Every Released Portal Mod Ever* In A Tierlist
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июн 2024
- Happy 11th Anniversary to Portal 2! Originally I was gonna release the Core Hub Era video today, but things came up and information had to be redone. So take this as a complementary upload to fill the gap! Here's my (unscripted) opinions on every released Portal mod ever.
Workshop Mappacks such as Into The Multiverse and Cosmogony were not included as they're workshop releases and not full on mods, plus I have other plans for them.
*not every single one otherwise we'd be here all day
-------------------------------------------------
Join My Discord! - / discord
Follow My Twitter! - / ossyflawol
Support My Patreon! - / ossyflawol
-------------------------------------------------
MOD TIMESTAMPS;
0:00 - Intro
0:39 - Portal: Prelude
1:55 - Chell's Way To Home
3:44 - Thinking With Time Machine
5:18 - Rexaura
5:52 - Portal: Project Beta & Portal: Prospekt
7:00 - Portal: The Flash Version Mappack
8:40 - Portal Unity
10:19 - Portal: Memories
11:35 - Wibi!Data
12:45 - Portal 2: Krzyhau's Speedrun Mod
13:33 - Aperture Ireland
15:25 - Mind Escape
16:42 - Portal Epic Edition
17:12 - Gamma Energy
18:05 - Aperture TAG
19:51 - Portal: Reloaded
20:15 - Portal Pro
20:52 - Blue Portals
21:19 - Portal Stories: Mel
22:33 - Factum Solus (Episode 1 and 2)
23:28 - Outro
-------------------------------------------------
DOWNLOAD LINKS FOR EVERY MOD
Portal Prelude - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-pre...
Chell's Way To Home -www.moddb.com/mods/cwth/downl...
Thinking With Time Machine - store.steampowered.com/app/28...
Rexaura - store.steampowered.com/app/31...
Portal: Project Beta - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-pro...
Portal: Prospekt - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-pro...
Portal: The Flash Version Mappack - portalmaps.wecreatestuff.com/
Portal Unity - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-uni...
Portal: Memories - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-2-m...
Wibi!Data - www.moddb.com/mods/wibidata/d...
Speedrun Mod - krzyhau.github.io/Portal2Spee...
Aperture Ireland - www.moddb.com/mods/aperture-i...
Mind Escape - www.moddb.com/mods/mind-escap...
Portal Epic Edition - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-epi...
Gamma Energy - www.moddb.com/mods/gamma-ener...
Aperture TAG - store.steampowered.com/app/28...
Portal: Reloaded - store.steampowered.com/app/12...
Portal Pro - www.moddb.com/mods/portal-pro...
Blue Portals - www.moddb.com/mods/blue-porta...
Portal Stories: Mel - store.steampowered.com/app/31...
Factum Solus - www.moddb.com/mods/factum-solus
-------------------------------------------------
Hey everyone, the name's Ossy Flawol! 
Игры
...Though obviously, not every single one, otherwise we'd be here for eternity.
Think my opinions suck or you'd like to know more about why I rate some mods the way I did? Join my Discord! We can talk >:) discord.gg/BkppBd7
You forgot Half-Life 2: CUBE
@@portalgaming8057 it also requires Portal installed, same as CWTH, but CUBE is way better than CWTH
@Ossy Flawol You forgot Portal: Google Translate Edition
Portal_life missed
And thinking with time machine
portal has a fucking CHOKEHOLD on me rn like im foaming at the mouth scratching at the walls of my enclosure i love the silly hole game
omg same, i need more of the funny robots that give me holes
I'm surprised he didn't cover Error; I thought it was pretty important (So to speak) being one of, if not the first Portal horror map
office prank did it first and better
@@OssyFlawol Oh right! I completely forgot about Office Prank! You're right, that's better horror :)
@@OssyFlawol True, when I first played Office Prank it was a really scary experience xD I wish there were more Portal horror experiences, I really think both of the games can fit into the horror aesthetic
@@OssyFlawol office prank was actually not scary at all wym.
"Oooo spooky mannequin moves!!!!" Is not scary at all. Idk how many times that's been done before but it's never been all that scary.
Error actually had me toss my headphones off at points and legit felt unnerving.
