In 1960s, in addition to generously supplying weapons, skilled pilots and military training to Egypt and Jordan to attack Israel, USSR trained any anti-Western rebels they could find, African, Asian, Middle Eastern. Palestinian PLO was one of them. It was KGB handlers who recommended Yasser Arafat to portray his movement as anti-colonialist liberation movement, because the left would take the bait. Eventually they were able to connect with domestic American anti-colonialists and portrayed themselves as victims of racism, the results are now before our eyes.
Fascists be like Putin playing victim on Tucker's interview then murdering his political opponent 2 wks later. These are the great servers of humanity keeping sapiens heartless and dumb.
Goebbels: "I'm the best ministry of propaganda..." Soviet Union: "Pathetic, we put people who believe in Judaism & Zionism on Gulag, we're also cooperated with terrorist organizations to antagonize the Jews, and Israel got blamed for it!" 😎
Goebbels: "I'm the best ministry of propaganda..." Soviet Union: "Pathetic, we put people who believe in Judaism & Zionism on Gulag, we're also cooperated with terrorist organizations to antagonize the Jews, and Israel got blamed for it!" 😎
It's possible, albeit not easy, to condense that even further, by leaving out the particulars and focusing on the overall trends, themes and motivations. Basically, to comes down to the modern far left being at its core Marxist, and Marxism being at its core rigidly fixated on the binary division of humanity into oppressed and oppressors, capitalists and workers, colonialists and the colonized, and so on. And, because at the time that Marx was developing his ideology, many European Jews, emerging from centuries of ghetto life and work and looking to improve their lot in life, choose to enter business and elite professions like law and finance, all associated by Marx with capitalist oppression, he associated Jews with capitalist oppression, and that association has stuck with Marxists ever since. When Zionism entered the picture a few decades later, because it was seen as a Jewish-European colonialist project, it further reinforced the view that Jews were white capitalist colonialist oppressors, and that view has stuck ever since, whether sincerely held or cynically exploited for political benefit. And, since Marxists tend to be a passionately unself-critical lot, never genuinely questioning their beliefs, making it more of an ideological and political religion--that is ironically itself a kind of opiate for certain kinds of masses--than a coherent thought system that survives critical scrutiny, they're not likely to challenge their core views, among which is that Jews, at least those who work in certain "bourgeois" fields like business, finance, sales, and that Zionism, being imperialist and colonialist, is inherently evil. Basically, they're stuck on fixed ideas and lack the intellect, courage or character to challenge those views, and invariably fall back on them because it's easy and comforting and keeps all the self-doubts that normal people undergo from time to time at bay. It really is a religion, and a way to avoid dealing honestly and productively with life's actual challenges and problems. Basically, it's a cult.
Bravo! Trudy Gold is tireless, and meticulous detective at the granular level, and a brilliant, comprehensive analyst at the global level. I'm so grateful she is here to help the world to understand Jews, Israel, and our rightful place in the world. Thank you, Trudy Gold! Am Yisrael Chai!
I’m a 60 year old, 1st Generation “Anglo” Irishman, a descendant of famine survivors and 1916 rebels. I was speaking with an English friend yesterday and we both wholeheartedly agreed that we would love to be citizens of a nation state whose government and citizenry were willing to stand against their enemies, those who would murder them in their beds as they slept, without compromise, to include ethical and moral considerations. Bravo and godspeed. Israel is one of the few countries i still wish to visit.
Just imagine the peace and prosperity they could have had for themselves and children had they accepted a two state solution. They are Esau, Ishmael on a spiritual level This political identity was created by their own admission to destabilise the Jewish state. ☪️ is just a belligerent imperialist religion, they just talk a different language when a small minority
Thank you Richard, I'm a 64 year old Dubliner, living in Switzerland, and I was beginning to think I was the only Paddy with a brain, curiosity and a moral compass.
Fantastic discussion. The ending reminded me of a joke I heard from Dan Schueftan: The Almighty saw that mankind had become wicked again, and was furious. He called the leaders of all 3 Abrahamic faiths to him, Muslim, Christian, and Jew, and told them "Once again, you have allowed yourself to become wicked and corrupted. And again I am going to flood the earth, but this time there will be no ark, no dove, nor olive leaf. This it, the end." So the Christian leader goes back to the Christians and says "We have sinned and so we have 2 weeks to give to charity and do good deeds and maybe we will be allowed into Heaven". The Muslim leader says "We have been doing everything correctly, so let's keep doing what we're doing and we will be forgiven". The Jewish leader says "We have 2 weeks to learn to live underwater."
Now go read all God's instructions to Israel concerning equal rights, justice, and charity to the poor, ill, sojourner, widow, and orphan. Go read God's explicit instructions to NOT shed innocent blood in the land because it is a desecration to His presence in Israel and will bring judgment. Zionism defies God.
Every Marxist is the facsimile of the same petit bourgeoise middling class man himself, people from money with few if any active brain cells, telling the world how the plebs should live whilst imagining themselves as "Inner Party" members. No amount of deaths due to his poor take on working class people- all from his hypoxia inducing ivory tower- is ever enough, there's always someone reinventing his bile for the present GM crop of useful idiots- a bumper harvest.
do you not feel that the experience of palestinians from 1900 onwards was conspicuously missing? an land without a people for a people without a land, funny nobody says that anymore, maybe because we all have the history at our fingertips. we all agree a home for the jews is a beautiful idea, but to pretend they didnt build paradise on the bones of the natives is folly. they knew what they were doing was wrong but they thought it was worth it to create israel. thats the truth. they saw modern military ability versus basically arab townships with zero military ability as easy to overthrow. and they were. imagine instead of insisting on a purely jewish ethnic state, zionism had embraced being citizens of palestine, maybe even being able to win the right for any jew to become a citizen (though that might have been very problematic, ) the fact that the jews arriving were white people and backed by western money, visibly displacing and buying land from under peoples feet who had lived there as far back as records exist, maybe a thousand years, to see white people coming and claiming a right to all the land backed by western money. peace was never on the minds of the early settlers, they knew it would be a fight. and it had nothing to do with being jewish, israel is the worst thing ever to happen to the jews, they took the only place in the world they were welcomed and turned it into the place they are most hated.
I'm a jew from Germany, my grandmothers side of the family suffered great losses during WW2. What i have to say though my fellow germans never caused my any trouble, the worst thing i had to deal with were atheists and this didn't came from anti sematic viewpoints but just from a stance against religion as a whole. Since 2015 though we started to let" you know what" flood the country. These are the most ungrateful people i met in my life, how do you treat a country and it's people that way when you are just a guest. Not to mention it became especially unsafe for pretty much every minority and even women. I myself avoid going out alone as much as possible especially at night. We are at a point now were we need protection from people who claim to be here because they need protection.
This is true - just before Covid I was abused exiting a swimming pool by five of these individuals. I am disabled so couldn't defend myself and the 2 female attendants were seemingly "unable" to intervene either. But my son reports that in the nightclub he worked in part-time as a student - it is normal. They don't report to the police, but send the victims home or to hospital in a taxi. The reason why is because they'd have to spend so much time dealing with the law they wouldn't be able to run the place.
@@notbaltic280 I can see that being true, i personally don't go to clubs but on of my friends here is not religious and very outgoing. He went to a club a few years ago and was attacked by two of these "individuals" which is strange since the religion they follow doesn't allow it, they flirted aggressively with his girlfriend and wouldn't leave her alone and at some point started to spit on her. My friend stepped in and initially just told them to leave, but they started to attack him, what they didn't knew was that he was trained in muay Thai and won multiple local tournaments, they ended up rather badly. The joke though was, that another friend called the police and they at first took these 2 guys with them but then a few days later my friend got post that he is a suspect in a "hate crime". Although my friend could bring multiple witnesses in the court he still lost, these 2 guys just said he was the aggressive one and used racial slurs before attacking without any reason and they believed them. He ended up paying, i think 4000€ and 100 hours community service (arbeits Stunden). They are seemingly never at fault for anything and you get punished for defending yourself.
@@kiwaization Nothing. My point was that germans never caused me trouble just based on my religion, that the worst thing was just atheists discussing how my religion is wrong. Which i empathized because that isn't a problem in any way and didn't came from a place of hatred. To make clear that, if that was the worst thing happening, things are pretty good
Trudy is a real gift to Jewish memory. Ollie, please have her on again soon to help Jewish viewers to understand not only the accusation of Deicide but also the 2000 year history of Christian supercessionism and replacement theology which runs deep in Christianity and is an ongoing source of western and Christian anti-Semitism today. And in contrast, she and you might discuss the positive quite modern development that there are Christians today who reject these false ideas. These are the Christian Zionists who are friends to the Jews and Israel. These are the Christians from the nations who come to Jerusalem during the Feast of Tabernacles to march on Jaffa Road every year to show their support for Israel based upon a more favorable reading, belief and application of Tenakh. These are those who celebrate their connection to the Jews and incorporate Shabbat and other aspects of Jewish living into their lives and many become Noahides. Jews should realize that we are not alone and there are other non-Christian cultures like the Indian Hindu people who are favorable in their opinions of Jews and are so numerous that they make great allies having no history of anti-Semitism as far as I can tell.
