"Technically" this episode makes no sense to do - this topic is not in the "Trends" - this episode may never get the "Views" .... however one promise to Deshbhakt Family - in 2024 - expect to see more such topics on the channel. Will make more from the heart and less from the head - will make episodes that matter to India - not what may 'work' Thanks to our Members for allowing me to do this - for trusting us - for motivating us - for keeping us independent. If you can do join in as a member on patreon.com/thedeshbhakt or click on the JOIN button above!!! 🙏🏼
January 26th republic day lekin apne pm sei lekar Desh khe log bhi Ram ayodhya temple open karne khe shock mei h . Inlog khele republic Gaya bhaad mei😂😂
There is so much to be done to take our country forward. Things looking in control right now is no gurantee of things continuing to remain so. We need to continuously steer the ship with genuine efforts towards the goal. Empty chest thumping is not going to save a sinking ship. Thanks again for bringing some of the hidden pulse of the nation in the open. Continue doing your bit.
As an Indian, I admit that we annexed Kashmir, Sikkim, Manipur and Northeastern states because we Indians have too many children and we need more territory. In the future, we Indians will have 5 billion people, We must continue to expand our territory, including Nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Tibet, and even the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and the United States...
Most educated pm ne kya diya? 20000cr k ghotala, iitan cm kya diya? Sharab scam, education scam, bus scam, health scam, kcr corrupt, didi corrupt, mama corrupt, yeh to hogap hi
There was this famous bengali film 'Hirak Rajar Deshe' by Bharat Ratna Satyajit Ray and there was this famous dialogue 'era joto beshi jane toto kom mane (the more they know the less they obey)' is very apt for the current situation.
I kept saying this to all my friends, we can never become anywhere close to a superpower if we cannot fix our basics, that includes education and healthcare. We are trying to build a skyscraper on a marshland!
EXACTLY!! We need many innovative companies like microsoft, google, Toyota, bmw, nestle, etc. Products of Indian companies should be popular worldwide. This requires good education base and world-class R&D setup
Well things that need to be done would pay the teachers better,hire more qualified staff and do the stuff buddy said in the video I guess but here's a problem the opposition In India is also the worst they never highlight any issues infact if the govt tries to do anything good they oppose it and when the government is making a bad decision they don't say shit they care about power they're willing to creat a North South divide and basically would even take an enemy nations help just to be in power if that's not treason I don't know what is we got many problems but there are good things govt should solve this problem or we might never become a superpower
@anirprasadd that would take a lot of time friends but I agree but here's a catch most of our resources are committed on the border disputes we have if we neglect them we are in real danger of being invaded
My father has worked as a teacher and a principal in a higher secondary school (government) in Gujarat for the last 35 years and according to him there were 8 teachers in the school and slowly all retired in the last 20 years and there have been no requirements so far. So now the school is running on temporary teachers only. The case in tribal areas is even worse. I have visited schools where the entire school is running on only 1 teacher, now you can only imagine the education children are getting when 1 teacher is managing 3 classes at the same time.
The situation of govt schools is worst in Kolkata and West Bengal. Teacher jobs have been sold for lacs of rupees. All gawars like cobblers zamadars have become teachers by joining TMC and those who have scored marks have not been recruited. SSC and TET scams have sky rocketted in primary schools in West Bengal
Save India ??!! This has been going on for 75 years and for 65 years India was safe huh ? Government is investing in NEP and educational scholarships - the result will be seen till the next decade
I m an employee of Pratham and currently working in an govt. School as a nursery teacher on contract basis. I am so proud of Pratham that's working so hard for the education sector of India. Political leaders are too busy in their politics that they even don't know what's the actual level of education in our country. After seeing your video , I am so glad that there are few people who are actually concerned about future of India. Thank you
Why we are not United???????? Why we are divided into parties, Hindu-Muslim,castes ??????? Is this divide and rule ☠️☠️☠️politics going on in India.♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@skbandhu7878people's are fools, that's why political parties leaders exploited them and now since 21st century most of them has become slaves to them. It has increased many folds after free rice n freebies introduced in high percentage. Our country is massive population size n billions are heavily dependented on Gods and Goddesses. 😢
I am a government teacher in rural India in Rajasthan I am watching it closely and on daily basis. The girls have to do the daily household work and the boys usually participate in agricultural work on the farm. There are many families in which the youth have to earn to support their family.Yet the government is trying to train already trained teachers.
When I was a school student (Govt. School) many of the teachers in our school lacked even basic English reading skills. I remember that we had an English teacher in 9th and 10th std, she didn't even know how to read English, a 5th class student could read it better than her.
@@YashSharma-iv7ok yeah ...this was the question that weighed in on my mind too🤔 and it's not to suggest that all private school kids speak tremendous English!!!
Hey Akash, today's episode hit close to home. Coming from a privileged background, I had the chance to attend one of the state's top schools. I want to share a story from my school days. In our Telugu class, a friend from my Hyderabadi community, though from a Telugu state, struggled to translate due to our Nizam-influenced background, which wasn't inherently Telugu. The Telugu teacher made him a laughing stock in class during my 10th-grade year. Despite being in a Telugu-speaking state, many from my community faced language challenges. Frustrated, my friend boldly expressed, "I spent a decade in this school mastering Telugu along with other subjects, yet I struggle to translate a simple Telugu sentence. The remarks made are a reflection of the school's shortcomings, despite its top-ranking status in the state." Unfortunately, his outspokenness led to a month-long suspension for perceived disrespect. Afterwards, his parents intervened, and he was compelled to apologize to continue attending the school. This incident highlights issues within our education system and the challenges faced by Indian parents, even in top schools in India's fourth-largest city. It's a reminder of the disparities that may prevail in India's rural areas, where a significant 60% of the total population resides. Despite challenges, stories like this one shed light on the complexities within our educational landscape.
The best part of this report is that it came out in Nov. 23. Now seeing some news articles and episodes on it, but it is totally absent from mainstream media.
You've nailed the frustration, loud and clear. The tired script of "development vs. freedom," the suffocating praise, the measly education budget - it all feels like a slap in the face. They're afraid of an educated populace, scared of voices that dare to speak their minds. At least you can talk. Our development has also taken away our freedom of speech! ভালোবাসা নেবেন বাংলাদেশ থেকে। 🇧🇩
I'm from Rural area (Malkangiri, Odisha). I can relate 😢😢. Most of the govt. High school students don't know even simple mathematical calculation like addition, substraction. But in our Odisha, government focus on school infrastructure (5T) not on students education or skills.😮
@@ug1880 yes because currently people don’t raise any questions and accept whatever the politicians do with them. I will be really happy if you ever raise valid questions in front of your area politicians then you can make as many jokes about my comment as you want.
@@mightytitan1719 90%! Dude your circle is either dead or doesn't exist... If not then I guess you're talking about knowledge and not wisdom... Each human is born with a great extent of wisdom, the only difference is we lack observing it and value knowledge... It's a whole different thing!
२००६ मे जो कांग्रेस पार्टी ने एज्युकेशन पोलिसी बनाई थी , जिसमै रिझल्ट % नही बताया जाता , सिर्फ A, B, C, D class बताया जाता है, जिस पोलिसी के हिसाब से १ से ९ कक्षा तक के बच्चे को फेल ना करने का और उसे सिधा अगले कक्षा मे डाला जाता हैं , २००६ मे ही प्रायव्हेट अंग्रेजी स्कुलो को किसीको भी बाटने का काम हुआ ,इसके बाद कोचिंग माफीया ने पैर पसारे, इससे गरिबो के सरकारी स्कूल बंद पडने शुरु हुए , २००६ के बाद इंजिनिअरिंग कॉलेज की संख्या १०० गुना बढाई गई , जिससे २००५ के बाद स्कुल मे १ क्लास मे प्रवेश किये हुए बच्चे ही इससे एफेक्ट किए है ,
@@45siddheshjha_sci24 well i have done my btech from iit delhi in mce branch andi know this is truth we only knew how to use formulas not the thought process behind it
This is the grey area that we need to talk about. Since 1947 people and our leaders neglected the importance of Education..now imagine if the leaders and the masses focused on education since then, where would India be today. . Akash sir you're a true spirit. 😊❤
Education has been spread worldwide by religion and its institutions but seldom by kings. In India also, this responsibility since Vedic times was given to Btahimins, Pandits, and Prohits, but unfortunately, they let Hindu society down as we are the most uneducated community in the world today. Brahmins of RSS have made the situation worse ever since they came to power.
