Robin Slaps Carly

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025
  • Robin slaps Carly after she insults Robin about her HIV status. 12-28-05.

Комментарии • 242

  • @TrinityTwo
    @TrinityTwo 2 года назад +56

    Carly had no right to throw Robin’s HIV status in her face like that. That was foul even by her standards. Good to see Robin deliver that slap.

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly Год назад

      But would sason put up all they did with anyone else no way . Even Carly told sonny basically agreed he felt sorry for robin

    • @brynne77
      @brynne77 Год назад +4

      Well, Sonny shouldn't have said that. He should NEVER have pitied Robin. If anything , people should have pity for him for putting up with a psycho like Carly who he can't seem to resist.@@cscarly

    • @janetevis1735
      @janetevis1735 11 месяцев назад +3

      Robin is no saint. She's so judgemental

    • @joannreader3260
      @joannreader3260 7 месяцев назад

      Carly was a bitch she messed up everyone's life

    • @TheloniousJackson
      @TheloniousJackson День назад

      @@janetevis1735compared to Carly she is

  • @tjnyc
    @tjnyc 2 года назад +58

    I love how unbothered Robin is after smacking Carly. 🤣

  • @boilerboy
    @boilerboy 12 лет назад +49

    'Takes one to know one.' That was a good line for Patrick.

  • @bubblezzxxd15
    @bubblezzxxd15 11 лет назад +83

    Carly talking about her HIV was a low blow, even for Carly

    • @williamparker5351
      @williamparker5351 3 года назад +15

      nothings off the table for carly

    • @neetrab
      @neetrab 3 года назад +7

      @@williamparker5351 exactly. And Cujo should be in jail anyway, if we're being honest.

    • @jeffreybokhari6772
      @jeffreybokhari6772 3 года назад +14

      Carly To This Day Is A Mean And Hateful Person And Doesn’t Have A Good Heart And Cares About No One But Herself And Is Very Selfish

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly 3 года назад +5

      Robin thrown carly illness her face . carly didnt leave her baby in snow

    • @Granger15
      @Granger15 3 года назад +3

      @Misty Waters,, I agree. That was completely disgusting.

  • @batwoman4487
    @batwoman4487 8 лет назад +86

    I loved Patrick's comment to Carly take one to know one. Carly did deserve that slap.

    • @finas12000
      @finas12000 7 лет назад +14

      She sure did. I wouldn't be friends with anyone on the show..they are all screwed up....lol

    • @stompbaddess1772
      @stompbaddess1772 4 года назад +2

      She sure did deserve that.

    • @stompbaddess1772
      @stompbaddess1772 4 года назад +7

      @@finas12000 No lie they all are.

    • @jenniferfields7113
      @jenniferfields7113 3 года назад +7

      Robin slap the shit out of Carly.lol

  • @kueen7538
    @kueen7538 Год назад +4

    Robin gave Carly behind the slap she should have given her years ago. It was about time!

  • @aprilmoses8303
    @aprilmoses8303 11 месяцев назад +4

    I think that Carly deserved to be slap, by Robin because Carly was saying cruel hurtful words to Robin.
    Carly doesn't care that she is so awful to Robin.

  • @armaa1000
    @armaa1000 13 лет назад +28

    in my opinion robin is 1000% more a better person than carly

  • @monuorah
    @monuorah 14 лет назад +22

    Carly: She's a bitch
    Patrick: I think it takes one to know one.
    Go Patrick!

  • @talonlove23
    @talonlove23 13 лет назад +17

    I love Carly and Robin but Carly deserved that! Ever since I started watching this show, when I hear people talk about HIV like that, I'm like, WTF. Carly just went way to far here.

  • @madbrowniac7871
    @madbrowniac7871 Год назад +4

    They even throw hands during The Christmas Season! And "Carly" practically stays on the um "Non Nice" List.😂🤣😂🎤💃🥊🎅🏻🤶📺B.W.