Supersessionism and replacement theory are not embedded in Christianity, but in certain apostate secs that claim to be Christian but are not. As you say, our God came here as a Jewish, and these people do not even understand their own assumed religion.
I am an of Italian descent and a christian. I believe that the old testament and new testament are intertwined. The Profits of the old testament have prophised of the coming Christ. I have always had a heart for the jewish people because of the old testament and hope that they would read the gospels written as soon as 5 years after the crucifixion by jewish deciples not under the Romans but by witnessing of what they saw. Also the Romans killed Christ from pressure by the Pharisees. I stand for Israel and always will as I believe that Judaism is the foundation of my christian beliefs.
@@jameswbuchananjr You don't understand anything at all, you are a religious fundamentalist incapable of using reason and the most basic common sense. Taking into account that you consider yourself a believer, you must believe in a god who supports the most execrable and brutal crimes possible, colonization, the most radical racism, fanaticism and the absolute lack of morality.
I don't know this woman, have never heard her speak, but I am stunned by her ability to cover vast swaths of history and citing dates and names in a thoroughly easy to understand way. I am in my eighties living in Pennsylvania. I am a Catholic and was an alter boy for 10 years. I was not aware of the fact that our local golf club had a sign "No Jews Allowed" well into the 1950s. I never met any Jewish kids until I went to Highschool. I never thought about anyone's religion until the first Jewish Holy Day when I wondered why number of my new friends were absent. My ignorance was a joke to a number of my friends and when my Jewish friends came back to school, they treated me to a Hamburger at Abe's and I asked for cheese on my burger and was refused. Then I was given a cup of coffee and asked for Milk and was refused. I Figured that my friends were kidding with me and they laughed and explained the Jewish meat and milk laws. Anyhow, I've been wandering off topic again and I'll finish with... Where Are The Police? Handcuff them, rip off those masks, throw them in the slammer until they pay bail! They'll think twice before doing it again! Just say'n.
I'm a Christian and I know enough scripture to know that there is no more wiping out the Canaanites and amalekites, that was old testament stuff written to teach us spiritual principles, NOT to copy.
Why is Islam never mentioned? The common thread among Hamas, Hezbollah, Boko Haram, etc., etc., is the ideology of Islam and it's blatant hatred of the "people of the Book", Jews and Christians. Would love to hear more on this topic from this brilliant historian.
Tremendous thanks to Dr Trudy Gold & Olly for this rare & magnificent history lesson. It’s as though I attended a brilliant history class at a top university ( not now). The details & insights revealed were absolutely the Best ever. Few know the minute & huge changes fuelling anti semitism over the ages & in so many countries. Unspeakably tragic of course but I will replay this rare educational video several times.Bless you both.
Weird, both of them are very POLITICALLY CORRECT. Neither of them spoke one word against islam (the religion of hatred/genocides of minorities) which is the basic reason why arabs hate Jews and it is not that Jews are, generally, more succesful than other people. In one of his hadiths, the profit$ of islam said that if ten Jews will convert to islam, all the rest will follow them. This, basically, means that he was not able to convince ten Jews to become muslims (except later by the sword). In Lebanon, palestinians, who wanted to work, were working like others. But most refused to work as they were waiting for the arabs to conquer Israel and take back their pseudo-land for them (meantime collecting jizya from small-businesses). For a while, Intra Bank was one of the best banks in the M.E. It was started by a palestinian guy. Also, they spoke abt the atrocities they have suffered in Europe but not abt. what the islamic khilafa(tes), during 1300 y, did to them and how they were disgraced and forced to pay jizya/khiraj taxes and live not as second-class but as a third-class citizens.
what happened to jews in the land from the end of the ottoman empire, through the mandate and right up to 47 was because the jews refused to be dhimmi of course that has it's roots in islam
Yes. The conversation is just tedious and pointless when it skirts around basic reality. What's the conclusion going to be? Probably, "we will continue trying to play ball with the extreme left and hope they don't snatch it away again"
@@artn2950 True that the British (and their French allies) split the M.E. but in anyway, pseudo-palestine did NOT exist as a state or even a 'wilaya' (arabic word for governate). During the ottoman empire, there was one single country for all M.E. It was the 'ottoman sultanate'a.k.a in the West as ottoman empire. They had governate such as the governate of Syria which included the present Syria, part of Lebanon, the today's Israel, a chunk of Jordan. The governor of Syria who was a turkish employee was dealing with the whole governate of Syria. Residents of the se-called palestine, used to identify themselves as, I am first name,last name, from Syria-Palestine (or I am .so and so,.a Syrian from palestine). They had no kings since Alexander the Great took over the whole M.E Another issue is the British and the Jews who immigrated to Israel did not have a honey-moon relation. They had many military confrontation with each others as well as with the arab-muslims. They have arrested many of the military Jewish gangs (who were the resistance )and jailed them. The British, and for a while, prevented the Europeans Jews from seeking refuge in Israel by the time the Nazis were persecuting them.
The study and understanding of history is so important. Today’s younger generation needs to understand the background of current events. This interview is helpful.
Sorry to see you go because of an old fella who liked gardening, jam making, and a fairer less exploitative world. Many decent, humane Jews are pro-Corbyn.
Stalin did a lot of work on Israel because he saw that as a way to damage the British interests. Jewish war veterans from the Red Army were allowed to emigrate to Israel, and there was an air bridge between Czechoslovakia and Israel, ferrying munitions to the Haganah and Israelis-to-be for accelerated military training. Golda's visit to Moscow did not go well. Stalin realized that he couldn't manipulate Israel the way he manipulated Mongolia, and Jews who assembled to welcome Golda were placed under surveillance as potential state enemies (meaning, one step away from being disappeared). The relationship cooled after that, but was allowed to continue until a blast in the Soviet embassy in Tel Aviv just before Stalin's timely death. A chauffeur was killed, and the cause of the blast remains, er, unknown - but has the CIA profile. A very cold peace continued until 1967, when USSR severed diplomatic relations with Israel after the war. The line that "we are against Zionism but are not antisemitic" comes straight from the Soviet media of my childhood. I remember the insulting coverage of the Munich Massacre, mixed with James Bond-style music on Soviet TV and the ridiculous coverage of the 1973 war, which was trumpeted as an Arab victory, diplomatically curtailed short of Israel being overrun. I am not at all surprised by the left-driven surge in antisemitism we are witnessing now. It was in their DNA for sixty years.
It is so sad😢 but most people are brain wash that they can't see the victim here. I am a Christian ✝️ and I am ashamed of our early fathers of the faith even St Augustine even during the Reformation Martin Luther all antisemitics. But despite a small number of people God bless 🙌 you guys. I ❤️ you all
I am heartbroken to witness how our American Youth are behaving. I grew up in Nuremberg Germany (as an American Dependant of a soldier), and while children here go to museums and parks om field trips, we went to Dachau and Auschwitz. I was around 8 or 9 so at the time I didn't fully grasp what I was seeing and I remember even asking my teacher why this elderly couple was crying and her response was "this is a sad place". I understand now because how could she have possibly explained it and made it understandable to an 8 year old. NOW, I look back at old photos and show my kids and teach my kids about the evils that existed and still exists. I sat them down and we watched Schindler's List, the Movie 'Munich' about the 1972 Olympic, and we recently watched a documentary called shtetl that showed just how slowly and sneakily everything happened in the 1920-30's that led to that demon's being placed in power. My entire purpose is to teach my children that this cannot be allowed ever again. And to think THIS is what some kids here want for this country?
Have you show your kids photos the mass graves discovered in gaza last week?. And how israhell was created, that israhell is using nazi tactics on those innocents children in palestine?, tiny u have a problem : FEARNESS !!!!
I've heard it this way. The KGB in the 1960s didn't _invent_ the "indigenous Palestinians" and "colonizer Jews" as a front of British & American imperialists. They borrowed from Joseph Goebbels and rewrote it to sound more socialist and sound less national-socialism.
As an Apostolic Christian in the UK, ( closest to the Messianic Jews of Iarael ) ; this has been THE most important podcasts of recent days. As well as Douglas Murray's brilliant analysis of the issues. "The truth shall set you free " as Yeshua said.
