YUP! I recognized his voice on the recording but I doubted myself so I came to see the live just to see if it was actually him singing the high note. Gotta love Minhyuk. xD
i love how they gave rocky a spotlight, they put him in a center huhu (with smoke effects or whatever) MA BOI DESERVES IT!!! astro deserves more recognition y'all sleepyheads! 😭💜💜💜
How can people dislike this performance...?? It was a FABULOUS performance.. ARTISTIC It was owned by MJ and Rocky I wonder why Rocky did not sing in other live performances... It was great to watch him hit those high notes like a pro.
Reading the older comments and knowing what WE know now about Astro as a whole and the subunits...Rocky's solo CPR, right?! And it's September 2022 and he had a musical part in The Three Musketeers as D'artanon (?sp). They've come so far, but I do so miss their antics as OT6.
MJ’s high note is *iconic.* ASTRO deserves more love. I remember the first time I found out about ASTRO. I was doing my Math homework and I couldn’t really think of a K-pop band or a K-pop song so I just decided to check them. It was “All Light”. The first ASTRO album that got me into them. The moment I heard “All Night”I just felt like it was the title and it was!. I fell in love with all of the songs, especially “Bloom”. I really couldn’t believe that I could fall in love with a K-pop group that fast, but I did. And I am proud of myself because I decided to check ASTRO, and now, here I am. As an AROHA. They are all so multitalented and if you’re still not part of this beautiful fandom. Well, you are *missing out.* Why do so many people just notice Dongmin because of his visual?. He is indeed very handsome but he is way more than that you know. He is called a “face genius” because of his visuals but he can play many instruments, he’s smart and is able to sing beautifully. He is not only a visual.
I'm a new one . At first yes it's because cha eunwoo visual that introduce me to astro but now.. i don't really think about his visual cause he has a good multitalent and the other member are amazing too.. I still amazed by his visual but not as much as last time..🙂
@@bellariana6266 concordo com você, mesmo porque se nós formos falar de visual eu acho que Astro todo é visual. Não descriminou arohas que acha Eunwoo o visual. Pois é a opinião dela, e para mim o Rocky é o visual. Tem quem acha do Moonbin, tem quem acha o Sanha, Jinjin, MJ. Tem para todas, mais cada uma com o seu bias. Agora dizer que só o Eunwoo é o visual, não concordo ❤️
i love ASTRO because all of the members aport something to the group. They have different styles and personalities but they sound so good together. They will be more and more succesfull, i know it. Love you ASTRO. Aroha forever
August 2020 anyone? Their voices still make me cry especially my baby rocky's highnotes T-T 02:0002:45 ROCKY'S HIGHNOTES IN THE BACK OMGGGG MOM I CRRYYYY 02:49 wtf rockkyyyy soo purrfeectt
2022 and still listening to this song... It was the first Astro song I heard and even though I'm not their fan I will always cherish this song as one of my favorite.
Coming here after the news because this is my comfort song. Moonbin, you will always be missed but I hope you're at peace now. I will forever remember you. Thank you for everything.
2021 but i still cry to this song. The fact that rocky is the lead rapper but he can hit high notes.. talented boy indeed. Astro world domination please. Rocky is so talented but he is a bit underrated. But for me this is the best
i just found this video a few days ago and i still cant believe how freaking amazing rocky is. i know he's amazing but this really blew my mind. he's so so talented and a gem of astro!! maaaan, rocky has it all.
I fell love at first sight to CHA Eun woo, I amaze MJ his voice and characters Mj make me happy always, I'm so proud of Rocky his amazing, SANHA is so adorable, Moonbin make me uncomfortable 🙈 sshhh🙊🙉 And I fall in love with JINJIN 😍😍😍
Little did they know, they'll have a win in a couple of months and another win the next year. I'm so proud of knowing them since day one, following them and hearing their music makes me the happiest person alive.
I wonder why people are sleeping on their talent. This is one the most beautiful song I have ever heard. I don't understand korean yet I was moved by this song and wanted to cry. Later I read the translation of this song and I was so surprised that how easily these boys conveyed the emotion behind this song to their audience .This is such a beautiful song and these boys are pure talent.
