I really need MJ to go on King of Masked Singer and slay everyone with his vocals and everyone will be like "who the fuck is he?" And then it's revealed and he'll be his cheerful, funny self and laugh and everyone will be like "wow Astro's vocalists are talented" because people seem to overlook that
this a random reply (and a late one) but i think Rocky should go on King of Masked Singer as well! despite his role of being a dancer and rapper, he's an amazing singer as well! (his highnotes on astro's cover of 'replay' got me shook)
Astro was the first kpop group that i stan back in 2017. Its now 2023 April just after Moonbin left us. I found this song in my playlist today and it felt so sad. I was really in shock so i couldn’t feel that Moonbin is not with us anymore but this song just remembered me how i loved them at the time and i felt that sadness, that we can’t see or able to hear his voice again. I think a lot of people don’t know this song but they and their angelic voices were my first loves in kpop. Thank you for all that good memories and rest in peace Moonbin…🙏🏼
사랑하는 빈아 니 목소리가 듣고싶을 때 항상 이 노래를 들었는데 이제 어떻게 이 영상을 틀어야하나 싶어 아마 가늠도 못할 정도로 힘들겠지 그래도 열심히 살아갈게 넌 내가 지칠때 힘이 돼 줬잖아 늘 그랬듯이 난 다시 일어설 수 있을 거야 니가 이제껏 들려준 목소리 보여준 무대 너의 사랑스런 웃음 언어 행동 모두 다 하나도 빠짐없이 사랑해 평생 기억할 거야 마음 편하게 행복하게 하고 싶은 거 다 하고 살아 사랑하는 우리 빈이❤
TO;아로하팬분들 맞아요 저도 빈오빠를 보내주고나서 노래를 들어서 그런지 가사가 너무슬프네요... 빈오빠 거기에서는 웃으면서 꼭건강하게 행복하게 잘 지내야해요... ㅜㅜ 그리고 멤버오빠들도 모두 힘들지만 그래도 힘내요❤ 파이팅🎉 PS:아스트로를 좋아하고 사랑하는 고2 학생김정연 평로하 아스트로팀 러브🔯💜
mj transforms when he sings. he usually seems like a carefree happy person but when he sings, he just looks so into it, he looks so good and sounds so good. I love him 😍😍
Eunwoo's speaking voice is a natural baritone. I just wish composers would make him try to sing more of low notes he would definitely sound beautiful and he is good at harmonizing using his chest vocal placement especially with sanha and moonbin.
+Yoo Inna I think Rocky is just being serious because ive watched one video in which a question will be asked then the person assigned will answer, then the question was.... i think who is the most affected or serious member when it comes to his personal life then he answered its rocky then i think he recaled his first love then suddenly became serious or something but i dont really know if thats the reason i just think it is but sorry if im wrong
@@ദേവൂ-ഖ1ഡ there’s adlibs in the back of mj’s lines that are Rocky’s high notes but I guess at the time the company wanted to push rocky more as a rapper from the start so he wasn’t able to do his high notes live
I've overcome the same struggle already. Eunwoo and Moonbin both became my biases. lol I just can't choose so I decided they're both going to stay at the top of my list.
+LMFAOyou I've overcome the struggle 😂 BinWoo is my Bias! I ship them but not hard core ship just brotherly twin like Ship 😇 Cuz sometimes they look alike and it's so cute it's like they're twins 💁
I think MJ definitely got a lot of publicity with just this one video because I so did. He is such an amazing singer. I know that's a bit clique because there are a lot of really talented singers in the kpop industry, but MJ really slayed it and I'm playing this video over and over again until I get sick of it, which I hope won't be for a long time. MJ isn't even my bias, yet I feel that fangirl connection yo. Haha. (Rocky is my bias). Even if he is short, that's okay, because his talent reaches far more higher that the height that keeps him on the ground.
One of my favorite tracks from their 'Spring Up' Album! Their vocals are on-point and the rapper line killed their verses! ASTRO has such a bright future as KPOP's newest, talented stars!