@@OssyFlawol well error is better in my opinion
19:53 honestly i'd put reloaded in S tier for how each puzzle is just difficult enough to make you feel like a genius when you solve it. it nearly short circuits your brain, but not quite.
i wrapped around the mechanics pretty quickly, but it hurt my brain from all of the thought processing lmao
it is very comforting to know that somebody else experienced portal unity
I played it too, thought it was fairly good. portal unity anniversary sucked tho.
Chell's way to home and Thinking with time machine were made by different guys, PollL and Stridemann.
Many of the most popular Portal 1 mods came from an era where developers mistakenly thought the harder the chamber, the better the quality. (Not the puzzle itself. Good puzzles are good. I mean the obvious solution that is too difficult to do for some people).
This is what reepblue said on a stream about Blue Portals and his regrets about how he made it.
This is definitely true for Prelude.
Also, stuff like Gamma energy doesn't bring much new stuff. Just puzzles with obvious solutions that take time. Later into the game, it becomes more interesting, but it's just that it's full of chamber place fillers that are retail Portal difficulty.
The dev for Unity said he never got to finishing the P2 edition and kind of made it playable enough to release it.
Also, I wonder what you think about Hetzchase Nailway, but that mod is near unplayable for half of the game now.
>near unplayable for half the game
????
@@ashisharky Because of various Valve updates that broke mods.
@@YishaiBarr it works fine for me
@@ashisharky Maybe Ian fixed it or something.
@GoTi4No It is for the inexperienced player.
forbidden testing tracks is its own tier
Your take on Tag is the most regarded* thing I’ve heard in a long while xD
You're totally wrong about tag. The levels were really fun and well designed. Difficult but fair
I agree
I would say the same about thinking with time machine i mean the later content in the storymode is trash but i love what the community makes out of it i really enjoy it :)
I am too smooth brained and impatient to play tag the intended way.
Yeah i agree
@@klaus.sfc01official71 it's obvious that they had no idea what to do with the story, the mod was created specifically for gameplay and its new mechanics
Did you know there's a fan port of Portal: Still Alive (basically an xbox exclusive portal mod, it just has a few more chambers and such)? I bring it up because the port includes the Portal: The Flash Version Mappack by default, and has all the originally xbox exclusive aspects too.
My man doesn't edit his burps out
I like this channel but the editing does kinda suck even on the newer videos
Aperture Ireland is the funniest title for any game ever ever
i haven't really been able to play many portal mods outside of steam tbh. i only got to play portal epic edition and i have no idea how i even got it to work on a steam deck lmfao.
all i can remember is that i replaced the portal 2 files with the files in the portal epic edition and it worked. it turned portal into epic edition.
it took a while to change back though.
and the glados bossfight would crash at the halfway point.
Just got finished playing Portal Reloaded (loved it) and came here hoping to find some other good mods to try out. Looking forward to trying some of these.
Aperture Tag is A tier it's so cool
Here is a complete list of the mods not mentioned worth mentioning at the time of this video's release, in no particular order:
ERROR
Aperture Deja Vu
Hetzchace Nailway
Hazmat's Portal Mappack
Portal: Google Translate Edition
Portal 2: Reverse
Portal: Elevators
Portal: Canonical Base of RxRxR
Portal-Life
Alive & Kicking
Portal: Still Alive For PC
PORTAL RELOADED SHOULD HAVE BEEN S TIER IT IS MY FAVORITE
also aperture tag should have been higher
reloaded is S tier for me, to this day i love my solution to the final puzzle SPOILERS: there was no hint for the button after fourth gate to reveal platform used for cube return, so i solved the puzzle as there was none. I setup time traveling light bridge to fling myself to the middle, skipping barrier 1 and 2, i had to do that twice to setup my cubes, one to open barrier 3 and 4, the second cube I throw at the end, so i can push required button. I knew it was cheese solution as it skipped first two barriers, but i was too invested to making it work, and it made a unique ending for me.
hey now, aperture tag and portal prelude are one of the best games out there. There aren't so many that we are able to play plus they give a lot of their custom story. I think a lot of effort is put into them, unlike most modders who pre-announce "something big" and then leave the mod to die on the mod db website for 10 years without any updates
Portal preludes story sucks ass though. Like its genuinely only a step above hunt down the freeman
True
Thinking with time machine was my favorite, I just liked the idea. If they remade it with better chambers and not so damn short I'd love it.
