CLIP: Boston Dynamics Atlas vs. Tesla Optimus
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 апр 2024
- Boston Dynamics announced their new and improved Atlas robot - the next step in commercializing their humanoid robot development. We look at how it compares to Tesla's Optimus robot. #robotics #robots #tech #bostondynamics #tesla
Наука
Comparimg boston dynamics to tesla is like comparing a sports car to a skateboard, both move, one just does it better.
In that sequence?
He is right tho, Boston Dynamics is a century ahead of Tesla. Not literally duhh
Tesla's AI driven software stack (derived from their autopilot work) is extremely impressive but their hardware is only about 2 years old. Boston's hardware is extremely mature but their software is still fairly basic and doesn't incorporate nearly as much AI. The real question is which one is more important -- great hardware or great software?
more like a bugatti and toyota. Boston Dynamics does have better performance but it is certainly gonna be hard to mass product the Atlas. Optimus is built with the purpose to mass produce and actually impact the industry.
@@user-sl1mg9co4x Mass producing optimus might be the long term goal, but the current version isnt even close to being mass production ready. The entire robot is made out of cnc parts, which are both extremely expensive and extremely time consuming to make.
This is like Stark Industries vs Hammer Industries.
I, for one, welcome our new Robot Overlords
[This comment is being reviewed by the Ministry of Truth]
there are special padded rooms for comments like that....
@@dougohboy5190 Resistance is futile
@@dougohboy5190 Also comedy rooms packed with patrons, with drinks served in the back 😂
Me 2
"Optimus" is Latin for "Elon promises it will do this next year"
"Next year, for sure"
There’s just no comparison between Boston and Tesla. Just look at Atlas, it moves like a living thing, and that’s the old retired one. Boston is like 10 years ahead of anything else.
For for them to retire a robot that’s that sophisticated they realy must’ve made something mind boggling.
Yeah lmao Tesla can barely even walk, Boston dynamics is just on a whole different level with how smooth their robots move, like just compare boston's robot atlas literally just jumping to the Tesla robot trying it's best to walk, not even a fair comparison.
@@marcxworld5708 Yeah lmao, Boston Dynamics was founded 30 years ago, the Tesla Optimus CONCEPT was introduced 3 years ago. Go figure.
@@thomaslilly5834 That's not the point. The point is that people are touting Optimus as competition to Boston Dynamics's Atlas, which is like saying a Homemade Go-Cart is Competition for a Ferrari.
@@Breakdown5297 It is actually kind of ironic that by saying "that's not the point", you are missing the point completely.
Again: Boston Dynamics had 30 years to develop their line of robots. OF COURSE they are much better, and years ahead. THE POINT IS that Tesla (and other companies) only needed 3 years to develop a product that, while not being there yet, is catching up with incredible speed. So maybe in a year or two, they may start being competitive.
guy at the end is definitely a robot
kiss good by to your jobs.....
@@dougohboy5190 As the video says, these AI can only perform specific jobs.
You reckon he was made by Boston Dynamics or Tesla?
Optimus is clearly the virgin and Atlas the chad. Optimus plays chess while Atlas does parkour
One is controlled by people (Boston dynamics) and the other is controlled by AI (Tesla bot)
@@TuneyDarko you belive that because... Elon said so? Like all the things he said were always truth, right?
if you happened figured it out yet Optimus is 100% bs shouldn't even be included when discussing robotics
"machine.. i will cut you down."
+ricoshot
+parried
"Break you apart, and splay the gore of your profane form across the stars"
I hope they don’t paint it blue and give it wings
that would make an awesome april fools video
it took me a second to get the reference
ULTRAKILL REFERENCE
Or make them look like automatons
mf throws a coin once and we can say bye bye to our lifes
lol Teslabot is a guy in spandex 😂😂😂😂
They actualy made robot. Its just its about 20 years behind Bostons Dynamic. It works only in pre-programed enviroment with no obstacles. It can only move in pre-programed path and needs markers in the enviroment to know where it is and where it should move.
And even with all this, it still needs multiple attempts to move from point A to point B while holding box without some kind of problems. You can find their video on youtube.