Rest in peace Moonbin, we will love you forever weren't getting tired for loving and supporting you and Astro. i'm not fan of Astro but I know the feeling of aroha's know because you are gone now.. Till the Moon meets the stars now..😭😭
okay this is my first time hearing this song and when MJ hit that high note I ran out of my room into the living room and screamed for god knows how long lmao then I came back and replayed it cause there's just no fucking way someone could sing so perfect I was in disbelief like omfg thanks MJ I'm bald now
OMG they're so cute. standing politely like that. nvm you can gain expereince and be more charismatic in the future especially during prformance that doesn't need you to move around♡
3:19 EunWoo just staring into peoples hearteu XD You cant choosed a bias in ASTRO you cant. Look at V app and youll understand me. MJ- Will tell you the best way to do everything. Will sing his heart off and kill you with his voice. He will make you ill with happines. SanHa- Maknae. You just need to know that to understand the level of aegyo. He will SING and will ruin you with his looks EunWoo- Smiles Smiles Smiles. And he aint only visual he is talented (whole ASTRO is what am i saying) JinJin- I die when he smiles. Hes just too cute. And he is slow. At rap and everything. MoonBin- puppy kitten. Puffy eyes (he always talks about them) voiceeee looooooks Rocky- LLAKKI XD likes his name a lot i think. Will do aegyo when you dont notice. Cute raps and where he is from Everybody knows him (thats what he says) Just ASTRO K? AROHA LOVES THEM! ASTRO FIGHTING!
Rest in peace moonbin😭 can't believe it still...i liked this much so much without knowing them much and i used to cry so much while listening to it and now on it's be more painfull...god bless and give patience to his family, sister and Astro members and fans!
MJ's high note has reached Eunwoo and Sanha's height
😂😂😂😂
😂😂
Omg haha😂😂
LOL 😂😂😂
omg HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Do they really have to put MJ in between Sanha and Eunwoo? 😂😂
hahahaaha........
Random Gurl HAHAHSHSHSHAHAHAHA 😂😂😂
Random Gurl oml 😂😂😂
I WAS THINKING THE SAME
they could just put Mj in between jinwoo and minhyuk
mj: hey, how perfectly should i sing this long high note?
me: just fuck me up
mE
My heart literally fluttered!
Kook and Suga lamb skewer duo he nailed it
The inside jokes on these names tho loool
Yesss,his voice is perfect
sanha was 16, eunwoo was 19, moon bin was 18, rocky was 17, jin jin was 20, mj was 22... they've grown
mj just enlisted 😭😭 bro
Moonbin sadly left us
@@rocketshiftgaming5693 yeah so sad
4 years later and this is still Mj’s song
So true!
Yeahhh it hits differently when he was rapping this song😭 Miss them tho
I really need MJ to go on King of Masked Singer and slay everyone with his vocals and everyone will be like "who the fuck is he?" And then it's revealed and he'll be his cheerful, funny self and laugh and everyone will be like "wow Astro's vocalists are talented" because people seem to overlook that
Or I need him to go on Duet Song Festival... I just really need him to show off his incredibly good voice
holy shit yesssss! i was so surprised my self like i didnt know MJ could go that high like omg slay
Svea Winter me toooo
this a random reply (and a late one) but i think Rocky should go on King of Masked Singer as well! despite his role of being a dancer and rapper, he's an amazing singer as well! (his highnotes on astro's cover of 'replay' got me shook)
Jay true I would love that too since they'd never guess who he is, rappers on that show are pretty rare
Everyone's commenting about Sanha and Eunwoo's height and I'm like
Moon Bin ain't smol ya'know
I agree!!!
It's probably because they're next to mj haha
+Euphoria Crew that's exactly why. Moonbin is tall but people are commenting only about Sanha and Eunwoo because they're next to the cutie MJ.
Koola Kat they just had to put the smol ones between the taller ones XD
Koola Kat exactly
Sanha is the youngest, he's the tallest....
