What if Anakin Skywalker Never Killed Count Dooku in Revenge of the Sith? - Star Wars Theory

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 дек 2024

Комментарии • 9 тыс.

  • @protato5896
    @protato5896 5 лет назад +5963

    Sideous: *Kills Padme*
    Sideous: Why do I hear boss music?

    • @atticus6234
      @atticus6234 5 лет назад +226

      No see bosses are designed to be able to be defeated

    • @protato5896
      @protato5896 5 лет назад +173

      need healing I think Anakin was using MidiChlorian hacks

    • @atticus6234
      @atticus6234 5 лет назад +29

      Ah I see

    • @allanfernandez6627
      @allanfernandez6627 5 лет назад +13

      420

    • @hazeldejesus
      @hazeldejesus 5 лет назад +43

      Sideous: Why do I hear Dovakiin theme?

  • @histguy101
    @histguy101 4 года назад +1769

    Palpatine: "Kill him. Kill him now"
    Anakin: "I won't. he will stand trial...after being questioned.'
    Palpatine: "DEW IT!"
    Anakin: "I won't!"
    Palpatine: (rolls eyes)"Very well, could I just borrow that communications device of yours?"
    Anakin: "Oh...sure. No problem"
    Palpatine "Execute Order 66"

  • @Im0nlySayin
    @Im0nlySayin 5 лет назад +526

    Dooku’s face when his hands were chopped off was like
    “Oh that’s not good, that’s really not good”

    • @lilhucke
      @lilhucke 5 лет назад +16

      The saiyan Warrior also when people don’t have life insurance and get hurt

    • @nursmalik6024
      @nursmalik6024 5 лет назад +17

      The fact that he didn't show the pain as Mace Windu or some others makes him the mightiest Jedi ever

    • @anthonyvargo7109
      @anthonyvargo7109 4 года назад +3

      "heyyy...those were mine...aw man..that sucks"~Dooku lol

    • @DaddyHensei
      @DaddyHensei 4 года назад +3

      Nurs Malik No, he didn’t show pain because he was in shock. To feel pain is to be strong. Him being disarmed overwhelmed everything, even the pain.

  • @unlogics9199
    @unlogics9199 3 года назад +1269

    "Dooku was an unarmed prisoner now"
    *damn*

    • @ibaadiqbal6180
      @ibaadiqbal6180 3 года назад +67

      Unhanded prisoner

    • @keithsvenson568
      @keithsvenson568 3 года назад +37

      @@ibaadiqbal6180 that moment when anyone in the star wars universe says "UNHAND ME!"

    • @jimmytawse9183
      @jimmytawse9183 3 года назад +5

      I got that reference

    • @DangerZone200
      @DangerZone200 3 года назад +19

      when getting disarmed is taken in a literal sense 😅

    • @ClaudevonRiegan_
      @ClaudevonRiegan_ 3 года назад +1

      ...

  • @saberdiamond3425
    @saberdiamond3425 7 лет назад +6059

    Palpatine:Do IT!
    Anakin:No.
    Palpatine:(crap)

  • @DrPhil-hz4up
    @DrPhil-hz4up 5 лет назад +6684

    Palpatine: *”Do it.”*
    Anakin: “No.”
    WRITTEN AND DIRECTED BY GEORGE LUCAS

    • @Blue-vs6fj
      @Blue-vs6fj 5 лет назад +77

      Dr. Phil watcha doin' here

    • @astelevey
      @astelevey 5 лет назад +53

      Thank you dr phil

    • @DuckiBoiHasPizza
      @DuckiBoiHasPizza 5 лет назад +33

      It looks like this boy *shows pic of Palpatine on screen* is definetely going to the ranch.

    • @waterbottle2696
      @waterbottle2696 5 лет назад +22

      *dew it

    • @latamalera6888
      @latamalera6888 5 лет назад +7

      Overused joke

  • @gudgel5307
    @gudgel5307 5 лет назад +472

    Count Dooku: The chancellor is a sith lord.
    Anakin: Wait what.
    Credits roll

  • @Jadenreyes1014
    @Jadenreyes1014 4 года назад +1393

    I love how yoda always says "We must"

  • @benvasey414
    @benvasey414 5 лет назад +1717

    “Dooku was an unarmed prisoner now”
    Oh man that’s was the greatest joke ever 👏 👏

    • @emmjea6913
      @emmjea6913 5 лет назад +53

      More like unhanded

    • @captainkiwi77
      @captainkiwi77 5 лет назад +67

      EmmJea I feel like obi wan probably would have been making hella jokes the whole time judging by his clone wars portrayal. “Your grasp on the galaxy has been halted count” “the sinister fingers of the sith shall encroach upon the galaxy no more” “well this landing has gone hand in hand with all my others”

    • @estherfu6288
      @estherfu6288 5 лет назад +1

      Lol

    • @apocalypseofoto
      @apocalypseofoto 5 лет назад +14

      "👏 👏" seems... Inappropriate.

    • @HovaSwerve
      @HovaSwerve 5 лет назад +2

      A line right from the movie.. lol.. kinda

  • @TheLalalaMan
    @TheLalalaMan 4 года назад +2116

    Sideous: Kills Padme
    Anakin: Activated Instant Kill Mode

  • @sammgz0012
    @sammgz0012 5 лет назад +1589

    Wait.... the jedi put handcuffs on a dooku after his hands were cut off?
    Definitely insult to injury

  • @joshuanaumowicz5115
    @joshuanaumowicz5115 5 лет назад +1397

    “Leading to the rise of Snoke...”
    Star Wars The Rise of Skywalker: “I think not”

    • @chungilord5221
      @chungilord5221 4 года назад +20

      SpOiLeRs!!!

    • @vperm7097
      @vperm7097 4 года назад +32

      @@chungilord5221 i mean the movie was released a month ago so most people have watched it already

    • @chungilord5221
      @chungilord5221 4 года назад +23

      I know I was being sarcastic, I saw it the day it came out

    • @mittensfastpaw
      @mittensfastpaw 4 года назад +7

      Joshua Naumowicz The last Jedi was shit and caused so much other bleck to happen.

    • @garrettquikstop2812
      @garrettquikstop2812 4 года назад +3

      Not if anything to say about it I have!!!!!!!!

  • @ianconness11
    @ianconness11 5 лет назад +1160

    Grievous: “I’m disappointed that you were captured by the Jedi, Dooku.”
    *Forgets that he was captured by Gungans in the Clone Wars and was only released because Dooku captured Anakin and convinced Padme to make the trade*

    • @treysevy5079
      @treysevy5079 5 лет назад +37

      That was a great part of the show

    • @Tkk861
      @Tkk861 5 лет назад +6

      Ian Conness fuck the clone wars

    • @lordorochimaru9431
      @lordorochimaru9431 5 лет назад +94

      Thomas Kelly fuck you the clone wars was awesome.

    • @fluffyboisquad7477
      @fluffyboisquad7477 5 лет назад +18

      Grievous: OH shoot your right

    • @ezyawn3161
      @ezyawn3161 5 лет назад +23

      Then Dooku to Grievous: It wasn't Jedi who bombed your plane it were the Sith
      Then Grievous would join him afterall Grievous was Dooku's apprentice
      Grievous: I will switch team if you help my people
      (idk if Grievous's people were all killed cuz in that case he would run away saying *Jedi Scum*)

  • @Pr0fess0rSasquatch
    @Pr0fess0rSasquatch 4 года назад +704

    “Dooku was now an unarmed prisoner”
    I see what you did there

    • @michaelnjenga8109
      @michaelnjenga8109 4 года назад +2

      Dooku has Force lightning

    • @Tony_58
      @Tony_58 4 года назад +25

      Not without hands

    • @xaevier
      @xaevier 4 года назад

      Don't think he ment to mean that lol

    • @faisaldlg735
      @faisaldlg735 4 года назад

      bruh i am dying lmfaoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

    • @chasedavis5752
      @chasedavis5752 4 года назад +1

      I would’ve said, “Dooku now an unhanded prisoner”

  • @thegreatkight8016
    @thegreatkight8016 4 года назад +801

    I have a theory:
    What if Qui-Gon, Obi-Wan, and the Trade Federation actually made negotiations at the beginning of The Phantom Menace?