And that is probably all that we ever will see from Musk on robotics. He made big promises, delivered pre-pre-pre-prealpha product and now he will pretend as if he never bragged about his venture into robotics
@@iglidor while I agree that Tesla robot is significantly behind in terms of hardware. 20 years is a massive overstatement. Also the claim that the Tesla robot only operates in preprogrammed ways couldn't be farther from true. The whole point of the robot was, that Tesla is extraordinarily good at mapping the outside world into a model, a computer (car or robot) can use. I wouldn't be surprised if the software of the Tesla bot is actually superior to Boston dynamics software. You wouldn't notice that fact though because everything hardware related is so far behind.
@@brockmann4815 Have you watched their promotional videos where they showcased their robot?
There are distinct markers placed in places where they want their robot to go. Because their robot was unable to properly map outside world. It is extraordinarily BAD at mapping outside world.
And that is in THEIR promotional video where they were showing only what they wanted and where they covered as much problems as they could. And still failed since they were kinda lazy about it and it was obvious that their video is spliced from multiple attempts because they could not get even a single clean run of their test.
@@iglidor Hate on them all you want, but something tells me you have no idea about image recognition. I'm actually studying in that field and worked with image recognition. Markers are used to train the robots neural network object recognition. In their showcase from 11 months ago you actually see the international representation which doesn't use markers at all. It places dots where the area is obstructed and that's essentially how such a representation is implemented. The Tesla fsd does it the same way although in a more complex manner. So now add a few years of tweaking that software to the requirements and sensors of the robot and you get a fairly capable model. The first step is representing physical space, the second step is object recognition, and the third step is efficiency and capability of movement. The Tesla bot is progressing at a far faster pace than Boston dynamics. It'll probably take years before they have a compatible model, but certainly not decades.
You seem to be biased on the topic too. You seem to hate Tesla itself and therefore insist that Tesla produces 'lazily done' videos where they can't get a single perfect take. That's just how musks companies operate. Hardware and failure rich testing improves the rate of improvement.
I think that dudes job been replaced by a machine now..
The Tesla robots seem so lifeless while Boston Dynamics robots are literally walking around like they are a living and breathing being
BD retired Atlas because it has no practicality, inefficient, prohibitively expensive, dangerous with hydraulic system. So much for like life movement. Tesla said no thanks to that relic. Good thing BD took inspiration and developing Atlas 2.0.
@@nguyep4lol if you think Boston Dynamics highly articulate and mobile Atlas 2 took inspiration from the geriatric stiff walker known as Optimus you’re very delusional. The moment Boston Dynamics makes one video with Atlas 2 they’ll still be well over a decade ahead of Tesla.
@@themadskeptic9316they are LITERALLY decades ahead of Tesla. Boston started 30 years ago, while Tesla had only 2 years.
I’m not convinced that the Tesla Bot is a serious project. Never seen it do anything physically interesting. Pretty sure it’s just a PR thing for Elon. Atlas is ALWAYS impressive, though. They really thought outside the box with this one already.
Never trust a project hyped by Elon. Literally a con.
Corporate Robot War incoming.
No-no, war is in the jurisdiction of governments, so they're going to buy the technology THEN use it for war.
New fast food worker
The new atlas robots fist looks like it would deal massive damage
gen 1 robot boxer from Real Steel: coming soon
+Parry
+Shotgun Boost
+Down to Size
+Cannonballed
+Fist full of dollar
If they're doing jobs, they're taking jobs. I may be inevitable, but facts is facts.
“They’ll only take jobs humans don’t want to do.”
Wait, so they’re taking all the jobs?
Then again, I say it's perfectly fine if they take the jobs that often end in human injury or death. Underwater welding is the first that comes to mind.
What I DON'T want to see is robots taking jobs for human creativity (AI artists/writers in Hollywood.)
@@Leekodot15 Even if they do it better?
Sooo should we get rid of automobiles, to bring back the horse and buggy, so that sh💩t shovelers can get their precious jobs back?? 🤷🏾
@@Tonabillity No. As I said, it's inevitable that technology replaces jobs. But we shouldn't deny that is what's happening and it's a problem. Some people try to play it down and deny the negative impact. I'm just suggesting we do things mindfully with eyes wide open.