MJ is the oldest, he's too small....
ikrr but i find dat so cute ngl
Astro Rocks!! I feel sad that in my group of friend im the second tallest and im still shorter than mj i think XD
Joy Alexander for now, Sanha is still growing
Joy Alexander the thing is even Jinwoo and Myungjun are taller than me but they look so short next to the other members
@@SarahZi1998 same. I'm only 155cm. Imagine me standing to these giants 😫😫
엠제이가 노래부르다 카메라 쳐다볼때마다 개설레네 근데 졸라 잘부른다
빈아~ 너 보고싶어서 왔어!❤❤
can we take a moment to appreciate MJ's eyelashes like daanngg boy
Also: Jinjin's eyes are so beautiful askdjsfhg
Right? MJ's eyelashes are the first thing I see 😍😍
That goodness I ain't the only one lol! 😊
YES MJ SING BOY OMG IM CRYING HIS VOCALS
Shook Suga IKRRR
HAVE YOU SEEN BTS DNA IF YOU ARE A BTS FAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
song name
Please remind me that Myungjun is the Eldest. Standing between two poles of the group? Too adorable fluffy kid is too much to handle
Poles lmfao
The younhest pole doesn't even seem like he's the youngest. Mj looks lile the maknae haha
no offence to anyone, but usually maknaes don't have the strongest voices.
AgentBubbles10 ikr
풋사랑 노래너무 좋아 아직도 듣는중
Astro was the first kpop group that i stan back in 2017. Its now 2023 April just after Moonbin left us. I found this song in my playlist today and it felt so sad. I was really in shock so i couldn’t feel that Moonbin is not with us anymore but this song just remembered me how i loved them at the time and i felt that sadness, that we can’t see or able to hear his voice again. I think a lot of people don’t know this song but they and their angelic voices were my first loves in kpop. Thank you for all that good memories and rest in peace Moonbin…🙏🏼
I with you this one i stan Astro from debut
@@jessicasia17 you so lucky because you stan astro from debut
A R E Y A L L H E AR I N G M Y C H I L D R E N
JUST LISTEN I'M CRYING
ME TO O
Huh?
Mj = 100% Voice 20% Height
Omg ahshaushausha lol
JINJIN heights though 😂😂
Hahaha 😂😂
hahaha
Hahahaha
when they harmonized tho... T_T it was so beautiful
yea..i replay so many times
이 노래 진짜 대박.. 진짜 풋풋하고 라련한 그 느낌을 너무 잘살림 특히 mj감성이 대박인듯
진짜 내 풋사랑 아스트로 진짜 많이 사랑하고 너무 사랑해서 미안하구 내가 너무 부족해서 미안해 그리고 빈아 부디 그곳에서는 아프지 말고 행복해야돼 너를 만난건 내 인생의 행운이였어
PLEASE STAN MYUNGJUN !!!! HE'S SUCH AN ANGEL. I AM BLESSSEDDDDDDDD
YESS OF COURSE!!!
your profile picture says it all 😂😂
Krisha Jenn Molina hahhahahah
Omg. I stann MJ from the buttom of my heart and soul
I STAN EVERY MEMBER :D
2:43 WHY IS NOBODY TALKING ABOUT THIS LISTEN TO HOW AMAZING HE SOUNDS IM SHOOK
Sydney Church im thinking of let me know from bts especially that high note remind me of jimin but both song has different feels 😍😍😍😍❤❤❤
the high notes dont sound the same but it just reminds me wen jimin did his high note 😁😁
Julie Herxox
song name
I was waiting for Sanha to do his high note but it’s okay cause that high note ended me 😔💜
2:44 MJ singing that high note effortlessly 😍😍 👏
모범생 아이돌...^^
요때루 다시 돌릴 수 없을까???
어쩜 이리두 하나같이 다 순수한지...^^
애기들...^^
사랑하는 빈아
니 목소리가 듣고싶을 때 항상 이 노래를 들었는데
이제 어떻게 이 영상을 틀어야하나 싶어
아마 가늠도 못할 정도로 힘들겠지
그래도 열심히 살아갈게
넌 내가 지칠때 힘이 돼 줬잖아
늘 그랬듯이 난 다시 일어설 수 있을 거야
니가 이제껏 들려준 목소리 보여준 무대
너의 사랑스런 웃음 언어 행동 모두 다
하나도 빠짐없이 사랑해
평생 기억할 거야
마음 편하게 행복하게 하고 싶은 거 다 하고 살아
사랑하는 우리 빈이❤
So cute haha seems like MJ forgot that it was still his part at 0:15 x3
OMG I THOUGHT THE SAME THING💕
"Let's all wear hats, ripped jeans and pink and not tell MJ."- Sanha
"He thinks we're actually gonna follow lol." - Jinjin
Oh maknae :)
OnceyouJIMINyoucantJIMOUT a
@@lailabunoan9507 ㄷㅎㄷㄱ슥ㄱㄴㅇㅣ
MJ has slayed me, I'll see y'all in the next life
They were more than ready to debut I cannot believe
+스테파니 yea
Rap? Sing? Dance? Visual? Personality? Smile? Name it all. My Rocky can do it all.
