Cheap vs Expensive Fermenter: Does The Beer Taste Different?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 июн 2024
  • If you split a beer between two fermenters - one a plastic $25 fermenter, and the other an expensive stainless steel conical fermenter temperature controlled with glycol, how different would the resulting beer be? Let's find out!
    RECIPE KITS: www.atlanticbrewsupply.com/se...
    CLAWHAMMER BREWING SYSTEM: www.clawhammersupply.com/?aff=5
    MERCH: shop.spreadshirt.com/thehomeb...
    RECIPE FOR 6 GALLONS:
    6 lbs Pilsner; Belgian
    2 lbs Wheat Malt, Bel
    1 lbs Flaked Oats
    1 lbs Wheat, Flaked
    8.0 oz Corn Sugar (Dextrose) [Boil]
    1.50 oz Saaz Pellets [3.75 %] - Boil 60.0 min
    0.50 oz Saaz Pellets [3.75 %] - Boil 10.0 min
    1.00 oz Coriander Seed (Boil 5.0 mins)
    1.00 oz Orange Peel, Bitter (Boil 5.0 mins)
    1.0 pkg Trappist Ale (White Labs #WLP500)
    MY BREWING GEAR
    Glycol chiller: blichmannengineering.com/glycol-chiller.html
    Kegs: kegco.com/?rfsn=5154203.9e84b9
    pH meter: amzn.to/3xchxwe
    Hydrometer: amzn.to/3KtzWs1
    Grain mill: amzn.to/3Juy2Gu
    Wireless hydrometer: amzn.to/3xg4BFs
    PBW for cleaning: amzn.to/3xiaz8L
    Starsan for sanitizing: amzn.to/3v4EeQo
    MY GLASSWARE
    Tulip: amzn.to/3jpcv7C
    Stemmed: amzn.to/3rfjxjg
    Pilsner: amzn.to/3rgb9QK
    Flight paddle: amzn.to/3O11fMr
    MY VIDEO GEAR
    Main camera (Sony): amzn.to/3E1DCyI
    Second camera (Panasonic): amzn.to/371K39f
    Main lens (Sony): amzn.to/3jlbxZY
    Main lens (Panasonic): geni.us/BobhSAf
    MUSIC
    Where I get all my music (2 months free): bit.ly/3kuaLbW
    These are Amazon affiliate links. It does not cost you anything to use these links and helps support the channel. Thanks for watching!
    Created by: Martin Keen
    Business inquiries: mouseykins@gmail.com
  • ХоббиХобби

Комментарии • 365

  • @grm3
    @grm3 9 месяцев назад +17

    If you temp control one and not the other it is no longer a comparison of plastic vs stainless steel fermenters.

    • @Hawk2phreak
      @Hawk2phreak Месяц назад +2

      Wasn't really the point though. One was all the bells and whistles, one was plain.

    • @Narapoia1
      @Narapoia1 8 дней назад

      Yeah, he wasn't testing the same variable at all, pretty dumb. Beer fermented in the $900 fermenter will be rubbish without temperature control 🤷

  • @andybecker5040
    @andybecker5040 2 года назад +127

    I’d be interested to see a similar test but where the cheaper fermenter is placed in temp control. For example, the CF-5 with chiller vs cheap fermenter in a chest freezer w/ controller.

    • @wesleyhanson4564
      @wesleyhanson4564 2 года назад +10

      I agree. I ferment in a carboy in a temp controlled fridge. Once I started fermenting in a fridge the quality went up!

    • @davejf1837
      @davejf1837 2 года назад +1

      Agreed. I think they would have been even closer in color, smell and taste

    • @ianross-bain3515
      @ianross-bain3515 2 года назад +4

      Just saw this and my first thought was not a real comparison as he is not temp controlling his cheap ferementer. My beer quality improved as soon as i brought in temp control £30 quid second hand fridge and a homemade inkbird, now with real inkbird! Id e interested to know if closed transfer, pressure of ferment and shape of vessel make a difference though

    • @malzundhopfen
      @malzundhopfen 2 года назад +1

      You could also ferment in kegs, that way you can do all the fancy stuff (except for harvesting yeast, but there are also ways to do it) for a 10th of a price what a stainless steel fermenter costs.

    • @jonathanlumsdon7140
      @jonathanlumsdon7140 2 года назад +6

      You need to just change one variable at a time - you aren’t testing the fermenter, you are testing the fermenter and the glycol chiller. As someone new to brewing, I’d love to see more comparisons of cheap vs expensive like this so I know what to focus on. I’ve just got an free fridge and an inkbird for temp control. I still use a plastic fermenter and bottle condition. I’ve just switched to bottles water. I also extract brew as I’m time poor (please don’t judge me!). Just need some pointers on where to focus next!

