SARDAR UDHAM (2021) - Round Table Review LIVE!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 ноя 2022
- Our adventures in Indian cinema continue with a look at Soojit Sircar's 2021 biopic, SARDAR UDHAM!
The film details the two decades that Punjabi Sikh revolutionary Udham Singh (Vicky Kaushal) spent planning the assassination of Michael O'Dwyer (Shaun Scott) the man responsible for the 1919 Jallianwala Bagh massacre.
SARDAR UDHAM was overwhelmingly demanded as the next choice for a live round table review, and it's no wonder why. Ian and Mark examine the complex angles from which Sircar tests the audience's sympathies--and, in the process, completely shifts the context in the third act in a way that demands both a re-watch and a re-evaluation.
Show Links
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch the SARDAR UDHAM trailer:
• Sardar Udham - Officia...
Support ALL of Earth's Mightiest Critics at our various outlets:
Check out Mark "The Movie Man" Krawczyk's The Spoiler Room Podcast:
www.specialmarkproductions.co...
And watch him and Ian discuss the 2010 thriller, HISSS (recorded live the day before their SARDAR UDHAM show):
• Hisss (2010) - Sinema ...
Get educated with Don Shanahan at Every Movie Has a Lesson:
www.everymoviehasalesson.com/
...And 25YL:
25yearslatersite.com/
...AND the Cinephile Hissy Fit Podcast:
open.spotify.com/show/6G0dYEH...
Follow David Fowlie's film criticism at Keeping It Reel:
keeping-it-reel.com/
Make Nice with Mike Crowley of You'll Probably Agree:
www.ypareviews.com/
Keep up with Annie Banks at Chuck Load of Comics:
www.chuckloadofcomics.com/
...AND Movieweb:
movieweb.com/
And stir things up with Will Johnson of the Cinephile Hissy Fit Podcast:
open.spotify.com/show/6G0dYEH...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe, like, and comment to the Kicking the Seat RUclips channel, and check out kickseat.com for multiple movie podcasts each week! www.kickseat.com/ 
Развлечения
How is it the British are never called terrorists? Even accidentally? They funded their industrial revolution and gained great wealth at the expense primarily of India, whom they stripped of its wealth with incredibly extortive means. The "art and culture and technology" that they brought is again at the expense of the art and culture of India, a far older and more complex civilization, whom they weren't equipped to even understand. The West still has a golden rosy understanding of colonial power and what they accomplished, thinking it was in some way beneficial to the countries colonized.
The truth is far, far worse. They impoverished a world power (India) who had the world's 3rd greatest economy at the time, and resulted in many generations of famine and poverty. The natural progression of development that would have occcurred in that society would be repressed for two centuries.
Their actions in the subcontinent are mostly hidden to history because they took great pains to cover up atrocities, and destroy the evidence. Just see this documentary, for instance (from the BBC, that bastion of revolution): ruclips.net/video/h8Ers8gw_W4/видео.html
U compared him to Osama bin Laden and called him terrorist, so many times he is clearly a different from that guy. He killed odwyer the man who was responsible not even the other viceroys who served in india for crown, remember he was in England he could have done it, simply he didn't kill any innocent people like Osama did, actually he had chance to kill so many evil British who did so many horrible things but stuck to this
I feel offended when he compared uddam Singh to Osama bin Laden.
I think one thing I'm assuming is that almost everybody Indian around the globe (the movie's primary audience) is very familiar with the story of Jallianwala Bagh and Sardar Udham, although the movie did make me better informed about details of his life. It was very well-sourced and researched and used available records from the legal proceedings etc.
You keep going back to Osama, that's a bit much. Osamas country ,Saudi Arabia, was not colonized by the brits in fact it was created by them and still is propped up by the west. Osama did what he did because he found the wests "protecting" his holy places as humiliating , an ego thing which cannot in anyway be compared to the reaction to the horrors of colonization that Udham Singh experienced. Ian Simmons review , in this aspect , makes one feel that this movie did not really get through to the western audience despite the realistic depiction of the Amritsar massacre in the last 45 mts. No wonder the brits have still not apologized for this act . After all no one in his/her right mind would think of apologizing to osamas people , specially after what he did on 9/11.
You're right. Sardar Udham assassinated the person who was DIRECTLY involved in Jallianwala (cutting off the snake's head so to speak). Osama/Al-Qaeda on the other hand was involved in taking planes full of civilians, and crashing them into buildings with even more civilians. These aren't remotely comparable.
Thank you for reviewing this film ❤️
Appreciate your review. Wish more people would watch it, across the globe. Everybody who wants to comment on India really needs to see it.
Thanks for watching this movie.... It's was sad moment for india... The black day for indians.... More than 1600 people lost their lives within 10 minutes
Watch "Andhadhundh" , it's better than bajirao mastani & Jai bheem.
Vicky Kaushal is an amazing actor. He literally transforms into the character that he plays.
Thanks and appreciate your taking the time to watch this wonderful film and giving your unbiased opinions on the film .. It is a hard film to watch for any person but the truth must be told about the colonial brutality of the British Raj in India for 200 years. Best wishes and regards from an Indian dude domiciled in Hong Kong. 🙏💖
Comparison to osama is really bad
Great movie great artist and great review 👌
As a Indian I allready know the event in my school history and it so normalised,it has only 1 or2 pages ,, After seeing those last seans ,I goes in to depressed,
BAJIRAO MASTANI ,,PADMAAVAT MOVIE NEXT PLEASE BASED ON TRUE STORY JUST LIKE "SARDAR UDHAM "
They compared Sardar Uddam to Osama Bin Laden. That shows the level of the review
Watch barfi