  • @primeemperor9196
    @primeemperor9196 5 лет назад +1397

    Emperor: DEW IT!
    Anakin: Why are you so obsessed with me killing him?
    Emperor: Oh, um... No reason. He's just a sith lord, and I figured...
    Dooku: PALPAPTINE IS THE SITH LORD!
    Emperor: ... Dammit.

    • @emerybrown8603
      @emerybrown8603 5 лет назад +18

      Aaron Floyd LOL😂😂😂😂

    • @flynn8845
      @flynn8845 4 года назад +9

      Filthy acts at a reasonable price no he revealed it to him when he converted him as the only the only way to gain his trust.

    • @emperorbarina
      @emperorbarina 4 года назад

      Right!

    • @flynn8845
      @flynn8845 4 года назад

      @Filthy acts at a reasonable price also nive jojo refrence

    • @aronsmith3417
      @aronsmith3417 4 года назад +2

      @Filthy acts at a reasonable price they actually had a conversation before obi wan and anakin was able to board the ship, so at this point in the story he would know.

  • @commissionerwarden6347
    @commissionerwarden6347 5 лет назад +614

    3:25 Two Obi-Wans
    This getting out of hand. Now there are two of them!

    • @WaluigiLebron
      @WaluigiLebron 4 года назад +41

      @Free Uyghur Obi-Two

    • @itzbrandon579
      @itzbrandon579 4 года назад +4

      This begs me to question, is there actually a force move that is similar to double team from Pokémon?

    • @darcyxerox1589
      @darcyxerox1589 4 года назад +8

      There can never be to many obi wans

    • @yerriff8115
      @yerriff8115 4 года назад +5

      Is this legal?

    • @maldorov6297
      @maldorov6297 4 года назад +3

      Obi - Two, love it

  • @FiveTen007
    @FiveTen007 4 года назад +667

    Palpatine: he took your arm
    Anakin: I took two of his hands, that seems fair doesn’t it?

    • @darthnbl
      @darthnbl 4 года назад +63

      Palpatine: u should kill him now
      Anakin: why
      Palpatine: ....

    • @Mephilis78
      @Mephilis78 3 года назад +14

      @@darthnbl Um.... because he's a dick

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 3 года назад +7

      @@Mephilis78 says the one who has sith slaves to do your dirty work.

    • @Mephilis78
      @Mephilis78 3 года назад +3

      @@mistylover7398 How did you know about my SWTOR life?

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 3 года назад

      @@Mephilis78 ummmmm idk 😗🤫😁

  • @kadentyler5277
    @kadentyler5277 4 года назад +177

    I absolutely love how in these theories anytime anakin sees padme hurt by Palpatine he just goes insane I feel it would really happen because anakin loves her and his family

    • @mikeexits
      @mikeexits Год назад

      I wonder how that relates to the fact that he basically killed her in episode 3.

    • @ThomasBrown755
      @ThomasBrown755 Год назад

      ​@@mikeexitsthat comment made my day

    • @earth2k66
      @earth2k66 4 месяца назад

      ​@@mikeexitsHe didn't kill her, she died from birth exhaustion and the trauma of whatever happened to Anakin.
      If Anakin was present there by her side, there was a high chance she would have survived.

  • @jak4179
    @jak4179 5 лет назад +2575

    We all know Samuel L Jackson would've killed Maul with just words.

    • @brandonoliver8547
      @brandonoliver8547 4 года назад +66

      Jack DaGreat he would have worked his mouth like a puppet 😂

    • @mishareal
      @mishareal 4 года назад +172

      Enough is Enough! I've had it with these mothafricking Sith in this mothafricking Senate!

    • @Evil_Peter
      @Evil_Peter 4 года назад +16

      @Francisco Martineau Liam Neeson gets killed by tons of people. ;)

    • @whipannyschnip9472
      @whipannyschnip9472 4 года назад +14

      When he died he says: ‘ awww motha f*cka

    • @MRH34DS40T98
      @MRH34DS40T98 4 года назад +1

      Nice profile picture bro 👐👍

  • @82dorrin
    @82dorrin 6 лет назад +2288

    Palpatine distracts the Jedi so he could escape.
    Palpatine: Hey look! It's a naked Twi'ilek woman!!
    *The Jedi all look. Palpatine jumps out the window*
    Yoda: Dammit.

    • @abdimohamud5252
      @abdimohamud5252 6 лет назад +66

      Good one

    • @dilospino
      @dilospino 6 лет назад +184

      Hey, Aayla is stripping!

    • @Halmir4126
      @Halmir4126 6 лет назад +144

      Truly devious the sith are

    • @tatumlasse
      @tatumlasse 6 лет назад +90

      Onyx1916 to be honest Mace would have said Dammit not Yoda

    • @mr_bruh8683
      @mr_bruh8683 6 лет назад +40

      That would be a good scene in the movie

  • @irishspudlad
    @irishspudlad 4 года назад +2520

    I doubt Maul would help Palpatine after his brother was killed.

    • @bray9995
      @bray9995 4 года назад +121

      honestly kind of agree.

    • @Abc-jm8mo
      @Abc-jm8mo 4 года назад +194

      No but remember maul begged for mercy and sheev is a master of manipulation

    • @lukebomber
      @lukebomber 4 года назад +91

      @@Abc-jm8mo Well mercy in that case mostly meant a swift and painful death I think

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow 4 года назад +23

      @@lukebomber right, and by not granting him that sheev could then force Maul to train under him once again, this is a very common sith thing to do

    • @jaydenk1938
      @jaydenk1938 4 года назад +20

      I doubt maul had a choice

  • @ameerkhan1028
    @ameerkhan1028 3 года назад +116

    “Dooku was an unarmed prisoner”
    I see what you did there

  • @bobzilla7894
    @bobzilla7894 5 лет назад +619

    And I love how you said he was a “ unarmed “ prisoner haha

    • @wta1518
      @wta1518 4 года назад +11

      Your grammar is atrocious.

    • @JoelEmiliano-vt4zf
      @JoelEmiliano-vt4zf 4 года назад +4

      @Bobzilla 789 , 2 Thing's!
      1: No pun intended.
      2: I only liked your comment because your username. BobZILLA!!!!

    • @bobzilla7894
      @bobzilla7894 4 года назад +3

      WorldTravel1518 I take it with pride

    • @bobzilla7894
      @bobzilla7894 4 года назад +1

      The little Toxic shadow thank you

    • @JoelEmiliano-vt4zf
      @JoelEmiliano-vt4zf 4 года назад +2

      Bobzilla 789 thank you.

  • @beepthehuman9808
    @beepthehuman9808 4 года назад +950

    Anakin: He must stand trial.
    Dooku: PALPATINE IS THE SITH LORD!
    Sheev: Oh shi-

    • @AmateurXP
      @AmateurXP 3 года назад +3

      Dayum 723 likes

    • @nicolasleal5644
      @nicolasleal5644 3 года назад +2

      To be continued.

    • @PurplexEdits
      @PurplexEdits 3 года назад +2

      @@AmateurXP 724 now

    • @EWBRboy2006
      @EWBRboy2006 3 года назад +1

      @beepthehuman
      Written and Directed by:
      George Lucas

    • @HappyBeezerStudios
      @HappyBeezerStudios 3 года назад

      Did you just assume any of us are on first name basis with the Senate?

