The chairman clearly knows his stuff. I've never seen the head of any space agency field such a barrage of technical questions with such ease. Good men bring good times.
What do you mean "head of any space agency" ?? You clearly have never watched NASA and ESA press briefings. Somanath is good and India is lucky to have such a good program manager of ISRO ..and ISRO is doing wonderful things.. but you obviously have never seen technical interviews of NASA scientist. Isro has learned everything from NASA.
@@SidSharma-d8p -- I've watched plenty of other agency briefings. I'm talking about the agency head -- the man in the top job. I think Bill Nelson is a very smart guy, but look at how deftly S Somanath breaks down the issues in the questions, and is able to put out cogent and coherent responses in realtime, replying in superb detail. The guy clearly knows his stuff. Just look at the depth and breadth of his knowledge.
Gareeb scientist take 12 top ka salam... Such a rich conversation. I was pissed off by that dumb youtuber.. you should get much more recognition man...more power to you..Gyan ki Gareebi sabse Bari😊 😊😊
@@GareebScientist Next time Just ask him why he has decreased the age limit from 35 to 28 in the recruiting process this time only😡😡😡😡 ....he has shattered many Engineering students dream...who ever has taken this decision... Karma will show you guys... Those all students heart are cursing those officers who have decided to do this.. . For General candidate... Only below 25-26 years of students can apply for scientists in barc, Npcil etc.... This is not Equality 😡😡😡😡😡😡😞😔😔 He has changed age limit this time... This is not done. 😡😡😡 This time vacancies were So many... And this man destroyed students dream... Already from last 4-5 years there were no vacancies after 2018😡😡😡😡 and suddenly he decreased age limit
I like the way that all aspects of ISRO is getting compared with spaceX and not NASA, that's what a compitition should be we should compair with the true competitor, Excellent job somanath sir and team
I agree. But the fact is most ppl on the Planet do not care about Space and have a hard time understanding Physics. So its a good thing to normalize a conversation so more ppl can understand. If more ppl on Earth understand the complexity of Space Science and Astro Physics and why its important ...more tax payers would be willing to fund a national program..whether it be Nasa or Isro.
Why Rocket science is Rocket science. . . N number of variables blending harmonically according to the needs and techinical limitations . . .Such a Rich and Technical Conversation. . . Dont ever stop making videos man. . ❤❤❤
As a SpaceX engineer I'm super impressed with what ISRO has accomplished. We always look at ISRO as our benchmark for $/kg launched. No one looks to India as a benchmark when it comes to science and technology. So it is quite astounding that ISRO has managed to break the mould with it's incredible breakthroughs and it's world-class engineers and scientists, Mr. S. Somanath included. Bravo, Gareeb Scientist!!
No doubt, ISRO operates efficiently when it comes to costing but I think price parity plays a big part in it. The labour cost, material cost, infrastructure cost, etc. are low in India as compared to Western countries.
@@kushagravlogs5627 Hardly! Chinese are good at copying, which is what they did. ISRO does tremendous innovation - referred to by us in SpaceX as "frugal innovation"
@@tm73827 India couldn't develop kerosine Or methane power engine till date. While many Chinese startups have developed kerosine or methane power engines. Landspace has developed 220+ tons methane power BR 20 engine similar to raptor engine of space x. While India has been developing SCE 200 engine ( copy of Ukrainian engine) since 2009. It is not ready till date. Many Chinese startups are going to launch reusable rocket in 2025. India is in a initial stage of developing methalox engine and rocket. India will take atleast 25 years to develop such rocket.
Good job GS 🎉🎉 We need such technical insight from DRDO Scientists also, hope some defence channel does it. More youth will be inspired and it will also be good pr for them.
bro here causally explaining aerodynamics like its a lecture. i love this. lets normalize such explanations please. Dont generalise it for the normies.
