idk why they arent promoting this cause everything about this, from the song itself to the choreo to the boys, is absolutely stunning and beautiful and I feel like not promoting this masterpiece is kind of a waste. @ Fantagio what the heck?
nowaititsme it's because they had all of their overseas showcases going on the past month (in Bangkok, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taipei, and the 1st Aroha festival) that Fantagio decided having to fly back and forth between the countries to perform on music shows would be too exhausting/overwhelming and wanted to give Astro a break before their 4th mini album (as Winter Dream is just a short special album)~ they did it to take care of the members, which is sad for fans but at the same time, we should be grateful they're taking care of Astro
nowaititsme I totally agree, they said it didn't fit their image but I think we should have been the judge of that. I believe this choreography absolutely fits their image. It's a beautiful song. I wonder if we can convince Fantagio to release the MV. Lol. I thank fantagio for taking care of the boys. @fantagio
Maria Benites Yes I agree! I heard that Astro did film an MV for this song but Astro and fantigo had a talk and they agreed to discard this mv bc they felt like this song doesn't match their concept but I would have to disagree. This song still pulls off that innocent, cute boy concept but with just sorrow this time haha. This song and dance is perfect! and I wish they had at least released it as a special for the fans and to just not promote it. but either way, I'm happy they gave us this dance practice as a present for us! Hehe it's a great song and I love it!
nowaititsme not only bc of that but bc this is for the fans ..like there are some song that artist released that is just for the fan like Park Kyung - 오글오글 ...
So I'm a pretty new fan, and I know Rocky has technical dance training (which is ballet), but do any of the rest of them? In every dance practice I watch, I'm seriously SO impressed by their choreography. I think out of all of the groups I stan, they have the best dancers. It makes the ballet dancer inside of me so happy. 😂
Sydnee Jinjin!! JinJin is amazing a house-dancing!! He won a lot of house dancing contests before he was a trainee (that’s why he knows GOT7 Yugyeom) Moonbin‘s great skills are due to his effort and 7years of hard work as a trainee. Sanha is very flexible and that’s why he’s so good too. And Rocky mastered not only ballet but genres like jazz, tap, hip hop, clap, modern dance, and omg I can’t remember (I’ve seen he even use his taekwondo skills in choreographies) well, he dances since he was a 5years-old lil boy so..
i can jump thank you!! im seriously so impressed every time i watch this, especially by 2:52 when both moonbin and rocky do a double pirouette into an axel turn like??? axel turns are hard with actual preps and they do it right out of a pirouette? it makes the dancer in me so happy 😂💕
ikr!!? They're both very talented and it's even harder to believe how synchronized they can be doing that at the same time. Their choreographies can seem easy, sometimes, but in reality they're a real challenge and so exhausting omg. I'm so happy you could enjoy their dancing skills as a dancer. I hope you like their style as much as we do ^^ Welcome to the AROHA family💕
Estoy tan orgullosa de mis niños 💜💜💜💜💜💜Astro es un grupo muy talentoso, sus habilidades de baile son muy increíbles, cualquiera lo admiraría aún si no fuera un Aroha
Not mad but i wish that they have a music video for this song...I think it would be very beautiful How i wish for the next comeback they have a mv for this ..btw they're having a comeback...so exciteddddd
I heard they had a music video made for this but it didn’t fit a concept at that time so they never uploaded it ahah. It’s prolly stuck on someone’s computer rn 👀👀👀👀
Nina Yeun yeeeees!!! astro are so amazing and deserve so much love. if you want to get to know them, you can watch To Be Continued, it's their web drama and it's on Netflix, or you can watch them on the Immigration
New Aroha: So who's their visual line?? me: Ughh Its Mj, Jinjin, Enwoo, Moonbin, Rocky and Sanha :D noob: ughh isnt that all of them?? me: yea CUZ ASTRO IS A VISUAL GROUP
Joy Alexander I mean yeah they did and I died xD but MOST of NCT127's songs have hard choreos but ALL of Astro's are difficult(I mean with all the foot work and hip movements)
You are actually kidding!!!! Name another KPOP group that puts a pirouette into a double axle in there coreo????? I'll wait..... STAN ASTRO YOU COWARDS!!!!!!!
Okay random question but have y'all seen Astro's choreo for With You??? I don't know anything about dancing but Rocky does this double spinning thing and then the splits like immediately after it and alsjlkjfkla
I remember being obsessed with this video when I found it 5 years ago because of the ending where everyone was laughing, screaming, just being normal Astro, I used to laugh along with them now I’m watching it with tears in my eyes. Rest in peace, Moonbin. ❤️🩹
I'm really not into kpop but Eun woo brought me to astro and there's no turning back now..i'm already inlove with these cute dorks..the only group i stan..fighting!! 😊😘
I have a feeling and my guts are never wrong. This guys will make it to the top. They will be huge in a couple of years. ( THAT is coming from someone that does not stan them)
sadia ahmed a month later but oh well they will be like bts believe me. as a feiendly army and a aroha o can say that they will be huge like them in terms of popularity
Hoping that: 1. Astro will continue their dancing skills and be the second Infinite with their knife choreography and practice more for their vocal skills and become the second btob, 2. Become big like BTS and slay charts until there's nothing left to be slayed, 3. Become popular in korea and internationally, 4. Have a big and loyal fandom, and lastly, 5. Win a Daesang in MAMA's. Maybe not today nor tomorrow, but maybe soon.
I am an army and moa. I used to say I'll never stan any other group aside from BTS and TXT. I never knew I needed Astro until I accidentally clicked Blue Flame. And here I am now, binge watching all their MVs, funny moments, Vlive. And I must admit, Astro has one of the best choreographies in Kpop.
I agree 100%, But I have hope, they are amazing and have awesome potential! I used to stan BTS before they made it, it's crazy but support who you love regardless :)
dhilynn I’M TELLING YOU! ONE DAY..... THEY ARE GOING TO BE AS KNOWN AS BTS!!! OR EXO! If it doesn’t happens then.... I can’t even imagine what would happend😂 it’s impossible that ASTRO doesn’t get known they are so good❤️ (And sorry for my English, I suck in English / I’m French)😂
SmileWithMe Hopefully this will make them stan Astro the best thing we can do as fans for the boys is reposting this and spreading the word about this video.
that's how I feel towards BTS. I'm happy that they're gaining massive attention around the world, but i also don't want them to become "mainstream". I really miss the old bangtan tbh :,((
ok real talk: no matter how surface-level impressed i get with a song, video, or group, i've never actually connected with a group besides BTS enough to properly stan them. However, i'm like 4 hours deep into an Astro binge (i just found them) and i tried so hard to resist (cause i don't have the emotional energy to stan another group tbh hahah) but *it's h a p p e n i n g* like fuck they're so funny and talented and i'm already so soft for them. I've just been grinning for the past 4 hours cause they're such goons. I know their names already so it's basically too late to back out now. I'm in it, guys. I stan.
House of Jikook SAME I ALREADY STANNED THEM IN JUST A DAY like what group have this kind of charm? I hard stanned Bts and Wanna one but Astro issssss........ Im speechless
I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO THOUGHT THAT. Today while I was in the car, I was listening to this song with my earphones in and I just thought of a drama scene in my head haha :D
My Daughter fell in love with these in less than 24 hours and now I'm here because I'm a kpop trash mum and I'm adopting these boys as my sons. They are so so talented and the songs are really good too.
Is Rocky the one with a black sweatshirt with print on? I am really new to Astro, but I know that Rocky is "the dancer" of the group, even though they all just dance amazingly!
Sarah Andersen he's the one with the long sleeve shirt with the picture thing on it with black jeans idk if that helps sorry im bad at explaining things 😂
@@lilacstars5307 Why not? Lmao I love that dude. He deserves more recognition for his dancing abilities. Would be a shame if you stan the others except for him.
ASTRO needs more attention! They are so good. They have good choreos, their songs are beautiful. But they are so underrated! We must support them more! WE MUST REACH MORE VIEWS!
I learn to dance ASTRO's AGAIN. And then i realized, how easy are all of the rest of Kpop's choreos. I hav never given up any dances that i wanted to learn. But here. I hav found one i couldn't get till the end. You missed one step. You miss the rest song.
