Thanks Zack for the update, I would not of thought that the persecution of jews was so extensive in Russia down through the ages….Thanks for enlightening us,
Greatly detailed historical documentary regarding the unfortunate persecution and oppression of Jews in Russia, Zack. You must have spent a significant amount of time on this video. You are very talented and are on a great path forward.
Very extensively researched. I can see you put in a lot of work on this. I am very interested in hearing the circumstances of how you came to live in the Jewish Autonomous Region and your experiences there. Something to look forward to.
Thanks Zack, very informative. My Jewish grandparents (carpenters) lived near Vilnius, fleeing to London about 1904. They died long before I was born. All my father said was they were persecuted and moved to London for a better life. I now have a better understanding.
This historical documentary was just epic. The research done and the information presented is so very professional and valuable. You may have found your true calling! I am in awe of your work. Congratulations!
Hi Zack, thanks for your great research. This video awakens the history fan in me and reminds me of my love of history. This information you share is not taught in our western civilization classes or public schools so is valuable in helping us get a fuller history of Jews in Russia. It's a long video so I will have to watch it in parts, but thank you for reviving my enthusiasm for history.
ZtR, kudos for the comprehensive commentary. It is important because, the geopolitical conduct of Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, is a consequential extension of the history of the Jewish people in Russia.
We were Soviet Jews, and left USSR in 1989 and it was the best decision ever. After the collapse of USSR, almost 1.6-1.7 millions Soviet Jews left and emigrated from the former Soviet Union.
Thanks Zack, I believe that we should take lessons from history and never repeat the previous painful mistakes that only were leading to misery, suffering and deaths.
Hi Zach. Thanks for introducing this to our next generation of young adults. One community center in Pittsburgh had a “Save Soviet Jewry” sign throughout the 80’s and 90’s. I’m sure this was a nationwide campaign. You would do well to interview some of those Soviet Jews and their families. I met and worked with several of them. They have very moving stories.
This video included little-known, and somewhat surprising information about the Jews. For example, few people realize that 80% of the Jewish diaspora lived in the Russian Empire. 0:10
Thank you, from another Zack, for taking on such a dense topic! My great-grandfather Morris Salman, born near Utena, Lithuania, left with his parents for New York in 1912. I have a number of other relatives from that generation who left other parts of imperial Russia around that time. I am very interested in visiting Lithuania, and would also love to visit Ukraine and hopefully a future free Russia.
Russians ahead of the world to transport Jews on freight trains.....It's likely my great grandparents were "disappeared" to an unmarked grave in Transnistria that way, then made to dig their own mass grave, shot and dumped......And of course the graves were unmarked..... Truthfully, we don't know what became of them, they disappeared completely in 1937. My family lived in almost every place you mentioned in the Pale. This is part(the Nazi years are some of the other part) of why we say Never Again. This is beautifully done, Zack! Thanks you for such a detailed history. You're a mensch!!! I am posting the link in many places where I think there are people who need educating.
Interesting video. We all have to face the ugly parts in history of our native countries. So to learn how to avoid to repeat the same mistakes. I would love a video on the movements of people in the far East side of Russia. 😊
Thanks for this fast-paced, yet very informative documentary. I knew bits and pieces of this, but you have filled the holes in my knowledge of this. Much appreciated!
Very interesting video on Russian history and Jewish history. I hope you were able to get credit for it in one of your college classes. Please do more videos about Russian history whenever you have the time.
