I thought we would grow old together and then he died , too young . I looked for him everywhere , even in my dreams there were crowds and I thought I could see him over their heads . 20 years later I still miss him
THIS. The originality of Gretchen's lyrics is matched by very few, and while many others have performed or covered her hits, as you note, she's also an excellent performer in her own right. (And as in this performance, her musical and personal chemistry with Barry Walsh often elevates that even further.) She has a devoted following, particularly in the UK, but it should by all rights be *at least* 10x or 100x larger, globally!
I am in St. Cloud, Minnesota, tonight because of this song. About to turn 60 in December, it's a good enough reason to do a road trip across North America. There are so many names for this road trip, but one of them is the Jimmy Lafave Memorial Road Trip. When I first discovered his music, about 20 years ago, I was ready to drive from Toronto to Oklahoma for his voice and his music. I had the luck to see Jimmy live a few times in Toronto and Ontario and then I was devastated to learn of his early and sad death. I love this song so much and I love Gretchen so much for supporting Jimmy's music and his memory. I am in St. Cloud, Minnesota, tonight because of Gretchen and Jimmy. This song is incredible and extraordinary, and I hope that the love of music makes this world a better place.
God, what a beautiful song! So sad, evoking lost love, regret, and what could have been. It makes this 72 year old man cry when I hear it. As an old man your regrets are for the things that you didn't do and the things that could have been, not so much regrets for things that you did. Thank you Gretchen Peters for perfectly capturing the feeling and writing it.
This is songwriting at its best. You can feel every word. 54 years ago, when I was in basic training my girlfriend came down to stay near the fort on a bus. We had a weekend together neither one of us will ever forget. We are still together travelling far and wide! Burlington Bill busking on the road and here on You-Tube.
The most amazing song I've ever heard live! I thought Tricia Yearwood was amazing until I watched the original artist Gretchen Peters sing it live! Amazing beyond belief ❤️
There come moments in a person's life when something is so hauntingly beautiful, it just stops you in your tracks, and just like the line from this song, "you weep in the arms of Jesus for the choices you made" This song is that for me.
Ken, me too. I love the Trish Yearwood version, but when I noticed that Gretchen was the author I had to find her singing it. Ripped my heart right out.
I'm in the U.K. I've been lucky enough to have seen these guys in concert three times now. They've surpassed themselves every time. That said, this, for me, is still the definitive version of this song. Brings me out in goosebumps every time I play it.
Saw Gretchen live at the Opera House in Buxton, Derbyshire a few years ago. Her stage presence was very genuine and honest... No frills required when pure talent speaks for its self.
Gretchen, You and Barry Walsh are an incredible duo. You both compliment each other's impeccable music talents. I listen to you all the time and feel as though I'm listening to good friends. Keep singing - you keep our hearts young and alive!
Your voice is beautiful... This song has always brought the hair on the back on my neck, but your version is the MOST beautiful... Brings the hair on the back of my neck plus chills down my arms. Thank YOU... We need more of your beautiful voice... :)
There's nobody like Gretchen Peters, to transport us *somewhere else* that we have known all our lives, even if we have never been there before, in our secret heart of hearts. Gracias, mi amiga!
This is such an awesome song. What a privilege to be able to listen to and watch her sing it so intimately. This song grabbed me the first time I ever heard it and I still get lost in it to this day. Most songs you just listen to; this is one you actually merge with for five minutes.
so inspiring to hear an older woman continuing to do her thing so exquisitely, so impeccably, in this world that demands youth and glamour before all else....
Taking a train from Grand Forks to Chicago we pulled into a station, and I realised we had arrived at the destination for one of my favourite songs. Given the time I have to take a bus there someday.
This is a masterpiece of a song - it has all the magic that a great song has - it tells a story , but vague enough so the audience can imagine their own version - it captures all the melancholy of failed love affair - such feelings are beyond words - it's as if Gretchen reached in to the collective unconscious and pulled out such a sad story - melancholy, but healing at the same time - Gretchen you deserve all the accolades - although your version is great, the version and video by Trisha Yearwood is a "masterpiece" - and a masterpiece of Americana music - a video that defines all that a music can be - it reaches into your soul and breaks your heart - what else can one say?
Sublime! I had the good fortune to hear Gretchen, and John Lester on bass, about 16 years back at Newcastle Quayside. A breath-takingly good performance. She certainly had, and retains, the magical zizz! [Tyneside, England.]
This song is haunting. Top three of my fave EVER. I know it song in Trisha Yearwood's version. Have loved it since it came out. Thank U, Gretchen Peters💙. Every corner in the world has its Saint Cloud story. Greegings from Poland❤.
