It's touching to know that even though Spock and McCoy are always at odds, they need each other to return to the present. I love that about TOS, it teaches us that no matter how much we differ, we ALL need each other to survive.
I thought the premise of this episode was so cool -- the population of a planet, knowing that their sun was going to explode, find a way to retreat into the planet's past.
That moment Spock has opportunity to express how feels about her. In reality, that moment extremely rare. We must always show our loved ones that Love them. You never know when could be last time.
every time I ever see the actor who played Mr Atoz in any other movie I always figured he just slipped through the timestream and showed up in an alternate past
@@TheNoiseySpectator I double-checked via Google and, beleve it or not, both are listed as her name (unless I Googled wrong, that is). But now that I think about it, you're more right than I am.
Feels kind of weird how Scotty is only in this episode as a voice over and this is the only TOS episode which no scenes are set on board the Enterprise at all. Good episode though.
As soon as they got back to the Enterprise, the star went nova and took the planet with it. Everybody on the planet had a chance to escape into some past of their choosing or they died with their sun.
@@TheNoiseySpectator you got people who are stupid enough to do ANYTHING! Look at the stupid things people have done in the past and the stupid things they do now. Stupidity is alive and well!
Mr Atoz/Ian Wolfe was one of only a few actors that appeared on the original Star Trek series that was born in the 1800's (and I don't get the opportunity to say that very often) 1896 in this case, Celia Lovsky was another, she played T'Pau in "Amok Time" and was born in 1897.
Mine too. But it was written by D.C. Fontana. All the fucking in the show _finally_ led to someone getting pregnant, but it was after the show had wrapped up. 👶
"There is no further need to observe me, Doctor. As you can see, I have returned to the present in every sense." "But it did happen, Spock." "Yes, it happened. But that was five thousand years ago, and she is dead now. Dead, and buried. Long ago."
@@RealityTrailers It's very subtle, but you hear regret in Spock's words. Leonard Nimoy really developed a nuanced portrayal of Spock over three years in the character.
The Sarpeidons were atavistic tending to revert to their ancestral pasts rather than find a way off their doomed world so no wonder they used an atavachron.
@AceOfHeart2012 Who knows? The story has no further information on that. Unless you want to find out in countless non-canon Trek novels & Trekkie-Fics Sites.
Great final scene with the nova enveloping the planet. My friend Steve the ultimate trekker always asked : She's dead and buried... Who buried her??? Just a metaphor Steve!!
This show contradicts the other two that had them going back in time. Today is tomorrow and the city in the edge of forever In those shows, going back would change the present. However in this one there is no concern of that
I wouldn't be sure of that. For one thing, they got into such dire trouble right away & needed to think only about escaping. And, Kirk did say they _didn't belong_ in their world's history. Besides, What could they change? It was the End of The World, and nothing they could do would have altered that. 🔥🔥🔥 ... Oh, yes! There is something else you should know.... 😏
But, maybe they did change the _past!_ 💡 In fact, they did change the past. D.C. Fontana wrote a novel in which Spock got Zarabeth pregnant, and she had a son.🤰🏼 The three of them used the Guardian of Forever to go back in time and rescue him, and bring him to the present. 🎆 (Zarabeth had passed away by that point in time).
I still would have liked better if Mr. Atoz had gone back to the Enterprise with them. Imagine that; These people had no concept of Extraterrestrials, nor even of other bodies around stars being other Worlds! He could have gone off to places that his kind had never _imagined_ could exist, before! 😍
Always amazed me how Spock had changed because his ancestors were so different 5000 years ago than they are in the current Star Trek time. McCoy didn’t change is the past ice age because, well, humans never change. We have always been violent and barbaric.
Can't help but wonder why they hang around for a FULL MINUTE after Spock & McCoy return despite there no longer being any reason whatsoever to do so -- if I was Scotty I'd have warped away without them lol
In Mirror, Mirror. bearded Spock would have stayed, killed McCoy, Kirk would have asked to beam up but Scotty would say “I am captain Scott to you.” And warp out.