Thank you for this extensive overview about the Jewish history in Russia / USSR etc. within one hour only ! In fact I started to wonder now whether there might be a growing threat again for Jews in Russia as a consequence of increasing state-sponsored persecutions due to the perceived threat of the Jewish cosmopolitan culture with strong ties to other Jews in Western cultures, especially in the U.S. and also in Israel etc., similarly as it also happened under Stalin's rule and also because Putin is notably a great admirer of Stalin and both of them share a pathological increasing fear of conspiracies against them that culminate in blindly suspecting any jews of supposedly planning a revolt against them... ? Also the fact that Putin never condemned the terror by Hamas against Israeli citizens at least suggests that Putin himself is truly an Anti-Semite at his core-beliefs and might become yet even a full-blown Nazi similar to Hitler (some may even think that there is basically almost no difference anymore between Putin and Hitler)... 🤔
just imagine when Americans find out who is at the southern border L0Lz The History Of Ladino Ladino is a language that was developed by the Sephardic Jews of the Iberian Peninsula (modern-day Spain and Portugal). It’s hard to pinpoint when exactly the language came about, because the divisions between languages were not as rigid many centuries ago. During the 15th century, Sephardic Jews spoke the same Spanish as anyone else in the area. Ladino started as a dialect of Spanish, which was influenced by Portuguese, Hebrew, Aramaic and other languages spoken around the peninsula. This early spoken Ladino was mutually intelligible with Old Spanish for some indeterminate period of time. -The separation of Ladino and Spanish was really initiated by the expulsion of Jews from Spain, which was ordered by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella in 1492. Some Jews stayed and were assimilated into the Christian culture, while others scattered across Europe and North Africa, with many fleeing to the Ottoman Empire. It was this expulsion that really created the Sephardim, a name derived from the Hebrew word Sepharad, meaning “Spain.” -Upon reaching the Ottoman Empire, the Sephardim were now tasked with building new communities, and language was an important part of that. The people spoke a range of different dialects from the Iberian Peninsula, and so as the groups mixed, so too did these different ways of speaking. Over the following few centuries, Spanish and Ladino evolved separately, and so they ended up sounding pretty different. Ladino, for instance, kept the hard “f” sound at the beginning of the words fablar and fijo, which Spanish speakers started pronouncing as hablar and hijo. And as mentioned, the Ottoman Empire wasn’t the only place the Sephardim moved to, but it was one of the only places where enough moved to that it allowed for a robust community to form. -The clearest early differences between Spanish and Ladino were in the writing. For one, Ladino was written in the Rashi script, which is a cursive style sometimes used for Hebrew. This alone makes Ladino look very different from the other languages used on the Iberian Peninsula. The earliest Ladino writings are translations of Hebrew texts from the 18th century, which tried to maintain as much of the original Hebrew grammar as possible.
Great job! Extremely well researched and accurate. Also, you presentation and production are very professional. Keep making documentaries. You could be the next Ken Burns!
To be honest, the USSR's setting up of a 2nd Israel was really nonthing more than a relocation program. Removing them from parts of the USSR with the promise of freedom elsewhere. USSR had a long history of Population Transfer Programs which Ethnicity cleansed large regions of the Soviet Union by send undesirables east of the Euro Mountains. It would not have been much different to the early Nazi's plans of resettlement to solve their small hat person problem... before they well became more extreme on the subject.
My understanding is rather that all totalitarian rulers (regardless whether Nazis as Hitler or Soviets as Stalin) were very afraid of highly intelligent and educated people/cultures and therefore they wanted to have them as far as possible away from the powerful (capital) cities (be it relocated a few thousands of kilometers into the wilderness or simply eliminated)... At least with regard to some aspects the idiology of Nazis and Soviets was very similar... @@maxibon7556
PathD 🇺🇸 on another user account: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Outstanding Zack! I have learned so much about the evolution of Russian anti-Semitism from your video! I am not Jewish although my husband is. I was raised in a religion that, as teens, took us to visit multiple different religious faiths in order to accept and honor them and cherish our country's freedom of religion and a synagogue was one. I have never understood anti-Semitism in my heart and the more I learn the more I understand why their beautiful country is so precious for all! Thank you, young man! You are so brave and on an admirable path in your life! Keep up your accomplishments! Yes!! I would truly appreciate more historical videos from you! Again, I sincerely thank you! Slava Ukraini!! 💛💙🇺🇦
Thank You Zack. I'm a mixture of nationalities. My surname is GOUIN. The French added the silent N. So it's pronounced Goo-waa. GOUI finds it's origins in the Hebrew language, and the Hebrews were Jews. So I guess there is a little tiny bit of Jew deep inside me.✌️🗽
Great overview. Regarding the pogroms, in addition to destruction of property and murder, rapes were also prevelent. If you want more detailed discussions of these topics I highly recommend Henry Abramson and Sam Aranow.
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn gave all the hints and explanations why certain things happened in his book "200 years together". Yes I understand it is easier to watch a colorful video in which many things are (purposly) omitted, rather than to read over a 1000 pages book but lemmings should wake up, at least Mr . Solzhenitsyn spelled it out for everyone out there.