I've been learning this song, baby and a lot of bts choreographies and bts also has really hard choreos ☺️ it also depends on what song and what choreo you are trying to learn, like baby is easier than again ❤️
One tip: Go to settings for the video and slow it down then you can learn it easier (I do this with sf9 choreo but I want to learn this one and all the songs of Astro sf9 and bts)
One of my favourite choreography. It's hard for even membered groups to make their dance look group when one of the members has a solo and is standing in the center because for it to be symmetrical, one person has to hide in the back or something so that there are two people on each side. However, Astro still manages to pull it off. I love the dance because it really expresses a lot of emotion; though I don't speak Korean I'd assume the song is about the anguish of missing someone and trying to get over them. I also love the formations they make, like when Eunwoo was singing his part and the members were circling around him. Ahh this song in general is so underappreciated. I love it so much.
oh wow they are really underrated. Please give astro some appreciation, love and support guys. this song is so good and that choreo is DAMN - i am lost for words.
2024: Back here after Eunwoo's Mystery Elevator Encore in Japan. Much time had passed, those young ASTRO boys in the video couldn't have imagined that one day they'll be tragically losing one of their precious brothers. That's why the memories that this video captured is a part of eternity that everyone will cherish forever. Thank you ASTRO and rest well our dear Moonbin. ☆♡
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS 1) Is this their comeback? Yes. ASTRO has been doing a seasonal concept throughout their first year (spring up, summer vibes, autumn story) and this is the title song of the winter album, Winter Dream. 2) When did they release an album? Winter Dream was released on February 22, 2017, one day before their first anniversary. This was most likely planned so that the "winter" comeback happened before the anniversary of the Spring album so they could come full circle with the concept. 3) Why does Winter Dream only have 3 songs? ASTRO did not end Autumn Story promotions until well into January. Winter Dream is titled a "special album", most likely because there was not enough time before the anniversary to create a mini album. However, the fact that ASTRO wrote lyrics to a song and title it "You&Me (Thanks AROHA)", a fan song, definitely makes up for the fact that there are only three songs. 4) Why aren't they promoting? How come I am just now hearing of this? They did not promote on music shows like groups typically do when they have a comeback. The release of the album was February 22 for the reason explained above. On February 26 they held two concerts for their Korean fans. On February 12, they traveled to Thailand to hold on a concert that had been rescheduled from October 2016. On February 28, they performed in Taiwan. On March 3, they performed in Hong Kong. On March 5, they performed in Singapore. Because of all of these concerts, they were unable to promote their song on music shows. Additionally, they've been working non stop all year round and fantagio probably wanted them to rest more during this time period and work on preparing a full album for the future. 5) Is there a music video? There is not. Although it was reported that a music video was filmed, the company released a statement saying that the footage was unsatisfactory and did not fit Astros image, and after much discussion astro and their management decided not to release anything. 6) Why do I also see it called "Should Have Held On To You" / "Should Have Held On" / "Should've Held On" / "Should've Held On To You"? Many of Astros tweets only used the hangul for the songs title, and fans did their best to translate the title. This dance practice is probably the first time many Aroha are seeing "again" as the official title. EDIT: ASTRO's official facebook did use the #Again when posting the highlight medley, but the title was not widely spread amongst AROHA and most still refer to it as "Should Have Held On To You". If you are looking for fancams, try searching Should Have Held On To You! if there are any other questions, please ask !!
Wow, thanks a lot ! I was actually wondering why the MV wasn't still out... So that's the reason :(. I'm quite disappointed, but anyways, i'll support them whatever :D ♥.
Ani Lin "Again" is the english title. When they post the medley of the album, one of the hastags there is #Again which I think many AROHAs didnt see. Look at their official FB account and search for the highlight medley post ☺️💫🌟⭐️
Sana Girl yeah, fans both domestically and internationally were expecting a music video when the song was realeased and everyone was really shocked when one didn't drop. it's a shame there is no video, but I also wouldn't want astro releasing something they aren't proud of
I'm stopping by after 6 years since I last commented. I watch this now and cry for a very different reason. Hell, I barely started the video and as soon as the music started and I heard Moonbin's voice, I just lost it. I've been with Astro for as long as predebut. I'll forever miss Moonbin so much.
I'll be honest, the only member I know is Eunwoo, tho I already know about ASTRO since their debut, I've watched some of their MVs too but didn't bother to know them more. I even just tried watching this dance practice because I heard this song before and I love it. But that guy at 1:29 caught my eye. Like damn, he can seriously dance. It's like he didn't even try hard and it just comes naturally on him, he just feeling the song and his every move. After his part my attention just suddenly focused only on him until the end. I even needed to watch it again to see his dancing at the beginning until the end, then watch it once again to watch it as a whole group and not just him. lol.
@@melainacaerlaverock7745 I feel the opposite to you.. 😅 rocky is my bias and yes I usually can't take my eyes off him but this time hits me different.. the other dance well tho, I heard on some vlive mj oppa is not a dance member but he did dance well tho.. I keep replaying to see each member dance, they're great..
People talking about how pity it is for astro for not releasing a mv for this song. i just want to say.. I AGREE WITH YOU TOO OMG. AND THEY SHOULD ACTUALLY PROMOTE THIS SONG. WHY DIDN FANTAGIO DID IT. WHY.
kpop._. pie Fantagio was not satisfied with the quality of the MV and didn't want to put out something that wasn't the best that they could do; yeah it kind of sucks but in a way, it shows the phenomenal amount of effort that goes into Astro's MV They didn't promote due to Astro's extremely busy overseas schedule where they've had showcases in Bangkok, Taipei, Hong Kong, etc and Fantagio didn't want to exhaust the members by having them fly back and forth to promote on music shows. Can you imagine how tired they would've been? At least they are getting some well deserved rest and staying healthy! In addition, this isn't even a mini album (winter dream); it's a special album for the fans, and they're already preparing for their 4th mini album, which WILL be promoted.
kwonh that was the problem fantasy-aegyo fantaegyo thats why they didn't release the video cause they looked so Manly and the thing is that they want to be noun as a cute group producers ^^
kwonh we want them to have mature concepts but Fantaegio, is known for cute concept groups and trainee, it sucks that the have no answer but To stay in cute concept
Oh my... not releasing a music video for this song might be a big mistake on Fantagio's part. It sounds SO good and has a beautiful choreography. It's the perfect opportunity for Astro to try out a different concept! I wasn't into their cute concepts, but this song is exactly my style. They totally could've reached a broader audience had they released a music video with this comeback. (I completely chanced upon this video on VLive today and was SHOOK because such a wonderful song has been out for a month and most of the kpop community didn't, and still might not, even know about it!) I understand why they're not promoting on music shows, but ahhhhh I can't help but feel like Astro lost a big growth opportunity here (TT-TT)
Emma Beldick yeah, I read all about that already. I still stand by my statement. I hope they'll be able to refilm something they find satisfactory once they have time and release it later. There's just too much potential lost here...
Aayisha Tabassum I think they are currently working on their next comeback which will from what I know be a full album, the 4 Season Project is over so they might get a new concept as well, in the first 4 seasons they were cute, it's time to start growing up, when they debuted half of the team was underage so I understand why they went for the cute concept, I mean Sanha was literally a child, but now 2/3 of the members are grown ups, only Rocky and Sanha are still underage, I'm not saying they should change completely and go for a sexy concept, no they should wait with that until Sanha gets off age as well, but grown up concepts doesn't necessary mean sexy,
I never stan any kpop group before but because of true beauty ,Cha Eun Woo☺💜 I was given the chance to know the group Astro, and I am madly in love with their moves, choreography,faces, voice , attitude ,etc. They have an amazing talent. They deserve to be on top☺💜 My boys ☺💜 My happy pill☺💜 Thanks God💜 I found ASTRO💜 Proud Aroha here from Cebu,the Philippines☺💜
tightly synchronized, masterfully executed with facial expressions that touches and moves the audience. Have never commented on any Kpop group but was totally impressed...