That was super interesting ❤ a brilliant conversation. Thank you both! I would love to hear more about the "Grand Mufti of Jerusalem" and his relations with the nazi regime and also about how he influenced his nephew- Yasser Arafat, the PLO leader. These are all some very dark details, forgotten by history. I definitely do think that the younger Jewish generation, even Israelis- are not well informed about all the aspects of this conflict. It is not taught in our schools in Israel. Everyone's been trying to talk about peace all the time. Wishful thinking.
I’m an Iranian American Christian and proud Zionist, and I could not agree with you more. I fear that October 7th was just the beginning of what will be very dark times ahead. These demons have been waging genoc1de on the Jews of Israel for over a century, while their religion has been commanding the genoc1de of all Jews for over 1,400 years now. Our late great Shahanshah Aryamehr had warned Western powers about 1slam, about what would happen if the Red & Black (the unholy union of Marxists and 1slamists) were to ever succeed in taking Iran: Israel would never know peace again, 1slamic terrorism would spread like wildfire worldwide, and the West would inevitably be next. Instead of listening to the Shah’s sage advice, the Western countries chose to betray him and the people of Iran - by funding, arming, and equpping the Red & Black terrorists that took our country hostage in 1979 and have been occupying and plundering it, and waging genoc1de against our people, ever since. And I doubt any Western layperson knows this. The West betrayed us because they wanted to continue to rob us of our oil, as they had been doing for most of the 20th century, and our Shah refused to let them do it. They sacrificed the people of Iran, the oldest surviving peoples in world history, on the altar of Western greed and hubris, and every warning the Shah gave to those Western countries has proven to be true; we are witnessing them now reap what they’ve been sowing for 45 years, with the Red & Black having infiltrated and taken over their countries. October 7th and the reaction in the West have been nothing short of demonic, but the fact that ALL Iranians are united with Israel and the Jewish people gives me faith that together, we will overcome and triumph over all these demons. Israel is my only hope for the survival of human civilization, because it still believes and fights for its values - for God, country, family, community - and it hasn’t sold out in the name of profits, as most Western countries did long ago. Americans today worship money and fame almost exclusively, so we shouldn’t be surprised that the USA doesn’t appear in the Bible. But the Lord redeems Iran in the Bible, and makes another throne for Himself in our lands. Today, over 70-80% of Iranians living in Iran are NOT Musl1m, and there are millions of Christians living in Iran again for the first time since before the Arab Musl1m invasions. To me, it feels like the Lord’s already begun to redeem my people, we just have to finish off the demonic regime and bring back our Shah and our 2,500-year long constitutional monarchy 🙏🏽 Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱 Long live Israel & the IDF 🇮🇱 Long live the Shah Reza Pahlavi II 👑 Long live Iran 💚🤍❤️🔥🦁☀️
You might enjoy my interview with Jewish South African historian Na’omi Allen about the Grand Mufti’s alliance with Hitler and his continuing influence in the Palestinian liberation movement today. ruclips.net/user/live8R9z-qbTf78?si=iHVuj-cdylOXF8NH
@@tomigun5180 The fact is, nobody has clean hands in the ME - all, at one time or another, have behaved badly - we have to try better, and move on. As millions of displaced people have for all history.
She makes an excellent point that the education system doesn't require us to think anymore. The only classes I can think of that required me to think rather than memorize anything was logic class and creative writing class. Memorizing a lot of facts and regurgitating them onto a test paper isn't really learning.
Great interview. Tremendous knowledge. I have always considered myself a liberal who believes in human rights and helping others. I guess that makes me a lefty. Problem is I have been absolutely disgusted with the “useful idiots” of the left. I could easily say, “oh, it’s because they don’t understand history.” But then I hear people like Bernie Sanders and Gabor Mate, who I had great admiration for, prior to Oct. 7th, speaking against Israel and I am stunned. I don’t understand it. It’s like they can’t see the manipulation by Hamas and the jihadist arabs. Can’t they see the planning that went into this? Anyway, I am 100% in support of Israel. I can see clearly what they are facing and when I see my fellow leftists chanting terrorist slogans taught to them by terrorists it makes me sick. Long live the great state of Israel! ❤️🇮🇱🇨🇦❤️
Remember the saying "never attribute to malice what can be to incompetence?" Well if the same people keep erring again and again in the same manner, it's definitely pernicious at that point.
The reason you don't understand it is because your understanding of politics is so shallow that you think "human rights and helping others" equals leftism. You had great admiration for Bernie Sanders? Why? How? He is on record saying that people queuing up for bread for hours and hours and hours is good because it proves equality. He got kicked out of a socialist commune when he was young, for being incredibly lazy. What are Bernie Sanders' actual virtues?
Hi so here is you are fundamentally wrong as the ideas of "human rights" and "helping others" are not liberal or left. The idea of value of the individual and their rights are from the right (individualism) and idea of helping others (charity or being in service of others) are Christian values. Left = collectivism which is the complete anathema of individual rights as individuals are only supported as long as they serve the collective (in the case of todays left/ liberals only as long as you further the ideology). As has been found time and time again the biggest givers to charity is "conservatives" and the most active people in community services is "Christians". Liberals just think saying they care, and posting BLM or whatever the latest thing is = empathy and caring, but its normally all just to satisfy their own desire to "feel' moral..
God Bless Israel and God Bless the Jewish people 🇮🇱🙏 That is why the main support for Israel right now is the conservative Christian’s. The reason we are still standing and haven’t bowed to society is because we believe the Bible to be 100% the infallible word of God. So when the Bible says the land belongs to Israel and the Jewish people we believe it. When the Bible tells us to bless Israel and the Jewish people we believe it. As a Gentile I know I am to honor and love the Jewish people. There are many of us who love you! ❤️🇮🇱🙏✝️
They are friends to the Jews, *for now* you must remember that they want all the Jews herded into Israel and then for them to all die, for SomeDamnReasonOrAnother(tm) they are not friends, just convenient for now.
Yes but there is more. The Palestinians, never owned Judea. They came from Syria and Egypt and other Arab countries and settled in Israel between 1890 and 1940 and then claimed this land as their land. The word Palestine comes from the Roman word Philistine. The Philistines were Greeks that lived along the coast of Gaza. Romans called Judea, Philistine to punish them, Palestinians never existed , they have no language, history or culture.
"We have forgotten that we have not come to an empty land to inherit it, but we have come to conquer a country from people inhabiting it.” ~ Moshe Sharett, 1914, (Benny Morris, Righteous Victims, p.91)
Thomas Sowell when asked how to end anti-semitism by Jews, said “Fail” …. success , particularly by an oppressed people, precipitates jealous and envy. So, fail if you want the bias to go away - obviously insane but hatred is insane
My ex mother in law used to say “Morta christo” to describe Jews. She was Italian American. I had never heard of this before. I was raised agnostic. It was blatantly dishonest and a lack of historical interest in my opinion. I have never understood antisemitism but I can see it happening.
My mum was Irish raised as a catholic, she raised me to be agnostic she hated all forms of religion she always said religion has done more to foster multi generational hatred than any nation. But I believe that being Jewish for the Jewish peoples subsumes all other cultural identity it’s about being Jewish first then national identity. And as an agnostic it seems to me that I do not know of any Jewish person who tries to convert others to their faith. One wonders when we as species are finally just going to live together in harmony. I personally believe that what people hate about the Jewish populace is their ability to thrive in spite of hardship.
Thank You. God bless You. We need to receive the Love and Life that Jesus brought "to the Jew first and also to the Gentile". Salvation is God's Mercy for all. Ignorance and lies are the enemy. We have been the victims and victimizers too long. The Scriptures are Truth for 4000 years. Love, Truth, and Faith have not changed. The Miracle of our Humanity is that we can change. Each one of us is Forgiven and we can forgive. I believe that is our destiny. Keep strong in your good work. Thank you both.
Those other middle eastern countries won't let them in because they say they won't abide by their laws. This not hearsay. I watched Egyptian & Saudis on RUclips voicing that. Jordon stands up for them like the Queen speaks against Israel, but she won't let them in. What does that tell you?
What a racist comment. The Palestinians have not appeared from nowhere, they have ancient roots in the area known as Palestine. The unceasing attempts to deny them their identity, historic land rights and their very humanity are morally repulsive.
I don't know the full backstory but the Arabs we call Palestinian today were part of tribes expelled for their homelands. A Lebanese colleague told me they were "the gypsies of the Arab world". He went on to say the only reason the Arab world cared about them was because it suited their anti-Israel propaganda but under no means do they want Palestinians returning to their ancestral homelands.