Oh nice, maybe I can learn about a good mod or two I can play from this video.
Gamma Energy is one of my favorites, always nice to replay for a bit of a longer Portal experience. I thought the mechanic of sending balls through the tubes was a really cool test style, and I really liked the look of the energy balls going through the glass tubes and generators during the escape section.
What software/website did you use to make this tierlist ? Seems pretty good. Also yeah, I agree with your judgement on most of these mods
Tiermaker
id unironically put portal epic edition on S tier.
it's a shitpost mod, but it's genuinely high quality and has some pretty good ideas for the "puzzles" the only thing i ever really hated was the backtracking on chamber 4.
i can't remember if that was the cbt maps or main map though.
CBT chambers were also amazing, they're shitpost and ridiculously difficult, but the concept is genius. like the part where you use a barrel boat on the blue acid to navigate the area in chamber 13.
it's a shitpost with quality, i love that.
the rocket turrets riding manhacks is like the 2nd funniest thing in the mod, next to the manhack crates.
I wish portal stories mel aperture tag and portal reload was a DLC for prequel and sequels and remake for Xbox series X or S and ps5 and switch
I played through most of Portal Stories: Mel. A for concept and story, C for puzzles. For example, maybe I'm just an idiot or haven't played Portal in over a decade, but the very first puzzle forced me to watch a walkthrough to see how I got out of that room. Not a good start for me, but I admit I was impatient to dive into a good fleshed out story mod. The majority of puzzles were challenging but not very satisfying. I got tired before the end and just watched a playthrough of the final stretch. Good overall, but needs more polish to be really on Portal 2's level. I agree it's probably the closest a mod has gotten to that level.
I only struggled with two puzzles in the later game, one in the dilapidated part and one in the modern part, it was the one with a big fan.
It was a fun experience for me at least.
Definitely agree that rexaura is a good portal mod. The best portal 1 mod. I play it tons of times it's funny it has cool music i would actually put it on s tier. Both portal pro and rexaura are baseculy dlcs of potal 1 baseculy
In regards to TWTM, I actually softlocked myself in one of the chambers and had to restart! It's like they didn't do any playtesting!
I'm with you on TWTM. It's not at all clear sometimes what the objective is, let alone how you're supposed to get to it. Even once you figure that out there's the whole problem of pretending to hand a cube to a version of you that you can't see, pretending to carry a cube you can't see while you're recording and just having to hope that it doesn't brush against a fizzler, and also hoping that you get to where you need to go before the ten second timer that you ALSO can't see expires and the fizzlers turn back on. If you screw any of that up, it's usually back to square one, starting the level over and re-re-re-re-RE-recording your movements. The first ten minutes of every puzzle are usually spent figuring out what you're even supposed to do, the next ten are spent figuring out how you're supposed to do it, and the remaining twenty plus are spent actually trying to execute your solution without throwing your keyboard in frustration. I don't think I even got halfway into that mod before giving up.
yeah even if you figure out what to do, if you mess it up, then you have to start all over again.
i did get through the first few tests but after that i ran into this problem and started to get annoyed that i was doing the same thing over and over again
TWTM looks very very good but I agree with the puzzles.
Aperture tag is pretty good, but the few really bad levels relying on exploits ruin it, it's weird how it continues after the escape sequence, as well
i dont like factum solus but nice to see someone who likes it talk about it
Disagree on aperture tag, and portal memories. Memories would be C Tier for me, and Tag would be S tier. Guess both are probably just on preference. Mostly agree with everything else or haven't played those mods.
I think this is a pretty good tier list! I’m really happy someone put Factum Solus as a good ranked mod, some people really hate the mod and there was this one video I saw that completely hated on it. Still, this is a great tier list!
Was it by Wonderland_War_gaming?
@@Portal2Player I think so, if I remember correctly I think they made a video on my mod as well xD I do agree with some of their viewpoints though, Portal 1 mods need more attention
@@StereoCoda Yeah, personally, I think that the story is good, but there are tons of hammer issues that could be fixed to make it better. Also, what was the mod that you made?