  • @jckelley10
    @jckelley10 2 года назад +57

    I was out drinking beers with family and friends last Friday and I wondered aloud if an expensive stainless steel brewing system makes a better beer than the beer I make in my plastic fermentation buckets. I was happily surprised to see your experiment and even happier with the results!

    • @BrewMeister27
      @BrewMeister27 2 года назад +3

      Depends on what you mean by "better." An expensive fermenter setup will produce a more predictable, consistent beer. But it might taste worse than a beer fermented in a bucket.
      Open transfers after fermentation will always make a beer taste worse over time. Beer can retain its freshness for months without significant oxygen exposure. But an open transfers will reduce those months down to weeks. Especially with beers that use a lot of flavor/aroma hops.

    • @ovidiumarian6719
      @ovidiumarian6719 2 года назад

      A stainless steel equipment make your work easier to clean and sanitation of all things and the worth in the fermentor i absence of light ferment better.

    • @brandonb417
      @brandonb417 2 года назад +5

      @@BrewMeister27 This isn't always true. When I transfer into a corny I'll fill the corny with CO2 (which is heavier than air, so the O2 will get purged) and put a paper towel wet with sanitizer over the opening and slip the tube past the towel. As the beer comes up, the CO2 comes out, and any O2 in the top of the keg will get pushed out before the beer can get to it.

    • @brandonb417
      @brandonb417 2 года назад

      The biggest difference between the two fermenters is the temp control. I used to ferment in a temp controlled freezer and it did pretty well. I have since moved and instead got a brew jacket. It works really well at holding temps. There are a couple things you have to plan for in advance, like cold crashing in an actual fridge, and using a counter flow chiller to hit ferm temp before going into the fermenter. The brew jacket is very slow in moving the temps. But these results are attainable with cheaper equipment, it just takes a bit more work to get there.

    • @BrewMeister27
      @BrewMeister27 2 года назад

      @@brandonb417 I agree, racking into a purged keg makes a huge difference. But CO2 blankets are easily disturbed, like when putting the lid on the keg. You're probably getting some oxygen exposure with that method whereas a closed system, with positive pressure, can transfer beer without any oxygen exposure. Does such a small amount of exposure make a perceptible difference in the beer? Maybe not, but eliminating this concern is certainly an advantage for more expensive systems.

  • @JesterNoNamer
    @JesterNoNamer 2 года назад +20

    I'd love to see these same taste comparisons but with Norm blind to the variable. Would eliminate any potential, subconscious bias going in.
    Blind test first would be more entertaining!

  • @ferrisr
    @ferrisr 2 года назад +41

    Some thoughts on what you could test:
    * Malt brands
    * Freshly crushed malts on brew day versus pre-crushed (or crushed ahead of time)
    * Yeast comparisons
    * Fermentation temperature profiles and the things that go along with that (impacts of D-rest, cold crash, dry-hop temperature, etc).

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +3

      Thank you!

    • @BrewMeister27
      @BrewMeister27 2 года назад +2

      What about testing the oxidation of closed transfers vs simply draining into a purged keg?

    • @hunterwebber6025
      @hunterwebber6025 2 года назад

      Ive always been curious about different yeasts and fermentation temperatures along with mash temp.

    • @mild_flounder
      @mild_flounder 2 года назад +1

      Also maybe a side-by-side test of different base malts!

    • @ValkeryRide
      @ValkeryRide Год назад

      For WLP500, Brew Like a Monk lists the "medium" temperature range at 67-75°F resulting in a spicy, light phenol and fruity flavor profile. Without cooling though, the temperature of fermentation could push it into the "high" range (75-85°F) resulting in a fruity, moderately phenolic and solventy flavor profile.

  • @rpguitar
    @rpguitar 2 года назад +65

    You can stick a Fermonster in an Inkbird-controlled fridge, pipe the airlock output into a keg to purge the latter with ferm CO2, and perform a closed gravity transfer from the spigot to a keg at the end. None of those capabilities are unique to a fancy fermenter. Your experiment didn't really compare fermenters; it compared different processes.

    • @unnuked
      @unnuked Год назад

      That's a gold tip for purging

    • @gtx332
      @gtx332 7 месяцев назад

      Does an inkbird controller have a negative effect on the fridge given it switches the electricity on and off?

    • @rpguitar
      @rpguitar 7 месяцев назад

      @@gtx332 Controllers are very commonly used by tons of brewers. There's been no issue for me in at least 10 years of use.