I'm so obsessed with Again and the dance that I watch it 3 times everyday (when I wake up when I come home from school and before I go to sleep) I'm pretty sure more than 3 times a day btw I'm being completely honest
Hanifa Muharroro this is the biggest mood. I don’t invest myself into Astro as much as I used to but they’re still my comfort zone. They make ppl so happy
Honestly, Astro are starting to remind me of Infinite.Obviously their styles are almost nothing alike but their dancing is very similar. Infinite are known for their synchronization and knife dances and I've yet to see a group that lives up to that title. Sure, some come close like Vixx and Monsta X but not on the level that Infinte is known for. But Astro, they're so synchronized and sharp it's almost ridiculous. *They* remind me of Infinite, the only group I've been able to compare to Infinite, and the only group that leaves me as surprised, breathtaken, and proud as Infinite.
totally agree. saw their speed dance on after school right after debut, I was lost for words. no idol I've know can do that precise other than Infinite.
세븐틴 몰래 듣지 마요 i'm an inspirit before. I followed their activities since you are my oppa era tbvh astro remind me of infinite so much it become one of the reason why i start to look at them properly. The vibe they are executing is similar that of infinite. I will continue to support astro and i hope they will become as successful as infinite too.
I totally agree, the only other band than reminds me of that type of dancing is the pre-debut group A.C.E. I dismissed Astro due to their cute concept but now i've released their dancing is no joke.
Never got interested in KPop until I saw this group's video. I admire their synchronicity and not one of them try to outdo the others. Thumbs up to the choreographer. Hope I will be able to see them perform live.
I just wonder why they're still such an underrated group. All of them has all the aspects in a perfect idol. Their dances are so precise and powerful even though the song itself isn't as upbeat as the usual title songs. Their vocals are amazing, being able to keep a stable voice whilst dancing really tiresome choreography is not something that can be as well executed as how astro does it. They have no visual holes in the group ( although this can be determined by many other's opinion on the topic ). They also all have acting abilities, coming from "to be continued". How? Just how are these such multitalented members go unheard of/ unnoticed from so many people?
Aegyo Suga A lot of people refused to look at them twice because they didn't like the "cute" concept of their debut song and first comeback, and might be stubborn to get into them now
IKR. When I first saw them on weekly idol i was like mehh i wasnt really into the cute concept. but then i decided to give it another try i listened to their albums and i became OBSESSED. i love the members too and they're all very talented.
Aegyo Suga although they may seem underrated, they are only underrated internationally--- ASTRO ( alongside the NCT units ) were the most popular male 2016 debuts in Korea. :) they recently received a Bosang award and were in second place for BEST NEW MALE ARTIST for MAMA 2016
theyre underratedish worldwide because not many worldwide like the cute concept. however this kikd of concept is very popular in korea and they have more of a chance of success goinf with the cute concept. watch edward avilas video for more
Literally watched this like 50 times and I never get tired of the song or the choreography. Astro is literally SO talented my heart is melting. Got7 is my ultimate bias group and I never thought I'd find a group that makes me as happy as Got7 does but Astro is coming close second. They're talented, driven, cute, and HILARIOUS. It's so refreshing to have a new group that I stan hard and they've quickly become my second bias group in the few months that I've known them. I'm literally so excited to watch them grow even more and see Arohas expand as they become more popular. Astro fighting!!❤
I try to watch the whole choreography, but I ended up just watching Rocky. The choreography itself is really good, I LOVE IT, but watching Rocky and his moves... dang it, he's amazing!
I love it. First, Rocky has to be one of the most natural dancers I've ever seen in my life (and I'm a dancer so I've seen my fair share). The way he moves, the motions just flow through him like it's as normal to him as walking. It's incredible and I honestly don't know if I've seen anything like it. And every single one of them is an amazing dancer. I remember when I first started watching their videos I was in shock at how good all of them were at dancing, and how they all seemed to be running on exactly the same frequency and were so in sync. Not to mention their songs/vocals/rapping is amazing as well. I cannot wait to see where these boys go.
It’s really good to see a group when all the members dance very well and this is the case of Astro, but when this happen in other groups the main dancers almost look the same than the rest, very sync that if you do not know the band it is difficult to identify who is the main dancers. However in Astro Rocky excels in his moves, he is almost perfect. In my opinion he is one of the best dancers of k-pop industry.
Honestly I want to cry so hard. This dance practice seems so different from the other ones. From the dance to the song to the video itself. The dance is so powerful and full, like they're giving it their all. The song is so powerful as well, their vocals are off the charts, it really seems like they're trying to make this one memorable. To me this feels like if they were disbanding. The room itself isn't as bright as usual, it's kinda dim. Once they finished and they went close to the camera acting like themselves, it really felt like this was the end of this group, their final leave. I don't know, it's just me but I'm so glad that they're going to have many more amazing comebacks in the future
Emma Beldick that's also what I mentioned in my comment, the feel, the way they act at the end, the dim room, the deep song, everything feels like it's the end and that's what I love the most about this beautiful song
Even if they release it later as some sort of extra I'd be happy, I just want to see what they've worked so hard on and what sort of video they wanted to originally go for :'( They said it doesn't match the concept but I feel like it was beautiful anyway
They won't be releasing one for this song, Fantagio released a statement saying '...we came to a conclusion that the final product of the music video did not match ASTRO's image and/or concept' and that they won't be releasing it
I never how deep this song is, i thought it was about a love one finding their soulmate or a happy ending on a love story something like that based on the vibes i get and their dance ha
I'm still kinda sad Fantagio doesn't release MV for this. I know it didn't match Astro's current concept.. but what about releasing it few years later as anniversary gift? :"
this is my first time watching astro and why the fuck there isn't a music video for this? this is so beautiful, the choreo is just perfect, and the short one (I apologise deeply I do not know names yet sorry if I offend someone) HIS VOICE IS DEEP AF HELP ME I WASNT EXPECTING IT AT ALL LIKE IS IT REALLY HIM WHAT WHAYAATATTTAAT HELP ME PLS TELL ME NAMES AND PROFILES PLSPLS
JINJIN @ 1:20 ('96 liner)- leader, main rapper MJ @ 1:00 ('94 liner)- main vocal (HIS VOICE IS ANGELIC) MOONBIN @ 0:24 ('98 liner)- lead vocal, lead dancer EUNWOO @ 0:42 ('97 liner)- visual, sub-vocal ROCKY (MINHYUK) @ 1:30 ('99 liner)- main dancer, lead rapper, hes got the vocals too but doesn't showcase it in their tracks :( SANHA @ 1:39 ('00 liner)- lead vocal, maknae PLS STAN ASTRO STAN TALENT THEY'RE AMAZING
justisine I have strong feelings for moonbin he's now my bias in the group, and my bias wrecker is jinjin, with his deep ass voice Boi how did I not find out about them before? And I want to ask about their logo, what does it mean?
Mia Bae haha mine are the other way: JinJin is my bias and Moonbin is my bias wrecker. ugh, their smiles....and MJ's voice makes him secondary bias lol
Mia Bae you've probably found out by now but "Astro" means star in spanish (therefore the logo) and they named themselves that because they want to be the stars in arohas hearts :)
Astro: Where you don't have a bias, because everyone is so perfect, then ... you are a multiple bias, you cannot deny this. or simply change bias on each comeback.
![[MelOn Premiere Showcase(One Take ver.)] SEVENTEEN(세븐틴) _ Pretty U(예쁘다)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ur243WXPEpA/mqdefault.jpg)
![ASTRO - Don't Look Back | 아스트로 - 돌이키지마 [Immortal Songs 2 / 2016.12.31]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wGDZsWU0mjk/mqdefault.jpg)
It's 2021, but this song deserves a music video
LOUDER ROHAS!!!
SAY IT LOUDERRE
AGREED 100%!!
I agree🙌🏻
Yesss! Arohas are still not over with this masterpiece!