Anyone in 2021!!! 😭❤️ Still my heart aches while listening to this song... I can't even understand this language without translation..but this music and their voice are so soothing 🎶❤️ music has no boundaries 💜🎶 #Aroha #Astro💜
Can we just talk about how Rocky’s rapping voice and singing sound lowkey different?. The first time I heard him sing (not in real life. In RUclips :V) was when he sang “Hide and Seek”. His singing voice is so cute!. I love it!.
MJ and Rocky 😱 they left me breathless that you notice without a doubt beautiful But in itself the whole song is beautiful together with all the voices of the Astro members, the best 😍💖
omg this song gives me goosebumps i am happy this is the only live that i have found out that rocky does his high note part live than playback. THIS should be every time they have performed this live... i'm sad and mad about that he couldn't in other lives :((
have you heard him doing the high notes in When The Wind Blows? I have the links if you want to hear it. Please check it out! 😂 ruclips.net/video/PAf1LVWQQlE/видео.html (When The Wind Blows Rocky guide version) have fun hearing this and stay safe +stream astro knock music video ❤😂
![너라서(Because It's You) - The 2nd ASTROAD to Seoul [STAR LIGHT]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RAMg97lXGgI/mqdefault.jpg)
![너라서(Because It's You) - The 2nd ASTROAD to Seoul [STAR LIGHT]](/img/tr.png)
![ASTRO [🎹 First Love + Because It's You + My Style] 2017 The 1st ASTROAD to JAPAN](/img/1.gif)
2020 anyone? Rocky highnotes still make me cry every time i heard this song
2021: Still here crying
Me.. a new one tbh, but I did some research and I'm proud of him..
Same
Every day!!!
2021 here, still crying
I love always this song
at 1:59 its rocky(second voice to mj)
at 2:48 again rocky on his high note
OH MY GOD 🌌🌌🌌
CLEONOR 😥😷😍😍😙😙😙😙😙😙😘😘😘😘😚😚😚🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌
Oi 😢😢♡♡👊👍👎✌👌✌
Mj and rocky duet is amazing..😭❤️❤️
They gave the high note to a Rapper???😱😱
Wow! I'm so proud of Rocky, he's perfectly amazing! Whoooo!
He slayed😍😍😍😘😘😘
He has the vocalist position in his profile u know 😂😂😂 he's an awesome guy 💓
YUP! I recognized his voice on the recording but I doubted myself so I came to see the live just to see if it was actually him singing the high note.
Gotta love Minhyuk. xD
Yes, and he did it perfectly.
Rocky can do anything 😍
Can Rap Can Dance Can Cook and Can Sing+ Visuals his killing it
Quadro threat😍
That's my boy
Astro can do anything (｡◠‿◠｡)
i love how they gave rocky a spotlight, they put him in a center huhu (with smoke effects or whatever) MA BOI DESERVES IT!!! astro deserves more recognition y'all sleepyheads! 😭💜💜💜
Yaaaas!
2:48 WHOAH PARK MINHYUK !!!!!
R-O-C-K-Y
Mr.Perfect
-Rapper
-Extreme Visual
-Dancer
-Vocalist
-Cook
-Cute
-Swag
-Tease
Etc.❣❣❣❣
ROCKYYYYYYY
you forgot visual
@@riz2356 it says extreme visual
@@tantan_pies_arohamo the comment is edited out already it's been 6 months after my comment , lol
@@riz2356 biane
if y'all hear the studio version, Rocky sang his high notes too :) he just never sang it live till later
CLEONOR 😥 😷 😍 😍 😙 😙 😙 😙 😙 😘 😘 😘 🌌 🌌 🌌 🌌 📞 📞, mas
Oi 📞📞📞😩😩😷😷😢😢💖😩😩😩📞📞🌌🌌🌌
I wonder why
Bellariana02 maybe he didn't feel that confident enough to sing it yet
I didn't expect that rocky can sing a high note
He's dark horse
Anyone here in 2024?
Mee
here☝🏻
Yes...