You are not wrong. “All Our Yesterdays”, S3E23, original airdate March 14, 1969, was the penultimate episode of Star Trek: TOS. The ultimate episode, “Turnabout Intruder”, S3E24, original airdate June 3, 1969, was the last broadcast episode of the series' original run. Source: IMDb
The Spock--McCoy relationship in this one is at its all-time worst; the viewer is actually made uncomfortable watching the two literally at each others' throats. It had never got that bad between the two of them previously. The explanation is that Spock is reverting to his primordial ancestors. Star Trek had already made clear that Vulcans were once horribly violent, and nearly destroyed each other, until logic saved them.
Well,the series is still for sale on DVD....$125 for all 3 seasons. Unlike the stuff I post,this isn't really Fair Use. So,no full-length eps for this.
Reminds me of the time I had to leave my Filipino girlfriend back in the Philippines and departed alone to head back to Canada. I couldn't take her with me as things would've made worse for me later on. I'm glad I made the right choice.
It's touching to know that even though Spock and McCoy are always at odds, they need each other to return to the present. I love that about TOS, it teaches us that no matter how much we differ, we ALL need each other to survive.
Interesting. That same theme was repeated in the movie, The Search for Spock.
my god i've just watched this episode, it's incredible, one of the best episodes from the 3rd season
Mr. Atoz is a gas. The funniest thing is that he has to replicate himself to handle the workload. 🤣
I thought the premise of this episode was so cool -- the population of a planet, knowing that their sun was going to explode, find a way to retreat into the planet's past.
With no immigration papers?
Definitely a unique spin on the concept, I think.
Like how Superman escaped from Krypton?
But wouldn’t that cause so many temporal paradoxes?
I always liked the final special effect shot of the star exploding -- very simple but very effective and really cool looking.
I agree - and watching the Enterprise warping off to safety just in time.
It actually looks much better than the remastered CGI version.
It’s a touching scene, their last goodbye, especially if you’ve ever lost someone close.
That moment Spock has opportunity to express how feels about her. In reality, that moment extremely rare. We must always show our loved ones that Love them. You never know when could be last time.
OMG! I never noticed before but the way Kirk slid his hand down Spock's back that was just lovely, those two are forever bonded.
every time I ever see the actor who played Mr Atoz in any other movie I always figured he just slipped through the timestream and showed up in an alternate past
The music signifying the heartbreak between Spock and Maryann Hartley is so on the mark...
Recycled from George Duning’s superb original score for “The Empath”.
Just a side note, Hartley"s character was named "Zarabeth".
I think autocorrect may have gotten you, there.
Wasn't Hartley's first name "Marriet"?
@@TheNoiseySpectator That escaped me. Thanks for sharing.
@@TheNoiseySpectator I double-checked via Google and, beleve it or not, both are listed as her name (unless I Googled wrong, that is). But now that I think about it, you're more right than I am.
Heartbreaking for Spock
Feels kind of weird how Scotty is only in this episode as a voice over and this is the only TOS episode which no scenes are set on board the Enterprise at all. Good episode though.
This is my favorite episode ! Gene Roddenberry sure knew how to create content !
Always been a fan of Marietta Hartley. She is now 80 years old.
Ian Wolfe had previously appeared in "Bread and Circuses" as Septimus, a former Roman senator who now follows the Son.
I loved this show growing up.. And I remember that episode when Piccard met Spock. Too too cool
And she had a beautiful little pointy eared boy that the enterprise rescued and placed on another planet. Who ended up being a ruler.
Return to Sarpeidon ?
Book title was Yesterday's Son. I think.
Who else here remembers Mariette Hartley from the Polaroid commericals with James Garner
Makes me sad!! That a tear in her eye says it all ! Like many of us to live alone!
A lovely episode,here!😊But,the crew alway’s get’s back…eventually!😊
That was a good episode. One of the better written.
As soon as they got back to the Enterprise, the star went nova and took the planet with it. Everybody on the planet had a chance to escape into some past of their choosing or they died with their sun.
