Lives of Sahaba 35 - Ali Ibn Abu Talib pt.6 - Battle of Siffeen - Yasir Qadhi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 сен 2016
- All previous videos from this series: bit.ly/1pomUSI
In this video, Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi covers the battle of Siffeen, when tensions arose between Ali [r] and Muwawiya [r] during the caliphate of Ali Ibn Abu Talib [r]
Watch the full video to learn about these stories and much more.
Presentation details: August 31, 2016 @ Memphis Islamic Center
In this series, Lives of the Sahaba, Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi discusses the lives of the noble companions, some of the greatest and most blessed human beings to ever live after the death of Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him [S].
While not a comprehensive history of the Khulafa Ar-Rashidoon, this series will provide a summarized biography of the men and women considered to be the Sahaba (companions of the Prophet [s]), including the Mothers of the Believers (the wives of the Prophet).
Please help MIC produce additional beneficial and educational content such as this presentation by visiting us at www.MemphisIslamicCenter.org/donate
Copyright MIC
This presentation may not be modified or used without the explicit permission of MIC
![Lives of Sahaba 56 - Anas Ibn Malik [r] - Sh. Dr. Yasir Qadhi](/img/1.gif)
No one but a believer would love Ali, and none but a hypocrite would nurse grudge against Ali.
Sahih Muslim 240
I honestly think that the main culprits have evaded attention from the eyes of historians. Hence we end up blaming one another excessively.
culprits ave never evaded just we don't want to see them due to our prejudices.
I'm a Sunni, and I can't believe how a Muslim of that era could side with the rebel, who happened to be son of Abu Sufyan (nothing less), against the Khalifa Ali (RA). Let alone he is the son in law of the Prophet and all his virtues, he was the Khalifa and the best Muslim alive at that time.
best muslim alive at that time ? whats ur point ? so hazrat ayesha was not above him keeping in mind wife of prophet pbuh and mother of all believers... ? dun call urself a sunni coz ur doing Taqqia and u sound more SHIA
Qalid Mocca The number one issue was a demand for justice for Uthman. This was ignored for some time, but the damage was done.
Napoleon Rabbit justice for usman (ra) wasn't ignored. It was difficult to identify the killler among the rebels.
How was it that the rebels and enemies of hazrat Usman were bad, but the rebels and enemies of hazrat Ali were good ??
Any one pls clarify logically.
@@LawlessRaafay brother so are we saying that bibi Khatija kubra
(the supreme) was better then hazrat Umar ??
whats your logic ?? as i am a sunni too.
Assalamu Alaykum Shaykh Yasir Qadhi,
Mashallah, I've learned a lot from your lectures and I truly want to thank you. May Allah bless your efforts and grant you the highest place in Jannah.
only confused arrogant people like the white washed history
May the Peace, Blessings and Mercy of ALLAH(SWT) be upon Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, his team, MIC,
& the rest of the Muslim Ummah.
Ameen, Ameen, Summah Ameen
One of the best Islamic history lecture i ever had have with Shaikh Dr. Yasir, he always take balanced approach and make things clearer, now a days we rarely find scholars and Islamic lecturers talking about these affairs and clarifying things to average Muslims. Jazak'Allah khair brother
Dr. Yasir, I join the rank of those who respectfully disagree with your own line of thinking. Mu'awiya did put an end to the Khilafa and that what let to all of the sultanates. emirates and kingdoms of our days and they are the MAJOR PROBLEM of the Muslim World. Please be objective, relate facts and let the listener decide. Most importantly DO NOT FILTER the Narration according to your belief - Thank you.
SubhanaAllah , indeed Allah gives wisdom to those whom he wills ! Ya allah grant us wisdom too Aameen allahumma Aameen. ! Sheikh Yasir is MashaAllah so full of wisdom !
My favourite scholer coz he talks abt history a lot ,unlike other scholars mashallah !!!!
Sahih al Bukhari Volume 1, Book 8, Number 438 :
Narrated by 'Ikrima
Ibn 'Abbas said to me and to his son 'Ali, "Go to Abu Sa'id and listen to what he narrates." So we went and found him in a garden looking after it. He picked up his Rida', wore it and sat down and started narrating till the topic of the construction of the mosque reached. He said, "We were carrying one adobe at a time while 'Ammar was carrying two. The Prophet saw him and started removing the dust from his body and said, "May Allah be Merciful to 'Ammar. He will be inviting them (i.e. his murderers, the rebellious group) to Paradise and they will invite him to Hell-fire." 'Ammar said, "I seek refuge with Allah from affliction."
