Many thanks to Jay Smith for honoring me by coming on the channel. Special thanks to Phil2:10 and keezenoom for the superchats and to everyone who joined live despite some stiff competition. To everyone - Muslim, Christian, or otherwise - I encourage you to pursue Truth whenever it leads. To any Muslim who wants to respond to this material (or anything else), email me at thaddeus@reasonedanswers.com and I'll set up a time for a friendly live chat! Timestamps: 0:00 Intro & Prayer 2:23 Jay Smith's Story 13:47 Evidence that Islam is False 19:32 Dangerous Qs for Islam 23:35 Problems with The Quran 29:00 Comparing The Bible 32:50 Quran Not Preserved + Errors 36:23 Chat Qs 40:00 Sources The Quran comes from 42:10 Memorizing Quran Lie 49:15 Quran Versions 51:49 Quran Standardized in 1924 + 4000 Changes 58:11 Oral Tradition of Bible vetted 1:00:31 Mohammad info 1:03:09 Bio of Muhammad 1:09:05 Scholarly Books on Muhammad/Quran 1:15:01 Critical apparatus of Quran 1:20:47 Quran Contradictions 1:30:14 Yeshua in Arabic 1:31:00 Ask Questions to Muslims 1:44:33 Qiblas - Dan Gibson's book 1:50:18 Dan Gibson's Series on Jay's channel 1:52:02 No Evidence for Islam in 7th Century 1:58:33 First Appearance of Mecca 1:59:31 Pfander Research 2:04:21 Closing Prayer + Final Statement
@@lorenzochimelis7359 "Historical tell us where does the new excrement tell us the tomb of the patriarchs is?" - If it was important for us to know where the tombs or graves were of the patriarch's the bible would have mentioned it but it does not.
@@Thanos-kp5jrby the way the Bible does mention it in the Old Excrement but it’s differed by the New fresh Excrement the original OLD EXCREMENT mentions the original sight which is there today and is one of the most popular tourist attractions in Israel and the NEW EXCREMENT mentions another sight far away from its present ancient location ...... NOT IMPORTANT HUH ..... could not resist throwing this in ..... be well sir!!
what devastation Jay smith say anything without any prove..He admit the Birmingham Maniscpt..is from seven century same as islam begin carbon dating say: (580-640) islam revelation start 609 ends 632 AD in the same frame and the 3 surat are Exactly as the current Quran he said No they are stories from the bible..but in the bible they do not exist and specially in the style of writing and the content of the text..can he prove that are from the bible he did not just because he was Destroyed by the fact. Quran is Reveletion in arabic from Mohamed sas.
I get the reason why the founders of Islam called for hate and violence against the critics. They knew it was all deception. It was a good tool for subjugation but the wonder is how an educated person of today stays enslaved therein! Hard work is needed!
Lol, the Internet is destroying Islam as we speak!!!!! Even the Muslim despots couldn't have imagined such a powerful tool. What is done in the dark will be brought to the light.
@riadanabtawi5880 We are speaking the very same thing about the Qur'an, it preaches hate and Islamic domination. Are you a troll? You're definitely not a Muslim. Probably a Western liberal.
Jay Smith is extremely important for understanding the very beginnings of what is today called Islam. The results of his scientific research in the field of the history of the first versions of the Quran and "Islam" in 6th-7th-8th century Arabian Peninsula and today's Israel/Palestine/Jordan is mind-blowing, eye opening, shocking. It will change your whole perspective on Islam. Everything by professor J Smith on RUclips is a must watch. Must hear.
@@JesusisaMuslim I know, it's because Muhammad was a Christian. Jewish-Christian. After accepting it after being born and raised in the Qureishi tribe, of course. The latest historical findings prove that. That's why he or rather his first followers created a compilation of abbreviated Christian and Jewish texts, translated from Aramaic, called the Qur'an. Your RUclips profile name is, indeed, onto something. It's just that, it's not that "Jesus is a Muslim". It's the other way around. Muhammad is Christian.
@@mohamadromzee7394 I actually started by reading the Quran and then over onto the Islam's most holy books. And then decided not to be "Dina Myopic" and then I discovered professor Jay Smith, and that's when I discovered the real truth.
God bless you Both and your ministry! Please continue to Spread the Truth of islaaam, the religion of No Holiness, No Righteousness and No Salvation! Jesus is Lord and the Only Way to the Father!
@@RafikKhan-ol4zk Ignorance is Bliss in islaaam! Father God! You do understand that I believe in a Triune God! Unlike the Best of Deceivers allah and your Pedo False Prophet named mo! Remember God is Holy and Righteous your allah is Neither! Do some research before you try to be funny! You know what's Funny the Tale of the ZamZam Well! Do you believe the Tale?
#ReasonedAnswers #JaySmith Thank You Both For All Your Tiredless Work for Our Lord, May Our Risen Lord Always Watch Over You and Your Families, Thank You For Amazing Stream, You Are Great Team Brothers🙏
From my post, Can Allah's Words be Changed? The Quran says No, Muslims say Yes. S 6:34 And messengers were called liars before you but they were patient concerning what they were accused of lying and they were harmed until our help came to them. And none changes Allah’s words and some news of the commissaries has come to you. S 6:115 And your lord’s word was fulfilled in truth and justice. None changes his words and he is the hearer, the learned. S 10:64 Theirs is the good news in the dunya life and in the hereafter. There is no change to Allah’s words. That is the great win. S 18:27 And read what you have been inspired with of your lord’s book. None changes his words and you will not find a refuge instead of him.
The two Muhammads, i.e. the Jewish Muhammad and the "John of Damascus" Muhammad are new to me. I definitely have to look into that. Oh my word - This is GREAT STUFF !!!
16:20 so encouraging about the Angels. I have been praying for Bob and Chris and our other warriors at SC for some time, but have just been inspired to pray for angels to attend to protect
She cant be tgere as long as Shamzi and Siraj are there. They were heard saying in arabic.... that they were going to kill her. They denied it. Police are cowards and didnt do anything . They are not closely observing these two 's moves.
PRAISE GOD FOR ALL OF YOU!!!! Really appreciate your work, the call on your life, and the way GOD uses you to share the Gospel!!!! KEEP THE FAITH AND MAY GOD CONTINUE TO PROTECT YOU AND THE WORK YOU DO FOR THE KING AND HIS KINGDOM!!!