If you do not assimulate over hundreds of years, you are a foreigner. You have your own culture. Your own ways of living that outweigh the interest of the country you reside.
You have done a great research, and this is a good video, but the narrative of "Jewish victimhood" compared to other minority gropes is just incorrect and unfair! Slavery in Russia was somewhat abolished, only in 1861! Almost ALL people were peasants! They had no rights!
Please explain why there happens to be so many Semitic peoples supposedly from the holy land residing in Europe? They do not belong here yet are here in large numbers.
I wish the reader could read a bit slower...it is fantastic info on this history but you just kewp going as if its one long sentence. As of you reading against time. Thanks though for the fantastic material.
Thanks for this,I’m from Tennessee in the USa and I love the Russian culture,it’s so beautiful and is Americas true brother land from the west,once you figure out what the land looked like before the flood,the truth will be seen,we are the same and one land divided in 2…Dan Sheekoz is a friend of mine,southern Russia,north of the black sea.Hes just learning English.❤
There is no significant evidence of turkic genetic, linguistic or other cultural influences in Ashkenazi DNA & history and culture. There were Christian, Muslim and Jewish people in the Khazar Empire, not just Jewish. There are no turkic words/vocabulary, grammer in Yiddish, minimal Turkic DNA, clothing, dance, architecture,.... archeological evidence. After Middle Eastern we have Italian/Roman DNA. From the Italian peninsula some of us went North into Gail/French and Germanic lands still others continued west. After centuries the Ashkenazi Jews that went West went farther and farther east to the Rhineland. There is also archeological & genetic evidence to support this Ashkenazi Rhineland migration theory while there is none for the Ashkenazi Khazar migration theory.
@@Latvian07 my former neighbour grew up in Königsberg: she had a distinct accent and used expression (which were understandable but) nobody else used in the village. Unfortunately there is hardly anybody of this generation still alive.
It's complicated . Russian jews can have a love/ hate relationship with Russia not unlike other minorities within Russia and its former republics . Many jews acclimatized to the domininant faith ( orthodoxy) or the political nationalism whether under czars or as scientific socialists under communism. To get along they felt they had to go along to greater or lesser extents. However the central moscow government whether under czars or Stalin territorially paddocked them - here called pale of settlements . Freedom of travel restricted theoretically their economic and political powers was restricted . Often like in western euro states land ownership was often denied. These restricting laws caused migrations if allowed till this day. Anti semmitism was not solely a nazi facist belief system. " Cosmopolitanism " a mere euphemism for it. Moscow has played one religion off against another ditto nationalities . Muslims vs jews Christians vs Muslims see Dagestan and Armenia and Azerbaijan.
One thing to add though is that under USSR regime life was not a picnic, but there was an ability to physically survive and remain a member of society - unlike in Europe under Nazis. Lets not forget that both US Congress and British parlament closed the doors to Jewish immigration from Nazi Germany.
The Jews have greatly enriched the cultural fabric of Russia. That the Jews have been accused of the murder of the Royal Martyr St. Tsar Nicholas is regrettable. 'The Joys of Hebrew' Lewis Glinert, 1992 UOP, pg. 262 has in the entry 'Yimach Shemo' - 'May his name be blotted out,' the following exampled use of that phrase - "That portrait in the corner is of Tsar Nicholas, yimach shemo."
Being critical of Jews is not anti semitic, just like being critical of christians, Muslims, black, white, Asian people. be aware of people saying you cant talk about something.
You can be critical of Jewish individuals who do bad things. No one is telling you that all Jews are saints compared to other ethnicities. But rarely if ever are the people who scream “we’re just asking questions” are ever good faith and use a thin veil to cover their clearly antisemitic ideology and talking points.
@@bennygoodmanisgod No, You can be critical of groups too! how do you think the Mafia was taken down. was that anti Italian ? fuck everyone who hates free speech, and yes asking questions is healthy and those questions can sometimes make people feel attacked. because maybe theres something there.
@@natashka1982 criticizing the Holocaust is fine because history is filled with liars! A lot of people don't believe that happened the way they say it did! Because a lot of it doesn't add up! No I'm not saying I don't believe it happened! But there are a lot of things that don't add up! I think it's 12 questions that most people ask. Plus there has been genocides apart from that one In Ukraine under the Bolsheviks which killed about 10 million! Armenian genocide! Cambodian genocide! Rwanda genocide!
