Episode
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 окт 2024
- 2021's Sadar Udham
A biopic detailing the 2 decades that Punjabi Sikh revolutionary Udham Singh spent planning the assassination of the man responsible for the Jallianwala Bagh massacre.
This epic biopic about the revolutionary Udham Singh also reffered to as Shaheed-i-Azam Sardar Udham Singh. We discuss all topics from the great acting and cinematography to the history of India, colonization and how the film industry will benefit from new great films from around the world.
Marie from the Alt Pop Repeat podcast joined us this week.
Cheapseat Reviews the podcast that explores the Hollywood film industry for the greater good.
Alt Pop Repeat - / altpoprepeat
www.cheapseatreviews.libsyn.com
www.imdb.com/t...
#SardarUdham #india #RRR
The film was not rejected for the Oscars by the academy. It was rejected by the selection committee in India. This committee has always been weird.
Thanks and appreciate your taking the time to watch this wonderful film and giving your unbiased opinions on the film .. It is a hard film to watch for any person but the truth must be told about the colonial brutality of the British Raj in India for 200 years.
Regarding the Indian soldiers firing on the crowd.. the British strategy in India was always 'divide and rule' .. so instead of bringing in the local Punjabi soldiers [who they knew would refuse or revolt], they brought in the regiment of Nepali Gorkas, who will have little emotional attachment to the local population. Furthermore there are reports and testimonies from eyewitnesses including British soldiers who participated in the shooting that General Dyer was walking amongst the soldiers, with his pistol drawn, threatening to shoot anyone who refuses to shoot directly at people, because some of the Gorkas felt so guilty that they started firing at empty spaces to avoid killing civilians.
By the way, we don't hate the British , same as today's Israelis don't hate Germans for their past atrocities, we just hate the colonial British rule in India. Indians are very forgiving people and are intelligent enough to understand that today's generation is not responsible for the actions of their ancestors, unlike the ''white hate'' / ''white guilt'' being encouraged in your part of the world. Ironically an Indian is now the Prime Minister of U.K 😜✌
Best wishes and regards from an Indian dude domiciled in Hong Kong. 🙏💖 ..
Thank you for your reply and for listening to the show!
@@Cheapseatreviews 🙏💖
I think you guys will love "3 idiots", it's an amazing film,
what really happened is more harsh than what is portrayed, there was a well in the park after shooting opened, all jumped in it with or without getting shot, in the end after shooting, the well was fully covered with dead bodies, this is just one part of the park
Indian soldiers did revolt that's how we got our independence, it took a visionary strong leadership from a guy called "subash Chandra Bose", Gandhi didn't make our independence possible, it's Bose who took indians fighting for British in Japan and formed a separate army which went from Japan to india for liberating india but they lost, but when other indians fighting for the British all over the world got to know about this, at same time they revolted leading to indian independence
Marie.. it is great to finally see someone acknowledge the inequity! Lots of Americans reacting to RRR re-imagined it as Washington and Jefferson (or some other Brit) fighting the Brits.. but it is more Geronimo and Siting Bull fighting colonisers. Reality is today's americans are the most successful colonisers who completely took over the land of the indigenous population, rule it with little recourse to the natives..India is one of the few places where indigenous population fought back..
It was 10 times worse.
What they didn't show is he individually corrected the soldiers who were missing the shots and ordered them to shoot at the densest section of the crowd so that more people can get killed in less time and Bullets ( Remember in RRR)
The movie is not meant to be a gore porn , what is shown have shown the point.
@@harshgarg7542I think u misunderstood.
Just 10 seconds of shot of showing him how he ordering to shoot at dense areas wouldn't made it a gore porn.
4 min of massacre scene is nothing short than peak level of gore.
English is most spoken language in India. I think Marie is right about the use of English by Sardar Uddham , he was using his identity and inherent prejudice to hide his competency of english language.
It is a statutory requirement in India to have such warning in the movie.
More than 1600 people lost their lives on 13 April 1919...in 10 minutes... It was not only a single brutality by english... We have several stories of colonial times
Andrew... Did feel wat we had gone through.... Respect for you
For me the most emotional scene... When he was exhausted n fell down on ground..... N pray.... "God have some mercy"......
36.39 indian film jury did not send movie for Oscar.... Because... They think.. It spread hatred against british
I think.... Marle... Forget lots of words while expressing her thoughts
49.00 it was nicer than wat actually happened... Because they fired bullets for 10 minutes.. 1600 lost their lives... Those who were survived by bullets they were killed because of stampede... Including Children woman... Elders...
Smoking is injurious to health is an Indian thing. And hurting animals (cgi animals etc) too. Those watermarks are always there for any scenes with that stuff.
Do Bahubali: the beginning
Bahubali: the conclusion
Review
And Marie is freaking cute 🥰
The answer to your question about why the soldiers could do what they did .....is rather simple to understand......rather than looking at India as a country look at it as a continent......with diversity and population more similar to an entire continent than a country. Now just imagine a Egyptian British soldier sent to suppress revolt in south africa. For the Egyptian soldier the south Africans are not his people. It was same for those soldiers .....they were not locally recruited .
What’s about Lunchbox as a sorbet?
P.S. I’m trilingual, I speak English, Hindi and Punjabi
P.P.S. Usually British would ‘divide and rule’. They would assign a different group of people as part of army/police over a completely different part of country. Like here in Punjab Jallianwala Bagh Massacre, the soldiers were Gorkha (Nepalese). And General dher walked around correcting the aim of soldiers who was missing humans throughout the duration of shooting.
Watch the movie Andhadhun or Padmavat or Ram Leela or Gully Boy or Tumbaad
On how indians could do this.
India is like EU. It could have been 28 different countries with different languages.
Please watch "3 Idiots" (2009) next ... its a fun comedy-drama .. good pallette cleanser that you would like
I am yet to see a movie about Tulsa Massacre.
In movie it was about 4 mins but in reality it was more than 10 mins.
You guys should checkout documentary "Silence of SWASTIKA " english version on youtube.
Duration 50 mins.
That will blow your mind.
37:41 they didn’t want to hurt the British sentiments or showcase the British colonial murders and atrocities which were similar to the Nazis in the millions of ppl they killed . So didn’t choose it as the Indian submission for best foreign film. Same as RRR.
30:22 .. Speaking of Seinfield, I remember they did an episode on the group travelling to India. It has many exaggerated stereotype or borderline racist jokes.But then again the show characters did that for many things so in show's context it was ok I guess but problem is the depictions subtly imact perception of many in US audience.
Pls watch Bahubali 1 and 2 by the director of RRR.
If ya'll are into Biopics then you should check out "Bhaag Milkha Bhaag" and " Rocketry: The Nambi Effect"
rocketry is kinda average movie cuz of it's cheezzy dialogues and bad acting i woul say but yeah "bhaag milkha bhaag" is masterpiece
You'll should probably now (after the break from heavy movies) watch Rang De Basanti which intertwines the history of Bhagat singh, jalianwala bagh too in a current affairs context
Of course I was trolling. I hate biopics. Lol
hahaha
BAJIRAO MASTANI
PADMAAVAT
Andrew's voice is too calming great story telling voice ❤️🇮🇳...do watch RAM Charan's Magadheera
I'll let him know
Not very accurate and no real research done by Shoojit …
Complete garbage. It was exhaustively researched and you are either are a hater or just agenda-driven troll.