Me too ✨
What tf is happening here???????? Are they really giving the highnote to a rapper?????? wow!!!! That' really great
Why is no one talking about their harmonization 😩😩💜💜
Ohhh yass😭😭😭❤❤❤
I think. We're too busy shocking cause of rocky highnotes
2:48 hell yeahhhhhhhhh Rocky is rocking that note❤️
Guys! I realized that when Rocky sings his high note he does it even higher than the studio version, Minhyuk came not to play, damn, is beautiful!
Mj and Rocky highnotes
Sanha and Bin vocals
Jinjin clear rap
Eunwoo piano skills
My babiess💞💞💞
The 180th like... 🤗
they had a beautiful blending voice
Also Rocky's rap
Send this to people who said astro can't sing live
Who said that? Nonsense
@@debbypermatasari54 some bitches
ASTRO ✡️
Mj and Rocky - highnotes
Sanha and Bin - extreme vocals
Jinjin - clear rap and deep voice
Eunwoo - vocals and piano skills
Talents 💞💕
wow, I actually didn9t expect Rocky's high note, damn..
the high notes are in the studio version though he rarely sings it live )): only a few notice it's rocky in the studio version and think its sanha ):
Rocky hitting the high note is crazy. You don’t expect from a rap line but he’s so versatile in anything!
I WISH THE WORLD KNOWS ROCKY'S EXISTENCE. 💜
How can people dislike this performance...??
It was a FABULOUS performance..
ARTISTIC
It was owned by MJ and Rocky
I wonder why Rocky did not sing in other live performances...
It was great to watch him hit those high notes like a pro.
i wish he sang it more live ): so that people actually know he has vocal lines in innocent love
2022 still here, appreciating their beautiful live vocals especially Rocky's high notes. who's with me?
Reading the older comments and knowing what WE know now about Astro as a whole and the subunits...Rocky's solo CPR, right?! And it's September 2022 and he had a musical part in The Three Musketeers as D'artanon (?sp). They've come so far, but I do so miss their antics as OT6.
Who is here after hearing Rocky's high notes in his own ballad song "CPR" from 2022 Restore album? He is indeed a great singer! Love his vocals!
Innocent love
Rocky: Rapping
Rocky: Singing
Rocky: Hitting hight notes
HE CAN DO EVERYTHING
Add dancing💜💜
MJ’s high note is *iconic.*
ASTRO deserves more love.
I remember the first time I found out about ASTRO.
I was doing my Math homework and I couldn’t really think of a K-pop band or a K-pop song so I just decided to check them.
It was “All Light”. The first ASTRO album that got me into them.
The moment I heard “All Night”I just felt like it was the title and it was!.
I fell in love with all of the songs, especially “Bloom”.
I really couldn’t believe that I could fall in love with a K-pop group that fast, but I did.
And I am proud of myself because I decided to check ASTRO, and now, here I am.
As an AROHA. They are all so multitalented and if you’re still not part of this beautiful fandom.
Well, you are *missing out.*
Why do so many people just notice Dongmin because of his visual?.
He is indeed very handsome but he is way more than that you know.
He is called a “face genius” because of his visuals but he can play many instruments, he’s smart and is able to sing beautifully.
He is not only a visual.
I'm a new one . At first yes it's because cha eunwoo visual that introduce me to astro but now.. i don't really think about his visual cause he has a good multitalent and the other member are amazing too.. I still amazed by his visual but not as much as last time..🙂
That's right...
It’s inevitable. His visuals screams attention even if he’s not doing anything.