She is amazing! Thank you for this brilliant analysis. I think I’ll listen to it again in order to absorb all the information presented in this interview.
As an Indian origin Hindu, I can relate to Jews ✡️ cause as we have suffered almost the same way as you at the hands of a common enemy. We have survived, and you have survived, whereas many civilisations have been perished over the centuries. Perhaps we could help each other to keep humanity alive along with our civilisation.
How do you know? You just automatically accept? Do you believe without researching yourself? Do you believe everything you see and hear? Did you take the 💉because you trusted the deceivers unknowingly?Trust only God know your BIBLE OT & NT. Bible prophecy unfolding fast 🙏
😮Brilliant informative summation. Thank you. I’m a 31 year veteran of the FBI, African American, who grew up literally in the Jewish households of people like Dore Schary and Norton Simon where my parents were domestic workers, my wife is Jewish, my only living family are Jews, and I am a strong supporter of Israel, particularly now. Having said all that, I struggle to understand why so many Jews (e.g., the Rosenbergs) were complicit in delivering the secrets of the A bomb to Russia given Russia’s historic oppression of Jews. Can someone help with that?
As a Christian I love and admire you guys and I certainly didn't pick up any antisemitism in my past from my family or culture. After all, Jesus, as well as the writers of the gospels and all the first Christians, were Jews, and so were Paul and the apostles. As Paul wrote: I'm a Jew among Jews. I'm deeply embarrassed by the stories of Jew-hatred of Christians in the past. Actually I was wondering if there wasn't a way for me to reach out to Jews in the area where I live.
Thank you, Ollie, for this interview. May I please offer just a side note? At several points in this program, you, Ollie, interrupted Trudy, just when she is about to make a point. I understand your enthusiasm for the speaker and the discussion, which I thoroughly share. But Trudy is of such highest caliber that EVERY word that comes out of her is a gem. So whatever additional (or continuation of a) point she is about to make, it is NEVER incidental, marginal or unimportant. Quite the contrary. This is why I wished I could have heard EVERY word that she would utter, both because of the clarity of her diction and the significance of her point. I'm sure this would not apply to every single person you interview, but Trudy deserves a full hearing, i.e. DOWN TO THE LAST WORD. Again, thanks to both of you for this beautiful program.
Brilliant! This needs to be heard everywhere. One thing I would like to hear more from Trudi is how unusual it is in history for a group to maintain their culture and religion despite being dispersed among suspicious and often hostile populations? I can only think of the Gypsies in Europe, but they could self segregate on account of their travelling lifestyle. In Muslim and Christian cities there was official segregation but not in the countryside, where you would have thought it would have been easier to convert and integrate, especially over the millennia.
Jews were not allowed to own land, so no place in the countryside. One of the reason being their religion forbids selling land to gentiles. You are assuming they kept their culture and religion. That's not really true, they usually adopt other people's culture and their religion adapts as well and there are different strands that pop up everywhere, like Christianity and Islam. It's really just that they keep the connection and the name, but what they do is quite different than the people that lived in Palestine 2000 years ago, let's say. The Hellenes were doing colonies in hostile territory, so did the Romans. Just about everybody does it. The Jews simply have a better memory because their faith and story is written in a book, and anybody can read it and want to relate to it, so the book converts people and make them think they are the same or come from the people in the book. So I guess that part is unique.
One thing that people haven't truly understood was how the Bolsheviks were against Jews. As a matter of fact one graffiti used around their time of things in Russia had it written out how they were against a politician who they thought was a Jew but glorifying Trotsky who they thought wasn't.
Trosky was a pure Jew that saved the Russian Revolution with Jew money from New York. He didn’t want to be Lenin successor bc he was afraid of that rejection .,.. how sad
Dude, the Russians have been persecuting the Jewish people for CENTURIES! Pale of Settlement anyone? How about The Protocols of the Elders of Zion?? That is ALL Russia, and long before the Soviet Union or Stalin came around. I’m surprised that there are any Jews left in Russia. I would hate Russia would every fiber of my being if I was Jewish 🤷🏽♀️
Are you serious? I’ve heard the numbers of Bolshevik Jews around about 80 to 83 percent hardly a minority. Also, though Hitler took a deal with the Rothschilds to send Jews to Palestine. Yeah that’s right trains went to Palestine, it’s called the Havaraa agreement are the transfer agreement.
I know. I am left wing myself, and am very unhappy about hostility towards Israel. It is usually people who leave the Labour Party and come out in their true colours.
@@brynawaldman5790 Stay with the faith. The true left wing thinking is the correct way, to my mind. True left wingers understand the influences. Hopefully some of those who have strayed will come back to us, as mended people.
In 1960s, in addition to generously supplying weapons, skilled pilots and military training to Egypt and Jordan to attack Israel, USSR trained any anti-Western rebels they could find, African, Asian, Middle Eastern. Palestinian PLO was one of them. It was KGB handlers who recommended Yasser Arafat to portray his movement as anti-colonialist liberation movement, because the left would take the bait. Eventually they were able to connect with domestic American anti-colonialists and portrayed themselves as victims of racism, the results are now before our eyes.
Fascists be like Putin playing victim on Tucker's interview then murdering his political opponent 2 wks later. These are the great servers of humanity keeping sapiens heartless and dumb.
Goebbels: "I'm the best ministry of propaganda..."
Soviet Union: "Pathetic, we put people who believe in Judaism & Zionism on Gulag, we're also cooperated with terrorist organizations to antagonize the Jews, and Israel got blamed for it!" 😎
Goebbels: "I'm the best ministry of propaganda..."
Soviet Union: "Pathetic, we put people who believe in Judaism & Zionism on Gulag, we're also cooperated with terrorist organizations to antagonize the Jews, and Israel got blamed for it!" 😎
It’s quite a tough job to condense all that history into 43 minutes, but Trudy did a real master class here. Great! Thanks! 👏
Likewise 🫶
It's possible, albeit not easy, to condense that even further, by leaving out the particulars and focusing on the overall trends, themes and motivations. Basically, to comes down to the modern far left being at its core Marxist, and Marxism being at its core rigidly fixated on the binary division of humanity into oppressed and oppressors, capitalists and workers, colonialists and the colonized, and so on.
And, because at the time that Marx was developing his ideology, many European Jews, emerging from centuries of ghetto life and work and looking to improve their lot in life, choose to enter business and elite professions like law and finance, all associated by Marx with capitalist oppression, he associated Jews with capitalist oppression, and that association has stuck with Marxists ever since.
When Zionism entered the picture a few decades later, because it was seen as a Jewish-European colonialist project, it further reinforced the view that Jews were white capitalist colonialist oppressors, and that view has stuck ever since, whether sincerely held or cynically exploited for political benefit.
And, since Marxists tend to be a passionately unself-critical lot, never genuinely questioning their beliefs, making it more of an ideological and political religion--that is ironically itself a kind of opiate for certain kinds of masses--than a coherent thought system that survives critical scrutiny, they're not likely to challenge their core views, among which is that Jews, at least those who work in certain "bourgeois" fields like business, finance, sales, and that Zionism, being imperialist and colonialist, is inherently evil.
Basically, they're stuck on fixed ideas and lack the intellect, courage or character to challenge those views, and invariably fall back on them because it's easy and comforting and keeps all the self-doubts that normal people undergo from time to time at bay. It really is a religion, and a way to avoid dealing honestly and productively with life's actual challenges and problems. Basically, it's a cult.
A master class in spinning Zionist, anti-humane Jewish, fascist propaganda.
Is this person even a credentialed historian? I'm pretty sure she was ceo for a Zionist think tank or something along those lines.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I'm a British Sikh and found this very interesting. Great guest.
Bravo! Trudy Gold is tireless, and meticulous detective at the granular level, and a brilliant, comprehensive analyst at the global level. I'm so grateful she is here to help the world to understand Jews, Israel, and our rightful place in the world. Thank you, Trudy Gold! Am Yisrael Chai!
Wonderful to be able to listen to this woman , I wish this talk could be broadcasted on every site on social media !!!
I’m a 60 year old, 1st Generation “Anglo” Irishman, a descendant of famine survivors and 1916 rebels. I was speaking with an English friend yesterday and we both wholeheartedly agreed that we would love to be citizens of a nation state whose government and citizenry were willing to stand against their enemies, those who would murder them in their beds as they slept, without compromise, to include ethical and moral considerations. Bravo and godspeed. Israel is one of the few countries i still wish to visit.
Israel is civilization and the West’s last and only hope
Just imagine the peace and prosperity they could have had for themselves and children had they accepted a two state solution.
They are Esau, Ishmael on a spiritual level
This political identity was created by their own admission to destabilise the Jewish state.