I was 20 the first time I heard this song.... 30 years later.. it's the same... And I love the Grechen has always held out for the down and out and the LGBTQ community!
drove thru St. Cloud, MN today...........love Gretchen's work....greetings from central MN where we are enjoying the most pleasant summer in recent history
A long time after this video appeared I know, but just to say, I also think this is magical, heart-wrenchingly beautiful, makes the hairs on the back of my neck tingle. Thanks Gretchen 🙏.
Great voice and performance. Its definitely her song. There is pain but also an underlying sweetness, unaffected by the very pain she sings about. Bravo.
We had the great good fortune to see Gretchen open for Janis Ian at the Palms in Winters, California a few years ago. Have been a great fan of hers ever since. What an amazing talent - both as songwriter and singer.
I love a lot of Gretchen's music, but I love this song the most. Who hasn't had the experience of thinking they see an old love? John Gorka tackles the same topic with "I Saw A Stranger With Your Hair"
Do not neglect Jimmy LaFave's amazing version of this song. He made it his own. As Gretchen has so humbly said: "It is Jimmy's song. I just happened to write it."
. For myself , I do believe she is being remarkably self-effacing to state that . This song is crying out for the texture , timbre and that , what I can only attempt to describe as ... ' known ... unknowingness ' of a woman's voice , one who has known what all that not knowing quite what happened ... will ever mean .
@@donaldcook3112 Gretchen may be self-effacing. She is a very good and humble soul, but she knew how much Jimmy LaFave loved the song and how he was so proud to deliver it in concert. And he always gave her full credit for writing it. It worked well for both of them, good friends as they were. I can appreciate and love both versions!
ON A BUS TO ST CLOUD LYRICS On a bus to St. Cloud, Minnesota I thought I saw you there With the snow falling down around you Like a silent prayer And once on a street in New York City With the jazz and the sin in the air And once on a cold L.A. freeway Going nowhere And it's strange, but it's true I was sure it was you Just a face in the crowd On a bus to St. Cloud In a church in downtown New Orleans I got down on my knees and prayed And I wept in the arms of Jesus For the choice you made We were just gettin' to the good part Just gettin' past the mystery Oh, and it's just like you, it's just like you To disagree And it's strange but it's true You just slipped out of view Like a face in the crowd On a bus to St. Cloud And you chase me like a shadow And you haunt me like a ghost And I hate you some, and I love you some But I miss you most... On a bus to St. Cloud, Minnesota I thought I saw you there With the snow falling down around you Like a silent prayer
I thought we would grow old together and then he died , too young . I looked for him everywhere , even in my dreams there were crowds and I thought I could see him over their heads . 20 years later I still miss him
She must be the most unappreciated performer of all time. So many hits for others but a fabulous voice and an excellent musician.
THIS. The originality of Gretchen's lyrics is matched by very few, and while many others have performed or covered her hits, as you note, she's also an excellent performer in her own right. (And as in this performance, her musical and personal chemistry with Barry Walsh often elevates that even further.) She has a devoted following, particularly in the UK, but it should by all rights be *at least* 10x or 100x larger, globally!
couldn't agree more
I am in St. Cloud, Minnesota, tonight because of this song. About to turn 60 in December, it's a good enough reason to do a road trip across North America. There are so many names for this road trip, but one of them is the Jimmy Lafave Memorial Road Trip. When I first discovered his music, about 20 years ago, I was ready to drive from Toronto to Oklahoma for his voice and his music. I had the luck to see Jimmy live a few times in Toronto and Ontario and then I was devastated to learn of his early and sad death. I love this song so much and I love Gretchen so much for supporting Jimmy's music and his memory. I am in St. Cloud, Minnesota, tonight because of Gretchen and Jimmy. This song is incredible and extraordinary, and I hope that the love of music makes this world a better place.
God, what a beautiful song! So sad, evoking lost love, regret, and what could have been. It makes this 72 year old man cry when I hear it. As an old man your regrets are for the things that you didn't do and the things that could have been, not so much regrets for things that you did. Thank you Gretchen Peters for perfectly capturing the feeling and writing it.
This is songwriting at its best. You can feel every word. 54 years ago, when I was in basic training my girlfriend came down to stay near the fort on a bus. We had a weekend together neither one of us will ever forget. We are still together travelling far and wide! Burlington Bill busking on the road and here on You-Tube.
Many songs make me tear up...this one makes me weep without shame.
I like Gretchen's rendition. Full of souls & emotions.
Magical. Thank you Gretchen Peters for writing such a stunning song.
One of the most beautiful songs ever....