I was born as a Christian in an Islamic country and I have the experience of these bugs biting and the best medicine to reform these thugs is Jesus and preach with authority that is the only way be aggressive and comparing Jesus with Mohammed two different personalities.
The biggest tripping point for me was the differences in the prophets from the Hebrew tradition to the Islamic tradition. Islam removes all negative traits from the prophets and leaders of Israel, like completely removing the affair of David with Bethsheba, and Noah getting drunk on wine following the deluge, and numerous other examples. "Prophets are incapable of sinning because they can control themselves otherwise God wouldn't have chosen them as prophets" or some such nonsense.
And yet Muhammed himself was duped into polytheism by the devil or something like that (the satanic verses), and that is totally acceptable. So many contradictions in the Islamic tradition.
Jesus was the only person who lived without sin, but he still suffered the same temptation and even had direct contact with satan in his temptations and showed us both satans intelligence and how to defend ourselves
I love to listen to Dr. Jay. He is so passionate and dedicated to becoming our modern-day apostle. Dr. Jay doesn't usually allow comment, and it's obvious that some handle the critique that Christianity has endured for a hundred years
I'm 53 yrs and I recently learned that Insertions without historical proof disqualifies any discussion, and I can confidently defend my point that the muslim jesus is not the same Jesus from the Holy Bible by using historical proof and evidence. One is never to old to learn how to avoid making Insertions and avoid feeling lack of intelligence or common sense against scholars.
Jazakallah Jay, perhaps Bukhari created Islam? He is responsible for creating the character of the muslim prophet Mohammed 200+ years later. He is responsible for the five time prayers, mecca rituals etc. do Bukhari's original works/writings exist? Islam spread largely once it was introduced to the indian sub-continant (India, Bangladesh, Pakistan)... almost a billion Muslims reside there. They seem to have taken up the role of protectors of Islam once they were Arabized.
Jay Smith. the Patriarch of Christian refutation of the heresy of islam. May his living memory extend long into the years. May the Blessed Savior of the Cross be merciful to him.
I always thought it was weird that they didn’t just use the oldest Qiraat which is Ibn Amir. At least it is supposed to be. He died before the Umayyad were thrown out and lived in their capital.
My understanding is it is pure historical accident that the Hafs became dominant and that it was because the first person to typeset the Quran (i.e. use a printing press to make huge number of copies) just happened to have that version on hand. By 1923 when the Quran was "standardized," Hafs was already the defacto standard. The problem, however, was that individual printings of Hafs varied slightly.
@Mohamad Romzee Blogging Theology is a brazen deceiver. Easy to see through his deceit if you care to. I have a Quran with 116 chapters. Has PW or EF mentioned theses?
@@mohamadromzee7394 Still waiting for the day you stop being a coward and agree to discuss any of you theories with me live. I guess we can just assume you have no confidence and are only trying to convince yourself by repeating lies over and over again?
You have God's heart of love for humanity. God bless you and your wife for this great effort. You'll reap bountifully because I see the HolySpirit reaching out to such zealous people.
It makes sense that Satan would have used a ruler instead of a desert dweller to put his Islamic plan into action that then created an abimination of a man that has been the root of many problems in the world.
List of Quran versions and where some are available. A few are almost the same but different prinring/editing. 1, Qaloon (Qalun) Qur'an. Amazon, book, Google play. 2, Al- susi(ibn-katheer) Qur'an ☆4 3,Khaled QUR'AN 4,Idrees QUR'AN 5, Warsh (Qalun) Qur'an 6, Hafs Ad- Dury (Abu - Amro alBasri) QUR'AN (1924 version, out of print? Used only?) ☆1 7,Al- Laith QUR'AN 8,Al- Bazzi Qur'an 9,Al- Azraq QUR'AN 10,As - Susi (Abu Amro alBasri) QUR'AN 11,Ad - Dury(alkisa'i) QUR'AN 12, Ibn shanboodh Qur'an 3,Al- Asbahaani QUR'AN 14,Hisham QUR'AN 15,Ibn Dhakwan QUR'AN 16,Isa BinWardan QUR'AN 17,Sulayman QUR'AN 18, Ibn Jammaz QUR'AN 19,Ahmad bin Farah QUR'AN 20,Qunbul Qur'an 21,Showba QUR'AN 22, Ruwais QUR'AN 23,Shujaa' bin Abi Nasr Al- Balakhi QUR'AN 24, Abu Amro Al -Ala QUR'AN 25,Hafs QUR'AN 1924 Cairo ☆1 edition 26, Ruh QUR'AN 27, Al- Dury(Al Hasan AlBasri) QUR'AN 28, Hafs Al - Dury(ibn kathir) QUR'AN 29,khalf QUR'AN 30,Ishaq QUR'AN 31,Al Hasan bin Said Al- Matuu'l QUR'AN 32, Abu- Farah Al- Shan - budhi QUR'AN 33,Ibn Masud QUR'AN 34,Ubai kab QUR'AN 35, Ibn Abbas QUR'AN 36,Abu Musa QUR'AN 37,Hafs QUR'AN 1982 edition ☆1
Thaddeus, Strongs G2280: large hearted, courageous! The heart of the Priest, the boldness of a King! May our Lord Christ Jesus continue to guide into the fulness of Sonship, my brother! Amen✝️
46:25 The only text you can remember is the text written on music like psalms. And learned from an early age. The rest is chinese wispers. Even those with a great memory know that.
Sources of Quran. Satan denies bowing down to Adam: cave of treasures. Jesus making clay birds: infancy gospel of Thomas. Seven sleepers of Ephesus 😂.. Targum sheba.. apocalypse of Abraham. And more
Could it not be 🤔 that the earliest mosques facing Petra or Jerusalem , weren't build as mosques.They could have been jewish synagogues , christian churches or nabatean temples. The Nabateans were a folk of international merchants.Which were later usurped by Muslims. It is easier to just overtake already build temples or churches than building completely new. Muslims don't have any problems to convert churches, synagogues, temples into mosques, what they don't allow is to ever give them back to the former religious groups, in case they don't use them anymore as mosques.
