I see the problem with photography, even though it has its benefits, harm can’t be denied! we witness pilgrims harming other pilgrims with their cell phone smart phone cameras, making pictures and videos while they’re in Hajj and umra and elsewhere May Allah reward this great scholar for his knowledge
Well Shaykh Al-Uthaymeen ( may Allaah has mercy on his soul ) had a different opinion regarding taking pictures with cameras. He said what is prohibited is to edit those pictures on programs to change Allāh creation. But if there’s not alterations of those pictures then it’s ok since cameras are just capturing the image that has being created by Allāh subhanahu wa ta’ala and Allāhu a’alam.
the word 'tawsir' in the hadith is about drawing pictures of living things or sculpting statues, it's totally different from photography, if video recording and mirrors are permissible then photography should be the same, you make an exact copy of a thing when you take a picture of it, you don't create anything with skills, and allaah knows best, and may he grant sheikh bin baaz firdaus.
So can we keep my grandfather's photograph in my house for his memory... I knew prophet has prohibited that also.. The word used there also is tasweer... So is it only for drwn pictures or for any photo? Can u clarify?
Like our Sheikh Ibn Baaz (rahimahullah) said: “It is not permissible to picture people whether with their consent or without their consent; and if it is with their consent then the sin is greater. And pictures with souls in them are prohibited, because the Messenger of Allah (Sal Allahu aliyhi wa sallam) cursed the picture makers”
“Those who say that photography is permitted have “frozen” the meaning of the word “tasweer,” restriciting it only to the meaning known at the time of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and not adding the meaning of photography, which is “tasweer” or “picture-making” in every sense - linguistic, legal, and in its harmful effects, and as is clear from the definition mentioned above. Years ago, I said to one of them, By the same token (way), you could allow idols which have not been carved but have been made by pressing a button on some machine that turns out idols by the dozen. What do you say to that?” (Aadaab al-Zafaaf by al-Albaani, p. 38)
@Awais Javed There are principles... Like guns didn't exist but killing someone with a gun is still impermissible. Likewise, a cigarette may not have existed in the time of the prophet ﷺ but smoking is still impermissible.
@@awaisjaved1402 Assalamu alaikum brother please write the salutation of the prophet (peace be upon him/sallahu alayhi wasallam) in full rather than abbreviating jn order to fulfill the obligation
Sheikh Albani Rahimahullah already said "I fear that (Believers) one day would say, Photography isn't picture making,you just press a button " ...And That's what today's youth seems to be
He said he used to be against videos of him being taken but realised because the videos are beneficial for people to learn from his lectures then he allowed it to be ok to happen but if it’s necessary then it’s should be avoided because you don’t wana be punished for it
You got a point! But he said that he approves now of videography which implies even photography when done for the common good. The point to ponder about is the digital nature of photography as against the physical drawing.
Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim Peace be upon the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wa sallam,his family and companions. Assalamualaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu. Some useful adhkars to recite everyday InshaAllah. 1)Allahumma ajirna minan nar (asking Allah for protection from hellfire)× 3 Times. 2)Allahumma inni as alukal jannah,and Allahumma azhkilni Jannat il firdaus(asking Allah for paradise)× 3 times 3) Sallallahu ala sayyidina Muhammad (durood) 4)Allahumma Innaka Afuwwun Tuhibbul Afwa Fa'fu Annee.(O Allah You are the most forgiving,You love to forgive,so forgive me.) 5) SubhanAllahi wabihamdihi SubhanAllahil azeem 6) SubhanAllahi walhamdulillahi wa la ilaha illallahu Allahu akbar. 7) Allahu akbar 8) SubhanAllah 9) Alhamdulillah 10)La ilaha illallah 11) Astaghfirullah 12)Hasbun Allahu wa ni'mal wakeel. 13) Bismillahi Tawakkaltu alallah wa la hawla wala quwata illa billah (when getting out of the house using the right foot) 14)La hawla wala quwata illa billah. 15) Allahumma inni auzubika minal barasi wal junooni wal juzami wa min sayy-il asqam.(Dua for seeking Allah's protection against all illnesses including coronovirus) Alhamdulillah, MashaAllah,Thank you very much for reading,Jazak Allahu Khairan, AllahHafez. May Allah bless, guide and protect us all,ameen.
If I understand well it means that when I want to watch lectures it is permissible because it’s for the greater good, to learn science... But if it’s for something else, besides passports and all the paperwork, it’s not permissible.
What if I just take photos of myself on apps like Snapchat but it can only be viewed by me? Will I still be sinning? Or am I considered a picture maker?
@@ابوآسيةالسويسري nah im being deadass. It's not like I'm flaunting myself or putting my pictures in public for people to view and save. I keep them as memories or reminders for myself to look back at in the future or wtvr.