☪️ is just a belligerent imperialist religion, they just talk a different language when a small minority
Please visit Israel. You are always welcome, here❤
Thank you Richard, I'm a 64 year old Dubliner, living in Switzerland, and I was beginning to think I was the only Paddy with a brain, curiosity and a moral compass.
Dublin not be totally anglicized challenge impossible
Fantastic discussion. The ending reminded me of a joke I heard from Dan Schueftan:
The Almighty saw that mankind had become wicked again, and was furious. He called the leaders of all 3 Abrahamic faiths to him, Muslim, Christian, and Jew, and told them "Once again, you have allowed yourself to become wicked and corrupted. And again I am going to flood the earth, but this time there will be no ark, no dove, nor olive leaf. This it, the end." So the Christian leader goes back to the Christians and says "We have sinned and so we have 2 weeks to give to charity and do good deeds and maybe we will be allowed into Heaven". The Muslim leader says "We have been doing everything correctly, so let's keep doing what we're doing and we will be forgiven". The Jewish leader says "We have 2 weeks to learn to live underwater."
Excellent information. Trudy Gold rocks.
She is an outstanding speaker or guest. I really enjoyed her insights and comments.
Formidable interview.! Thank you Ollie
She is a charlatan who leaves out conspicuous history which doesn’t help her narrative
just read Karl Marx...i was shocked when i read him as a naive and idealistic teen. cured me.
Ironically, Karl Marx is a Jew.
Read The Devil and Karl Marx
Now go read all God's instructions to Israel concerning equal rights, justice, and charity to the poor, ill, sojourner, widow, and orphan. Go read God's explicit instructions to NOT shed innocent blood in the land because it is a desecration to His presence in Israel and will bring judgment. Zionism defies God.
Every Marxist is the facsimile of the same petit bourgeoise middling class man himself, people from money with few if any active brain cells, telling the world how the plebs should live whilst imagining themselves as "Inner Party" members.
No amount of deaths due to his poor take on working class people- all from his hypoxia inducing ivory tower- is ever enough, there's always someone reinventing his bile for the present GM crop of useful idiots- a bumper harvest.
@@franmorrison1080 they're the same guy anyway...
This is excellent. Thank you for this information. Trudy Gold has a superb command of the facts.
I could literally sit and listen to her all day, because she is such a great speaker! Thank you for interviewing her, and please bring her back soon!
do you not feel that the experience of palestinians from 1900 onwards was conspicuously missing? an land without a people for a people without a land, funny nobody says that anymore, maybe because we all have the history at our fingertips. we all agree a home for the jews is a beautiful idea, but to pretend they didnt build paradise on the bones of the natives is folly. they knew what they were doing was wrong but they thought it was worth it to create israel. thats the truth. they saw modern military ability versus basically arab townships with zero military ability as easy to overthrow. and they were. imagine instead of insisting on a purely jewish ethnic state, zionism had embraced being citizens of palestine, maybe even being able to win the right for any jew to become a citizen (though that might have been very problematic, ) the fact that the jews arriving were white people and backed by western money, visibly displacing and buying land from under peoples feet who had lived there as far back as records exist, maybe a thousand years, to see white people coming and claiming a right to all the land backed by western money. peace was never on the minds of the early settlers, they knew it would be a fight. and it had nothing to do with being jewish, israel is the worst thing ever to happen to the jews, they took the only place in the world they were welcomed and turned it into the place they are most hated.
What a pleasure to listen and learn from this great lady.
It is a big problem which haunted me for a long time. Thanks for shedding much lights on it.
Much Light. And haunted is the wrong word.
I'm a jew from Germany, my grandmothers side of the family suffered great losses during WW2. What i have to say though my fellow germans never caused my any trouble, the worst thing i had to deal with were atheists and this didn't came from anti sematic viewpoints but just from a stance against religion as a whole. Since 2015 though we started to let" you know what" flood the country. These are the most ungrateful people i met in my life, how do you treat a country and it's people that way when you are just a guest. Not to mention it became especially unsafe for pretty much every minority and even women. I myself avoid going out alone as much as possible especially at night. We are at a point now were we need protection from people who claim to be here because they need protection.
This is true - just before Covid I was abused exiting a swimming pool by five of these individuals. I am disabled so couldn't defend myself and the 2 female attendants were seemingly "unable" to intervene either. But my son reports that in the nightclub he worked in part-time as a student - it is normal. They don't report to the police, but send the victims home or to hospital in a taxi. The reason why is because they'd have to spend so much time dealing with the law they wouldn't be able to run the place.
@@notbaltic280 I can see that being true, i personally don't go to clubs but on of my friends here is not religious and very outgoing. He went to a club a few years ago and was attacked by two of these "individuals" which is strange since the religion they follow doesn't allow it, they flirted aggressively with his girlfriend and wouldn't leave her alone and at some point started to spit on her. My friend stepped in and initially just told them to leave, but they started to attack him, what they didn't knew was that he was trained in muay Thai and won multiple local tournaments, they ended up rather badly. The joke though was, that another friend called the police and they at first took these 2 guys with them but then a few days later my friend got post that he is a suspect in a "hate crime". Although my friend could bring multiple witnesses in the court he still lost, these 2 guys just said he was the aggressive one and used racial slurs before attacking without any reason and they believed them. He ended up paying, i think 4000€ and 100 hours community service (arbeits Stunden).
They are seemingly never at fault for anything and you get punished for defending yourself.
Yes, but what does the immigration problem have to do with atheists?
@@kiwaization Nothing. My point was that germans never caused me trouble just based on my religion, that the worst thing was just atheists discussing how my religion is wrong. Which i empathized because that isn't a problem in any way and didn't came from a place of hatred. To make clear that, if that was the worst thing happening, things are pretty good
@@brotbrotsen1100it was the Jewish community that let the migrants in.
Total own goal
Trudy is a real gift to Jewish memory. Ollie, please have her on again soon to help Jewish viewers to understand not only the accusation of Deicide but also the 2000 year history of Christian supercessionism and replacement theology which runs deep in Christianity and is an ongoing source of western and Christian anti-Semitism today. And in contrast, she and you might discuss the positive quite modern development that there are Christians today who reject these false ideas. These are the Christian Zionists who are friends to the Jews and Israel. These are the Christians from the nations who come to Jerusalem during the Feast of Tabernacles to march on Jaffa Road every year to show their support for Israel based upon a more favorable reading, belief and application of Tenakh. These are those who celebrate their connection to the Jews and incorporate Shabbat and other aspects of Jewish living into their lives and many become Noahides. Jews should realize that we are not alone and there are other non-Christian cultures like the Indian Hindu people who are favorable in their opinions of Jews and are so numerous that they make great allies having no history of anti-Semitism as far as I can tell.
Supersessionism and replacement theory are not embedded in Christianity, but in certain apostate secs that claim to be Christian but are not. As you say, our God came here as a Jewish, and these people do not even understand their own assumed religion.
I am an of Italian descent and a christian. I believe that the old testament and new testament are intertwined. The Profits of the old testament have prophised of the coming Christ. I have always had a heart for the jewish people because of the old testament and hope that they would read the gospels written as soon as 5 years after the crucifixion by jewish deciples not under the Romans but by witnessing of what they saw. Also the Romans killed Christ from pressure by the Pharisees. I stand for Israel and always will as I believe that Judaism is the foundation of my christian beliefs.
Who do you think you are to speak on behalf of all Jews?
@@jameswbuchananjr You don't understand anything at all, you are a religious fundamentalist incapable of using reason and the most basic common sense. Taking into account that you consider yourself a believer, you must believe in a god who supports the most execrable and brutal crimes possible, colonization, the most radical racism, fanaticism and the absolute lack of morality.
@@peteranna7788 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I could listen to Trudy all day. Thank you for having her on again ❤
I literally said the same thing before I read what you wrote! I completely agree, she is an amazing speaker!
She is a racist colonial throwback
I don't know this woman, have never heard her speak, but I am stunned by her ability to cover vast
swaths of history and citing dates and names in a thoroughly easy to understand way. I am in my
eighties living in Pennsylvania. I am a Catholic and was an alter boy for 10 years. I was not aware of
the fact that our local golf club had a sign "No Jews Allowed" well into the 1950s. I never met any
Jewish kids until I went to Highschool. I never thought about anyone's religion until the first Jewish Holy Day when I wondered why number of my new friends were absent. My ignorance was a joke
to a number of my friends and when my Jewish friends came back to school, they treated me to a
Hamburger at Abe's and I asked for cheese on my burger and was refused. Then I was given a cup of coffee and asked for Milk and was refused. I Figured that my friends were kidding with me and they laughed and explained the Jewish meat and milk laws. Anyhow, I've been wandering off topic again
and I'll finish with... Where Are The Police? Handcuff them, rip off those masks, throw them in the
slammer until they pay bail! They'll think twice before doing it again! Just say'n.