How beautifully he explained such a sensitive matter. JazakAllah Sheikh.
Yeah he's really a good and true Shaik
you should say how systematically twisted !!!
Thank you Dr Yasir. Sad story though but there's no need of sugar coating
Are you mehdavi?
Jazak Allah.
I came here with huge doubt but Alhamdulillahi thank you jazakallahu khair
When Rabb opens our heart, we know who is on the Haq and who is on the Wrong side. We have to ask ourselves why Maula Ali Karam Allahu Waju faced so much internal wars. Why he and the family of Prophet Muhammad sallahu allihe wa sallam were killed by so-called Muslims? Along with Muhammad bin Yasir(RA), Owais-al-Qaran(Ra) also was on the side of Maula Ali. The Character of Maula Ali, takes us towards our Nabi Kareem Sallahu allaihe wa sallam. I am seeing this speaker is trying to protect more about Muwayia in a speech which he is supposed to talk about Maula Ali's character during the battle of Siffin. There are few occasions in the battle where Maula Ali shows the beautiful character learnt from our beloved prophet sallahu allaihe wa sallam. He gives water to the enemy, and when one of his companions says that he killed the same number of people he killed, he replies saying that there is a difference between you kill and I kill. You kill people whoever come in front of you where as I see seven generations behind that person whom i am going to kill. If i see one good person among them, i'll leave him so that another good person might come along his forth coming generations. Abu Sufyan was the enemy of our Nabi sallahu allihe wa sallam through out his life even though he accepted Islam when Mecca was conquered. His son Muwaiya, was against Maula Ali, and his son Yazid, killed Imam Hussain and all the men among the family of Prophet Muhammad sallahu allihe wa sallam except Imam Zainulabudeen(RA). Mr Yasir see this as a political issue, I see the perfection of Deen of Muhammad (sal) in the family of Muhammad(sal.). Allahumma salli ala saiyathina Muhhamadin wa Aala le Muhammadin wa barika salli allaihe wa sallam.
we need more people like him in muslim community
May Allah protect Yasir Qadhi. May Allah spread the true knowledge through you. May Allah always keep you of the path of Salaf us saleheen.
MashAllah
May Allah gives you long life brother JZAK
May Allah increase your knowledge my brother in islam.
This man is just awesome
Shaykh Yasir is either knowingly or unknowingly hiding the complete hadith of the Prophet (saww) at 39:20 and onwards because then it will leave no wiggle room for a different interpretation.
Sahih al-Bukhari (#2812)
وَقَالَ " وَيْحَ عَمَّارٍ، تَقْتُلُهُ الْفِئَةُ الْبَاغِيَةُ، عَمَّارٌ يَدْعُوهُمْ إِلَى اللَّهِ وَيَدْعُونَهُ إِلَى النَّارِ "
"May Allah be merciful to `Ammar. He will be killed by a rebellious group. `Ammar will invite them to Allah and they will invite him to the fire."
Does this hadith leave anything for interpretation?
i love shaikh yasir bcz he not only give all story as its but also explaining it logically ....great....you are writing history thru this series..insha allah this series will be excellent deposit for your akhira ..may allah bless u and all those behind this ( ameen)
Beautifull explanation Dear sheikh
great lecture, i just love your lecture, thx
So did Mawyia ever ended up finding and killing the killers of Uthman?
It was never the agenda. Only a means to get what he wanted
Subhan Allah you nailed it my brother.
@@mehrullahsoomro7991 so right
Jazakallah khair
It is a sad part of our history. Allah will judge between them both. We love them both and ask Allah to forgive whoever was in the wrong.
Imam Ali is haq who ever fought against ali fight against rasoolallah
Mansha Allah jizaka Allah khair keep up the good job
The character of Muawiyah? Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t the custom of cursing Ali RA from the pulpit in Damascus start during the caliphate of the Muawiyah? Didn’t he break the treaty he signed with Imam Hasan RA?
putarkan video ini selalu
I was amazed by the way you sugarcoated the Muawiyah part, i.e the death and hadith related to the Ammar ibn Yasir.