  • @cheesyman195
    @cheesyman195 12 лет назад +27

    I hope they bring robin back so robin can slap carly again

  • @GiovannaHI
    @GiovannaHI Год назад +10

    Robin looks good in this clip.

  • @TheLovely155
    @TheLovely155 13 лет назад +40

    Carly doesn't stand a chance in a fight against Robin. Can we say Anna and Robert's daughter

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly 3 года назад +3

      Lol robin walked all over

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +1

      No the writer's made it this way, Carly should've whupped her ass years ago. Robin needs to mind her own damn business

    • @DesireeBoone
      @DesireeBoone 5 месяцев назад +2

      Only because patrick intervened, so carly insulted robin, but robin has insulted carly too. She calls carly a hateful person, but she loves sonny and jason who launder money and kill people ok

  • @generalhospitalfans
    @generalhospitalfans 12 лет назад +31

    good job robin slap carly again

    • @Whyducry
      @Whyducry 5 лет назад +6

      And again... and again!

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +3

      Robin only slapped her after the word sex was mentioned. Robin insulted her, so carly gave her a taste of her own medicine

  • @ahjiyahzameriah616
    @ahjiyahzameriah616 9 лет назад +18

    i think that jason mind was like a child , and robin taught him how to love, and he fell in love with her a deep love,,but yet and still he got mixed up with the nightmare of his life, and he did know really how to take her, carly, used herself as long as he took her so she figured out a way to keep him under her thumb.because he used what other people say to learn everything he knew,,she really trapped him, lost the love of his life , and he did not think twice about it, he did not deserve robin, think about it the man was strange, robin was better off without him in her life.

  • @Marqjis
    @Marqjis 10 лет назад +70

    I love carly but the HIV thing was a lowblow

    • @rhondathompson6942
      @rhondathompson6942 3 года назад +10

      why you love carly she ruins everyone in her way

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +3

      I wish carly would've punched robin, because carly is right, robin does nothing but judge people playing the HIV card. Robin slaps carly but when Tony kidnapped her and michael, and she almost died, it didn't bother her in the least. Then she condemns carly but she loves sonny and jason who are mobsters.

    • @TrinityTwo
      @TrinityTwo 2 года назад +4

      @@desireeboone3631 that might be true, but she never married one, which is more than we can say about Carly.

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 Год назад +2

      ​@@TrinityTwo yes that because when robin told AJ that was Michael's biological father Jason dumped her. So if Carly were to launder money and kill will she then gets robins approval?

  • @jorydwilliams-negron59
    @jorydwilliams-negron59 3 года назад +6

    I love Robin. "I can't deal with you or who I become when I'm around you." That's one classy bad bitch. Carly can't ever get on her level.

  • @jordanreadsalot
    @jordanreadsalot 14 лет назад +24

    i love that slap go Robin

  • @dereka79
    @dereka79 8 лет назад +52

    Carly is disgusting for throwing Robin's HIV status in her face. I stopped liking Carly after SB left the role.

    • @jordanreadsalot
      @jordanreadsalot 6 лет назад +7

      why? SB's Carly was just as rude and hateful and self righteous as laura Wrights portrayal or Tamara portrayal of Carly they each brought something amazing and powerful to the role i mean remember the whole thing when Sarah played the role and she had an ongoing feud with her own mother which involved carly seducing Tony and stuff i think all the women have done a great i'm leaving Jennifer bransford who took over for Tamara when she left cause jennifer as Carly she was horrid and she looked to similar to Nancy aka alexis

  • @DMJ9012
    @DMJ9012 13 лет назад +20

    Out of everyone in PC it always seemed as if Robin was the only one besides Sam who could buck up with Carly & get the best of her. lol I loved their arguements for that reason alone.

    • @timothymoore6341
      @timothymoore6341 7 лет назад +8

      Brenda is another one that is an enemy of Carly.

