When actually playing, nothing feels better then a real piano vibration wise, but assuming you have all the bells and whistles, midi will almost always be a million times times better in the context of a final recorded piece imo. There are variables, but technology is only getting better and harder to differentiate when used by a skilled player
A pianist is not only someone who knows how to play piano, but someone who plays it on an everyday basis and/or exclusively plays it. If you practice with a keyboard, you’re a keyboardist because that’s the instrument you own. If you practice with a piano, you’re a pianist. the weight of the keys would be too different, so a keyboardist would not do so great without practice or proper piano lessons. the keyboardist would need a lot of time to get used to the dynamics changing by pressing keys softer or harder as well because it's not as easy when you're not used to it. I am a pianist and I for the love of god cannot play the keyboard. The keys are too light and it causes me to make too many mistakes, and the songs I play are not accustomed for the keyboard. It’s not to say you can’t be both, though, but people are mixing the two up I feel.
@@Ocelot_Growl You wouldn't need whole lessons to get used to the weight of the keys lol. And not really, it's something pretty simple to get used to, all you gotta do is just control how hard you press the keys for both of those, that's the only difference.
I have a keyboard, but I still call it a piano. Even though it doesn’t have strings and stuff like that, I’m still able to use pedal, and I can play as loud or as soft as I want without turning it up or down.
There are keyboards that are weighted (meaning the notes are as heavy as normal piano keys) and keyboards that are touch sensitive (meaning the harder/softer you press the keys the volume changes) and put these together on an 88 key keyboard, add some pedals, and that keyboard can do everything a piano can (except projection)
I play piano (self taught on a keyboard) but never said I could until I got an electric. Proud musician here that can play bass guitar (4+5 strings) , guitar (electric + acoustic) , violin , kalimba and drums (getting a kit at Christmas apparently!!) ! Sadly, at school I’m expected to learn songs quickly and preform. If you play the keyboard but can transition to a piano, use pedals, etc, I would say you are a pianist. Sadly not everyone can afford one. And the tiny pianos you get at school for computers don’t make you one.
I walk a lonely road The only one that I have ever known Don't know where it goes But it's home to me, and I walk alone I walk this empty street On the Boulevard of Broken Dreams Where the city sleeps And I'm the only one, and I walk alone I walk alone, I walk alone I walk alone, I walk a- My shadow's the only one that walks beside me My shallow heart's the only thing that's beating Sometimes, I wish someone out there will find me 'Til then, I walk alone Ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah Ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah I'm walking down the line That divides me somewhere in my mind On the borderline Of the edge, and where I walk alone Read between the lines What's fucked up, and everything's alright Check my vital signs To know I'm still alive, and I walk alone I walk alone, I walk alone I walk alone, I walk a- My shadow's the only one that walks beside me My shallow heart's the only thing that's beating Sometimes, I wish someone out there will find me 'Til then, I walk alone Ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah Ah-ah, ah-ah, I walk alone, I walk a- I walk this empty street On the Boulevard of Broken Dreams Where the city sleeps And I'm the only one, and I walk a- My shadow's the only one that walks beside me My shallow heart's the only thing that's beating Sometimes, I wish someone out there will find me 'Til then, I walk alone
A pretty big difference I noticed is that a piano will have a good bit more resistance. It was kinda embarrassing when I went to play a piano and I couldn't get used to applying more force so playing quickly wasn't possible for me within the timeframe. Luckily it was only friends around.
Everytime I see an old comment I made, I feel bad for the person I used to be. One day I'll see this reply and I'll feel pity for two versions of myself at once. In fact, I think I already do.
I learned to play with a cheap keyboard, and now I have a good one with key sensitivity and the 3 pedals. Yet I still will call myself a pianist because both my school and a English learning school I go to (English isn’t my first language) have grand pianos, and at this point I have played more at those places than at my own house. What about the times I don’t go to school since I’m in vacation? My grandma also has a grand piano at her house. The ONLY reason I don’t have a piano is because I live in a apartment at a pretty high floor and it would be hell to try to get one, so I got a keyboard because I have to practice somehow, but how I already mentioned I have played more the pianos at these places than the keyboard at my house, so I ask you, I’m a pianist? Edit: if anyone asks, I have a CDP-S360. Not the absolute best but I think is pretty good Edit(yes, again): I also don’t really get this video, wouldn’t a 88 keys keyboard with key sensitivity and the 3 pedals (mine is like that) be considered a digital piano? I’ve also seen some grand pianos that were digital. And still, there’re some people that just can’t afford to buy and maintain a piano or just don’t have space (also kinda my case). I’ve seen a lot more pretty good keyboards with all the things I mentioned earlier being cheaper than a considered cheap piano Also a side note here: who the hell plays pianissimo by turning down the volume? I’ve never seen that
It's sad cause in music school I got to play of piano and fortepiano but at home I have a keyboard. I finished 6 years of music school and I needed to leave my precious piano behind, and now play on keyboard😭
As a MIDI pianist player myself, I wouldn’t really call myself a pianist idk 🤷🏽♂️ but we can do what keyboardists can do and what pianists can do but better.