Just tell me why you have decreased the age from 35 to 28 in the recruiting process this time only😡😡😡😡 .... You have shattered many Engineering students dream...who ever has taken this decision... Karma will show you... Those all students heart are cursing those officers who have decided to do this.. . For General candidate... Only below 25-26 years of students can apply for scientists .... This is not Equality 😡😡😡😡😡😡😞😔😔 You have changed age limit this time... This is not done. 😡😡😡🤣 This time vacancies were So many... And you destroyed students dream... Already from last 4-5 years there were no vacancies after 2018😡😡😡😡 and suddenly you decrease age limit
Golden segment of the interview. I think Somnath sir and everyone in ISRO should be ready for the new wave of science curious folks asking basic physics questions and "spilling secrets". GS datey raho, hum tumhare saath hain!
Hearing the conversation and details, I know that if we could fund more to ISRO, we could very possibly do things like SpaceX. Although I am not comparing with it, we have tremendous capability from ISRO's point of view. It is just that funds are low, geo-location issues, and things like that. But when you listen to Somnath sir's dialogues, you know why he is the head of ISRO. He is a genius. Man, I wish we could arrange more funds for ISRO. Gareeb Scientist you rock man!
For those comparing Falcon 9’s cost-effectiveness: in the U.S., manufacturing and launch costs are high due to labor costs, making booster recovery a significant savings for SpaceX. While ISRO could benefit from recovering boosters, the savings wouldn’t be as substantial because manufacturing and labor costs in India are much lower, which keeps ISRO's launch costs cheaper than SpaceX, even with Falcon 9's reusability. However, developing reusable rockets would advance ISRO's engineering, inspire future generations, reduce ocean waste, and still provide some cost savings.
love the questions and love the answers. I am sure Somnath SIr must have loved the conversation. He must have felt like the knows what he is talking about and that makes this conversation two sided. brilliant work man!
Interesting engineering insights. Really secrets as Somnathji said.Excellent information.🎉 You could have used a closeup shot cropping all the distracting surroundings. Take care next time.❤
From a country of over a billion people, i hope we have more of these talks from our scientific greats. It sad that this is the only indian channel which is providing content about india this good. I hope you grow as good as veritasium and more. A lot of our people are working on really great stuff and if we have more of these platform to display their expertise. We could motivate more people in these fields. There is tedx india stuff, but i would prefer more technical interviews and documentaries.
Can you improve your podcasting setup? It would be great if you setup the cameras in such a way that it feels that you both are having a conversation; this setup doesn't justify the stature of hosting someone from reputed organizations such as ISRO currently.
Spring glass cravings upon silicon or remove silicon , spring = π , 3.14 - 0.1 = o , circle . Using D , 89 degree or 89.5 degree or 90 degree or 90.5 degree or 91 degree angle.
Isro should develop a more reliable and innovative booster recovery system better than spacex Example Instead of giving legs to land Give foldable wings along the body of booster Let it glide for that 600km back to launch pad reducing fuel cost, drone ship cost
The space sector does not operate in a vacuum. It is limited by the manufacturing technologies available in the country. The insight about not having equipment to make rings larger than 5.5 was a bit sad. It makes me realise that as a country, we need a MASSIVE MASSIVE thrust in manufacturing of all kinds, especially MACHINE TOOLS. Only then can ISRO achieve breakthroughs like SpaceX
I can understand your feelings. Even I was sad when Nasa retired the space shuttle. 15 years after that when I got an opportunity to visit USA I went to Smithsonian museum near Washington to see Space Shuttle Discovery.
Dang! Doing some of the landing/reusability tests while testing the abort system is a great move achieve dual objectives in the price of one. Would be interesting to see. Good catch and questions GS!
Just change the channel name from Gareeb scientist It is not a justified name for a lovely channel with amazing scientific information It also ends up creating a wrong impression
Mujhe lagta ye rocket 🚀 ka kam dusri Indian Private Space 🌌 companies ko dena chahiye . Jese agnikul he unko . Aur ISRO ko aur bhi bade kamo me lagana chahiye like nasa.
The problem with ISRO is that they try to copy recent trend from foreign country and spend couple of decades to achieve that technology but mean time that technology become old and absolute, Same things happened to India RLV programme, they tried to copy space shuttle technology. Now they are trying to copy SPACEX Falcon rocket technology. I am sure they will take atleast decade to get that technology and meantime this technology will become old. Hence ISRO should come with their own idea and innovation...
