thank you for continuing to do the comparison with Ipsy and Macy's. I agree, that IPSY bag would be a hard no for me, no shedding of glitter (and like you, I do like glitter!)
I love this series even if I've unsubscribed to ipsy. I never got a fragrance from them even though I chose it as a frequent item. But with Macy's I'm always able to try a new scent 😍
I was going to pass on the bag this month because I am Extremely annoyed they keep raising the price. I saw the pretty bag and a cute pallet and changed my mind. I would LOVE to get a scent for in my bag or box. I received scents in my last two boxes that I really love. I stopped getting the Macys box about a year ago because the samples are tiny. I live in NY and we pay to many taxes. With all the BS taxes the least expensive box are about $20. The Boxycharm/Ipsy box is now close to $35 for me so I chose the yearly plan. They charged me almost $40 just in taxes for the year. Enjoy all your goodies. I hope you have a Fabulous New Year. ❤❤❤😘😘
The fragrance is massively expensive and available at Liberty London here in the UK. I really wish the American beauty boxes would ship to the UK, you get much more value and variety of brands in your boxes.
I got that fragrance as an add-on back in November, didn't know about the connection to Bowie! I think it's a pretty nice scent. That Shape Tape was super tiny! It is a great product, but I prefer to apply UT with a concealer brush. I definitely like the Macy's bag better, no shedding glitter! Nice Tarte eyeliner. Lancome, Two Faced, Macy's definitely killed it this month! Better brands, better products, and I'd wager they are fresher too!
Hands down Macy’s box wins! It’s fire! Ipsy sent that tiny tiny Tarte concealer I got it before. I hate that bag Ipsy sent the glitter gets everywhere. They should’ve sealed it. There’s a way to do that. By far, Macy’s was so much h better!!! TFS ❤❤Merry Christmas & Happy New Year! U look stunning as always! 🎉🎉❤
I loved the mini shape tape!! Enough to try it and decide if you like it! Small enough that if you don’t like it it’s minimal waste. And I love minis!!!!
I believe Tresluce is just rebranding. They're a sleeper brand so I hope they get more recognition with their relaunch. Everything I've tried from them has been great
I wonder if the Macys box was was so good this month, as a special Christmas one. I hope not because I’ve been considering subscribing. You’re on the money that the Macys box won hands down. Merry Christmas Sydney. 🎄
Hey Sydney! The Tarte is a colour corrector just an FYI! But it is very tiny. I love getting fragrances from Ipsy especially in the glam bag. That mascara I seen another content creator use it and she loved it. I do not like that glitter bag. Ugghhhh 😢! The glam bag is not bad this month.
😂 I was just about to write about the hand creams at Costco and then you said it! I bought it to add to gifts, but then they didn't go so I held on to most of them. Love having one in my bag 🤷🏻♀️ that ipsy bag.. didn't even want to give it to my niece bc of the glitter! Macy's was awesome!! Wishing you and your family a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! 🎄❤
I skipped this month because I hated the bag and was not happy with the price increase. Actually, the January bag is ugly also. I don't know who is designing these bags, but to me, epic fail
Nice Macy's ❤
Merry Christmas 🎁
I got the peach too
thank you for continuing to do the comparison with Ipsy and Macy's. I agree, that IPSY bag would be a hard no for me, no shedding of glitter (and like you, I do like glitter!)
I’m about to switch !!! Quality !! And quantity haha
The Macy's bag actually is bigger than it first appears, itholds about 6 full size mascaras.
Shape Tape product is a color corrector not a concealer.
I do like the macy's better and I canceled my ipsy five years ago I was tired of getting the same stuff or it never matched my profile
Enjoyed the video! Your top is super cute. Do you remember where you got it?
I didn’t even bother getting upset this month…and next month is t looking good either lol
I may switch to just macys…
Macys wins!
I love this series even if I've unsubscribed to ipsy. I never got a fragrance from them even though I chose it as a frequent item. But with Macy's I'm always able to try a new scent 😍
Macy's for the win ✨ Merry Christmas everyone 🎄 🦌
❤
I was going to pass on the bag this month because I am Extremely annoyed they keep raising the price. I saw the pretty bag and a cute pallet and changed my mind. I would LOVE to get a scent for in my bag or box. I received scents in my last two boxes that I really love. I stopped getting the Macys box about a year ago because the samples are tiny. I live in NY and we pay to many taxes. With all the BS taxes the least expensive box are about $20. The Boxycharm/Ipsy box is now close to $35 for me so I chose the yearly plan. They charged me almost $40 just in taxes for the year. Enjoy all your goodies. I hope you have a Fabulous New Year. ❤❤❤😘😘
I think Item is the one that went under.