  • @maldorov6297
    @maldorov6297 4 года назад +195

    Dooku: unhand me!
    Anakin: whatever you say pal

  • @qingruiscookery
    @qingruiscookery 4 года назад +107

    Palpatine: kills padme
    “Why do I sense midiclorian hack?”

    • @keithsvenson568
      @keithsvenson568 3 года назад +8

      palpatine: does anybody else suddenly smell broken game mechanics?

    • @bigmansir3745
      @bigmansir3745 3 года назад +2

      @@keithsvenson568 WHY DO I HEAR BOSS MUSIC

  • @allah-a2353
    @allah-a2353 6 лет назад +1355

    Kill obi-wan? Hah what a joke we all know he would take the highground

    • @Red-sm5so
      @Red-sm5so 5 лет назад +87

      @@alexross1816 LMAO I was just about to say the same thing. Obi Wan jumps to the highest point in all the Jedi temple and from the top of his lungs screams " ITS OVER PALPATINE I HAVE THE HIGH GROUND!!" & Palpatine scream "WHAT!? I CAN'T HEAR YOU FROM UP THERE"

    • @mr.b8780
      @mr.b8780 5 лет назад +33

      Yeah. On top of that, Sith Lords are his speciality, so he would easily defeat Palpatine

    • @lavasqrl702
      @lavasqrl702 5 лет назад +1

      @@mr.b8780 You mean on top of Obi-Wan?

    • @Robert-pn3dq
      @Robert-pn3dq 5 лет назад +7

      Palpatine: "Shit, i shoulda taken the joy sticks so i could have the higher ground..."

    • @brucelane6528
      @brucelane6528 5 лет назад +6

      When he said Obi Wan was killed same with mace in the video I felt so sick because I can’t imagine Obi dying by the emporer

  • @Archon3960
    @Archon3960 4 года назад +1591

    Maul is very much alive.
    "I was saved! By a bunch of fans!"

  • @tazrinchowdhury9767
    @tazrinchowdhury9767 5 лет назад +911

    Even if maul got upgraded, he could not kill mace in minutes

    • @Whispangle
      @Whispangle 5 лет назад +10

      Lol this comment section gonna get bad in a few minutes these two people are together

    • @Whispangle
      @Whispangle 5 лет назад +2

      @@liljdiamond2245 Sorry dude but I like Obi Wan more

    • @Cornponetheape
      @Cornponetheape 5 лет назад +7

      But he has the balls to fight you Unlike yours which he cut off years ago

    • @Whispangle
      @Whispangle 5 лет назад +3

      @@Cornponetheape you talking to me or Darth Maul?

    • @Whispangle
      @Whispangle 5 лет назад +2

      @@liljdiamond2245 don't worry dude I only don't like you as much is because Kenobi beat the crap out of Anakin

  • @andrewabate2570
    @andrewabate2570 3 года назад +104

    Palpatine: “Good, now kill him.”
    Dooku: “bruh”

    • @wavix
      @wavix 3 года назад +10

      Dooku: wait a minute this whole operation was your idea

    • @tommyl.dayandtherunaways820
      @tommyl.dayandtherunaways820 3 года назад +6

      Palpatine: Do it!
      Dooku: Skywalker, now is the chance to prove you are not as ignorant as your master, I am going to tell you the exact same thing I told him on Geonosis...

  • @limeddasch382
    @limeddasch382 6 лет назад +1013

    I don‘t think Windu would have died. I mean, he could keep pace with Palpatine.

    • @Dankumemes
      @Dankumemes 6 лет назад +82

      I agree the only difference I can see how windu would die is that maul took advantage of a small opening like he did with qui gon

    • @limeddasch382
      @limeddasch382 6 лет назад +67

      Zeno-sama Which I think Windu would have been the one who would have done that.
      Windu did it with Palpatine, so he could have done it with Maul.

    • @Dankumemes
      @Dankumemes 6 лет назад +35

      @@limeddasch382 the difference between sidious and maul is that maul is a pure duelist while sidious is not

    • @limeddasch382
      @limeddasch382 6 лет назад +6

      Zeno-sama So how does this affect this situation?
      I thought they both used the force for seeing gaps.

    • @williamkrause5831
      @williamkrause5831 6 лет назад +42

      Zeno-sama Sidious is still a better dueler than Maul, though.

  • @maytix6270
    @maytix6270 5 лет назад +385

    Haha.
    “This video could end with Palpatine in Jail and Snoke rising which we know little about”
    Haha *Thats a funny Joke*

    • @MediaLeft425
      @MediaLeft425 5 лет назад +16

      Waiting for a comment like this. So about that... Haha. Yeah that would TOTALLY happen

    • @NunchuckOmega
      @NunchuckOmega 5 лет назад +19

      Snoke was such a wasted character

    • @bromicorn
      @bromicorn 5 лет назад +3

      *HAH* THAT IS HILLARIOUS

    • @piyo744
      @piyo744 5 лет назад +7

      @@NunchuckOmega He should've been Plagueis.

    • @thehiddenone2875
      @thehiddenone2875 5 лет назад +4

      @Jacob Underwood Yeah but still Snoke was a really interesting and mysterious Character and now its just like "eh he is nobody just some tall dingdong about whom we still know nothing, who was he before Sheev cloned him was he just created by Palpatine or was he a real person before and if that is the case who was he and how did he get those scars"

  • @Horesmi
    @Horesmi 8 лет назад +371

    "I won't kill him".
    "Then you will... Die."
    *blasts Anakin with force lightning*
    "Chancellor, what happened on that ship?"
    "Everyone tragically died. I'm the only survivor."

    • @elijahnakumura4375
      @elijahnakumura4375 8 лет назад +16

      Realistically could have happened. If only the Sith weren't constantly trying to upgrade from one another lol. Once obi was out cold, Palpatine could have joined in and Ani would have died instantly. Grievous, Dooku, Sidious and Maul? Sounds good enough to me.

    • @agentdash8999
      @agentdash8999 7 лет назад +11

      Wasn't Palpatine locked into that chair so he couldn't do anything?

    • @elijahnakumura4375
      @elijahnakumura4375 7 лет назад +15

      Agent Dash Anakin pressed a button or used the force(cant remember which) that released the cuffs. Im sure the Emperor of the Dark side would have no problem

    • @adeel-eh7xq
      @adeel-eh7xq 7 лет назад +3

      He could use his force powers to open the lock. He can bring people back to life with his sith powers.

    • @antoniomcneary
      @antoniomcneary 7 лет назад +6

      He actually doubled back once vader put on his suit and said he didn't have the ability and that they would search for the answer together

  • @Double_D__
    @Double_D__ 3 года назад +43

    Palpatine: *Kills Padme*
    *Suddenly O Fortuna begins playing and Anakin stares at him*
    Palpatine: I think I just made a terrible mistake.

  • @jooasalmi730
    @jooasalmi730 5 лет назад +316

    "he was an unarmed prisoner"
    ... I see what you did there

  • @jacksonthesyndicalist2771
    @jacksonthesyndicalist2771 7 лет назад +331

    Mace is the least likely person to lose to maul because he harnesses dark power and is the second best duelist of the Jedi order.

    • @pohenixwielki3178
      @pohenixwielki3178 6 лет назад +21

      At this time Anakin could become more powerful than Mace. Few more years of training will make difference. J thing Mace will be 3rd.
      It's also important to note that Maul has been training from episode 1 to 3 + additionall years after Sidius escape. It's like whole Anakin live. His power will be equal or slightly less than his master's so he could take out Mace easily. In best scenario he was medium opponent.