You shouldn't mix up Rus and "Russia". Rus is current Ukraine and Belarus. Jews could live there, although anti-Semitism undeniably did exist. Russia has nothing to do with Rus. That country was originally called Muscovy and officially Jews had not been allowed to live on its territory until World War One. Muscovy changed its name to justify grabbing Ukrainian and Belarus lands.
Roman amramovic olegi delipaska dimitri medvedev mihali fridman mihali zvetlov peter aven aleksander aleshkin viktory veksenlberg oligark jewish russia 2024
@@matthewsteele99 mate USA done worst crimes in history and still support crimes against humanity this fella is USA Israel simpatizer what Russia did to Israel,what Germany did to Israelis what now israel doing to Palestine , fool try to make with his vids like Russia is the worst country on his videos makin all anti russian videos no single one about Palestine and he talking about Jew history .
Subtitles available!
Thanks Zack for the update, I would not of thought that the persecution of jews was so extensive in Russia down through the ages….Thanks for enlightening us,
You need time stamps for your American viewers. Good video though. Thanks 👍
I find the subtitles annoying as they seem to be based on voice recognition so have errors in the selection of words.
"Reuters: Alexei Navalny, 47, has died suddenly - Kremlin: Putin has been informed
Alexei Navalny may have died suddenly."
@@מריםדיויסyou can switch them off: click cc
Thanks Zach! This is very informative.
Greatly detailed historical documentary regarding the unfortunate persecution and oppression of Jews in Russia, Zack. You must have spent a significant amount of time on this video. You are very talented and are on a great path forward.
well leaned wot ANTI-semitism is - we are yet to find out, wot SEMITISM is ???
Very extensively researched. I can see you put in a lot of work on this. I am very interested in hearing the circumstances of how you came to live in the Jewish Autonomous Region and your experiences there. Something to look forward to.
Me, too.
Thanks Zack, very informative. My Jewish grandparents (carpenters) lived near Vilnius, fleeing to London about 1904. They died long before I was born. All my father said was they were persecuted and moved to London for a better life. I now have a better understanding.
wow a realy interesting documentary!
Thank you Zack to doing this for us!
Very informative, I get the impression that you have put a lot of effort into this video.
I want to say thank you again for all the work you did on this. It means a lot to me.
This historical documentary was just epic. The research done and the information presented is so very professional and valuable. You may have found your true calling! I am in awe of your work. Congratulations!
Once again a wonderfully informative video! Good job, Zack!
Hi Zack, thanks for your great research. This video awakens the history fan in me and reminds me of my love of history. This information you share is not taught in our western civilization classes or public schools so is valuable in helping us get a fuller history of Jews in Russia. It's a long video so I will have to watch it in parts, but thank you for reviving my enthusiasm for history.
Thank you so much for this. Thoroughly enjoyed watching this young man. Keep up the good work, you're going to do wonderful things in your life.
Wow ! You put a lot of time into developing that video. Looking forward to hearing about your teenage years in a Jewish Oblast city.
Very interesting look at history not widely reported. Good video, graphics and clips. Best/Rob
ZtR, kudos for the comprehensive commentary. It is important because, the geopolitical conduct of Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, is a consequential extension of the history of the Jewish people in Russia.
Good stuff!
We were Soviet Jews, and left USSR in 1989 and it was the best decision ever. After the collapse of USSR, almost 1.6-1.7 millions Soviet Jews left and emigrated from the former Soviet Union.
i also hear it will happen with ships that are sinking
to germany ?
Good on you!
After you destroyed the country. This time y'all are destroying the US and the West!
@@marvin2678To USA, Israel and South America.
My grandpa's dad was a jewish, but luckily he was not sent to Salaspils concentration camp.
Thanks Zack, I believe that we should take lessons from history and never repeat the previous painful mistakes that only were leading to misery, suffering and deaths.
Wow! I am speechless; this is a gem! Outstanding work, Zack,
Great video,Zack! Thank you for that!
An impressive, monumental effort. Now we know where you've been recently.
Hi Zach. Thanks for introducing this to our next generation of young adults. One community center in Pittsburgh had a “Save Soviet Jewry” sign throughout the 80’s and 90’s. I’m sure this was a nationwide campaign.