I still can't get over this 🥺
Astro is no.1 kpop for me..♥️💕
OBRA DE ARTE TREMENDA!!!!
i go back to this dance practice video every other week - it just hits different for me each time i watch it. Fantagio give me the MV for this PLEASE
idk why they arent promoting this cause everything about this, from the song itself to the choreo to the boys, is absolutely stunning and beautiful and I feel like not promoting this masterpiece is kind of a waste. @ Fantagio what the heck?
nowaititsme it's because they had all of their overseas showcases going on the past month (in Bangkok, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taipei, and the 1st Aroha festival) that Fantagio decided having to fly back and forth between the countries to perform on music shows would be too exhausting/overwhelming and wanted to give Astro a break before their 4th mini album (as Winter Dream is just a short special album)~ they did it to take care of the members, which is sad for fans but at the same time, we should be grateful they're taking care of Astro
Ah that makes sense. Their health and well being definitely comes before anything else!
nowaititsme
I totally agree, they said it didn't fit their image but I think we should have been the judge of that. I believe this choreography absolutely fits their image. It's a beautiful song. I wonder if we can convince Fantagio to release the MV. Lol. I thank fantagio for taking care of the boys. @fantagio
Maria Benites Yes I agree! I heard that Astro did film an MV for this song but Astro and fantigo had a talk and they agreed to discard this mv bc they felt like this song doesn't match their concept but I would have to disagree. This song still pulls off that innocent, cute boy concept but with just sorrow this time haha. This song and dance is perfect! and I wish they had at least released it as a special for the fans and to just not promote it. but either way, I'm happy they gave us this dance practice as a present for us! Hehe it's a great song and I love it!
nowaititsme not only bc of that but bc this is for the fans ..like there are some song that artist released that is just for the fan like Park Kyung - 오글오글 ...
Wow~~~Astro is the king of choreography!!!!
There are like mini Infinite, their moves are so sync :")
k_trashbean :D TRUEEE. Inspirit and Aroha here 💜💛
Inspirit and Aroha here too :)
They are really good.. that is what you call “well synced dance” I Like also the choreography ❤️❤️❤️ASTRO❤️❤️❤️
Siento algo en mi corazon q no se puede explicar verlos ahora q ' an crecido se siente tan hermoso
Who is watching 2021
Because of Cha eun woo .he
Is my fevorite actor dancer singer ..
This song is sooo to be in the soundtrack of a kdrama :x
I'M NEW AROHA!!!! and my bias is Rocky ♡♡♡♡
Welcome! :)
coreografia 10/10
integrantes 10/10
sincronia 10/10
ASTRO 10/10 os nenês da Aine SZ
💜🇩🇪💜Germany loves Astro💜🇩🇪💜
Watching this again❤❤❤❤❤❤
So I'm a pretty new fan, and I know Rocky has technical dance training (which is ballet), but do any of the rest of them? In every dance practice I watch, I'm seriously SO impressed by their choreography. I think out of all of the groups I stan, they have the best dancers. It makes the ballet dancer inside of me so happy. 😂
Sydnee Jinjin!! JinJin is amazing a house-dancing!! He won a lot of house dancing contests before he was a trainee (that’s why he knows GOT7 Yugyeom) Moonbin‘s great skills are due to his effort and 7years of hard work as a trainee. Sanha is very flexible and that’s why he’s so good too. And Rocky mastered not only ballet but genres like jazz, tap, hip hop, clap, modern dance, and omg I can’t remember (I’ve seen he even use his taekwondo skills in choreographies) well, he dances since he was a 5years-old lil boy so..
i can jump thank you!! im seriously so impressed every time i watch this, especially by 2:52 when both moonbin and rocky do a double pirouette into an axel turn like??? axel turns are hard with actual preps and they do it right out of a pirouette? it makes the dancer in me so happy 😂💕
ikr!!? They're both very talented and it's even harder to believe how synchronized they can be doing that at the same time. Their choreographies can seem easy, sometimes, but in reality they're a real challenge and so exhausting omg. I'm so happy you could enjoy their dancing skills as a dancer. I hope you like their style as much as we do ^^ Welcome to the AROHA family💕
kangen kalian selalu ASTRO~
Kangen practiceroom yg dulu^^"
La sincronización!!!! por Dios son unos dioses, como los amo!
VAMOOOOOS VOTAAA
Si puedes difunda lo
Coming back here cuz this is the first video that makes moonbin becoming my bias in ASTRO. I miss him already, rest in peace angel.
Oh my gawd love this song
Estoy tan orgullosa de mis niños 💜💜💜💜💜💜Astro es un grupo muy talentoso, sus habilidades de baile son muy increíbles, cualquiera lo admiraría aún si no fuera un Aroha
This choreography will forever be the best choreography ever in the history of kpop!
Estoy de acuerdo
You spilled the facts!
Agree
@Fatima Mohamed /Aroha and now after a month :))
@Fatima Mohamed /ArohaAtiny ㅎ
2019
WHO'S STILL MAD THAT THIS SONG DOESN'T HAVE MUSIC VIDEO?
edit: it's already 2020... *where's the mv?*
I can't still believe it had never become a MV this song is too beautiful to handle it. BUTJABASSEOYAHAAAAAEEEEE AAAAAHHHH
Not mad but i wish that they have a music video for this song...I think it would be very beautiful
How i wish for the next comeback they have a mv for this ..btw they're having a comeback...so exciteddddd
I heard they had a music video made for this but it didn’t fit a concept at that time so they never uploaded it ahah. It’s prolly stuck on someone’s computer rn 👀👀👀👀
Wyndi i guess i’m hacking into someone computer
lingggvs lmao
I JUST DISCOVERED THIS GROUP LIKE 10 MINS AGO AND I THINK THERE IS NO RETURN FROM THIS POINT
Nina Yeun yeeeees!!! astro are so amazing and deserve so much love. if you want to get to know them, you can watch To Be Continued, it's their web drama and it's on Netflix, or you can watch them on the Immigration
Nina Yeun I suggest you watch their web drama "to be continued" and you'll be locked forever. hahahahaha been there done that.😂😂😂😉
welcome to the dark side😂😂😂
same
littlemermaid Exactly same
New Aroha: So who's their visual line??
me: Ughh Its Mj, Jinjin, Enwoo, Moonbin, Rocky and Sanha :D
noob: ughh isnt that all of them??
me: yea CUZ ASTRO IS A VISUAL GROUP
Jiminieee_ Park jinjin our handsome boy 😂
I just realized how much they grew up since the debuted
My eyes are sweating
TroyesKookie I was thinking the same but then i saw the end lol
They develop even better each season makes me proud as an Aroha since their debut
I know
:D
I feel you ;;
I swear Astro's choreos are the hardest but their songs are the easiest to sing
Joy Alexander I mean yeah they did and I died xD but MOST of NCT127's songs have hard choreos but ALL of Astro's are difficult(I mean with all the foot work and hip movements)
*eunwoo cries in a corner* (didn't sign up for this)
@Joy Alexander but astro is number one on group that dance perfectly in sync. Check it on soompi hun :) and ofc NCT was in too
Not anymore. One is serious shit.
@@lucydontdoxme what?? You didn't like 'one' ??
when it comes to dance practices rocky is ur bias dont lie
minhoe_lee • rocky is my bias all of the time 😆
Kdksiwnwien truuuueeeee
actually it's rocky and sanha xD
Hes my bias 24/7
Of course! I'm a Eunwoo bias but whenver Rocky dance, I always fell for his moves
You are actually kidding!!!! Name another KPOP group that puts a pirouette into a double axle in there coreo????? I'll wait..... STAN ASTRO YOU COWARDS!!!!!!!
Dont challenge astro
I was gonna say, they put some double axle moves in this, its incredible!
Okay random question but have y'all seen Astro's choreo for With You??? I don't know anything about dancing but Rocky does this double spinning thing and then the splits like immediately after it and alsjlkjfkla
I KNOW! I kept rewinding cause I've never seen another group that can do pirouettes. They all did a double coupé in another video and I was shook
Which part?
I remember being obsessed with this video when I found it 5 years ago because of the ending where everyone was laughing, screaming, just being normal Astro, I used to laugh along with them now I’m watching it with tears in my eyes. Rest in peace, Moonbin. ❤️🩹
I'm really not into kpop but Eun woo brought me to astro and there's no turning back now..i'm already inlove with these cute dorks..the only group i stan..fighting!! 😊😘
me too !!! no going back!! in fact can't go back!! to be honest
This is so me
Me too!
Me too..