@@pardeeptandonits not completely true man, there are various documents depicting the no of students enrolled in gurukuls caste wise , there were double amount of shudras studying in gurukuls compared to bhramins . But quality education started declining due to British interference in Indian education system. After independence few attempts were made to increase the quality of education like set up of nits and iits, iims, medical colleges like aiims but later leaders realised that its better to keep people uneducated and hence they cut down funding of institutions 😂😂and large chunk of population remains uneducated
@@pranjalrai944but again in iit and these institutions the quality of professors and content is not good. Pple who are good at it are leaving country coz they can’t handle the institutional politics and arnt given opportunities for their own career growth do you know research funds are cut down drastically so where is research in these institutions to offer a global standing. Even the team fr chandrayan wasn’t paid fr 6-7 months
Kash main bhi kisi job mein engaged hota toh jorur kuch apna taraf se bhi toda contribution 💰 deta... 😢 Btw thanks for " ENGLISH SUBTITLES ". Keep it up... You guys ( whole DESHBAKH TEAM ) are doing great. 👍🏻👌🏻
Vietnam has improved its education system. It now does as well as many wealthy countries on PISA(secondary school math, reading, science). Vietnam's per capita income has surged ahead. NR Narayana Murthy has said India should bring in 10,000 accomplished teachers from around the world to train Indian teachers. India's school teachers ought to learn pedagogy from the best, like Singapore.
@@santoshmeshram3773 OECD PISA 2022 Table I.1. Snapshot of performance in mathematics, reading and science. Vietnamese students perform as well as students in high income countries.
But we are in Amrit Kal so now with establishment of Bhagwan Ram Mandir we will be in Ram Rajya. So why to study we should re-establish the golden period of ram Rajya. Our pm is incarnation of Bhagwan Vishnu who doesn’t believe in education coz he himself gt two fake degree so he knows western education is mithya and we should go and live by old Gurukul days. Jai Sri Ram 🚩
@@trevorgtals jahan dekho vahan pr illogical batein pta nhi desh me kb padhne likhne ki baat aayegi. Jb bhi education unemployment poverty ki baat kare tb Rahul Gandhi ko pappu bol dete ho.. isse kya fayda hoga desh sudhar jayega?? Sawaal se sarkar ese hi logo ki vajah se bhagti hai jb tk desh me tum jese log hai tb tk education sudhar hi nhi skti🙄
@@penacle7 maybe u r his PA that's u know his degree is fake.... Btw go and oppose madarsa not our mandir bcoz we pay taxes from mandir as well as we run hospitals, schools, ngos and we also feed to hundreds and thousands of homeless through mandirs.... And the main reason we don't make terrerrestttt in mandirs 😂
The ASER survey is on point. I am from rural India and I know many 6th graders who cannot even answer questions of a 2nd standard. I know many teachers in govt schools complaining that hardly students attend schools and this system have been going on for years now.
@@Vdbailso what? Millions of people in india still can't afford 2 time meal. What's the point of trillions of $ economy when the country itself is rotting in by the hands of greed politicians with there cheap politics?
Oh I've seen kids bragging about bunking classes most of the time I don't know but Maybe our people need some civic sense and deciplin heck our people don't even follow the traffic rules properly so of course this shool bunking Is popular among kids because why the hell not
Going to say the same. Also, "Amra jodi na jagi maa kemne sokal hobe? tonar chhele uthle mago raat pohabe tobe." We have to start doing the job ourselves and stop waiting for others to do it for us.
1.We never become a 5 trillion GDP if INDIA rural area peoples are not educated. 2.Employment:-If there is no job after studying because educated people have the greatest hand in our GDP 3.Farmers issues:-In these days Farmers are attending suicide and there are no helping aid to aiding our farmers but our politician for vote saying 'Jay Jawan Jay Kisan'. 4.Religion conflict:- In these days our godi media just focus upon hindu Muslim , mandir masjid but no media talking about our main issues. Thank you ❤
Aisa lagh raha hai ki India mai saari prblm 2016 ke baat shuru hua hAi jab se internet aaya hai India hamesha se aisa tha Aur India 5 trillion ban jayega 5 trillion 1.4 billion logo ke liye badhi vaat nahi hai India aaj he 4 trillion dollars economy hai
True. Modi should have done balancing act. He started off well but drifted away in irrelevant issues. One man army. He could have saved billions of rupees which used in his projections, self personification, advertisements, huge events ,Rallies road shows , media tv payments n much more in the list. The same expenses could have used for good schools infrastructure all over n teachers n students welfare. Even now he is blowing up lots of dough. Looks like even Sri Ram's advice to him not worked 😢
@@sandeepshah105 - please tell me this is a joke ? Corruption was at all time high and Security situation was pathetic plus globally we had no hold watsoever .
@@hilboyk1408ya the 2008 crisis which brought the world down on knees did not mess with India was an exceptional work...and if u get time please watch agricultural development in UPA period
Thank you for bringing insightful content and keeping up the quality. It is not easy at all to do it with consistency for long. You are killing it! Please keep it up Aakash.
Last time I checked, the average combined IQ of our country was between 76-83. This was due to non affordability of nutritious food, also quality of education was below par. Need to invest heavily in education, at least we should spend 8 percent of our GDP.
@Akarsh2008well at least he's done some good but worst part is they make policies they get passed in the parliament and they never implement them I've always asked why i mean the sheer overbloted incompetent Beaurucracy is one of the factors but dammit you're the Prime minister you can literally tell them to fuck the red tape and just do it although I love our forgine policy
This is true .. Being a banker posted in rural area of Bengal here when students comes to withdraw fund(govt subsidy) they are unable to fill the the form the completely,they can't even write the correct spelling of '8' when I ask you are in which class he said he is in class 9.😅 Ye banayenge 5 trillion ki economy 😢
Yes, this is a very big problem, when I passed 12th, even basic questions were not given to me, only Q&A system of memorization has been created in the school. I may blame my shortcomings on bad schooling.
As a very wise man (Ambrose Bierce) once said: "A government is too big and too important to be put in the hands of politicians." Once again, a superb episode, @Akash da. Dhonyobad 🎉
@@johnanthonydutta6579 ha abhi likh lo bhai bangla me, vaise bhi 40-50 saal baad arabi me hi likhna hai, Bangladeshi kabza jamane hi vale hai tumhare west Bengal me
@@Gustav_fringe na na.... Waste Bengal tab bhi tha, Aaj bhi hai aur aage bhi rahega. Lekin main sure hu ke Uttar Pradesh Bhagwa atankwadi ya yuh bolle yeh Hindu Pakistan banne wala hai bohoth jald.
@@johnanthonydutta6579 beta, west Bengal me 79% hindu the 1951 me aaj sirf 70% hai bavjood iske ki Bangladesh se Hindu refugee west Bengal aaye bhaari sankhya me. Vahi muslims 19% se 28% par pahuch gye sirf 60 saal me Aur hindu Pakistan to nahi ban Raha lekin jo Pakistaniyo ne Bengali hinduo ke sath Kiya tha vo tum bhul gye shayad, direct action day bhul gye, noakhali bhul gye, 1971 me Bangladesh me 30 lakh hindu ko mara gya vo bhul gye, 5 lakh hindu women ka r@pe hua vo bhul gye. Tere jaise log radical islam ko defend karte hai aur fir khud unke hatho kat jaate hai
Thanks a lot @The Deshbhakt for making these important issues visible to the Indian audience. I am a teenager and have been following you since a long time, your videos help me to shape my thoughts about these issues and share them with people:)
it is not a coincidence that higher studies in india have much better facilities compared to primary education. making IIT even greater is always a good thing, but then also give enough teaching support in village schools as well. the reason they will not do it is because smothering a child's interest in studies from a very young age satisfies our politicians' agendas.
Waah bhut hi badhiya....ekdum to the point baat khi h....pehla aisa koi mila jo roots tk problem ko smjhaya aur kaise education se maximum cheez sahi ho skta h ye btaya....ekdum shi baat kha h correct education se hi sb thik ho payega🔥🔥👍👏
Quality of education at every level - from primary to PhD and beyond - is perilous in India. I am a university teacher and I can vouch for it. Even PhDs cannot write one correct sentence, forget school children. People with MA, MSc degrees have zilch general knowledge.
Will that in anyway help you respond / comment better to my observation? Or are you looking for elaboration about why I made the comment? I can discuss in detail of course about every level, but this I guess is not the space...@@sarthakmehrishi7687
My cousin who studies in our village school is in 7th but he can't even count numbers above 20. When I asked his teachers why they had been passing him to next class, they told me that they passed him because of 'no-fail' policy of govt. Similarly, CBSE has been continuously reducing the syllabus for 3 years now so that more students would pass. Overall quality of our school education is falling down day by day just to boost the numbers.
Thank you for addressing this problem which has been ruining the quality of education standard in our country especially in primary and below elementary std. Atleast in some of the states the govt is trying to do away with no detention policy but it has already done a serious damage in our country’s quality of education. It’s very pathetic, the quality of education, in most of the public schools. Elementary school students of 5th and 6th std some even 7 th and 8th pupils don’t know how to write all the alphabet properly 😢
You absolutely on point Akash!! Good STEM education is the way to go. All the developed and nearly developed countries have clear distinction in STEM education. UK is trying to revive their declining STEM education standards. It's the phenomenon also happening in other developed economies as well.