V1 ultrakill
Grippers? 🤨
Design to grip your balls
automaton lore boutta be crazyyyyyyyyyyyyy
People don't want the "dirty" jobs because employers only offer enough money to make the job viable for a subsidized migrant.
I kind of wonder if/when VR tech will start being used in conjunction with these kinds of bots. I could see it for situations where the human body is just very well suited to the situation, but the environment itself is hostile to the human body, so they send in one of these Atlases instead but control it with a VR headset and controllers
yep those jobs are sometimes the jobs that people need or can only do what then
New Battlebots FullSize! In the Red corner, Tesla's Optimus with a sword, VS Atlas by Boston Dynamics, with just a shield, in the blue corneeeeeerrrrr.
Don’t worry Optimus will stumble and impale itself and Atlas will be dancing on its defeated opponent.
Greed/// Climax
Clair de Soleil
Atlas is going whoop every robot's shiny metal @$$.
Just remember, YOU ARE the carbon they wish to reduce.
The robots will define which jobs you don't "want".
They should give atlas a ultrakill makeover.
Will we see this robots working in airport terminals, or mine shafts one day?
It's not a matter of which is currently better, but which is advancing more quickly.
The current rate of innovation does not predict future rates, I expect it to look like a logistical curve in the long term. The question remains where on the curve is each company and where will they end up on the curve in 5 or 10 years.
The face of the new robot reminds me of the face of the robot in the new incarnation of Lost in space that I believe was on Netflix
Whoever has most money wins
As long as the job people don't like is still a job that people can do, a robot performing the task will always take someone's job from them. I don't like this at all, lord know we have enough unemployed. But sadly this is nothing new, we been getting rid of or streamlining jobs with technological advancement since forever.
Soon there will be universal income for all and people will be hooked into vr and won't leave their pods.... For their own good, OF COURSE 😉
literally the most exciting thing
Terminator
I have yet to see footage of optimus that looks realistic.
Ther taekin ure jobes 😡
Dukudooo!
Honesty, why not just both them (turn into one)
Edit: also if they can do cleaning stuff then is worth it
How about “capable of working a 12 hour day without complaining or filing a workman’s comp claim”
Which one would I buy none of the above
Don’t be fools. Eventually robots will take jobs. Why would a company not invest in robots that need no sleep, no insurance no food essentially no comfortable heat possibly. It’s a matter of time. The question will be how will displaced workers be taken care of.
bro really called them grippers ☠️☠️☠️
I hope they make R2-D2, C-3PO, an atlas Titan from Titanfall, Astro Boy, an autonomous Iron Man suit that is actually just a robot.
I could see the Atlas models in an industrial setting. But I can also tell which of the two is likely to be the consumer model that sells 100x more units. Especially if only one of them gets access to AI training on custom-made AI chip arrays.
Collaboration will do better and faster
"It could SERVE a variety of functions" - I think sooner or later they're gonna have a word about that.
I'm all for robots taking our jobs, I mean there's a massive labor shortage and has been for years. But can we all agree these things need a speed limit? If they can go faster than 5mph that's an issue
Commercialization is the way to reach the masses and then only comes domination.
Why is teslabot even spoken of in this video. 1 has actual robots and the other has a person dressed up in a suit doing the Charleston
Keep summer safe
If it can do anything autonomously it’s better than the Tesla bot, that thing needs a human operator at all times.
what if u want a pleasure bot?
Когда они создадут модель Т-2000 начнется самое интересное...
The Tesla bot may take away our factory jobs, but the follow-on ATLAS has the potential to take away more general and broader categories of jobs done by humans such as combat soldiers clearing muddy trenches.
Trust me, tesla bot is not taking anything. It's ridiculous that it's even compared to something like bd
DO NOT let Atlas get a hold of a revolver and spare change!
I think you don't understand much about robotics, or understand that Tesla has made something very rudimentary.
Tesla is in major financial problems right now, and their bot is basically a grift on stock price. It's a car company.
Don’t worry, Elon promised us it will happen, so surely everything will be on schedule and turn out as expected.