ASTRO WILL BE HAVING A COMEBACK THIS AUGUST 2 !!! they already released the MV TEASER #1 on FANTAGIO YT CHANNEL !!
Who is here in 2020? This is literally my favorite Astro Song😭😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️
It's my favorite too♡
same here..but i.love all there song..hah just like them hard to choose who is who would be your bias😂😂
Yes, this is one of my fav too!
Tambien es mi favorita
Same!
rocky never fails to amaze no matter how many times i watch him dance, his moves are so smooth and sharp, he inspires me to be as good as him
***ASTRO COMEBACK 2ND AUGUST! mark your calendar roha and DON'T FORGET to collect those thing you need for VOTING ! :)
YASSSSS IKRRRRRRR
His moves captivates me every single time i try to look at another member..... And his moves r soo powerful i meannnnn
He is one of the best out there,.. my eyes are always on him…💜🥰
true 😭❤️
I have a feeling and my guts are never wrong. This guys will make it to the top. They will be huge in a couple of years. ( THAT is coming from someone that does not stan them)
I hope so too 💪
sadia ahmed yes I totally agree. I can see it. they are so cute and amazing. like wow
yes.that is right ASTRO SEEMS be the next most famous group .......if we wnt that remember aroha always support astro ..GO TEAM ASTRO
sadia ahmed a month later but oh well
they will be like bts believe me.
as a feiendly army and a aroha o can say that they will be huge like them in terms of popularity
sadia ahmed I TOTALLY AGREE😦
can we talk about moonbin and rocky's double spin in the back 2:51? and eunwoo gliding across the stage
Rocky- the Baryshnikov of KPOP! For real.
Yeahh...it's the best part
That is what they learnt in acrobatics I guess???
Eunwoo do be sliding tho
Amazing! Thanks for the time stamp :D
WTF 😳😳 did Rocky and Moonbin just do a freakin double pirouette into axel ? At 2:53 Lol
Lynnie Xiong yes they did and at the same time 😮
i was shook !! but it was perfect, the landing and everything !
Lynnie Xiong u
Lynnie Xiong Yup,. Gosh, i would have missed that, if IT werent for you..
Lynnie Xiong WHOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA OMGGGGGG
Hoping that: 1. Astro will continue their dancing skills and be the second Infinite with their knife choreography and practice more for their vocal skills and become the second btob, 2. Become big like BTS and slay charts until there's nothing left to be slayed, 3. Become popular in korea and internationally, 4. Have a big and loyal fandom, and lastly, 5. Win a Daesang in MAMA's. Maybe not today nor tomorrow, but maybe soon.
vai ser logo logo
multifandom strong power thankyou because they deserve to have everything especially awards.Their hardworks needed to be payed off
i'm crying, i really want this to happen.. astro deserves the best❤
How long is the dance
multifandom strong power thankyou i hope it happens too
I am an army and moa. I used to say I'll never stan any other group aside from BTS and TXT. I never knew I needed Astro until I accidentally clicked Blue Flame. And here I am now, binge watching all their MVs, funny moments, Vlive. And I must admit, Astro has one of the best choreographies in Kpop.
welcome to Aroha family 💜 they are sooo talented and funny!!! sadly people dont give much attention to them
@@rockysuweggg200 I know right. I can feel the genuineness of this group. I hope they become big someday.
True. Genuine crackhead and angels too. Cure to depression
WELCOMEE TO THE FAMMM!!! THEY WILL HAVE A NEW COMEBACK THIS MAY 4 💜
They are entertaining to watch for sure!
why are they so underrated, i mean like they didn't get enough attention while they're so talented and their songs are all good whyyyyy???
I agree 100%, But I have hope, they are amazing and have awesome potential! I used to stan BTS before they made it, it's crazy but support who you love regardless :)
dhilynn I’M TELLING YOU! ONE DAY..... THEY ARE GOING TO BE AS KNOWN AS BTS!!! OR EXO! If it doesn’t happens then.... I can’t even imagine what would happend😂 it’s impossible that ASTRO doesn’t get known they are so good❤️
(And sorry for my English, I suck in English / I’m French)😂
Proud to say that ASTRO introduced me to K-pop and they still are my number 1 !!😍
Yes! Me too.
Me too
Hi!
yeah...for me too...they are the reason why I am watching kpop today
I'd like to know your story of getting into K-pop since it's through astro.
Tell us please if you don't mind. It will be interesting
Its not an ASTRO dance practice without the yelling and chaos at the end XD
NIkki G omo so trueee hahahaa
NIkki G lmao yes thats what astros choreography mv's are made of
NIkki G Yazzz
YAAAAAAAS 😂
The choreography is so fucking good. Seriously, I haven't seen a choreography this good and with a unique style like this since Infinite and Shinee.
saranghae821 When you think about it Astro resembles Infinite's style when it comes to dances. They're both really sharp and in sync
@Brina Li especially since theres no member lacking when it comes to dancing, they'r all in sync and are sharp but fluid in their moves
saranghae821 Ugh True!!
Try checking out BTS :)
아스트로하 is Love
Is that sarcasm? I can't tell through writing. If not they simply suggested to try Bts. No big deal.
They performed it at Kcon and the audience loved it! Lots of people attending Kcon on Twitter said this song made them want to check Astro out!!!!
SmileWithMe Their stage was so perfect❗️❗️
SmileWithMe
Hopefully this will make them stan Astro the best thing we can do as fans for the boys is reposting this and spreading the word about this video.
SmileWithMe I hope this boosts Astro's popularity!!! They deserve this!!
SmileWithMe yesss I was there and this was the song that is making me love them and I feel so blessed that I saw it live
SO PROUD OF OUR BOYS ❤❤😢😢
For any new Astro fans...
Watching their drama 'To Be Continued' is a good way to know who they are! That's how I learned their names and looks :)
Bangtan Trasheu13 ME TOO AND THAT'S HOW I GOT INTO ASTRO TOO 😊
Bangtan Trasheu13 I watched it already and all I can say is... I got addicted to the movie 😭😍
I watched it after I know all of them and their looks
Bangtan Trasheu13 lmao
Ooh Thankyou. I'll to watch that :)
I want them to get big but at the same time I want them to be my little secret... it's really selfish of me to ask it though
They deserve to be seen
sameee:(
+X same fam D: I want Astro to stay rookies forever buhuhuhu ahhhh my precious children QAQ but I also want them to reach the top.
X I feel you 😭😭😞😔💔
Basically what I feel with every group I discover before they make it big >
that's how I feel towards BTS. I'm happy that they're gaining massive attention around the world, but i also don't want them to become "mainstream". I really miss the old bangtan tbh :,((
ok real talk: no matter how surface-level impressed i get with a song, video, or group, i've never actually connected with a group besides BTS enough to properly stan them. However, i'm like 4 hours deep into an Astro binge (i just found them) and i tried so hard to resist (cause i don't have the emotional energy to stan another group tbh hahah) but *it's h a p p e n i n g* like fuck they're so funny and talented and i'm already so soft for them. I've just been grinning for the past 4 hours cause they're such goons. I know their names already so it's basically too late to back out now. I'm in it, guys. I stan.
Welcome new Aroha!
Welcome to the fandom
House of Jikook SAME I ALREADY STANNED THEM IN JUST A DAY like what group have this kind of charm? I hard stanned Bts and Wanna one but Astro issssss........ Im speechless
then i'm sure you'd be happy to know that astro are huge bts fans too :D
Yes I am. I really love Sanha ,Jin Jin, and Mj here😻
! Oh no... Sanha got me feeling so attacked... Thought I was ready for a fierce concept but Idk anymore 😂 #HAPPYSANHADAY
Nik Syazana Sanha is REALLY rude in this video. My noona heart can't take it.
Nik Syazana I always forget that he is the same age as me
isalovewierdo อืกเ
This song must be perfect if they drop it as a soundtrack in K-drama
YESSS
I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO THOUGHT THAT. Today while I was in the car, I was listening to this song with my earphones in and I just thought of a drama scene in my head haha :D
your right
Faisal Kahfi true true.
Tbh, most of their songs can pass as an ost for a k-drama.