    • @killertoxic2859
      @killertoxic2859 6 лет назад +3

      Poh enix yes especially being trained by he’s years in the run and his training with palpatine as maul does have a lot of potential

    • @ScienceStuff24
      @ScienceStuff24 6 лет назад

      Probably Third to before luke and yoda

    • @rss8641
      @rss8641 6 лет назад +9

      Poh enix more powerful in the force, yes but the more powerful in the dark side he was, the more chance Vapaad will work against you. This is why he beat Sidious quite easily. Maul, if was more powerful in the dark side than sidious, would have a harder time against Mace.

    • @quillproductions377
      @quillproductions377 6 лет назад +5

      Poh enix Windu would have beaten Maul as he wouldn't have used Vaapad to reflect Maul's dark side nature back at him. Maul was not as powerful as Sidious so this duel would be convincing in Windu's favour

  • @gerstein03
    @gerstein03 5 лет назад +104

    One tiny change: if Palpatine was forced to flee, he wouldn't have been able to execute order 66 as Dooku probably would have told the Jedi about it and the Jedi would have taken precautions to prevent

    • @rundc6979
      @rundc6979 5 лет назад +2

      @WiiManElite In the movie they never said Clones had chips in their brains, chips that control their actions and motivations. In the movie they said that Clones were bred for obedience. The whole chip idea was something that was made up for Rebels and the Clone Wars cartoon. You know they have chips in their brains. To me that's just something where some writer came by and was like: "Clones being bred for obedience doesn't make much sense, we'll just say they have chips in their brains." To me it's just ehhhh. It's all kinda dumb and i'm not really a fan of that. I'm not a fan of just like writing your own excuses for someones nonsense writing. You know Overall, to me it seems that subsequent writers just never seem too happy with how the Clones work, so they keep changing them and their motivations around. To be quite honest i'm not a fan of the Clones anymore in general. They're just a bad contrived Prequel idea that never makes much sense no matter how many revisions they go through.

  • @James-rm7sr
    @James-rm7sr 4 года назад +54

    I really liked that version. As Anakin is far more balanced then in the actual timeline thereby fulfilling his role as to bring balance to the force. I would honestly love to watch a live action version of it.

  • @joer741
    @joer741 5 лет назад +3622

    If obi wan dies I don’t like the theory

    • @Alexz_202
      @Alexz_202 5 лет назад +128

      i agree

    • @californiaranger6232
      @californiaranger6232 5 лет назад +99

      Hello there time ends

    • @albinocorbino
      @albinocorbino 5 лет назад +36

      EXACTLY.

    • @jjdepree5148
      @jjdepree5148 5 лет назад +41

      Same with mace

    • @Wonderland89
      @Wonderland89 5 лет назад +13

      But he still dies this is just in a different way l.So if you don’t like it if he dies you don’t like A New Hope 😑😑😑

  • @thetman0068
    @thetman0068 6 лет назад +1392

    *DEW IT*
    No...
    Directed by George Lucas

    • @Robin-dr5zp
      @Robin-dr5zp 6 лет назад +7

      Mountain Dew it

    • @rainefyre6750
      @rainefyre6750 5 лет назад +2

      The Mad Gentleman your dog 😂

    • @jeffreyjeffrey1935
      @jeffreyjeffrey1935 5 лет назад

      @@rainefyre6750 ayeeeywse

    • @rainefyre6750
      @rainefyre6750 5 лет назад

      Jeffrey Jeffrey dhahabshsheb

    • @therealMrA
      @therealMrA 5 лет назад +2

      *same celebratory ending as Return of the Jedi plays*
      "It's like poetry. They- They rhyme."

  • @Tman-fp9dy
    @Tman-fp9dy 8 лет назад +903

    I have a few recommendations, "What if padmes presence wasn't soothing" "What if general grievous wasn't shorter than anakin expected" "What if anakins power hadn't doubled since the last time he met dooku" "What if anakin liked sand" "What if an anakin wasn't a fast learner"

    • @borisgenchev8567
      @borisgenchev8567 8 лет назад +68

      That would change everything.

    • @chasegilmond5637
      @chasegilmond5637 8 лет назад +97

      What if anakin wasn't haunted by that kiss?

    • @thewinterlord1518
      @thewinterlord1518 8 лет назад +86

      What if Dooku didn't say the "double the pride twice the fall" joke?

    • @chasegilmond5637
      @chasegilmond5637 8 лет назад +64

      What if nobody said midochlorions

    • @_vavss_
      @_vavss_ 8 лет назад +86

      What if Obi-Wan was brave enough for politics?

  • @zenithstudio6819
    @zenithstudio6819 4 года назад +68

    April 1st theory: "what if the negotiations weren't short?"

  • @trycoldman2358
    @trycoldman2358 8 лет назад +1474

    Un-armed...ha..haha...

    • @Horesmi
      @Horesmi 8 лет назад +17

      That joke is so bad... I love it!

    • @SOMEGUY7893
      @SOMEGUY7893 8 лет назад +23

      More like "I'd ask you to unhand me, but..."

    • @DRMINT-np1bj
      @DRMINT-np1bj 8 лет назад +18

      Dooku is harmless because HE IS ARMLESS!!!
      Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahhahahhaahahahahhahahhaahahhaahaahahahahahahhahahhahh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      That's not funny

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 лет назад +75

      lol glad someone got that :)

    • @DRMINT-np1bj
      @DRMINT-np1bj 8 лет назад +2

      :)

  • @jwoodsonmusic
    @jwoodsonmusic 8 лет назад +385

    What if Count Dooku never turned to the dark side?

    • @StarWarsTheory
      @StarWarsTheory  8 лет назад +67

      oooh I like it man!!

    • @tjnorth6531
      @tjnorth6531 8 лет назад +3

      Jacob Woodson the reason why he did was because qui gon jinn died

    • @Comedy-up5ck
      @Comedy-up5ck 8 лет назад +23

      Star Wars Theory What if Anakin caught obi wan and padme cheating

    • @tjnorth6531
      @tjnorth6531 8 лет назад +1

      Jacob Woodson and I think it's already been done

    • @bibitybop5447
      @bibitybop5447 8 лет назад +1

      Jacob Woodson yes

  • @odd-eyes6363
    @odd-eyes6363 5 лет назад +157

    This is probably one of the most interesting “what if Anakin didn’t fall” stories ever written. I actually really want to know what would happen next

    • @williamwest9204
      @williamwest9204 5 лет назад +5

      If u wanna lookup a good "what if" try the one where anakin is given the job of training younglings with Yoda. The points he makes on how that would have changed anakins mental state entirely.

    • @seanb6962
      @seanb6962 4 года назад

      Mother... good for u hony
      you... STOP CALLING ME THAT

  • @eoinbalfe873
    @eoinbalfe873 3 года назад +51

    Does anyone else just get sad when u hear something like this because of how sad anikin's story could have turned out, like it was probrably worst case scenario for him

  • @jarmoliebrand3395
    @jarmoliebrand3395 5 лет назад +115

    Padme gets hit by force lightning
    Anakin in Battlefront 2
    ReTrIbUtiOn

  • @mrditkovich7213
    @mrditkovich7213 5 лет назад +436

    What do you mean fiery landing on coruscant, it was a happy landing

    • @jasondyrkacz8270
      @jasondyrkacz8270 5 лет назад +12

      "We're coming in too hot."
      For 10 miles of runway?

    • @Whispangle
      @Whispangle 5 лет назад +12

      "Not to worry, We are still flying half a ship"

    • @hoshiryu
      @hoshiryu 5 лет назад +4

      Rent?

    • @FeeJeeWater
      @FeeJeeWater 5 лет назад +3

      You'll get your rent when you fix this DAMN DOOR!