I know Jay Smith and others may have already discussed this in other videos about the early Arab coins, but what about the western liberal narrative that the Arabs just adopted the currencies of their conquered territories? As they claim that the Arabs had no government, currency and no economy of their own, etc. I couldn’t find a Muslim answer to the coins with crosses. Surely this contradicts the importance the academics and the Quran place on Mecca as the most important city in the 6th century?
Quran have went through many scriptural changes. The original name of the Islamic religion is called the Suen a.k.a SIN religion. Summara archeological records on Summara gods explains the origin of Islam. Also check the Pakanstanchristiampost/Allah. It explains why the Quran paraphrased biblical verses of the bible.
No to Chinese whispers! That’s not how oral tradition works. In the game, people make lots of noise as pairs whisper. Repetition isn’t allowed. The game doesn’t represent how oral accuracy works. This is not to say you are wrong in your claim, but this is poor evidence. Oral learners can and do learn and recite information accurately over long periods of time.
there are 30 different Standard Arabic Qiraat versions of the Quran listed on Wikipedia - Hafs isn't even one of the first ten. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qira%27at#The_readings The people working with Hatun and Jay have identified about 7 different version of the Hafs an Aasim version of the Quran too.
@@ReasonedAnswers Yes, they haven't got rid of everything yet though I'm told it has got worse and things like the truth about the banu Qurayza massacre seem to have had some definite editing to suit the Muslim narrative. But we can still find stuff like: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sleepers#Account_in_the_Quran and en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhu_al-Qarnayn#Alexander_the_Great complete with a coin of Alexander showing one of his horns. Take a big view en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhu_al-Qarnayn#/media/File:Alexander-Coin.jpg God bless you.
@@Thanos-kp5jr nope...totally an unsafe assumption cos I don't fancy pre-pubescent kids, nor would beating my wife (lightly) give me any pleasure, as for muta, I may have enjoyed it if I wasn't totally dedicated to my creator with a new/circumcised heart
Hi a Muslim friend of mine was being kinda a idiot yesterday and horrible and he sent me this afterwards what does this mean can some one elaborate please 🙏
I don't know why or how you could want to save pieces of crap like that who attacked you. Its utterly satanic. It's either stupidity or God's divine work. But I couldn't or wouldn't go where I would get beaten up high lighting how evil Islam is.
You should do the same scrutiny with the Protestant denominations including Lutheranism, Calvinism and the Anglican sect all beginning with pretenders without any Church authority.
I agree with the bible but what you say in 29:56 is a bit iffy because we have Rev 22:19 And if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the holy city, and from the things which are written in this book. and also Deu_12:32; Jos_1:7; Pro_30:6; Ecc_12:13; Mat_5:18, Mat_5:43, Mat_15:2-9; Mar_7:1-13; Gal_3:15;
I wish Thaddeus starts taking an aggressive stands towards islam. like us Indians, Jay is very aggressive towards islam. puts them on the defensive. Come on Thaddeus. just erase all nice guy symptoms and think like an Indian. you cannot win a war trying to be a nice guy.
I would not say so. Because although there is some claim to similarity the identity is different. Isa is a created being just a man. Jesus whose name means salvation is the eternal son of God incarnate in the flesh; God incarnate. The alpha and omega. It’s like saying the quranic Allah is the same as YHWH. While Muslims claim Allah is the same God- the identity is so very different.
Truth. Quran refers to you as the"Unlearned." Islam is the truth and will prevail over all religions. QURAN ABRAHAM NEVER SAID HE WAS A CHRISTIAN OR JEW, BUT HE WAS ONE INCLINING TOWARDS THE TRUH."
The oral tradition criticism seems very biased. The Books of Moses were written at least 600 hundred years after Moses but jay criticizes a 200 year oral tradition because it comes from Islam
Where did you get your "at least 600 years" claim? Even the most critical scholars would say "about 600" from the purported time of Moses, but they would also say Moses didn't exist... and I'm sure Jay doesn't agree with such conclusions
@@ReasonedAnswers it’s as far as I am aware a large consensus among scholars of all backgrounds that the Books of Moses weren’t written until the Babilonian exile
"The 66-book Bible is an 16th century innovation by Martin Luther. He also tried to delete Romans and James and Revelation." - What evidence do you have that Martin Luther tried to delete/remove Romans, James and Revelation? The burden of proof is on you since you who made the claim.
Its too late to fight Islam for all methods u hv used to fight Islam au not tired coz the more fight it the more come to learn about it and the more it spread rapidly and will dominate the world whether you want or not coz it blessed by God
@mysotiras 018 agreed no point in fighting over trivial stuff n making things easy for the Islamist thugs to make inroads using this division among the faithful… as it is we have the secular liberals n atheist giving them Islamic goons a platform to rub the Christian faith underfoot n into the ground
surah rahman : 66 which of your lords favors do you deny jinns and human beings. Allhamdulillah the west has wasted alot of money on projects like Jay Smith but wow Allah is true. Do you know what he says in the Noble Quran, Surah Tobah Aya 32: They want to extinguish Allah's Light with their mouths, but Allah will not allow except that His Light should be perfected even though the disbelievers hate (it) you claim that quran is false prove it wrong by attempting its challenge posed in surah 2 : 23, any you cannot. islam has risen not to over 2 billion followers. Hey Jay and your team you need to revisit. your not doing a good job. maybe you need more money from donors and sponsors. or you should be fired by them. you cant fight the Quran, many tried and failed and you failed the day you started and booked a place in the hell fire. sahih buhari 109
Until either religion unconvers the actual god those doctrines describes one is just as fake as the other. Neither has given any indication that what it says is the truth .
@@ReasonedAnswersWas not asking you to talk because all you are going to do is hand me a bunch of bs and tap dance around not having the kind of evidence you know should be there but isn't. What did you think I meant by actual god if you were talking about the Bible and Koran? Playing games already so no we do not have to talk.
The same that you Christians say about the Quran and Mohamed, wich is good, can be sayd about the gospels. There's no way that Mathew new greek koine. According to what is knoewd that gospel was written 60 years after the so called death of Jesus. What age ad him at that time? He was a tax collector we may presume that he was a growen up man already when Jesus died... So after 60 years what age? 85, 90, 100? Neverless he ad time to learn Greek as it was spoken in Alexandry...