Optimus doesn't have a chance! Atlas really moves like the robots we watched in movies! Actually I need they interchange heads that's all.
As a blind man, can i please have a version of spot? Would literally change my life to have something like that
You can buy spot, the entry model costs $74,500 but doesn’t include any of the accessories.
Some creating body and some creating Ai brain
I liked the old funky one😂
All the problems with other robots is the joints.
Sure they won't replace us, for now...
boston 30 anos de tecnologia e evolucao
I cant wait for the Robo Olympics
Tesla Optimus
it will be good if the robot is able to repair by itself.
Wen mass production. Can we have atlas and Optimus start to produce themselves?
"Robots aren't here to take your jobs, they're here to augment people!"
But isn’t a job we don’t want what most of us have?
Boston dynamics is building soldiers.
First time im seeing a walking camera lens 😂😂
Gabriel ultrakill first time he sees V1
Atlas was human controlled mostly while Tesla bot is mostly all AI
Even if that was true, and there's no evidence to indicate such, the fact the Tesla bot needs to be harnessed in indicates that Tesla is far behind r&d when it comes to motion and movement
@@TealBeal11 Atlas HD was a path algorithm that was programmed for the robot to walk on, the Tesla bot being all AI would be able to make its own ai generative path compared to a human made algorithmic path, best way to explain it is like Toribash in some sense
Jobs most rich people don’t want but poor people need
Elon fanboys are like "nooo but Atlas is hard-coded, Optimus runs on an adaptive AI 😭". Really? Tesla CARS have failed AI self-driving for YEARS but they can make something that's 1000x more complex?
B.D. has been doing this for decades already. Literally. But its mainly programming/directed movement more focused on the mechanics. Tesla is newish to the game and is starting with self guided robotics. Honestly if you put them together youd have a halfway decent terminator
hardware is the limiting factor in robotics, so BD has a huge lead, who cares about advanced AI if it moves like that
i prefer my seegson. He makes great mashed potatoes.
It blows my mind when they say robots are here to do jobs we don't want to do.
None of us want to jobs we don't like!
The problem is, we HAVE to!
So every robot manufacturer that says they are here to help is exactly the same as employers saying we care about your future😂😂😂
If a robot can do a job, don’t need to be paid monthly, don’t takes holiday, don’t organise themselves in union, end up being the cheapest labour ever, and eventually with higher productivity, which CEO will say no to that we have to keep human in the loop?
Comparing these two is just silly. They aren't remotely in the same league. Atlas is doing flips while Optimus can barely walk in a straight line, on perfectly level ground, at sub-geriatric speeds.
Hahaha. Reality is companies with replace humans with as many robots as possible
Very Amazing!!
😊🎉
The flexible robot is perfect for Power Rangers!
Next step, SkyNet.
Tesla has a robot?
Shouldn't this video be about whether *IT* can compete with Boston Dynamics?
In ten years we will all be jobless
Augment... people...?
plts cable charge sky longitude
No one wants a job, most of us do it for money. 90% of all jobs are dull or boring.
Yeah okay buddy, there coming for our jobs.
The tesla bot will be a mass produced with die cast and plastic injected parts. The precision parts in the evaluators will be what drives the cost. If they can punch these out cheaply, the robot should be affordable. The Boston Dynamics robot doesn't look like it's designed for affordability.
Break the machines!
And yet ask any LLM and they will tell you that the one thing they hate doing is meaningless, repetitive tasks.
You all need to watch Terminator 2, Judgment Day.
The VHS 📼 tape I found had a lot of distortion 😢
You will change your mind once it takes your job. The robots/AI are already smarter/stronger to do specific jobs than human.
Optimus got that biden walk down.
White collar and blue collar robots 😂😂
Interesting
Worst idea in the next 50 years: Over-the-air updates for humanoid robots.
Pelosi will be pissed if these bots learn to pick fruits and veggies. Running out of excuses right Nancy?
I like to see Atlas robot perform that stunts in public seems to me its only CGI made.
tesla robotics manage to make that robot in 2 years or so while boston took them 10 years to where they are now.