    • @The12thDoctor
      @The12thDoctor 5 лет назад +3

      FIX THIS DOOR

  • @StarWarsTheory
    @StarWarsTheory  8 лет назад +3527

    Hey everyone! Hope you liked this one...I know many of you have been requesting it, and I just couldn't go with the first option to end this video. Any other ending would have been just too light and boring. I think this one would have played out pretty cool, what do you think? Anything you'd have changed?? Let me know, always like to improve and hear (read) everyone's opinions. See you all on the Facebook page later, I'll be catching up on your inbox messages :)
    Thanks again so much for watching!!!
    May The Force Be With You!

    • @kwikscope1919
      @kwikscope1919 8 лет назад +20

      Star Wars Theory ur awesome

    • @gabrielalhbin817
      @gabrielalhbin817 8 лет назад +9

      Star Wars Theory This is awsome because I was thinking about this yesterday

    • @cereal9986
      @cereal9986 8 лет назад +8

      Star Wars Theory maul wouldn't join palpatine because he is stronger because of his mandalorians

    • @devranhasan4969
      @devranhasan4969 8 лет назад +5

      after order 66 what happened to the clones

    • @harrycarey5846
      @harrycarey5846 8 лет назад +2

      Star Wars Theory I recently started my channel and I want it to be about star wars have you got any advice on how to make good star wars content

  • @triixstiir
    @triixstiir 3 года назад +120

    If dooku had been able to tell him and they teamed up against palpating that would’ve been GOLD!!! Perhaps Dooku wouldn’t have turned back to the light side but imo I feel as though Dooku isn’t on the light or dark side rather just being one with the force regardless of light or dark.

    • @GudJonnyCakes
      @GudJonnyCakes 3 года назад +21

      If you actually hear dooku literally said to Obi-Wan Kenobi that the supreme Chancellor ran was the sith Lord but he didn't believe it how dumb is that

    • @HappyBeezerStudios
      @HappyBeezerStudios 3 года назад +23

      The big difference between Dooku and most dark side users is, that Dooku didn't use the force for personal gain. He never really fell to the dark side, but was surely seduced by it.

    • @thehighground2014
      @thehighground2014 2 года назад +5

      @@HappyBeezerStudios to add to that, pretty sure someone said that Dooku was more of a political man than a power-hungry Sith Lord, since he was a fallen Jedi who left because of the corruption he saw within the Republic, therefore wanting to somewhat expose it into the public eye. But I'm just quoting someone else lmao

    • @nickcozzie6614
      @nickcozzie6614 2 года назад +7

      Dooku was never fully a sith u have to pay attention to his eyes when he fight all the other sith use anger during their fights but he didn’t he still had the Discipline of the Jedi but he was a force sensitive who used the dark and light side just the revan was in the old republic

    • @nickcozzie6614
      @nickcozzie6614 2 года назад +5

      @@HappyBeezerStudios I wouldn’t even say seduced he was intrigued. But also was angry at the Jedi for them not paying attention to qui gon and for not listening to him when really qui-gon was right from the beginning

  • @tommy_502
    @tommy_502 5 лет назад +573

    video should have been titled: *if dooku became 6ix9ine*

  • @basheddt9544
    @basheddt9544 4 года назад +189

    3:16 this is getting out of hand, there's two obi wans!

  • @Real_creator
    @Real_creator 5 лет назад +136

    Palpateen - Anakin, he took your arm!
    Anakin - I took his hands.

  • @oryx_the_god5027
    @oryx_the_god5027 4 года назад +29

    “ How could you do this Anakin! Remember he took your arm!” He can’t do anything Chancellor I took his hands we equal

  • @thes.k.eletonhunter7951
    @thes.k.eletonhunter7951 5 лет назад +97

    Palpatine: “... now kill him.”
    Duke: bruh!

    • @marklleshi3383
      @marklleshi3383 5 лет назад +1

      Chewwer bro chill he didn’t do anything it’s a joke

  • @حنانالشهراني-د3ه
    @حنانالشهراني-د3ه 4 года назад +664

    Me: **laughs**
    Teacher: what's so funny
    Me: nothing
    My brain:
    3:22 obi-two-kenobi

  • @NaturalHazard10
    @NaturalHazard10 5 лет назад +17

    The sight of Anakin, Obi Wan, Mace and Yoda standing together with sabers out would be the best moment in Star Wars history

  • @hydrodrift
    @hydrodrift 2 года назад +40

    It doesn’t matter how powerful Maul gets, ain’t no way he’s killing Mace Windu. He was one of the most powerful Jedi 2nd only to the Grand master.

    • @psydrith1
      @psydrith1 Год назад +5

      That's exactly what I was thinking 😂. Maul who is stronger from more hatred? That's playing right into Mace'a Vaapad.

    • @moddedinkling4168
      @moddedinkling4168 Год назад

      This was the one part I found strange, especially since Mace was just as much of a Master of Form VII as Maul was.

    • @Aaron-zk6jn
      @Aaron-zk6jn 9 месяцев назад

      Windu defeated sidious, and in the attack of the clones series, face off of sidious and maul, there was no contest.

    • @natefontana5757
      @natefontana5757 5 месяцев назад

      ⁠@@Aaron-zk6jnHe didn’t defeat Sidious, Darth Sidious threw himself on purpose as soon as Anakin showed up to play the victim to get Anakin to turn to the dark side.

  • @lancelothiphop5470
    @lancelothiphop5470 8 лет назад +349

    what if Count Dooku stayed with the Jedi Order?

  • @lumie2798
    @lumie2798 7 лет назад +503

    Big sale at the maul, everything’s half off

  • @guitarnerd4091
    @guitarnerd4091 4 года назад +164

    “...Would leak to the eventual rise oof Snoke...”
    2020 Me: Let me stop you right there.

  • @Cyano64
    @Cyano64 4 года назад +86

    Poor Padme, always dying in all of these

    • @YourFavoriteNoob
      @YourFavoriteNoob 3 года назад +5

      thats very true! well she only has a gun no power or ligthsaber

    • @rudy1999
      @rudy1999 3 года назад +3

      xD Rey would have decapitated all of the Sith with one swing

    • @personwholikesbasicallyany3519
      @personwholikesbasicallyany3519 3 года назад +9

      @@rudy1999 because rey is a disney character, and thus can't have a bad ending

    • @SMarie-zk9oj
      @SMarie-zk9oj 3 года назад +5

      @@rudy1999 lol look one of Disney’s alt accounts

    • @terrfan
      @terrfan 2 года назад +1

      Make one where Padmé lives pls why she always dies 😭

  • @ZayecValentine
    @ZayecValentine 5 лет назад +21

    Palpatine: Dooku took your arm!
    Anakin: I took both his hands. We’re even.

  • @StealthySpace7
    @StealthySpace7 6 лет назад +184

    I don’t really believe all the Jedi besides 4 would die to 2 sith, I think after the first 3 or 4 assassinations Yoda would have sensed maul and palpatine, then dozens of remaining Jedi would gang up buy the tens against 2 sith

    • @TheBrino.
      @TheBrino. 6 лет назад +14

      PowerOfThePick I agree with this more!

    • @SalumarLP
      @SalumarLP 6 лет назад +11

      Also what about all the highly trained Jedi guard patrolling the temple. I don't think Maul could sneek by all of them. Also in this scenario the Jedi would be more cautious than ever, they've just discovered that a powerful Sith has been under their nose for many years, you bet your ass that they'll focus on discovering dark side users sooner.