    • @Soulripper1988
      @Soulripper1988 4 месяца назад

      ​@@gtx332Used one for cheesemaking for some years... Works l
      Well, doesnt brake anything 😊

  • @64cheako86
    @64cheako86 2 года назад +16

    I use a fermonster and utilize a closed transfer by purging the keg with CO2, putting the line from the fermenter spigot to the Out (liquid) post on the keg, put a second hose on the In (gas) post back to the top of the fermenter and let gravity do the work. The beer pushes the CO2 out from the bottom up and the CO2 goes back into the fermenter

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад

      Recycling!

    • @1mhv2themax
      @1mhv2themax 2 года назад

      I do the same, keep the purge open on the Corny and gravity feed the beer into the out spout. Fill from bottom out, pushing out the inert CO2

    • @luukgx
      @luukgx 2 года назад

      Came her to comment the same :)

    • @davec4955
      @davec4955 2 года назад

      I was going to suggest exactly the same !👍

  • @RussInGA
    @RussInGA 2 года назад +10

    yea.. there is a lot of range in between what you did with the cheap and what you did with the expensive. Some temp control for the cheap method.. yea not free but lots of options. Then purge the keg with co2 before draining into the keg with the cheap. I love all the gear but with good practices and some effort the cheap can match the quality of the expensive setup. the results of your tests were interesting and fun! thanks!

  • @danielreiss3443
    @danielreiss3443 Месяц назад

    Thanks for your concise presentation for a "newbie" such as myself! As soon as you began I heard you say my 3 favorite words, " Belgian, Trappist, Ale"!

  • @cmcurran5
    @cmcurran5 2 года назад +15

    I’d love to see traditional 3 tier brewing setup compared to BIAB. So many claim they’re so different

  • @vgamedude12
    @vgamedude12 Месяц назад +1

    It really confirms my suspicions. People have brewed beer thousands of years in a very simple and even "wrong" way and its ALWAYS been good
    Beer is a delicious and traditional beverage it doesnt have to be fancy

  • @Kucuno1
    @Kucuno1 2 года назад +3

    I can see the passion and excitement in your eyes every time you brew. Awesome video!

  • @TheBruSho
    @TheBruSho 2 года назад +1

    Excellent experiment Martin, would love to see more split batch stuff like this!

  • @Mikemat5150
    @Mikemat5150 2 года назад +6

    A traditional cold vs. a warm lager fermentation would be a good comparison.

  • @ElementaryBrewingCo
    @ElementaryBrewingCo 2 года назад +1

    Super fun experiment Martin! Thanks for sharing!!

  • @bobhelm4942
    @bobhelm4942 2 года назад +5

    Its been my experiance that if you dont know what the brew was fermented in, you can't tell. As a LHBS worker I have challenged many customer to tell the difference between plastic, glass or S/S fermenters. Very few, without prior knowledge, can tell the difference.

  • @ffwast
    @ffwast 2 года назад +6

    A comparison I'd love to see is pitching two different yeasts in a batch versus pitching them in their own batches then blending them.

  • @seriomarkj
    @seriomarkj 2 года назад +2

    These are always fun to see..always shows it doesn't make u a good brewer, but a good brewer can make better beer (or more precise beer)

  • @kricketdude
    @kricketdude 2 года назад

    Keep these comparisons going !!

  • @Ghonosyphlaids
    @Ghonosyphlaids 2 года назад +1

    Love the test series!

  • @eddjordan2399
    @eddjordan2399 2 года назад +1

    brilliant i love this kind of stuff. plus people not being cocky and just going oh well fair enough. top work.

  • @tooidiotsbrewingcompany8137
    @tooidiotsbrewingcompany8137 2 года назад +1

    Great Video. Interesting to see the results since I have not yet dived into the stainless fermenters yet.

    • @richardwestwood3861
      @richardwestwood3861 Год назад

      Some say ph tester is a better choice of equipment than a expensive fermentation chamber if you looking to get serious at brewing and achieving consistency because this simply cannot be done if pH level is different at any process of the brew it won't be consistent

  • @JP..
    @JP.. 2 года назад +2

    I really enjoy the relaxed cheerful style of your videos and the chemistry with you both. Clearly good mates!
    I would be interested to see the same recipe but:
    1. with different brand malts. I’m often substituting brands due to local availability here in South Australia.
    2. perhaps the same brew with different yeast. Maybe an English bitter (I do miss cask ale as a Pom is Oz!) with two different English ale yeasts so it’s a close call!
    3. Same beer legged and bottled and tested after say 4 to 6 weeks.
    Already looking forward to the next video.

  • @SeanaldMcDonald
    @SeanaldMcDonald Год назад

    I watched this a while back, and then today I saw you explaining the Transformer architecture! As a home brewing hobbyist, software engineer interested in ML, some day I hope to follow in your footsteps!