    • @TrinityTwo
      @TrinityTwo 2 года назад +7

      Add Brenda and maybe Tracy to that list.

    • @TheLuscious
      @TheLuscious 2 года назад +7

      You forgot Brenda. Brenda ran circles around Carly

    • @angiechambless1092
      @angiechambless1092 Год назад +3

      Emily didn't back down either, and slapped her good!

    • @whiteshell1
      @whiteshell1 3 месяца назад +2

      And Elizabeth back when SB was Carly. They had some good fights

  • @redpia215
    @redpia215 8 месяцев назад +1

    If it had ACTUALLY been about AJ knowing the truth, Robin would have told AJ, when she found out. IT WAS NOT ABOUT THE TRUTH. Robin was fine living with Jason and raising Michael together. It was Carly ruining Robin’s plans to have a family with Jason. That is why Robin told AJ. Plain and simple.

  • @JaxxStarr81
    @JaxxStarr81 2 года назад +9

    This is one satisfying slap! Robin needs to return and slap Carly again, and again, and again!

    • @renealexander2703
      @renealexander2703 2 года назад +1

      Why? Robin loves Patrick and she and Carly respect each other. Carly saved Robin's life. They should be friends.

    • @Viewer92136
      @Viewer92136 2 года назад +3

      @@renealexander2703 Carly isn't friends with anyone unless it benefits her, Joss, or Michael.

  • @lindadowns4193
    @lindadowns4193 6 лет назад +22

    Don't Apologise Own It Robin. Tell her Patrick 👍

  • @MyDymin
    @MyDymin Год назад +4

    Lil Robin slap the ISH out her, I love it! C**** is such a BULLY!

  • @Whyducry
    @Whyducry 5 лет назад +10

    Robin please slap Carly again and again and again and again. Can’t stand the character of Carly. Never have never will.

    • @neetrab
      @neetrab 3 года назад +3

      Perfectly said!

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +1

      Well Robin should've minded her own business, carly is right, because she is judgmental, but since she is HIV positive who is she to judge anyone when she apprantly made a bad judgment herself.

    • @Whyducry
      @Whyducry 2 года назад

      Ya … not a good argument to plant your flag on.

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +1

      @@Whyducry Well who doesn't know that Robin is HIV positive, she slaps carly but Tony kidnapped her and michael, she left him off the hook. It was no big deal to her. The hell with Robin

    • @Whyducry
      @Whyducry 2 года назад +1

      Still not a good look for you to plant your flag on and if I was standing there I’d slap Carly too. This was one of her most vile moments and she’s had a lot. I’m surprised the writers went there and I’m even more surprised you as a viewer would even support this.

  • @sa5772
    @sa5772 2 года назад +5

    Carly was the one lying about her kid’s paternity and robin ruined her son’s life? I like more these days atleast she has more logic.

  • @druler65
    @druler65 14 лет назад +3

    Man five years goes by quick! I love their dynamic on the show!

  • @katjamendez
    @katjamendez 14 лет назад +7

    TEAM ROBIN!!! i love to hate the *original* carly character, but laura wright plays her so flat and one-dimensionally. she screams in every scenes. i do like when laura's carly has a soft scene... it's like a breath of fresh air, but mostly she's a waste of screen time. kim mccullough is a fine, nuanced actress. team kim as well!!

  • @Ashleyludwig901
    @Ashleyludwig901 Год назад +1

    Robin always talks about her hiv like she is the only person who has it I’ve been watching Chicago med and they have hiv patients

  • @neetrab
    @neetrab 14 лет назад +14

    HAHA!!! "No wonder Sonny won't take you back"..LOL! "Sonny got fed up with your insanity. So you can think that this..NEW IMPROVED version of Carly that you're trying to sell is gonna fly? You're in for a rude awakening" LOL! - go Robin!!

