Dumbledore SHOULDN'T have been in Gryffindor!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2024
- T-SHIRTS WEBSITE: driftwoodappar...
SEAMUS T-SHIRT: driftwoodappar...
TWEET ME QUESTIONS AT #ASKSAMMUS / 875397614149218305
So, what do you think? Is Gryffindor really the best house for Dumbledore? Would there be less house "racism" if Dumbledore hadn't been in Gryffindor? Let me know in the comments section down below!!
NEW VIDEO COMING ON MONDAY!! (maybe i'll actually start uploading on time...)
I hope you enjoyed this video! If you did make sure to hit that like button!
THANKS FOR WATCHING!!
SUBSCRIBE!!
YouNow - www.younow.com...
Twitter - / gormanseamus
Instagram - / seamusgorman4
Snapchat - seamusgorman4
For Business Enquires: seamusgormanbusiness@gmail.com
#harrypotter
Gryffindor: Dumbledore
Hufflepuff: Dumblepuffe
Ravenclaw: Dumbleclawe
Slytherin: Dumblerine
Makes sense...
omg😂
9nikolai omg yeah 100% true
9nikolai I
9nikolai Ha ha 😂 lol
Oh totally makes sense!😂😂
With Hermione in Ravenclaw, Harry would've died at his first quidditch match - that would make the books a whole lot shorter....
I personally believe she is definitely a Gryffindor. Yes she highly values knowledge and intelligence but I feel that her actions tend to be more brave than wise at times. She takes risks rather than the 'smart' decision for the sake of good.
I think hermione is a gryfimdor. Also I just made a new video on what would happen if Voldemort fell through the veil before his horcruxes were destroyed, mind checking it out?
N.weaver but Hermione wouldn't be in the bathroom if it weren't for Ron
OMG ur totally right
bailal1 Maybe without meeting Hermione, Harry and Ron would've met another Gryffindor who they could be close to. Also it's not like you can't be friends with people from other houses.
You do know that merlin,the person every wizard looks up to,was a SLYTHERYN!?!?!!
Danger Doughnut yes I did. People! Not every Slytherin is bad!
No, Merlin wasn't in Slytheryn. He was in SlytherIn. With an I ;)
Sarah Stevens no one has made that claim since 2005
SOYUZ NEROSHIMI!
I already know
“Forget about Drarry,
Forget about Dramionie,
Forget about Drapple,
Actually no, don’t forget about Drapple”
Drapple is the best 🍏👦🏼🍏👦🏼🍏👦🏼
Drapple should be canon
Forget about them all except for Drapple.
Drapple is the best ship to ever set sail.
YESS!!!
While JK Rowling is a brilliant author one flaw I found was that she basically put all the "good" characters in gryffindor regardless of their character traits which always bugged me
I assume that she put Hermione (Ravenclaw), Ron (Hufflepuff), Harry (Slytherin, but I truly believe he’s from griffindor) to represent the houses and if they weren’t all together, I don’t really know if they would be great friends or fight through things together. ( I cant really explain it, so apologies for my terrible explanation ) but yeah.
Uhhh you forgot tonks and hagrid and Luna and Cedric and shape and albus potter and Scottish and so many more
Scottish?
a g i àgree
I know. Thank Cedric!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
racism..
you mean..
HOUSISM?
lol
Very true
@WinterEclipse #EndHousism
Tribalism maybe? Housism sounds off to me
"Books! And cleverness! There are *more* important things- friendship and *bravery*"
THIS is why Hermione does not fit Ravenclaw. She values bravery *over* books. Had to say that! I agree Dumbledore should be Ravenclaw.
Fee Müller correct your speech marks.
Azure Griffin I'm sorry, I'm from Germany 🙈 English isn't my mother tongue.
Fee Müller Germand don't have different rules for speech marks, do they? I hope not, because that would be so annoying to learn (I study German). Or did you just mean you lost track?
Azure Griffin Aaah I should have checked the word speech mark in stead of relying on my personal translation(I figured you mean grammar misstakes or something like that... I only know the word quotation mark for these marks :D) I corrected it now.
Amen
Seamus: is it RE-mus or RAY-mus
Me:RE-mus obviously. Wait RAY-mus. RE-mus. RAY-mus. STOP PUTTING IDEAS IN MY HEAD SEAMUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RE-MUS. It's how it's pronounced in the movies. And it's how I pronounce it in my head.
Is it Seamus or Saymus? 🤔
@Sammie Games Obviously Shee-mus
Sea-mus? Or Sha-mes? Who knows. Dont you dare @ me!!
Bridget Marie
Lol, now we should call Seamus: see-mus! LMAO
I should be asleep but Seamus is more important
same.
Ayeshkream 101 true
Ayeshkream 101 where are you? Where I am it's only 10:45! And that's really early!
It's 11:46, but I'm a child, and I like to sleep.
Ayeshkream 101 the same for me👌🏻🙈😂
You're a Hufflepuff AND you hate the Cursed Child? Seamus my friend you have yourself a new subscriber.
And you have a like for disliking the cursed child, although I'm ravenclaw
I hate the cursed child. It was like the biggest disappointment of my life.
Funny Cupcake tell them they are a good person.
Dita Roses Ravenclaw is my second favorite house so you get a like for that!