" Era joto janbe.. Toto kom manbe" this was the iconic dialogue in Satyajit Ray's one of the best films.. Hirak Rajar Deshe. This is what India is going through since Independence 😊
@@sardarji162the more they read, the more they will know and the more will they disobey us , this dialogue was said by a King to his minister in the bengali film , Hirak Rajar deshe . Basically the King is saying that educated people are harder to control .
Congratulations for doing this episode. I am an avid follower but have never commented. However, this is too close to my heart to let it pass. In my opinion this issue should not be taken only with reference to the present report. As a teacher and author who has been observing the changes for the past 28 years, many points need to be considered and resolved in tandem to bring about a positive change. Though not exhaustive, here is a list of some problems and remedies: 1) Teaching should not be considered as a last career option by meritorious students. If it is made competetive and lucrative, it will attract excellence. 2) Excellence should not be judged by marks alone but also include evaluation of behavioural skills. 3) The no detention policy has led to dilution of excellence, complacency in students and disarming teachers. Several batches of children have passed out without basic knowledge. 4) Accountability of teachers with respect to the results may also have triggered unfair practices. 5) The role of parents in upholding values and methods taught in school is also important. What is taught in school should not get undone at home and vice versa. 6) There is immense need for investment in infrastructure of schools. Unless all facilities are provided, recognition should be reviewed. 7) The strength of classes is too high for even the most sincere teachers to do justice to each child. Better infrastructure and hiring regular teachers should be helpful. 8) Teachers should be actively involved in making changes to policies regarding education, as they are the ones who can judge whether they can be implemented or not. 9) Additional duties unrelated to teaching given to educators hinders their motivation and efficiency. 10) Very importantly, people who genuinely have a passion for the profession and can practice what they preach, should become teachers.
dar isse nahi lagta ki desh kab aage badhe ga.. dar isse lagta hai ki aapka content kabhi niche na chala jaii... dil chuu liya aaj ki baat sun kar ... keep uploading ... love youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
i m working at an rural educational institution and can say that each and every word u are telling is a fact thanks akash sir this needs to change just enrolling is not enough teachers are responsible but they have to face many difficulties and pressure of upper people as well
I am from Odisha, our High school teacher recruitment came after 4,5 years, in which almost 25,26k vacancy filled with 3 stages within 6,7 months with urgency..There was no minimum qualifing mark, SC,ST cutoff was in single digit out of 100... Situation is like 1 post per 1.5 candidates available... If such quality teachers got posting in High school that is matriculation, then think about our Quality of education one student will get in our Govt High school.. Last few years our School infrastructure is improving at a rapid pace in Odisha,but quality teacher is absent in our schools...Now a days almost 80pc Students are going to Intermediate college after passing matriculation but the main issue is quality of education they are getting...
Only caste entitled people would say something like that .people like who discriminate will ensure reservations, thanks to you.youa re forgetting, upper castes hindus do believe in more superstitious and propaganda of government in India.so called upper castes hindus are teaching religion in iit bhu .
You are living in a country where in villages which is 70 percent of India is feudal and discriminate on caste and religious basis and deliberately don't teach students from oppressed caste and marginalized backgrounds.
Hey AB! Good one! Politicians normally thrive on social engineering models, one of the not so popular one being keeping the population busy to make their ends meet- so that they seldom have time to raise questions as they keep moving from one existential crisis to another!
In 2022,Haryana Govt. Distribute tabs to students of 10th and 12th standard and its affect is very bad. students became addicted to social media and they do misuse of internet access.
Well guess when you try to do the hybrid system it blows up in your face I guess we also need to tech students to not do this bullshit or if that not possible because people don't really like bi binded by rules so restrict social media access om govt tablets I guess they can do that
Quality of education has gone down drastically. I work in an organization which recruits people from all over India. I have seen that people lack basic skills such as comprehension or writing.
I don't know what profile or what industry you're hiring from, but I don't think the heart of lack of education is to be seen in the cities and the size of population impacted because of it mostly live outside the cities. Unless you are suggesting you're hiring from rural areas.
I think it is high time to transform primary education into Montessori method of learning. The present primary education system in India is outdated and is killing the curiosity of children by the time they reach secondary education.
Bro Start preparation of Upsc or Start Thinking like A Education minister Kud pta chal jayega Kyu hame jis education system me hai wohi thik hai Bachhe Humans hai robots ya fir ai nhi ki sab kuch store hota rhe Samjke kya rakha hai 😡 Skill ki baat krne wale ye bhul jate hai ki bade hoke Khana kya khayege Etc Jo important hai uspe dhyan do Faltu Chiz ki wajah se hi aaj esa hota hai Or To or Agar Kisi bachhe ko koi topic nhi aarha to Uski ek hi galti ki usne revision nhi kiya Agar tum Us, Russia, japan jaisi country se India ko compare kararhe ho To Tum se bade Nich soch wale or koi nhi poverty, unemployment Vagare sab chiz pe bhi focus kro and Agar koi company bolti hai ki yaha ke workers skilled nhi hai to Company ko ujadke fekne ki jarurt hai Pahle To skill will ka itna jyada culture nhi tha aaj kal company ek dusri company Ko dekh dekh kar desh ko chush rhi hai i hope Government ban Some business man and Some company because College me tum sab shik jate ho jo life me kam aaye
@@Bholedsoza I understand your pain and I also have gone through the same education system and it is not right. If you need more clarity you can watch " Dark Reality of Indian Education system" on Dhruv Rathee's youtube channel. He has explained it so beautifully.
@@BholedsozaTob vai,batao jobs kaise milegi agar skill na ho. Trade Schools are needed. Welding, Electrician, Fitters aise jobs bahar ke countries mein bohut popular hain. Padhe likhe log bhi aise jobs karte hain. Yaha to bas competitive exams, govt. jobs aur social status chalta hain. Skills ke liye pay karti hain Companies. Problem ye hain ki, har cheez bohut unsustainable tareeke se ban rahi hain. Har cheez 5-6 saal mein change. This is why people are finding it hard to upskill & adapt. This is the grey area where we need to fill the gap. Skills chahiye but upskilling should be sustainable.
Hello Akash sir, I'm from Chhattisgarh ( North Bastar) always watching your informative videos and this not just a report it's a reality of our Rural India especially here in 'Bastar' where I can see the clear difference between the students of 'South Bastar and North Bastar' ( not comparing )and my elder Sister who is a teacher in South Bastar region more than 16 years has always told me about the ground reality of South Bastar's education and how and why the system has failed over there just for votes and their sakes. And I'm requesting to you please make a video on ' HASDEO BACHO' protest. Thank you.
Not just in rural India… I live Delhi, I work in an NGO called CRY, and I teach them. They don’t know how to read and write who are in 5th-6th class and one girl was in 8th class who doesn’t know ABCD and 1-20 counting numbers. Some of them go to government schools in Delhi. I would like to ask which government schools in Delhi are giving good quality education? Only 4-5 in posh areas of Delhi. I teach in slum areas. What about those government schools?
So true... as I am a student myself in 10th... quality of teachers nowdays is getting worse...some new teachers joining in my school and others as well are like... some of us 10th students know better than them... and even in my batch there are students who could not read and do basic maths because of some teachers who don't pay attention to them becuase they think as Everybody goes to tuition they can learn there. Everybody says to students how do you don't even know this but "jab tak sikhaoge nhi toa kaise aayega!?" Even me, although I can speak, talk and write proper english but I cannot speak in front of stage because of my stage fear, I tried to participate in events to get rid of this fear but the teachers...rather than teaching us they choose the best same students every year to show the glory of school ...😔 Now education is not a sacred work or about teaching but a business🥲
As an UPSC student, your every video is working as a revision video, especially education, health, unemployment, and government schemes. If I say it in layman's terms, you are doing a tremendous job. In your recent video, you discuss obligarchy government with Dr. Raghuram Rajan, which is really concerning.
Being a tution teacher I have alot students of classes 1 to 10 most of the students are not able to read Hindi English is way more far not able to calculate in mathematics not even able to analyse anything between 6th to 10th classes...........and graduate level students also not able to read it's very dangerous for our country................do something government
Govt should give good salaries and more incentives for teachers opting rural areas. After all it is a job, a profession they have chosen to earn their living, not social service.
@@trevorgtals IITs and IIMs? Where? BJP MP said in Parliament no new ones have been built so far. Aap ka sapna hai kya? In fact in states like UP govt schools are closing down. Be a bhakt not andhbhakt.
@@humanbeing6838 yes the atleast they must be professionals or have passion for teaching, they were given a decent salary yet don't choose and the seats remained vacant. The students were the victims. A possible solution is to recruit local people to the school in rural india that could solve the salary problem
Absolutely correct, I am a teacher of govt higher secondary school , and I face the same thing from students, after completing x+ students can't read english passages and don't know basic maths.