    • @tompetty927
      @tompetty927 6 лет назад +2

      Lenny Plötz yes but it's not as if that just happened in this what if he said they trained and gained power for years until they were versions of themselves we've never seen

    • @dirtnugget5968
      @dirtnugget5968 5 лет назад +3

      In this scenario it had also been a few years after Order 66 right? So the Temple would only have a fraction of the Jedi and younglings left defending

    • @hopefulpetheaven3616
      @hopefulpetheaven3616 5 лет назад

      Yeh like before order 66 and battle of geonosis< sorry if spelt wrong) there was thousands of Jedi so they’re wouldn’t be like 10 in the temple there would be hundred as not all of them would be on missions on other planets

  • @_Toxicity
    @_Toxicity 7 лет назад +137

    5:50 - I dunno. I think Palpatine is manipulative enough that he would let himself get arrested, using all his political connections and allies to convince the senate he's innocent, make the Jedi look bad in the process, and then be released a free man (possibly protected by Double Jeopardy if Star Wars has it). That would then force the Jedis' hands. They can't let Palpatine go free knowing he's a sith lord; however, attacking him would trash all public perspective of them and play right into Palpatine's hands.
    If you ever want to do a follow up video/story taking the first path, you're welcome to use my idea/draw inspiration from it.

    • @MarshWaha
      @MarshWaha 6 лет назад

      Nameless Nameless I love that idea. I think that would make a great video.

    • @taranummehraj3999
      @taranummehraj3999 6 лет назад +1

      Nameless Nameless

  • @chemicalzteam7345
    @chemicalzteam7345 3 года назад +42

    3:14:
    Obi-Wan has a new power: He can duplicate himself!

    • @jasondyrkacz8270
      @jasondyrkacz8270 2 года назад

      At least one will always have the high ground.

  • @theprogaming6164
    @theprogaming6164 4 года назад +123

    Star wars theory: now that hes unarmed...
    Me: ’’looks down on dooku’s cut off hands on the floors” yup.

  • @ChanandIerBong
    @ChanandIerBong 5 лет назад +315

    There is no world in which I believe Maul could ever defeat Windu.

    • @amidamaru4414
      @amidamaru4414 5 лет назад +21

      Chanandler Bong you underestimate his power

    • @blackbookt.vchannel7616
      @blackbookt.vchannel7616 5 лет назад +10

      @@amidamaru4414 nah hes not that good

    • @Ffi_Millo
      @Ffi_Millo 5 лет назад

      U dare disrespect me

    • @Ffi_Millo
      @Ffi_Millo 5 лет назад

      I shall wait no longer and take revenge

    • @blackbookt.vchannel7616
      @blackbookt.vchannel7616 5 лет назад +29

      @@Ffi_Millo he lost to dam near a padawon, obi-won wopped his ass and split his double blade within a few minutes after his master died, that was not supposed to happen lol

  • @nilslorand
    @nilslorand 7 лет назад +571

    "An Unarmed prisoner"
    Get it?
    Hahahaha

    • @radarred4529
      @radarred4529 6 лет назад +3

      Oh, great. First Obi-wan, now you? Who's next, Ahsoka?

    • @pogchamp1138
      @pogchamp1138 6 лет назад +1

      Ha! (Not Funny)

    • @ajl1218
      @ajl1218 6 лет назад +1

      Nils Lorand actually he was only just a unhanded prisoner

    • @ajl1218
      @ajl1218 6 лет назад

      Radar Red no I’m next the greatest threat the galaxy has ever known

    • @thediamondsword5019
      @thediamondsword5019 6 лет назад +1

      LOL

  • @krassout
    @krassout 3 года назад +14

    3:25 Obi wan just casually chillin in his chair while obi wan stands with dooku and sheev

  • @riyadbatli
    @riyadbatli 4 года назад +569

    Sideous: *jumps out*
    Mace: Hey Sideous where are you going *holds him up with force*
    Yoda: How embarrassing made big mistake you have made emperor
    Obi-Wan: We’ll take him together
    Anakin: No I’m taking him now
    Obi-Wan: No, Anakin no!
    *Anakin runs forward with lightsaber*
    Sideous: Good, wait what
    *Anakin stabs him*
    Sideous: Ahhh
    Anakin: Yes chosen one!
    Yoda: Anti climactic that was
    Credits

  • @CE77777
    @CE77777 4 года назад +67

    Nah they honestly need to do an alternate version of the Star Wars trilogy’s honestly would be dope for instanced like this

    • @thatoscarguy9965
      @thatoscarguy9965 4 года назад +3

      Oh how I wish they would. So many amazing and very real possibilities to work with while still keeping the personalities and traits of the characters identical. I don’t speak for everyone but I would’ve much rather seen this or another great fan fiction as a film being well done as opposed to what we got with the sequel trilogy. It had so much potential but it was ruined by the wrong people. So seeing something like this would’ve been far superior and so refreshing for me.

    • @Sgil97
      @Sgil97 4 года назад

      They should do a ‘what if’ like they have with marvel

  • @GrizzlyHansen
    @GrizzlyHansen 8 лет назад +186

    Darth Maul take on and Kill Windu, someone is delusional. There's no way Maul could beat Windu Windu is specialized in taking down dark siders as powerful as sidious.

    • @19TheFallen
      @19TheFallen 8 лет назад +32

      Especially since Windu's fighting style cancels out Dark Side users and turns their own anger, rage and power back on themselves!

    • @GrizzlyHansen
      @GrizzlyHansen 8 лет назад +10

      It took Maul ages to kill qui Gonn who was never really a Lightsaber Specialist and an old man, against a power house like Windu who specializes in Dark Side users and defeated one of the most Powerful Sith in history, yeah no.

    • @toxicmurdererr7597
      @toxicmurdererr7597 8 лет назад +1

      John Hansen even though maul is more powerful than before you're right

    • @GrizzlyHansen
      @GrizzlyHansen 8 лет назад +2

      Well Palpatine would never make Maul more powerful than himself and Mace beat Palpatine.

    • @gav349
      @gav349 8 лет назад +2

      Well keep in mind this was a while after RotS, so I believe Windu would be decently out of his prime, unable to keep up with other enemies even with his masterful use of Vapaad.

  • @colorbenja6163
    @colorbenja6163 4 года назад +34

    I know Padme's death would trigger Anakin instantly, but I honestly think that Obi Wan's death prior to that would've had a similar effect.

  • @swingman1978
    @swingman1978 5 лет назад +98

    2:30 “Dooku was an unarmed prisoner”
    Actually, he’s an un-handed prisoner now...

    • @swingman1978
      @swingman1978 5 лет назад +2

      Chewwer :((

    • @odst_735
      @odst_735 4 года назад

      😃👍

    • @linkheroofhyrule9364
      @linkheroofhyrule9364 4 года назад +2

      Dooku: You'd strike an unarmed prisoner?
      Palpatine: Do it!
      Anakin: No! Its not the Jedi way. Dooku! In the name of the Galactic Senate of the Republic, you are under arrest Count Dooku.
      Dooku: Thank you, my boy. Please help me up to my feet. I could use a hand.
      Anakin: A hand is all I've got thanks to you.
      Palpatine: Ooooooooh! That burn must have hurt more than the lightsaber burn. Savage Anakin!

    • @wta1518
      @wta1518 4 года назад +2

      Dooku: “unhand me Jedi scum”
      Anakin: “If you say so”

    • @nursmalik6024
      @nursmalik6024 4 года назад +2

      Bruh

  • @slasherhero9795
    @slasherhero9795 5 лет назад +19

    Palpatine: Dooku took your arm!
    Anakin: And I took his hands.

  • @bboye.musical9349
    @bboye.musical9349 7 лет назад +113

    Obi and Plo were fodder? C'mon bro, fodder?

