) is much better than the san-j stuff that you normally find, but I can only seem to find it at Japanese markets as well. Kikkoman is definitely the best supermarket stuff by far.
The san-j had a strange off flavor to me as well. Not pleasant at all.
wellivea1 I’ve found Yamasa in regular supermarkets now and then but I usually go to a Japanese market for the big bottle. It’s the best.
@@fisch723 I've never seen it in normal supermarkets here in NC but I'll keep my eyes open for it.
These folks need to grab the 50+ brands in any Asian store. Then we'll talk.
Frank Tedesco You know they test large varieties of soy sauce right? But they only show few example here in the video. If you want to see full test of other brands you have to go through their paywall. This is true of other test conducted by ATK
@@Mryodamiles Also, they tend to test what will most likely be available to you in your local supermarket.
@@jpaliwal That's the most important part. There are large parts of the country where there aren't Asian groceries (or the closest one is an inconvenient distance/time away).
Without consciously comparing flavors, I have drifted toward Kikkoman over time.
Thanks for the Videos. Great Thanks
Informative, but I do wish the sample size was much larger.
It was.
10 to be exact. But you have to join their site to see full reviews of what they test.
If you want to see full test of other brands you have to go through their paywall. This is true of other test conducted by ATK
Would've done the same thing as Bridget. Grew up with La Choy as the condiment soy sauce of choice, so I know that flavor well. I've bought Kikkoman for about 10 years now, but I have to admit when I go home to the parents ... I'm actually happy to have some of the La Choy again.
I think it's merely "what we grew up with" though. And I get why people love Kikkoman.
All i knew was VH soy sauce for 23years, then we ran out of some out the house, I picked up kikkomans, we havent switched back
LOVE Kikkoman! I particularly like the ponzu citrus and ponzu lime.
At the opening, he said they round up 10 best soy, but only four very tested and tasted. I wish more samples were tried. We love the Kikkoman soy and use it almost daily. However, when cooking, we use a variety of Chinese, mostly Lee Kim Kee soy to get a certain flavor or color.
Foodtown Teriyaki Sauce - truly unique ingredients... nothing else like it!
100% agree with your choice. Kikkoman's the only Soy Sauce I use and I've used it for decades. Yes; tried others and never liked them. Your video also reminded me that I used the last bit of my Soy Sauce (Kikkoman) 2 weeks ago and again forgot to buy another bottle. It's now on my list. :)
As a kid growing up in the Great Lakes area, I would have an oriental style food once in a while. I would dash on some soy sauce. Or, thought that I was.
My first duty station in the U.S. Air Force was in northern Japan. That was 1961. There, I was introduced to Kikkoman soy sauce. WOW!!! What a difference. If I added one part Kikkoman to five parts water, I would again have the American soy sauce that I had grown up with. Yuck.
A new friend that I met there, explained it well. “After Japanese soy sauce, American soy sauce is just a bitter disappointment.”
BINGO! He encapsulated the entire subject in one sentence.
Courtesy of Half Vast Flying
Just bought some Lee Kum Kee double fermented soy sauce...very rich with complex flavor...can’t wait to play around with it
I wonder if they tested my favorite, Kimlan. I like their pick as well.
My favorite too - they have low sodium too.
Kimlan is what I put in my Kikkoman dispenser.
My favorite too.
My wife is Asian from SE Asia and a great cook. We have a number of true Asian supermarkets in our area but she only buys Kikkoman low sodium.
My fav too!
For many of us who regularly use soy sauce/tamari I really wish they done more with the sauces you find at an Asian market. Interesting that Kikkoman came out on top of these four, though. I've used San-J a lot.
Best show ever!!!
My Thanksgiving turkey game changed when I found Kikkoman's video on using it in a brine. Happy to see it winning out!
My Chinese friend said that Kikkoman was pretty good approximation of what they had in Hong Kong when his parents first came to the US. Of course, there are plenty of others such as Pearl River Bridge on the low end and more expensive ones from Japan.
I grew up with Kikkoman, and it's good, but I've happily used San-J reduced sodium Tamari (white label with red circle) for decades. I love to try special varieties for different things, but the San-J Tamari is my go-to.
...Tamari all the way (Lima if you can get it) ...otherwise MISO brown, is my favorite
These tests would be better with a broader range of examples.