_"There's no way that Mathew new greek koine. "_ LOL, Koine Greek was the lingua franc of the day. Virtually everyone knew it and Matthew, in particular, would have had to know it as a tax collector working for the Roman empire. _"According to what is knoewd that gospel was written 60 years after the so called death of Jesus. "_ I know math is hard, but the year 60 AD (the best guess as to when Matthew was written) is not "60 years after Jesus died." I am not aware of a single scholar who would date Matthew as late as the 90s, but even 60 years after an event is a short amount of time in the field of ancient history. By this "standard," you can't know anything about ancient history. Maybe you should stop getting "arguments" off a random atheist conspiracy theory website and start doing some real research,
Oh really? I bet I can name 5 imams that converted to Christianity for every 1 pastor who converted to Christianity. You up for that bet, or are you just desperately trying to distract from actually relevant facts that prove Islam is false no matter how many people allegedly convert to it?
Islam is dying and there is NOTHING you can do about it. Hatun who is Jay's Smith own colleague have already converted 17 imams ... lol 66.7% of mosque are shutting down an Iran, 400,000 apostasy to Pakistan and 25% of Islamic youth in the west leave Islam.
'Jesus Christ cannot be son of himself" - i agree you see terms like Father and Son are relational, that means a Father cannot be a Father without a Son and a Son cannot be a Son without a Father. And besides no Christian believes that Jesus is a Son unto himself.
How you can compare the Bible with Quran? In Bible there are many issues simply against the modern science whereas in the Hole Quran you will find none. Ref. Dr. Morris Bukaily's Bibel Koran and science.
Bible is a book with 50.000 lies and funny jokes. This book is also insult their gods. Read John 3:16. It says Jesus the only begotten son of Bible gods. What begotten means?
surah rahman : 66 which of your lords favors do you deny jinns and human beings. Allhamdulillah the west has wasted alot of money on projects like Jay Smith but wow Allah is true. Do you know what he says in the Noble Quran, Surah Tobah Aya 32: They want to extinguish Allah's Light with their mouths, but Allah will not allow except that His Light should be perfected even though the disbelievers hate (it) you claim that quran is false prove it wrong by attempting its challenge posed in surah 2 : 23, any you cannot. islam has risen not to over 2 billion followers. Hey Jay and your team you need to revisit. your not doing a good job. maybe you need more money from donors and sponsors. or you should be fired by them. you cant fight the Quran, many tried and failed and you failed the day you started and booked a place in the hell fire. sahih buhari 109
Many thanks to Jay Smith for honoring me by coming on the channel. Special thanks to Phil2:10 and keezenoom for the superchats and to everyone who joined live despite some stiff competition. To everyone - Muslim, Christian, or otherwise - I encourage you to pursue Truth whenever it leads. To any Muslim who wants to respond to this material (or anything else), email me at thaddeus@reasonedanswers.com and I'll set up a time for a friendly live chat!
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro & Prayer
2:23 Jay Smith's Story
13:47 Evidence that Islam is False
19:32 Dangerous Qs for Islam
23:35 Problems with The Quran
29:00 Comparing The Bible
32:50 Quran Not Preserved + Errors
36:23 Chat Qs
40:00 Sources The Quran comes from
42:10 Memorizing Quran Lie
49:15 Quran Versions
51:49 Quran Standardized in 1924 + 4000 Changes
58:11 Oral Tradition of Bible vetted
1:00:31 Mohammad info
1:03:09 Bio of Muhammad
1:09:05 Scholarly Books on Muhammad/Quran
1:15:01 Critical apparatus of Quran
1:20:47 Quran Contradictions
1:30:14 Yeshua in Arabic
1:31:00 Ask Questions to Muslims
1:44:33 Qiblas - Dan Gibson's book
1:50:18 Dan Gibson's Series on Jay's channel
1:52:02 No Evidence for Islam in 7th Century
1:58:33 First Appearance of Mecca
1:59:31 Pfander Research
2:04:21 Closing Prayer + Final Statement
@@lorenzochimelis7359 No evidence of Islam in the 7th century says it all really.
@@lorenzochimelis7359 "Historical tell us where does the new excrement tell us the tomb of the patriarchs is?" - If it was important for us to know where the tombs or graves were of the patriarch's the bible would have mentioned it but it does not.
@@Thanos-kp5jr your not even worth a reply be well by a brain 🧠
@@Thanos-kp5jrby the way the Bible does mention it in the Old Excrement but it’s differed by the New fresh Excrement the original OLD EXCREMENT mentions the original sight which is there today and is one of the most popular tourist attractions in Israel and the NEW EXCREMENT mentions another sight far away from its present ancient location ...... NOT IMPORTANT HUH ..... could not resist throwing this in ..... be well sir!!
@@lorenzochimelis7359 so whats your evidence?
Great collab, Dr. jay smith historical critique is devastating to Islam god bless both of you 🙏🏼
what devastation Jay smith say anything without any prove..He admit the Birmingham Maniscpt..is from seven century same as islam begin carbon dating say: (580-640) islam revelation start 609 ends 632 AD in the same frame and the 3 surat are Exactly as the current Quran he said No they are stories from the bible..but in the bible they do not exist and specially in the style of writing and the content of the text..can he prove that are from the bible he did not just because he was Destroyed by the fact. Quran is Reveletion in arabic from Mohamed sas.
G-d bless you Thaddeus. You always bring me to tears starting with your lovely prayer.
I get the reason why the founders of Islam called for hate and violence against the critics. They knew it was all deception. It was a good tool for subjugation but the wonder is how an educated person of today stays enslaved therein! Hard work is needed!
Exactly. Islam was founded as a system of political domination and fundamentally remains that to this day.
Lol, the Internet is destroying Islam as we speak!!!!! Even the Muslim despots couldn't have imagined such a powerful tool. What is done in the dark will be brought to the light.
You're spewing hate here.
@riadanabtawi5880 We are speaking the very same thing about the Qur'an, it preaches hate and Islamic domination. Are you a troll? You're definitely not a Muslim. Probably a Western liberal.
Amazing that Jay's wife was key to lead him onto mission work with Islam. I never knew that.
That proves women are evil as Islam teaches. LOL
Great discussion! Jay's sort of like a walking Encyclopedia or like a chatGPT. Ask a question and out pops a relevant reply.
Jay Smith is extremely important for understanding the very beginnings of what is today called Islam.