Liz W It was up there for me, though I didn't get my hopes very high so it wasn't all that disappointing. Only good thing that came out of it imo was Scorpious Malfoy, love that kid.
I’m a ravenclaw we are sooooooo unrecognized. U want proof people get our MASCOT wrong it’s a EAGLE NOT a RAVEN!!!!!
And for the people out there who think it’s a raven I think this is your mind right now: 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
Yes! Omg Ravenclaws for the win
Supercarlinbrothers made a video on this
Eagle is a symbol of Presitige. Raven also mean glossy black color. Maybe a long time ago the fist Ravenclaw name himself after his Eagle pet with glossy black claws.
As I'm also a ravenclaw I agree
I'm a Ravenclaw and I agree that Dumbledore should be in my house. He's wise,talented,intelligent,and I have to say unique. He's a perfect match.
Sure, but the sorting hat doesn't know that.. younger Dumbledore is pretty much a straight up Slitherin.
Not only Ravenclaws can be talented and wise, as not all brave are in Gryffindor. There are reasons why for example Hermione was placed in Gryffindor and the same with Dumbledore. Sorry but why do people want to have gryffindor characters when they have own like Ravenclaw has Luna and Slytherin has Snape. Do not get that.
yeah and we really need something to boost our credit right now we have maybe three characters going for us one Luna to flitwick and the biggest one we've got is three ollivander come on we need Dumbledore
But you're forgetting what makes a Ravenclaw a Ravenclaw. Or *at least I think.* Ravenclaws like *us* are outside-the-box thinkers, it's what makes Ravenclaws smart. Please. *This is just my opinion.*
Well he was not put there, He obviously had more Gryffindor in him because he was placed there. As same as Snape was put in Slytherin even if he was brave but that was not his main trait. I have some Ravenclaw traits but I would choose bravery in the end like Hermione was chosen bravery over books in the end. So the houses are not black and white (if you get my point)
The real question brought up after this video- “is Dumbledore a good guy?”
Nope.
Yes Dumbledore did things not because he wanted to but if he did not things would not have gone as they did in the harry potter movies he had to make decisions no one wanted to make but had to
@@eharper7 Yes, he is. Probably the most tragic character next to snape too.
Short answer: Yes.
Long answer: Absolutely yes.
"Forget about Drarry! Forget about Dramione! Forget about Drapple! wait no no no don't forget about Drapple... WE ARE THE DUMBLECLAW FAMDOM!!!"
Miluna what the hell is drapple
draco apple
I am friggin in
I read this while he said that XD
Housism needs to stop. Hufflepuffs aren't weak or stupid, Slytherins aren't evil, Ravenclaws are way underrated, and Gryffindors aren't the best house. Okay but Dumbledore would be a great Ravenclaw. By the way, I am in no way saying that there is a "best house". They all have good and bad attributes and that's okay.
Ally housism does need to stop, but also, we need to stop this entire "Gryffindors think they are the best and are all jocks and A*sholes. because while you say that we think that, then the rest of the houses turn around and bash us. Gryffindors are also human, and we aren't all bad.
I do agree with that. we aren't the best house. we all have our good and our bad qualities. heven knows I can be a brainless idiot rushing into situations I have no clue how to get out of.
Ally #StopHouseShaming
YA i am all of the houses i was watching another vid i saw this notifacation i was like YAS SEAMUS UPLODED YEEEESSSS I LOVE VIDS BY SEAMUS HE SO COOL EEEEEEEKKKKKKK exept ishould be alsleep soi didnt scream
Ally Yeah he would I feel like he was more Ravenclaw than Gryffindor
Hermione in Ravenclaw:
Harry falls of his broom.
No more books.
remember that Dumbledore was over the age of 100 when he died. With years of experience, he is likely to be wise at that age. However he was 11 when he was first sorted in to griffindor. With over 90 years after that, it's likely that he would've changed. He may have suited griffindor when he was sorted.
Xyrryl That is an awesome theory I agree with you.
tru tru
Actually he was 80+/90- years old
Rumple 7 actually he was 114 when he died. His canon birth year is 1881. So he would’ve been 100 when the first wizarding war ended
Merlin was in Slytherin, whoops.
Oh wow Yeah I like this.
Which doesn't make sense, as Hogwarts wasn't created at Merlin's time. Whoops.
Gwen von Blottnitz actually it does make sense. Merlin’s birth was in 982 and Hogwarts was founded and opened in 993. Which would make Merlin 11 years of age when Hogwarts opened. He was sorted into Slytherin by Salazar himself and was one of the very first Slytherins. Yet he’s wasn’t like the stereotypical Slytherin due to his hatred for the mistreatment of muggles and or muggle born magical peoples.
How you know that
Also
Hogwarts
Wasn't
Built!!!
They are making a series about Newt they should make one about Mr.Ollivander(A Ravenclaw) which would also allow us to learn even more about wands.
Yeah and maybe a founder movie or something for Slytherin (even though i'm a Ravenclaw, a Slytherin movie would be cool)
[insert text here] Productions for a Slytherin series you could have a backstory of Voldemort....
I know it just puts a bad picture on Slytherin oh well....
Shaykh MHSSI Yeeeesssss
Wands are made of the essence of fantastic beasts
sorry guys i cant drive, im under the influence.