As a keyboardist, I can play pianissimo with full volume and I attach a pedal. I hate the reverb. When someone says to me that I'm a pianist, I correct them bc the keys play different and it's difficult for me to play with heavy keys. The reason I'm a keyboardist is bc I'm an argentinian and a piano is A LOT of money. My parents bought me a keyboard bc it's so much cheaper
i want to be a pianist but a) i don't have enough space at home for one b) i can't afford one. but i have a keyboard! and I'm trying to play like a pianist
I usually say I do piano/keyboard, because you can technically transfer all you’ve learned from keyboard to piano, then expand to using the pedals and such. But you still have to say you play keyboard. I also play violin 🎻
Idk if I'm considered a keyboardist or pianist bc my keyboard looks just like a piano, just with 4 buttons and a volume knob, and it also has touch sensitive keys and 2 pedals. However, i might be neither bc i mainly focus on guitar and i can only play fallen down, disassembly required, and the intro to the entertainer on the piano
A good keyboard player and a good painist will have certain difficulties playing the other instrument (assuming they haven't done such before) but will still be very skilled at the other instrument, however a low-level painist or keyboard player most likely won't have much issue or feel much difference
![Cody Johnson - I'm Gonna Love You (with Carrie Underwood) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yy9PuYMU29g/mqdefault.jpg)
Me a Piano tiles player: *laughs menacingly*
THIS IS THE BEST COMMENT EVER I LOVE IT
Still hit hard because piano tiles 2 was taken down ;(
Underrated af
We openly welcome you
You, my friend, are a true pianist, and one of the best.
The kid with garage band on his phone:
Kid named garage band installed on mobile:
When you plug your MIDI device into the iPad:
Ikr-
@@Stan_Castan take the reactionary symbol out of your name
@@dad_bot_3924 what
the trianglest after like 6 hours of this:
“Hey I can do E flat minor ok?” 😂
The cowbell players laughing menacingly:
Triangle is not a real instrument!
Its just a kids Toy
@@duke1160 Yeah it is, I can do anything you can do!
@@squog8009 can you code?
Me: *changes keyboard to piano mode* I’m a pianist now
If piano isn’t the base sound for your piano then what is 😨😳
**Changes tone** Reality can be whatever I want
@@raikiriuchiha7884 whatever you want, yo. I like saws and strings.
“Hey you cant call yourself a peni-“
Looking for the person who realized it to
Atleast im not the only one that heard that
Thank god I wasn’t the only one
MAN I WAS JUST ABOUT TO COMMENT THAT
100.
It’s almost the same thing some people can’t have a whole piano in there house so they buy a keyboard for way cheaper but they are still pianists
Another man comes with piano app in his phone : I can do whatever you can do.
Edit: thanks for so much likes I have never got this much likes.
@@joe_z Concert grand paino : I am going to end this man's whole career.
Piano tiles
@@Aeterin walkband or GarageBand maybe
@@Aeterin
Piano tiles is not even a real piano
@@skyral4137 yeah
When actually playing, nothing feels better then a real piano vibration wise, but assuming you have all the bells and whistles, midi will almost always be a million times times better in the context of a final recorded piece imo. There are variables, but technology is only getting better and harder to differentiate when used by a skilled player
A pianist is someone who can play the piano. If you can play the keyboard, you can play the piano
Not with understanding
But if u do have a good keyboard probably
@@pap3rpuppyrl585 You wouldn't be able to play with understanding if you had a shitty piano either, so it's irrelevant
A pianist is not only someone who knows how to play piano, but someone who plays it on an everyday basis and/or exclusively plays it. If you practice with a keyboard, you’re a keyboardist because that’s the instrument you own. If you practice with a piano, you’re a pianist.
the weight of the keys would be too different, so a keyboardist would not do so great without practice or proper piano lessons. the keyboardist would need a lot of time to get used to the dynamics changing by pressing keys softer or harder as well because it's not as easy when you're not used to it.
I am a pianist and I for the love of god cannot play the keyboard. The keys are too light and it causes me to make too many mistakes, and the songs I play are not accustomed for the keyboard.
It’s not to say you can’t be both, though, but people are mixing the two up I feel.
@@Ocelot_Growl You wouldn't need whole lessons to get used to the weight of the keys lol. And not really, it's something pretty simple to get used to, all you gotta do is just control how hard you press the keys for both of those, that's the only difference.