The most amazing song I've ever heard live! I thought Tricia Yearwood was amazing until I watched the original artist Gretchen Peters sing it live! Amazing beyond belief ❤️
There come moments in a person's life when something is so hauntingly beautiful, it just stops you in your tracks, and just like the line from this song, "you weep in the arms of Jesus for the choices you made" This song is that for me.
Ken, me too. I love the Trish Yearwood version, but when I noticed that Gretchen was the author I had to find her singing it. Ripped my heart right out.
This is one talented Troubadour had the pleasure of seeing Gretchen live in Dublins Fair City and a meet afterwards what a pleasure
I'm in the U.K. I've been lucky enough to have seen these guys in concert three times now. They've surpassed themselves every time. That said, this, for me, is still the definitive version of this song. Brings me out in goosebumps every time I play it.
Saw Gretchen live at the Opera House in Buxton, Derbyshire a few years ago. Her stage presence was very genuine and honest... No frills required when pure talent speaks for its self.
What a powerful song. And such a powerful performance.
Wonderful vocals from GP. Lovely interpretation.
Thank you Gretchen! Absolutely lovely!
Gretchen, You and Barry Walsh are an incredible duo. You both compliment each other's impeccable music talents. I listen to you all the time and feel as though I'm listening to good friends. Keep singing - you keep our hearts young and alive!
I have no words for what I just heard. But thank God Gretchen Peters has the words for how we all feel at times.
Your voice is beautiful... This song has always brought the hair on the back on my neck, but your version is the MOST beautiful... Brings the hair on the back of my neck plus chills down my arms. Thank YOU... We need more of your beautiful voice... :)
Oh, my goodness. If this doesn't rip your heart out, you don't have one.
Awe... bless you...gets to me too.
Beautiful song.
There's nobody like Gretchen Peters, to transport us *somewhere else* that we have known all our lives, even if we have never been there before, in our secret heart of hearts. Gracias, mi amiga!
So beautiful!
This is such an awesome song. What a privilege to be able to listen to and watch her sing it so intimately. This song grabbed me the first time I ever heard it and I still get lost in it to this day. Most songs you just listen to; this is one you actually merge with for five minutes.
so inspiring to hear an older woman continuing to do her thing so exquisitely, so impeccably, in this world that demands youth and glamour before all else....
So incredibly beautiful and I love the piano with it too thank you Elizabeth for posting and sending to me
Thank you sweetheart for posting the video and sending it to me I loved it
Sent from my iPhone
Perfection
Taking a train from Grand Forks to Chicago we pulled into a station, and I realised we had arrived at the destination for one of my favourite songs. Given the time I have to take a bus there someday.
This is so beautiful!!
i heard this song for the first time today. oh it is heart breaking.
I love this song so very much.... I saw Gretchen Peters live performance back in 2002 in Maidstone, UK. She is wonderful...
This is a masterpiece of a song - it has all the magic that a great song has - it tells a story , but vague enough so the audience can imagine their own version - it captures all the melancholy of failed love affair - such feelings are beyond words - it's as if Gretchen reached in to the collective unconscious and pulled out such a sad story - melancholy, but healing at the same time - Gretchen you deserve all the accolades - although your version is great, the version and video by Trisha Yearwood is a "masterpiece" - and a masterpiece of Americana music - a video that defines all that a music can be - it reaches into your soul and breaks your heart - what else can one say?
Beautiful, always brings me to tears - life!
Sublime! I had the good fortune to hear Gretchen, and John Lester on bass, about 16 years back at Newcastle Quayside. A breath-takingly good performance. She certainly had, and retains, the magical zizz!
[Tyneside, England.]
You were on quite a roll when you recorded this one... what a great album. Wore out 2 CD"s listening to these songs on my trips... 🙂😊
Simply one of the greatest songs ever written .
Not often that my hometown gets props like this. :)
Stunning song & performance 😮
This song is haunting. Top three of my fave EVER. I know it song in Trisha Yearwood's version. Have loved it since it came out. Thank U, Gretchen Peters💙. Every corner in the world has its Saint Cloud story. Greegings from Poland❤.
I have both, but this is the version I prefer.
I was 20 the first time I heard this song.... 30 years later.. it's the same... And I love the Grechen has always held out for the down and out and the LGBTQ community!
In think that's really beautiful, love the way she sings. I saw her at Cambridge Folk Festival this year. She's a great song writer.
One of my favorite songs. ❤
Love her music , best version.
Thanks, Aaron. The Miktek really captures the emotional nuance of Gretchen Peters' voice in this lovely song.
Love Gretchens music very much, it takes me different places I've never been
drove thru St. Cloud, MN today...........love Gretchen's work....greetings from central MN where we are enjoying the most pleasant summer in recent history
a very beautiful song and message. thanks for this
My God this lady is fantastic !