@@Portal2Player A bit ago I worked on a mod called ERROR, there was some aspects of it that I could’ve done way better and I agree with his viewpoints on the video! For me at least hammer errors are alright as long as it doesn’t distract from the overall experience, but yea Factum Solus does have a couple of hammer errors aaaa
@@StereoCoda Ah yeah, I watched that one too. I haven't gotten around to trying it since I'm working on my own hammer project, but when I have time i'll check it out.
I agree with this. Mostly Aperture Tag. I struggled with that game.
Hah loser.
I did too
Just because one struggles with something, doesn't mean it's bad, I'd put it on "C" or "B" because I like the idea, and puzzles was fair.
That mind escape logo looking kinda sus ngl
wdym
@@KirikkSiSq What they're trying to say is that it looks vaguely like an Among Us crewmate
I do think Aperture Tag and TWTM should be a bit higher. They're more competently put together than say, Prelude, even if they aren't the best.
How hard are some of these BTW. I was able to beat Reloaded without a guide but it was brutal (especially that last chamber) and I'd like to play a few (Rexaura, Factum, Gamma Energy mainly) but I don't want to get stuck for hours/have to cheat like I did with Original Mel and Prelude (Though those were both a long time ago)
TWTM maybe B tier but Apeture Tag is easily S tier or A tier
Will you play Aperture: Salt Mines when it releases?
If...
i hope so! im putting a lot of effort into it
@@OrinjiNeko oh shit hi
@@azziea Heya ✌️
@@OrinjiNeko how much do i gotta suck suck to be a voice actor for the mod? (Im joking lmao)
I did not know Rexaura was a portal mod, I thought it was for halflife, better go check it out!
You should do a full video about Factum Solus someday
I am planning a review series later down the line, though I’m not sure if I could work Factum Solus into it, maybe in it’s Season 2…
@@OssyFlawol it would be cool if you eventually do cover it because Factum Solus is criminally underrated, and if it does appear on Season 2 then I am hyped
@@OssyFlawol maybe... Half-Life 2: CUBE?
I hear a bird squaking I hink
Are you gonna make a wibidata video sometime?
Portal prelude, portal reloaded and portal the flash version MapPack was my favs portal mods
i'm not sure but do you work on portal desolation?
👍
"only mod that broke me"
P.F.T.T make that one of the two mods
We need a playthrough/bigger video on CWTH, because it's got so much insanity but no one talks about it-- it's almost worthy of the S tier just because of how ridiculously stupid it is. I hated every single moment, had to go on god mode to finish it, it made my laptop overheat and die, and it haunts me at night. It's my favorite mod
@@portalgaming8057 It's so terrible that it's absolutely glorious man
i'm surprised so many people are disagreeing with you about aperture tag. Maybe I'm just biased because it's the only portal mod with a price tag, but i always felt like it just fell behind most other mods.
The gel gun is kinda a very limited gameplay mechanic to begin with, the artstyle was a mess, and the story was just weird.
Prelude is very good
tbh wasn't a big fan of rexaura I didn't get too bored since it was short but I was definitely done with it by like chamber 17 and was forcing myself to carry on
TWTM was really fun, the mechanic was good
I think it had a really cool and unique astetic
Yes, but it kinda sucks that there is little to no storyline
hell yeah
I agree with generally all of the ratings, maybe would push aperture tag to a low b for me personally. I thought it had a lot of charm and was different then most mods with its original gun.
how have you played even half of these mods if they're all broken for me. I can't even start it. It keeps crashing lol
One thing that's strange about Mind Escape is that the explanation on the design change only shows why there are two different designs, but not how it changed, you just go from one to the other after a BTS part in-between.
Spoilers ahead!
The answer is that the two designs come from two different universes, but there is no indication at all that you either went to the other universe or caused an alteration in your own.
There is a LOST TV series easter egg that might be the reason, but the change still happens whether you find it or not, so I don't think so.
Are we to assume that our Aperture just used the design from their counterpart in another part of the facility?
If that's the case, there's no need for a multiverse backstory to explain it.
Some people already assumed Portal 2 begins in another part of the facility with a similar but not identical test track in a different design, since the chambers are not exactly the same, and a few ones are even totally different.
I still like the mod, but that kinda makes the main motivation behind it pointless.