@@GareebScientistI reside in Sullurpet town, near Shar, I also aimed to work in SDSC like my uncles who work in Admin. I completed Aeronautical Engineer in Chennai, but I deviated from goal and now I am regretting.
Just tell me why you have decreased the age from 35 to 28 in the recruiting process this time only😡😡😡😡 .... You have shattered many Engineering students dream...who ever has taken this decision... Karma will show you... Those all students heart are cursing those officers who have decided to do this.. . For General candidate... Only below 25-26 years of students can apply for scientists .... This is not Equality 😡😡😡😡😡😡😞😔😔 You have changed age limit this time... This is not done. 😡😡😡🤣 This time vacancies were So many... And you destroyed students dream... Already from last 4-5 years there were no vacancies after 2018😡😡😡😡 and suddenly you decrease age limit
Paying him , ISRO chief earns more than 2 lacs combining him as his position as cabinet secretary ( highest position if you was an IAS ) , don’t worry bro
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
The chairman clearly knows his stuff. I've never seen the head of any space agency field such a barrage of technical questions with such ease.
Good men bring good times.
@@manofsan strong men bring good times
In ISRO the chairmen are scientists themselves unlike in other institutions who are either army personnel or bureaucrats.
What do you mean "head of any space agency" ?? You clearly have never watched NASA and ESA press briefings. Somanath is good and India is lucky to have such a good program manager of ISRO ..and ISRO is doing wonderful things.. but you obviously have never seen technical interviews of NASA scientist. Isro has learned everything from NASA.
@@SidSharma-d8p -- I've watched plenty of other agency briefings. I'm talking about the agency head -- the man in the top job. I think Bill Nelson is a very smart guy, but look at how deftly S Somanath breaks down the issues in the questions, and is able to put out cogent and coherent responses in realtime, replying in superb detail. The guy clearly knows his stuff. Just look at the depth and breadth of his knowledge.
@@manofsan Thats my point brother. He is the right person for the job. Isro needs massive funding. That is all im saying.
This is the most informative interview series ever of any ISRO Chairman. Stright to point questions. Kudos @Gareeb Scientist
Awesome, no beating around the bush, just straight answers
Gareeb scientist take 12 top ka salam... Such a rich conversation. I was pissed off by that dumb youtuber.. you should get much more recognition man...more power to you..Gyan ki Gareebi sabse Bari😊 😊😊
🙏🏻Hope so
@@GareebScientist Next time Just ask him why he has decreased the age limit from 35 to 28 in the recruiting process this time only😡😡😡😡 ....he has shattered many Engineering students dream...who ever has taken this decision... Karma will show you guys... Those all students heart are cursing those officers who have decided to do this..
. For General candidate... Only below 25-26 years of students can apply for scientists in barc, Npcil etc.... This is not Equality 😡😡😡😡😡😡😞😔😔
He has changed age limit this time... This is not done. 😡😡😡
This time vacancies were So many... And this man destroyed students dream... Already from last 4-5 years there were no vacancies after 2018😡😡😡😡 and suddenly he decreased age limit
@@समाचार-थ3झao you want 35-40 years old people coming into job with no good knowledge
The clarity in his voice is incredible!
I like the way that all aspects of ISRO is getting compared with spaceX and not NASA, that's what a compitition should be we should compair with the true competitor,
Excellent job somanath sir and team
I agree. But the fact is most ppl on the Planet do not care about Space and have a hard time understanding Physics. So its a good thing to normalize a conversation so more ppl can understand. If more ppl on Earth understand the complexity of Space Science and Astro Physics and why its important ...more tax payers would be willing to fund a national program..whether it be Nasa or Isro.
This is so informative... At least many who compare everything to SpaceX will understand why India choose its way... 😊
Wow very informative
ISRO has a bright future
Why Rocket science is Rocket science. . . N number of variables blending harmonically according to the needs and techinical limitations . . .Such a Rich and Technical Conversation. . . Dont ever stop making videos man. . ❤❤❤
As a SpaceX engineer I'm super impressed with what ISRO has accomplished. We always look at ISRO as our benchmark for $/kg launched. No one looks to India as a benchmark when it comes to science and technology. So it is quite astounding that ISRO has managed to break the mould with it's incredible breakthroughs and it's world-class engineers and scientists, Mr. S. Somanath included. Bravo, Gareeb Scientist!!