“of what?”
*CHILD FRIENDLY CONTENT.*
Slytherin isn’t a bad house! We’re cunning, which is a seriously useful trait, and Merlin himself was in Slytherin! Then again, I’m a Slytherin, so I might be a little biased
Sophia Rahim Slytherin’s not evil
Markseptiphanpie We aren’t. I hate it when people think Slytherin = Evil
I personally think that Slytherin is evil during the reign of Voldemort, so from 1960 to 1997, during this time, Slytherin was like cursed by Voldemort and a lot of wizards are Deatheaters or sympathisants to the Deatheaters. But the House SLytherin was not evil during a lot of time, and are not anymore, it's just Voldemort ^^
People think I’m a huffleuff when I’m really a Slytherin.
totally agree. Slytherin = cunning, resourceful and ambitious. i very much believe that a Slytherin could have the traits of any other house, but so long as they have this great ambition which utilises those traits, they will always end up in Slytherin
"Child friendly" lol you set a great example, Seamus
0:18
Omg I see you all of the time in Seamus' Comments
Elsie Hannay lol I get that a lot
LOL! I know, I spat out what I was drinking at the moment.
Forget drarry
Forget dramionie
Forget drapple
Actually don't forget drapple
6:28 after he said that I realized in how many ships Draco is in
The most powerful wizard of all time was Merlin, who was in Slytherin :)
ilia zamanabadi :) yes slytherin pride
ilia zamanabadi SLYTHERIN!!!
ilia zamanabadi yass
Merlin's beard...
ilia zamanabadi I thought hogwarts was build after Merlin...
DRAPPLE IS MY OTP🙎🏼♂️🍏
Tori Wood... Dramione, just Dramione. The actors even liked each other during the filming of the series. How could you not ship them.
Paris *Heart emoji* because RON + HERMIONE IS OTP
Paris *Heart emoji* I think Tom Felton (that's Draco's actor, right?) has/had a crush on most of the cast
Paris *Heart emoji* i dont ship dramione (just a lil bit) but i DO ship feltson (tom felton+emma watson) 😍
I ship both 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
When you watch this in 4 in the morning
exactly me right now.
Malva Malfoy same
Malva Malfoy 2*
I'm watching it at 5 in the morning 🤗🤗! Also I just made a new video on what would happen if Voldemort fell through the veil before his horcruxes were destroyed, mind checking it out?
;)
Seamus:AVADA KEDAVRA
Me:WHY
Seamus:I have changed my name to Tom marvolo riddle
Me:Wait then shouldn’t be Voldemort
Seamus:No I’m not that ugly
he has a nose 😂
Cool
"And you wonder why I don't like Draco"
I mean, the only reason he's a bad person is because he was raised to believe these things. Lucius and Narcissa are terrible people and they influenced him. Draco didn't want to be a death eater, he was forced into wanting to. And he didn't want to kill Dumbledore. In the end he didn't but still. Im actually proud to say that Draco is my favorite character.
This has nothing to do with my biased opinion because I am in fact a Slytherin.
Paris *Heart emoji* I'm a Slytherin too and people always think I'm evil because my favorite character is Bellatrix and are all like "She's not a good character. She's the bad guy" but I never said she was the good guy, I said she was my facorite character. Plus I'm not evil because I'm a Slytherin, I'm evil because it's easy to manipulate people with charm, charisma and big vocabulary.
Emily Jackson EXACTLY Bellatrix would be my 3rd. 2nd being Severus Snape.
Paris *Heart emoji* Narcissa is hardly evil like she told Voldemort Harry was dead when he wasn't and therefore saved him
Emily Childs she isn't completely evil. She has her bad days. Lol but Lucius did have a big influence on Draco.
#S.S.Leather&Libraries
Look it up
the most powerful wizard of all time, was Merlin. Who was in Slytherin.
Merlin have been not sorted into slytherin but he created it becouse he is one of the four founders of hogwarts
Mohammed Al Garaawi What on earth are you talking about? Salazar Slytherin was the one who created Slytherin. Not Merlin
Pls, we.have no proof of Merlin being any more powerful than Dumbledore
Choices matter...except when they don't. Neville asked to be put in Hufflepuff because he didn't think could handle being in Gryffindoor. Hat ignored him.
And generally agree that there's a lot of characters who probably shouldn't have been in Gryffindoor but were because they needed more scenes with Harry or some sort of connection to him.
I think Dumbledore is a Ravenclaw. Loyalty isn't a strong suite for a guy who raises and mentors a kid just so he can die at the proper moment. His most defining characteristic is his cleverness and foresight. Loyalty not so much.
Maybe the Sorting Hat could sense Neville's true traits. People can believe they're less than what they really are after all! And it was proven that Neville was much braver than he believed. It just needed to be coaxed out of him. So maybe the Hat just decided to put Neville into Gryffindor based on that since Neville's request was based on anxiety and self-criticism and not what he REALLY wanted.
Probably because Neville wanted to go into another house because he thought he wasn't worthy of the one he really wanted when that obviously wasn't true, and Harry wanted to avoid Slytherin because he didn't want to be associated with its students and didn't want to be looked at as someone who was doomed to be evil. It's actually pretty fun to think about stuff like this!