नमस्कार सर💐🙏 बच्चें पढ़ नहीं पाये समझ में आता है, लेकिन क्यों नहीं पढ़ पाये?? क्या हमने इस पर विचार किया और इनकी कमजोरी दूर करने के बजाये हम इन्हें अगली क्लास में क्यों भेज रहे है? क्या हम मूल समस्या को जानने का प्रयास कर भी रहे है या नहीं?? 💐🙏
As a private teacher,I can confirm that Indian education system is at the worst situation right now ( specially the Goverment schools,unimaginable ). Government should focus on the quality education rathar than devolapment of school buildings.
It was also rightly mentioned by Raghuram Rajan in his recent book Breaking the Mould. Most of the students in elementary school have lost the track during COVID. Imagine sitting idle for 2 years and then asking the students to learn.
Same things happening in my Village -ek 15 saal ka larke ko main bola bike kitni km chali hain (170000 km chali thi ) ab larke ye digit nahi bol paya uske dost log bhi nahi bol paye 7-8 boys sabhi 10th class me hai.
Milestones which india is definitely going to cross- 5 trillion dollars GDP by 2027 10 trillion dollars GDP by 2033 20 trillion dollars GDP by 2040 28 trillion dollars GDP by 2047. But we should also remember that China already has a 19 trillion dollars GDP and US with 1/4th of India's population has a massive GDP of 28 trillion dollars as of 2024. India has a long way to go, and that also with great resilience and determination
@afridisahid07 in nominal, yes india is $100 behind Bangladesh in per capita but in PPP terms, India is still 1000 dollars ahead of Bangladesh. And India is a pretty big diverse country, you can't compare it with your homogeneous Bangladesh
@oof9420 yeah like Bangladesh is any better in terms of religion. Atleast minority percentage does not decrease in India. From 23% in 1951 to 7% in 2023.
@@Gustav_fringe If you think we can quadruple our economy from 5T to 20T in 13 years, then keep your compounding knowledge to yourself. China was 5T in 2009, its still not 20T.. And that with the china speed.. I hope you are much more educated than me, only 1st year IITB mechanical
I am a teacher as well as a student...and I can assure you that this is all true.....these days students of class XI and XII find calculations tough like multiplication of decimal numbers, 1^8 , remembering values of sin 30, cos 45, tan 30 ...etc...and it's an alarming state for our economy.
I don't remember many things.. You don't need to.. You got machines... Instead, we should focus on how to use those things.. Problem-solving.. I too don't remember the value of cos 45 or sin 47 etc.. I used to remember them in school days but now the values are present in my tab which I plug in the software to give result..
Salute sir, for focusing on issues plaguing india's development. It is because of the social media and efforts of creators like you we are getting to what is eyewash and what is real need for the development of country.
It's very disheartening to see the state of education in our country. We indians truly believe we are the best and the brightest in the world but in reality we are one the worst countries in the world when it comes to social indicators.
I was an officer in one of the central government departments. But quit in 2017. One thing I would definitely agree, if the govt’s machinery want to execute a project. Trust me it gets executed no matter how big the project is. But if they don’t want to it will never get done.
I agree to each and every word you said in the video. My mom is professor in B.ed collage and and the students who come for enrollment at the time of admissions many of them don't even know what their subjects were. And few of my cousins living in rural area have the same condition.
My mother was a government teacher in Rajasthan and has retired last year. I have been visiting all the schools she taught in and here’s a list of problems I observed, funding and corruption ( most schools don’t even have enough classrooms, there are no chairs or tables, kids sit on floor atop some rag), teachers are given many other wasteful tasks beyond teaching that is taking a lot of their time, household conditions of a lot these kids are dire therefore they work with their families There’s also a huge impact of social conditioning
"Technically" this episode makes no sense to do - this topic is not in the "Trends" - this episode may never get the "Views" .... however one promise to Deshbhakt Family - in 2024 - expect to see more such topics on the channel. Will make more from the heart and less from the head - will make episodes that matter to India - not what may 'work'
Thanks to our Members for allowing me to do this - for trusting us - for motivating us - for keeping us independent.
If you can do join in as a member on patreon.com/thedeshbhakt or click on the JOIN button above!!! 🙏🏼
Excellent episode Akash
Watched it till the end
Desh bahut khatre mai hai😢
A Marathi news channel "Lokshahi" (meaning democracy in Marathi) also got 1 month ban recently. As it used to cover news which matters.
January 26th republic day lekin apne pm sei lekar Desh khe log bhi Ram ayodhya temple open karne khe shock mei h . Inlog khele republic Gaya bhaad mei😂😂
aur ak side china ko dekho
2-3 guna zaada bada size
almost same population
now check the difference of work done for their respective countries!
There is so much to be done to take our country forward. Things looking in control right now is no gurantee of things continuing to remain so. We need to continuously steer the ship with genuine efforts towards the goal. Empty chest thumping is not going to save a sinking ship.
Thanks again for bringing some of the hidden pulse of the nation in the open. Continue doing your bit.
As an Indian, I admit that we annexed Kashmir, Sikkim, Manipur and Northeastern states because we Indians have too many children and we need more territory. In the future, we Indians will have 5 billion people, We must continue to expand our territory, including Nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Tibet, and even the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and the United States...
@@bruch-TB This is why we need good education to have good thinking.
Bhai mera bhi recharge karwa dena 239 ka😁🤪🤣🤣
@@deepusharma22😂😂😂
@trevorgtals Oh! Here you are Pappu! Who is a better comedian than our shri shri PM?
First of all this episode was needed .... so thank you ... we really need to undersrand the gap which lies between the market and data ...
Unemployment Poverty and Illiteracy are not problems but an advantage for the political leaders.
Remembering the Killing fields of Cambodia and Pol Pot their leader who hated education
Divide and rule ☠️☠️☠️ politics is still going on, in India.♥️♥️♥️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Is it right to keep 18% GST in education????
Almost 97% of Indians pronounce UncerTAINTY as UncerTINITY ..... lol
Most educated pm ne kya diya? 20000cr k ghotala, iitan cm kya diya? Sharab scam, education scam, bus scam, health scam, kcr corrupt, didi corrupt, mama corrupt, yeh to hogap hi
There was this famous bengali film 'Hirak Rajar Deshe' by Bharat Ratna Satyajit Ray and there was this famous dialogue 'era joto beshi jane toto kom mane (the more they know the less they obey)' is very apt for the current situation.
@@kaberiganguly7330 Yeah, he was and will remain a jewel for India
I kept saying this to all my friends, we can never become anywhere close to a superpower if we cannot fix our basics, that includes education and healthcare. We are trying to build a skyscraper on a marshland!
Very well said
Exactly!
EXACTLY!!
We need many innovative companies like microsoft, google, Toyota, bmw, nestle, etc. Products of Indian companies should be popular worldwide. This requires good education base and world-class R&D setup
Well things that need to be done would pay the teachers better,hire more qualified staff and do the stuff buddy said in the video I guess but here's a problem the opposition In India is also the worst they never highlight any issues infact if the govt tries to do anything good they oppose it and when the government is making a bad decision they don't say shit they care about power they're willing to creat a North South divide and basically would even take an enemy nations help just to be in power if that's not treason I don't know what is we got many problems but there are good things govt should solve this problem or we might never become a superpower
@anirprasadd that would take a lot of time friends but I agree but here's a catch most of our resources are committed on the border disputes we have if we neglect them we are in real danger of being invaded
My father has worked as a teacher and a principal in a higher secondary school (government) in Gujarat for the last 35 years and according to him there were 8 teachers in the school and slowly all retired in the last 20 years and there have been no requirements so far. So now the school is running on temporary teachers only. The case in tribal areas is even worse. I have visited schools where the entire school is running on only 1 teacher, now you can only imagine the education children are getting when 1 teacher is managing 3 classes at the same time.
The situation of govt schools is worst in Kolkata and West Bengal. Teacher jobs have been sold for lacs of rupees. All gawars like cobblers zamadars have become teachers by joining TMC and those who have scored marks have not been recruited. SSC and TET scams have sky rocketted in primary schools in West Bengal
And that teacher is allotted many works in election and other Government plans !!
That is true here in Meghalaya also
In South India it is the other way round. Schools are giving good education.
People tend to migrate abroad and settle there permanently.
@@BengaliManfromWB
Then u too become cobbler and zamadar 😂😂
This is exactly the kind of reportage we need . A billion reports/programs like this are needed. Akash salute to you. Save India !!!
Is it right to keep 18% GST in education????
It's not gonna matter because no one is gonna listen except some of us. Mass media will never cover this
Aakash ko pata chal Gaya ke BJP ko harana mumkin nhi isliye..av neutral vdo banata he 😂😂
Save India ??!! This has been going on for 75 years and for 65 years India was safe huh ? Government is investing in NEP and educational scholarships - the result will be seen till the next decade
@@sonupatro1599nah he didn't even make a neutral video u can see at the start which politicians he showed
One of the best episode. You proved yourself real deshbhakt by discussing this very crucial problem of the country, which most of us neglecting
❤
I m an employee of Pratham and currently working in an govt. School as a nursery teacher on contract basis. I am so proud of Pratham that's working so hard for the education sector of India. Political leaders are too busy in their politics that they even don't know what's the actual level of education in our country.