No doubt, ISRO operates efficiently when it comes to costing but I think price parity plays a big part in it. The labour cost, material cost, infrastructure cost, etc. are low in India as compared to Western countries.
Chinese space start ups are defeating ISRO in reusable, heavy payload , methane and kerosine power engine and rocket. ISRO is backward
@@kushagravlogs5627 Hardly! Chinese are good at copying, which is what they did. ISRO does tremendous innovation - referred to by us in SpaceX as "frugal innovation"
@@tm73827 India couldn't develop kerosine Or methane power engine till date. While many Chinese startups have developed kerosine or methane power engines.
Landspace has developed 220+ tons methane power BR 20 engine similar to raptor engine of space x. While India has been developing SCE 200 engine ( copy of Ukrainian engine) since 2009. It is not ready till date.
Many Chinese startups are going to launch reusable rocket in 2025. India is in a initial stage of developing methalox engine and rocket. India will take atleast 25 years to develop such rocket.
@@tm73827 Chinese are winning, copying is producing results, you cannot copy rocket technology by looking at videos. You are no SpaceX engineer.
Good job GS 🎉🎉
We need such technical insight from DRDO Scientists also, hope some defence channel does it. More youth will be inspired and it will also be good pr for them.
thankyou Somnath sir, for this.
bro here causally explaining aerodynamics like its a lecture. i love this. lets normalize such explanations please. Dont generalise it for the normies.
Full episode could have been better idea
Link is in the description for the full episode buddy.
🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭
Yes a full uncut version will be nice, some episodes were abruptly ended
Does he talk about Mangalyaan 2
Just tell me why you have decreased the age from 35 to 28 in the recruiting process this time only😡😡😡😡 .... You have shattered many Engineering students dream...who ever has taken this decision... Karma will show you... Those all students heart are cursing those officers who have decided to do this..
. For General candidate... Only below 25-26 years of students can apply for scientists .... This is not Equality 😡😡😡😡😡😡😞😔😔
You have changed age limit this time... This is not done. 😡😡😡🤣
This time vacancies were So many... And you destroyed students dream... Already from last 4-5 years there were no vacancies after 2018😡😡😡😡 and suddenly you decrease age limit
Really appreciate highly scientific and technical questions here rather than general stuffs. This is unique about this channel.
Like an excellent teacher Somnath sir explains. 🎉
Golden segment of the interview. I think Somnath sir and everyone in ISRO should be ready for the new wave of science curious folks asking basic physics questions and "spilling secrets". GS datey raho, hum tumhare saath hain!
Absolute masterpiece... Proud of our scientists...
Hearing the conversation and details, I know that if we could fund more to ISRO, we could very possibly do things like SpaceX. Although I am not comparing with it, we have tremendous capability from ISRO's point of view. It is just that funds are low, geo-location issues, and things like that. But when you listen to Somnath sir's dialogues, you know why he is the head of ISRO. He is a genius. Man, I wish we could arrange more funds for ISRO.
Gareeb Scientist you rock man!
For those comparing Falcon 9’s cost-effectiveness: in the U.S., manufacturing and launch costs are high due to labor costs, making booster recovery a significant savings for SpaceX. While ISRO could benefit from recovering boosters, the savings wouldn’t be as substantial because manufacturing and labor costs in India are much lower, which keeps ISRO's launch costs cheaper than SpaceX, even with Falcon 9's reusability. However, developing reusable rockets would advance ISRO's engineering, inspire future generations, reduce ocean waste, and still provide some cost savings.
9.29 min refers to load to thrust ratio which is varying as fuel is being burnt as also shedding of stages.
dear Gareeb scientist .. use good audio equipment ..hd camera ..give a good vibe. you half a million subscribers.
Look at the quality of content, not the quality of video. Gareeb for a reason. ;-)
love the questions and love the answers. I am sure Somnath SIr must have loved the conversation. He must have felt like the knows what he is talking about and that makes this conversation two sided. brilliant work man!