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +2

      Robin needs to shut the hell up and mind her damn business. That's how this feud started because it wasn't her place to tell AJ that he was Michael's biological father. Robin being HIV OBVIOUSLY made a poor judgement herself, so she has no right to judge other people. Robin was jealous of carly, she just makes me sick

  • @JustMegan
    @JustMegan Год назад +6

    I can't stand Carly! She destroyed J&R and they never got a second chance. Which is a shame. SB and KM have fantastic chemistry. I miss seeing them together on screen

    • @DesireeBoone
      @DesireeBoone 5 месяцев назад +1

      No jason dumped robin for telling aj the truth, he expected loyalty and she betrayed him.

    • @JustMegan
      @JustMegan 5 месяцев назад

      @DesireeBoone I know why he dumped her, but Carly became a wedge between the pair before she ever told AJ the truth.

    • @DesireeBoone
      @DesireeBoone 5 месяцев назад

      @@JustMegan no they broke up after robin told Jason that she told a j that he was Michael's biological father. Then afterwards she thought that jason was going to cut carly out of his life, but instead her dumped her. I don't understand why robin was always judging carly, when she made a very very poor judgment herself taking a man's word that she was safe with him, no you still use condoms

  • @lisamckinney3991
    @lisamckinney3991 Месяц назад

    Love me some Robin. I am so glad they never recasted her.

  • @jennel802009
    @jennel802009 14 лет назад +7

    I have always liked Robin, too. Her and Brenda are my two favorite female characters on here. Of course, my favorite male characters are Sonny and Jason. Oh yeah, and now Dante. Dante is so HOT!!!

  • @kaitykaity
    @kaitykaity 9 месяцев назад +3

    Pwincess Wobin lost Jason because she took it upon herself to tell a truth that wasn’t hers to tell , betraying him and breaking his heart. Her selective morality didn’t save her.

  • @ahseeuh
    @ahseeuh 6 лет назад +26

    Carly should’ve left when Tamara Braun left. The writers ruined her afterwards. Laura’s Carly is just a big looming bully. I have zero empathy for her.

    • @luismigueldjdhsjsusususidi8775
      @luismigueldjdhsjsusususidi8775 6 лет назад +4

      Ahseeuh s

    • @jacobyoungbauer4521
      @jacobyoungbauer4521 6 лет назад +4

      I've always liked Carly up until the last year and half because of how her and sonny treat Ava and think they are better then her. The writers are ruining many of the characters

    • @qvxcswqr
      @qvxcswqr 3 года назад +4

      carly is supposed to be a controversial character, you either love or you hate her and laura wright pulls off carly pretty well

    • @Viewer92136
      @Viewer92136 3 года назад +2

      I have always been sad that the character of Tony Jones was vilified and ruined for the character of Carly Roberts Benson Whatever.

  • @neetrab
    @neetrab 13 лет назад +19

    I have NO idea why Robin even apologized for slapping Cujo. I would've punched her, myself.

  • @ThrillsofColdplay
    @ThrillsofColdplay 3 месяца назад +1

    Slaps don’t occur anymore on this show

  • @PintheDog
    @PintheDog 13 лет назад +5

    Was this how Patrick found out about Robin's HIV?

  • @starweavernation
    @starweavernation 7 месяцев назад +1

    Carly is so jealous, hateful, selfish, pretentious... OMG she never changed, from then til now, HATE Carly LOVE Robin

  • @criticwatcher
    @criticwatcher 2 года назад +4

    Carly's the hypocrite who thinks she's better than everyone else. Especially in the new episodes.

    • @isaiahhill2104
      @isaiahhill2104 2 года назад +2

      Truth! And you can’t forget Sonny and Jason. Apparently everyone must be decent but them smh.

  • @lindadowns230
    @lindadowns230 Год назад +3

    Best thing Robin Ever Did😂

  • @DMJ9012
    @DMJ9012 12 лет назад +17

    A delusional Carly fan, why am I not surprised... Even Carly had to admit that she was always wrong about Robin, but funny nobody ever admits that they were wrong about Carly's venomous attitude?