It hurts so bad, watching all members do their parts except Rocky. He hit that high note despite being a rapper, he deserves applause guys 👏👏❤️
All I need in my life is for Seungkwan and MJ to sing a duet
ohh yasssss
I need MJ to sing a duet with DK too!!
+Lidia Rodrigues MJ DK AND SEUNGKWAN SHOULD SONG TOGETHER AND SLAY ME
EYYYYYY YESEU!!!
Sofie A. OMG YAAASSSS
why did they put myungjun in between the two tallest members.......save him
+tori coleman jinjin beside sanha too :)))
I see what u mean 😺
+tori coleman
exactly what I thought XD
MJ is obviously the most natural on stage right now it makes the rest extra awkward😂 it's okay babies. you'll slay every stage by next comeback 😚
I Agree
Rocky always impressing everyone with his high notes 😩😩😩 also, enwooo looks like an actual angel 😭😭
1:48 Just 7 years ago Moonbin was singing so beautifully. The world has lost another star, why does this keep happening? It's so heartbreaking
내가 제일 좋아하는 노래,, 그동안 얼마나 아팠고 힘들었을까, 빈아 부디 그 곳에서 웃으면서 행복하게 지내줘..
In "Too Be Continue" they made MJ look so tall!!! WHATEVER!! HIS VOICE MAKES HIM HIGH NOTES ARE ENOUGH FOR ME!
Sorry erase the "Notes Are" lol
Taeyoung V95 omg im laughing hahahahahahah
Taeyoung V95 also he is next to the two tallest members whicj also makes him look shorter
lol what its a literal running gag that hes short
빈이 보내고 들으니까..넘 슬픈가사다..ㅜㅜ❤
TO;아로하팬분들 맞아요 저도 빈오빠를 보내주고나서 노래를 들어서 그런지 가사가 너무슬프네요... 빈오빠 거기에서는 웃으면서 꼭건강하게 행복하게 잘 지내야해요... ㅜㅜ 그리고 멤버오빠들도 모두 힘들지만 그래도 힘내요❤ 파이팅🎉
PS:아스트로를 좋아하고 사랑하는 고2 학생김정연 평로하 아스트로팀 러브🔯💜
역시 4년 전이나 지금이나 노래 실력은 여전히 완벽한 아스트로 💜
Moonbin smiling at the end ❤️
mj transforms when he sings. he usually seems like a carefree happy person but when he sings, he just looks so into it, he looks so good and sounds so good. I love him 😍😍
얘들아... 절대 자책하지말고 힘내거라... 너희땜에 문빈이가 떠난 거 절대 아니니까 1년이 걸리더라도 언젠가 무대에서 다시보자... 빈이야 형이 진짜 사랑해
이 영상을 참 많이도 봤지... 이걸 보고 아스트로라는 보석을 발견하고 빛나는 너희들이 무대에서 항상 진심으로 아로하에게 다가왔던 모든 순간들을 잊지 못해! 빈아 알아주지 못해서 미안해 더 많이 사랑해줄걸.. 정말 너무 미안해
It’s literally 2019 and I’m still watching this 😍😭
2020 Now!!!
June 2020
2020 heree
2021 now
2021
Been with Astro since pre-debut. I have always loved this song, it will never be the same❤ shine bright in the sky Moonbin🌕🌌
Really you aroha before astro debut you so lucky
진진이 왜케 귀엽지..? 뭔가 귀여워...
아담해서..?♡
Eunwoo's voice is so soft and good to hear idk why they dont give him more lines tbh
Actually Eunwoo is the weakest vocalist in ASTRO
that's why...
Eunwoo's speaking voice is a natural baritone. I just wish composers would make him try to sing more of low notes he would definitely sound beautiful and he is good at harmonizing using his chest vocal placement especially with sanha and moonbin.
Beside of the technic, Eunwoo's voice is so gently and good to hear.. I love his voice..
Ikr, I am super addicted to his voice. I can listen to it forever.