Freelancer's Hub aww a dumbass
I am embarrassed as its so true that we sunnis sugarcoat all these major incidents. Just lame excuses nothing else.
He who killed a believer intentionally, his will be the hell fire
Addendum: With all due respect, why do we, the Sunnis, say Radhiya Allaho "Anh and not Rahimaho Allah? He refused to chose/elect Ali (RA) and later on, time betrays him an shows his true intentions by becoming "king". He was referred to in the Hadith as being on the wrong side and he still played with the obvious interpretation of the Hadith. He disobeyed the Khalifa's order to replace him. He started the killings at the meeting point - encampment. He used the Quran to deceive (most likely when he was weak despite his proximity to his headquarters) and worst he did not repent before his death; instead he passes on the control to his son. All of the above factors DO NOT speak well of his "NIA" i.e. Intentions. Is it Not what all the present kings do from Morocco to Oman?
Why does it feel like I am not listening to Fazayl e Ali(ra) but Fazayl e Muawiya(ra), the title should be The greatness of Muawiyah(ra) . May Allah(saww) guide us all. .
Muawiya lalnatolal
Do you want to say that Muawiya misinterpreted .Or reverse the meaning of hadeeth in order to save himself from being a bagee...Your interpretation of this episode is as bizarre as Muawiya.I as a Muslim don't want to judge sahaba as I believe that Allah is the best judge but Muawiya and his family killed the whole family of prophet saw and demolished the institution of Khilafati rashida....What do you say about Muawiya getting bayat for yazeed by hook by crook.
Gh Nabi Sunnis do not doubt the intentions of the sahaba, but are not obliged to agree with their decisions. Majority, if not all, would agree that many of his decisions were not the wisest including the one you mentioned.
It's not the intention of any person I can predict for only Allah swt who knows what's there in the minds of people ,it's the the institute of khilafat of the almighty that was demolished by Muawiya what I suppose we have lost till date.and l think daees like you need to concentrate on this side of Muawiya,'s personality and then we see that the condemnation of the family of Rasoolullah ,assassination of sihaaba,and in the end Karbala and Hurrah are the end products of the same rejeem( govt) of Muawiya
Gh Nabi Doubting the niyyah of the sahabi is not something Sunnis do. If you Shia & your imoms want to do that then thats your perogative. Sunnis leave his affairs to Allah SAW, for He is All Knowing, All Wise.
@@24xv555 I'm a Muslim and that's enough as Allah wants us to be Muslims.I'm from Kashmir and have been raised by a family that I know for sure is not shia.I'm not a scholar of Islam but have been reading Islam very enthusiastically and it's the saheehain that have proved me that various sects of "Sunnis" are taking ahadees partially to prove their point.Whats is Islam.perhaps it's the tawheed ,service of Allah in all aspects of life.He is the Lord and no one should be obeyed other than him.Obeying anyone else is kufr.Please leave this Sunni..Be Muslim .
Gh Nabi It is Ibn Abbas that used the term “followers of Sunnah & the jamaah”. So i follow in his footsteps & those before him & of his companions & students.
And also in the matter of Muawiyah being the Khalifah, whom after the passing of Ali RA all of the sahaba gave their baiyah to willingly including Hasan & Husein ibn Ali, ibn Umar, ibn Abbas, ibn Zubayr, Abdur Rahman ibn Abu Bakr, ibn Amr ibn As. The list goes on.
Put this Muawiyah RA matter aside and focus on contemporary Muslim issues.
Realty is that Muawiya demolished the institution of khilafat that was erected after unimaginable sacrifices offered by Allah's prophet his family and friends just to live a life of king.
He again took byaah for his son yazeed against the soul of Islam. ~and you say that it's not a part of our rheology.please read saheeh hadeeth and see for yourself how Muaawiyah resurrected the monster of qabaylee jahilyah in order to make his life luxurious ....Please revert to the path of Allah
All the shias commenting on this video you should be more concerned about (tawheed which means stop calling upon the dead) than imamah and the battles.
@ShiaMuslim nope
insha'Allah we will unite again in the time of Mehdi A.S
Till then worship Allah alone and work on things which are common in both the groups.
From the reply of the Shia it is obvious their deen is not about Islam and worshiping Allah for their Jannah but interested into division. The average of them don't know anything about the deen but know is everything about the fitnah. Sick people.
When's the next part out?