  • @robertmullins9639
    @robertmullins9639 2 года назад +1

    Absolutely fascinating!!! Thanks!!!🙌✌️

  • @fifis101
    @fifis101 2 года назад

    That is bloody gold!

  • @robertscott6615
    @robertscott6615 2 года назад +1

    Great video!

  • @TheApartmentBrewer
    @TheApartmentBrewer 2 года назад +9

    While I also own a Spike CF5 , I almost always find myself reaching for the Anvil bucket fermenter instead, unless I need the extra capabilities that the conical has. I think it would be interesting to see this experiment conducted with a variety of different beer styles. This was great to evaluate temp control impacts, but I think a hop forward beer is going to see a much more significant impact from oxygen exposure than a Belgian ale, plus then you can really leverage the features of the conical. Keep up these experimentation videos, they are really fun to watch!

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +1

      I must say I did enjoy the ease in clean-up of the PET fermenter. No tri-clamps to disassemble. Can throw it around in the sink.

  • @brucearchambault6774
    @brucearchambault6774 2 года назад +5

    Interesting video, but to truly test cheap vs. expensive I'm disappointed that you didn't control temps on both, because you ended up introducing the variable of fermentation temp into the mix.

    • @ValkeryRide
      @ValkeryRide Год назад

      Exactly this.. or...
      For example; Do not temperature controle it, so the fermentation temperature can rise a little and give you some other interesting or disgusting flavours

  • @gregbush8573
    @gregbush8573 2 года назад +5

    I'd like to see the exact comparison on a beer that would see more faults from higher temps, belgian yeasts often "improve" their characteristics in a hot tank, whereas doing a clean us05 pale ale or similar would give you more esters in the cheap system

  • @AlejandroRamiz
    @AlejandroRamiz 2 года назад

    Excellent vid, Congrats!!! Super funny... Would the difference worth the price?

  • @ffwast
    @ffwast 2 года назад +4

    The best price to feature ratio I found for fermenters is used corny kegs. Stainless steel, rated for high pressure and equipped with safety valves, standardized gas and liquid fittings, compatible with floating dip tubes and spunding valves, built for easy storage and handling, and best of all dual purpose for storing and dispensing beer when not fermenting.

    • @codyhacker4937
      @codyhacker4937 2 года назад

      This is the by far the best option. Ferment in the corny, in a 5 cu ft freezer with an inkbird and spend about $500 (less if you buy used gear) and that even includes a co2 setup for carbonating and transfers. You also a have a keg cooler when you're done too. No reason at all to spend around $2k for a fermenter and glycol. Save your money.

    • @ffwast
      @ffwast 2 года назад +1

      @@codyhacker4937 a set up like that from used parts can be had for far less than $500 too

  • @NetworkGeek280
    @NetworkGeek280 2 года назад +1

    All grain vs partial mash. Pressure vs no pressure. Kviek vs lager yeast.

  • @Jango1989
    @Jango1989 2 года назад +1

    Great experiment.

  • @patrickbruske5488
    @patrickbruske5488 2 года назад

    I really enjoy your videos. This video was a comparison of temp control vs no temp control more so then comparing fermentation vessel types. You could have easily hooked that freezer up to a temp controller and taped & insulated the temp probe to the side of the plastic fermenter. You could have also most likely pulled off a pressure transfer using a $10 carbonation cap and small piece of hose going though the bung. The video showed how convenient the expensive conical makes things, though the plastic fermenter could have pulled off the same conditions if paired with a mini fridge or freezer, a $35 temp controller, and a $10 carbonation cap setup.

  • @egruber50
    @egruber50 2 года назад +1

    Great video

  • @HopsANDgnarly
    @HopsANDgnarly 2 года назад +1

    Love it! A call back to the first video I ever saw of yours! It'd be a cool challenge to try to clone a beer so well he can't tell the difference. Cheers guys!

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +2

      Yeah it would - have never been able to get very close with clones.

    • @HopsANDgnarly
      @HopsANDgnarly 2 года назад

      @@TheHomebrewChallenge Martin, similar but different idea. Which one is non-alcoholic? I've been having a lot of fun experimenting with NA recipes!

  • @alexrocks135
    @alexrocks135 2 года назад +1

    I have a ss brewtech unitank and don’t use a glycol chiller. I just use a soda fridge and put it in there with an ink bird, saved 1000$

  • @uwesumser1276
    @uwesumser1276 2 года назад +1

    i have the grainfather conical fermenter and the results with top fermenting yeasts are pretty good. Before I used plastic fermenters and I had no control of the temperature.

  • @basweny1
    @basweny1 Год назад

    This test is more about temp control vs non-temp control. Many great brewers have made great beer in plastic fermentors, but temperature control will set them apart. This argument can be made with water quality. Great video I really enjoyed reading the comments.