Beautiful. Made me cry!
A long time after this video appeared I know, but just to say, I also think this is magical, heart-wrenchingly beautiful, makes the hairs on the back of my neck tingle. Thanks Gretchen 🙏.
Just beautiful .
Great voice and performance. Its definitely her song. There is pain but also an underlying sweetness, unaffected by the very pain she sings about. Bravo.
I have loved this song for many years. Beautifully done!
Just beautiful been lucky enough to see her twice in Manchester UK a great artist.
Simply beautiful! Wonderful keys as well!
We had the great good fortune to see Gretchen open for Janis Ian at the Palms in Winters, California a few years ago. Have been a great fan of hers ever since. What an amazing talent - both as songwriter and singer.
Love this song
I love a lot of Gretchen's music, but I love this song the most. Who hasn't had the experience of thinking they see an old love? John Gorka tackles the same topic with "I Saw A Stranger With Your Hair"
What a perfect song.
Amazing performer and song writer, she moves me to a wonderful place Thank You for sharing it all Gretchen, Hugs from Whitby , Ontario Canada
Thanks for posting this. Gretchen Peters is a fabulous singer/songwriter.
Just found Gretchen Peters...such emotion!!! Love it!!! let me see what else she has now
Gretchen wrote this, wow.
Wow, Gänsehaut!
Thank you so much for this Gretchen xxxx
Hearing the songwriter perform their own song... priceless.
Love it, thank you.
Fantastic heartfelt ridiculously great song!!!
One of my favorite songs and song writers....
what a superb live performance. Love you Gretchen xx
Fantastic song and lyrics that touch my heart
Just beautiful. Love her voice. Love her to bits. Will I be able to get Gretchen to sing this at my birthday next year?
Thanks for the hug in Ireland Gretchen You'll always be my number one! Oh how I envy that Walsh guy!!!! (:-)
One of my favs
beautiful song.
just love this song..just kills me..
The genuine music is right here. I felt my hair being patted by a gentle older sister.
Do not neglect Jimmy LaFave's amazing version of this song. He made it his own. As Gretchen has so humbly said: "It is Jimmy's song. I just happened to write it."
.
For myself , I do believe she is being remarkably self-effacing to state that . This song is crying out for the texture , timbre and that , what I can only attempt to describe as ... ' known ... unknowingness ' of a woman's voice , one who has known what all that not knowing quite what
happened ... will ever mean .
@@donaldcook3112 Gretchen may be self-effacing. She is a very good and humble soul, but she knew how much Jimmy LaFave loved the song and how he was so proud to deliver it in concert. And he always gave her full credit for writing it. It worked well for both of them, good friends as they were. I can appreciate and love both versions!
LaFaves version is awful. But that’s just me.
@@jimb408 that's just you!
@@barnesnewberry9183 that's what i said :)
I have been playing this song all day for my friend Anthony Bourdain.. :-(
Just Beautiful.
Has anyone mentioned she has the voice of an angel yet? If not may I be the first? But maybe even more important...the emotion! Exquisite!
Took the words right out of my mouth! Music Fog Fan!
Amazing!
ON A BUS TO ST CLOUD LYRICS
On a bus to St. Cloud, Minnesota
I thought I saw you there
With the snow falling down around you
Like a silent prayer
And once on a street in New York City
With the jazz and the sin in the air
And once on a cold L.A. freeway
Going nowhere
And it's strange, but it's true
I was sure it was you
Just a face in the crowd
On a bus to St. Cloud
In a church in downtown New Orleans
I got down on my knees and prayed
And I wept in the arms of Jesus
For the choice you made
We were just gettin' to the good part
Just gettin' past the mystery
Oh, and it's just like you, it's just like you
To disagree
And it's strange but it's true
You just slipped out of view
Like a face in the crowd
On a bus to St. Cloud
And you chase me like a shadow
And you haunt me like a ghost
And I hate you some, and I love you some
But I miss you most...
On a bus to St. Cloud, Minnesota
I thought I saw you there
With the snow falling down around you
Like a silent prayer
Gretchen is a great composer and Trisha's version of this song is very beautiful !!
great songwriter is our Gretchen.
love you and your music keep playing pleasexxxx
Oh Gretchen ❤️
melancholia at its finest. life is so good
this son
y heart its simple words and singing. im not a poet but this song and words keep my faith in human love for basically for every person
to
BELLA VOZ , Y UNA MELODIA QUE ENCANTA.
astounding, just astounding!
Falls into my "Exquisite" category and all too rare....
This I so do love...........
I didn't want goosebumps this early in the morning, but when you hear an angels voice, well
Incredible Songwriting
Mesmerizing…
just the best..
that was great !!
amazing