O Shaikh! Assalam Walekum. Q:- If the large armies were stationed in Qufa/Basra/Damascus then which army protecting Madina the capital city. Or in other words as Caliph what he (ra) himself kept direct under him?
Wasslam.
The capital was moved to Kufa at the time.
It is evident from the text of some Sunni scholars, for some or other reasons the then elites didn't like Hazrat Ali (ra) to be in power and this started just after the demise of rasul (s).
Hifzur Rahman Choudhury because he was beloved and chosen by the prophet (Saw) jealousy has ravaged Arabs since the beginning of time. And this is no different
Holy prophet said: Ali is the MASTER of every believer AFTER me!!
Musnad ibn hanbal, v5, page 25
Farzan Ak And? Abu Bakr was still appointed the imam by Rasulullah SAW when he got sick.
24xv555 appointed by who? They held an election while the prophet was being buried.
Tony Chaychab As if the timing would have changed the outcome
By all sahaba, including Ali RA & the ahl bayt. Some of whom gave the allegiance earlier, some later than others.
@@24xv555 try 2 do some research bro... refer 2 below suni historians book 4 who the prophet appointed as successor apart from the incident of Ghadir khum.
Majma al zawaid & Tabarani!! 😃
Farzan Ak As Yasir Qadhi says, they don’t like to do research of our history because “it’s in the past” lol. The real reason is that it is unfavorable for Sunnis to talk about Islamic history
Can we do a talk about the dynasties open till now
Sheik how do you know what Mu’awiya intends,when he says “it is those that brought him to the battle that killed him.”I am sunni but from so many narrations the various actions and inaction of Mu’awiya didn’t portray him as a good sahaba to put it mildly.
Muawiyahs son Yazid Ibn Muawiyah killed the Grandson of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in the battle of Karbala read the history of Islam dude
James wohley Yazid is not a sahabi and is not liked & shouldnt be liked/respected by any Muslim.
Aliyu Madaki youre absolutely right. Muawiya has NEVER been liked/portrayed as a good Muslim in the last 1300 years! However there is unfortunately a new wave of “salafi/Wahhabi muawiya apologists” like Yasir Qadhi and others, who have attempted to salvage the reputation of Abu Sufyans son, MuAwiya. I believe it is tied to politics and this new Sunni/Shia fued that has plagued our ummah
@@24xv555 Well Sunnis call him and his father a Sahabah but Shias dont consider Muawiyah and Yazid as Sahabah
James wohley Sunnis do not call Yazid a sahaba. Those who do are wrong. Muawiyah RA is a sahaba and he is very young during his conversion to Islam (fathul Makkah).
What about Abu Bakr & Umar & Uthman RA? I know the Zaidis consider them sahaba and good. I dont know which Shia strand you are from.
I now understand why Dr. YQ always give disclaimer. Yet still you see people claiming this and that.
Yusif Huseini Its like people stop listening and just comment for the sake of arguing.
Muwawia
- didn't give his allegiance to Ali
- waged a war on really a null issue (if we can understand the killers of Uthman could not be caught, why didn't Muwawia understand this and leave Ali alone) .
- he rejected a clear cut Hadith
- his actions lead to the killing of thousands of Muslims
- self proclaimed cilaphat as soon as Ali passed
I find it difficult to accept your stand Yasir
yes even me why is he not clearly explaining its like he is hiding some thing
44.40
Yasir qadi was quite right about a few incidents but mostly he is speaking under the influence of sunnism and also imam taymiyyah. All these unfortunate incidents are mentioned in the sunni books of ahadith. Nothing is hidden. We sunnis are just too stubborm to accept that some so called sahaba destroyed the true image of Islam and went against the sunnah. I am surprised as to why he never spoke about all of this in detail. Detail is what would have shown the true nature of the incidents. As usual he acted like a typical sunni and hid most of the stuff. Hazrat Ali a.s had no choice but to fight. To get the facts about all this, people should listen to Maulana Ishaq r.a of Faisalabad Pakistan.
he lied on many occasion. listen to abu yahya noorpuri on islah merdia he has debunked both engineer and maulana ishaq
As a sunni I agree, it seems to me the Shayk knows in his heart what is right and what is falsehood. He seems heavily influenced by certain influencers. We must never shy away from the truth and our rightly guided khalifa's.