Love it! Your comedy is superb
A real pianist would accept all piano player even if its a keyboardist or a midi player so respect pls
MIDI can do everything a piano can do 😮 and moreee
Play c8 for me then
@@thatonemilkshake5495 *hits the transpose octave button*
@@damousx6860 ok hold that for 87655366 hours then look at your electric bill
@@thatonemilkshake5495 okayyy hold c8 for 8836286 hours and see if it needs to be tuned
@@damousx6860 bet
I have a keyboard, but I still call it a piano. Even though it doesn’t have strings and stuff like that, I’m still able to use pedal, and I can play as loud or as soft as I want without turning it up or down.
as a piano player, i always feel weirded out when someone calls me a "pen*st" like bro its a pianist ;-;
dentists: we’re doctors too!
Grand Pianist: *You cant call yourself a pianist either.. THATS AN UPRIGHT!!!!*
one word for the midi players: octaves.
Me watching this knowing full well that my keyboard is not a piano
Pianist : "Can you play la Campanella ?" 😂
Me as a electric piano player: *A S C E N S I O N*
Pianists: *I always come back*
There are keyboards that are weighted (meaning the notes are as heavy as normal piano keys) and keyboards that are touch sensitive (meaning the harder/softer you press the keys the volume changes) and put these together on an 88 key keyboard, add some pedals, and that keyboard can do everything a piano can (except projection)
Keyboards and digital pianos are different
Walks in with a church organ
It’s ironic since the piano is a type of keyboard 💀
I agree with the pianist.😂❤❤❤😊
Me with a Touch sensitive, Yamaha keyboard and a pedal: You think you’re superior?
Then when the pianist meets me as an organist… 😂
Your not slick, We’re onto you
Why do people genuinely fight about this though like we’re all just playing music.
I play piano (self taught on a keyboard) but never said I could until I got an electric. Proud musician here that can play bass guitar (4+5 strings) , guitar (electric + acoustic) , violin , kalimba and drums (getting a kit at Christmas apparently!!) ! Sadly, at school I’m expected to learn songs quickly and preform. If you play the keyboard but can transition to a piano, use pedals, etc, I would say you are a pianist. Sadly not everyone can afford one. And the tiny pianos you get at school for computers don’t make you one.
Me "singing" piano: You guys play piano too?
The piano is a form of a keyboard instrument
RUclips Piano Player: “You guys play piano too?”
Me with a guitar: the fuck is happening?
How are you supposed to play a song on the last one lol
I walk a lonely road
The only one that I have ever known
Don't know where it goes
But it's home to me, and I walk alone
I walk this empty street
On the Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Where the city sleeps
And I'm the only one, and I walk alone
I walk alone, I walk alone
I walk alone, I walk a-
My shadow's the only one that walks beside me
My shallow heart's the only thing that's beating
Sometimes, I wish someone out there will find me
'Til then, I walk alone
Ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah
Ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah
I'm walking down the line
That divides me somewhere in my mind
On the borderline
Of the edge, and where I walk alone
Read between the lines
What's fucked up, and everything's alright
Check my vital signs
To know I'm still alive, and I walk alone
I walk alone, I walk alone
I walk alone, I walk a-
My shadow's the only one that walks beside me
My shallow heart's the only thing that's beating
Sometimes, I wish someone out there will find me
'Til then, I walk alone
Ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah, ah-ah
Ah-ah, ah-ah, I walk alone, I walk a-
I walk this empty street
On the Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Where the city sleeps
And I'm the only one, and I walk a-
My shadow's the only one that walks beside me
My shallow heart's the only thing that's beating
Sometimes, I wish someone out there will find me
'Til then, I walk alone
So relatable 😂
A pretty big difference I noticed is that a piano will have a good bit more resistance. It was kinda embarrassing when I went to play a piano and I couldn't get used to applying more force so playing quickly wasn't possible for me within the timeframe.
Luckily it was only friends around.
Everytime I see an old comment I made, I feel bad for the person I used to be. One day I'll see this reply and I'll feel pity for two versions of myself at once. In fact, I think I already do.
Getting a medicine of it's own😂
I usually use my keyboard, but I have a grand piano in my other house
You can play really quiet as long as you have weighted keys
Me, playing a piano rhythm game: *You underestimate my power*
Me, an organist: 👁️👄👁️
Keytar player pianist can be the villian
I get invited to the pianists club
Thats one way to piss a pianist
I learned to play with a cheap keyboard, and now I have a good one with key sensitivity and the 3 pedals. Yet I still will call myself a pianist because both my school and a English learning school I go to (English isn’t my first language) have grand pianos, and at this point I have played more at those places than at my own house. What about the times I don’t go to school since I’m in vacation? My grandma also has a grand piano at her house.
The ONLY reason I don’t have a piano is because I live in a apartment at a pretty high floor and it would be hell to try to get one, so I got a keyboard because I have to practice somehow, but how I already mentioned I have played more the pianos at these places than the keyboard at my house, so I ask you, I’m a pianist?