My Daughter fell in love with these in less than 24 hours and now I'm here because I'm a kpop trash mum and I'm adopting these boys as my sons. They are so so talented and the songs are really good too.
atinkerfairy me as a mom tho
You are my role model for mom
Malia GS plz adopt me
ME TOO
Thats some good parenting right THERE wish my mum was like this
과거로 가서 붙잡고... 싶다
과거로 가면 미친사람 취급해도 되니깐 죽지 말아달라고 빌고싶다 진짜
Rocky is so damn hypnotizing. I kept trying to pay attention to everyone else but my eyes would always stay on Rocky (not complaining)
Is Rocky the one with a black sweatshirt with print on? I am really new to Astro, but I know that Rocky is "the dancer" of the group, even though they all just dance amazingly!
Sarah Andersen he's the one with the long sleeve shirt with the picture thing on it with black jeans idk if that helps sorry im bad at explaining things 😂
rocky......why is rocky your bias?......i mean no shade.....just *gulps
@@lilacstars5307 Why not? Lmao I love that dude. He deserves more recognition for his dancing abilities. Would be a shame if you stan the others except for him.
3J slays Me that is why he is main dancer he is fantastic
ASTRO needs more attention!
They are so good. They have good choreos, their songs are beautiful. But they are so underrated!
We must support them more!
WE MUST REACH MORE VIEWS!
Rafia B YES
Rafia B They aren't that underrated, they get more and more popular each year.
They might be the next bts.
Angela Amoako
OHO YES PLEASE
FANTAGIO IS SUCH A KIND COMPANY AND Y E AH SS
YES
I learn to dance ASTRO's AGAIN.
And then i realized, how easy are all of the rest of Kpop's choreos.
I hav never given up any dances that i wanted to learn.
But here. I hav found one i couldn't get till the end.
You missed one step. You miss the rest song.
Saaaaame
I've been learning this song, baby and a lot of bts choreographies and bts also has really hard choreos ☺️ it also depends on what song and what choreo you are trying to learn, like baby is easier than again ❤️
I learned one step form baby
SAME :(
One tip: Go to settings for the video and slow it down then you can learn it easier (I do this with sf9 choreo but I want to learn this one and all the songs of Astro sf9 and bts)
One of my favourite choreography. It's hard for even membered groups to make their dance look group when one of the members has a solo and is standing in the center because for it to be symmetrical, one person has to hide in the back or something so that there are two people on each side. However, Astro still manages to pull it off. I love the dance because it really expresses a lot of emotion; though I don't speak Korean I'd assume the song is about the anguish of missing someone and trying to get over them. I also love the formations they make, like when Eunwoo was singing his part and the members were circling around him. Ahh this song in general is so underappreciated. I love it so much.
Winnie NCT yep, the song is about trying to get over someone after a break up.
oh wow they are really underrated. Please give astro some appreciation, love and support guys. this song is so good and that choreo is DAMN - i am lost for words.
2024: Back here after Eunwoo's Mystery Elevator Encore in Japan.
Much time had passed, those young ASTRO boys in the video couldn't have imagined that one day they'll be tragically losing one of their precious brothers. That's why the memories that this video captured is a part of eternity that everyone will cherish forever. Thank you ASTRO and rest well our dear Moonbin. ☆♡
My team always wins modern dance competitions if they bring the choreography of every Astro song !!!
Wow!! That shows the standard of their choreo!
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
1) Is this their comeback?
Yes. ASTRO has been doing a seasonal concept throughout their first year (spring up, summer vibes, autumn story) and this is the title song of the winter album, Winter Dream.
2) When did they release an album?
Winter Dream was released on February 22, 2017, one day before their first anniversary. This was most likely planned so that the "winter" comeback happened before the anniversary of the Spring album so they could come full circle with the concept.
3) Why does Winter Dream only have 3 songs?
ASTRO did not end Autumn Story promotions until well into January. Winter Dream is titled a "special album", most likely because there was not enough time before the anniversary to create a mini album. However, the fact that ASTRO wrote lyrics to a song and title it "You&Me (Thanks AROHA)", a fan song, definitely makes up for the fact that there are only three songs.
4) Why aren't they promoting? How come I am just now hearing of this?
They did not promote on music shows like groups typically do when they have a comeback. The release of the album was February 22 for the reason explained above. On February 26 they held two concerts for their Korean fans. On February 12, they traveled to Thailand to hold on a concert that had been rescheduled from October 2016. On February 28, they performed in Taiwan. On March 3, they performed in Hong Kong. On March 5, they performed in Singapore. Because of all of these concerts, they were unable to promote their song on music shows. Additionally, they've been working non stop all year round and fantagio probably wanted them to rest more during this time period and work on preparing a full album for the future.
5) Is there a music video?
There is not. Although it was reported that a music video was filmed, the company released a statement saying that the footage was unsatisfactory and did not fit Astros image, and after much discussion astro and their management decided not to release anything.
6) Why do I also see it called "Should Have Held On To You" / "Should Have Held On" / "Should've Held On" / "Should've Held On To You"?
Many of Astros tweets only used the hangul for the songs title, and fans did their best to translate the title. This dance practice is probably the first time many Aroha are seeing "again" as the official title.
EDIT: ASTRO's official facebook did use the #Again when posting the highlight medley, but the title was not widely spread amongst AROHA and most still refer to it as "Should Have Held On To You". If you are looking for fancams, try searching Should Have Held On To You!
if there are any other questions, please ask !!
Wow, thanks a lot ! I was actually wondering why the MV wasn't still out... So that's the reason :(. I'm quite disappointed, but anyways, i'll support them whatever :D ♥.
Ani Lin "Again" is the english title. When they post the medley of the album, one of the hastags there is #Again which I think many AROHAs didnt see. Look at their official FB account and search for the highlight medley post ☺️💫🌟⭐️
Sana Girl yeah, fans both domestically and internationally were expecting a music video when the song was realeased and everyone was really shocked when one didn't drop. it's a shame there is no video, but I also wouldn't want astro releasing something they aren't proud of
Thank you~~~
Ani Lin good job chingu 😊 thanks for description.. i know there's a lot of ppl who still doesnt know this
I'm stopping by after 6 years since I last commented. I watch this now and cry for a very different reason. Hell, I barely started the video and as soon as the music started and I heard Moonbin's voice, I just lost it. I've been with Astro for as long as predebut. I'll forever miss Moonbin so much.
Who's Here In 2020?!?!
MEE
I am here too. Love for Astro group and my sweet cha eun woo.💖💖
November 2020 💚❤💜💙
December 2020 💕
BUT I LIVE FOR SANHA'S RIPPED JEANS BRUH
Kim Minhyuk OMG I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS 😂🙈
SAME HE LOOKS SO GOOD IN THIS OML
Kim Minhyuk YES
Kim Minhyuk SOOOO COOL (✪▽✪)💕💕
SO AMAZING RIGHT?!
I'll be honest, the only member I know is Eunwoo, tho I already know about ASTRO since their debut, I've watched some of their MVs too but didn't bother to know them more. I even just tried watching this dance practice because I heard this song before and I love it.
But that guy at 1:29 caught my eye. Like damn, he can seriously dance. It's like he didn't even try hard and it just comes naturally on him, he just feeling the song and his every move. After his part my attention just suddenly focused only on him until the end. I even needed to watch it again to see his dancing at the beginning until the end, then watch it once again to watch it as a whole group and not just him. lol.
BBYU SungJae_SooYoung 1:29 ROCKY
1 ruclips.net/video/hcG8eDC_xCY/видео.html
2 ruclips.net/video/rWl3RCT-keg/видео.html
2 ruclips.net/video/UoFdnUrjG0w/видео.html
3 ruclips.net/video/uKqPsfOiJLU/видео.html
4 ruclips.net/video/zAB36mywm0c/видео.html
5 1 ruclips.net/video/xz9aikm0qog/видео.html
6 ruclips.net/video/GRDO4vg-060/видео.html
7 ruclips.net/video/RbQ75ZJ9OM4/видео.html
8 ruclips.net/video/6zS7R1Anhac/видео.html
9 ruclips.net/video/lpoCuO0fITM/видео.html
10 ruclips.net/video/m1aEYZhAR-U/видео.html
11 ruclips.net/video/5RXftzDOYuw/видео.html
12 ruclips.net/video/avXDxWtjGRM/видео.html
13 ruclips.net/video/uUgsXm4AHMs/видео.html
14 ruclips.net/video/IqgABuYDHMQ/видео.html
Is the best group ♡
Yeah,that's Rocky,a Rock but actually became a paper when he dance,coz his body was as light as paper.that part was my favorite.