Surely if he was able to see all of that in Neville he'd have been able to see that Peter Pettigrew was literally the antithesis of a Gryffindoor and ignored his choice too.
Sorting hat isn't all that consistent. Which is fine. Nowhere in the lore does it suggest that the sorting hat is infallible, so it's not really a problem for the story.
Well, the Sorting Hat DOES call Harry "difficult to place" so maybe that implies that it does make mistakes in who it places where.
Pettigrew was an undeniable mistake. Others are debatable, but that one's not. Placing a character who's defining feature was cowardice and opportunism in the bravery house.
I fully agree! Dumbledore should have went into Ravenclaw.
#DumbleClaw
Merlin's slytherin
Thank you! Idk how many times I have had to say that. Another interesting fact: Colin Morgan who portrayed Merlin in the TV show Merlin was sorted into SLYTHERIN.
LokiLover35 Alan Rickman was in Slytherin too, which made my fan girl heart happy.
+Abhay Prabhakar Bullshit.
Karl Smith emmm no its not... its says on pottermore
+ExpectoPatrnumEoin Pottermore was created by Slytherin fans. If anything, Merlin was a Ravenclaw or a Hufflepuff since he was too much of a good guy to be in Evil Snake house.
Ok all the fake fans have left it’s just us loyal ones now
Soffia The Ravenclaw haha my name is Sophia and I’m a ravenclaw
#Dumbleclaw Yes. Dumbledore needs to be in my house, in #Ravenclaw. Excellent idea.
agree i am a ravenclaw to
ItsBryony I so agree
I'm a Ravenclaw so people think I'm a walking talking dictionary
ItsBryony
I think he should be in Ravenclaw or Slytherin.
Maybe Dumbledore didn’t become wise and all that until he was like 150 🤷🏽♀️
Tbh young dumbledore was hardcore slytherin imo
He died when he was 115 so-
He was a child when he was sorted, he might have had different values when he was a child.
Samantha Dragon that is true! Also I just made a new video on what would happen if Voldemort fell through the veil before his horcruxes were destroyed, mind checking it out?
True
Thats not how the Sorting Hat works...
Samantha Dragon c
99 likes
Harry potter is for gryffindor. Cursed child is for slytherin.
Fantastic beasts is for huddle puff
We NEED one for ravenclaw
Fantastic Beasts doesn’t count imo, because even though Newt is from Hufflepuff, he isn’t in the hogwarts anymore
I'M A SLYTHERIN AND I'M PROUD OF IT!!!! 💚💚
Oh and Seamus it's REE-MUS. You're welcome. 😏😉
Karen the Bear #StopSlytherinShaming
🐍 Hiss Hiss 🐍
Karen the Bear I'm a Hufflepuf and I agree! My sister is in Slytherin and she's not evil. (btw its you're)
Karen the Bear slythehrin Pride! 🐍🐍hiss hissy hiss
*you're
Karen the Bear Gryffindor all the way ❤ let's have a duel -----💨
I love Tom Holland and him saying something like that literally just breaks my heart
Arina
Him saying that shows he is a hufflepuff
0:18 Yeah I mean, who DOESN'T question the purposes of life while in the middle of watching a Disney movie?!
Surely I can't be the only one!
That ending would have been way better!
Bumble Bee lol
Bumble Bee 🐝 l
Bumble Bee yeah ikr! Also I just made a new video on what would happen if Voldemort fell through the veil before his horcruxes were destroyed, mind checking it out?
How did he sacrifice himself ? He was already dying. He was already doomed, it's not like he accepted death at his prime time in order to save the world.
Dumbledore wasn't the bravest person, at several times he ran from battle if he could (mostly showed in his youth, with his family, sister, Grindelwald...). Even if he did have to face them in the end, he still always tried to run at first.
As a Gryffindor though, I think he fits the whole "daring and nerve" part as he went to the end of things, he didn't pretend nor changed his opinions. If he believed in something, he went with it until the end.
But Ravenclaw fits him so much more. Creativity, wisdom, intelligence, wit, originality, individuality, acceptance... ? Come on, they all *perfectly* fits Dumbledore !
And most of his advices or the things that he valued could be put in either Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff, not Gryffindor. He does value courage, but that's one thing. Friends, family, love, loyalty, being who you are, not being afraid of who you are, finding yourself, using your brains, being witty... they're not the values of Gryffindor.
I agree!"
I think it’s pronounced “Ree-mus”
Dumbledore's DEFINITELY a Slytherin!!! I mean... his ambition... his thirst for power at his teens... OMG everything!!
lol. Slytherin problems: everyone hates us
NEVEAH MOROFSKY my mom says she's a Gryffindor. she bought me a Gryffindor shirt to annoy me. I gave that shirt to my friend.
I don't, and I'm Ravenclaw(although I am a bit of Slytherin as well;)).
Cece Lian :( at school I get bullied for being a slythehrin :.(
ikr?! people really need to stop these stereotypes shit.
Ma'dam jade
Seriously?!