  • @johancederholm5074
    @johancederholm5074 2 года назад +1

    Love these tests Martin! Since you're a coffee guy I think a cheap vs expensive coffee in a coffee-forward stout would be a great comparison. Coffees with similar roast would be preferable! Cheers!!

  • @alexanderosborn8801
    @alexanderosborn8801 2 года назад +1

    Good content! Keep these coming, Norm's great too.

  • @normlang1994
    @normlang1994 2 года назад +1

    That was a lot of fun Martin. Can't wait for the next batch you need tested! 🍻

  • @ninkasihomebrewer8226
    @ninkasihomebrewer8226 2 года назад +1

    Thanks 😊

  • @JusBrewing
    @JusBrewing 2 года назад +1

    Awesome video as usual! Blind Taste Tests are fun (literally just uploaded another one) give it a go! I like to do test local popular beers to support them but you could even blind taste test old unlabeled beer!

  • @skateparkitzepuertoviejoli9694
    @skateparkitzepuertoviejoli9694 Год назад +1

    really nice video gracias

  • @pondwaterjr
    @pondwaterjr 2 года назад +1

    i like that fact that you proved you can make great beer on cheap equ, and that you dont need to spend a fortune. we all upgrade over time but there is nothing wrong starting cheap

  • @mongo4048
    @mongo4048 2 года назад +3

    It would be interesting to compare an isothermal mash with an infusion mash of 3 steps. 🤔

  • @dmac3603
    @dmac3603 2 года назад +3

    Love the comparison vids. How about same beer with different flaked adjuncts?

    • @liquidgold2735
      @liquidgold2735 2 года назад +1

      i like this idea. Like flaked barley vs flaked rye vs flaked wheat

  • @dj_cam
    @dj_cam 2 года назад

    When you know what is what there is a bias, I like the 3 cup blind method that was an honest way to do it, cool challenge

  • @gomezfriesen
    @gomezfriesen 2 года назад

    Great video!
    I would live to see this with a Pilsner or Lager. As the temperature would be much more extreme.

  • @dennislnbrewing
    @dennislnbrewing 2 года назад +1

    you could always increase your mash thickness too. I've had great results with thicker mashes for high gravity beers.

  • @deckerhand12
    @deckerhand12 2 года назад

    I have the anvil conical and I love it.

  • @tonguetwistjake6919
    @tonguetwistjake6919 2 года назад +1

    Damn, I never thought I could click the first like on any video, and I got to do it on this! Which just makes it even better since I've been keenly (haha...) following your homebrew journey and developing my own homebrew skills by learning so much from your videos. I guess all I want to say is: Hey Martin, thanks for existing!

  • @krisiglehart3061
    @krisiglehart3061 2 года назад +1

    I do not have a conical yet, so when I keg, I purge the keg with Co2 then start the transfer and periodically add Co2 while filling the keg.

  • @marksoler7338
    @marksoler7338 2 года назад +1

    The homebrewing shop in Santa Barbara is closing, and there is a Gluten free beer kit on the shelf. Want it? It would be fun to see it made.

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад

      What is a gluten free beer kit I wonder?

    • @marksoler7338
      @marksoler7338 2 года назад

      @@TheHomebrewChallenge Good point! It's based on sorghum extract, with non gluten adjunct grains, some honey, Belgian yeast, and hops. Might taste like sh*t, might be passable. I was going to make it in the shop (BYOB! In Santa Barbara) but ran out of time when I made a New Zealand Bitter instead....

  • @JimFosterVO
    @JimFosterVO 2 года назад +1

    What about a cheap fermenter in a fridge/freezer with temperature control vs the expensive glycol chiller?

  • @malex2200
    @malex2200 2 года назад

    This makes me very happy as a new homebrewer using a base kit. It means that the expensive equipment I have been considering for easing my workload will have minimal impact. It really just comes down to good ingredients and proper technique. Not equipment.

  • @larmckenna
    @larmckenna 2 года назад +7

    You can closed transfer using those plastic fermenter. I've done plenty on my fermonster. Just use gravity as normal and some appropriately sized gasoline to fit on the hole in your bung. Keep it to about 1-2 psi. That may help with the darker colour in case there was a touch of oxidation.

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +1

      Yeah I do think the darker color was probably a sign of oxidation

  • @timothyshank3208
    @timothyshank3208 2 года назад +1

    Another idea is a higher gravity beer that has a secondary fermentation or a bulk aging period like you might do with an imperial stout. The longer time in those fermenters would make differences more comparable, I would think

  • @zeddicus1980
    @zeddicus1980 2 года назад +5

    Great video again Martin! Stands to show that you can make great beers with cheap equipment :) As for another blind test, I would suggest a lager brewed with a classic lager yeast vs a lutra. I heard that many struggle to tell them apart.