@@yyxy5030 But it's still sooo good.
I'm crying over this after 5 years. They were literally perfect since the beginning. I'm so proud of them 🥺👑
순수해 아이고 넘이뻐라
" we cried together, we smiled together. I'm thankful for a person like you "
Moonbin
Rocky looks sad here ;-;... I wanna think is for the concept of the song.
i saw it and i was like ' who done this to my baby rocky XC '
i think the song's concept is they can't unite with their first love..
+Yoo Inna I think Rocky is just being serious because ive watched one video in which a question will be asked then the person assigned will answer, then the question was.... i think who is the most affected or serious member when it comes to his personal life then he answered its rocky
then i think he recaled his first love then suddenly became serious or something
but i dont really know if thats the reason i just think it is but sorry if im wrong
When I saw his face at 3:21 I wanted to cry like who hurt you baby?😭
Eunwoo's and Rocky got into the song
this is making me cry evn though i dont have a first love lmao :")
LOL
임재린 LMAO
Me too T_T
I'm just like TT
임재린 Same😂😭
why are there no comments talking about rocky's high note
It also hurts my insides... I get the note is hard to hit, but that doesn't mean they won't let Rocky do it with others 🥺❤️
진짜 왠만한 발라드 가수 노래보다 좋다. 나 힙합 아니면 별로 안듣는데 이 노래 ㅈㄴ 헤어진 사람 생각나서 듣게 됨.....개 슬퍼...........
2:52 Rocky high note wow he voice so powerful.
?
😆✋💜
It's not Rocky, it's mj.
@@ദേവൂ-ഖ1ഡ there’s adlibs in the back of mj’s lines that are Rocky’s high notes but I guess at the time the company wanted to push rocky more as a rapper from the start so he wasn’t able to do his high notes live
하 문빈 도랐다 진짜 개잘생겼다...어떡하지....아 입덕하면 안되는데 미쳤나봐진짜...
얼른 입덕하시죠...!!
Was JinJin's microphone not working?
And holy shit, Moonbin is my bias but Eunwoo looked so beautiful here
same struggle here hmmmph. I can't decide between Moonbin and Eunwoo :c omg... they are perfect! ❤
I've overcome the same struggle already. Eunwoo and Moonbin both became my biases. lol I just can't choose so I decided they're both going to stay at the top of my list.
+LMFAOyou I've overcome the struggle 😂 BinWoo is my Bias! I ship them but not hard core ship just brotherly twin like Ship 😇 Cuz sometimes they look alike and it's so cute it's like they're twins 💁
Eunwoo looked beautiful in other shows too
sam ney
Idk about jinjin‘ mic :o
I think MJ definitely got a lot of publicity with just this one video because I so did. He is such an amazing singer. I know that's a bit clique because there are a lot of really talented singers in the kpop industry, but MJ really slayed it and I'm playing this video over and over again until I get sick of it, which I hope won't be for a long time. MJ isn't even my bias, yet I feel that fangirl connection yo. Haha. (Rocky is my bias). Even if he is short, that's okay, because his talent reaches far more higher that the height that keeps him on the ground.
Do you think 175cm is that much short.i don't think so
2:42 excuse me? hahaha I'm 6 years late to stanning astro but I'm glad I'm here
지금도좋은노래네요ㅜㅠㅠ아스트로를차은우덕분에 입덕했지만다들 매력넘치네유^^응원합니다
와. ......MJ노래 핵 잘한다 음색👍고음👍노래👍멋짐👍귀여움👍 와....
oh god myungjun's vocal 100%
So young 🥰
Eunwoo looks like a white steemed bun. My dumpling 🥺❤
문빈오빠는나에겐언제나좋은아이돌이야은하
One of my favorite tracks from their 'Spring Up' Album! Their vocals are on-point and the rapper line killed their verses! ASTRO has such a bright future as KPOP's newest, talented stars!
은우 목소리 되게 맑네
MJ voice can make me fly💜💜😭😭
Rest in peace Moonbin, we will love you forever weren't getting tired for loving and supporting you and Astro. i'm not fan of Astro but I know the feeling of aroha's know because you are gone now.. Till the Moon meets the stars now..😭😭
who is here in 2021?
Me
Me everytime I'm watching this video and the live performance of this song..💜💜💜
rapp line are sing too....