The results of his scientific research in the field of the history of the first versions of the Quran and "Islam" in 6th-7th-8th century Arabian Peninsula and today's Israel/Palestine/Jordan is mind-blowing, eye opening, shocking. It will change your whole perspective on Islam.
Everything by professor J Smith on RUclips is a must watch. Must hear.
@@JesusisaMuslim I know, it's because Muhammad was a Christian.
Jewish-Christian.
After accepting it after being born and raised in the Qureishi tribe, of course.
The latest historical findings prove that.
That's why he or rather his first followers created a compilation of abbreviated Christian and Jewish texts, translated from Aramaic, called the Qur'an.
Your RUclips profile name is, indeed, onto something.
It's just that, it's not that "Jesus is a Muslim".
It's the other way around.
Muhammad is Christian.
@@mohamadromzee7394 I actually started by reading the Quran and then over onto the Islam's most holy books.
And then decided not to be "Dina Myopic" and then I discovered professor Jay Smith, and that's when I discovered the real truth.
@@JesusisaMuslim Hey spam bot, when will you grow a pair and have a talk with me live?
@@ReasonedAnswers 💪 I'd love to see that!
@@JesusisaMuslim Isa is a fictional character, is not Jesus.
You are treasure troves to all humans who desire to know the truth regardless of whether they have a faith allegiance or not. GBU both.
The thing I enjoyed the most is the prayer at the end. It showed the character of Jay.
Fantastic material!
@@JesusisaMuslim YESHUA is GOD,,if you like it or Not!Your isa is a different Person if he ever exist!
I downloaded Creating the Quran from a link from one of Lloyd's videos. I've just started working my way through it.
Always appreciate and value the prayer you begin with in every livestream.
If orality works so well why did Allah have His Koran on tablets? Why wasn’t the Koran just an attribute 🤔
Ha, that is a great point I had never thought of!
Any religion that doesn't let you leave is not even worth a glance
Islam is a cult and that's why they won't allow a member to leave for fear of exposing their secrets.
What a great title! On point! 👍😁
God bless you Both and your ministry! Please continue to Spread the Truth of islaaam, the religion of No Holiness, No Righteousness and No Salvation! Jesus is Lord and the Only Way to the Father!
jesus is the Lord then whose the father
@@RafikKhan-ol4zk Ignorance is Bliss in islaaam! Father God! You do understand that I believe in a Triune God! Unlike the Best of Deceivers allah and your Pedo False Prophet named mo! Remember God is Holy and Righteous your allah is Neither! Do some research before you try to be funny! You know what's Funny the Tale of the ZamZam Well! Do you believe the Tale?
@@RafikKhan-ol4zk GOD THE FATHER ×YESHUA THE SON×HOLY SPIRIT =ONE GOD
Wow Thaddeus you have been having some amazing guests lately, how wonderful to see you fully immersed in the ministry 🤩
#ReasonedAnswers #JaySmith Thank You Both For All Your Tiredless Work for Our Lord, May Our Risen Lord Always Watch Over You and Your Families, Thank You For Amazing Stream, You Are Great Team Brothers🙏
And thank you for you wonderful moderating on so many channels. You are so kind and welcoming to so many people in the chat. GBU sis
Amen sister ❤
@@ProfYaffle she is truly one of the most precious to the online christian ministry 🕊
@@Ange0967 Blessed Holly Friday, God Bless You 🙏
From my post, Can Allah's Words be Changed?
The Quran says No, Muslims say Yes.
S 6:34 And messengers were called liars before you but they were patient concerning what they were accused of lying and they were harmed until our help came to them. And none changes Allah’s words and some news of the commissaries has come to you.
S 6:115 And your lord’s word was fulfilled in truth and justice. None changes his words and he is the hearer, the learned.
S 10:64 Theirs is the good news in the dunya life and in the hereafter. There is no change to Allah’s words. That is the great win.
S 18:27 And read what you have been inspired with of your lord’s book. None changes his words and you will not find a refuge instead of him.
Great video!! You should do a pt2 ppl had good questions. Thank you for this information. God bless you and your ministry ❤🙏✝️
Great interview! Thanks.
The two Muhammads, i.e. the Jewish Muhammad and the "John of Damascus" Muhammad are new to me. I definitely have to look into that. Oh my word - This is GREAT STUFF !!!
16:20 so encouraging about the Angels.
I have been praying for Bob and Chris and our other warriors at SC for some time, but have just been inspired to pray for angels to attend to protect
Note: Hatun has not been at SC for some time as far as I know
She cant be tgere as long as Shamzi and Siraj are there. They were heard saying in arabic.... that they were going to kill her. They denied it. Police are cowards and didnt do anything . They are not closely observing these two 's moves.
PRAISE GOD FOR ALL OF YOU!!!!
Really appreciate your work, the call on your life, and the way GOD uses you to share the Gospel!!!! KEEP THE FAITH AND MAY GOD CONTINUE TO PROTECT YOU AND THE WORK YOU DO FOR THE KING AND HIS KINGDOM!!!
I was born as a Christian in an Islamic country and I have the experience of these bugs biting and the best medicine to reform these thugs is Jesus and preach with authority that is the only way be aggressive and comparing Jesus with Mohammed two different personalities.
More great content Thaddeus. Love hearing from Jay. Thaddeus your patience and generosity distinguishes your channel from every other youtube.
The biggest tripping point for me was the differences in the prophets from the Hebrew tradition to the Islamic tradition. Islam removes all negative traits from the prophets and leaders of Israel, like completely removing the affair of David with Bethsheba, and Noah getting drunk on wine following the deluge, and numerous other examples.
"Prophets are incapable of sinning because they can control themselves otherwise God wouldn't have chosen them as prophets" or some such nonsense.
They needed to do so in order to claim their prophet was infallable.
And yet Muhammed himself was duped into polytheism by the devil or something like that (the satanic verses), and that is totally acceptable. So many contradictions in the Islamic tradition.
Jesus was the only person who lived without sin, but he still suffered the same temptation and even had direct contact with satan in his temptations and showed us both satans intelligence and how to defend ourselves
They don't seem to have sanitised Mohammed's character. He is known as a soldier, a trickster and a paedophile.
Thanks to both, very interesting show!
PS. shame on Shamoun for treating audience like babies, and banning people all the time!