Dumbledore is a Slytherin. point. blank. period. I'm Ravenclaw. And I think Magonagal (sp) should have been Ravenclaw
Well, she almost go into Ravenclaw, the Sorting Hat hesitates almost five minutes before put her in Gryffindor. And the same with Flitwick, the Sorting Hat hesitates between Ravenclaw and Gryffindor and finally put him in Ravenclaw ^^
Right! He was obviously a very ambitious young wizard
McGonagall**
Oh, shut up
i am also a rewenclaw
Dumbledore *died* to save the Wizarding World.
*_Obviously a Scared little Bowtruckle that is in no way Brave, no no-sir-ee nada_*
yeah, but at 11 years old, he must have been a Ravenclaw. Or even a Slytherin
I 100% think that Dumbledore is a Slytherin. Literally everything we learn about him in Deathly Hallows indicates this. I personally have never liked Dumbledore very much, and I feel like harry has a bit of a blind spot towards him, because I think Dumbledore makes a lot of mistakes throughout the series that everyone just forgives him for.
Gillian Gottlieb hmmm.. maybe but he’s not overly cunning or prideful. I lean way to Ravenclaw
@@Jackylification Prideful is more of a Griffendore trait. I think he should have been Slytherin, he did everything to achieve his goal, to kill Voldemort, he in a way used Snape's love for Lilly and regret for her death for a spy. Observed everyone to know near exactly what they would do to achieve and or fit into his plan, achieve his goal, and even as a young man with his and Grindelwald's phrase "for the greater good" and many more I don't feel like typing (I'm lazy, deal) Don't get me wrong I love Dumbledore but I believe he makes a perfect Slytherin and would have given them a much better wrap. They're not evil just cunning, ambitious, will do anything to achieve their own goals.
Gillian Gottlieb also it would pretty much destroy the housism (yes i just said that) against Slytherin
Thank you! I think the real villain of Harry Potter is Dumbledore. He knowingly let 3 (probably more) children go back to horrible home life conditions. I dont know about most people but if I was a teacher who saw how tom riddle Jr was treated id at least try to help. And Snape and Harrys abuse was worse. Dumbledore could have prevented everything just by helping a kid who was mistreated. Thats why Albus Dumbledore is my least favorite character from Harry Potter.
destiny Haas first of all Dumbledore had Harry go back to the Dursley’s because that was the only place he was safe at until he came of age and yes Tom Riddle did grow up in an orphanage but it was not that horrible of a childhood and it is never revealed if Dumbledore knows how Snapes home life is like.
Dumbledore wasn't orringinally wise, he was young and foolish back then, he only was wise after many years of life
Slytherin would have suited him way better
But he was sorted too soon
Angus Heays every one becomes wiser with experience
True - but he never gives Harry direct answers or explainations and instead gives him hints and leaves him to figure things out on his own. Sound familiar? - Ravenclaw common room riddles?
I mean seriously . "Nitwit blubber oddment tweak"?? The guys HAS to be in ravenclaw for God's sake
As a slytherin i might be bias towards my house, but I really like the idea of Dumbledore being a slytherin!🐍🐍🐍
10000% agree! Dumbledore shudda been in Ravenclaw! #dumbleclaw XD but the whole Slytherin thing would have been cool too
It would've been cool to see someone so good and cool and brave as dumbledore come from slytherin
charley15z loool good point XD
you can be a Slytherin and refuse some power/positions. btw he was very ambitious younger. Like if you are comfortable or think that you can do more being the headmaster and is going to help in your future plans... you stay there.
Did you just make a whole video that's just a buildup for a way to get rid of the cursed child? I like the way you think
YouNow - Slytherin
Twitter - Ravenclaw
Instagram - Gryffindor
Snapchat - Hufflepuff
Go on... follow him according to your house
I followed him on Twitter right before I read this. You must be psychic.
same here
snapchat
But... I don't have nor want a snapchat...
snapchat
They should give more attention to us Ravenclaws!
I mean I'm a proud Ravenclaw and yet we're just the smart people in Blue in the background! Like if ur a Ravenclaw!
Shula Natan ravenclaws for life! 😂😂
Shula Natan RAVENCLAW FAM
Shula Natan Goooo Ravenclaw!!!!!!
Boi more than half the fandom are ravenclaws
Eunice ;3 Actually more than half of the fandom is Slytherin. Ravenclaw has the least percent of people in it. In order is Slytherin, Hufflepuff, Gryffindor, Ravenclaw.
Yes, Dumbledore is smart, but he is also ambitious, cunning, manipulative and he can be cruel. He is a Slytherin in my book! He wanted to prove he is better than his muggle killing father rotting in Azkaban. When he couldn't go on his adventures with his best friend after graduating, he befriended Grindelwald and started looking for the Deathly Hallows. He even sacrificed his sister for it. Not to mention that despite the tragedy he achieve several top jobs in the Medical community, and owns the Elder Wand sfter defeeting Grindelwald. The only reason he never became the minister is becouse he wanted to stay at Hogwarts, to manipulate Harry later on. He also took advantage of Snap as well, using him to further his own cause to defeat Voldemort. Yes, he is smart, but so is Tom Riddle. Dumbledore orchestrated a child's death since he was over a year old.
"So the boy… the boy must die?" asked Snape quite calmly.
"And Voldemort himself must do it, Severus. That is essential."
Another long silence. Then Snape said, "I thought… all these years… that we were protecting him for her. For Lily."