Michael Burke Their actual testing is with many more brands. The video segments are just a brief summary.
You know they test large varieties of soy sauce right? But they only show few example here in the video. If you want to see full test of other brands you have to go through their paywall. This is true of other test conducted by ATK
I wish they said more about how many brands they explored and how they cooked with them. Myself, I like Kimlan. But you need an Asian store to find it. But drinking soy sauce from a glass is just not good--as would be the case, too, with fish sauces.
Mine too. They also have good low sodium.
If you want to see full test of other brands you have to go through their paywall. This is true of other test conducted by ATK
I like the Kikkoman low sodium with the green label
Yes! ✅
Yep, green label Kikkoman is all I buy.
None of these brands are ones that a Chinese grandmother cooks with. They have a test chef there that's Asian, why didn't they ask her to do the testing?
Kikkoman or Yamasa is what I buy, I saw a pic of Yamasa in the thumbnail, I wonder how it tested, I am gonna hazard a guess it was pretty close to Kikkoman.
@Vikingr Beerdserkr Their website usually lists notes from everything they tested.
@@ncooty thanks!
Yamasa tastes better for the price imo, although the Kikkoman Marudaizu is really good. The one I really love is the Yamaroku kioke soy sauce, but that stuff is $20 per 18 oz. bottle.
Yamasa, from Japan, is what’s used in high end Japanese restaurants.
My dad worked at a La Choy plant in Detroit, in the 1930s.
I must stick with Tamari since I have gluten issues, but now I understand that I need to add a bit of sweetness to balance it out.
Always love watching your testing of products. I have used your shows to guide me on buying items for my kitchen. You have never steered me wrong❤️
You can find Japanese-made kikkoman in Asian grocers, and if you're in Hawaii you should buy some Aloha Shoyu
Kikkoman is really good it's all we use and made right here in Wisconsin of all places.
ATK is a family favorite - We love you all - stay safe
Kukkiman is way, way to salty, I am truly blessed living in Edmonton Alberta. My two local supermarkets have very large Asian sections with over 40 verieties of soy sauces. It gets even better with a dedicated Asian supermarket also nearby called T&Ts
Phillip Mulligan Totally agree with you. Also in Edmonton and 5 minutes from T&T. Presently own 5 different soy sauce varieties.
Phillip Mulligan yamasa low sodium is my go to
Not too salty but tasty
Try Yamasa from Japan, it’s the best and used in a lot of high end Japanese restaurants.
Lee Kum Kee is my favorite
Matthew Hunter Mine too. Just found out they have a mushroom flavor...Ive always used the Premium version.
Mine too. Lite and dark
I use Ohsawa Nama Shoyu organic in everything. It’s the best soya sauce in the American market so far.
Like wine, garlic, vinegar and bitters, some foods are rather assertive by themselves - they need other elements to bring out their hidden flavors - soy sauce needs to be traditionally brewed and aged, regardless of what it is made of (wheat vs no wheat) and used sparingly in order to utilize it's subtle characteristics - this taste test illustrates how complex flavors can be
In Malaysia we use black soy sauce to mix with rice, chicken, fish, and also potato even we can make it to be sauce for Fried banana, fried sweet potato or fried cassava. And it taste very much great and delicious.
KIKKOMAN is my favorite!
The best-tasting soy sauce we have found is Lee Kum Kee Soy Sauce.
My favorite is the Kikkoman Made in Japan, you’d have to check the label since it’s at some stores and not at others. It is miles ahead of their US version even. It must be fermented longer
Finally! Something familiar to me! That’s the one I use!,,,
Thanks from Texas. No Kimlan? My favorite.
Mine too! ...all of the flavors are excellent for all my various cooking and eating purposes...but sushi gets the excellent generic Japanese Kikkoman...
I had forgotten about Kimlan. I used to love it. I now use Lee Kum Kee. Wonder if its the same producer.
Every Asian cooking class I’ve taken the chefs all recommended kikkoman as a good general all purpose soy sauce
They had different recommendations for different purposes (maninades, dipping, soups.etc) but said if cost & availability were an issue then kikkoman was the best
I’ve also noticed that several of the Asian cooking channels I follow they have that industrial size bottle of kikkoman soy sauce to refill their soy sauce bottles
I've been trying different soy sauces, so this was fun to watch.