Thanks Jay Smith you are the best very informative and Truth will prevail, Islam is false religion
I love to listen to Dr. Jay. He is so passionate and dedicated to becoming our modern-day apostle.
Dr. Jay doesn't usually allow comment, and it's obvious that some handle the critique that Christianity has endured for a hundred years
❤❤Tell Dr. Smith to slow down. I can't write as fast as he is talking. Hahaha. Be blessed.❤❤
I'm 53 yrs and I recently learned that Insertions without historical proof disqualifies any discussion, and I can confidently defend my point that the muslim jesus is not the same Jesus from the Holy Bible by using historical proof and evidence. One is never to old to learn how to avoid making Insertions and avoid feeling lack of intelligence or common sense against scholars.
Jazakallah Jay, perhaps Bukhari created Islam? He is responsible for creating the character of the muslim prophet Mohammed 200+ years later. He is responsible for the five time prayers, mecca rituals etc. do Bukhari's original works/writings exist? Islam spread largely once it was introduced to the indian sub-continant (India, Bangladesh, Pakistan)... almost a billion Muslims reside there. They seem to have taken up the role of protectors of Islam once they were Arabized.
With more lies islame still dies 🤔🤔😁
Coming up next….Christianity.
@@davestr7031 Why are you here?
@@TM_AZ because I want to be.
Truth is catching up with the lies of Mohamed, all eyes will open to the truth
Beautiful. God bless you Jay.
Jay Smith. the Patriarch of Christian refutation of the heresy of islam. May his living memory extend long into the years. May the Blessed Savior of the Cross be merciful to him.
My favorite brother in christ
The ads are hilarious considering
The disclosure about the German origin of the Life of Muhammed is awesome! So, will Thomas Alexander make videos about it?
the beauty of the bible is it has predicted that someone will add word or phrases and given a warning Revelation 22:18-19
The problem with attacking the historicity of Mohammad is you can’t criticize someone who didn’t exist no matter how bad he was...I mean, wasn’t.
I always thought it was weird that they didn’t just use the oldest Qiraat which is Ibn Amir. At least it is supposed to be. He died before the Umayyad were thrown out and lived in their capital.
My understanding is it is pure historical accident that the Hafs became dominant and that it was because the first person to typeset the Quran (i.e. use a printing press to make huge number of copies) just happened to have that version on hand. By 1923 when the Quran was "standardized," Hafs was already the defacto standard. The problem, however, was that individual printings of Hafs varied slightly.
@Mohamad Romzee Blogging Theology is a brazen deceiver. Easy to see through his deceit if you care to.
I have a Quran with 116 chapters. Has PW or EF mentioned theses?
@Mohamad Romzee Google it. Its easy to find the truth if you are honest. I'm not a home right now. Don't have my Quran
@@mohamadromzee7394 Still waiting for the day you stop being a coward and agree to discuss any of you theories with me live. I guess we can just assume you have no confidence and are only trying to convince yourself by repeating lies over and over again?
😂😂😂 you don't know what the qiraat means..how can you talk about something that you don't know?
Wow...d sngel thing is so heartwarming to hear
You have God's heart of love for humanity. God bless you and your wife for this great effort. You'll reap bountifully because I see the HolySpirit reaching out to such zealous people.
*Love from India 😘*
So informative. Thank you both so much
It makes sense that Satan would have used a ruler instead of a desert dweller to put his Islamic plan into action that then created an abimination of a man that has been the root of many problems in the world.
List of Quran versions and where some are available. A few are almost the same but different prinring/editing.
1, Qaloon (Qalun) Qur'an. Amazon, book, Google play.
2, Al- susi(ibn-katheer) Qur'an ☆4
3,Khaled QUR'AN
4,Idrees QUR'AN
5, Warsh (Qalun) Qur'an
6, Hafs Ad- Dury (Abu - Amro alBasri) QUR'AN (1924 version, out of print? Used only?) ☆1
7,Al- Laith QUR'AN
8,Al- Bazzi Qur'an
9,Al- Azraq QUR'AN
10,As - Susi (Abu Amro alBasri) QUR'AN
11,Ad - Dury(alkisa'i) QUR'AN
12, Ibn shanboodh Qur'an
3,Al- Asbahaani QUR'AN
14,Hisham QUR'AN
15,Ibn Dhakwan QUR'AN
16,Isa BinWardan QUR'AN
17,Sulayman QUR'AN
18, Ibn Jammaz QUR'AN
19,Ahmad bin Farah QUR'AN
20,Qunbul Qur'an
21,Showba QUR'AN
22, Ruwais QUR'AN
23,Shujaa' bin Abi Nasr Al- Balakhi QUR'AN
24, Abu Amro Al -Ala QUR'AN
25,Hafs QUR'AN 1924 Cairo ☆1 edition
26, Ruh QUR'AN
27, Al- Dury(Al Hasan AlBasri) QUR'AN
28, Hafs Al - Dury(ibn kathir) QUR'AN
29,khalf QUR'AN
30,Ishaq QUR'AN
31,Al Hasan bin Said Al- Matuu'l QUR'AN
32, Abu- Farah Al- Shan - budhi QUR'AN
33,Ibn Masud QUR'AN
34,Ubai kab QUR'AN
35, Ibn Abbas QUR'AN
36,Abu Musa QUR'AN
37,Hafs QUR'AN 1982 edition ☆1
Dr Jay i cant help but feel you are enjoying your work a biit too much 😉
It is wrong for us to name our guardian angels. Naming a creature implies that you are its master.
Thaddeus, Strongs G2280: large hearted, courageous!
The heart of the Priest, the boldness of a King! May our Lord Christ Jesus continue to guide into the fulness of Sonship, my brother! Amen✝️
46:25 The only text you can remember is the text written on music like psalms. And learned from an early age.
The rest is chinese wispers. Even those with a great memory know that.
Way too many ads! The number of ads in this video ruined the flow of the video
Sources of Quran. Satan denies bowing down to Adam: cave of treasures. Jesus making clay birds: infancy gospel of Thomas. Seven sleepers of Ephesus 😂.. Targum sheba.. apocalypse of Abraham. And more
Could it not be 🤔 that the earliest mosques facing Petra or Jerusalem , weren't build as mosques.They could have been jewish synagogues , christian churches or nabatean temples. The Nabateans were a folk of international merchants.Which were later usurped by Muslims. It is easier to just overtake already build temples or churches than building completely new. Muslims don't have any problems to convert churches, synagogues, temples into mosques, what they don't allow is to ever give them back to the former religious groups, in case they don't use them anymore as mosques.
