What is the New Apostolic Reformation?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 86

  • @bettycarmella1127
    @bettycarmella1127 Год назад +21

    I was involved in a “ministry” for some time that taught prophesy and S.I.T. It felt uncomfortable and weird and kept me on edge not knowing if I would be called on. I know now it was a cult🥺 I’m so grateful for you Holly speaking out about this deception🙏🏽

  • @marymcmann9546
    @marymcmann9546 Год назад +8

    A friend of mine gave me your book a few weeks ago. I’m in a Foursquare church and had never heard of this movement before I read your book. After I read it I was appalled at the direction the NAR people were going. My first thought after I read it was that No man ever appoints an apostle or a prophet, only God can do that. And in the Word the people who God called to these offices usually didn’t want the job! I believe that the same gifts Jesus gave to the disciples are still possible today. The things and ideas happening in the NAR movement are just weird. It’s no wonder some so called Christians wander from church to church looking for the next new emotional demonstration. They never have developed the deep faith from studying the word and listening to the Holy Spirit to be able to discern and test the spirits. Thank you for exposing this movement. I agree with you, some of it approaches new age teachings.

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 Год назад +1

      Exactly the holy spirit guides you to the biblical truth. Just as he inspired the writing of the NT. The Holy Spirit, the helper, as Jesus told us himself in the gospel, the helper, the spirit which proceeds from Father.

    • @lou_-mg7mb
      @lou_-mg7mb 11 месяцев назад

      There is no reason to believe we have the same gifts the Apostles did. Foursquare also has terrible, unChristian roots. Aimee Semple McPherson was a fornicator. Well-documented. She started Foursquare. You should research that, leave and find a church that has good roots and is clear on preaching the Gospel. Foursquare has witchcraft tendencies in many cases.

  • @dirkhoekstra727
    @dirkhoekstra727 Год назад +12

    I read your and Doug's book "Counterfeit Kingdom". It was absolutely fantastic! Thanks for exposing the NAR

    • @teresamitchell5090
      @teresamitchell5090 6 месяцев назад +1

      I read it too, I refer back to it often and have recommended it to several people leaving NAR churches!!!

  • @jboreal7982
    @jboreal7982 11 месяцев назад +3

    Holly and Doug are very good at what they do; their expose’ of the NAR is well researched and presented. I live in a geographical area highly influenced by a cult that has high jacked the words and titles of Apostle and Prophet as well. The kingdom of darkness has laid claim to those words and titles, that alone is lesson number one.

  • @sandrapihlskott3262
    @sandrapihlskott3262 Год назад +2

    Thank's for all you're doing!

  • @fightthegoodfightoffaithmi8676
    @fightthegoodfightoffaithmi8676 Год назад +4

    Romans 16:17
    Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them.

    • @eltonron1558
      @eltonron1558 Год назад

      I was roaring with laughter, after reading, " contrary to the doctrine ye have learned". That's the rub. That's the fly in the ointment. That's the liar doing it to the church. As a former atheist, I'm totally dismayed how quickly the very words of Christ, if he is the truth, are made invalid by doctrine, of the vast majority. I see nothing in that new movement any different from the current cookie cutter, Sunday is the Lord's day, nonsense. Can't even get past Mathew 4:4, but ignore and go on anyway, not caring what it means.

  • @cosmichrist
    @cosmichrist Год назад +1

    Thank you Holly.

  • @AlexHop1
    @AlexHop1 3 месяца назад

    Thank you!

  • @encouragingword1172
    @encouragingword1172 11 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you for differentiating between NAR and other pentecostal churches. Ive been mostly in the AOG for most of my life. I have been very very unhappy about the lumping together of all in one, which we are not.

    • @paulryan5984
      @paulryan5984 Месяц назад

      encouragingword. Well actually most of them are. If you go to Malaysia for example, almost all pentecostal churches are NAR and in America all of the megachurches and most denominations are with the NAR even though they may not say so pubically. The leaders are hiding what they believe about the NAR until the One World Religion is established then all will be revealed.

  • @i-jamesazubuike9208
    @i-jamesazubuike9208 Год назад

    Thanks for this exposition.

  • @brucegraystaff7428
    @brucegraystaff7428 7 месяцев назад +1

    No matter what the NRA says, the scriptures are sufficient for today and forever!!!

  • @merrylstreak7118
    @merrylstreak7118 10 месяцев назад +2

    Jesus specifically said, My kingdom is NOT of this world. The Great Commission is to spread the gospel (the good news) to ALL people. Anything that causes division and control is not from God. This is the apostate church spoken about by Jesus in Matthew 24.