LOU HI I REALLY LIKE WHAT YOU POSTED FROM A JEWISH PERSON IN THE USA AM YISRAEL CHAI❤💙🙏💙🙏
I am a Christian and I support Israel, the chosen people of God.
If you are true Christian, you can not hate Israel.
that's fine but you should understand you sound like an insane person out here
@@IBMCs2009 Stop accusing people of what you are. You gobble up nazi propaganda and keep hating jews. Insane is the one who keep hating.
I'm a Christian and I know enough scripture to know that there is no more wiping out the Canaanites and amalekites, that was old testament stuff written to teach us spiritual principles, NOT to copy.
@@IBMCs2009 Insane is the person who hate Jews as a group of people.
@@rdaleyj1 October 7th massacre is an a act of war by Hamas, Israel is justified to defend herself.
Thank you for this cogent and insightful discussion during these incredibly difficult and dangerous times.
Well done Ollie and Trudy! What a down to earth talk. What intelligent insights.
Why is Islam never mentioned? The common thread among Hamas, Hezbollah, Boko Haram, etc., etc., is the ideology of Islam and it's blatant hatred of the "people of the Book", Jews and Christians. Would love to hear more on this topic from this brilliant historian.
So intelligent and deep knowledgeable. This is real humanism , facts for peace , truth will lead to real justice
This was a great interview! Thanks for sharing this with us, Ollie!
Great interview Pray for Israel
Tremendous thanks to Dr Trudy Gold & Olly for this rare & magnificent history lesson. It’s as though I attended a brilliant history class at a top university ( not now). The details & insights revealed were absolutely the Best ever. Few know the minute & huge changes fuelling anti semitism over the ages & in so many countries. Unspeakably tragic of course but I will replay this rare educational video several times.Bless you both.
Thanks! We need more of such voices...
Thank you very much Mrs. Gold.
Shalom from Germany.
Fantastic summary
Well done to Ollie and Trudi.
Weird, both of them are very POLITICALLY CORRECT. Neither of them spoke one word against islam (the religion of hatred/genocides of minorities) which is the basic reason why arabs hate Jews and it is not that Jews are, generally, more succesful than other people. In one of his hadiths, the profit$ of islam said that if ten Jews will convert to islam, all the rest will follow them. This, basically, means that he was not able to convince ten Jews to become muslims (except later by the sword).
In Lebanon, palestinians, who wanted to work, were working like others. But most refused to work as they were waiting for the arabs to conquer Israel and take back their pseudo-land for them (meantime collecting jizya from small-businesses). For a while, Intra Bank was one of the best banks in the M.E. It was started by a palestinian guy.
Also, they spoke abt the atrocities they have suffered in Europe but not abt. what the islamic khilafa(tes), during 1300 y, did to them and how they were disgraced and forced to pay jizya/khiraj taxes and live not as second-class but as a third-class citizens.
what happened to jews in the land from the end of the ottoman empire, through the mandate and right up to 47 was because the jews refused to be dhimmi
of course that has it's roots in islam
Yes. The conversation is just tedious and pointless when it skirts around basic reality. What's the conclusion going to be? Probably, "we will continue trying to play ball with the extreme left and hope they don't snatch it away again"
Thanks
The Turks left after losing WWI and Britain carved it up. Just ask Peter O'Toole( just kidding!!!)
@@artn2950
True that the British (and their French allies) split the M.E. but in anyway, pseudo-palestine did NOT exist as a state or even a 'wilaya' (arabic word for governate). During the ottoman empire, there was one single country for all M.E. It was the 'ottoman sultanate'a.k.a in the West as ottoman empire. They had governate such as the governate of Syria which included the present Syria, part of Lebanon, the today's Israel, a chunk of Jordan. The governor of Syria who was a turkish employee was dealing with the whole governate of Syria. Residents of the se-called palestine, used to identify themselves as, I am first name,last name, from Syria-Palestine (or I am .so and so,.a Syrian from palestine). They had no kings since Alexander the Great took over the whole M.E
Another issue is the British and the Jews who immigrated to Israel did not have a honey-moon relation. They had many military confrontation with each others as well as with the arab-muslims. They have arrested many of the military Jewish gangs (who were the resistance )and jailed them. The British, and for a while, prevented the Europeans Jews from seeking refuge in Israel by the time the Nazis were persecuting them.
The study and understanding of history is so important. Today’s younger generation needs to understand the background of current events. This interview is helpful.
TRUDY is brilliant
Corbyn is my MP but not for long I am selling.
*Is it hyperbolic to call him a traitor?* 🤔
Yes. Hyperbole is exaggerated description not to be taken literally.
@@anthonyhuber-permanentlyre7808 No, not hyperbolic. There is no terrorist anti-British movement he won't support.
Corbin is a traitor for not repressing Israeli interests but not for ignoring British ones? Interesting take
Sorry to see you go because of an old fella who liked gardening, jam making, and a fairer less exploitative world. Many decent, humane Jews are pro-Corbyn.
Amazing conversation! Thanks so much! 🎺
Stalin did a lot of work on Israel because he saw that as a way to damage the British interests. Jewish war veterans from the Red Army were allowed to emigrate to Israel, and there was an air bridge between Czechoslovakia and Israel, ferrying munitions to the Haganah and Israelis-to-be for accelerated military training.
Golda's visit to Moscow did not go well. Stalin realized that he couldn't manipulate Israel the way he manipulated Mongolia, and Jews who assembled to welcome Golda were placed under surveillance as potential state enemies (meaning, one step away from being disappeared).
The relationship cooled after that, but was allowed to continue until a blast in the Soviet embassy in Tel Aviv just before Stalin's timely death. A chauffeur was killed, and the cause of the blast remains, er, unknown - but has the CIA profile.
A very cold peace continued until 1967, when USSR severed diplomatic relations with Israel after the war. The line that "we are against Zionism but are not antisemitic" comes straight from the Soviet media of my childhood. I remember the insulting coverage of the Munich Massacre, mixed with James Bond-style music on Soviet TV and the ridiculous coverage of the 1973 war, which was trumpeted as an Arab victory, diplomatically curtailed short of Israel being overrun.
I am not at all surprised by the left-driven surge in antisemitism we are witnessing now. It was in their DNA for sixty years.
This was an informative analysis. Todah Rabah 🙏🏼
It is so sad😢 but most people are brain wash that they can't see the victim here. I am a Christian ✝️ and I am ashamed of our early fathers of the faith even St Augustine even during the Reformation Martin Luther all antisemitics. But despite a small number of people God bless 🙌 you guys.
I ❤️ you all
I am heartbroken to witness how our American Youth are behaving. I grew up in Nuremberg Germany (as an American Dependant of a soldier), and while children here go to museums and parks om field trips, we went to Dachau and Auschwitz. I was around 8 or 9 so at the time I didn't fully grasp what I was seeing and I remember even asking my teacher why this elderly couple was crying and her response was "this is a sad place". I understand now because how could she have possibly explained it and made it understandable to an 8 year old. NOW, I look back at old photos and show my kids and teach my kids about the evils that existed and still exists. I sat them down and we watched Schindler's List, the Movie 'Munich' about the 1972 Olympic, and we recently watched a documentary called shtetl that showed just how slowly and sneakily everything happened in the 1920-30's that led to that demon's being placed in power. My entire purpose is to teach my children that this cannot be allowed ever again. And to think THIS is what some kids here want for this country?
Have you show your kids photos the mass graves discovered in gaza last week?.
And how israhell was created, that israhell is using nazi tactics on those innocents children in palestine?, tiny u have a problem : FEARNESS !!!!
I've heard it this way.
The KGB in the 1960s didn't _invent_ the "indigenous Palestinians" and "colonizer Jews" as a front of British & American imperialists. They borrowed from Joseph Goebbels and rewrote it to sound more socialist and sound less national-socialism.
I had to look up shtetl. I found a PBS documentary on RUclips & going to check it out.
As an Apostolic Christian in the UK, ( closest to the Messianic Jews of Iarael ) ; this has been THE most important podcasts of recent days. As well as Douglas Murray's brilliant analysis of the issues.
"The truth shall set you free " as Yeshua said.
Why don’t you just convert to a messianic Jew then.
How interesting and informative this is!
I'm so glad someone more learned than I has pointed out the Soviet backing of the Pan-Arabists.
Today the left say that they hate Israel. They hate America and Britain more.