My salut to you JS
I know Jay Smith and others may have already discussed this in other videos about the early Arab coins, but what about the western liberal narrative that the Arabs just adopted the currencies of their conquered territories?
As they claim that the Arabs had no government, currency and no economy of their own, etc. I couldn’t find a Muslim answer to the coins with crosses.
Surely this contradicts the importance the academics and the Quran place on Mecca as the most important city in the 6th century?
Quran have went through many scriptural changes. The original name of the Islamic religion is called the Suen a.k.a SIN religion. Summara archeological records on Summara gods explains the origin of Islam. Also check the Pakanstanchristiampost/Allah. It explains why the Quran paraphrased biblical verses of the bible.
Where can we find the PhD thesis on tha Quran Dr Smith mentioned?
Islam is projected as a perfect religion with a perfect prophet ... pah !
Are you serious? Thaddeus is in his 40's? I thought you must be in your 20's. You look so young!
If anything happen to this speakers be it they are murdered or going to jail, that only prove the violence of the 7 AD religion.
No to Chinese whispers! That’s not how oral tradition works. In the game, people make lots of noise as pairs whisper. Repetition isn’t allowed. The game doesn’t represent how oral accuracy works. This is not to say you are wrong in your claim, but this is poor evidence. Oral learners can and do learn and recite information accurately over long periods of time.
We are havins a diskuccion here in Denmark, where muslims claim, Jay smith dont know arabic. What is the truth?
Blind follower open your eyes Jesus is our savior ❤
there are 30 different Standard Arabic Qiraat versions of the Quran listed on Wikipedia - Hafs isn't even one of the first ten. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qira%27at#The_readings
The people working with Hatun and Jay have identified about 7 different version of the Hafs an Aasim version of the Quran too.
Awesome, I didn't realize Wikipedia was on top of this.
Quick download it before it goes
@@ReasonedAnswers Yes, they haven't got rid of everything yet though I'm told it has got worse and things like the truth about the banu Qurayza massacre seem to have had some definite editing to suit the Muslim narrative.
But we can still find stuff like:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sleepers#Account_in_the_Quran
and en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhu_al-Qarnayn#Alexander_the_Great complete with a coin of Alexander showing one of his horns. Take a big view en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhu_al-Qarnayn#/media/File:Alexander-Coin.jpg
God bless you.
Mmm, so Jay's got d jungle fever like me😊. Once u go black, there ain't no going back bruh😉
"Mmm, so Jay's got d jungle fever like me. Once u go black, there ain't no going back bruh" - So it is safe to assume that you are Muslim?
@@Thanos-kp5jr nope...totally an unsafe assumption cos I don't fancy pre-pubescent kids, nor would beating my wife (lightly) give me any pleasure, as for muta, I may have enjoyed it if I wasn't totally dedicated to my creator with a new/circumcised heart
Hi a Muslim friend of mine was being kinda a idiot yesterday and horrible and he sent me this afterwards what does this mean can some one elaborate please 🙏
I don't know why or how you could want to save pieces of crap like that who attacked you. Its utterly satanic. It's either stupidity or God's divine work. But I couldn't or wouldn't go where I would get beaten up high lighting how evil Islam is.
I rather listen to Jay all by himself, no offence.
Then watch his channel :P
You should do the same scrutiny with the Protestant denominations including Lutheranism, Calvinism and the Anglican sect all beginning with pretenders without any Church authority.
I agree with the bible but what you say in 29:56 is a bit iffy because we have Rev 22:19 And if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the holy city, and from the things which are written in this book. and also Deu_12:32; Jos_1:7; Pro_30:6; Ecc_12:13; Mat_5:18, Mat_5:43, Mat_15:2-9; Mar_7:1-13; Gal_3:15;
The word Muhammad on the Dome of the Rock refers to Jesus, not a Muslim warlord.
I wish Thaddeus starts taking an aggressive stands towards islam. like us Indians, Jay is very aggressive towards islam. puts them on the defensive.
Come on Thaddeus. just erase all nice guy symptoms and think like an Indian. you cannot win a war trying to be a nice guy.
Islam ✨❤️ is truth
Is Isa the Jesus Christ of the bible
I would not say so. Because although there is some claim to similarity the identity is different. Isa is a created being just a man. Jesus whose name means salvation is the eternal son of God incarnate in the flesh; God incarnate. The alpha and omega.
It’s like saying the quranic Allah is the same as YHWH. While Muslims claim Allah is the same God- the identity is so very different.
Hello Mr Smith is Prophet is Prophet Isa the Jesus Christ of the bible
No isa never exist!Yeshua is GOD
Truth. Quran refers to you as the"Unlearned." Islam is the truth and will prevail over all religions. QURAN ABRAHAM NEVER SAID HE WAS A CHRISTIAN OR JEW, BUT HE WAS ONE INCLINING TOWARDS THE TRUH."
Read the bible, the truth Word of God!Not a Bad copy!
Seek the Truth through the Bible and loving your neighbor. Your eternity depends on it. You will never be good enough through your own actions.
The oral tradition criticism seems very biased. The Books of Moses were written at least 600 hundred years after Moses but jay criticizes a 200 year oral tradition because it comes from Islam
Where did you get your "at least 600 years" claim? Even the most critical scholars would say "about 600" from the purported time of Moses, but they would also say Moses didn't exist... and I'm sure Jay doesn't agree with such conclusions
@@ReasonedAnswers it’s as far as I am aware a large consensus among scholars of all backgrounds that the Books of Moses weren’t written until the Babilonian exile
The 66-book Bible is an 16th century innovation by Martin Luther. He also tried to delete Romans and James and Revelation.
That's neither true nor relevant to anything said.
Not only false but has nothing to do with the video. Obviously you have nothing to defend your phony religion with.
"The 66-book Bible is an 16th century innovation by Martin Luther. He also tried to delete Romans and James and Revelation." - What evidence do you have that Martin Luther tried to delete/remove Romans, James and Revelation?
The burden of proof is on you since you who made the claim.