    • @davidgraham3162
      @davidgraham3162 10 месяцев назад

      Based on your comment, who is causing division? Holly perhaps.

    • @merrylstreak7118
      @merrylstreak7118 10 месяцев назад +3

      @@davidgraham3162 the division and control is being caused by those in the church who have replaced the Gospel with Christian nationalism. God has never told Christians to take over government. My post is pretty specific.

  • @Msfracture
    @Msfracture Месяц назад

    Someone being a charismatic yet mad at the NAR is like a thief who did a robbery and has stolen goods but is mad that a different thief broke in and stole those stolen goods. Both are wolf clans.

  • @AndiCude
    @AndiCude 10 месяцев назад +1

    Do you know about the 7 mountains?

  • @therecoverytabernacle
    @therecoverytabernacle Год назад +1

    Thank you for your ministry. Do you go over NAR in relation to end times eschatology and prophecy?

    • @HollyPivecOfficial
      @HollyPivecOfficial  Год назад +3

      Yes, I do. I'm a contributor to a podcast called Bible Prophecy Daily, where I discuss NAR views of the end time. Check it out here: bibleprophecydaily.com/holly-pivec/ I also plan to discuss this topic on my RUclips channel.

  • @DefenderoftheCross
    @DefenderoftheCross Год назад +2

    I think this NAR problem is largely a problem within the restorationist movement and not the cessationist camp. (No one is really a continuationist because Church history does not indicate the continued practice of the gifts until the late 1800s. People who insist the gifts are for today are really restorationists.)
    Cessationists are not as susceptible to fall for the weird practices of the NAR as the restorationists.

    • @HollyPivecOfficial
      @HollyPivecOfficial  Год назад +2

      It's true that, since cessationists do not believe in the present-day miraculous gifts of the Holy Spirit, they would be less likely to embrace NAR doctrine. But many continuationists are also concerned about NAR.

    • @i-jamesazubuike9208
      @i-jamesazubuike9208 Год назад

      ​@@HollyPivecOfficialIs it really that ceasationists do not believe in present day gifts of the Holy Spirit, or the apostolic sign gifts only have ceased?

    • @davidgraham3162
      @davidgraham3162 10 месяцев назад +1

      Cessationist believers have already fallen into wrong belief biblically which is not a position to be bragging about.

    • @davidgraham3162
      @davidgraham3162 10 месяцев назад

      No they do not claim that critical new information or revelation is required to complete the great commission. So long as babies are being born the great commission can never be completed. Simple logic.

    • @DefenderoftheCross
      @DefenderoftheCross 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@davidgraham3162
      You're just wrong. Scripture does say the gifts will cease. Cessationists look at Church history and the COMPLETE ABSENCE of the gifts being used to help them conclude that (certain) gifts have probably ceased.

  • @following-Jesus
    @following-Jesus Год назад

    Good word.

  • @jackpullen3820
    @jackpullen3820 Год назад

    In the frame work of the N.A.R. one of the rules is that the pastor can not be fired.

    • @keith3362
      @keith3362 Год назад

      I think one of the guys on remnant radio was fired from what would be considered a NAR church.

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 5 месяцев назад

      Buy they will be asked to step down when it comes out they have affairs outside marriage, consensual or otherwise

  • @Sigbuddy
    @Sigbuddy Год назад

    Redefining terms is the same as lying...run

  • @lou_-mg7mb
    @lou_-mg7mb 11 месяцев назад +1

    Holly, you do have a foundation in this topic. And your firsthand experience and the way you presented it do some good. I encourage you to do some further research though. Around 5:30 to 6:12 minutes in (the end of the video) you said that Pentecostals, and Assemblies of God people have endorses the book and some of them "are critics of this movement." Please put a BIG asterisk, italics, highlight, and footnote on SOME. AOG did have a history of preaching the Gospel. And AOG churches do have a history of local autonomy. By no means am I going to critique nor make blanket statements about all AOG and Pentecostal churches. However, Bethel-Redding came out of AOG, and endorsed it in the beginning, especially in California. That is still the case, in Bethel-Redding and it's "School of Supernatural Ministry" have huge influence on AOG, Charasmatic, and Seek-Friendly churches in Northern California, and other places. Bethel-Reddings practice of "Christian Tarot cards" is definitely witchcraft, and has made its was into many AOG and other churches, all over California. In 2016-2019 I was involved with AOG churches that full endorsed Bethel-Redding and claimed what was going on their was Christianity- with no evidence to support that position. New Year's Eve 2016/2017 I was at a church event at an AOG church that was promoting movements and "ministries" affiliated with Bethel-Redding, and a Los Angeles offshoot. The Gospel was NOT preached, everyone was encouraged to speak in "tongues" (rananana-shananana type nonsense). I understand your point that all charasmatics should not be lumped together. Generally, that is true. But I have seen many examples in Northern CA, Southern CA (Angeles Temple), and Kansas, where the lumping together is actually totally fair. Yes, it depends, but many charasmatics have affiliated themselves with this garbage- I know because I was one who fell into that error. Many charasmatics pastors have lead their flocks into this heresy, just as they have promoted other errors, like female church leadership. AOG and other "churches" that come out of the 1914 Azusa Street Revival have horrible roots. Some of them may have some Christian teaching, many have done good things that can be pointed out, but like Foursquare, they all have a terrible origin and foundation, if you look at the facts. I hope many repent and believe in Jesus Christ.