@@bellariana6266 concordo com você, mesmo porque se nós formos falar de visual eu acho que Astro todo é visual. Não descriminou arohas que acha Eunwoo o visual. Pois é a opinião dela, e para mim o Rocky é o visual. Tem quem acha do Moonbin, tem quem acha o Sanha, Jinjin, MJ. Tem para todas, mais cada uma com o seu bias. Agora dizer que só o Eunwoo é o visual, não concordo ❤️
i love ASTRO because all of the members aport something to the group. They have different styles and personalities but they sound so good together. They will be more and more succesfull, i know it. Love you ASTRO. Aroha forever
I cry T.T
Fantagio always have multitalented person
I got goosbumps! YOU REALLY HIT THAT ROCKY! I just hope they will give him another high note😊
Have you seen their cover of Shinee's "Replay" ? He gets a high note there too. It's beautiful. xD
Same
August 2020 anyone? Their voices still make me cry especially my baby rocky's highnotes T-T
02:00 02:45 ROCKY'S HIGHNOTES IN THE BACK OMGGGG MOM I CRRYYYY
02:49 wtf rockkyyyy soo purrfeectt
Oh Rocky.,., You gave me goosebumps.,. and my ♥ beats very fast.,. 😭😭😭 im so happy and I'm in tears.,., just wow., Astro Astro Astro 💜💜💜💜💜💜
waaaahhhhh i can't believe that park minhyuk can sing like that. ........yieeeeee..😍😍😍
Noones gonna talk about Eunwoo playing piano? Im shookt and in love
That's my Rockyswag everyone!!! So proud!!! 😍💜
My bias rocky 👏👏👏😍❤️
ROCKY IS THERE ANYTHING THAT YOU CAN'T DO!!!??? YOU'RE TOO PERFECT😭😭😭❤❤❤❤
2:48 the spotlight for a more dramatic introduction of Rocky, the powerful vocalist..
i listen to this song long long time ago and today i just found out that rocky did that highnotes part, im gonna cry, beautifullll
okay first of all, ROCKY IS AMAZING.
but also, can we just appreicate mj and eunwoo’s heartfelt vocals?
02:03 Is It Rocky's High notes...I can't believe ....Superb.....Astro Is One and only best....❤💜️
2022 and still listening to this song... It was the first Astro song I heard and even though I'm not their fan I will always cherish this song as one of my favorite.
A rapper doing a high note is so amazing, I can't believe that Rocky is so good in his vocals.
Is Perfect!
My english no is so good :v
Im here after streaming ONE..
this is one of my fav.song of ASTRO..ill go back later to stream..
My curiosity brings me here to prove that ROCKY HIT THAT NOTE F*CKING NOTE!!!!! Rip my heart 🖤.. Rocky why do this to me 🤘👏👏👏🔥🔥🔥
2023 mi amor por esta canción y por ASTRO sigue siendo el mismo. ❤😊
2:44 Mj Started the highnote with a Combination voice by rocky
this song won't ever get old
MJ and Rocky!! 😍😍😍 #ASTRO
This is just make me more in love with rocky😍😘❤oh my god
Coming here after the news because this is my comfort song. Moonbin, you will always be missed but I hope you're at peace now. I will forever remember you. Thank you for everything.
Mj and Roclys High note I Cannot😞😞
I'm so Proud Of Our Babyss💕😞💕💞💕
2021 but i still cry to this song. The fact that rocky is the lead rapper but he can hit high notes.. talented boy indeed. Astro world domination please. Rocky is so talented but he is a bit underrated. But for me this is the best
Still here in 2021 - this song. Those vocals 😍🤩 Especially MJ and Rocky in the high notes 👌😍
Rocky is their secret weapon.
@ FANTAGIO MORE VOCAL LINES FOR MINHYUK OMG
Rocky singing the highnote will forever be iconic and I mean ICONIC.
2020 still hearing this song..they are the best
Rocky is proving to be their ace card... ✡️💜 I love all these guys. My bias is Eunwoo but I'm so confused now.
I don't why I always feel sad and cry whenever I listen to this song.Anyone in 2021?
Jin jin's clear rap. 💜💜💜 I'm inlove. 💜💜
THIS STAGE.ㅠㅠinnocent love deserves this. 💕
i just found this video a few days ago and i still cant believe how freaking amazing rocky is. i know he's amazing but this really blew my mind. he's so so talented and a gem of astro!! maaaan, rocky has it all.
OWW SO PERFECT ..PERFECT ASTRO ..ROCKY WOW PERFECT
I fell love at first sight to CHA Eun woo,
I amaze MJ his voice and characters Mj make me happy always,
I'm so proud of Rocky his amazing,
SANHA is so adorable,
Moonbin make me uncomfortable 🙈 sshhh🙊🙉
And
I fall in love with JINJIN 😍😍😍
Little did they know, they'll have a win in a couple of months and another win the next year. I'm so proud of knowing them since day one, following them and hearing their music makes me the happiest person alive.