There is a LOST TV series easter egg because some of ME developers worked on Half-Life 2: CUBE earlier and CUBE was heavily inspired by LOST. The main easter egg of ME is huge SARMA Initiative hatch which can be unlocked by entering the code. In order to get the code, you had to find a SARMA cube inside a big car which is faced its back side to the wall in the room with 2 big cars and floating "chamber". Then, you had to take the cube with you and bring it to the TV so it would show the code. This is the code you have to enter
020163
Anagram of 163020, number of Snowdrop Escape
OTHER-LIFE is a universe where USSR continued to exist so SARMA IRI is a new organisation here. Together with Aperture, they built Object 29 "CUBE". Yeah, this reminds of Snowdrop Escape. This is because SDE developers are ME developers
@@KirikkSiSq Don't SDE and ME share a universe? And isn't that universe very loosely connected with SARMAverse?
Aperture Tag is more Low B, high C. It had fun moments, neat concept, a lot of polish, ehh jokes. It was ok, however my perspective was moved a bit with Portal Stories Mel being free and a million times better.
FINALLY SOMEONE AGREES WITH ME ON TAG!!!
Bro forgot the still alive mappack ☠️
Portal the flash version mappack isnt a mod. Its just a custom bonus map pack
you did not mention the fact aperture tag costs money?
The creators deserves it
>Portal: Prelude sucks
git gud, my friend, git gud
nomnom
YES!!! ANOTHER FACTUM SOLUS ENJOYER!!!
For me, chell's way to home was so boring I didn't even want to finish it lol. I think I got up to the submarine part until I was like "I'm done with this"
I feel like thinking with time machine wasn't bad, at least conceptually; you said the biggest part of the puzzles were the setups, but I see no issue with that, there's still puzzles, just with a different approach. I would put it at least C teir, maybe B teir. It was definitely bear bones, but I would take it over portal stories: sMells cluster yuck, over "decorated", unintuitive, broken story, poor puzzle design [which you even mentioned] pain any day; I honestly can't believe you put it S teir at all, let alone without any hesitation. Like with Crapature Tag, it had a lot of potential, but just missed it in so many ways.. instead of undershooting tho, it woefully overshot, and in all the wrong areas..(in both "versions", though there were a lot of things in the nerfed chambers that I feel like should have just been in the original..). They couldn't even be bothered to get their particle in the portal gun to not freak out when you moved.. And it had such a great team working on it, too...
(Also kind of a side point, I'm not really sure why these things have been dubbed 'mods' since they're more like fan games; even the ones that do modify the gameplay are in completely different environments/chambers, so I really don't see the correlation 🤷🏿♀️)
They are called “mods” because they require either Portal or Portal 2 to play them. If they were fan games, you wouldn’t have to buy either of them.
@@charredcobalt That's kind of irrelevant
Im making a portal mod so i hope you rate it when it comes out:)
gamer
Thinking with Time Machine: Title is kinda ass, but it is a fantastic concept and pretty good execution
What about portal error mod? Its a horror mod
Hi, Ossy.
This is too long I'm not gonna watch this sorry Ossy.
mid
I respect your opinion but I think Tag should have been a little higher also not trying to come off like a d**k but theirs some instances were you a doging on these mods look some of these people took their time and effort and money to work on something they are intrigued and interested in which they didn’t have to make most of them did it for free all I’m saying is pay more respect and don’t dog on mod authors because with out them you wouldn’t have made your video and we would not have really good story’s being told anyway have a good day or night Ossy if your reading this but I agree with the rest
>some of these people took their time and effort and money to work on something
My brother and christ, that's pretty much every mod.
>and don’t dog on mod authors because with out them you wouldn’t have made your video and we would not have really good story’s being told
So you're saying... "you cant criticize/dunk on a mod for issues/being bad, think of the work they put into it :("?
What.
@@higueraft571 Damn, didn’t think that someone would have replied to this but, here I go. I have changed my mind on a lot of thing’s I’ve said in the original comment. Obviously, I do believe that criticism isn’t bad. One reason being that it can help the mod author out in their future projects. In all honesty I do think properly criticizing the mod author’s about certain flaw in their game is good. I don’t know what was going on in my head when I made the original comment. Other than I think Tag should have been higher. I do think attacking the creator of the mod is wrong but, criticism is alway’s welcomed.
Tag literally isn't free though? It's literally the only Portal mod that costs money.
@@nuclearshill I meant most of the mod makers makes the mod’s for free. Tag is an outlier.