    • @davidgraham3162
      @davidgraham3162 10 месяцев назад +1

      Female church leadership. At that point I ran out of energy to read and respond to your message. Why follow Holly then, is she the one leading you into truth and out of darkness. Is she your leader?

  • @BloodBoughtMinistries
    @BloodBoughtMinistries Год назад +1

    Subbed, thank you for your work!

  • @Dilley_G45
    @Dilley_G45 Год назад +2

    Being a cessationist doesn't mean you don't believe in the holy spirit or that God can do miracles. That is a lie from the NAR and others. By the way they are not continuationists, they are restorationists. The APOSTOLIC gifts have ceased. Now some people pretend to bring them back. They have ceased as they have done their job. We have scripture now. The canon is closed

    • @keith3362
      @keith3362 Год назад +3

      Yet Jesus sent the Holy Spirit and He's still here - He just decided to do less? I don't agree with a lot of NAR stuff but the Bible never says the gifts ceased, Paul said to desire spiritual gifts, he never said but soon forget it.

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 Год назад +1

      @@keith3362 where there are tongues they will cease. Paul to Timothy: "have some wine for your frequent ailments." He didn't just heal himself...I can't limit God.the apostolic gifts have fulfilled their job. Bible says signs are for unbelievers

    • @keith3362
      @keith3362 Год назад +1

      @@Dilley_G45 the scripture you are referencing is speaking about the return of Jesus and us being in God's glory -
      'Charity never faileth: but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away. For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. But when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away. When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things. For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known. (1 Corinthians 13:8-12, KJV)'
      No one is seeing God face to face here. It doesn't support cessationism. There is no other scripture that says the gifts ceased or will cease.

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 Год назад +1

      @@keith3362 It has ceased. Signs are for unbelievers.

    • @keith3362
      @keith3362 Год назад +1

      @@Dilley_G45 No scripture says it ceased. It is supported nowhere in the bible.

  • @kirstyfoote8582
    @kirstyfoote8582 Год назад +4

    What's your thoughts on Post millenialism? It sounds like some viewpoints cross over from NAR and post millenialism? Just curious.
    Thank you for clarifying that you aren't demonizing traditional charismatic or pentecostal teachings. I find a lot of people throwing all charismatics/pentecostals into the same NAR basket.

    • @HollyPivecOfficial
      @HollyPivecOfficial  Год назад +5

      I personally don't find support for postmillennialism in Scripture. That being said, there are many sound Christians who have held to classical postmillennialism, believing the kingdom of God will be established on earth prior to Christ's return through the proclamation of the gospel. But the NAR version of postmillennialism--the view that the kingdom of God will be established on earth through the employment of strategies revealed by present-day apostles and prophets--is very different from classical postmillennialism and is aberrant.

    • @kirstyfoote8582
      @kirstyfoote8582 Год назад

      Thanks for clarifying Holly, love your work, it's been a real eye opener for me. I've had big questions my whole life, your book "counterfeit kingdom" really helped me answer a lot of those questions and I'm extremely greatful

    • @lou_-mg7mb
      @lou_-mg7mb 11 месяцев назад

      Post Millenialism has nothing to do with NAR. All Post Mil folks I'm aware of are Cessationist. HUGE different right there, no crossover.

  • @catpocalypsenow8090
    @catpocalypsenow8090 11 месяцев назад

    They believe they can raise the dead.

  • @aranza1221
    @aranza1221 Год назад

    Ok this is a stupid question, but what is a comtinuationist? I understand that it implies that it continues something. But what is referring to within Christianity?

    • @jrhawk0032
      @jrhawk0032 Год назад +3

      Apostolic gifts continuing after the Apostolic age. Gifts of healing, prophecy, etc. A cessationist belives those gifts ended with the 12 Apostles. Cessasionists do belive miracles happen , but they are not a gifting. Thats a quick deacription.