I watched this 7 and 1/2 times after the first 1/2 watching it focusing on each member, but my eyes always wanted to watch Rocky.
@@melainacaerlaverock7745 I feel the opposite to you.. 😅 rocky is my bias and yes I usually can't take my eyes off him but this time hits me different.. the other dance well tho, I heard on some vlive mj oppa is not a dance member but he did dance well tho.. I keep replaying to see each member dance, they're great..
me: *skips back every 5 seconds so I can look at a different member because they're all talented individuals who are skilled at dancing*
Jaden's vanity same i repeated this 6 times to focus on each member xD
Seventeen is only group I agreed when it comes to synchronize but they're two groups now because Astro slap me this. I should stan them ✊
People talking about how pity it is for astro for not releasing a mv for this song. i just want to say.. I AGREE WITH YOU TOO OMG. AND THEY SHOULD ACTUALLY PROMOTE THIS SONG. WHY DIDN FANTAGIO DID IT. WHY.
kpop._. pie
Fantagio was not satisfied with the quality of the MV and didn't want to put out something that wasn't the best that they could do; yeah it kind of sucks but in a way, it shows the phenomenal amount of effort that goes into Astro's MV
They didn't promote due to Astro's extremely busy overseas schedule where they've had showcases in Bangkok, Taipei, Hong Kong, etc and Fantagio didn't want to exhaust the members by having them fly back and forth to promote on music shows. Can you imagine how tired they would've been? At least they are getting some well deserved rest and staying healthy! In addition, this isn't even a mini album (winter dream); it's a special album for the fans, and they're already preparing for their 4th mini album, which WILL be promoted.
before dis they used to wore pink green yellow shirt but now they wore black&white xD astro manly concept has comes out 😍
I'm just scared if they do a 'bad boy' comeback..I don't think my heart would take it
Jasmine Memon they won't do it for awhile so you don't have to worry
Ik, I kinda want them to do one but at the same time I want them to stay innocent XDD
kwonh that was the problem fantasy-aegyo fantaegyo thats why they didn't release the video cause they looked so Manly and the thing is that they want to be noun as a cute group producers ^^
kwonh we want them to have mature concepts but Fantaegio, is known for cute concept groups and trainee, it sucks that the have no answer but To stay in cute concept
Oh my... not releasing a music video for this song might be a big mistake on Fantagio's part. It sounds SO good and has a beautiful choreography. It's the perfect opportunity for Astro to try out a different concept! I wasn't into their cute concepts, but this song is exactly my style. They totally could've reached a broader audience had they released a music video with this comeback. (I completely chanced upon this video on VLive today and was SHOOK because such a wonderful song has been out for a month and most of the kpop community didn't, and still might not, even know about it!)
I understand why they're not promoting on music shows, but ahhhhh I can't help but feel like Astro lost a big growth opportunity here (TT-TT)
fantagio made a statement regarding the music video, the mv didnt fit their image and tried to fix it but failed so they didnt put it out
Emma Beldick yeah, I read all about that already. I still stand by my statement. I hope they'll be able to refilm something they find satisfactory once they have time and release it later. There's just too much potential lost here...
I Believe in Bangtan I feel like this is the "real" Astro Moonbin has mentioned before not the cute Astro
why aren't they promoting on music shows !?!?!?
Aayisha Tabassum I think they are currently working on their next comeback which will from what I know be a full album, the 4 Season Project is over so they might get a new concept as well, in the first 4 seasons they were cute, it's time to start growing up, when they debuted half of the team was underage so I understand why they went for the cute concept, I mean Sanha was literally a child, but now 2/3 of the members are grown ups, only Rocky and Sanha are still underage, I'm not saying they should change completely and go for a sexy concept, no they should wait with that until Sanha gets off age as well, but grown up concepts doesn't necessary mean sexy,
It's almost 2022, but this is still one of the best song and dance.
THEY ARE ALL SO IN SYNC!!
But you could tell Rocky's dancing skill is on another level
Agreed
omg eunwoo took aroha's advice of wearing white dress shirt from jinjin's birthday vapp
yaoi diick Ohmygod 😂😂😂 you're right
OMG I was thinking that too lol
manly eunwoo
AS A DANCER I AM JEALOUS OF ROCKY AND MOONBIN'S DOUBLE INTO AN AXLE UPDATE: BC ITS SO SOLID AND PROBABLY CONSISTENT LIKE GOALS
SAME
Christie Chen I have never thought of the idea of double to an axle LOL
the stRUGGLE IS REAL i can like *just* do one and its not that solid yet RIP
+Christie Chen what is it??
^^ at around 2:50 Rocky and Moonbin do two turns into a jump called an axle :)
I never stan any kpop group before but because of true beauty ,Cha Eun Woo☺💜
I was given the chance to know the group Astro, and I am madly in love with their moves, choreography,faces, voice , attitude ,etc.
They have an amazing talent.
They deserve to be on top☺💜
My boys ☺💜
My happy pill☺💜
Thanks God💜
I found ASTRO💜
Proud Aroha here from Cebu,the Philippines☺💜
same here!!!
Whenever someone says Eunwoo is just a pretty face show them this video, he has the most lines and his dancing is on point!
I know I'm late, but I was just thinking the same thing while watching.
tightly synchronized, masterfully executed with facial expressions that touches and moves the audience. Have never commented on any Kpop group but was totally impressed...
why do i have a feeling that sanha is wearing rocky's shirt from the hide and seek dance practice
I SWEAR THEY SHARE CLOTHES SO MUCH ITS SO ADORABLEWEKF
라키애인 OMG I NOTICED THAT TOO IT'S ADORABLE
라키애인 okay i went back and the sleeves are way too short but still the coincidence is still cute
+kath rin rocky folded up the sleeves tho 👀👀
라키애인 👀 maybe then HAHAHHA it's still adorable
I'm so obsessed with Again and the dance that I watch it 3 times everyday (when I wake up when I come home from school and before I go to sleep) I'm pretty sure more than 3 times a day btw I'm being completely honest
Nouchee Gnav i feel you seriously I am obsessed With it. This Song also was the Reason why I became Aroha .
Same~~ and I'm still doing this everyday until now😊
Wow you guys are really loyal fans thank you
kagehina's child lol 😂 it's like a daily routines now
everytime I'm in a bad mood, I always come here and my mood gets better:) alwayss
Hanifa Muharroro this is the biggest mood. I don’t invest myself into Astro as much as I used to but they’re still my comfort zone. They make ppl so happy
honestly, this is my fav astro song and choreography.. its a shame theyre not promoting this but im glad they finally dropped the dance practice 😍
same.
when u study n got this notification
then immediately choose to watch this video
D.O Dilla ME TOO
D.O Dilla mee tooo
D.O Dilla Same
me too hahaha lol
D.O Dilla - don't
Honestly, Astro are starting to remind me of Infinite.Obviously their styles are almost nothing alike but their dancing is very similar. Infinite are known for their synchronization and knife dances and I've yet to see a group that lives up to that title. Sure, some come close like Vixx and Monsta X but not on the level that Infinte is known for. But Astro, they're so synchronized and sharp it's almost ridiculous. *They* remind me of Infinite, the only group I've been able to compare to Infinite, and the only group that leaves me as surprised, breathtaken, and proud as Infinite.
Yassss I agree ♥
세븐틴 몰래 듣지 마요
Eunwoo would love to hear you say that, being such of a big fan of infinite :)
totally agree. saw their speed dance on after school right after debut, I was lost for words. no idol I've know can do that precise other than Infinite.
세븐틴 몰래 듣지 마요 i'm an inspirit before. I followed their activities since you are my oppa era tbvh astro remind me of infinite so much it become one of the reason why i start to look at them properly. The vibe they are executing is similar that of infinite. I will continue to support astro and i hope they will become as successful as infinite too.