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly 3 года назад

      Different carly and robin is robin puts robin needs first where carly puts everyone else even if breaks her heart love scene michael and carly and sonny during carly breakdown

  • @neetrab
    @neetrab 13 лет назад +7

    @CHRISTIANABUSED - Seriously, why is she still thinking that Robin is "jealous" of her because of Jason??? She hasn't wanted Jason for how many years now?? Even when she was arguing with Robin at Kelly's a couple of weeks ago, she brings up the SAME thing. Her being jealous of her and Jason...LOL!! She doesn't get it... she doesn't realize that Robin has actually moved on and she didn't realize that Robin is HAPPILY MARRIED with children.. She acts like Robin can't hate her for other reasons.

  • @kevonslims7269
    @kevonslims7269 Год назад +4

    Patrick and Carly would’ve been good together..

  • @NeishaD21
    @NeishaD21 11 лет назад +7

    And because Courtney was Sonny's sister and she wanted to keep Sonny.

  • @brinkgrl
    @brinkgrl 4 года назад +4

    I never liked either of these two. Carly is selfish and wants Sonny & Jason all to herself even if she’s with someone else. And in always thought Robin did feel like she was better than everyone else, always lecturing people. But Carly had not right throwing the HIV card in Robin’s face. In turn, Robin should have brought up Tony!

    • @qvxcswqr
      @qvxcswqr 3 года назад +4

      carly has literally always been obsessed with sonny and jason lmao

    • @neetrab
      @neetrab 3 года назад +2

      @@qvxcswqr exactly. The wench was barely in port charles b4 she knew those 2 jokers.

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +1

      Well when Tony kidnapped Robin and Michael, it didn't bother robin, she gave him a free pass, I only wish that carly would've shot the both of them

    • @DesireeBoone
      @DesireeBoone 5 месяцев назад

      Yes Tony who kidnapped herself and Michael, and she could've died from it but that didn't seem to bother her at all. Carly had every right to loathe robin because she always making judgments on people when she clearly made a BAD judgement herself. You never take. man's word that he is disease free. You always wear a condom.

  • @PintheDog
    @PintheDog 13 лет назад +4

    @ocd4lane This kinda makes the fact that he still regularly spends time with Carly all the worse.

  • @Horacejr2000
    @Horacejr2000 9 месяцев назад +1

    don't mess with Robin

  • @kevindavis296
    @kevindavis296 6 лет назад +3

    Carly's bad back then.

  • @DMJ9012
    @DMJ9012 12 лет назад +14

    Yeah Carly's adorable with venomous attitude. Carly could never get the best of Robin & could never understand her friendship with Sonny & Jason, two men she has always staked her claim into. Carly, THE BITCH, knows her place when it comes to Robin & its scum, that's why she tries so hard to tear her down.

    • @angiechambless1092
      @angiechambless1092 Год назад +2

      The thing of it is. Robin was well liked, and loved by most. She showed compassion, and friendship. Carly was a royal B to any female, except Courtney, when it came to Jason or Sonny. She was jealous of Robin, Elizabeth, Sam, Brenda, Emily, and Kate. She played on the men, especially Jason to feel sorry for her. She cheated on Jason, Sonny and Jax. She accused good women of being hypocrites because of deep jealously. She is not a good person.

  • @jad8123
    @jad8123 Год назад

    Jason Thompson looks so different here. The hair, the face…everything. That said, I’m not sure why. Maybe, because he’s older or he lost a lot weight. Which is weird because it’s not like he was heavy either. I can’t put my finger on it.