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад

      I’ve heard the same but not done much with Lutra yet

    • @GraveFable25
      @GraveFable25 2 года назад

      I recently did a lutra pseudo and while it came out great, fast and clean, I don't think I'd ever confuse it with an actual lager.
      It was a very pale beer though, perhaps with more malt character it would be easier to confuse them.

  • @fifis101
    @fifis101 2 года назад +5

    I have recently been in a debate of the source of the traditional "homebrew" smell/taste that we all know of. I swear that it comes from bottle carbonating. I bottle carbed for 10+ years and always seemed ot have this flavour in some aspect but since moving to kegs a year ago I haven't had it. Some say it's what you get for making rookie beer but I used to use temperature control as well as squeeze all the air of the plastic bottles before capping. I would love to hear your thoughts on it and it would be a great taste comparison for you to do.

  • @jornsorensen3647
    @jornsorensen3647 2 года назад +1

    I would like to see you compare cheap vs Expensive brew equipment .
    By that I mean use a Drinks cooler for a mashtun ,no hop basket, no water treatment and still use cheap vs expensive Fermenters.
    Beer of choice Amber Ale
    Other than that, This was a great Video that showed how different a beer could taste and even smell by just using a controlled fermentation temperature.
    I suppose its all about yeast health.
    I'm Personally waiting to upgrade from cheap to something better.
    Started Brewing in September 2020 still using a 50L Urn , Drinks Cooler and Plastic Bucket.
    Made over 1600L of beer since then. My father and I brew every Sunday and love the unique tastes compared to Commercial brews.
    Thanks for the video, You got me into brewing and your videos have helped a lot.
    Keep up the great work.
    Regards
    Jorn Sorensen
    Durban, South Africa

  • @jasonhalliwell6445
    @jasonhalliwell6445 2 года назад +1

    Hi Martin, love the content. I have a Flemish red that is maturing atm and I’m waiting for your follow up video on how you are going to bottle/keg your aged sours. Is it coming soon?

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад

      How exciting. Yes I finally have a plan for my sours. Coming soon.

  • @gerardnatale2387
    @gerardnatale2387 2 года назад +1

    I use a cheap Fermonster fermenter but I have also devised cheap ways to both have temp control and closed transfers. I wonder how my beer would stand up. Great experiment! Cheers!

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад

      Do tell…?

    • @gerardnatale2387
      @gerardnatale2387 2 года назад

      @@TheHomebrewChallenge I attached a gas-in post to the stopper on the Fermonster to push the beer out of the spigot and into a keg through a ball lock disconnect for a closed transfer. My cold basement keeps the fermentation at 54 and I bring the fermenter up stairs for the D rest. I guess when the warmer weather comes my basement wont be cold enough though. Back to Ales! Thanks again!

  • @diegodamo813
    @diegodamo813 2 года назад

    You probably saved my life..or at least my bank account. I understand i dont need one of these beautiful, wonderful, almighty stainless steel fermenter.

  • @davidlawson5937
    @davidlawson5937 2 года назад

    Great idea. Try this again but use temp control and closed transfer on the cheap fermenter to see if results are closer. I suspect they will be.

  • @NikitaVorontsov
    @NikitaVorontsov 2 года назад +1

    Great video aside, your thumbnail game is fantastic! Big fan of the simplicity

  • @electricjay111
    @electricjay111 2 года назад +1

    Temp control is more important then what you're fermentation vessel if you want to go low tech look up a swamp cooler its easy but you have to watch it I use plastic with a chest freezer

  • @EricVandenAkker
    @EricVandenAkker Год назад +1

    I'd like to see the beers tried again, after a few months. Let's see what that oxygen exposure did.

  • @fagerholmjimmy
    @fagerholmjimmy 2 года назад +4

    Super interesting comparison!
    I'd love to see a comparison on how the beer's been carbonated with different sugars, force carb etc.

    • @mortimerlojka5912
      @mortimerlojka5912 2 года назад +1

      As you talk about different sugars, I'm just gonna paste my previous comment posted above, in case you'd be interested:
      Belgian here: everybody use corn sugar, it's dextrose, it's ok. We sometimes use "cassonade" instead, which is a blond sugar (sucrose. Sweetening power of dextrose is 0,7, sucrose is 1). Cassonade gives a special *tasty something*: everytime I say there's a bit of cassonade in the beer (trappist or saison), it's approved; Plus, it adds a layer of "tradition", compared to the use of dextrose.
      The most famous here, industrial but still "traditional", is the one with the blue "T" (Tirlemont) logo and the kid. Go for it !