Are you suggesting some people might have specifically _chosen_ to witness the supernova destroy their world? 🤔
@@TheNoiseySpectator you got people who are stupid enough to do ANYTHING! Look at the stupid things people have done in the past and the stupid things they do now.
Stupidity is alive and well!
God, Star Trek was so far ahead of it's time...
According to star trek novels they had a son.
Spock ate animal flesh and he enjoyed it!
woman flesh tasted better
Towards the end Spock and Bones would still be frozen to death with the wind howling and the lack of furs for protection
"orders or no, I'm beaming you up first" "NO!" 🤣
BONES! SPOCK! sounds like he's calling a dog and a cat lol...
Great series...
Mr Atoz/Ian Wolfe was one of only a few actors that appeared on the original Star Trek series that was born in the 1800's (and I don't get the opportunity to say that very often) 1896 in this case, Celia Lovsky was another, she played T'Pau in "Amok Time" and was born in 1897.
There's a book series base on a child born of the lady's and Spock's romance that was quite good. Though my mind is blanking on its name.
Mine too. But it was written by D.C. Fontana.
All the fucking in the show _finally_ led to someone getting pregnant, but it was after the show had wrapped up. 👶
Mr. Atoz stole Gary Seven's computer from Assignment Earth and made it the Atavachron...
Either that or Sarpeidon also bought their computers from Beta V.
Ian Wolfe was a great actor.
"HIRSCH!"
Yes, was also great as the sage “Septimus”
This is from All Our Yesterdays, not The Savage Curtain.
Sad ending
This is actually the last episode they ever filmed. Though "Turnabout Intruder" was the last episode listed on the DVD set.
This was one of the better late episodes, coming near the end of the series' three-year run.
Which (episode) is your favorite.
@@JackReynolds-w7g Me? City On the Edge of Forever.
I hope they at least took some of those discs back back with them for further study.
Actually, this scene is from the episode All Our Yesterdays.
The original series is Superior to all others!
AMEN!!!
"There is no further need to observe me, Doctor. As you can see, I have returned to the present in every sense."
"But it did happen, Spock."
"Yes, it happened. But that was five thousand years ago, and she is dead now. Dead, and buried. Long ago."
Almost as if Spock was trying to convince himself and at the same time while telling McCoy the facts
@@RealityTrailers It's very subtle, but you hear regret in Spock's words. Leonard Nimoy really developed a nuanced portrayal of Spock over three years in the character.
The Sarpeidons were atavistic tending to revert to their ancestral pasts rather than find a way off their doomed world so no wonder they used an atavachron.
What a beautiful woman!
mr atoz youre a very agile man!!
Mr. Atoz was actually pretty good at hand to hand combat at his advanced age.
@@tperk well to be fair he was cloned . 🤣
This is one of only two eposodes of TOS where Spock fell in love. The other one with Jill Ireland in This Side Of Paradise.
@AceOfHeart2012 Who knows? The story has no further information on that. Unless you want to find out in countless non-canon Trek novels & Trekkie-Fics Sites.
Great final scene with the nova enveloping the planet. My friend Steve the ultimate trekker always asked : She's dead and buried... Who buried her??? Just a metaphor Steve!!
"Metaphor" is not an acceptable reason for people from the autism spectrum.
As someone above said:
5000 years of snow and dust burried her.
The episode is actually "All Our Yesterdays" - not "The savage Curtain"
This is from "All Our Yesterdays", not "Savage Curtain".
I thought that was captain Picard in the thumbnail for a second
This show contradicts the other two that had them going back in time. Today is tomorrow and the city in the edge of forever
In those shows, going back would change the present. However in this one there is no concern of that
I wouldn't be sure of that.
For one thing, they got into such dire trouble right away & needed to think only about escaping.
And, Kirk did say they _didn't belong_ in their world's history.
Besides, What could they change?
It was the End of The World, and nothing they could do would have altered that. 🔥🔥🔥
... Oh, yes!