That was super interesting ❤ a brilliant conversation. Thank you both! I would love to hear more about the "Grand Mufti of Jerusalem" and his relations with the nazi regime and also about how he influenced his nephew- Yasser Arafat, the PLO leader. These are all some very dark details, forgotten by history. I definitely do think that the younger Jewish generation, even Israelis- are not well informed about all the aspects of this conflict. It is not taught in our schools in Israel. Everyone's been trying to talk about peace all the time. Wishful thinking.
I’m an Iranian American Christian and proud Zionist, and I could not agree with you more. I fear that October 7th was just the beginning of what will be very dark times ahead.
These demons have been waging genoc1de on the Jews of Israel for over a century, while their religion has been commanding the genoc1de of all Jews for over 1,400 years now. Our late great Shahanshah Aryamehr had warned Western powers about 1slam, about what would happen if the Red & Black (the unholy union of Marxists and 1slamists) were to ever succeed in taking Iran: Israel would never know peace again, 1slamic terrorism would spread like wildfire worldwide, and the West would inevitably be next. Instead of listening to the Shah’s sage advice, the Western countries chose to betray him and the people of Iran - by funding, arming, and equpping the Red & Black terrorists that took our country hostage in 1979 and have been occupying and plundering it, and waging genoc1de against our people, ever since. And I doubt any Western layperson knows this.
The West betrayed us because they wanted to continue to rob us of our oil, as they had been doing for most of the 20th century, and our Shah refused to let them do it. They sacrificed the people of Iran, the oldest surviving peoples in world history, on the altar of Western greed and hubris, and every warning the Shah gave to those Western countries has proven to be true; we are witnessing them now reap what they’ve been sowing for 45 years, with the Red & Black having infiltrated and taken over their countries. October 7th and the reaction in the West have been nothing short of demonic, but the fact that ALL Iranians are united with Israel and the Jewish people gives me faith that together, we will overcome and triumph over all these demons.
Israel is my only hope for the survival of human civilization, because it still believes and fights for its values - for God, country, family, community - and it hasn’t sold out in the name of profits, as most Western countries did long ago. Americans today worship money and fame almost exclusively, so we shouldn’t be surprised that the USA doesn’t appear in the Bible. But the Lord redeems Iran in the Bible, and makes another throne for Himself in our lands. Today, over 70-80% of Iranians living in Iran are NOT Musl1m, and there are millions of Christians living in Iran again for the first time since before the Arab Musl1m invasions. To me, it feels like the Lord’s already begun to redeem my people, we just have to finish off the demonic regime and bring back our Shah and our 2,500-year long constitutional monarchy 🙏🏽
Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱
Long live Israel & the IDF 🇮🇱
Long live the Shah Reza Pahlavi II 👑
Long live Iran 💚🤍❤️🔥🦁☀️
You might enjoy my interview with Jewish South African historian Na’omi Allen about the Grand Mufti’s alliance with Hitler and his continuing influence in the Palestinian liberation movement today.
ruclips.net/user/live8R9z-qbTf78?si=iHVuj-cdylOXF8NH
Also look up the Zionists' relations with the Nazi regime (Haavara Agreement).
@tomigun5180 yes, let's all look up "interesting" information about how the zionists collaborated with their executionist. Get the 🤬 off
@@tomigun5180 The fact is, nobody has clean hands in the ME - all, at one time or another, have behaved badly - we have to try better, and move on. As millions of displaced people have for all history.
Thank you for this great interview!
Clear, informative and well-reasoned, thank you both.
Very informative show. Excellent guest, thank you n
She makes an excellent point that the education system doesn't require us to think anymore. The only classes I can think of that required me to think rather than memorize anything was logic class and creative writing class. Memorizing a lot of facts and regurgitating them onto a test paper isn't really learning.
Thank you for such a good Interview!!!
Excellent. Trudi is brilliant, I’ll listen again to memorize all that I learned about our history 😂
I absolutely loved this conversation. What a powerful thing to be wise and knowledgeable.
Great interview. Tremendous knowledge. I have always considered myself a liberal who believes in human rights and helping others. I guess that makes me a lefty. Problem is I have been absolutely disgusted with the “useful idiots” of the left. I could easily say, “oh, it’s because they don’t understand history.” But then I hear people like Bernie Sanders and Gabor Mate, who I had great admiration for, prior to Oct. 7th, speaking against Israel and I am stunned. I don’t understand it. It’s like they can’t see the manipulation by Hamas and the jihadist arabs. Can’t they see the planning that went into this? Anyway, I am 100% in support of Israel. I can see clearly what they are facing and when I see my fellow leftists chanting terrorist slogans taught to them by terrorists it makes me sick. Long live the great state of Israel! ❤️🇮🇱🇨🇦❤️
Remember the saying "never attribute to malice what can be to incompetence?" Well if the same people keep erring again and again in the same manner, it's definitely pernicious at that point.
The reason you don't understand it is because your understanding of politics is so shallow that you think "human rights and helping others" equals leftism. You had great admiration for Bernie Sanders? Why? How? He is on record saying that people queuing up for bread for hours and hours and hours is good because it proves equality. He got kicked out of a socialist commune when he was young, for being incredibly lazy. What are Bernie Sanders' actual virtues?
So many are deceived by Hamas and supporters.
Hi so here is you are fundamentally wrong as the ideas of "human rights" and "helping others" are not liberal or left. The idea of value of the individual and their rights are from the right (individualism) and idea of helping others (charity or being in service of others) are Christian values. Left = collectivism which is the complete anathema of individual rights as individuals are only supported as long as they serve the collective (in the case of todays left/ liberals only as long as you further the ideology). As has been found time and time again the biggest givers to charity is "conservatives" and the most active people in community services is "Christians". Liberals just think saying they care, and posting BLM or whatever the latest thing is = empathy and caring, but its normally all just to satisfy their own desire to "feel' moral..
I'm in the same boat. I agree with every word you've written in the/your OC (Opening Comment).
Thank you both
Very well done! Thank you for that wonderful presentation!
Remarkable interview so knowledgeable and moving at the same time !
God Bless Israel and God Bless the Jewish people 🇮🇱🙏
That is why the main support for Israel right now is the conservative Christian’s. The reason we are still standing and haven’t bowed to society is because we believe the Bible to be 100% the infallible word of God. So when the Bible says the land belongs to Israel and the Jewish people we believe it. When the Bible tells us to bless Israel and the Jewish people we believe it. As a Gentile I know I am to honor and love the Jewish people.
There are many of us who love you! ❤️🇮🇱🙏✝️
Much love ❤❤❤❤
I totally agree with you! ❤️
You poor thing. I'm Christian and Bible believing. You're deluded.
They are friends to the Jews, *for now* you must remember that they want all the Jews herded into Israel and then for them to all die, for SomeDamnReasonOrAnother(tm) they are not friends, just convenient for now.
Yes but there is more. The Palestinians, never owned Judea. They came from Syria and Egypt and other Arab countries and settled in Israel between 1890 and 1940 and then claimed this land as their land. The word Palestine comes from the Roman word Philistine. The Philistines were Greeks that lived along the coast of Gaza. Romans called Judea, Philistine to punish them, Palestinians never existed , they have no language, history or culture.
"We have forgotten that we have not come to an empty land to inherit it, but we have come to conquer a country from people inhabiting it.” ~ Moshe Sharett, 1914, (Benny Morris, Righteous Victims, p.91)
What a lovely lady! It’s a pleasure to hear her talk.
Listening to this was like sitting down to a conversation with my Aunt Natalie
Is that a good thing? 😂
@@JTVGlobalJewishChannel most certainly it is if only it could be
A very thoughtful and interesting interview: I learnt a lot. Thanks, Ollie.
Glad you enjoyed it!
A wonderful knowledgeable lady . Thank you. Standing with Israel from Scotland. 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇬🇧
Thomas Sowell when asked how to end anti-semitism by Jews, said “Fail” …. success , particularly by an oppressed people, precipitates jealous and envy. So, fail if you want the bias to go away - obviously insane but hatred is insane
Amazing interview’👍
This has been very interesting, profitable, and informative. Thank you to both of you for sharing from your hearts.
My ex mother in law used to say “Morta christo” to describe Jews. She was Italian American. I had never heard of this before. I was raised agnostic. It was blatantly dishonest and a lack of historical interest in my opinion. I have never understood antisemitism but I can see it happening.
My mum was Irish raised as a catholic, she raised me to be agnostic she hated all forms of religion she always said religion has done more to foster multi generational hatred than any nation. But I believe that being Jewish for the Jewish peoples subsumes all other cultural identity it’s about being Jewish first then national identity. And as an agnostic it seems to me that I do not know of any Jewish person who tries to convert others to their faith. One wonders when we as species are finally just going to live together in harmony. I personally believe that what people hate about the Jewish populace is their ability to thrive in spite of hardship.