Ibn taymiyah is one of the greatest scholars. Thats why he is called shaykh al islam. You must be shia to single my beloved scholars
nice lecture - respect, i was wondering is this true that did Mu`awiyah' sent to Busr ibn Abi Artat to Hijaz or maybe yemen? and killed the two young boys of `Ubaydullah ibn `Abbas (goverener of yemen? )... ? is it true ??
waste of time debating with misguided sects, Rawafid, Qadiyani, Brelvi's, Sufi's etc... may Allah guide them and us all... ameen
It is a waste of time debating people who ignore historical events and certain sayings of the Prophet (A.S.)
Is is never a waste of time debating misguided sects.
This is discusting history of Nani omayed la speaking of the barking female dog referring to him as radia Allah on him may Allah la3na go on the female barking dog mo3awiyatah the son of shayton Abu sufian what an unbelievable disgusting video 'tis
Al Zahraa Sayedati
Plz explain your side of story instead of badmouthing well thats what you guys are taught not surprised.
Unlocked
My best friend was a twelver shia and he used to swear at sahaba.
Dr Sugar Coat, Mashallah 👍
Keyboard warrior.
How is it not blindingly obvious that Mu`āwiyah was just using `Uthan's (radiyAllāhu `anhu) blood as a pretext for his rebellion?
You're still sugar-coating, Doctor Qadhi!
Sorry for the disappointment. He is not here to say what you want to hear. Ha ha ha. LOL
Why should muawiyah Ra as a shaba wants to have revenge for utman Ra where as His sobór could Save several thousand momin Muslim life. I have two points here he disobey Ali Ra command second one being momin why he did not show sobór whereas he knew His revenge Will bring Blood of Muslim. I have More points but i do not want to mention here because it Will be creating Division in Our heart. I feel So sąd whenever i remember this part of Islamic time.
have you not seen when rumor of murder of uthman has arrived then rasoolAllah pbuh took biyah from sahaba to avenge the blood. qisas is must for a momin. how can we leave those who killed uthman free?
This is all false upon false, Muawiyah hated Ali thats the reality Uthman was stuck 49 days in his palace writing letters to him saying he needs help and he was ignoring them all his own cousin! if he really wanted to avenge Uthman he would’ve joined with Aisha or even before her the guy hated Ali and whoever supported him for decades he made people do la3na on Ali on pulpits you’ll never find anyone praising him even in Sunni books brother i promise you if you read through the books you’ll have many more questions the truth is out there
Umm Salamah? I think she was Umm Sulaym. Please correct me if I am wrong.
This guy speaks as if he was present there and clearly shows his heart not the facts. See how he is so soft speaking on muwaiah and misinterpreted the Hadith on Ammar Yasir. Amazing how Allah puts seal on such people who refuse to accept the truth even if it is from the Prophet pbuh himself. SubhanAllah!
How many comments do you write for this video brother?
When it has become clear that Ammar Bin Yasir (RA) was killed by the army of Muawia (RA), why do you hesitate to call them the Rebel as per the Hadith? Muawiah (RA) did not take the oath of allegiance to Ali (RA), did not obey his orders, fought against him and you call it his Ijtihad? On top of it, you suggest that he will be rewarded for doing wrong Ijtihad where 60 ,000 best Muslims were killed?
it is bcoz of some extremists wahabis
He did affirm that Muawiyah was the rebel in the hadith 😅
wow after killing each other they pray with each other does it make sense ?
asalaamu calaykum brother and sisters was dies any one knows if Khalid binu walid was alive at this time if he was which side was he
He died in the time of Caliph Umar ra
Most of the elite Sahaba either passed away before the fitna or did not participate in any of the civil wars.
So ali gives bayah to abu bakr, to umar, to uthman, all the while not happy with it. but muawiyah refuses to give bayah, and actually fights ali, he's just trying to seek justice for uthman. gimmie a break. uthman replaces countless governors when he becomes khalif and its his right. ali does the same, and muawiyah is acting in his right? gimmie a break. Is Ali rightly guided, or is muawiyah deserving or 'RA'. Because if you chose the ladder, then there should only be 3 rightly guided khalifs in the sunni fiqh. Aisha i will not get into, but rightly guided can't be against rightly guided. Complete absence of logic here.