    • @motoristan7707
      @motoristan7707 2 года назад

      I tried out with my uncle as he is a beekeeper to use very the hard honey we have in our region due to the high melezitose content in it and it as here the bees take in loads of plant sap makes the beer very flavorful using spelt and spelt malt is also something good to use I work in my family's bakery I have always free access to various grains and malts here so being creative with everything is good.

  • @unboxwithme2366
    @unboxwithme2366 2 года назад +3

    Just a few thoughts pro stainless steel conical. WIth the CF5 you can yeast and reduce risk for off flavors. You have always access to your beer though the sample valve and can measure fermentation process. In my test the beer reaches a much longer "best" date - in my kegs 6 months+. Cleaning much easier and no risks for infections. I think with a stainless steel conical you do not necessarily create better taste, but better quality.

  • @brewido
    @brewido 2 года назад +1

    T90 hops vs cryo in dryhop adjusted for concentration

  • @cohoanglervancouverwa6755
    @cohoanglervancouverwa6755 2 года назад

    It’s never about the equipment. It’s about the skill of the brewer. An expensive, complex system can be difficult to use. There is value in simplicity.

  • @CascadesHomebrew
    @CascadesHomebrew 2 года назад +1

    Great content. I moved from glass carboys to Fermonster fermenters and it was a huge upgrade. The low cost let me get 4 of different sizes. I have one stainless brew bucket, and I miss not being able to see what is going on with the beer. I would note that you can do temp control with a cheap fermenter, and you can do closed transfers too. I do both, and I even might know somebody with a video on doing a closed transfer with a Fermonster!
    Since you have equipment to control mash temps, I would love to see some experiments in that area. 149F vs 156F. Consistent temp vs wrapping in a blanket. Step mash vs single temp. Etc.

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +1

      I did enjoy seeing the fermentation in the plastic fermenter… it’s been a long time since I could watch that.

  • @fuba44
    @fuba44 2 года назад

    I love this too

  • @Leo99929
    @Leo99929 2 года назад +1

    I think a heavily dry hopped pale ale should show a bigger difference between the fermenters, especially if that clear fermenter is anywhere near a window.

  • @matsy1000
    @matsy1000 2 года назад

    There is no end to ole gunners skills

  • @afhostie
    @afhostie 2 года назад +1

    I just found your channel. If you haven't already, doing comparisons of dry yeast vs liquid would be really interesting.
    Really neat to see the results. I figured the initial testing would throw off the results but it looks like it didn't. Thanks for the content!

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +1

      We tried our best to give ourselves a little advantage in the tasting.. apparently didn’t work.

    • @afhostie
      @afhostie 2 года назад

      @@TheHomebrewChallenge i think you might inadvertantly shown how perception can affect taste which is super interesting.

  • @simonmoran67
    @simonmoran67 6 месяцев назад

    Nice vid. Sticking to cheap here in Kyoto. ¥500 open pickling tub, fish tank heater. Pop round for a taste test 🙂

  • @seanjennings9042
    @seanjennings9042 2 года назад +1

    Really enjoyed that one. Comparison videos often spring a surprise or two. Would be interesting to see a lager fermented at 2 different temps e.g. one at 10C and the other pretty high at 16-18C and see what the outcome would be. Have read w34/70 has quite a big range so perhaps you could try with that yeast. Other possibilities could be dry yeast vs liquid yeast, strains geared for the same style of course. Have been enjoying your content for quite some time now down here in South Africa. Thanks for the content!

  • @96FiRE96
    @96FiRE96 2 года назад

    Great video! Maybe same beer but one with cone hops and one with pellet hop equivalent. Or maybe open transfer vs open transfer of a hazy but one batch using ascorbic acid the other without left for a month or 2 would be cool!

  • @manueljulianrodriguez1705
    @manueljulianrodriguez1705 2 года назад +1

    I'm still waiting the lambic and flanders red video

  • @TheSidnelson
    @TheSidnelson 2 года назад +2

    Great experiment! I have been brewing in a cheap fermentor for more than 3 years now, and my biggest wish is a fancy fermentor like the one u got :)
    I would love to see a test pretty much like this one, however with a beer with dry hop, where the hops are the main characters, because as far as I studied, the strongest point in using closed transfer is to preserve the aromas and flavors from the hops

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад +1

      That would be a good test.

    • @GraveFable25
      @GraveFable25 2 года назад

      To add to this, it would also be interesting to see how these 2 hoppy beers would change over time.
      Would one lose aroma faster? Oxidise more?

  • @dominikp7649
    @dominikp7649 2 года назад +1

    I think that although temperature control gives quite a lot when it comes to off flavors, it is nothing compared to oxidation. I think you should also test this beer after some time, or maybe even in couple intervals.
    You also kegged the beer from plastic fermenter, which gives very little oxidation. It would be also nice to check the difference between kegged and bottled beer and how they age

  • @TheAlchemistsBrewery
    @TheAlchemistsBrewery 2 года назад +1

    Great exbeeriment!