+Alif Wahyu ofc
oh they're talented
you might wanna search Btob. 😂😂. (No hate, I'm a fanboy of both (Btob and Astro))
Moonbin, você sempre irá brilhar onde quer que esteja 🤍🌠
okay this is my first time hearing this song and when MJ hit that high note I ran out of my room into the living room and screamed for god knows how long lmao then I came back and replayed it cause there's just no fucking way someone could sing so perfect I was in disbelief like omfg thanks MJ I'm bald now
ムンビン君の高音、凄い⤴️⤴️😀
ステキ❤❤
もうムンビン君のステキな歌声が聞けない😢😭
when i was a baby aroha i would watch moonbins “we cried together, we laughed together, i’m grateful for a person like you” part on repeat 🥹
ChaEunWoo looks like the prince of korea even then. Gorgeous !
OMG they're so cute. standing politely like that. nvm you can gain expereince and be more charismatic in the future especially during prformance that doesn't need you to move around♡
울 별둥이들 넘 풋풋하고 이뻐서 우째~~~~💜💜💜💜💜💜
에궁 애기들이네 이렇게 보니까 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
진짜 풋풋해.....
엠제이 고음 쩌러ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 울 별둥이들은 노래면 노래 춤이몀 춤 랩이먄 랩 외모면 외모까지...ㅎㄷㄷㄷ 사랑해♥♥ 아스트로♥
와...차은우 음색 좋다
저세상 풋풋함이다.
귀엽고 이쁘고 노래도 잘하고
서있는 것도 어색하고ㅋㅋ러블리해
We love you Moonbin, thank you for your music and the memories 💜
0:15 Myungjun was like "oh it's still my part" 😂😂
aheuaheuah Yes my poor son
at mj's high note... my soul has left my body
The way Jinwoo and Sanha look and smile at each other at the beginning is the sweetest thing I've ever seen 💗
이영상 내 최애영상 탑5에 드는거라 맨날 보는데 2020년에 보러온 아로하분들 또 있을라나..?
🌙
⠀ 여기 있습니다 . 2021년에도 찾아서 보는 아로하 1 🖐
요때 명주니 목소리 진짜 맑당 다른 느낌이네
진짜 띵곡ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
요 앨범 수록곡들은 다 좋은듯 ㅠㅠ
라이브 다들 잘한다
3:19 EunWoo just staring into peoples hearteu XD You cant choosed a bias in ASTRO you cant. Look at V app and youll understand me.
MJ- Will tell you the best way to do everything. Will sing his heart off and kill you with his voice. He will make you ill with happines.
SanHa- Maknae. You just need to know that to understand the level of aegyo. He will SING and will ruin you with his looks
EunWoo- Smiles Smiles Smiles. And he aint only visual he is talented (whole ASTRO is what am i saying)
JinJin- I die when he smiles. Hes just too cute. And he is slow. At rap and everything.
MoonBin- puppy kitten. Puffy eyes (he always talks about them) voiceeee looooooks
Rocky- LLAKKI XD likes his name a lot i think. Will do aegyo when you dont notice. Cute raps and where he is from Everybody knows him (thats what he says)
Just ASTRO K? AROHA LOVES THEM! ASTRO FIGHTING!
Rest in Peace Moonbin, you'll be dearly missed...🌤😇🙏✝️🕯
풋풋하다 이뽀
Baby faced Eunwoo 🥺, now he looks so mature
Dat harmonization and MJ's vocals, dayummm
why is eunwoo is so pretty?.lol😅😂😂 ....anyway sanha is so cute..😆😁
ikrr prettier than me n any other girl ik irl, same with sanha, like share ur good looks fam
Please tell me they are going to make a MV to this this is one of my favorite songs by them
yea iwant it tooo
me too...!!!
This is from the drama, so I kinda doubt it ......
Madz Van which drama ?!omg
NCRRN its ToBeContinued
빈이 정말 수고했고,거기에선 편히 쉬길바랄게..♡
Came here to reminiscing the memory of mine during the first time I know Astro. Rest well, Moonbin.
Rest in peace moonbin😭 can't believe it still...i liked this much so much without knowing them much and i used to cry so much while listening to it and now on it's be more painfull...god bless and give patience to his family, sister and Astro members and fans!