How can the lecturer say RA after Muawiya when he fought the Khalifa of his time leading to mass Muslim death? Muawiya cursed Imam Ali (as) on the pulpit after prayer and instructed others to do so aswell, and yet he was righteous and deserves Allah's (swt) pleasure? May Allah (swt) forgive this speaker for covering the truth. He is deliberately sugar coating Muawiya's evil and doesn't want laymen Sunni to delve deep into it because he knows that questioning history will unravel Sunnism as a whole. May Allah (swt) guide you!
You shias get these sources from liars and fabricators. In which book does it say muawiyah RA commanded the people to curse Ali RA? Muawiyah literally said "Ali is better than me". Why would he say that after cursing him? No logic in shi'ism.
Unlocked Wikipedia, the best source of Islamic knowledge
Sheikh why are you creating excuses for Mu’awiya.I am Sunni but even based on your narration Mu’awiya is not a good Muslim to put it mildly.
we admit he make many mistakes, and Ali was better than him, but we shouldn't criticize Mu'awiyah beyond what is acceptable. Only misguided Shia do this.
Sherief Elsayad that’s like obeying Allah and Shaytan you have to choose 1 you’re either with Allah (swt) or shaytan just like in this situation you’re either with Ali (as) or Muawiyah may Allah curse be upon him and also his son Yazid Ibn Muawiyah killed the Grandson of Prophet (Pbuh) in the battle of Karabala
Muwaiyah was a great sahaba. Dont be fooled by shias. They hate everything abiut muwaiyah. Ali radialanhoo was better. It was itjihad. We love the sahaba. Who are we, sitting at home talking about the most blessed nation to walk the earth. Every deed we do is not equal to sahabas or anywhere near!
@@alimaster133 Muawiyah fought with Caliph Ali (as) and the son of Muawiyah killed Husayn Ibn Ali (as) the Grandson of Prophet (PBUH) in Karbala so who's side are you taking??
Jay Ali there are those that claimed to be sahabas that even the holy prophet called hypocrites.
When someone rebels and refuses to pay Zakah to Abu Bakr, Umar or Uthman, they are treated as 'Baaghi' and 'Murtad' and are fought against and killed by the Khalifa. And you exemplify those actions.
But when the exact same thing happens against Hadhrat Ali, you seek to justify things and make it look innocent and stuff. Terrible double standards. Reconsider your stand.
I'm not saying that it should matter to our 'Aqeedah'. Im saying open your eyes and reject double standards.
+Warjohn Jackson I'm impressed :)
+Warjohn Jackson And I 100% agree to that! I'm asking my question completely independent of theology, brother!
+Warjohn Jackson There's no need for you to believe hear-say and falsely accuse anyone or anything. All Ulama (not road-side Mullahs)have clear fatawa against speaking ill of the Khulafaa and Ummahatul Mu'mineen.
Just like if Sunni scholar supports terrorism is deviated, same way a Shi'i scholar who curses the wives of the Prophet (S) is deviated.
+Warjohn Jackson Also, thanks for giving me a label, because I don't give myself a label other than Muslim.
+Warjohn Jackson Also, thanks for giving me a label, because I don't give myself a label other than Muslim.
people who oppose Ali are munafiq or deviated muslim
Who opposed Ali radiAllahu 3anhu? Muawiyah was not against Ali, he wanted justice for Uthman. Both believed they were in the right, although Ali radiAllahu 3anhu was closer to the right.
Suhyla Justice by fighting the Calip Ali Ibn Abi Talib? If he was a real Muslim he would pray to Allah, the provider of justice, rather than starting a battle that resulted in the death of thousands of Muslims.
@@lemortedbrian6070 no one said anyone was correct or wrong. But this all happened after the Prophet عليه الصلاة والسلام and all parties had their own wisdom. Of course, I respect the authority and wisdom of Ali رضي الله عنه but I also know that Aisha and Amr had their own wisdom and did not intend to hurt anyone. They merely wanted to make a point through numbers, as the video demonstrates. Who was absolutely correct, Allah knows best. But both parties are honorable and worthy of respect. You make mistakes and sin all the time, Allah doesn't hold men to their sins if they repent. And Aisha was known to seek forgiveness for what happened that day. You didn't live through their age or saw what they saw. These are people who lived with the Prophet عليه الصلاة والسلام and fought with him.
The Shaytaan (RA) attacked and fought Adam (RA)...and when that sword was unsheathed, it will not be sheathed again till the Day of Reckoning...but it was only a "mistake" since each of them (RA to both) truly believed that he alone is right and the other wrong...and Allah knows best!