  • @westracermj118
    @westracermj118 11 лет назад +8

    laura wright's carly makes the carly-robin feud better, she and kimberly mccullough look great as enemies

  • @neysarascona8512
    @neysarascona8512 12 лет назад +5

    yea robin

  • @Popfan93
    @Popfan93 14 лет назад +3

    @Nadia0200
    Carly never got along with Robin since since she got preggo with Michael and Jason claimed to be the father. At the time Jason and Robin were together and sort of raised Michael and Carly moved in with them.
    The big thing that happened was Robin found out Jason wasn't the father and that A.J. was and told A.J.
    Carly never forgave Robin for that. It didn't help that Carly and Jax had Nikolas kid "john" who was Spencer and tried to raise him, Robin found out and told Nikolas as well.

    • @zozobear320
      @zozobear320 Год назад +1

      Robin and Carly didn't like each other long before Carly got pregnant.

  • @bikegoiooie98
    @bikegoiooie98 11 лет назад +6

    My favorite seen between Robin and Carly.

    • @d3fault95
      @d3fault95 4 года назад

      No carly vs. Sam was good

  • @MaureenKoscinski
    @MaureenKoscinski День назад

    Funny how this clip doesn't show how nasty Robin was to Carly before this

  • @BehindTheHarleyShop
    @BehindTheHarleyShop 12 лет назад +4

    So ok is Carly "in love" with Jason, Like at one point did she want to be with him like married and havinga family? I kow she says their best friends but I don't know she' relies so much on him that I think maybe she would be happy if he would confess his love for her and make her his wif.

  • @bombay3201
    @bombay3201 Год назад +1

    Is this Saint carly?

  • @dvafosho
    @dvafosho 13 лет назад +2

    @PintheDog I know right!

  • @dinahwestallen
    @dinahwestallen 6 месяцев назад +1

    Team Robin always..Carly is garbage

  • @PintheDog
    @PintheDog 13 лет назад +2

    @ocd4lane Wow. Worst possible way for him to find out.

  • @TheloniousJackson
    @TheloniousJackson День назад

    This clip isn’t the original. Certain Lines Carly said aren’t on this clip

  • @SharonHoyne
    @SharonHoyne 2 месяца назад

    Robin grew up in the town not Carly she came to town to get revenge on her birth mother Bobbie. Long past due to get rid of boring Carly & Sonny

  • @muertos2975
    @muertos2975 6 лет назад +3

    jeeze how many woman slaps carly lol first robin then sam and monica

  • @stingerfan30
    @stingerfan30 10 месяцев назад +1

    Carly is all talk and no action. She thinks she's tough but she isn't. As soon as Patrick held her back she get all let's go Robin! Please. LW's version of Carly never sat right with me

  • @heddalee
    @heddalee 11 лет назад +4

    she did seem to like Courtney. exception to the rule...

  • @rhondathompson6942
    @rhondathompson6942 3 года назад +6

    brenda need to come back to gh to replace carly

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +1

      What for so she could wear another wire on sonny

    • @rhondathompson6942
      @rhondathompson6942 2 года назад +1

      @@desireeboone3631 That crap was years ago at least my girl Brenda didn't sleep with her mom husband

    • @desireeboone3631
      @desireeboone3631 2 года назад +1

      @@rhondathompson6942 Brenda wearing a wire was not crap, just look at the clip. He was beyond furious and threw her ass out. Well Carly slept with Tony, but her mother forgave her. It's just like when carly was suspicious of hannah and she was right, she turned out to be a FED. To me that is more of a betrayal, than having an affair

    • @rhondathompson6942
      @rhondathompson6942 2 года назад

      @@desireeboone3631 Didn't that sank Carly just slept with jaxs in sonnys bed besides Brenda brings ratings

    • @isaiahhill2104
      @isaiahhill2104 2 года назад +1

      @@desireeboone3631 Carly literally turned Sonny into the FBI in 2001, which was the reason SJB left the role and TB came on (allegedly).

  • @LifeIsNotorious
    @LifeIsNotorious 12 лет назад +4

    Just about everybody got slapped on this soap lol.