Happy Diwali 🎇🎇🎇
Shandar,and thank you G.S.
Reliable and reusable want to see landing rocket back to earth by isro ❤
Great work sir
Thanks for such video
JAI HIND SIR 🇮🇳 😊
Bro please make a conclusively video after that
Interesting engineering insights. Really secrets as Somnathji said.Excellent information.🎉 You could have used a closeup shot cropping all the distracting surroundings. Take care next time.❤
Give this man a long run and a bigger budget. He is a visionary leader.
I dont understand some terms being a defence nerd like the last part of admire, but i am glad isro is going towards reusablity
GS this is high value content, you could milk(long videos making) out proper videos with each of these interview sections ❤
Kya banda hai yaar....he knows his shit big time. Very happy to have seen this video! :) He should also teach students when he is done with ISRO.
samaj me kuch nahi aaya but sun ke acha laga
bro it will be better if you both take seat side by side like poadcast, they are so good to watch. the reaction, vibe
This is a very good explanation
From a country of over a billion people, i hope we have more of these talks from our scientific greats. It sad that this is the only indian channel which is providing content about india this good. I hope you grow as good as veritasium and more. A lot of our people are working on really great stuff and if we have more of these platform to display their expertise. We could motivate more people in these fields. There is tedx india stuff, but i would prefer more technical interviews and documentaries.
congrats❤❤❤❤ best interview on tech
Thank you so much sir 🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Very very informative video
I have a stealth drone design ready... How can I talk to HAL or another competent authority?
Just do email to hal 's official email ID
Or write official letter to hal
How did you analyze the rcs to claim its stealth?
Keep them coming
Good one, questions as well as simple answers like teaches explain!!
Love and support frim Rajasthan, i have land isro can use it for observatory purpose, it's gr8 to contribute to science 🔭
Best interview everr
Thank you so much ❤❤❤❤
Can you improve your podcasting setup? It would be great if you setup the cameras in such a way that it feels that you both are having a conversation; this setup doesn't justify the stature of hosting someone from reputed organizations such as ISRO currently.
Hi what's up, here are a few suggestions,improve the audio quality and upload such videos as one or two part videos and provide time stamps. 🙂
Spring glass cravings upon silicon or remove silicon , spring = π , 3.14 - 0.1 = o , circle . Using D , 89 degree or 89.5 degree or 90 degree or 90.5 degree or 91 degree angle.
Yes isro from to world No1❤
Thanks a lot
I think he upload videos in partwise because he want see reaction and opinion regarding different sections of question.
Bro, literally making GOLD content
Namaskaram Sir
Great work. Just point to improve set camera elbow up. Video is too zoom out.
Also your voice feels distant and disconnected.
Great interview
Isro should develop a more reliable and innovative booster recovery system better than spacex
Example
Instead of giving legs to land
Give foldable wings along the body of booster
Let it glide for that 600km back to launch pad reducing fuel cost, drone ship cost
Is it possible for isro to try something like starship ... That amount of mass to orbit ..
This is the interview we wanted, all technical and fact based questions 🫡🇮🇳
🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🔭🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Sir
This clip uploading system was a bad idea. You should upload the full video.
The space sector does not operate in a vacuum. It is limited by the manufacturing technologies available in the country. The insight about not having equipment to make rings larger than 5.5 was a bit sad. It makes me realise that as a country, we need a MASSIVE MASSIVE thrust in manufacturing of all kinds, especially MACHINE TOOLS. Only then can ISRO achieve breakthroughs like SpaceX
Full episode ❤?
Check description
Man! Is it only or you all facing audio issues?
no bro it only u use headphone
Gareeb Scientist is becoming Greedy Scientist. Pulling out secrets from chairman Isro
@@okman9684 😄 curious, bro should join isro
PSLV will be retired 😢 my favourite LV😭
I can understand your feelings. Even I was sad when Nasa retired the space shuttle. 15 years after that when I got an opportunity to visit USA I went to Smithsonian museum near Washington to see Space Shuttle Discovery.