Nasbis detected in the comment section.
Hey Yasir Qadhi, so you think MUAWIYAs good deeds outweigh his “trivial” sins? Do you hear yourself speak?
If prophet (pbuh) excused companions like Hatib for helping the pagans in Makkah and overlooked it due to his virtues and his backgrounds which accredits him as worthy of being due lenience, what of Mu'awiyah ? Our history is replete with companions making ij'tihadi mistakes but not being deemed non-Muslims as a result of it.
As for rebels in Sunni thought unless they hold beliefs of kufr they are not deemed unbelievers.
Yasir sab.. who assasinated Hassab (RA.. ) can you prove Moaviya was qatibe vahi... as most of quraan revealed before conquest of makah.. ?????? shia telling correct you are with moaviya no doubt..
Hassan would aqueous? Lmaooo he was the second strongest warrior on the battlefield in the history of Islam after his father! What did he do to all of your beloved bani ummaya caliphs? What did imam Hasan (a.s) do to them on the battlefield? SHAME ON YOU FOR DISRESPECTING AHLUL BAYT! Imam Hasan is the grandson of the prophet SAW, at least put some respect on his name and story you WAHHABI
For me its clear that muawiya was wrong on this and we dont know what intention he had. But you cannot rebell against khalifa if you diasagree with something and start a war. And what happened after was even worse, in karbala they killed hussain an yazid didnt even punish the killers, but still in the end allah knows best and he will give them the right judgment.
What Shaykh Qadhi fails to realize is that Hd. Ali is one of the 5 purified By Allah SWT as stated in 33:33 in The Holy Qur'an and the Custodian of The Message of Allah SWT Sent through the real Muhammad-RasulAllah-rahmatan-lil-alameen after the Prophet PBUh passed away and because of this he is the successor of the Prophet PBUh and furthermore Hd. Ali's sons are the defenders and savior's of Allah SWT's Message culminating in Imam Mehdi behind whom Hadrat Eesa RasulAllah will offer salat when Allah SWT Wills.
Hadith, Prophet was the City of knowledge and Ali was the gate. Mawyia was corrupt so Imam Ali wanted to replace him and corrupt people. Shame on you for insulting Imam Ali. You’re confusing people more with not giving facts. Everything Imam Ali did was crystal.
who is insulting ali radhiyallhu anhu?
Ali stopped fighting moawia that is the key. If moawia was corrupt as you say ali would have fighting him. Antill deth but the fact that ali stopped fighting moawia tell that moawia was never corrupt.
You have tried your best Yasir Qadhi but you failed to be 100% honest when you started to talk about Muwaiya. Anyone can see your desperation to somehow keep Muwaiya's image unblemished. That's hypocrisy which is NOT the mark of an intellectual man.
Seems he is trying to work on an Agenda instead of facts and hadiths
sorry but it looks power politics to me on both sides
#YasirQadhi
U r the most misguided person I have ever seen.
U claim to respect the big sahaba yet u end up praising the least and rebellious of them.
How does you Aqida don’t change im confused! You take your deen and hadith from the likes of Muawia, hi murdered imam Hassan pbuh, He fought Imam Ali at Siffin killing thousands of people, he refused to help Uthman after he wrote to him 40 days straight asking for help, he put the quran on spears! These are facts in history. We have to talk about these people, my sunni brothers and sisters do not be fooled, everyone knows who the likes of Muawia and his son Yazid were. Yazid killed Imam hussain and his sahaba. Muawia killer ammar bin Yasir, hadith in bukhari says prophet said Ammar will be killed by a baghi group, while he’s calling them to jannah and The other calling them to hell fire. My suni brothers read this in Sahih Al bukhari : sahih al bukhari book 8 hadith 96 . Be careful, you are being lied to. Ali is with Quran and Quran is with Ali, prophet hadith. Hadith from prophet, i leave behind two weighty things, the Quran and my itra(my Ahlulbayt), so long as you hold on to them you’ll never go astray. Shia follow the Ahlulbayt and of course some of the sahaba, the ones who didn’t go against Islam, Quran and the Ahlulbayt. We don’t dislike all of them of course, most of them we don’t know! There were probably 200 thousands sahaba and the books of history probably mention about 200 of them. But read and educate yourself on who the Shia Of Ali RA are. Allah gave us a brain and intellect to study and learn.
it's not a "notion" but a FACT that the mobs who rebelled against uthmaan was riding with Ali & they also supported Ali as khaleef. so in essence, aisha talha, zubir & muawiyah etc was asking Ali to kill those who put him in power. Ali said he had no power to do that but at the same time he had power to deal with aisha in jamal & almost won in sifeen.