I totally agree, the only other band than reminds me of that type of dancing is the pre-debut group A.C.E. I dismissed Astro due to their cute concept but now i've released their dancing is no joke.
Never got interested in KPop until I saw this group's video. I admire their synchronicity and not one of them try to outdo the others. Thumbs up to the choreographer. Hope I will be able to see them perform live.
I just wonder why they're still such an underrated group. All of them has all the aspects in a perfect idol. Their dances are so precise and powerful even though the song itself isn't as upbeat as the usual title songs. Their vocals are amazing, being able to keep a stable voice whilst dancing really tiresome choreography is not something that can be as well executed as how astro does it. They have no visual holes in the group ( although this can be determined by many other's opinion on the topic ). They also all have acting abilities, coming from "to be continued". How? Just how are these such multitalented members go unheard of/ unnoticed from so many people?
Aegyo Suga A lot of people refused to look at them twice because they didn't like the "cute" concept of their debut song and first comeback, and might be stubborn to get into them now
I know right? 😩
IKR. When I first saw them on weekly idol i was like mehh i wasnt really into the cute concept. but then i decided to give it another try i listened to their albums and i became OBSESSED. i love the members too and they're all very talented.
Aegyo Suga although they may seem underrated, they are only underrated internationally--- ASTRO ( alongside the NCT units ) were the most popular male 2016 debuts in Korea. :) they recently received a Bosang award and were in second place for BEST NEW MALE ARTIST for MAMA 2016
theyre underratedish worldwide because not many worldwide like the cute concept. however this kikd of concept is very popular in korea and they have more of a chance of success goinf with the cute concept. watch edward avilas video for more
Literally watched this like 50 times and I never get tired of the song or the choreography. Astro is literally SO talented my heart is melting. Got7 is my ultimate bias group and I never thought I'd find a group that makes me as happy as Got7 does but Astro is coming close second. They're talented, driven, cute, and HILARIOUS. It's so refreshing to have a new group that I stan hard and they've quickly become my second bias group in the few months that I've known them. I'm literally so excited to watch them grow even more and see Arohas expand as they become more popular. Astro fighting!!❤
I try to watch the whole choreography, but I ended up just watching Rocky. The choreography itself is really good, I LOVE IT, but watching Rocky and his moves... dang it, he's amazing!
It doesnt matter how many years have passed, im always coming back to this perfect dance practice
I love it. First, Rocky has to be one of the most natural dancers I've ever seen in my life (and I'm a dancer so I've seen my fair share). The way he moves, the motions just flow through him like it's as normal to him as walking. It's incredible and I honestly don't know if I've seen anything like it. And every single one of them is an amazing dancer. I remember when I first started watching their videos I was in shock at how good all of them were at dancing, and how they all seemed to be running on exactly the same frequency and were so in sync. Not to mention their songs/vocals/rapping is amazing as well. I cannot wait to see where these boys go.
He's a "classically trained" dancer :) he's done ballet, tap, jazz; all of that fun stuff!
thank you a lot. our boys deserve such good words.
It’s really good to see a group when all the members dance very well and this is the case of Astro, but when this happen in other groups the main dancers almost look the same than the rest, very sync that if you do not know the band it is difficult to identify who is the main dancers. However in Astro Rocky excels in his moves, he is almost perfect. In my opinion he is one of the best dancers of k-pop industry.
Kings of synchronization, no cap
***ASTRO COMEBACK 2ND AUGUST! mark your calendar roha and DON'T FORGET to collect those thing you need for VOTING ! :)
Honestly I want to cry so hard. This dance practice seems so different from the other ones. From the dance to the song to the video itself. The dance is so powerful and full, like they're giving it their all. The song is so powerful as well, their vocals are off the charts, it really seems like they're trying to make this one memorable. To me this feels like if they were disbanding. The room itself isn't as bright as usual, it's kinda dim. Once they finished and they went close to the camera acting like themselves, it really felt like this was the end of this group, their final leave. I don't know, it's just me but I'm so glad that they're going to have many more amazing comebacks in the future
dont worry, they aren't leaving, I think now they are working on their next album so they will come back
I know they aren't leaving but this video just gives off vibes like if this were their actual leaving
It does but thats the feel of the song
Emma Beldick that's also what I mentioned in my comment, the feel, the way they act at the end, the dim room, the deep song, everything feels like it's the end and that's what I love the most about this beautiful song
Stan Marsh somebody even mentioned that MJ looked distant. :((( dont make me sad ohmygod
I've watched this choreography for a thousandth times and the LOW THE VOLUME still always kills me 🤣🤣🤣
Now I *really* want to know what the M/V would've been like if this is how beautiful the choreography is ;-;
Laura Ward i wish fantagio wld at least release it to make arohas happy since astro spent time to flim it!! :"-(
Even if they release it later as some sort of extra I'd be happy, I just want to see what they've worked so hard on and what sort of video they wanted to originally go for :'( They said it doesn't match the concept but I feel like it was beautiful anyway
me too~~~
yahh me too!
They won't be releasing one for this song, Fantagio released a statement saying '...we came to a conclusion that the final product of the music video did not match ASTRO's image and/or concept' and that they won't be releasing it
I don't trust any kpop fan who's never seen this
Applaud to the translator who said LOW THE VOLUME
Skskskskks
I never how deep this song is, i thought it was about a love one finding their soulmate or a happy ending on a love story something like that based on the vibes i get and their dance ha
I absolutely adore this video and especially the video where Moonbin excels we continue to love and support all Astro members ❤
I'm still kinda sad Fantagio doesn't release MV for this. I know it didn't match Astro's current concept.. but what about releasing it few years later as anniversary gift? :"
yass
or after crazy sexy cool!
this is my first time watching astro and why the fuck there isn't a music video for this? this is so beautiful, the choreo is just perfect, and the short one (I apologise deeply I do not know names yet sorry if I offend someone) HIS VOICE IS DEEP AF HELP ME I WASNT EXPECTING IT AT ALL LIKE IS IT REALLY HIM WHAT WHAYAATATTTAAT HELP ME PLS TELL ME NAMES AND PROFILES PLSPLS
JINJIN @ 1:20 ('96 liner)- leader, main rapper
MJ @ 1:00 ('94 liner)- main vocal (HIS VOICE IS ANGELIC)
MOONBIN @ 0:24 ('98 liner)- lead vocal, lead dancer
EUNWOO @ 0:42 ('97 liner)- visual, sub-vocal
ROCKY (MINHYUK) @ 1:30 ('99 liner)- main dancer, lead rapper, hes got the vocals too but doesn't showcase it in their tracks :(
SANHA @ 1:39 ('00 liner)- lead vocal, maknae
PLS STAN ASTRO STAN TALENT THEY'RE AMAZING
justisine I have strong feelings for moonbin he's now my bias in the group, and my bias wrecker is jinjin, with his deep ass voice Boi how did I not find out about them before?
And I want to ask about their logo, what does it mean?
Mia Bae haha mine are the other way: JinJin is my bias and Moonbin is my bias wrecker. ugh, their smiles....and MJ's voice makes him secondary bias lol
Mia Bae you've probably found out by now but "Astro" means star in spanish (therefore the logo) and they named themselves that because they want to be the stars in arohas hearts :)
I'm pretty sure everyone calls MJ the short one the first time they watch an Astro video.
Astro: Where you don't have a bias, because everyone is so perfect, then ... you are a multiple bias, you cannot deny this.
or simply change bias on each comeback.
The most satisfying choreography ever, THEY'RE SO SYNCHRONIZED
Besides One Direction, i didn’t stan any other band. And now Astro. IM ADDICITED.
Oh don't remind me One direction how much I stanned that group 💔😭 but now Astro is the only one 💕
after RAin..tHIs is my 2nd kpopwho i will stan..and support but im addicted to them more
ashlee morenz SAMEEE GIRL
@@marwah1824 ☺️☺️☺️😍
I'm also a directioner, but apparently the directioner sisters have the same taste. HERE'S LOVING ASTRO💜💜✨🥺
That was neat! The synchronization is no joke! Everybody dances with almost the same intensity no one outdoes or outshines anyone. Bravo 👍🏻#Astro