Edit: if anyone asks, I have a CDP-S360. Not the absolute best but I think is pretty good
Edit(yes, again): I also don’t really get this video, wouldn’t a 88 keys keyboard with key sensitivity and the 3 pedals (mine is like that) be considered a digital piano? I’ve also seen some grand pianos that were digital.
And still, there’re some people that just can’t afford to buy and maintain a piano or just don’t have space (also kinda my case). I’ve seen a lot more pretty good keyboards with all the things I mentioned earlier being cheaper than a considered cheap piano
Also a side note here: who the hell plays pianissimo by turning down the volume? I’ve never seen that
I mean I can play pianissimo by tapping the keys softly
Meanwhile a harmonium singer comes out with harmonium and evryone dies after listening to raag
And then there's the $1 piano guy, the piano tiles guy, the play piano on youtube guy, and the "everything's a piano" guy
It's sad cause in music school I got to play of piano and fortepiano but at home I have a keyboard. I finished 6 years of music school and I needed to leave my precious piano behind, and now play on keyboard😭
“Hey, you can’t call yourself a penis!”
Me, a melodica player:
Cant believe that someone has the same keyboard as me
POV your keyboard has pedals:
The question is where a digital piano falls, then (those with weighted keys and pedals)
Meanwhile Me having an electric piano I Mean keyboard 😂
A little game of size doesn't matter
as a keyboardist i extremely agree with the pianist
im a keyboardist by force, i would much rather have a piano than an keyboard
Most midi controllers have velocity control tho and you can hook up a pedal, boom piano. And if you invest enough you’d get the weighted keys
Now the kid comes with the toy piano
The dude with Tiles hop as a mobile game
As a MIDI pianist player myself, I wouldn’t really call myself a pianist idk 🤷🏽♂️ but we can do what keyboardists can do and what pianists can do but better.
I have a piano degree and I occasionally call the damper pedal the 19th century reverb pedal.
remember: if you play the piano in concerts/lessons/in your orchestra and then you exercise with a keyboard you are a pianist.
FOR A SECOND I THOUGHT HE WAS SAYING PEN-
As a keyboardist, I can play pianissimo with full volume and I attach a pedal. I hate the reverb. When someone says to me that I'm a pianist, I correct them bc the keys play different and it's difficult for me to play with heavy keys. The reason I'm a keyboardist is bc I'm an argentinian and a piano is A LOT of money. My parents bought me a keyboard bc it's so much cheaper
This came up when I searched omori
i want to be a pianist but a) i don't have enough space at home for one b) i can't afford one. but i have a keyboard! and I'm trying to play like a pianist
Me with a keyboard with pedals:
Keyboard does actually have attachable pedals, and some are pressure censored
Remember, kids' size doesn't matter you can do the same thing with a smaller piano 😉
Not me hearing pianis instead of pianist
Meanwhile non pianists are the one who make banger music and pianists are just repeating Beethoven
My brain broke
High end keyboards are literally pianos, but electric. They have the pedals, they have key weight.
I would just called them a Beginner pianist
le me who just realized piano and a keyboard is different
The water keyboard be like: where am i at
Harpejjist: can you guys do vibrato?
I usually say I do piano/keyboard, because you can technically transfer all you’ve learned from keyboard to piano, then expand to using the pedals and such. But you still have to say you play keyboard. I also play violin 🎻
I wish I could get a piano, but it takes up way more space than a keyboard 😭
I play piano, currently my piano is somewhere else. For now I have a keyboard. I still consider myself a piano player.
Me a melodica player:
i play piano and keyboard? can i call myself a pianist?
Next comes the FL Studio prodigy
Me having a piano in my phone 💀
As a music producer, MIDI KEYBOARDS ARE NOT PIANOS!!
i still call my digital keyboard a piano :D
ask the keyboardist to play a 7 octave chromatic scale going from piano to forte.
Me who plays the melodica: 👀
(I play piano too but the piano tiles player made me cackle)
Medolica player: Hey guys- *Gets booed out of the room* screw you all! 32 keys is plenty!
“ I’m a peni-“
im a "penist"
-MIDI player
next would be people who play a piano app on a phone 💀
melodica player:
Idk if I'm considered a keyboardist or pianist bc my keyboard looks just like a piano, just with 4 buttons and a volume knob, and it also has touch sensitive keys and 2 pedals. However, i might be neither bc i mainly focus on guitar and i can only play fallen down, disassembly required, and the intro to the entertainer on the piano
A good keyboard player and a good painist will have certain difficulties playing the other instrument (assuming they haven't done such before) but will still be very skilled at the other instrument, however a low-level painist or keyboard player most likely won't have much issue or feel much difference
The keyboard we had growing up had a pedal with a cable running up to the back and the keys sensed how much force you used to choose the volume.