As someone who has run a farm this is not the whole picture. There are times when I have had to destroy an entire batch of crops because the retailers like Beleaf wouldn't purchase from us because the demand was less during certain times. It's only farmers who are left bearing the costs when prices go down or when crops fail. None of these organisations will actually help farmers plan for these situations.
If Indonesia with all it's arable fertile land is still struggling, you can just imagine how worse it is here in the Philippines. And that's not including the annual losses from the typhoons.
You didn't highlight the real issue.. the struggle is on how to digitalize agriculture effectively with the real time data, building reliable mechanism between farmers, distributors, land owner, partnerships, government support on agriculture ecosystem, building their own fertilizers not depending imports. Those are the struggles, with proper digitalization you can minimize any natural disasters you u have, so stop making excuse. But the problem is the PH gov have no long term plan on how to digitalize their agrciculture
indonesia is making herself a GREAT disservice. She was a net exporter of oil... then become net IMPORTER. Now, with her massive aerial land, she still cannot have food security !?
Not really its actually showed how Indonesia managed to diversify from oil based economy to diverse economy. Indonesia oil reserve is small to begin with, relative to other opec members, and it shows how a country should diversify before its single resource ran out. Something can't be said about Brunei or gulf economies. At least Saudi are trying now.
@@WahyuWishnuWardhana all of them are like that?, there are no goodwill compatent indonesian official is that what your saying. why dont you look in a mirror first than critize other
Food self sufficiency is a scam, if we grew staples instead of cash crops we could easily accomplish it. But of course we grow cash crops which is good economically. Indonesia enjoys good relations with aus, nz, south america which have large surplus of food. let them produce it efficiently and we can let indonesian farmers grow whats best for their condition
Malaysia kebingungan mau cari muka di Dunia dan Inggris ketawa melihat negara boneka nya sudah menjadi negara sok keras padahal di masa lalu nya bersujud ke negara Inggris demi kemerdekaan menjatuhkan harga diri, ngakunya Melayu dan bagian Nusantara tapi nyata nya jiwa boneka,
Bangsa jawadesh ldiotnesia Iow lQ.. berita tentang indon bawa² Malaysia..😅😅 padahal si sukaporno pengecut terpaksa bayar utang ke Belanda untuk merdeka.. memalukan bangsa lndon tiada jati diri
Sekarang anak muda pada gengsi jadi petani. Di daerahku contohnya sawah masih luas, tapi yang menggarap hanya orang2 tua aja. Anak muda banyak nganggur/nongkrong di jalan malam2.
@@aryw8634emang pernah lu kekurangan pangan Anak kota sok bilang anak ngk mau bertani?? Terus bahan pokok yg lu makan itu darimana klu ngk ada petani? Bodoh Datang kau sini ke Sumatra Utara Biar lu tau betapa luasnya Disini perkebunan sayuran dan sebagainya
During past time indonesia government manage to have surplus in agriculture sector. But nowadays under jokowi agriculture sector is innbad shape as oligarch prefer importing food which beneficial to handfull of importir which many believe the fee for corrupt official is huge. rather than caring for locals farmer to grow and indonesia have self suficiency in food
Other than climate crisis the land rules also not really friendly to farmers Like, everything is expensive people sometimes sell their rice field just so their children can go to university But after graduation the price of land is really pricey, rent too, moreover if there's mining or more bigger industry farmers marginalized More over technological application sometimes hardly thrive because our government accountability is very dubious, we hope our corruption gone, all the government apparatus trustworthy (all the people too), our communication/bureaucracy is getting more effective and easier between every shareholders (like I already talk many times through many routes about how fertilizer damaging our nature but still no speed improvement the budget for fertility subsidy in my Professor's public lecture he explain should be directed to a higher purchase price but still no good news till today) It's a myth that youth doesn't want to go to agricultural sector but we're really deprived of supports . Thank you so much for covering this issue 🙏🙏🙏
From the majapahit ancient era even from primitive plestosen era , Indonesian people take rice and tempe for their primary food, but the funny fact is untill now there is no food self sufficiency for those item..cannot control the minimum stock, canot control the maximum price .. the fact , those item imported from smaller agriculture country land like cambodia, vietnam, thai even japan !!..tempe soy bean imported from US !! i dont know wether there is anny research by dept.of agricultural , anny research from university related to reach this food self sufficiency???..what are they doing ????, i dont know ..