I Respect Him allot, But actually the pictures and camera was never existed at the time of Prophet PBUH, it was just Sketching which was prohibited. But Alhamdulillah now the Scholars have understood and no one Object any more. May Allah Bless him with Jannah, we have to understand that he was also Human being and he can have his own understanding. The Pictures are Completely allowed in Islam with or without special case. JAZAKALLAH
Such a great scholar he was Alhamdulillah...May Allah protect us from the fitna of photography
Amin ya rabb
Aameen... Allahumma aameen.
Akhi you have a picture on you comment 🤣
@@abx6539 La hawla ve la kuwata illa billah🤣
Allah peace. and mercy on Shaikh
Allahuakbar, may Allah grant him mercy and make us among the successful ones.
assalamu alikum , just some advice, you should not use faces or pictures with living creatures
Bārak Allāhu Fīkum for the beneficial video. May Allāh aza wa jal make it heavy on your scales of good deeds
I see the problem with photography, even though it has its benefits, harm can’t be denied! we witness pilgrims harming other pilgrims with their cell phone smart phone cameras, making pictures and videos while they’re in Hajj and umra and elsewhere May Allah reward this great scholar for his knowledge
Not to mention the self amazement aspect and how it stirs up the nafs.
What a scholar ma shaa Allah may Allah guide you and give you jannatul firdause
آمین
The correct view is that taking photographs is not permissible, general evidence is in this direction.
Well Shaykh Al-Uthaymeen ( may Allaah has mercy on his soul ) had a different opinion regarding taking pictures with cameras. He said what is prohibited is to edit those pictures on programs to change Allāh creation. But if there’s not alterations of those pictures then it’s ok since cameras are just capturing the image that has being created by Allāh subhanahu wa ta’ala and Allāhu a’alam.
Shaykh Uthaymeen also said it's not permissible to take pictures for memories sake e.g. hanging pictures on the wall and selfies.
the word 'tawsir' in the hadith is about drawing pictures of living things or sculpting statues, it's totally different from photography, if video recording and mirrors are permissible then photography should be the same, you make an exact copy of a thing when you take a picture of it, you don't create anything with skills, and allaah knows best, and may he grant sheikh bin baaz firdaus.
So can we keep my grandfather's photograph in my house for his memory... I knew prophet has prohibited that also.. The word used there also is tasweer... So is it only for drwn pictures or for any photo? Can u clarify?
@@ramsheedabootty3648 Bismillah. I think U already know the answer. Photo is Picture.
Like our Sheikh Ibn Baaz (rahimahullah) said:
“It is not permissible to picture people whether with their consent or without their consent; and if it is with their consent then the sin is greater. And pictures with souls in them are prohibited, because the Messenger of Allah (Sal Allahu aliyhi wa sallam) cursed the picture makers”
“I fear that Salafiyoon one day will say- Photography isn’t picture making. You just press a button.” [Silsilat ul Huda wan Nur 393]
“Those who say that photography is permitted have “frozen” the meaning of the word “tasweer,” restriciting it only to the meaning known at the time of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and not adding the meaning of photography, which is “tasweer” or “picture-making” in every sense - linguistic, legal, and in its harmful effects, and as is clear from the definition mentioned above. Years ago, I said to one of them, By the same token (way), you could allow idols which have not been carved but have been made by pressing a button on some machine that turns out idols by the dozen. What do you say to that?” (Aadaab al-Zafaaf by al-Albaani, p. 38)
What if a person argues that digital photography is not "making" an image, rather it is just "capturing" what is already physically there.
It comes in 2-D photography which he mentions. So better to avoid unnecessary digital photography.
Exactly, The Camera and Pictures not even there in the Time of Prophet PBUH, it was Just Sketching which was prohibited not Pictures for sure.
@Awais Javed There are principles... Like guns didn't exist but killing someone with a gun is still impermissible. Likewise, a cigarette may not have existed in the time of the prophet ﷺ but smoking is still impermissible.
@@awaisjaved1402 Assalamu alaikum brother please write the salutation of the prophet (peace be upon him/sallahu alayhi wasallam) in full rather than abbreviating jn order to fulfill the obligation
Sheikh Albani Rahimahullah already said "I fear that (Believers) one day would say, Photography isn't picture making,you just press a button " ...And That's what today's youth seems to be
Jazakallah
Can someone please clarify the current stance as of today about recording videos in regards to islamic lectures?
JazaakAllahu khayr. Do you have any more fataawa on this ikhwa. BaarakAllahu feekum
But videos like this video are just a series of images that are cut together. Please someone clarify for me.
He said he used to be against videos of him being taken but realised because the videos are beneficial for people to learn from his lectures then he allowed it to be ok to happen but if it’s necessary then it’s should be avoided because you don’t wana be punished for it
You got a point! But he said that he approves now of videography which implies even photography when done for the common good. The point to ponder about is the digital nature of photography as against the physical drawing.
also pictures are used for black magic another reason not to make pictures an evil person can use it
JazakAllah khair akhi that is a good point
Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim
Peace be upon the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wa sallam,his family and companions.
Assalamualaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu.
Some useful adhkars to recite everyday InshaAllah.
1)Allahumma ajirna minan nar (asking Allah for protection from hellfire)× 3 Times.
2)Allahumma inni as alukal jannah,and Allahumma azhkilni Jannat il firdaus(asking Allah for paradise)× 3 times
3) Sallallahu ala sayyidina Muhammad (durood)
4)Allahumma Innaka Afuwwun Tuhibbul Afwa Fa'fu Annee.(O Allah You are the most forgiving,You love to forgive,so forgive me.)
5) SubhanAllahi wabihamdihi SubhanAllahil azeem
6) SubhanAllahi walhamdulillahi wa la ilaha illallahu Allahu akbar.
7) Allahu akbar
8) SubhanAllah
9) Alhamdulillah
10)La ilaha illallah
11) Astaghfirullah
12)Hasbun Allahu wa ni'mal wakeel.
13) Bismillahi Tawakkaltu alallah wa la hawla wala quwata illa billah (when getting out of the house using the right foot)
14)La hawla wala quwata illa billah.
15) Allahumma inni auzubika minal barasi wal junooni wal juzami wa min sayy-il asqam.(Dua for seeking Allah's protection against all illnesses including coronovirus)
Alhamdulillah, MashaAllah,Thank you very much for reading,Jazak Allahu Khairan, AllahHafez.
May Allah bless, guide and protect us all,ameen.
Jazakumullahu Khayran💜
@@amaaroh7366 wa jazakum
In other words, pictures and videos unnecessarily are haraam..
If I understand well it means that when I want to watch lectures it is permissible because it’s for the greater good, to learn science... But if it’s for something else, besides passports and all the paperwork, it’s not permissible.
Is taking photos for celebrations ok or not? Birthdays, marriages, graduation, family functions, etc?
@@kalebj7001 just a side point, birthdays are haram, straight up no debate. About photography I'm still not sure
Sheikh Rahimakallah
Please sir convert video language in Bangla
❤
Whose voice it is in starting.....
Sheikh Rabee' Al Madkhali (Hafidhahullahu Ta'ala)
السلام عليكم
هذا لجميع طلاب يحيى الحجري.
قال الامام مالك رحمه الله : «كلٌّ يؤخذ منه ويردُّ إلا صاحب هذا القبر» و أشار إلى قبر النبي ﷺ
So is taking unaltered digital pictures permissible?
What if I just take photos of myself on apps like Snapchat but it can only be viewed by me? Will I still be sinning? Or am I considered a picture maker?
is this a real question?
@@ابوآسيةالسويسري nah im being deadass. It's not like I'm flaunting myself or putting my pictures in public for people to view and save. I keep them as memories or reminders for myself to look back at in the future or wtvr.
@@RCKY-OHX yes its haram as per the view it's non benificial it's like saying I draw and keep it to my self may allah grant us jannah
@@dontinsultme4821 but it's so difficult to get rid of. I have some for specific reasons such as pre weight loss motivation and outfit inspiration etc
@@RCKY-OHX if it wasn't difficult it wouldn't have been called dunya it would have been called jannah
Making pictures as in drawing or fotografy/ making movies?
@Mohan Prince so no educational documentaries allowed ?
@@Scorpion-wv1hs allowed if it is benefit for muslim such as lecture about islam. Haram for others for business. Except for what syaikh said.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
What is the meaning of the intro?
و عليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
ruclips.net/video/SqD_mgiNocM/видео.html
Salaf and books are the difference between us (other “muslim sects”)
what about facetime with your mom ?
It is permitted then Allah knows the best
FaceTime is not a still image it’s like a mirror or like a reflection you would see of your yourself in water
So i mean just taking ur own picture on your phone is haram this one i don't think it's true
How is it any different from drawing a picture
@@eesakhan7837 very very big difference
@@ibrahimlamptey3627 may allah forgive you and me brother this life is short
Do you realize that he is saying that pictures are haram while in a video?
Dario Haruni he did talk about that if you watched the video
Please watch the whole thing before coming to conclusions.
Halal for spreading lecture of islam.
I Respect Him allot, But actually the pictures and camera was never existed at the time of Prophet PBUH, it was just Sketching which was prohibited.
But Alhamdulillah now the Scholars have understood and no one Object any more. May Allah Bless him with Jannah, we have to understand that he was also Human being and he can have his own understanding. The Pictures are Completely allowed in Islam with or without special case. JAZAKALLAH
What you just said is completely dangerous making something halal without proofing yourself
This is an incorrect dangerous statement
Istaghfurallah! Who are you to claim it’s allowed and even the scholars today haven’t allowed it they just allow it during Islamic lectures
@@MysticYusha shaikh uthaymeen oppinion
@@mohamedlibya9895 shaykh uthaymeen oppinion and shaikh Salih
I follow shaikh bin baz oppinion 🤗