  • @Nadia0200
    @Nadia0200 14 лет назад +3

    I know that this is out of the blues but, I started to watch gh, oltl and amc 6 years ago when i was 4. I dont know why Carly and Robin hate each other. Can someone Please fill me in?

  • @cscarly
    @cscarly Год назад

    Love that you see why sason put Robin away carly they knew she stayed carly kill her especially after aj killed her baby who gave power Robin did .

  • @UT5000
    @UT5000 12 лет назад +2

    do u kno wut happned here in this scene , like why ?

  • @CHRISTINAX990
    @CHRISTINAX990 13 лет назад +2

    @neetrab Carly should realize why all these other females hate her. Good acting by Carly though.

  • @maddieramsell
    @maddieramsell 13 лет назад +3

    Wow it seems like everyone takes advantage of Jason and Carly either slaps, or gets slapped for it!

  • @greenlee7smythe
    @greenlee7smythe 11 лет назад +3

    true

  • @dvafosho
    @dvafosho 13 лет назад +1

    @PintheDog Yes

  • @Horacejr2000
    @Horacejr2000 3 года назад +1

    Oh shit

  • @markc-ru4qz
    @markc-ru4qz Год назад +2

    Laura Wright has always bugged me so it was good to see her get slapped! God I hated her on Guiding Light !

  • @armaa1000
    @armaa1000 13 лет назад +2

    @saadoucha2011 cuz im a gurl of ma word i said i wasnt gonna curs at u no more cuz u eh in ma league...but i c u eh have friends..so i go leave u with dat. but mayhave to reply...so i wont curse at u no more u 2 clean fi me kk.

  • @christerry1611
    @christerry1611 Год назад

    Karen Corinthos Spencer Benson Roberts

  • @waltnolfa
    @waltnolfa 14 лет назад +2

    Robin had a chance to leave - why didn't she just walk away? I know Carly was wrong here but I don't like to see Robin getting physical - It was dissapointing...

  • @DoubleAgents
    @DoubleAgents 9 лет назад +3

    Snarly is fierce.

    • @rhondathompson6942
      @rhondathompson6942 3 года назад +1

      yeah right making comment about someone hiv she sucks

  • @saadoucha2011
    @saadoucha2011 13 лет назад +1

    @armaa1000 you need an literacy

  • @cscarly
    @cscarly 11 лет назад +2

    women feels no remorse didn't care she killed a child or not long she beat carly where carly always put child first . We spose like robin over carly what universe .
    Woman well had carly blood and Emily blood spilled all over her

    • @PintheDog
      @PintheDog 7 лет назад +11

      +et wee I don't understand a word you're saying. Please don't post until you learn how to post some sense.

    • @rhondathompson6942
      @rhondathompson6942 3 года назад +4

      dont post til you know gh history robin never killed a child

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly 3 года назад +1

      @@rhondathompson6942
      She handed spencer straight to helena knowing nothing about courtney and carly relationship

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly 3 года назад +1

      @@rhondathompson6942 then she tells nik i made a mistake because Spencer could been killed . he doesnt know he alive because of carly

  • @DearestLover09
    @DearestLover09 9 лет назад +6

    Yeah, the HIV thing was a low blow, but Carly has every single right to hate Robin. As much as I do have a soft spot in my heart for Robin, I would hate her too if she did to me what she did to Carly.

    • @lexi219
      @lexi219 9 лет назад +13

      +Cheyenne Bonnick Ehh but Carly hated Robin before the whole Michael reveal because Jason loved Robin and didn't want to be with Carly. And Carly did keep Michael away from his father under the false pretenses of it being in Michael's best interest. She did the same thing with Spencer years later - keeping him away from his father because it suited her agenda. Carly just wants to assert control over these children's lives and got upset that she didn't succeed, so she takes it out on Robin.