"We have protected him because it has been essential to teach him, to raise him, to let him try his strength," said Dumbledore, his eyes still tight shut. "Meanwhile, the connection between them grows ever stronger, a parasitic growth: Sometimes I have thought he suspects it himself. If I know him, he will have arranged matters so that when he sets out to meet his death, it will truly mean the end of Voldemort."
Dumbledore opened his eyes. Snape looked horrified.
"You have kept him alive so that he can die at the right moment?... You have used me… I have spied for you and lied for you, put myself in mortal danger for you. Everything was supposed to keep Lily Potter's son safe. Now you tell me you have been raising him like a pig for slaughter…" (33.182-185)
oOoRiellaoOo he didn’t sacrifice Ariana
No, he didn't became Minister because he knew that he shouldn't have power, peoples asking him to became Minister before Harry was born, maybe even before James and Lily was born XD
But I agree on all the rest, yes Dumbledore will make a perfect Slytherin. Like Harry is sometimes Slytherin ^^
He did sacrifice Ariana, Olive Tree. He didn't want his death, but he abandon her when she needs care, he said itself in the seventh book. I'm sorry, but doesn't care of a disabled child is sacrifice this child ^^'
Krankar Volund,
AGREED.
Amen.
That’s totally what J.K Rowling was implying! Totally..
I am a Hufflepuff, my mum is a Griffindor, my dads a muggle, and my friend is slitherin, and the rest of the "average Potter fans" are in Griffindor…the betrayals
I know what a muggle is, but what do you mean here exactly? That he doesn’t like Harry Potter?
Merlin was a slytherin and so am I !
I think Hermione could have been in Ravenclaw and the HP series would of been the same. With her being in that house we would have had more insight on more things Ravenclaw. I wonder why she didn't get put in that house? Did she "ask" the sorting hat to be in Gryffindor? In the first book she was definitely not for sneaking around at night and breaking rules at first, you'd of thought she would've chose to be in Ravenclaw.
Marcus I disagree. Yes she was smart but very close minded. She was more brave then anything.
Can the hat predict the future? An 11 year old Hermione was way more wise and smart than brave?
if she was in ravenclaw ron would be dead in the first book and voldemort had actually had killed potter in the seventh book
No No thank you, there is a difference.
Marcus she says in the philosopher's stone that she sees bravery as more important than intelligence, remember? In the chess room? So she was most likely sorted into Griffindore because she admired it's values more than Ravenclaw's. She was already a genius after all, she was talented. But she most valued bravery so she was sorted onto Griffindore.
I love your theory, but do have a couple of reasons Dumbledore was in the correct house.
His loyalty and bravery, misplaced or not, in regards to his hesitation to fight Grindelwald are textbook Griffindore.
Like Hermione, he was extremely intelligent, but how they used that intelligence is the difference between Ravenclaw and Griffindore. While both scholarly in their approach to a problem, to figure it out, both had a tendency to act on the information instead of gaining information for information's sake which is a hallmark for a Ravenclaw. While a Ravenclaw is brave they need time to assimilate the information before acting. Either that or they tend to have a kneejerk reaction to sudden situations.
Seamus, I love your videos and found them through the SuperCarlinBrothers. You have a very original and unique take on things with a delightful energy and point of view. I look forward to your future videos. Have a wonderful one!
He was also manipulative and incredibly ambitious
Dumbledore wasn’t wise when he first came to Hogwarts, I think he was more suited for Slytherin
Seamus: "It's not just the purebloods, it's also the weasleys"
Me: T_T
Distractible Wolf yeah he said the SLYTHEIRN purebloods not purebloods
CowboyandTuc Clash Gaming and more oh, whoops, I guess I just missed that
I knew something was up, because he is a dedicated potterhead!
Distractible Wolf yeah, but they're all "blood traitors" so I don't consider them pure blooded
i ❤you
I'm so glad you mentioned Ravenclaw getting basically no recognition these days. It's so frustrating that so many people don't care about my house!
KeyJKandy I know right!!!!!😀😀😀
“Drarry is real”
Me: *subbed*
I love the new ending it’s unexpected and gives Slytherins a better reputation
Who has a time machine I need to go give jk Rowling a little advice
I was running around like a maniac trying to find my headphones when I got the notification 😂
Seamus @ 6:29 "Forget about Drarry . . ."
Seamus @ 7:52 "Because Drarry is real."
The infamous hufflepuff scarf is back!!!💛🖤 3:00
Tori Wood ahhh yes! 😃
Tori Wood
Seamus does look amazing in those colours, doesn't he.
I fully support Dumbleclaw. Respect for the ravens
B-but it’s an Eagle
Eagles, but thank you💙🧡
Eagles*
Thank u 🟦🟫🟦🟫
Eagle*
Thank you.
*eagle
"Child friendly content." XD
We need to get everyone on board with Dumbleclaw 😂
+Golden S HP, YAS! I actually don't mind Ravenclaws even though I'm a Hufflepuff. Seamus was right: Ravenclaws are the most underrated now.
Grace The Great I'll make a thread for it in a bit!
0:05 why do you learn to read then read to learn?