There is something else you should know.... 😏
But, maybe they did change the _past!_ 💡
In fact, they did change the past.
D.C. Fontana wrote a novel in which Spock got Zarabeth pregnant, and she had a son.🤰🏼
The three of them used the Guardian of Forever to go back in time and rescue him, and bring him to the present. 🎆
(Zarabeth had passed away by that point in time).
It is "All Our Yesterdays", not "The Savage Curtain"!
I still would have liked better if Mr. Atoz had gone back to the Enterprise with them.
Imagine that;
These people had no concept of Extraterrestrials, nor even of other bodies around stars being other Worlds!
He could have gone off to places that his kind had never _imagined_ could exist, before! 😍
😮...😮...😊... freeze 🥶 and really say 3 to beam up 😢...🎉.
That's usin' the ol' noodle...
ah this is not the The Savage Curtain its " All our Yesterdays "
Always amazed me how Spock had changed because his ancestors were so different 5000 years ago than they are in the current Star Trek time. McCoy didn’t change is the past ice age because, well, humans never change. We have always been violent and barbaric.
The brutality of this scene.
I would have stayed ❤
Where did their fur coats go?
They rotted away to dust in the 5,000 years it took them to reach the portal in the Library.
"All Our Yesterdays" not "The Savage Curtain".
Can't help but wonder why they hang around for a FULL MINUTE after Spock & McCoy return despite there no longer being any reason whatsoever to do so -- if I was Scotty I'd have warped away without them lol
No shit! He would have "moved up in rank" without those assholes around ala "Mirror Mirror"
In Mirror, Mirror. bearded Spock would have stayed, killed McCoy, Kirk would have asked to beam up but Scotty would say “I am captain Scott to you.” And warp out.
The librarian's name is Mr. Atoz. A to Z how many people caught that one?
I believe this was the penultimate episode of the original series. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
You are not wrong. “All Our Yesterdays”, S3E23, original airdate March 14, 1969, was the penultimate episode of Star Trek: TOS.
The ultimate episode, “Turnabout Intruder”, S3E24, original airdate June 3, 1969, was the last broadcast episode of the series' original run.
Source: IMDb
@@flashkellam7395 Thank you
How could Kirk be so rude to a member of the "Brotherhood of the Sun"/older actor there?
I think I prefer the original FX for the nova. You all?
So if she was the only inhabitant of that planet, who buried her?
she was buried by snow.
The man that exiled her.
The Spock--McCoy relationship in this one is at its all-time worst; the viewer is actually made uncomfortable watching the two literally at each others' throats. It had never got that bad between the two of them previously. The explanation is that Spock is reverting to his primordial ancestors. Star Trek had already made clear that Vulcans were once horribly violent, and nearly destroyed each other, until logic saved them.
Spoiler! She preggers with Spocks kid! Read the book" Yesterday's Child!"
Well,the series is still for sale on DVD....$125 for all 3 seasons. Unlike the stuff I post,this isn't really Fair Use. So,no full-length eps for this.
#IstandwithAxanar!
Reminds me of the time I had to leave my Filipino girlfriend back in the Philippines and departed alone to head back to Canada. I couldn't take her with me as things would've made worse for me later on. I'm glad I made the right choice.
How'd that work out for her?
Sarpeidon...
What is wrong with you people ,, what happen to full length eps.? get it togather
Men ' always get caught up in what they believe is love...🤔, Save yourself men...
Men don't love women, - they 'want' women.
@AceOfHeart2012 Buried by years of dust, you ninny.
Why is Bones always an _ss?
"She's dead and buried"
"Who buried her? She was alone Spock"
"Shut the fuck up Bones"......
Rather melancholy I would say... :(
She reminds me of Melania trump…..
Cavewoman or hot.
tghis shit does not work at all if it did everyone would be a billionaire!\
Please explain; how would everyone become a billionaire if "this shit" worked?
2:03 Dr. Fauci when they try to sentence him to prison …
For what?