    • @i-jamesazubuike9208
      @i-jamesazubuike9208 Год назад +2

      ​​@@jrhawk0032Those preachers found today claiming they have these gifts have often been found fake. There's hardly a proof of their claims - their healings fake, prophecy false, tongues speaking gibberish!

    • @anthonyoruovo6733
      @anthonyoruovo6733 11 месяцев назад

      @@i-jamesazubuike9208 Be very careful of what you say.
      Did you know that the none of the Sanhedrin ever saw Jesus perform a miracle?
      This was why they asked for a sign

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@i-jamesazubuike9208correct

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 5 месяцев назад +1

      The correct term is restorationist. The gifts have ceased and Noone claimed them for centuries. Than came the unholy events of 1907

  • @1ricky77333
    @1ricky77333 Год назад +2

    Most of the new stuff is rehashed dominionsm.
    Its been around.

  • @neoturfmasterMVS
    @neoturfmasterMVS Год назад +1

    To say the new apostolic reformation is not part of Pentecostalism and charismatics is akin to saying a father has nothing to do with his son.
    New apostolic reformation movement is another slant or variant from Pentecostalism. Think of it this way Pentecostalism is an off shoot of the holiness movement.
    If you really have interest in getting to the heart of the matter this goes all the way back to Lutheran Pietism. All movements descended from Lutheran Pietism are kooky, wonky, strange and to be completely avoid and hopefully one day given up. So silly.

  • @John-Christchurch-NZ
    @John-Christchurch-NZ 4 месяца назад

    The Church was divided long before you came along stirring it up
    with misinformation Titus 3:10

  • @NormanAiken
    @NormanAiken Год назад +2

    What about MAGA "Christian Nationalism" - isn't that dividing the Church?

  • @eltonron1558
    @eltonron1558 Год назад

    So, yawn, there is yet another denomination, sigh, started by a movement, but let me guess. Are they still, yawn, Sunday keepers? Still buy that Lord's day non biblical thing, while professing love and obedience to God?
    In very little time, this movement will settle down to the mainstream norms, no real substance, a sameness that resides with the other multitude of denominations and doctrine. From this video, the funny part, is about the "Revelations", of the movement, while the word of God calls true Christianity, a remnant, by the time all is said and done. The blessed remnant keeps the commandments of God. 12:17, 22:14.

    • @catpocalypsenow8090
      @catpocalypsenow8090 11 месяцев назад

      So are you still following the obsolete old covenant?

    • @eltonron1558
      @eltonron1558 11 месяцев назад

      @catpocalypsenow8090 The new covenant, is the ten commandments written on the heart of the truly converted, or Christ is a liar.
      What is every word? Mt. 4:4
      What is the law that cannot pass away until heaven and earth pass? The ten commandments.
      What did Christ, ipse dixit, say concerning the commandments? To keep them.
      Mt. 19:17. Is Christ the way and truth? What is all the law?
      Mt. 22:36-40. I challenge you to make a SPECIFIC list of ways to love God. Hint: the first 4 of the commandments.
      The ten commandments, are eternal law, only first expressed to the Israelites, and valid, good, and HOLY, to the end of time, as Revelation says so.
      22:14.
      Are you not aware the commandments are completely different from the 600 plus laws through Moses? It's because they didn't come from, nor through Moses, but by the voice of God to the great crowd of Israelites, who heard God. Eleven of those tribes not Jewish.
      Then there's the matter of your deliberate insistence on being the subject of 1 John 2:3-4.
      Why?

    • @anettecoetzee3363
      @anettecoetzee3363 6 месяцев назад

      We're not under the law, but under grace

    • @eltonron1558
      @eltonron1558 6 месяцев назад

      @anettecoetzee3363 Under grace?
      Even graceful liars are eligible for salvation.
      1John 2:3-4.
      Blessed sainthood?
      Those who keep the commandments of God.
      Mt. 4:4, 22:36-40. Ipse dixit.
      He, himself said it.
      Rev. 12:17, 14:12, 22:14.
      The very end of the Bible.
      What is the new covenant, written on the heart?
      The commandments. Heb. 10:16
      What is the law that not one jot or tittle can pass away, until heaven, earth and all must be fulfilled before it passes?
      The commandments.
      If someone told you they came through Moses, the law of Moses, mosaic law, or even old testament law, they lied, for they are the eternal law that cannot pass, and we are to live by, bless your mortal heart.

    • @anettecoetzee3363
      @anettecoetzee3363 6 месяцев назад

      @@eltonron1558 ‭Romans 6:14 NKJV‬
      [14] For sin shall not have dominion over you, for you are not under law but under grace.

  • @bigtobacco1098
    @bigtobacco1098 6 месяцев назад

    It's garbage