I like how you made Drarry a thing with your theory just to get rid of the cursed child
I know I’m gonna get arguments about this, but in my opinion, the popularity of the houses from most to least is 1-Hufflepuff 2-Slytherin 3-Ravenclaw 4-Gryffindor. I know a lot of people assume Gryffindor is the most popular because of the books and movies, but once fans start to go even farther into Harry Potter culture, they usually change the house they want to one of the other three houses. Being a Gryffindor is much harder than most people assume because almost every time u tell a Harry Potter can that ur a Gryffindor, they assume u haven’t taken the quiz and only want to be in Gryffindor because the story is based around people in that house. While there are some Gryffindors like this, there are also many of us who aren’t.
Right? Like maybe when we were all little kids wanting to be in Gryffindor because Harry was more of a thing but nowadays in the fandom it's like everyone wanted to be different so much that Slytherin and Hufflepuff became the most popular and you can't click on anything HP related without hearing "not all Slytherins are evil" when like, no one has made that claim since like 2005. And like hardly anyone self-identifies as Gryffindor anymore cause it's too mainstream or whatever.
Pottermore put me in Slytherin
Sylphid Dual Blades preach! 👏❤️🦁
true
I was sorted into Gryffindor, and I don't mind. ^^ But I sure as hell didn't wanted to go in there 'because of Harry Potter'. If for anyone, for Fred and George :D But I could as well have wished to be in Ravenclaw to be with Luna if I follow this idea.
Based on the houses values, I think I could have been Hufflepuff or Gryffindor, but I am so not hardworking at all... :D
Anyway, I asked my friends who did the test in which house they were sorted : 8 in Gryffindor, 7 in Hufflepuff, 7 in Ravenclaw and 6 in Slytherin (although, I think I know another Slytherin but she didn't answer).
Idk why but Seamus' videos make me feel at home
I, for one, fully support Dumbleclaw
The reason is the dude is brave. He fought Voldemort with a calm tone in the book. Ootp (order of the Phoenix) he says everything calmly (Except when he asked harry if he put his name IN THE MOVIE PEOPLE.)
On the last bit I laughed harder than I should have
Book: Harry, did you out your name in the Goblet Of Fire? (Calmly)
Movie: DID YOU OUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE?!
Although, as a fellow Slytherin, the Slytherin Dumbledore is a tempting idea.
I thought Dumbledore WAS a Ravenclaw.
If Dumbledore wasn't a Gryffindor, he couldn't have passed the Sword to Harry. The Sword would have just disappeared back into the Sorting Hat
No, it didn't ^^'
It's Snape who passed the swrd to harry, he create a copy and keep the real sword and then put it in the water (idea of the stupd Gryffindor of Dumbledore I'm sure XD), yes with the instructions of Dumbledore, but if the House mattered, the sword will had disapeared when Dumbledore dies.
I think that the sord is a normal sword which can be carried by all wizards... but disapeared and appaeared in the Sorting Hat when a Gryffindor needs it ;)
I made up my own Hogwarts house it's called Dumbledoria it's for everyone who can fit into every house.
Isabelle Goodwin no, it should be Grivenhuin (griffindor + ravenclaw + Hufflepuff + Slytherin)
Isabelle Goodwin lmao, dumbledoria? Also I just made a new video on what would happen if Voldemort fell through the veil before his horcruxes were destroyed, mind checking it out?
Isabelle Goodwin I’m in Dumbledoria
I'm in dumbledoria
Im a ravenclaw and i think if dumbledores choice wasn't accounted he would probably be in ravenclaw because he is really wize.
The problem is I CAN'T FORGET ABOUT DRARRY. SORRY. bye. have a nice day
Александра Сунцова Me too!!!
What if Dumbledore is a descendant of Godric Gryffindor???
Draco Malfoy holy crap
Draco Malfoy im sure JK Rowling said that all of Gryffindor's lineage was cut off, but I may be mistaken
I remember hearing that the only one of the four founders that actually has their bloodline still carrying out is Slytherin... unless I'm mistaken.
Yeah... they're correct.
Ravenclaw had her only child we know of- Helena, who died before having children.
Hufflepuff's last descendant that we know of was killed by a Young Tom Riddle when he was searching to make the horcruxes.
Exactly my point- We know that Slytherin's carried on through the Gaunts and made it to America, but we never knew about Gryffindor.
Dumbledore doesn't value intelligence a lot. The reason he likes harry is because he´s really brave thats what he values. He shows this when he gives Neville points for being brave and standing up against his friends. I think Gryffindor or Slytherin are the best options. He doesn't really care about loyalty. He doesn't care how smart someone is. But he values bravery and ambition. I think young Dumbledore was a Slytherin and the older Dumbledore was a Gryffindor.
Sander Neeft when he was young he valued knowledge and adventure thats what made him and grindlewald friends in the first place
Agreed xD
I value Hufflepuff's values. I wish I was a Hufflepuff, actually, but I'm a Ravenclaw with Slytherin tendencies. So what you value of other house doesn't make you part of that house
Jo Moody actually what you value is what gets you into a certain house most of the time, as JK said. Not your main traits but rather the ones you value the most.
example: Ron, Hermione, Peter, Persie(probs misspelled) Weasley etc....
Mmm, I get what you're saying but in my opion they where looking for power. What you can see as ravenclaw because knowledge is power. But you can also see it as ambition. I do understand the ravenclaw more now so thx for your comment.