  • @sanstheskeleton4285
    @sanstheskeleton4285 4 года назад +15

    Dooku: *gets decapitated*
    Him: I think he's alive

  • @TheFrew
    @TheFrew 8 лет назад +540

    I personally don't see Mace Windu dying to Maul but thats just me XD

    • @Nathan-uc6zb
      @Nathan-uc6zb 8 лет назад +19

      TheFrew or obi one

    • @TheFrew
      @TheFrew 8 лет назад +20

      See I feel as if he could die to Sidious that dude is op I feel as if when Obi wan came he would fight Maul and Windu would fight Sidious

    • @darthmalak190
      @darthmalak190 8 лет назад +52

      I feel the same way. Windu would be too much for Maul. I don't believe that in Episode III Palpatine let Windu win. He wasn't toying with him. I believe that Windu won fair and square. Maul couldn't touch Windu on his best day. Then again, Maul did defeat Qui-Gon. Then again, Maul was defeated by an older padawan, Kenobi. Theories. Lovin it.

    • @TheFrew
      @TheFrew 8 лет назад +23

      I doubt it vapad is op man

    • @ante1
      @ante1 8 лет назад +7

      #TeamMace

  • @Chelseacarefree-nm8tm
    @Chelseacarefree-nm8tm 7 лет назад +554

    Mace losing to maul just doesn't do it for me.

    • @bigdeal3459
      @bigdeal3459 7 лет назад +67

      ikr,like seriously.ITS MACE MUTHAFUCKIN WINDU

    • @Guardian0101
      @Guardian0101 7 лет назад +5

      OK let me ask you this because at least one person in that fight was going to get injured or killed who do you think it should have been

    • @neutralchicken7682
      @neutralchicken7682 7 лет назад +54

      2in1 He freakin nearly killed Palpatine xD

    • @thealmightyderp5117
      @thealmightyderp5117 7 лет назад +14

      I think it would of been better if obi died

    • @onord2425
      @onord2425 7 лет назад +32

      yes
      because mace is using vaaypad and maul full of hatred

  • @cobra3667
    @cobra3667 5 лет назад +141

    The council: Go and save palpatine
    Obi Wan and Anakin: no.
    *WRITTEN AND DIRECTED BY GEORGE LUCAS*

  • @themightycrixus1131
    @themightycrixus1131 3 года назад +51

    This really is one of the most badass channels on youtube. Lucas Films really owes a lot to you and your work and its a shame what they did to the sequel trilogy. It derailed a lot of careful speculation that you and the fans have fairly made. We could have seen a way better conclusion for our characters. Thank you for all your work Star Wars Theory!

    • @UnitedWars
      @UnitedWars Год назад

      Fan fictions shouldn’t dictate a film trilogy

    • @themightycrixus1131
      @themightycrixus1131 Год назад

      @@UnitedWars the new trilogy was fan fiction.... The bad kind

    • @UnitedWars
      @UnitedWars Год назад

      @@themightycrixus1131 yeah okay

    • @themightycrixus1131
      @themightycrixus1131 Год назад

      @@UnitedWars i trust Star wars theory way more than I do Kathleen Kennedy with staying true to lore and telling a compelling story.

    • @themightycrixus1131
      @themightycrixus1131 Год назад

      @@UnitedWars why did Kathleen have Rey and Kylo kiss? Because of all the ReyLo shippers..... That is fan fiction in itself...

  • @Thinkmore807
    @Thinkmore807 6 лет назад +508

    I thought it was a great video but the part where Mace Windu lost to Darth Maul is just plain stupid.

    • @jynxed66six54
      @jynxed66six54 6 лет назад +15

      depends. the best fight weve seen to judge his strength is jango, who isnt exactly a sith. the fight he had with palp isnt really fair to use, since its entirely possible, if not most likely, that he let mace gain the upper hand to ensure anakin would turn. let me put the events in order so you can see just how likely this is
      palp knows anakin is going to get a jedi master. anakin said so. he also knows mace is the only counsel member in the area, as the others have left on missions.
      mace and anakin dont get along. every time anakin has tried to progress, mace shut him down. the relationship is rocky, and hes the jedi anakin is least likely to trust.
      next, palp tells anakin hes a sith, knowing that at that point palp could take him on. but instead, anakin leaves to tell the only jedi master on the planet.
      immediately after the fight starts, palp kills the other jedi. these guys are the only ones there who would have protested they kill a surrendering palp. the only one left was mace, known for using the dark side of the force to aid him in combat.
      next, he sensed anakin coming, as he knew the arrogant boy would, and faked a surrender. but mace wouldnt accept it.
      then anakin, who was in the middle of regretting killing a surrendering sith (which palp made him do) was watching a jedi master about to do the same thing. he had already decided this wasnt how jedi act, and begged mace to stop. all the while, palp begged for his life. when mace went for the killing blow, anakin saw how the jedi were not the force of light they claim to be. a jedi was acting in the same way they were told sith act.
      all of this was done by palp to get anakin on his own side. if anakin walked in on palp killing mace, his turn would never happen. so instead, palp fakes a loss to get his apprentice. this is why we cant use the palp fight to judge how strong mace is, so we cant really say he would beat or lose to maul. so its whatever the plot demands!

    • @dylanb1812
      @dylanb1812 6 лет назад +41

      Joseph Payne George Lucas has literally said that mace windu best palpatine. End of story

    • @jynxed66six54
      @jynxed66six54 6 лет назад +2

      @@dylanb1812 prove it

    • @CraigMcGuinn
      @CraigMcGuinn 6 лет назад +6

      TOXIC SQUIRELS maul was an assassin in the original timeline, but he was palpatine’s apprentice in this timeline...remember that maul beat qui-gon as an assassin and only lost to obi-wan because he let his guard down before finishing his mission

    • @co8wei
      @co8wei 5 лет назад +20

      "Okay, well, this sequence always started out with Mace overpowering Palpatine, and then Palpatine using his powers to try to destroy Mace, and Mace deflecting his rays with his lightsaber. And it always was that Anakin cut the lightsaber out of his hand. But this part where he pretends to lose his power and be weak was something that I added later, 'cause this is, it moved the point where Anakin turns down to this moment right here, and you can see now, that it's very clear that he's, he, he wants him to go on trial so he can pump him for information about how to get these powers."
      - Revenge of the Sith commentary, narrated by George Lucas
      Mace legitimately won the duel, he was Overpowering Palpatine. The quote also states that Palpatine only started faking weakness after Anakin arrives and not before. The part after the disarming and retreat into a corner by Sidious and him feigning weakness is irrelevant though because at that point Anakin interferes.
      Sidious purposely throwing the whole fight is just a fan theory with no canon proof to back it up.

  • @williampayne5709
    @williampayne5709 5 лет назад +134

    Sidious would have attacked anakin, and dooku

    • @arshygohardy
      @arshygohardy 5 лет назад +1

      Ya he had the potential to take out both dooku and anakin easily

    • @diobrando5896
      @diobrando5896 5 лет назад +1

      @@alexmote6779 Obi-Wan was unconscious. If dooku started to talk Palpatine would use a slight Force pull on Anakin's lightsaber to behead him And Gaslight him.

    • @nathanforbes8417
      @nathanforbes8417 5 лет назад

      He was shackled to the chair because he had been “captured” by Grievous

    • @williamwest9204
      @williamwest9204 5 лет назад

      And lost to anakin.

    • @SG-ys6fu
      @SG-ys6fu 5 лет назад

      He would have killed them and would use Kenobi (because He was unconsious at that Moment, but saw them fight bevor) as witness, so he could say, that they fought and killed each other.

  • @vinnielucci1099
    @vinnielucci1099 5 лет назад +54

    The storyline could have changed only by one second

  • @welk6913
    @welk6913 3 года назад +12

    I know I'm obviously late AF but I thought that it was an amazing story. I think you completely nailed what it would have been like. I enjoyed that very much, you are truly gifted. Thank you!