You would do well to interview some of those Soviet Jews and their families. I met and worked with several of them. They have very moving stories.
Amazing reseach and work you put in to this .Was well worth the hour of listening and watching .
This video included little-known, and somewhat surprising information about the Jews. For example, few people realize that 80% of the Jewish diaspora lived in the Russian Empire. 0:10
Thank you. A fascinating documentary on something of which I know very little. I would like more like this.
Yes more of this kind of video thks
Excellent analysis. Thank you Zack 🙏💛
Important subject! Bookmarking the vid to watch later 📑 P.S. 0:28 - that B-roll feels very familiar, almost as if we've used it before 🤪
So well
Done Zach. Thank You so much for putting this together. This is such a valuable timeline of Jewish history.
Outstanding research. Well done zac
Thank you, from another Zack, for taking on such a dense topic! My great-grandfather Morris Salman, born near Utena, Lithuania, left with his parents for New York in 1912. I have a number of other relatives from that generation who left other parts of imperial Russia around that time. I am very interested in visiting Lithuania, and would also love to visit Ukraine and hopefully a future free Russia.
Amazing video.
Wonderful video. There is alot of research involved in this. I love this video!😊❤
Wow, Zack! What a video! Thank you so much! And keep going!
amazing documentary, thank you!
Russians ahead of the world to transport Jews on freight trains.....It's likely my great grandparents were "disappeared" to an unmarked grave in Transnistria that way, then made to dig their own mass grave, shot and dumped......And of course the graves were unmarked..... Truthfully, we don't know what became of them, they disappeared completely in 1937. My family lived in almost every place you mentioned in the Pale. This is part(the Nazi years are some of the other part) of why we say Never Again. This is beautifully done, Zack! Thanks you for such a detailed history. You're a mensch!!! I am posting the link in many places where I think there are people who need educating.
Zak Another good video Very infomative
Highly interesting and informative documentary!
Interesting video. We all have to face the ugly parts in history of our native countries. So to learn how to avoid to repeat the same mistakes. I would love a video on the movements of people in the far East side of Russia. 😊
Much obliged for this presentation.
Fantastic presentation
Every time I watch your video I learn something. I can’t help it.
Great info on the culture we in the west have no education on Russia & Jews over time! Thank You!
Thanks for this fast-paced, yet very informative documentary. I knew bits and pieces of this, but you have filled the holes in my knowledge of this. Much appreciated!
Very interesting video on Russian history and Jewish history. I hope you were able to get credit for it in one of your college classes. Please do more videos about Russian history whenever you have the time.
Thank you for this extensive overview about the Jewish history in Russia / USSR etc. within one hour only ! In fact I started to wonder now whether there might be a growing threat again for Jews in Russia as a consequence of increasing state-sponsored persecutions due to the perceived threat of the Jewish cosmopolitan culture with strong ties to other Jews in Western cultures, especially in the U.S. and also in Israel etc., similarly as it also happened under Stalin's rule and also because Putin is notably a great admirer of Stalin and both of them share a pathological increasing fear of conspiracies against them that culminate in blindly suspecting any jews of supposedly planning a revolt against them... ? Also the fact that Putin never condemned the terror by Hamas against Israeli citizens at least suggests that Putin himself is truly an Anti-Semite at his core-beliefs and might become yet even a full-blown Nazi similar to Hitler (some may even think that there is basically almost no difference anymore between Putin and Hitler)... 🤔
What wrong did those great Palestinian freedom fighters did? Fighting against land grabber ewws from Eastern Europe is a crime?
First thanks for the vid
Very nice Yiddish pronunciation! Thanks for this.
just imagine when Americans find out who is at the southern border L0Lz
The History Of Ladino
Ladino is a language that was developed by the Sephardic Jews of the Iberian Peninsula (modern-day Spain and Portugal). It’s hard to pinpoint when exactly the language came about, because the divisions between languages were not as rigid many centuries ago. During the 15th century, Sephardic Jews spoke the same Spanish as anyone else in the area. Ladino started as a dialect of Spanish, which was influenced by Portuguese, Hebrew, Aramaic and other languages spoken around the peninsula. This early spoken Ladino was mutually intelligible with Old Spanish for some indeterminate period of time.