I wonder why people are sleeping on their talent. This is one the most beautiful song I have ever heard. I don't understand korean yet I was moved by this song and wanted to cry. Later I read the translation of this song and I was so surprised that how easily these boys conveyed the emotion behind this song to their audience .This is such a beautiful song and these boys are pure talent.
I wish they give Rocky some vocal lines in future comebacks😢
They haven’t in a while
I'm so in love with high notes MJ and rocky
I always thought it was moonbin's high note but ITS ROCKY OMFGGG
Anyone in 2021!!! 😭❤️
Still my heart aches while listening to this song... I can't even understand this language without translation..but this music and their voice are so soothing 🎶❤️ music has no boundaries 💜🎶 #Aroha #Astro💜
Ill forever treasure this song which ever part its just perfect. Mj and rocky's high notes are just a +++ i love you #Astro 😭😭😭
Cha eunwoo🤩🤩
those note adding to my life span ugh give rocky more of itttt i neeeddd
CLEONOR 😥 😷 😍 😢 😢 😢 😍 😍 😙 😙 😘 😘 😘 🌌 🌌 🌌 📞 📞 📞 📞 📞
astro literally has some of the best vocals in kpop and i wish more people knew of them
Oh my Rocky I'm so proud of you! Your the best💖
CLEONOR 😥 😷 😍 😍 😙 😙 😘 😘 🌌 🌌 🌌 🌌 📞 📞, mas
Years had passed since I first watched this video but it still gives me goosebumps. Oh Rocky! 😫❤️
It's 2021, and I'm still amazed by Rocky hitting that high note, bruh he killed it. Just WOW.
it's 2021 but Rocky's Highnote will always be a legendary moment in KPOP industry!
Rockys high note gave me goosebump
Can we just talk about how Rocky’s rapping voice and singing sound lowkey different?.
The first time I heard him sing (not in real life. In RUclips :V)
was when he sang “Hide and Seek”.
His singing voice is so cute!. I love it!.
Omg rocky that note
Me watching this in 2020 mind blown when rocky played that high note I screamed he has hidden vocals💜💜💜
He is awesome right, ddocca's mom..❤️
MJ and Rocky 😱 they left me breathless that you notice without a doubt beautiful But in itself the whole song is beautiful together with all the voices of the Astro members, the best 😍💖
omg this song gives me goosebumps
i am happy this is the only live that i have found out that rocky does his high note part live than playback. THIS should be every time they have performed this live... i'm sad and mad about that he couldn't in other lives :((
Hoooo! that gives me goosebumps Rocky! you amazed me 😍😍😍😍
I will wait for rocky to join for the King of the mask singer😢😍
yes yes pleaseee he will blow everyone's mind
well, he just joined a month ago.
Rocky's highnotes are just amazing how a rapper can do highnote.
I never get tired of watching this video..it makes me cry everytime i watch it especially on Rocky's high note..love it, son.
Rockyswag's highnote making Arohas so proud! 💜
ROCKY LITERALLY ROCK MY WORLD!!!🔥 ILOVEHIMSOMUCH! 🥺
Oh my god they were so amazing that I started crying.
And rocky voice was just
😱😱😱😍
there's no rapper can beat rocky high notes 😭 i dont know they are very underrated yet talented
Pengen sih kalo comeback mereka bawain lagu ini,,, pasti lebih wow lagi
I love it...it made me cry💕💕
I love and stan 'em all but Rocky is just EVERYTHING! I'm crying every time I watch this. 💜😚😭
My favorite Astro's "innocent love" version... 😍🥰💜
Rocky deserve to have some vocal lines in some of their music... That damn voice was so good
have you heard him doing the high notes in When The Wind Blows? I have the links if you want to hear it. Please check it out! 😂
ruclips.net/video/PAf1LVWQQlE/видео.html (When The Wind Blows Rocky guide version) have fun hearing this and stay safe +stream astro knock music video ❤😂
Rocky is just amazing
The chills of listening to rocky’s vocalsss. This amazing talented man is so unreal. Our minhyuk is such a well-rounded artist and he deserve more!
I came here so many times because of rocky
Still here in 2021. My main filler as I swim for after midnight, bc Rocky's vocals deserve love and attention
Who is still here it's 2020 still watching it