  • @jesseterlouw4526
    @jesseterlouw4526 6 лет назад +645

    Maul could not kill mace windu.

    • @xavierlauzac5922
      @xavierlauzac5922 6 лет назад +37

      Jesse Terlouw remember, in this timeline, he is up against a MUCH more powerful Darth maul.

    • @MuShinnen
      @MuShinnen 6 лет назад +162

      @@xavierlauzac5922 It still wouldn't matter. Naturally speaking, Maul was a great duelist, but a weakling in regards to using the force. Training would help him utilize it more effectively, but still wouldn't make it stronger. On top of that, Mace is a master duelist, in vaapad. Maul's dark side strength would only enhance mace's combat. Finally, Mace has much more combat experience over Maul. I'm sorry, but in no alternative universe does Sidious have time to make Maul an equal to Mace.

    • @xavierlauzac5922
      @xavierlauzac5922 6 лет назад

      MuShinnen um, no.

    • @MuShinnen
      @MuShinnen 6 лет назад +97

      @@xavierlauzac5922 Vaapad is literally meant to counter those who fight with the dark side. All that would happen is maul getting himself killed. Google Vaapad. You'll realize "um, no" is not a proper response. Mace outclasses Maul in every category. Experience, Vaapad, force manipulation, Shatterpoint.

    • @stitcherquet3709
      @stitcherquet3709 6 лет назад +47

      @@xavierlauzac5922 sounds like everyone else who doesnt have any facts or knowledge, just straight up denial haha

  • @darkdamacgenious
    @darkdamacgenious 8 лет назад +166

    people love to kill off windu as if he is nothing, only yoda was stronger than windu.

    • @autismalert2788
      @autismalert2788 7 лет назад +13

      Darin Johnson I think even that Is questionable, Mace is extremely strong. I think it could go either way if he went against Yoda but ey

    • @B4h4muth
      @B4h4muth 7 лет назад +12

      Yoda is way more powerfull than Windu when it comes to the Force, but even in the book is said that Windu's Vapad makes him one of the best duelist ever.

    • @kevinthunder3375
      @kevinthunder3375 7 лет назад +5

      Darin Johnson Anakin was far stronger in the Force than Mace Windu lol.

    • @kecu0
      @kecu0 7 лет назад +12

      +Kevin Thunder Yoda was stronger than Windu in knowledge and use of the Force, but the two were extremely powerful duellists. Honestly, it's hard to say who would win, since the two of them were masters of different styles, yet equally as skilled.
      Anakin was stronger in his natural Force abilities (or Midichlorian count....god, I feel dirty saying that); but Mace was no push-over himself, and had the advantage of experience. Furthermore, in a lightsaber fight, Mace would have owned Anakin's arse any day of the week.

    • @bigsmoke7853
      @bigsmoke7853 7 лет назад

      Kage lol

  • @jaykikak7229
    @jaykikak7229 5 лет назад +387

    Even if maul had a buff, mace would still clap his cheeks easy

    • @kevingibson7654
      @kevingibson7654 5 лет назад +9

      Not to mention anakin is like 2 or 3 years away from being able to one shot mace and Yoda.

    • @TheFattestLInHistory
      @TheFattestLInHistory 5 лет назад

      lol

    • @liljdiamond2245
      @liljdiamond2245 5 лет назад +2

      Not true at all I would destroy mace windu in a couple seconds of the duel

    • @vect0r279
      @vect0r279 5 лет назад +6

      Not easily but Windu would defeat Maul in a duel or at the very least hold his own long enough for Yoda and Anakin (who from what i understood was pretty much at same level Windu was at the time of this event) to arrive. Overall no chance for Maul like him but...Just no way

    • @herculesismymiddlename7919
      @herculesismymiddlename7919 5 лет назад +6

      If maul had a buff mace would actually beat him easier

  • @herbmaaster
    @herbmaaster 3 года назад +5

    thank you for throwing yourself into these characters with a deep understanding and respect. you have my sincere gratitude.

  • @Gamingetic
    @Gamingetic 5 лет назад +31

    Palpatine: kills Padme
    Anakin: goes godmode on some sons of b’s

  • @zalentoptier
    @zalentoptier 5 лет назад +104

    Darth maul could not battle yoda without dying within 3 seconds. Yoda is the most powerful and skilled Jedi of all time.

    • @bs2202
      @bs2202 5 лет назад +29

      You forgot about the Gonk Droid

    • @shadows_star
      @shadows_star 5 лет назад +9

      I doubt it, you gotta remember that this Maul was stated to have trained with Palpatine for this moment for a couple years.

    • @LZBruh
      @LZBruh 5 лет назад +7

      I dont think maul will win against windu

    • @aaronwood43
      @aaronwood43 5 лет назад +1

      Yah Luke or Yoda

    • @fishergunner42
      @fishergunner42 5 лет назад +2

      pretty sure luke surpassed him in the eu

  • @duskmike8526
    @duskmike8526 4 года назад +27

    Anakin: Kill dooku without consequences
    Also anakin: hE mUSt StaND TrIaL

  • @LupisGoat
    @LupisGoat 4 года назад +42

    Yoda: "The time here it is, Execute order 65."

  • @parablevision7166
    @parablevision7166 7 лет назад +552

    Mace losing to maul wouldn’t happen

    • @jakegrey5405
      @jakegrey5405 6 лет назад +31

      I also think this

    • @sadjustsad
      @sadjustsad 6 лет назад +28

      Yeah maybe he would be losing but he wouldn’t lose he would be slower since he would be older but he would still be nearly as strong as a super powerful darth maul.

    • @kablatai
      @kablatai 6 лет назад +42

      They both mastered the same lightsaber skills, but Maces Power:Shadow Point would be the edge in the fight

    • @Gennnnnnnnnnnn
      @Gennnnnnnnnnnn 6 лет назад +13

      Kablatai shatter point

    • @jacksonbashiri8118
      @jacksonbashiri8118 6 лет назад +3

      Agree i do

  • @cahlelbarthlow6685
    @cahlelbarthlow6685 4 года назад +145

    every theory: oh, and also sidious killed padme

    • @mechengr1731
      @mechengr1731 3 года назад +5

      And sometimes gets maul to join him?

    • @SomeGuy_Somewhere
      @SomeGuy_Somewhere 3 года назад +1

      @@mechengr1731 wouldn't maul just murder sidious?

  • @OppressiveMaul
    @OppressiveMaul 8 лет назад +162

    Do what If Anakin joined the son and Left Mortis together

    • @boldnbrash5646
      @boldnbrash5646 8 лет назад +3

      I would like to see that and What if they remembered everything that happened on Mortis

    • @OppressiveMaul
      @OppressiveMaul 8 лет назад

      True Blue Hero they did except anakins vision of the future Anakin even discussed it with Yoda afterwards

    • @boldnbrash5646
      @boldnbrash5646 8 лет назад

      Oh my mistake I haven't watched the clone wars in awhile, it would still be cool if Anakin remembered his visions

    • @Boofus90
      @Boofus90 8 лет назад +1

      Luan Birch I'm sure they will both have done the purge of the Jedi temple

    • @OppressiveMaul
      @OppressiveMaul 8 лет назад +1

      Darth Vader if we've learned anything from Star Wars it's that the sith and the Jedi tend to form a coalition when events such as this happen such as vitiate, Revan and the eternal throne it would be cool to see Sidious and dooku and Yoda and the Jedi council reaching out to each other to fight them both

  • @turbkeysamdwich1880
    @turbkeysamdwich1880 3 года назад +4

    2:44
    Palpatine: He took your arm.
    Anakin: and I took his hands, now we’re even.