Saya memimpikan padi bisa ditanam di laut, mengapa tidak? Bulan mempunyai lahan kosong yang luas. Jika ada negara yang bisa menanam padi, mangga, kentang, kubis, maka negara itu pemilik lahan di bulan. China dan Arab adalah contoh kreatifitas mengubah gurun menjadi sawah.
🤣🤣🤣 Datang dan lihat Orang Indonesia...!! Orang Indonesia itu gemuk-gemuk karena kebanyakan makan dan karbohidrat..!! Bukanakah kami sangat kelebihan makanan. .. 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Jadi jangan khawatir dengan kami .. kami punya banyak makanan... 😘🤣🤣🤣
I wonder if CNA would ever make an investigation into Singapore's food security, the show would probably last 10 seconds long, just the host saying: Singapore has zero food security. 😂
Melayu Malaysia hanya bisa mengklaim bahwa Mereka punya segalanya padahal sejarah mengatakan Malaysia itu tidak ada kalo tidak di beri kemerdekaan dari tuan nya (Inggris), menjadi sebuah negara melalui jalur give away tapi sok keras
Intinya Malaysia itu tidak ada, mengatakan Nusantara padahal Nusantara itu artinya negara yg di satu Majapahit atau dalam bahasa kasarnya jajahan Majapahit
This documentaries felt as a half done report, perhaps need to also include Al-Zaytun institution's claim that been boasting their bountiful rice harvests and fruit crops for years on youtube...
Sedikit2 melayu apa2 melayu, memangnya melayu itu dewa, klo mau di hargai, hargai jg orang lain,tp yah tau sendirilah, betapa sombong nya melayu semenanjung
@@markzzzzberg1312 minimal punya peradaban Melayu,baru koar2 sebagai Melayu asli ,lah cuman Melayu pinggiran merasa paling Melayu 🤣🤣🤣,lawak lah kau malon
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,loh loh loh bukannya maling chia yg sampai sekarang masih bayar upeti kepada British 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,ingat masih 999 tahun lagi ,dan paling kocak malah jadi anjing penjaga pintu gerbang istana inggris 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Itulah kebodohan orang-orang malingsial, menganggap semua yg ada di Indonesia orang Jawa dan merasa paling Melayu 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,cuman Melayu pinggiran aja kalian 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,benci Jawa tp suka klaim kebudayaan Jawa 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣, kalian ini idiot apa tolol ...upssss sama aja ya 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
As someone who has run a farm this is not the whole picture. There are times when I have had to destroy an entire batch of crops because the retailers like Beleaf wouldn't purchase from us because the demand was less during certain times. It's only farmers who are left bearing the costs when prices go down or when crops fail. None of these organisations will actually help farmers plan for these situations.
If Indonesia with all it's arable fertile land is still struggling, you can just imagine how worse it is here in the Philippines. And that's not including the annual losses from the typhoons.
You can have the most fertile land in the world and still have hunger if the ones in charge don't know how to utilise it properly
It's about "How" and keep trying.. not Excuse like filipino mentality
You didn't highlight the real issue.. the struggle is on how to digitalize agriculture effectively with the real time data, building reliable mechanism between farmers, distributors, land owner, partnerships, government support on agriculture ecosystem, building their own fertilizers not depending imports. Those are the struggles, with proper digitalization you can minimize any natural disasters you u have, so stop making excuse. But the problem is the PH gov have no long term plan on how to digitalize their agrciculture
The only huge chunk arable land in indonesia is Java.
Singapore Cna just loves exaggerating the problem faced by their asean neighbours. No need to take their reports too seriously.
indonesia is making herself a GREAT disservice. She was a net exporter of oil... then become net IMPORTER.
Now, with her massive aerial land, she still cannot have food security !?
corrupt
Not really its actually showed how Indonesia managed to diversify from oil based economy to diverse economy. Indonesia oil reserve is small to begin with, relative to other opec members, and it shows how a country should diversify before its single resource ran out. Something can't be said about Brunei or gulf economies. At least Saudi are trying now.
Lots of fertile lands already turned into asphalt and industries.