After seeing your video , I am so glad that there are few people who are actually concerned about future of India.
Thank you
Hi..im curious.. what is Pratham into? Seems like they really are into shaping the future..is there a website or insta account or email I can get pls.
Content is changing
thanks - this means a lot. respect for the work you guys do
@@NINI-pq3cdyeah you can check it on Google...
how much worse condition now or more worse than this video showing
Thanks!
thanks !!!! appreciate the long term support boss
pakistani dalla
Considering India's population the Portion of our GDP allocated to Education in yearly budget is like feeding handful of grains to an elephant.
Why we are not United????????
Why we are divided into parties, Hindu-Muslim,castes ???????
Is this divide and rule ☠️☠️☠️politics going on in India.♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Is it right to keep 18% GST in education????
Education nexus is also owned by political parties
@@Miyamoto_Mushashi atleast they should not impose tax on education 🥲🫠
@@skbandhu7878people's are fools, that's why political parties leaders exploited them and now since 21st century most of them has become slaves to them.
It has increased many folds after free rice n freebies introduced in high percentage.
Our country is massive population size n billions are heavily dependented on Gods and Goddesses.
😢
Respect to Dr. Ambedkar to understand the importance of education. ❤
❤
Yes...
😂10% .?
Swarn caste don't support to ambedkar....can u feel it
merit?😅
I am a government teacher in rural India in Rajasthan I am watching it closely and on daily basis. The girls have to do the daily household work and the boys usually participate in agricultural work on the farm. There are many families in which the youth have to earn to support their family.Yet the government is trying to train already trained teachers.
When I was a school student (Govt. School) many of the teachers in our school lacked even basic English reading skills. I remember that we had an English teacher in 9th and 10th std, she didn't even know how to read English, a 5th class student could read it better than her.
@@Blackberry578If you are from government school, how is your english this good?
He's a teacher@@YashSharma-iv7ok
Well now govt school teachers are more educated than most of the private one@@YashSharma-iv7ok
@@YashSharma-iv7ok yeah
...this was the question that weighed in on my mind too🤔 and it's not to suggest that all private school kids speak tremendous English!!!
Hey Akash, today's episode hit close to home. Coming from a privileged background, I had the chance to attend one of the state's top schools. I want to share a story from my school days. In our Telugu class, a friend from my Hyderabadi community, though from a Telugu state, struggled to translate due to our Nizam-influenced background, which wasn't inherently Telugu.
The Telugu teacher made him a laughing stock in class during my 10th-grade year. Despite being in a Telugu-speaking state, many from my community faced language challenges. Frustrated, my friend boldly expressed, "I spent a decade in this school mastering Telugu along with other subjects, yet I struggle to translate a simple Telugu sentence. The remarks made are a reflection of the school's shortcomings, despite its top-ranking status in the state." Unfortunately, his outspokenness led to a month-long suspension for perceived disrespect.
Afterwards, his parents intervened, and he was compelled to apologize to continue attending the school. This incident highlights issues within our education system and the challenges faced by Indian parents, even in top schools in India's fourth-largest city.
It's a reminder of the disparities that may prevail in India's rural areas, where a significant 60% of the total population resides. Despite challenges, stories like this one shed light on the complexities within our educational landscape.
The best part of this report is that it came out in Nov. 23. Now seeing some news articles and episodes on it, but it is totally absent from mainstream media.
Godi Media 🎉
nothing surprising there !!!
You've nailed the frustration, loud and clear. The tired script of "development vs. freedom," the suffocating praise, the measly education budget - it all feels like a slap in the face. They're afraid of an educated populace, scared of voices that dare to speak their minds. At least you can talk. Our development has also taken away our freedom of speech! ভালোবাসা নেবেন বাংলাদেশ থেকে। 🇧🇩
I'm from Rural area (Malkangiri, Odisha). I can relate 😢😢. Most of the govt. High school students don't know even simple mathematical calculation like addition, substraction. But in our Odisha, government focus on school infrastructure (5T) not on students education or skills.😮
Yes buddy.. 5T
Some students are great in other subjects like science, history, political science and etc
Then what u decided to vote this time😮
Whenever I see people like you and raise valid questions from the government, I feel so proud to be an Indian and want to say, Jai Hind.
Raising questions is good but raising questions to the govt when it's the only good thing that's happening is nonsense
Same feeling bro , jai hind
@@lamokingy_t974 Who should the question be raised to then? These videos are for uneducated folks like you.
People raising valid questions and for that you feel proud to be Indian 😂.....
@@ug1880 yes because currently people don’t raise any questions and accept whatever the politicians do with them. I will be really happy if you ever raise valid questions in front of your area politicians then you can make as many jokes about my comment as you want.
Politicians should have wisdom instead of degree
Sadly, they lack both
same goes for 90 percent of human population
@@mightytitan1719 90%!
Dude your circle is either dead or doesn't exist...
If not then I guess you're talking about knowledge and not wisdom... Each human is born with a great extent of wisdom, the only difference is we lack observing it and value knowledge...
It's a whole different thing!
@@Vdbail bot... Playing bad politics 😔
२००६ मे जो कांग्रेस पार्टी ने एज्युकेशन पोलिसी बनाई थी , जिसमै रिझल्ट % नही बताया जाता , सिर्फ A, B, C, D class बताया जाता है, जिस पोलिसी के हिसाब से १ से ९ कक्षा तक के बच्चे को फेल ना करने का और उसे सिधा अगले कक्षा मे डाला जाता हैं , २००६ मे ही प्रायव्हेट अंग्रेजी स्कुलो को किसीको भी बाटने का काम हुआ ,इसके बाद कोचिंग माफीया ने पैर पसारे, इससे गरिबो के सरकारी स्कूल बंद पडने शुरु हुए , २००६ के बाद इंजिनिअरिंग कॉलेज की संख्या १०० गुना बढाई गई , जिससे २००५ के बाद स्कुल मे १ क्लास मे प्रवेश किये हुए बच्चे ही इससे एफेक्ट किए है ,
@@45siddheshjha_sci24 well i have done my btech from iit delhi in mce branch andi know this is truth we only knew how to use formulas not the thought process behind it
This is the grey area that we need to talk about. Since 1947 people and our leaders neglected the importance of Education..now imagine if the leaders and the masses focused on education since then, where would India be today. . Akash sir you're a true spirit. 😊❤
Education has been spread worldwide by religion and its institutions but seldom by kings. In India also, this responsibility since Vedic times was given to Btahimins, Pandits, and Prohits, but unfortunately, they let Hindu society down as we are the most uneducated community in the world today. Brahmins of RSS have made the situation worse ever since they came to power.
@@pardeeptandonits not completely true man, there are various documents depicting the no of students enrolled in gurukuls caste wise , there were double amount of shudras studying in gurukuls compared to bhramins .
But quality education started declining due to British interference in Indian education system.
After independence few attempts were made to increase the quality of education like set up of nits and iits, iims, medical colleges like aiims but later leaders realised that its better to keep people uneducated and hence they cut down funding of institutions 😂😂and large chunk of population remains uneducated
@@pranjalrai944but again in iit and these institutions the quality of professors and content is not good. Pple who are good at it are leaving country coz they can’t handle the institutional politics and arnt given opportunities for their own career growth do you know research funds are cut down drastically so where is research in these institutions to offer a global standing. Even the team fr chandrayan wasn’t paid fr 6-7 months
Is it right to keep 18% GST in education????
@@pranjalrai944
Dont spread nonsense, man.
Kash main bhi kisi job mein engaged hota toh jorur kuch apna taraf se bhi toda contribution 💰 deta... 😢
Btw thanks for " ENGLISH SUBTITLES ".
Keep it up... You guys ( whole DESHBAKH TEAM ) are doing great. 👍🏻👌🏻
Vietnam has improved its education system. It now does as well as many wealthy countries on PISA(secondary school math, reading, science). Vietnam's per capita income has surged ahead. NR Narayana Murthy has said India should bring in 10,000 accomplished teachers from around the world to train Indian teachers. India's school teachers ought to learn pedagogy from the best, like Singapore.
Sir please share the document mentioned
@@santoshmeshram3773 OECD PISA 2022 Table I.1. Snapshot of performance in mathematics, reading and science. Vietnamese students perform as well as students in high income countries.
india have top notch teacher in coaching iitians
@@tubelzsino sepians >indo sepians
@@padhlekyakarrhahaituyahanp1011 They should have a role in improving the public education system.
The first step to solve a problem is to recognise it and accept it, but not to hide it under the carpet.