@@Marv3Lthe1
Discovery is at Virginia!
@@Nithincr1 yes, but I took bus from Washington dulles airport. It only takes 30 mins from there and ticket is only 2$.
damn. the aura of Som Sir.
100 ton plus is good to have
why no parachutes??
Man this comment section guys thinks, they know more than isro scientists
Good❤
Giving me a vibe of a threatened professor 😅
Bro upload full video
Dang! Doing some of the landing/reusability tests while testing the abort system is a great move achieve dual objectives in the price of one. Would be interesting to see. Good catch and questions GS!
Happy shankaranthi as a son of old R&D child remembering of economy of railway of khammam station sir of satellite stn a clue of
Starship 💯
Just change the channel name from Gareeb scientist
It is not a justified name for a lovely channel with amazing scientific information
It also ends up creating a wrong impression
Its comes from his moto gyan ki gareebi sab se badi, but yes the name should be better. May be name should be gyan ki gareebi.
GKG
@@neerajchoudhary3709 yeah exactly
Gareeb scientist is completely misleading that way lol
Gareeb Scientists bhai just one question "Why isn't it possible for US meaning ISRO two use two stage like Falcon 9 instead of 3"?
6:26 😅❤️
what ISRO is doing now for reusable rocket
Wow PSLV could retire that's huge
Mujhe lagta ye rocket 🚀 ka kam dusri Indian Private Space 🌌 companies ko dena chahiye . Jese agnikul he unko . Aur ISRO ko aur bhi bade kamo me lagana chahiye like nasa.
Learning about ADMIRE on hold is kind of sad
Strange you didn't ask about mars landing rest of things are best
First space private Company will start with him under TATA after his retirement. Then india will move other paths
very nice 😊
अंदर की बात leak हो गयी
i think u are making something.
GREAT LEADER
Cricket insect..?
The problem with ISRO is that they try to copy recent trend from foreign country and spend couple of decades to achieve that technology but mean time that technology become old and absolute, Same things happened to India RLV programme, they tried to copy space shuttle technology.
Now they are trying to copy SPACEX Falcon rocket technology. I am sure they will take atleast decade to get that technology and meantime this technology will become old.
Hence ISRO should come with their own idea and innovation...
Did you not listen to the video. Here the chief of Isro is simply saying - they aren't focussed on the concepts space x is chasing.
Secondly money and budget is a concern. So whatever they want they have to manage with what they have.
Full video dalo na bhai!! Itna kyu tadpa rahe ho?
Check description
Kya hua Bhai past 14 hours mein bhot video agaye
Methalox engin status
Bruu do mahinon ke liye discord kay band liya yha tho somu bhi aa gaya 😵😵
Is this interview or a guest lecture 😂?
My last hope its isro technical asistant mechanical job
All the best
@@GareebScientistI reside in Sullurpet town, near Shar, I also aimed to work in SDSC like my uncles who work in Admin. I completed Aeronautical Engineer in Chennai, but I deviated from goal and now I am regretting.
Mr Gareeb Scientist any information regarding space docking experiment
He said soon
Don't copy space x try something new technology in reusable launch vehicle
Change the channel name
Why bro?
Just tell me why you have decreased the age from 35 to 28 in the recruiting process this time only😡😡😡😡 .... You have shattered many Engineering students dream...who ever has taken this decision... Karma will show you... Those all students heart are cursing those officers who have decided to do this..
. For General candidate... Only below 25-26 years of students can apply for scientists .... This is not Equality 😡😡😡😡😡😡😞😔😔
You have changed age limit this time... This is not done. 😡😡😡🤣
This time vacancies were So many... And you destroyed students dream... Already from last 4-5 years there were no vacancies after 2018😡😡😡😡 and suddenly you decrease age limit
His name is gareeb scientist how will he pay you 😢😢
Paying him , ISRO chief earns more than 2 lacs combining him as his position as cabinet secretary ( highest position if you was an IAS ) , don’t worry bro
Gareeb is written for knowledge not for wealth.............. that's why he says at the end of his video Gyan ki gareebi.
@@partialsage he's talking about the interviewer.