@@Thanos-kp5jr ruclips.net/user/shortstsmfwDL495Y?feature=share
Its too late to fight Islam for all methods u hv used to fight Islam au not tired coz the more fight it the more come to learn about it and the more it spread rapidly and will dominate the world whether you want or not coz it blessed by God
It is time to repent,tomorrow is maybe to late!YESHUA IS THE ONLY LIVING GOD
If it is blessed by God, don't you think this God is an extremely cruel one? He doesn't sound like God at all.
Test comment
worked
@@ReasonedAnswers thank you! :) RUclips shadow banned or something
ALLAH AKBAR
What exactly is Allah bigger than?
Bigger than falafel
The bible has 73 books sir
bible is collection of books .
kuran is hadidh, not even a book.
@Ministry of Silence 🥂🙏🏽🙌
@mysotiras 018 agreed no point in fighting over trivial stuff n making things easy for the Islamist thugs to make inroads using this division among the faithful… as it is we have the secular liberals n atheist giving them Islamic goons a platform to rub the Christian faith underfoot n into the ground
You Jay, are interpreting your way. You will remain " deaf, dumb and blind." As the quran says.surah al baqra
YESHUA IS THE ONLY LIVING GOD!
surah rahman : 66 which of your lords favors do you deny jinns and human beings. Allhamdulillah the west has wasted alot of money on projects like Jay Smith but wow Allah is true. Do you know what he says in the Noble Quran,
Surah Tobah Aya 32: They want to extinguish Allah's Light with their mouths, but Allah will not allow except that His Light should be perfected even though the disbelievers hate (it)
you claim that quran is false prove it wrong by attempting its challenge posed in surah 2 : 23,
any you cannot.
islam has risen not to over 2 billion followers. Hey Jay and your team you need to revisit. your not doing a good job. maybe you need more money from donors and sponsors. or you should be fired by them. you cant fight the Quran, many tried and failed and you failed the day you started and booked a place in the hell fire. sahih buhari 109
Until either religion unconvers the actual god those doctrines describes one is just as fake as the other. Neither has given any indication that what it says is the truth .
Do explain to us what it even means to "uncover the actual god" oh great and wise free thinker. Then we can talk.
@@ReasonedAnswersWas not asking you to talk because all you are going to do is hand me a bunch of bs and tap dance around not having the kind of evidence you know should be there but isn't. What did you think I meant by actual god if you were talking about the Bible and Koran? Playing games already so no we do not have to talk.
The same that you Christians say about the Quran and Mohamed, wich is good, can be sayd about the gospels. There's no way that Mathew new greek koine. According to what is knoewd that gospel was written 60 years after the so called death of Jesus. What age ad him at that time? He was a tax collector we may presume that he was a growen up man already when Jesus died... So after 60 years what age? 85, 90, 100? Neverless he ad time to learn Greek as it was spoken in Alexandry...
_"There's no way that Mathew new greek koine. "_ LOL, Koine Greek was the lingua franc of the day. Virtually everyone knew it and Matthew, in particular, would have had to know it as a tax collector working for the Roman empire.
_"According to what is knoewd that gospel was written 60 years after the so called death of Jesus. "_ I know math is hard, but the year 60 AD (the best guess as to when Matthew was written) is not "60 years after Jesus died." I am not aware of a single scholar who would date Matthew as late as the 90s, but even 60 years after an event is a short amount of time in the field of ancient history. By this "standard," you can't know anything about ancient history.
Maybe you should stop getting "arguments" off a random atheist conspiracy theory website and start doing some real research,
Sorry to say quran is not copied. Final revelation was sent to you christians and jews the lost sheep.
YESHUA IS THE ONLY LIVING GOD!
Whats devastating is pastors revert to islam
By the loads no matter how hard these guys lie
Oh really? I bet I can name 5 imams that converted to Christianity for every 1 pastor who converted to Christianity. You up for that bet, or are you just desperately trying to distract from actually relevant facts that prove Islam is false no matter how many people allegedly convert to it?
@@ReasonedAnswers go on then son name me 5 imams that's imams
Not no xmuslim who don't even be Muslims from the start and I'll show a few good pastors
@@majidali365 look at Iran !Dont you know,how many muslims go to the mosque,but still pray to Yeshua!
Islam is dying and there is NOTHING you can do about it. Hatun who is Jay's Smith own colleague have already converted 17 imams ... lol
66.7% of mosque are shutting down an Iran, 400,000 apostasy to Pakistan and 25% of Islamic youth in the west leave Islam.
Jesus Christ can not be son of himself
Cool, good thing literally no one believes he is. Now, can you explain why Islam's history is obviously made up and you don't care?
'Jesus Christ cannot be son of himself" - i agree you see terms like Father and Son are relational, that means a Father cannot be a Father without a Son and a Son cannot be a Son without a Father. And besides no Christian believes that Jesus is a Son unto himself.
A liar non ethical monopoly speaker
Facts????
How you can compare the Bible with Quran?
In Bible there are many issues simply against the modern science whereas in the Hole Quran you will find none.
Ref. Dr. Morris Bukaily's Bibel Koran and science.
🙈🙈🙈
Bible is a book with 50.000 lies and funny jokes. This book is also insult their gods. Read John 3:16. It says Jesus the only begotten son of Bible gods. What begotten means?
All your Blasphemie you must say to Yeshua, he allready answers to you,but you cant hear him!Your soul is lost,without Yeshua!
The book The People versus Muhammad is by J. K. Sheindlin and not by J. Schindlin.
surah rahman : 66 which of your lords favors do you deny jinns and human beings. Allhamdulillah the west has wasted alot of money on projects like Jay Smith but wow Allah is true. Do you know what he says in the Noble Quran,
Surah Tobah Aya 32: They want to extinguish Allah's Light with their mouths, but Allah will not allow except that His Light should be perfected even though the disbelievers hate (it)
you claim that quran is false prove it wrong by attempting its challenge posed in surah 2 : 23,
any you cannot.
islam has risen not to over 2 billion followers. Hey Jay and your team you need to revisit. your not doing a good job. maybe you need more money from donors and sponsors. or you should be fired by them. you cant fight the Quran, many tried and failed and you failed the day you started and booked a place in the hell fire. sahih buhari 109
Without Yeshua you are lost!