Blaming infastructure and industrialization?, very smart
@@wonkagaming8750 i blame greed and narrowmindedness among Indonesian officals
@@WahyuWishnuWardhana blame yourself too. How do you think you can access the internet? By jampi-jampi? 😂
@@WahyuWishnuWardhana all of them are like that?, there are no goodwill compatent indonesian official is that what your saying.
why dont you look in a mirror first than critize other
Food self sufficiency is a scam, if we grew staples instead of cash crops we could easily accomplish it. But of course we grow cash crops which is good economically. Indonesia enjoys good relations with aus, nz, south america which have large surplus of food. let them produce it efficiently and we can let indonesian farmers grow whats best for their condition
Good effort to Indonesia.. ❤
CNA mana pernah beritain yg bagus2 soal Indonesia 😂😂😂
if a country is self-sufficient, it will be hated by the world esp. economics.
Jempol kebawah untuk Malaysia
Singapore have zero food security then.
Unplanned population growth also responsible for food shortage anywhere!!!
Negara2 Asean kena contohi Negara China membagunkan industri makanan seperti Vietnam .
Malaysia kebingungan mau cari muka di Dunia dan Inggris ketawa melihat negara boneka nya sudah menjadi negara sok keras padahal di masa lalu nya bersujud ke negara Inggris demi kemerdekaan menjatuhkan harga diri, ngakunya Melayu dan bagian Nusantara tapi nyata nya jiwa boneka,
...what does that has to do with Indonesian struggle for food security?
Bangsa jawadesh ldiotnesia Iow lQ.. berita tentang indon bawa² Malaysia..😅😅 padahal si sukaporno pengecut terpaksa bayar utang ke Belanda untuk merdeka.. memalukan bangsa lndon tiada jati diri
blakkampong Otak bodoh. .udah keluar dr tajuk prrbincangan. Dasar otak gorilla. Mesti masa sekolah juga otak bodoh.
Sekarang anak muda pada gengsi jadi petani. Di daerahku contohnya sawah masih luas, tapi yang menggarap hanya orang2 tua aja. Anak muda banyak nganggur/nongkrong di jalan malam2.
pemikiran javasentris.. di luar jawa semua berlomba jadi pemilik kebun sawit
@@ferrykurniawan1919petani kelapa sawit bisa memenuhi kebutuhan pangan? Yg dimaksud itu bertani kebutuhan pangan bkn pekebun
@@aryw8634emang pernah lu kekurangan pangan
Anak kota sok bilang anak ngk mau bertani??
Terus bahan pokok yg lu makan itu darimana klu ngk ada petani? Bodoh
Datang kau sini ke Sumatra Utara
Biar lu tau betapa luasnya Disini perkebunan sayuran dan sebagainya
All that plastic in production. It’s scary.
During past time indonesia government manage to have surplus in agriculture sector. But nowadays under jokowi agriculture sector is innbad shape as oligarch prefer importing food which beneficial to handfull of importir which many believe the fee for corrupt official is huge. rather than caring for locals farmer to grow and indonesia have self suficiency in food
Other than climate crisis the land rules also not really friendly to farmers
Like, everything is expensive people sometimes sell their rice field just so their children can go to university
But after graduation the price of land is really pricey, rent too, moreover if there's mining or more bigger industry farmers marginalized
More over technological application sometimes hardly thrive because our government accountability is very dubious, we hope our corruption gone, all the government apparatus trustworthy (all the people too), our communication/bureaucracy is getting more effective and easier between every shareholders (like I already talk many times through many routes about how fertilizer damaging our nature but still no speed improvement the budget for fertility subsidy in my Professor's public lecture he explain should be directed to a higher purchase price but still no good news till today)
It's a myth that youth doesn't want to go to agricultural sector but we're really deprived of supports
.
Thank you so much for covering this issue 🙏🙏🙏
Tapi selalu menolak sejarah
You sure this is about self sufficiency when they are thinking about exports?
Bcus they use old technology
I think Indonesia need to import some food from Singapore in the future.
nice idea maibe singapore is number 1 in agriculture
Unlikely to be the case since singapore also can't fulfill its needs.
Mimpi kamu ! Singapura ngga ada pangan kalau india stop yg lain stop semua mati kelaparan
@@ujisusanto8599 cuman sarkas itu bang wkwk
From the majapahit ancient era even from primitive plestosen era , Indonesian people take rice and tempe for their primary food, but the funny fact is untill now there is no food self sufficiency for those item..cannot control the minimum stock, canot control the maximum price .. the fact , those item imported from smaller agriculture country land like cambodia, vietnam, thai even japan !!..tempe soy bean imported from US !! i dont know wether there is anny research by dept.of agricultural , anny research from university related to reach this food self sufficiency???..what are they doing ????, i dont know ..