  • @samdt9671
    @samdt9671 9 месяцев назад

    Grab some old kegs - fantastic frementer vessles and you can boil to sterilize. Orange carboy caps slip over the top nicely. Ultimately though temperature control is key - a stc, an old fridge and a lightbulb will get you there on the cheap.

  • @garyv2498
    @garyv2498 2 года назад

    Interesting experiment.

  • @ryjustsz
    @ryjustsz 2 года назад +5

    This might be a hard experiment to pull off but think be kind of cool to see precisely how much time in the boil the hop editions make. Like we all know that 60 minute hops and 1 minute hops make the beer taste really different. But what about 60 minute compared to 50 minute 50 minute to 40 minute 60 to 40. How far away from 60 minutes do you have to go before the taste makes a difference? Also could work the other way, how far away from flame out do you have to get before the taste makes a difference?

    • @hemavol6449
      @hemavol6449 2 года назад +1

      Basic brewing guys has done this kind of experiment in their podcast. Not in these intervals, but lf i remember correctly it was like 60min, 30min, 15min, 0min or something like that. 60min and 30min they could not tell apart from each other.. but closer to the "aroma time" compared to 60min it was more clear difference. But listen to the episode yourself.

  • @TheMortgageBrewer
    @TheMortgageBrewer 2 года назад

    Really fun video. Maybe do a comparison with yeast…make a starter for one and not the other.

  • @nieks9212
    @nieks9212 2 года назад

    Very interesting Experiment! These kind of comparisons from you and other channels really help nail down for me where spending more money/effort makes a difference as a starting brewer, and what parts of the process can be kept simple.
    After the video I do still wonder what factors (Temperature, oxygen ingress from open transfer) contributed to the final result (aroma, body, color, taste). Would be really interesting if that could be split out. For my reference: what was your room temperature for the plastic fermentor? You might have said it but I don't recall hearing it ;p.

  • @hobbeeswe7472
    @hobbeeswe7472 Год назад

    So amusing. I am just a beginner, so please forgive me if I am wrong. According to my limited know-how, the main difference here is pressurized and non-pressurized fermentation. Pressurizing the beer will counter creation of some esthers, making it taste less "wild". In my experience pressure has a significantly larger effect than the temperature range (i.e. If you do what you can with simple means, like placing the brew in a cold room).

  • @peterswatton7400
    @peterswatton7400 Месяц назад

    In cooler areas you can stand your cheap fermenter in a bin full of water heated with an aquarium heater and closed transfer to a keg is no problem.

  • @corybeaver7562
    @corybeaver7562 2 года назад +1

    Could you test fermentation under slight pressure (4ish psi) versus non-pressurized for a hoppy style?

  • @MikeSiscofitness
    @MikeSiscofitness 2 года назад +1

    This is an awesomely helpful video. Would love more like it!

  • @jumpjasper5276
    @jumpjasper5276 2 года назад +1

    Ha! ,ive done the same. I cant tell the difference. I also use baking soda on my plastic fermenter’s after using starsan. So Mabey thats the secret

  • @davidbeiler6364
    @davidbeiler6364 2 года назад

    i made a west coast IPA a couple weeks ago, im going to do it again everything the same way, except change my caramal crystal from a light 15-17 levibond to crystal 60

  • @ningfung91
    @ningfung91 2 года назад

    Could try out Kveik yeast and wb-06 with same wort? Is Hot country fermentation really differ?

  • @alanfiddament1735
    @alanfiddament1735 2 года назад +1

    You compared processes not fermenters .
    I use a blowoff tube to a tee with a balloon and blowoff jar.
    Place Fermonster in a temp controlled fridge.
    You can do a sealed transfer or I usually purge the keg with CO2 then transfer the beer without splashing the beer as CO2 is heavy and will protect the beer from most of the oxygen.
    I love the channel and have enjoyed watching your brews

  • @BrewMeister27
    @BrewMeister27 2 года назад +1

    The biggest advantage of temperature control is consistency between batches and ensuring yeast performance, especially with yeasts outside your standard US-05 type varieties (lager strains, kveik, ect).
    Your pressure transfers are critical for long term stability of the beer, but you won't notice that in an immediate taste test. A good test would be brewing a NEIPA, kegging with and without a closed system, waiting a month, and then taste testing.

    • @TheHomebrewChallenge
      @TheHomebrewChallenge  2 года назад

      Yeah no doubt it would be very apparent in a NEIPA. That style seems sensitive to any oxygen exposure.