I really dislike Shape Tape. It's too heavy for me. I used it as a shadow base until I use it up.
Yup, it was Item Beauty. You are correct!
I’m with you on that glam bag I threw it away. Macy’s for sure won this round
The eyeliner is full size and I believe I saw it listed for $18 online. I am really happy with Macy’s!
Correction: it’s $22 on Tarte’s website.
I think this tart product is not a concealer it’s color corrector
The fragrance is massively expensive and available at Liberty London here in the UK. I really wish the American beauty boxes would ship to the UK, you get much more value and variety of brands in your boxes.
I got that fragrance as an add-on back in November, didn't know about the connection to Bowie! I think it's a pretty nice scent. That Shape Tape was super tiny! It is a great product, but I prefer to apply UT with a concealer brush. I definitely like the Macy's bag better, no shedding glitter! Nice Tarte eyeliner. Lancome, Two Faced, Macy's definitely killed it this month! Better brands, better products, and I'd wager they are fresher too!
Hands down Macy’s box wins! It’s fire! Ipsy sent that tiny tiny Tarte concealer I got it before. I hate that bag Ipsy sent the glitter gets everywhere. They should’ve sealed it. There’s a way to do that. By far, Macy’s was so much h better!!! TFS ❤❤Merry Christmas & Happy New Year! U look stunning as always! 🎉🎉❤
My bag hasn't shed at all, either I lucked out or you got a faulty one.
Holy smokes Macy’s blew it away! They won by a landslide slide! Great products! Thanks Sydney ♥️ Merry Christmas 🎄
I had to cancel my subscriptions.. so I may weep a bit while I watch...but I have a cupcake with me. I loved my sub boxes.
I loved the mini shape tape!! Enough to try it and decide if you like it! Small enough that if you don’t like it it’s minimal waste. And I love minis!!!!
This month Macys all the way! Merry Christmas 🎄
I believe Tresluce is just rebranding. They're a sleeper brand so I hope they get more recognition with their relaunch. Everything I've tried from them has been great
So happy I left Ipsy. Doing Allure and Macys going forward ❤ TFS!!
Did we get a December Boxycharm unboxing?
Not yet! I have it filmed and I think I am going to post it Tuesday. 🙂
@@SubscriptionSisters Yay okay awesome! 😍
I wonder if the Macys box was was so good this month, as a special Christmas one. I hope not because I’ve been considering subscribing. You’re on the money that the Macys box won hands down. Merry Christmas Sydney. 🎄
I think you're in to something. I think the December boxes will always be a bit nicer just because it's the holiday season
Macy's won this time.
The tarte one is actually a color corrector. I thought it was a concealer but was so dark then I reread it.
Macy's for the win this month!
Ok, I need to ask, where is yoyr top from?
Amazon! Its the softest shirt too! Here is the link: a.co/d/jb08wbS
Hey Sydney! The Tarte is a colour corrector just an FYI! But it is very tiny. I love getting fragrances from Ipsy especially in the glam bag. That mascara I seen another content creator use it and she loved it. I do not like that glitter bag. Ugghhhh 😢! The glam bag is not bad this month.
Marry Christmas and a happy new year to you and your family.
💝🎄🤶🎁🎅🎄💝
Big hugs from Denmark 💝🌹🥰
You could put your small Tarte shape tape in your small Macy’s bag 😂
Bahahaha! That is genius.
Yep I canceled Ipsy after this recent price increase.
😂 I was just about to write about the hand creams at Costco and then you said it! I bought it to add to gifts, but then they didn't go so I held on to most of them. Love having one in my bag 🤷🏻♀️ that ipsy bag.. didn't even want to give it to my niece bc of the glitter! Macy's was awesome!! Wishing you and your family a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! 🎄❤
Maceys for the win
Macy’s took it for December!!!!!!
Good job Macys! I may subscribe after seeing this video.
Macys has my vote…I actually cancelled my Ipsy subscription..I’m just so over Ipsy. Macys and Eyescream are my two favorites.
I signed up for macys hoping for December’s and I’m not getting it until January 😭
Is the macy box the sane for everyone?
Yup, everyone gets the same things.
I skipped this month because I hated the bag and was not happy with the price increase. Actually, the January bag is ugly also. I don't know who is designing these bags, but to me, epic fail
That wasn't even a competition. Macys won hands down!
Poor Ipsy, I thought for sure they had it. Then Macy’s knocked it out of the park.
Wow, I'm first?
And I'm second 😂
That concealer 😂😆