Security Council of UN - tasked with primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace & security. - 15 member body out of which 5 perm members : represent post WWII realities - Balance of power. Major power wouldn't have joined unless given some incentives - Failure of league of nations. India's Stand on SC: - First 40 yrs we did not want a membership : Non alignment policy. - 1993 - subsequently we put a request for permanent membership - India's Claim: huge population, Economy 3rd in PPP, democracy . No international org which does not have India's representation can claim to be int org. France has emerged as a leading voice to expand the powerful global body with its envoy to UN underlining the need to place India, along with Germany and Brazil, as permanent members. - Issues with power sharing: 2005: Kofi Annan pushed hard for resolution but US & China lobbied very hard with African countries to drop it in General assembly. - Public statements are different than the resolutions: for the P5 countries. Morally, they cannot deny right but inaction in the assembly. - France positioning itself as a defender of multilateral order. - Indo-France affinity - Autonomous foreign policy like India unlike other countries (NATO & other commitments) - debate of Greater representation vs Less efficient. - Top contenders like India, Germany, Japan, Brazil - will be opposed by some countries. Argentina vs Brazil. Pak vs India, Japan vs India Pros & Cons: - India can put its interests more powerfully Azhar Masood - took us 10 yrs to put sanctions through UN due to one veto. - With greater power comes responsibility: you have to pick sides Korea, Libya Issue - India abstained or Jamal Kashoggi murder - India then have to take stand on such contentious issues. - We should be seriously debating on the consequences as we get closer. In a way there is a growing consensus for India to be there in SC. Even, China has made a statement that a country of 1 billion population cannot be denied a seat in SC. This itself is a testimony to rising global stature, Economy & strategic affairs of India.
Please make no negative comments about anchor of the show. He is still much better than any other private media showman. Respect his efforts and focus on grasping maximum knowledge from the discussion.
@@kamalsingh-qk3zi If you are so keen to change the anchor then pls use appropriate means to voice your feedback; this comment section won't serve your purpose
The best part of the discussion was that once India becomes a permanent member of UNSC, it will have to take stands on multiple international issues which confronts around 200 countries today. India, then cannot abstain from taking a stand from important international issues, as it does today. So, India, along with making efforts for a seat in UNSC, should also focus on preparing itself for a more proactive future role.
One more thing is missing here that We have 3rd Largest Army in the world and one of the strongest Armed Forces in the World. If you see all P5 members that is one similarity of having Strong military power. Apart from this We are largest contributor of UN Peace Keeping Forces which is more that combined of many member countries. We are also Nuclear Power and having nuclear triad Moreover we have image of mature and peacekeeping nation. So if we consider this strategic points then we have upper hand on Brazil, Germany, Japan.
How many times i have request rstv to replace this respected anchor. But i dont know why RSTV not considering our commantsss. We all should make our responsibilitiy to give more time for practice this gentleman in dis field...if u r agree
ye program kitna imp hai ye sirf ek upsc aspirant hi jaan sakte hai ....so please sir ..hum isme har ek word ka meaning samjna chahate hai ..adha adhura bich bich ka nahi ...
Is India's claim really feasible ? I mean just because we have an advantage in terms of population can it be used as a measure to claim a permanent seat ? China and India have roughly same population but China's clout in international arena is way higher than India. India is a major player in south Asia or maybe even in asia. But in asia in my opinion Japan has a better claim than India to UNSC. What are your thoughts guys ?
UN is not a cartel for the powerful to push their interest. It's purpose is global coordination and stability. India has 17% of world's people, more than 7% of world GDP which is increasing at a rapid pace and a military which is generally considered 4th best in the world. Japan, UK and France has no reason to be there. All of them are saturated economies with declining and ageing population.
Modi making bilateral relations with all the developing andj developed countries we have a good foreign policies then why ee need a seat in security council
Friends it is the ultra excess population which keeps india poor by per capita income,value of living and non living things,ecology, gutlessness in foreign policy because we can never question or challenge a country as it would affect our human export (foreign workers)and fdi which we are badly require because of our wrong market policies and anti- indigenous worship.So it is the the population which not only keep this country out of unsc (permanent) but also for hardships we face first DOMESTICALLY and then internationally.
Hello rs tv .. kya aap ye program hindi language me present nahi kr sakte kya ..??? lakho students English language ke vajah se is program ka advantage nahi le pa rahe hai....(sorry but ) aap apni desh ki bhasha chhod kr videshi language ke pichhe Q lage huve ho ..?????