-The separation of Ladino and Spanish was really initiated by the expulsion of Jews from Spain, which was ordered by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella in 1492. Some Jews stayed and were assimilated into the Christian culture, while others scattered across Europe and North Africa, with many fleeing to the Ottoman Empire. It was this expulsion that really created the Sephardim, a name derived from the Hebrew word Sepharad, meaning “Spain.”
-Upon reaching the Ottoman Empire, the Sephardim were now tasked with building new communities, and language was an important part of that. The people spoke a range of different dialects from the Iberian Peninsula, and so as the groups mixed, so too did these different ways of speaking. Over the following few centuries, Spanish and Ladino evolved separately, and so they ended up sounding pretty different. Ladino, for instance, kept the hard “f” sound at the beginning of the words fablar and fijo, which Spanish speakers started pronouncing as hablar and hijo. And as mentioned, the Ottoman Empire wasn’t the only place the Sephardim moved to, but it was one of the only places where enough moved to that it allowed for a robust community to form.
-The clearest early differences between Spanish and Ladino were in the writing. For one, Ladino was written in the Rashi script, which is a cursive style sometimes used for Hebrew. This alone makes Ladino look very different from the other languages used on the Iberian Peninsula. The earliest Ladino writings are translations of Hebrew texts from the 18th century, which tried to maintain as much of the original Hebrew grammar as possible.
Thank you, Zach
Looking forward to the next video on this theme
Great job! Extremely well researched and accurate. Also, you presentation and production are very professional. Keep making documentaries. You could be the next Ken Burns!
The soviets were great at taking away everybody's shit and putting it in storage. Especially the farmers. Poor farmers.
To be honest, the USSR's setting up of a 2nd Israel was really nonthing more than a relocation program. Removing them from parts of the USSR with the promise of freedom elsewhere. USSR had a long history of Population Transfer Programs which Ethnicity cleansed large regions of the Soviet Union by send undesirables east of the Euro Mountains.
It would not have been much different to the early Nazi's plans of resettlement to solve their small hat person problem... before they well became more extreme on the subject.
so.. the russians giving the jews a homeland is nazi. i see. maybe they should remove that place so it is not nazi anymore.
My understanding is rather that all totalitarian rulers (regardless whether Nazis as Hitler or Soviets as Stalin) were very afraid of highly intelligent and educated people/cultures and therefore they wanted to have them as far as possible away from the powerful (capital) cities (be it relocated a few thousands of kilometers into the wilderness or simply eliminated)... At least with regard to some aspects the idiology of Nazis and Soviets was very similar... @@maxibon7556
Excellent work!
PathD 🇺🇸 on another user account:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Outstanding Zack! I have learned so much about the evolution of Russian anti-Semitism from your video! I am not Jewish although my husband is. I was raised in a religion that, as teens, took us to visit multiple different religious faiths in order to accept and honor them and cherish our country's freedom of religion and a synagogue was one. I have never understood anti-Semitism in my heart and the more I learn the more I understand why their beautiful country is so precious for all! Thank you, young man! You are so brave and on an admirable path in your life! Keep up your accomplishments! Yes!! I would truly appreciate more historical videos from you! Again, I sincerely thank you!
Slava Ukraini!! 💛💙🇺🇦
wow, Russia antisemitism towards Jewish peoples is just terrible, makes me wonder about the Wagner group name.
One of the top leaders in Wagner is an avid neo-Nazi.
Exactly. Putin's nothing short from being the new Hitler. And it just makes him more absurdly cynical to claim he is "fighting Nazis" in Ukraine!
Does this video mention Solzhenitsyn and his book '200 Years Together'? I think the objective world has recognized his brilliance and integrity.
Thank You Zack. I'm a mixture of nationalities. My surname is GOUIN. The French added the silent N. So it's pronounced Goo-waa. GOUI finds it's origins in the Hebrew language, and the Hebrews were Jews. So I guess there is a little tiny bit of Jew deep inside me.✌️🗽
Great video. My family is Russian Jewish immigrants from Belarus came to the USA in 79
If they are from Belarus aren’t they Belarusian? Or maybe Polish
Glad to have y’all here 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
The pale of settlement is where my ancestors came from. They fled after jews started getting murdered in the pogroms.
stelts is actually shtetls..... rhymes with petals.....