Couple of things. The expensive brand one is actually Shoyu. Which is Japanese Soy Sauce. Its thinner, milder, and that particular product is a dipping shoyu. Javanese shoyu addsjrice and barley usually to the fermenting process.
Kikkoman I agree is the best all around soy sauce, however I prefer the lower sodium version for a dipping sauce straight. If you are combining the soy with other ingredients use full on kikkoman.
Usually you add mirin to tamari to make it have a sweeter balance.
Whew, I was getting nervous there, I’m glad the panel picked Kikoman. Tried and true.
Family favorite has been Kikkoman for over 30 years. I lived in Okinawa for 3 1/2 yrs. The soy sauce from there is not available where I live.
Wish Jack would have discussed all the fake soy sauces on the market...not just the ones that are not fermented but the ones that do not use soybeans in the process.
I wanna hear about those!
That’s LaChoy lol. I grew up on that one and can’t stand it now. I even got my parents to FINALLY convert to Kikkoman!
Just stay away from them is you need to know.
I made the mistake of buying DOLLAR TREE soy sauce once. 🤮🤑🤑 it tasted like paint remover.
@@pauly5418 Amen brother! That crap is, well... Crap! 🤣
Kikkoman is the best. I've used it for many many years and it's just good.
I have both Kikkoman and la choy. La choy is my favorite all purpose soy sauce. Kikkoman is lighter on the saltiness and works well with wasabi
They also don’t mention that there’s two ways to ferment soy sauce. The organic soy sauce is fermented for two years using traditional cedar vats - some of which are over a century old. However most fermented soy sauce is made in stainless steel vats and usually fermented less than a year. The BBC website had an interesting article about a month ago about efforts in Japan to preserve the traditional process.
Kikkoman has been my go to soy sauce for decades. 😊
LaChoy is the soy sauce of my childhood, too!
I was SO SURPRISED here...I like Kikkoman, but was prepared to see you talking like Kikkoman was just that "cheap, common, supermarket" brand.....and then you liked it!
I may be biased but i highly recommend a Taiwanese brand (only in asian markets) called Kim Lan. They probably have over 20 soy products - pick the ones with no preservatives and no English labeling, normally priced around 5-7usd. I guarantee they are so much better than Kikkoman. The US Kikkoman is very salty and one-dimensional in my opinion, plus we don’t want any soy sauce that needs preservatives in them. The best ones have 3-4 ingredients and all natural ones.
Kikkoman is just standard mass Japanese (American) produced soy sauce. Kikkoman tastes different depending on where it’s produced. Kikkoman also makes light soy sauce not to be confused with lightly salted which is just watered down, and sweet soy sauce. Further there are “boutique” brands and techniques that are much better and costly. Then of course there are many different Chinese and Korean soy sauces. Soy sauces are a bit like wines all being different.
I wish they had labeled this “Japanese soy sauce” or Shoyu because they aren’t the same as other Asian soy sauces like Korean or Chinese sauces. Some sauces are more salty, others sweeter, or more funky because that’s what you use them for in those cuisines. Japanese soy sauce can taste down right weird in certain Chinese dishes for example. I had the same issue with their fish sauce tasting. Thai, Viet, Chinese and Korean fish sauces are all different for legitimate reasons.
It just shows they know nothing about soy sauce and you can tell how they picked it.
I'm with you. Considering they like to set themselves up as experts they didn't even bother discussing this. I'm no expert and even I know that there is a difference between Japanese and Chinese soy sauces. I had always hated soy sauce because all I'd tasted was kikkoman. I discovered that Chinese soy sauce is sooo much more flavorful and with a lot less salt. Lately I also get the reduced salt versions as well. Even the generic Winco low salt version taste so much better to me.
Yamasa is my favourite
The best soy sauce is from taiwan... It is also wheat free so good for gluten free diet.
'Chopstick company wei jung red rice yeast soy sauce'
Its a finishing sauce too expensive to cook with
About 8-9 dollars for less than a cup.
You will be amazed if you can find it.
In los angeles we have asian markets that are the size of a costco. One whole aisle for soy sauce alone!
That is where I get mine.
I like to wrap it up and bring for host/ess gift