An amazing and eye-opening interview! Thank you J-TV for putting this together.
Just a brilliant interview ! thank you so much .
Thank You. God bless You. We need to receive the Love and Life that Jesus brought "to the Jew first and also to the Gentile". Salvation is God's Mercy for all. Ignorance and lies are the enemy. We have been the victims and victimizers too long. The Scriptures are Truth for 4000 years. Love, Truth, and Faith have not changed. The Miracle of our Humanity is that we can change. Each one of us is Forgiven and we can forgive. I believe that is our destiny. Keep strong in your good work. Thank you both.
I wish I could talk to my liberal children as eloquently as you.
Thanks.
Good to know your children aren't fascists.
This interview needs to be shared with the larger academic community. Brilliant, thoughtful and generative.
What a great explanation. I’m not Jewish, but I think it’s vital to understand where this craven hatred comes from. Thank you very much.
Wow. She’s a captivating teacher thx I learned so much.
Excellent presentation! Thank you! God bless Israel and the Jewish people! 🇮🇱💕🇱🇷
Excellent whitewashing you mean. It's what she doesn't say that is most important.
Don’t conflate your demonic state with the Jewish people
@@SydBaron Which is?
@@SydBaron I think she has covered the subject from many aspects. What do you think she doesn't say?
@@fotter9567 That they are committing a planned genocide.
Jews all over the world are now uneasy. In my 73 years in earth, I have never seen this.
amazing
This is a superb interview. Thank you
Wow. Really badass job of wrapping up so much history in an hour! 👍
Excellent, right on point; congratulations and thank you!
We are in an era where it is possible to prove your origins. Most of the palastinians come from nearby states. Why cant they go back there?
Those other middle eastern countries won't let them in because they say they won't abide by their laws. This not hearsay. I watched Egyptian & Saudis on RUclips voicing that. Jordon stands up for them like the Queen speaks against Israel, but she won't let them in. What does that tell you?
Because they have an objective. The Jews
@@rosykatzCATS
It tells you a lot. Nobody wants them because they are trouble.
What a racist comment. The Palestinians have not appeared from nowhere, they have ancient roots in the area known as Palestine. The unceasing attempts to deny them their identity, historic land rights and their very humanity are morally repulsive.
I don't know the full backstory but the Arabs we call Palestinian today were part of tribes expelled for their homelands. A Lebanese colleague told me they were "the gypsies of the Arab world". He went on to say the only reason the Arab world cared about them was because it suited their anti-Israel propaganda but under no means do they want Palestinians returning to their ancestral homelands.
I learn alot tonight thanks
This is a brilliant interview.
Brilliant!!
She is amazing! Thank you for this brilliant analysis. I think I’ll listen to it again in order to absorb all the information presented in this interview.
Thank you for this. Finally a voice of reason.
As an Indian origin Hindu, I can relate to Jews ✡️ cause as we have suffered almost the same way as you at the hands of a common enemy. We have survived, and you have survived, whereas many civilisations have been perished over the centuries. Perhaps we could help each other to keep humanity alive along with our civilisation.
The Savior of all humanity including the Jews is Christ.
She is incredible; so intelligent! The ideologists are a dangerous bunch, for sure. We do not think anymore. Am Yisrael Chai!
What a fascinating interview. Thank you.
Absolutely amazing talk - Trudy is captivating, what a great mind! Thank you for this, so valuable.
Thanks for a very interesting realistic conversation.
Thank you for this
My pleasure!
She us so full of knowledge
How do you know? You just automatically accept? Do you believe without researching yourself? Do you believe everything you see and hear? Did you take the 💉because you trusted the deceivers unknowingly?Trust only God know your BIBLE OT & NT. Bible prophecy unfolding fast 🙏
😮Brilliant informative summation. Thank you. I’m a 31 year veteran of the FBI, African American, who grew up literally in the Jewish households of people like Dore Schary and Norton Simon where my parents were domestic workers, my wife is Jewish, my only living family are Jews, and I am a strong supporter of Israel, particularly now. Having said all that, I struggle to understand why so many Jews (e.g., the Rosenbergs) were complicit in delivering the secrets of the A bomb to Russia given Russia’s historic oppression of Jews. Can someone help with that?
As a Christian I love and admire you guys and I certainly didn't pick up any antisemitism in my past from my family or culture. After all, Jesus, as well as the writers of the gospels and all the first Christians, were Jews, and so were Paul and the apostles. As Paul wrote: I'm a Jew among Jews. I'm deeply embarrassed by the stories of Jew-hatred of Christians in the past. Actually I was wondering if there wasn't a way for me to reach out to Jews in the area where I live.
Love this lady 🤍
Far and away the best pod on television
He’s a great, great dude and I’m so happy I found this channel 🫶🏽
Trudy Gold is Truly Gold.
Thank you, Ollie, for this interview. May I please offer just a side note? At several points in this program, you, Ollie, interrupted Trudy, just when she is about to make a point. I understand your enthusiasm for the speaker and the discussion, which I thoroughly share. But Trudy is of such highest caliber that EVERY word that comes out of her is a gem. So whatever additional (or continuation of a) point she is about to make, it is NEVER incidental, marginal or unimportant. Quite the contrary. This is why I wished I could have heard EVERY word that she would utter, both because of the clarity of her diction and the significance of her point. I'm sure this would not apply to every single person you interview, but Trudy deserves a full hearing, i.e. DOWN TO THE LAST WORD. Again, thanks to both of you for this beautiful program.
Excellent thank you ❤❤❤
Brilliant
Brilliant! This needs to be heard everywhere.
One thing I would like to hear more from Trudi is how unusual it is in history for a group to maintain their culture and religion despite being dispersed among suspicious and often hostile populations?
I can only think of the Gypsies in Europe, but they could self segregate on account of their travelling lifestyle. In Muslim and Christian cities there was official segregation but not in the countryside, where you would have thought it would have been easier to convert and integrate, especially over the millennia.
Jews were not allowed to own land, so no place in the countryside. One of the reason being their religion forbids selling land to gentiles.
You are assuming they kept their culture and religion. That's not really true, they usually adopt other people's culture and their religion adapts as well and there are different strands that pop up everywhere, like Christianity and Islam. It's really just that they keep the connection and the name, but what they do is quite different than the people that lived in Palestine 2000 years ago, let's say. The Hellenes were doing colonies in hostile territory, so did the Romans. Just about everybody does it. The Jews simply have a better memory because their faith and story is written in a book, and anybody can read it and want to relate to it, so the book converts people and make them think they are the same or come from the people in the book. So I guess that part is unique.
One of the best interviews I have seen since 7.10. Trudy is a wonderful well of knowledge. Thank you Ollie ❤
Glad you enjoyed it! We'll keep bringing Trudy on!
One thing that people haven't truly understood was how the Bolsheviks were against Jews. As a matter of fact one graffiti used around their time of things in Russia had it written out how they were against a politician who they thought was a Jew but glorifying Trotsky who they thought wasn't.
Trosky was a pure Jew that saved the Russian Revolution with Jew money from New York. He didn’t want to be Lenin successor bc he was afraid of that rejection .,.. how sad
Dude, the Russians have been persecuting the Jewish people for CENTURIES! Pale of Settlement anyone? How about The Protocols of the Elders of Zion?? That is ALL Russia, and long before the Soviet Union or Stalin came around.
I’m surprised that there are any Jews left in Russia. I would hate Russia would every fiber of my being if I was Jewish 🤷🏽♀️
Are you serious? I’ve heard the numbers of Bolshevik Jews around about 80 to 83 percent hardly a minority. Also, though Hitler took a deal with the Rothschilds to send Jews to Palestine. Yeah that’s right trains went to Palestine, it’s called the Havaraa agreement are the transfer agreement.
Bolshevik’s were dominated by Jews according to Alexander Solzhenitsyn among others
Because the Bolsheviks were not against Jews and made antisemitism illegal
I know. I am left wing myself, and am very unhappy about hostility towards Israel. It is usually people who leave the Labour Party and come out in their true colours.
The Leftists Democrats here in the US are biting from the same stick, and it's do disheartening.
American Jew here. I've thought of myself as a leftie all my life. It makes me feel a little bit schizophrenic . . . .
@@brynawaldman5790 Stay with the faith. The true left wing thinking is the correct way, to my mind. True left wingers understand the influences. Hopefully some of those who have strayed will come back to us, as mended people.
I was left but the left left me....
@@peace-nowFWIW, yt just accused me of **t* speech & said they may block me for a few days.