Great overview. Regarding the pogroms, in addition to destruction of property and murder, rapes were also prevelent. If you want more detailed discussions of these topics I highly recommend Henry Abramson and Sam Aranow.
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn gave all the hints and explanations why certain things happened in his book "200 years together". Yes I understand it is easier to watch a colorful video in which many things are (purposly) omitted, rather than to read over a 1000 pages book but lemmings should wake up, at least Mr . Solzhenitsyn spelled it out for everyone out there.
26:46 it's Chişinău not Kishinev.
In Russian its Kishinyov
@natashka1982 and we should stop using ruzzian names for places ruzzia colonized.
@@lianagheorma92 I dont really care. Its history. Deal with it.
If you do not assimulate over hundreds of years, you are a foreigner. You have your own culture. Your own ways of living that outweigh the interest of the country you reside.
Eles querem por que querem que as pessoas aceitem ser exploradas por eles
Not all Jews followed Judaism, genius. Also, when the government didn't let Jews assimilate, how would they do it?
You have done a great research, and this is a good video, but the narrative of "Jewish victimhood" compared to other minority gropes is just incorrect and unfair!
Slavery in Russia was somewhat abolished, only in 1861! Almost ALL people were peasants! They had no rights!
My Jewish family came from Rostov. I shudder to think about the atrocities they witnessed in the Russian Empire.
Nothing they didn’t bring on themselves
Jesus Christ? Do you know him?
Please explain why there happens to be so many Semitic peoples supposedly from the holy land residing in Europe? They do not belong here yet are here in large numbers.
Please explain why so many muslims? Hmm
How many Jewish people stay in Russian federation after the Russian invasion in Ukraine?
Go and count.
About 170k still live in Russia, was around 200k when the war started
Everyone should read 200 лет вместе (200 years together) by Solzhenitsyn on the role of Jews in Russia
It’s hard to be jewish in russia!
Historically too
Please analise the: "Exclusive: Tucker Carlson Interviews Vladimir Putin" if you can. Thanks
I wish the reader could read a bit slower...it is fantastic info on this history but you just kewp going as if its one long sentence. As of you reading against time. Thanks though for the fantastic material.
Always what happened, but never why.
🤓🤓🤓☝🏻
درود بر تورات و درود بر یهودیان جهان
47:26 palestine helped the jews and this is what they get? bombed? smh
This was Jews not Arabs...
It is Jewish land not Arab Muslim land and Jews have every right to make decisions on that land.
Khazar empire
Thanks for this,I’m from Tennessee in the USa and I love the Russian culture,it’s so beautiful and is Americas true brother land from the west,once you figure out what the land looked like before the flood,the truth will be seen,we are the same and one land divided in 2…Dan Sheekoz is a friend of mine,southern Russia,north of the black sea.Hes just learning English.❤
There is no significant evidence of turkic genetic, linguistic or other cultural influences in Ashkenazi DNA & history and culture. There were Christian, Muslim and Jewish people in the Khazar Empire, not just Jewish.
There are no turkic words/vocabulary, grammer in Yiddish, minimal Turkic DNA, clothing, dance, architecture,.... archeological evidence.
After Middle Eastern we have Italian/Roman DNA. From the Italian peninsula some of us went North into Gail/French and Germanic lands still others continued west. After centuries the Ashkenazi Jews that went West went farther and farther east to the Rhineland. There is also archeological & genetic evidence to support this Ashkenazi Rhineland migration theory while there is none for the Ashkenazi Khazar migration theory.
My family moved to Australia at the turn of the century (late 1800’s)… I wonder why they chose somewhere so far away
I forgot what Alexander was close with the America's founder's🤔
the map of the partition of Poland show can't be quite acurate: Russia got the largest chunk and Prussia didn't extant into todays Lithuania.
How i wish Prussia existed today.. Prussian is like mix of Latvian and German
@@Latvian07 my former neighbour grew up in Königsberg: she had a distinct accent and used expression (which were understandable but) nobody else used in the village. Unfortunately there is hardly anybody of this generation still alive.