But we are in Amrit Kal so now with establishment of Bhagwan Ram Mandir we will be in Ram Rajya. So why to study we should re-establish the golden period of ram Rajya. Our pm is incarnation of Bhagwan Vishnu who doesn’t believe in education coz he himself gt two fake degree so he knows western education is mithya and we should go and live by old Gurukul days. Jai Sri Ram 🚩
@@penacle7I hope you are being sarcastic 😅😂
When the leader thinks he himself Vishwa Guru, there is no chance for any failure & accepting it no way!😂
@@trevorgtals jahan dekho vahan pr illogical batein pta nhi desh me kb padhne likhne ki baat aayegi. Jb bhi education unemployment poverty ki baat kare tb Rahul Gandhi ko pappu bol dete ho.. isse kya fayda hoga desh sudhar jayega?? Sawaal se sarkar ese hi logo ki vajah se bhagti hai jb tk desh me tum jese log hai tb tk education sudhar hi nhi skti🙄
@@penacle7 maybe u r his PA that's u know his degree is fake.... Btw go and oppose madarsa not our mandir bcoz we pay taxes from mandir as well as we run hospitals, schools, ngos and we also feed to hundreds and thousands of homeless through mandirs.... And the main reason we don't make terrerrestttt in mandirs 😂
The ASER survey is on point. I am from rural India and I know many 6th graders who cannot even answer questions of a 2nd standard. I know many teachers in govt schools complaining that hardly students attend schools and this system have been going on for years now.
@@Vdbailso what? Millions of people in india still can't afford 2 time meal. What's the point of trillions of $ economy when the country itself is rotting in by the hands of greed politicians with there cheap politics?
@@Vdbailtoh g@@ndu tere economy se kya Hoga jab Maire Gaon ke logon ka kuch nai hai
Oh I've seen kids bragging about bunking classes most of the time I don't know but Maybe our people need some civic sense and deciplin heck our people don't even follow the traffic rules properly so of course this shool bunking Is popular among kids because why the hell not
@@deletedaccount573 you do know any funding given by the center Is mostly ate up by the beaurucrats and the politicians
@@deletedaccount573 also a trillion dollar economy might give us more money to expand our territory
Thanks
Thanks Akash. Very important issue that you have highlighted.
Line from "Hirak rajar deshe" written and directed by Satyajit Roy "The more they know, more they ask that much more they disobey you"
Going to say the same. Also, "Amra jodi na jagi maa kemne sokal hobe? tonar chhele uthle mago raat pohabe tobe." We have to start doing the job ourselves and stop waiting for others to do it for us.
U speak the truth.
India's role model speaks only and only .....
1.We never become a 5 trillion GDP if INDIA rural area peoples are not educated.
2.Employment:-If there is no job after studying because educated people have the greatest hand in our GDP
3.Farmers issues:-In these days Farmers are attending suicide and there are no helping aid to aiding our farmers but our politician for vote saying 'Jay Jawan Jay Kisan'.
4.Religion conflict:- In these days our godi media just focus upon hindu Muslim , mandir masjid but no media talking about our main issues.
Thank you ❤
Aisa lagh raha hai ki India mai saari prblm 2016 ke baat shuru hua hAi jab se internet aaya hai
India hamesha se aisa tha
Aur India 5 trillion ban jayega
5 trillion 1.4 billion logo ke liye badhi vaat nahi hai
India aaj he 4 trillion dollars economy hai
@@MriKum-wr6ks tujhe kya benefit mil raha hai economy se (personal benefit batana).
Freedom can only be attained through education | শিক্ষার মাধ্যমেই মুক্তি পাওয়া যায়। - NETAJI
We want Atal ji and Dr Manmohan Singh ji era again when they were introducing Right to education act and many more laws related to this continuously 😔
When u say Manmohan era I hope u mean as Finance minister ? 🙏🏻
@hilboyk1408 Except for the last 2 years, UPA govt did pretty well in its term of 10 years.
True.
Modi should have done balancing act. He started off well but drifted away in irrelevant issues. One man army.
He could have saved billions of rupees which used in his projections, self personification, advertisements, huge events ,Rallies road shows , media tv payments n much more in the list.
The same expenses could have used for good schools infrastructure all over n teachers n students welfare.
Even now he is blowing up lots of dough.
Looks like even Sri Ram's advice to him not worked 😢
@@sandeepshah105 - please tell me this is a joke ? Corruption was at all time high and Security situation was pathetic plus globally we had no hold watsoever .
@@hilboyk1408ya the 2008 crisis which brought the world down on knees did not mess with India was an exceptional work...and if u get time please watch agricultural development in UPA period
Thank you for bringing insightful content and keeping up the quality. It is not easy at all to do it with consistency for long. You are killing it! Please keep it up Aakash.
@@trevorgtals uski Marzi woh joh bhi kare apne paiso ke saath, tera kya ja raha hai Andhbhakt??
thanks a ton boss....it is this support that keeps us going
do consider becoming an annual member via patreon.com/thedeshbhakt
Last time I checked, the average combined IQ of our country was between 76-83. This was due to non affordability of nutritious food, also quality of education was below par. Need to invest heavily in education, at least we should spend 8 percent of our GDP.
nutrition and the lack of it is a whole another episode :((((
@@thedeshbhaktjai modi ghar ghar modi.
@@thedeshbhaktcolleages and schools are just making people slaves lmao
Good joke.
@Akarsh2008well at least he's done some good but worst part is they make policies they get passed in the parliament and they never implement them I've always asked why i mean the sheer overbloted incompetent Beaurucracy is one of the factors but dammit you're the Prime minister you can literally tell them to fuck the red tape and just do it although I love our forgine policy
Ap sache muddon par baat karte ho jiske bare main sochna sabko bhaut jaruri hai hats-off u sir 🙌🙌🙌🙏🙏🙏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤
This is true ..
Being a banker posted in rural area of Bengal here when students comes to withdraw fund(govt subsidy) they are unable to fill the the form the completely,they can't even write the correct spelling of '8' when I ask you are in which class he said he is in class 9.😅
Ye banayenge 5 trillion ki economy 😢
Ekdom sahi baat bola apne, when I go to bank some people's come to me for fill the withdraw form
How would they do it?? Tell me, does your bank forms have options in Bengali?? No, right?? you think rural kids will be fluid in English and hindi??
R u working in RRBs as PO/Clerk??
@@smilingCherrywriting 8 in numbers doesn't need to be fluid(fluent)
@@sagnikbhattacharya9191 I'm working in PSU as clerk
Yes, this is a very big problem, when I passed 12th, even basic questions were not given to me, only Q&A system of memorization has been created in the school. I may blame my shortcomings on bad schooling.
As a very wise man (Ambrose Bierce) once said:
"A government is too big and too important to be put in the hands of politicians."
Once again, a superb episode, @Akash da.
Dhonyobad 🎉
Dhonyobad ta bangla te likhle aaro bhalo lagto
@@johnanthonydutta6579 ha abhi likh lo bhai bangla me, vaise bhi 40-50 saal baad arabi me hi likhna hai, Bangladeshi kabza jamane hi vale hai tumhare west Bengal me
@@Gustav_fringe कुछ भी bc
@@Gustav_fringe na na.... Waste Bengal tab bhi tha, Aaj bhi hai aur aage bhi rahega. Lekin main sure hu ke Uttar Pradesh Bhagwa atankwadi ya yuh bolle yeh Hindu Pakistan banne wala hai bohoth jald.
@@johnanthonydutta6579 beta, west Bengal me 79% hindu the 1951 me aaj sirf 70% hai bavjood iske ki Bangladesh se Hindu refugee west Bengal aaye bhaari sankhya me.
Vahi muslims 19% se 28% par pahuch gye sirf 60 saal me
Aur hindu Pakistan to nahi ban Raha lekin jo Pakistaniyo ne Bengali hinduo ke sath Kiya tha vo tum bhul gye shayad, direct action day bhul gye, noakhali bhul gye, 1971 me Bangladesh me 30 lakh hindu ko mara gya vo bhul gye, 5 lakh hindu women ka r@pe hua vo bhul gye.
Tere jaise log radical islam ko defend karte hai aur fir khud unke hatho kat jaate hai
Whithout termination 10323 teachers terminated by Tripura Govt.
Thanks a lot @The Deshbhakt for making these important issues visible to the Indian audience. I am a teenager and have been following you since a long time, your videos help me to shape my thoughts about these issues and share them with people:)
it is not a coincidence that higher studies in india have much better facilities compared to primary education. making IIT even greater is always a good thing, but then also give enough teaching support in village schools as well. the reason they will not do it is because smothering a child's interest in studies from a very young age satisfies our politicians' agendas.
Fabulous work, may you succeed in your goal for the good of this country.
Waah bhut hi badhiya....ekdum to the point baat khi h....pehla aisa koi mila jo roots tk problem ko smjhaya aur kaise education se maximum cheez sahi ho skta h ye btaya....ekdum shi baat kha h correct education se hi sb thik ho payega🔥🔥👍👏
Please make a detailed video on why supreme court lawyers are protesting against EVM
Quality of education at every level - from primary to PhD and beyond - is perilous in India. I am a university teacher and I can vouch for it. Even PhDs cannot write one correct sentence, forget school children. People with MA, MSc degrees have zilch general knowledge.