Ibrahiym Ghany Thats not what it meant. Islamic jursprudence requires undeniable proof and a punishment that befits the crime. To actually sort out who did what in a very short time frame cannot be done. And if it was rushed, the tribes of the people who were punished would have rebelled, and that would have caused a bigger problem.
Remember that the people who are leading these mons are actually leaders of their own tribes, hence why the priority of Ali RA is to have a solid government through and through before any drastic action could be taken.
You are a bloody nasbi.
Ok did Amir Muawiya punish the killers of uthman RA after he became the Khalif?
The hades Ali is with Haq and Haq is with Ali is highly authentic and yet you look of the truth you logical conclusions are astonishing you my friend are a master of deception Prophets hadees wrt Ammar Yaser is clear your begging the question is unfair.
No need to tell the Shia version of the history opinion, though good for acknowledgement but they are nothing more than a hypocrite and deceiver.
If most of this account is coming from a single historian of dubious character (Abu Mihnaf) who was copied by all later historians, then, is it a good idea to talk about all this nonsense? No sane person can remain a Muslim after hearing these nonsensical "historical accounts" written by people 150-700 years after the demise of the Propphet (swt). These stories malign the character of our mother Ayesha (ra) and the noble Companions. Listening to these kind of baseless historical tales is the reason we have had - and continue to have - the KNOWN blood-curdling internal conflicts.
The Qur'an mentions none of these characters. If Allah chose to remain silent, why shouldn't we be?
@@lemortedbrian6070 Are Ayesha and Hafsa mentioned in the Qur'an? Allah did not names, why should anyone? Furthermore, the word in the ayah you quoted is "minkunna" (not dual plural), which means that Allah is NOT talking about any specific "two wives", but ayah is a general warning to all the Prophet's wives that they should be more careful. Similar warning from Allah to all the Prophet's wives can be found in 33:32 where He says "You are not like other women... 33:32". That's because they are special to Allah because Allah wishes to 'purify them to the fullest extent" (see 33:33).
This sheikh is depicting one of his wives - Ayesha (r.a) - in a way that - ma'azallah - many other women, even of today, would look better than her. Is it acceptable to you?
I really liked Yasir Qadhi, but after being exposed my DawahMan - I can't listen to him anymore. How can you sit there and talk about the sahaba when you personally believe that the Quran is not the word of Allah?
Please clarify.
dawah man? seriously? he is in his 20s with no proper islamic background apart from his study with abdulrahman hasan compared to Yasir Qadhi HAFIZAHULLAH, BA and MA from madinah uni with a phd in islamic theology. you really wanna compare the two?
if you really have been listening to this series, you would know that the people who killed Uthman RA are also a bunch of nobodies who claimed they know the Quran and aqeedah better than Uthman and the sahabas. Fitnah is rampant then and today is no different. Be careful of where you get knowledge from.
Hazim Hashim Your comment is completely irrelevant. What does him having a PhD to do with the fact that he is saying that the Quran is not 100% the word of Allah? So anyone with a PhD can say any rubbish and hide behind the fact that they are Doctors and everyone else have no saying because they are not "too advanced" in their studies?
+huznmeee then leave these videos alone and go get your knowledge from dawah man and co. arguments on youtube never solves anything and this will be no different. May Allah guide us all. ameen.
Have you ever heard Sh Yasir Qadhi said this?
Irfan Afif No, but he wrote this and confirmed that it was his email.
Saudi is the true face of Sunni. Abu Sufyian father of Mawia was the enemy of Holy Prophet PBUH, Mawyia father of Yazid was the enemy of Imam Ali and Yazid the enemy of Imam Hussein and finally slaughtered Holy Prophet’s family. Dirty blood vs Holy blood.
On the day of judgment May you be raised in the Company of Mawyia.
May the Peace, Blessings and Mercy of ALLAH(SWT) be upon Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, his team, MIC,
& the rest of the Muslim Ummah.
Ameen, Ameen, Summah Ameen