Saya memimpikan padi bisa ditanam di laut, mengapa tidak?
Bulan mempunyai lahan kosong yang luas.
Jika ada negara yang bisa menanam padi, mangga, kentang, kubis, maka negara itu pemilik lahan di bulan.
China dan Arab adalah contoh kreatifitas mengubah gurun menjadi sawah.
🤣🤣🤣
Datang dan lihat Orang Indonesia...!! Orang Indonesia itu gemuk-gemuk karena kebanyakan makan dan karbohidrat..!! Bukanakah kami sangat kelebihan makanan. ..
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Jadi jangan khawatir dengan kami .. kami punya banyak makanan...
😘🤣🤣🤣
I wonder if CNA would ever make an investigation into Singapore's food security, the show would probably last 10 seconds long, just the host saying: Singapore has zero food security. 😂
Melayu Malaysia hanya bisa mengklaim bahwa Mereka punya segalanya padahal sejarah mengatakan Malaysia itu tidak ada kalo tidak di beri kemerdekaan dari tuan nya (Inggris), menjadi sebuah negara melalui jalur give away tapi sok keras
Kenapa bawa² Malaysia ni indon? Bangsa jawadesh pengecut yg tidak merdeka dan merdeka hasil bayar hutan upeti ke Belanda..😅
Intinya Malaysia itu tidak ada, mengatakan Nusantara padahal Nusantara itu artinya negara yg di satu Majapahit atau dalam bahasa kasarnya jajahan Majapahit
Apa sih bang? Komen tuh yg bener, pakai EYD.
Jawadesh ldiotnesia Iow lQ 😅😅
Malingksiakontol
👀
This documentaries felt as a half done report, perhaps need to also include Al-Zaytun institution's claim that been boasting their bountiful rice harvests and fruit crops for years on youtube...
Hahaha Al zaytun... Part of Sunda empire????
kaos nya mas rahmat hidayat 😂😂😂
Belajar dari Israel teknologi pertaniannya
Intinya kalo mau jadi Melayu itu harus tidak malu maluin,
Sedikit2 melayu apa2 melayu, memangnya melayu itu dewa, klo mau di hargai, hargai jg orang lain,tp yah tau sendirilah, betapa sombong nya melayu semenanjung
Apa kaitan indon?
@@markzzzzberg1312 loh apa kaitan dgn maling chia 🤣🤣🤣, merasa si paling Melayu 🤣🤣🤣
@@markzzzzberg1312 minimal punya peradaban Melayu,baru koar2 sebagai Melayu asli ,lah cuman Melayu pinggiran merasa paling Melayu 🤣🤣🤣,lawak lah kau malon
ga nyambung
Cek perjanjian negara boneka (Malaysia) dengan tuannya (Inggris) negara boneka jangan sok keras
Come on overproud indo netizen aka "BuzzeRp", deny it!!
🤣🤣🤣
Klaim kebudayaan orang
Fak fak what?
Fak fak is a region bruh
Sue the reporter for cursing in public
😂
It's the name of a town in the West Papua.
Merdeka aja kena beri
blakkampong No brain this guy...🤪
Jawadesh ex president, sukaporno have to pay upeti to Belanda in order to get merdeka berbayar 🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,loh loh loh bukannya maling chia yg sampai sekarang masih bayar upeti kepada British 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,ingat masih 999 tahun lagi ,dan paling kocak malah jadi anjing penjaga pintu gerbang istana inggris 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Oya jgn lupa bayar sewa tanah Sabah 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,jgn sampai asetnya di sita lagi oleh pejuang Sulu 🤣😂😂😂😂
Siap malaydesh.. the country full of bangla people
@@piscesgoreng1444 jawadesh Banglanesia negara kumuh 280 juta warga tikus🤣
@@markzzzzberg1312 ahh malaydesh.. country full of bangla
Why jawadesh ldiotnesia Iove to cIaim hindu cuIture from tamil lndia?
Itulah kebodohan orang-orang malingsial, menganggap semua yg ada di Indonesia orang Jawa dan merasa paling Melayu 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,cuman Melayu pinggiran aja kalian 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,benci Jawa tp suka klaim kebudayaan Jawa 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣, kalian ini idiot apa tolol ...upssss sama aja ya 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