    • @DearestLover09
      @DearestLover09 9 лет назад +2

      lexi219 Carly hates everyone that Jason is with, so in that regard, Robin is not special. Of course Carly would be mad at Robin because she was with Jason if she herself wanted him, but keep in mind that even though Jason didn't want to be romantic with Carly, he was still devoted to her and Robin knew that and was jealous as well. That's why she did what she did. It wasn't because AJ had a right to know, it was out of pure spite and jealousy. And Carly was acting in Michael's best interest, or at least she truly thought she was. Michael is not Robin's child so she had no right to go against what Carly wanted for him, especially for vicious reasons.

    • @lexi219
      @lexi219 9 лет назад +7

      Cheyenne Bonnick
      But Robin did tell the truth about Michael bc she thought AJ had the right to know. Not only was AJ her friend, but throughout her run on the show, Robin has always been someone who values the truth. It's why she felt so awful when she realized that she was shutting Patrick out of their baby's life when she first found out she was pregnant. She told him over and over that she was so wrong for not telling him right away because she knew that the truth is so important and that a child shouldn't be kept away from its father.
      And while I agree that bc Michael is Carly's child, she should have say over his life than Robin, AJ was Michael's father and was being completely deprived of his child. Carly claimed that she was keeping Michael away out of his best interests, but that is absolute bs. Jason and Sonny are strong loving men and fantastic fathers, but she knew their lifestyle and how often they were shot at and how often the people around them were kidnapped, etc. from the get go. She just let her hormones and her dislike for AJ decide that her son was safer with mobsters than with him. I'm not saying AJ was perfect at all (he absolutely had his own issues), but Carly was thinking about herself while keeping him away from his child.

    • @lexi219
      @lexi219 9 лет назад +5

      Cheyenne Bonnick
      And I didn't say that Carly's hate for Robin was special - I just said that she hated her bc Jason loved her in a way that he never loved Carly. It's the same reason why Carly is always awful to Elizabeth and why she used to be so awful to Sam (whom she only became actually friendly towards when Jason died).

    • @DearestLover09
      @DearestLover09 9 лет назад +4

      lexi219
      I disagree. She hates Robin and especially Elizabeth not just because of Jason's love for them, but because they are hypocritical. They pull their shit, but talk about honesty and turn their noses down at others, especially that Elizabeth. It's one of the reasons Carly never got along with Alexis. And though she and Sam were never friendly until after Jason's death, she eventually rooted for Jason to be with Sam and encouraged their relationship. And she hated Sam because Sam slept with her husband, again a valid reason.
      As for Robin, I think it is BS to think that jealousy didn't play into her telling AJ about Michael's paternity. Because Jason did everything Carly needed and she was jealous of their relationship, she wanted to hurt Carly so she did. I know Robin cared a lot about truth and honesty, but she is human, and she was being spiteful in that moment.
      I don't know if you're a mother, but would you want your child to be raised by a man as effed up as AJ? Look at it from Carly's perspective. There's AJ, a "trust fund lush" to use her words, who has never taken responsibility for his actions and who crashed his own brother into a tree, causing irreparable damage and who treated her like garbage along with a family who treated her like garbage. Would you want your child in that situation? Then there's Jason. He was kind to her, helped her, supported her, loved her, all unconditionally. Yeah he did dangerous things for a living, but isn't the choice obvious? Abuse or love?
      As for Sonny, the ONLY reason he became Michael's father was because he got Carly pregnant and they ended up living together because of what was right for their baby. They just happened to fall in love. And When Jason saw how good Carly and Sonny were for each other, he wanted them to stay a family. Originally, Sonny was never meant to be Michael's father, but they made a mistake and fell in love and then what was she supposed to do? Again, abuse or love?
      I don't think Carly was right to take Michael completely away from AJ. I agree with you that a mother should never keep a child away from the father. It's why I will never forgive Alexis and will always be mad at Olivia. I even harbour feelings of anger towards Carly (I know, I am too intense about this show). But I can certainly see where these women were coming from.