That's why Desh Deshantar program of RSTV exists. And I don't get why only hindi medium guys are bitching and moaning about an English program. You don't see bengalis or malayalees or punjabis here blaming RSTV of bias. Pls grow up.
Consequences of globalisation. Don't worry more alternative and better sources are coming slowly for Hindi medium students. You can watch the Hindi shows on rstv.
Understand ua concern,felt da same. However, to be at peace vth uaself,primarily focus on the discussion and can learn a lot from the xperts.just a tip never let circumstances affect u!!rstv isn't going to change da anchor so it's waste of tym
Amit,Shubham patel ,Prashant Singh It not the population growth,not A Bomb threat to any country, moreover India in 2020 & Modi & Amit Shah Government can not claim to be the premantent representative in UN. Look at your face in mirror what you are now,Bharat,Hindustan,Ram Janam Bhumi,what you call yourself ? why you treat minorities as NRC/CAA what does it mean.Slove your internal & external problems with neiboughering countries. The present hostile situation of India can not be given any seat as permanent seat to UN.Why there is riot in India ? .They always dueal or hypocratic role from separation from 1948.Japan,Turkey,Indonesia,Germany may be conssidered as one of the position as permanent representative of UN.Not India, sorry,Time goes round comes round.Slove the problem of neiboughering countries..It will be like Donald Trump result ? Hah hah hah
Security Council of UN - tasked with primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace & security.
- 15 member body out of which 5 perm members : represent post WWII realities - Balance of power.
Major power wouldn't have joined unless given some incentives - Failure of league of nations.
India's Stand on SC:
- First 40 yrs we did not want a membership : Non alignment policy.
- 1993 - subsequently we put a request for permanent membership
- India's Claim: huge population, Economy 3rd in PPP, democracy . No international org which does not have India's representation can claim to be int org.
France has emerged as a leading voice to expand the powerful global body with its envoy to UN underlining the need to place India, along with Germany and Brazil, as permanent members.
- Issues with power sharing:
2005: Kofi Annan pushed hard for resolution but US & China lobbied very hard with African countries to drop it in General assembly.
- Public statements are different than the resolutions: for the P5 countries. Morally, they cannot deny right but inaction in the assembly.
- France positioning itself as a defender of multilateral order.
- Indo-France affinity - Autonomous foreign policy like India unlike other countries (NATO & other commitments)
- debate of Greater representation vs Less efficient.
- Top contenders like India, Germany, Japan, Brazil - will be opposed by some countries.
Argentina vs Brazil. Pak vs India, Japan vs India
Pros & Cons:
- India can put its interests more powerfully
Azhar Masood - took us 10 yrs to put sanctions through UN due to one veto.
- With greater power comes responsibility: you have to pick sides
Korea, Libya Issue - India abstained or Jamal Kashoggi murder - India then have to take stand on such contentious issues.
- We should be seriously debating on the consequences as we get closer.
In a way there is a growing consensus for India to be there
in SC. Even, China has made a statement that a country of 1 billion population cannot be denied a seat in SC.
This itself is a testimony to rising global stature, Economy & strategic affairs of India.
Shashi Ketan Samal Nice summary. There is one mistake ,it will be China vs. Japan instead of JapanVs. India
You are really good at this. Please continue :)
@@harshvardhan4260 thanks for the correction Harsh!
Nice👍
Keep doing👌best explained✌️
Please make no negative comments about anchor of the show.
He is still much better than any other private media showman.
Respect his efforts and focus on grasping maximum knowledge from the discussion.
What u want...i think u dont want to see improvement in this anchor
@@kamalsingh-qk3zi If you are so keen to change the anchor then pls use appropriate means to voice your feedback; this comment section won't serve your purpose
Excellent topic ,excellent discussion
Thanks RStv
The best part of the discussion was that once India becomes a permanent member of UNSC, it will have to take stands on multiple international issues which confronts around 200 countries today. India, then cannot abstain from taking a stand from important international issues, as it does today. So, India, along with making efforts for a seat in UNSC, should also focus on preparing itself for a more proactive future role.
Mr. Pant is awesome.
One more thing is missing here that We have 3rd Largest Army in the world and one of the strongest Armed Forces in the World. If you see all P5 members that is one similarity of having Strong military power.
Apart from this We are largest contributor of UN Peace Keeping Forces which is more that combined of many member countries.
We are also Nuclear Power and having nuclear triad Moreover we have image of mature and peacekeeping nation.
So if we consider this strategic points then we have upper hand on Brazil, Germany, Japan.