@@henningbartels6245Prussians were my Baltic brothers
It's complicated . Russian jews can have a love/ hate relationship with Russia not unlike other minorities within Russia and its former republics . Many jews acclimatized to the domininant faith ( orthodoxy) or the political nationalism whether under czars or as scientific socialists under communism. To get along they felt they had to go along to greater or lesser extents. However the central moscow government whether under czars or Stalin territorially paddocked them - here called pale of settlements . Freedom of travel restricted theoretically their economic and political powers was restricted . Often like in western euro states land ownership was often denied. These restricting laws caused migrations if allowed till this day. Anti semmitism was not solely a nazi facist belief system. " Cosmopolitanism " a mere euphemism for it. Moscow has played one religion off against another ditto nationalities . Muslims vs jews Christians vs Muslims see Dagestan and Armenia and Azerbaijan.
Victoria Nuland - Wiki early life.
One thing to add though is that under USSR regime life was not a picnic, but there was an ability to physically survive and remain a member of society - unlike in Europe under Nazis. Lets not forget that both US Congress and British parlament closed the doors to Jewish immigration from Nazi Germany.
Which country has the most prisoners 😂😂
The Jews have greatly enriched the cultural fabric of Russia.
That the Jews have been accused of the murder of the Royal Martyr St. Tsar Nicholas is regrettable.
'The Joys of Hebrew' Lewis Glinert, 1992 UOP, pg. 262 has in the entry 'Yimach Shemo' - 'May his name be blotted out,' the following exampled use of that phrase - "That portrait in the corner is of Tsar Nicholas, yimach shemo."
The Labeling of a Soul Due To Their Religion, A Child of Hashem Has No Labels, He Has DNA IN All Worldwide
Shtelt lol. It’s shtetl not shtelt
Being critical of Jews is not anti semitic, just like being critical of christians, Muslims, black, white, Asian people. be aware of people saying you cant talk about something.
You can be critical of Jewish individuals who do bad things. No one is telling you that all Jews are saints compared to other ethnicities. But rarely if ever are the people who scream “we’re just asking questions” are ever good faith and use a thin veil to cover their clearly antisemitic ideology and talking points.
@@bennygoodmanisgod No, You can be critical of groups too! how do you think the Mafia was taken down. was that anti Italian ? fuck everyone who hates free speech, and yes asking questions is healthy and those questions can sometimes make people feel attacked. because maybe theres something there.
@@davidjd123 Most of the Mafia was Jewish not Italian! Look it up!
So...is denying Holocaust or telling me its a good thing my family was killed just being critical?
@@natashka1982 criticizing the Holocaust is fine because history is filled with liars! A lot of people don't believe that happened the way they say it did! Because a lot of it doesn't add up! No I'm not saying I don't believe it happened! But there are a lot of things that don't add up! I think it's 12 questions that most people ask. Plus there has been genocides apart from that one In Ukraine under the Bolsheviks which killed about 10 million! Armenian genocide! Cambodian genocide! Rwanda genocide!
The khazar theory isn’t true.
He didn’t affirm it
Did any Jews die in that pogrom in 2023?
You shouldn't mix up Rus and "Russia". Rus is current Ukraine and Belarus. Jews could live there, although anti-Semitism undeniably did exist. Russia has nothing to do with Rus. That country was originally called Muscovy and officially Jews had not been allowed to live on its territory until World War One. Muscovy changed its name to justify grabbing Ukrainian and Belarus lands.
Germany, Soviet empire and now USA 😂😂
I'm Jewish and am doing fine in the US
В России у власти всегда были евреи
до совка не были
Rabbi Tovia Singer, anyone? 😅
Roman amramovic olegi delipaska dimitri medvedev mihali fridman mihali zvetlov peter aven aleksander aleshkin viktory veksenlberg oligark jewish russia 2024
What about history of usa dont make double standard they are most evil colonizators ,what about Palestine Usa history you too much Usa simpatizer .
Your comment does not make much sense. This video is about Russia not the US....
Don't troll around
@@renater.540 free speech American when i say USA i mean politcs they are just worse than Russian i write this cause i see alot USA simpatizers
what Palestine history? lol
@@matthewsteele99 mate USA done worst crimes in history and still support crimes against humanity this fella is USA Israel simpatizer what Russia did to Israel,what Germany did to Israelis what now israel doing to Palestine , fool try to make with his vids like Russia is the worst country on his videos makin all anti russian videos no single one about Palestine and he talking about Jew history .
@@matthewsteele99Мочам на сите американски поддржувачи кои ги одржуваат воените конфликти
bro i aint watching all that ahhaha