My friends Elliot, Megan, Julia, and Avery are all in Hudflepuff. My friend Abby and I are Ravenclaws, My friend Amy is a Gryffindor, and my friend Lacey is a Slytherin. My friends and I are very similar though.
You get sorted when you're 11 not 115
#RavenClaw4life RAVENCLAWS UNITE!!!!!
Lyra Woofheart RAVENCLAW!!!!! #ravenclawforlife
Lyra Woofheart
Finally a ravnclaw comment
#ravnclawforlife
Lyra Woofheart #dumbleclaw #bringdumblehome
I'm halfway between slitherin and ravenclaw
whoop whoop ravenclaw squad #RavenClaw4Life
make a video explaining what would have happened if Tom riddle killed Ginny. Would the new "Voldemort" be protected by the other hocruxes? Can he only be killed by a strong magical object, similar to the hocruxes?(Nagini)
would this new Voldemort be a seperate person? So many questions!!
The ending was so intense XD. I was just thinking the entire time that my house would be rectified (the whole all death eaters are slytherin but not all slytherins are death eaters), my favorite character would befriend the golden trio and Drarry would become a reality. Bravo Seamus, bravo.
To suggest Dumbledore wasn't a Gryffindor at heart is to grossly miscalculate his entire character.
Personality traits have little hold over a person's character; they determine WHAT you are, not WHO you are. What makes you really who you are, are your values. Your choices....what YOU personally consider to be important in life, and the principles you stand by.
You could be the most genius person on the entire planet, and still not be Sorted into Ravenclaw, because, (being as smart as you are,) you recognize there are things far more important and more valuable than intelligence. That's Hermione. That's Dumbledore. That's McGonagall.
If Dumbledore had been a Ravenclaw, he wouldn't have been there at all. Because it's not very smart to potentially sacrifice your life in order to help people, is it? It's noble. Had he been Ravenclaw, and valued his intelligence and his freedom, more than justice and love, he wouldn't have lead the charge against Voldemort.
I could elaborate much further, but I would be here for hours. There are many reasons why Albus Dumbledore plainly belongs in Gryffindor House.
Seamus did you know that Merlin was in Slytherin the greatest wizard of all times so that proves that not all Slytherin's are bad and evil.
Kailah Dupee thank you for defending my house
Zervis 4life! No problem I actually like Slytherin though I'm in Hufflepuff
The end of this video solidified my love for you 😍😍😍
"Seamus OUT!!" *mic drop*
Slytherin had the most powerful wizard of all time, Merlin.
Okay... Im in Slytherin and as soon as i told my friends they all thought i was evil! and we played "most likely to" and i was voted most likely to kill all my friends just because i was a SLYTHERIN!!!
*Ravenclaw for the win!*
#DumbleclawFandom
Burger Cat YEET
7:23 Woah Harry is cute as Luke. Also, Drarry is real...
WHERE MY FELLOW HUFFELPUFFS AT! 💛
Carsen Kelley YAAAS BADGER PRIDE
carsen kelley Here
Carsen Kelley Yaaaaassssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!
Here
Pressent!
RAVENCLAW HERE!!! yes i agree if dumbledore was in Slytherin it would have been epic. but ya dumbledore is more suited for ravenclaw! awesome video
Fellow Ravenclaw! :D
True
#dumbleclaw
I'm in ravenclaw btw! Also I just made a new video on what would happen if Voldemort fell through the veil before his horcruxes were destroyed, mind checking it out?
DUMBLECLAW FTW 🤣
#ravenclawpride #dumbleclaw #EndHousism
The first point I’d make is that the sorting hat can see things that lie deep within the individual. Such as Peter Pettigrew whom his whole life had been a coward but in his final moments, chose to be brave.
You are placing Dumbledore based off the old man we know.
Not Dumbledore the 11 year old boy.
Who wasn’t naturally wise and made many mistakes and learned much of his wisdom through hardships, trial and error.
That being said, it’s clear that loyalty was also something he had to learn. He learned this through the tragedy of his sister, Ariana, and then of course his past with Grindelwald. He had to learn the value of loyalty before he could appreciate it or be naturally loyal himself.
We know in his youth that Dumbledore was a brilliant and talented wizard. This doesn’t make you any particular house. Being brilliant isn’t the same as being wise and a lot of people mix that up. Not saying you did as you obviously described Dumbledore as being wise.
I think the obvious choice would be Slytherin because he was ambitious, cunning, and achievement oriented in his youth. But even still I agree with the Sorting hats choice to place Dumbledore in Gryffindor because he was brave. Firstly for all his ambition he never sought the power of Minister of Magic although many wanted him to. Back to bravery. He was brave in the face of his own death. But more importantly. We all remember the proud moment when Neville stands up to the dastardly trio whom he considered his friends. Dumbledore rewards him for it. Dumbledore himself did the very same thing. He set his feelings aside and his love for Grindelwald and mustered up all of his Bravery to take on his friend and the one he loved, knowing he would be imprisoned for the remainder of his life, if not executed. Dumbledore through his NATURAL BRAVERY stands up to both a friend and lover. This is what was I believe was the inner trait the sorting hat saw in an 11 year old Dumbledore so long ago.
Gilbert Mischel this is a very underrated comment