Mr Alok Bansal - w/o a hat yr goodself look very graceful...
But what can be the final decision for reforms?? Is india going to be get permanent membership or not??
FANTASTIC DISCUSSION RSTV
www.drishtiias.com/loksabha-rajyasabha-discussions/the-big-picture-un-security-council-reforms
Hello, sir how can I get rstv the big picture summary and can we watch rstv the big picture with subtitle, please help and give the suggestion
How many times i have request rstv to replace this respected anchor. But i dont know why RSTV not considering our commantsss. We all should make our responsibilitiy to give more time for practice this gentleman in dis field...if u r agree
Please have next debate on rising tension between US and Iran.
Plz support this anchor bc'z everyone not knowing every thing respect him.
Our govt is very slow in effort to get this permanent posion
ye program kitna imp hai ye sirf ek upsc aspirant hi jaan sakte hai ....so please sir ..hum isme har ek word ka meaning samjna chahate hai ..adha adhura bich bich ka nahi ...
hindi medium students please cooperate. ...
Where is FAIR and RENUMERATIVE PRICE ??
Is India's claim really feasible ? I mean just because we have an advantage in terms of population can it be used as a measure to claim a permanent seat ?
China and India have roughly same population but China's clout in international arena is way higher than India. India is a major player in south Asia or maybe even in asia. But in asia in my opinion Japan has a better claim than India to UNSC. What are your thoughts guys ?
UN is not a cartel for the powerful to push their interest. It's purpose is global coordination and stability. India has 17% of world's people, more than 7% of world GDP which is increasing at a rapid pace and a military which is generally considered 4th best in the world.
Japan, UK and France has no reason to be there. All of them are saturated economies with declining and ageing population.
Agni _ u r right every continent should be given representation
Did news channels beat.RSTV also beast discussion.
truth
Modi making bilateral relations with all the developing andj developed countries we have a good foreign policies then why ee need a seat in security council
@anjani kumar only these five countries hold absolute powers. This is a improportionate representation.
please use india not modi.
@@abhishekkumarsingh4696 Both have become synonymous now in the current state of politics.
garmiyaan sai mein aa gui hein. (if u know what i mean)
Friends it is the ultra excess population which keeps india poor by per capita income,value of living and non living things,ecology, gutlessness in foreign policy because we can never question or challenge a country as it would affect our human export (foreign workers)and fdi which we are badly require because of our wrong market policies and anti- indigenous worship.So it is the the population which not only keep this country out of unsc (permanent) but also for hardships we face first DOMESTICALLY and then internationally.
Is india need a veto power in un security council analyze?
day dream
Where is Frank?
On election coverage
anchor is unable to keep discussion engaging
Hello rs tv ..
kya aap ye program hindi language me present nahi kr sakte kya ..???
lakho students English language ke vajah se is program ka advantage nahi le pa rahe hai....(sorry but )
aap apni desh ki bhasha chhod kr videshi language ke pichhe Q lage huve ho ..?????
ma'am, because today we are living in a global village whose language is English.
That's why Desh Deshantar program of RSTV exists. And I don't get why only hindi medium guys are bitching and moaning about an English program. You don't see bengalis or malayalees or punjabis here blaming RSTV of bias. Pls grow up.
We have been suffering with globalisation please grow up mind set
Deepa Lotulkar plz watch desh deshantar and vishesh
Consequences of globalisation.
Don't worry more alternative and better sources are coming slowly for Hindi medium students.
You can watch the Hindi shows on rstv.
No not again this anchor
Understand ua concern,felt da same. However, to be at peace vth uaself,primarily focus on the discussion and can learn a lot from the xperts.just a tip never let circumstances affect u!!rstv isn't going to change da anchor so it's waste of tym
Amit,Shubham patel
,Prashant Singh
It not the population growth,not A Bomb threat to any country, moreover India in 2020 & Modi & Amit Shah Government can not claim to be the premantent representative in UN.
Look at your face in mirror what you are now,Bharat,Hindustan,Ram Janam Bhumi,what you call yourself ? why you treat minorities as NRC/CAA what does it mean.Slove your internal & external problems with neiboughering countries. The present hostile situation of India can not be given any seat as permanent seat to UN.Why there is riot in India ? .They always dueal or hypocratic role from separation from 1948.Japan,Turkey,Indonesia,Germany may be conssidered as one of the position as permanent representative of UN.Not India, sorry,Time goes round comes round.Slove the problem of neiboughering countries..It will be like Donald Trump result ? Hah hah hah
The most worst host of big pic