Sir, if you are comfortable with it then I would like to ask that which university's lecturer are you, and which stream?
@@sarthakmehrishi7687problems in method of teaching, wrong syllabus , glorified one religion educationalists.
Will that in anyway help you respond / comment better to my observation? Or are you looking for elaboration about why I made the comment? I can discuss in detail of course about every level, but this I guess is not the space...@@sarthakmehrishi7687
Because the focus is on distributing certificates and degrees not learning and developing critical thinking, @@D.ThirumalaikumarKumar
If you could care to explain why do you need this information @@saryooarora1947
My cousin who studies in our village school is in 7th but he can't even count numbers above 20. When I asked his teachers why they had been passing him to next class, they told me that they passed him because of 'no-fail' policy of govt. Similarly, CBSE has been continuously reducing the syllabus for 3 years now so that more students would pass. Overall quality of our school education is falling down day by day just to boost the numbers.
Thank you for addressing this problem which has been ruining the quality of education standard in our country especially in primary and below elementary std. Atleast in some of the states the govt is trying to do away with no detention policy but it has already done a serious damage in our country’s quality of education. It’s very pathetic, the quality of education, in most of the public schools. Elementary school students of 5th and 6th std some even 7 th and 8th pupils don’t know how to write all the alphabet properly 😢
देशभक्त का ये रुप असली देशभक्त वाला रूप सबसे पसंद आया और सच सामने लाने वाला वक्ती ही सच मे देशभक्त कह सकते हे 🙏🏻
You absolutely on point Akash!!
Good STEM education is the way to go. All the developed and nearly developed countries have clear distinction in STEM education.
UK is trying to revive their declining STEM education standards. It's the phenomenon also happening in other developed economies as well.
I think hovt should try to make mathematics compulsory for everyone from class 1 to 4th year of graduation....(I am a blind math lover though...😁)
@@slayypoint126learning maths can make you logical
@@rishavkumar1250 ha toh wahi toh bola Maine....especially probability and pnc....at high school level..
@@slayypoint1261 to 4th 😂? Apne yaha toh 1 to 10th already compulsory hai.
@@FaizanRaza_MD 4th year of graduation bola....
" Era joto janbe.. Toto kom manbe" this was the iconic dialogue in Satyajit Ray's one of the best films.. Hirak Rajar Deshe. This is what India is going through since Independence 😊
Bhai iska matlab kya hai dialogue ka bata na
@@sardarji162the more they read, the more they will know and the more will they disobey us , this dialogue was said by a King to his minister in the bengali film , Hirak Rajar deshe .
Basically the King is saying that educated people are harder to control .
@@rishavkumar1250 great thought i like it. Thank you for telling me
Congratulations for doing this episode. I am an avid follower but have never commented. However, this is too close to my heart to let it pass.
In my opinion this issue should not be taken only with reference to the present report. As a teacher and author who has been observing the changes for the past 28 years, many points need to be considered and resolved in tandem to bring about a positive change. Though not exhaustive, here is a list of some problems and remedies:
1) Teaching should not be considered as a last career option by meritorious students. If it is made competetive and lucrative, it will attract excellence.
2) Excellence should not be judged by marks alone but also include evaluation of behavioural skills.
3) The no detention policy has led to dilution of excellence, complacency in students and disarming teachers. Several batches of children have passed out without basic knowledge.
4) Accountability of teachers with respect to the results may also have triggered unfair practices.
5) The role of parents in upholding values and methods taught in school is also important. What is taught in school should not get undone at home and vice versa.
6) There is immense need for investment in infrastructure of schools. Unless all facilities are provided, recognition should be reviewed.
7) The strength of classes is too high for even the most sincere teachers to do justice to each child. Better infrastructure and hiring regular teachers should be helpful.
8) Teachers should be actively involved in making changes to policies regarding education, as they are the ones who can judge whether they can be implemented or not.
9) Additional duties unrelated to teaching given to educators hinders their motivation and efficiency.
10) Very importantly, people who genuinely have a passion for the profession and can practice what they preach, should become teachers.
dar isse nahi lagta ki desh kab aage badhe ga.. dar isse lagta hai ki aapka content kabhi niche na chala jaii... dil chuu liya aaj ki baat sun kar ... keep uploading ... love youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
i m working at an rural educational institution and can say that each and every word u are telling is a fact
thanks akash sir this needs to change just enrolling is not enough
teachers are responsible but they have to face many difficulties and pressure of upper people as well
I fully support you DADA!!✊🏼
To whom you support he's like another pappu
@@safariboy8933what's your age? And why are you saying like that? Like just eloborate
Eyes opening video !! Subscribed !!
Thank you bhaiya ❣️❣️
Your points are as clear as transparent glass.... I've no idea what happened to our people.......
Keep working on it sir....
I am from Odisha, our High school teacher recruitment came after 4,5 years, in which almost 25,26k vacancy filled with 3 stages within 6,7 months with urgency..There was no minimum qualifing mark, SC,ST cutoff was in single digit out of 100... Situation is like 1 post per 1.5 candidates available... If such quality teachers got posting in High school that is matriculation, then think about our Quality of education one student will get in our Govt High school.. Last few years our School infrastructure is improving at a rapid pace in Odisha,but quality teacher is absent in our schools...Now a days almost 80pc Students are going to Intermediate college after passing matriculation but the main issue is quality of education they are getting...
0.6 thila 😂😂.....
Actually. Quota teachers are worst in Odisha.
Follow the AAP model of education.
Only caste entitled people would say something like that .people like who discriminate will ensure reservations, thanks to you.youa re forgetting, upper castes hindus do believe in more superstitious and propaganda of government in India.so called upper castes hindus are teaching religion in iit bhu .
You are living in a country where in villages which is 70 percent of India is feudal and discriminate on caste and religious basis and deliberately don't teach students from oppressed caste and marginalized backgrounds.
Hey AB! Good one! Politicians normally thrive on social engineering models, one of the not so popular one being keeping the population busy to make their ends meet- so that they seldom have time to raise questions as they keep moving from one existential crisis to another!
We support you DB we need people like you !! 🇮🇳
Politicians wanted the people to be uneducated and not question them on anything but blindly believe and vote .
In 2022,Haryana Govt. Distribute tabs to students of 10th and 12th standard and its affect is very bad. students became addicted to social media and they do misuse of internet access.
Well guess when you try to do the hybrid system it blows up in your face I guess we also need to tech students to not do this bullshit or if that not possible because people don't really like bi binded by rules so restrict social media access om govt tablets I guess they can do that
I am a student of class BA ..and I am saying this report is absolutely right sir ..
I am a tuition teacher for Class 9 students from a village. The students can't read anything or understand what they are reading.
Quality of education has gone down drastically. I work in an organization which recruits people from all over India. I have seen that people lack basic skills such as comprehension or writing.
Majak krra bhai bs
I don't know what profile or what industry you're hiring from, but I don't think the heart of lack of education is to be seen in the cities and the size of population impacted because of it mostly live outside the cities.
Unless you are suggesting you're hiring from rural areas.
@@blingbling2841 Hiring for IT freshers.
I think it is high time to transform primary education into Montessori method of learning. The present primary education system in India is outdated and is killing the curiosity of children by the time they reach secondary education.
Bro Start preparation of Upsc or Start Thinking like A Education minister Kud pta chal jayega Kyu hame jis education system me hai wohi thik hai Bachhe Humans hai robots ya fir ai nhi ki sab kuch store hota rhe Samjke kya rakha hai 😡 Skill ki baat krne wale ye bhul jate hai ki bade hoke Khana kya khayege Etc Jo important hai uspe dhyan do Faltu Chiz ki wajah se hi aaj esa hota hai Or To or Agar Kisi bachhe ko koi topic nhi aarha to Uski ek hi galti ki usne revision nhi kiya Agar tum Us, Russia, japan jaisi country se India ko compare kararhe ho To Tum se bade Nich soch wale or koi nhi poverty, unemployment Vagare sab chiz pe bhi focus kro and Agar koi company bolti hai ki yaha ke workers skilled nhi hai to Company ko ujadke fekne ki jarurt hai Pahle To skill will ka itna jyada culture nhi tha aaj kal company ek dusri company Ko dekh dekh kar desh ko chush rhi hai i hope Government ban Some business man and Some company because College me tum sab shik jate ho jo life me kam aaye
@@Bholedsoza I understand your pain and I also have gone through the same education system and it is not right. If you need more clarity you can watch " Dark Reality of Indian Education system" on Dhruv Rathee's youtube channel. He has explained it so beautifully.
@@BholedsozaTob vai,batao jobs kaise milegi agar skill na ho. Trade Schools are needed. Welding, Electrician, Fitters aise jobs bahar ke countries mein bohut popular hain. Padhe likhe log bhi aise jobs karte hain. Yaha to bas competitive exams, govt. jobs aur social status chalta hain.
Skills ke liye pay karti hain Companies. Problem ye hain ki, har cheez bohut unsustainable tareeke se ban rahi hain. Har cheez 5-6 saal mein change. This is why people are finding it hard to upskill & adapt. This is the grey area where we need to fill the gap. Skills chahiye but upskilling should be sustainable.
Hello Akash sir, I'm from Chhattisgarh ( North Bastar) always watching your informative videos and this not just a report it's a reality of our Rural India especially here in 'Bastar' where I can see the clear difference between the students of 'South Bastar and North Bastar' ( not comparing )and my elder Sister who is a teacher in South Bastar region more than 16 years has always told me about the ground reality of South Bastar's education and how and why the system has failed over there just for votes and their sakes.
And I'm requesting to you please make a video on ' HASDEO BACHO' protest.
Thank you.
Not just in rural India… I live Delhi, I work in an NGO called CRY, and I teach them. They don’t know how to read and write who are in 5th-6th class and one girl was in 8th class who doesn’t know ABCD and 1-20 counting numbers. Some of them go to government schools in Delhi. I would like to ask which government schools in Delhi are giving good quality education? Only 4-5 in posh areas of Delhi. I teach in slum areas. What about those government schools?
So true... as I am a student myself in 10th... quality of teachers nowdays is getting worse...some new teachers joining in my school and others as well are like... some of us 10th students know better than them... and even in my batch there are students who could not read and do basic maths because of some teachers who don't pay attention to them becuase they think as Everybody goes to tuition they can learn there.
Everybody says to students how do you don't even know this but "jab tak sikhaoge nhi toa kaise aayega!?"
Even me, although I can speak, talk and write proper english but I cannot speak in front of stage because of my stage fear, I tried to participate in events to get rid of this fear but the teachers...rather than teaching us they choose the best same students every year to show the glory of school ...😔
Now education is not a sacred work or about teaching but a business🥲
You exposed the reality. Good job 👏
As an UPSC student, your every video is working as a revision video, especially education, health, unemployment, and government schemes. If I say it in layman's terms, you are doing a tremendous job. In your recent video, you discuss obligarchy government with Dr. Raghuram Rajan, which is really concerning.
Being a tution teacher I have alot students of classes 1 to 10 most of the students are not able to read Hindi English is way more far not able to calculate in mathematics not even able to analyse anything between 6th to 10th classes...........and graduate level students also not able to read it's very dangerous for our country................do something government
That's why 49 teachers in west Bengal refused to join rural schools . (They are passionate about money not for teaching profession b)
Govt should give good salaries and more incentives for teachers opting rural areas. After all it is a job, a profession they have chosen to earn their living, not social service.
@@trevorgtals IITs and IIMs? Where? BJP MP said in Parliament no new ones have been built so far. Aap ka sapna hai kya? In fact in states like UP govt schools are closing down. Be a bhakt not andhbhakt.
@@humanbeing6838 yes the atleast they must be professionals or have passion for teaching, they were given a decent salary yet don't choose and the seats remained vacant. The students were the victims. A possible solution is to recruit local people to the school in rural india that could solve the salary problem
@@humanbeing6838 thank you for your opinion
@@soumodippaul1235 just like you have a choice to work somewhere.. Teachers do have a choice...
Absolutely correct, I am a teacher of govt higher secondary school , and I face the same thing from students, after completing x+ students can't read english passages and don't know basic maths.
नमस्कार सर💐🙏
बच्चें पढ़ नहीं पाये समझ में आता है, लेकिन क्यों नहीं पढ़ पाये?? क्या हमने इस पर विचार किया
और इनकी कमजोरी दूर करने के बजाये हम इन्हें अगली क्लास में क्यों भेज रहे है?
क्या हम मूल समस्या को जानने का प्रयास कर भी रहे है या नहीं??
💐🙏
As a private teacher,I can confirm that Indian education system is at the worst situation right now ( specially the Goverment schools,unimaginable ).
Government should focus on the quality education rathar than devolapment of school buildings.
as a government teacher i have shared this vedio in my WhatsApp status.
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
This is very important video for every Indians.
You sir!!...aree BRILLIANT,
the topic selection itself is very vital 👍🏻
It was also rightly mentioned by Raghuram Rajan in his recent book Breaking the Mould. Most of the students in elementary school have lost the track during COVID. Imagine sitting idle for 2 years and then asking the students to learn.
You speak the real truth sir about our educational system.
And amazing thing is that political parties don't want to develop it 😔
What a searing reality check! Thank you, Akash!
Great video with valid questions..Hats off to Deshbhakt🙏
Same things happening in my Village -ek 15 saal ka larke ko main bola bike kitni km chali hain (170000 km chali thi ) ab larke ye digit nahi bol paya uske dost log bhi nahi bol paye 7-8 boys sabhi 10th class me hai.
A complete topic is very important, and explained well. Salute you 🙏
Love from Kerala ❤❤❤,for being a sincere journalist and showing the real issues to people .
BJP SDPI set 0 kerala people 🧠💯
Milestones which india is definitely going to cross-
5 trillion dollars GDP by 2027
10 trillion dollars GDP by 2033
20 trillion dollars GDP by 2040
28 trillion dollars GDP by 2047.
But we should also remember that China already has a 19 trillion dollars GDP and US with 1/4th of India's population has a massive GDP of 28 trillion dollars as of 2024.
India has a long way to go, and that also with great resilience and determination
5 trillion by 2027
10T by 2038
20T by 2055
28T by 2063
@@vedants.vispute77 don't you know about compounding? banarjee is right, we have a lot of uneducated people in India
@afridisahid07 in nominal, yes india is $100 behind Bangladesh in per capita but in PPP terms, India is still 1000 dollars ahead of Bangladesh.
And India is a pretty big diverse country, you can't compare it with your homogeneous Bangladesh
@oof9420 yeah like Bangladesh is any better in terms of religion. Atleast minority percentage does not decrease in India. From 23% in 1951 to 7% in 2023.
@@Gustav_fringe If you think we can quadruple our economy from 5T to 20T in 13 years, then keep your compounding knowledge to yourself. China was 5T in 2009, its still not 20T.. And that with the china speed.. I hope you are much more educated than me, only 1st year IITB mechanical
I am a teacher as well as a student...and I can assure you that this is all true.....these days students of class XI and XII find calculations tough like multiplication of decimal numbers, 1^8 , remembering values of sin 30, cos 45, tan 30 ...etc...and it's an alarming state for our economy.
Yes naman but some teachers waste time gossiping and don't teach properly in schools but they do in their private tutions
I don't remember many things.. You don't need to.. You got machines... Instead, we should focus on how to use those things.. Problem-solving..
I too don't remember the value of cos 45 or sin 47 etc.. I used to remember them in school days but now the values are present in my tab which I plug in the software to give result..
Government is 'now' introducing Maths and Science in Madarsa ...i wonder why it wasn't done in last 70 years
PM was right 😅 in cloudy weather signals got weaker due to dense cloud for any kind of radar be it surveillance or tracking
Good job deshbhakt for presenting this report in such a easy and amazing way Hat's off to you and your team ❤❤
Being a Politician is a career. They all are there to line their pockets. They don't care about us.
Exactly...
Salute sir, for focusing on issues plaguing india's development. It is because of the social media and efforts of creators like you we are getting to what is eyewash and what is real need for the development of country.
It's very disheartening to see the state of education in our country. We indians truly believe we are the best and the brightest in the world but in reality we are one the worst countries in the world when it comes to social indicators.
Vote for AAP
I was an officer in one of the central government departments. But quit in 2017. One thing I would definitely agree, if the govt’s machinery want to execute a project. Trust me it gets executed no matter how big the project is. But if they don’t want to it will never get done.
Why did you quit?
Indian people are not able to think on these kind of questions....Katju told this in 2012....😊😊😊🤗🤗🤗
Your video I used to watch without fail... I agree with you... Education quality is a must for the future .
I agree to each and every word you said in the video.
My mom is professor in B.ed collage and and the students who come for enrollment at the time of admissions many of them don't even know what their subjects were. And few of my cousins living in rural area have the same condition.
Sir Nice Explanation Apki Videos Bohat Informative and Eye opening Hote hain Thank you for your all Efforts 🙌❤️
Well explained ❤😊
My mother was a government teacher in Rajasthan and has retired last year. I have been visiting all the schools she taught in and here’s a list of problems I observed, funding and corruption ( most schools don’t even have enough classrooms, there are no chairs or tables, kids sit on floor atop some rag), teachers are given many other wasteful tasks beyond teaching that is taking a lot of their time, household conditions of a lot these kids are dire therefore they work with their families
There’s also a huge impact of social conditioning
गजब sir अपने देश को आईना दिखा दिया है
Ur doing a great job brother .When the current national media outlets are becoming a joke we the people should come forward and question the wrongs .