"14 минут до старта" (14 Minutes Until Start)- Soviet Cosmonaut Song

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
  • "14 Minutes Until Start", also known as "I Believe, my Friends" is a popular Soviet Cosmonaut song and was the unofficial anthem of the Soviet Space Program. It was composed in 1960 by Oscar Feltsman, with the lyrics being written by Vladimir Voinovich
    Discord server: / discord
    Check out my friend's channel!
    Link: / channel

Комментарии • 246

  • @cortexradio
    @cortexradio  Год назад +32

    Check this out!
    "Sare Jahan se Accha- Indian Patriotic Song"
    ruclips.net/video/VgEpe5y3WZ0/видео.html

  • @ckknews2085
    @ckknews2085 Год назад +463

    It makes me feel nostalgic for a magnificent future that never came

  • @haljordanwithm6077
    @haljordanwithm6077 Год назад +168

    Это песня сильно бьёт в душу... Отголоски прошлого...
    _На пыльных тропинках, далёких планет._
    _Останутся наши следы..._

  • @bananayellow6438
    @bananayellow6438 Год назад +525

    This song sounds like he is singing it in the past and it like echoed to this day

    • @cortexradio
      @cortexradio  Год назад +70

      Thanks! Yes, I did try to add some voice effects to the original audio, glad you loved it :)

    • @sousacordeiro9684
      @sousacordeiro9684 Год назад +96

      It reminds me of the story of Sergei Krikalev, the last Soviet cosmonaut and the last citizen of the Soviet Union, who was in space when the USSR fell on December 25, 1991 and stayed there alone in space until March 25, 1992.
      Imagine, alone in space, singing those songs, not imagining that your country down there on Earth no longer exists and therefore your words seem to be from a distant past that now blends with the Universe.

    • @comsot
      @comsot Год назад +45

      @@sousacordeiro9684 He actually used radios to talk to someone in Ireland because the Irish guy was testing his radio and just managed to go to the frequency Sergei was using and they chatted often. Atleast thats how I remember the story but there is a short movie on it called Mir friends

    • @blackarrow7988
      @blackarrow7988 Год назад +4

      He wasn’t there alone. His commander was up there with him as well. But other than that, it was just those two (and anybody Sergei managed to talk to via radio).

    • @Wandkater
      @Wandkater Год назад

      @@cortexradiodo you have kohls cash?

  • @Cesar1492Enjoyer
    @Cesar1492Enjoyer 3 месяца назад +6

    This my favorite version of the song, it’s so comforting and nostalgic at the same time

  • @arleighburkeclassdestroyer1240
    @arleighburkeclassdestroyer1240 Год назад +36

    happy 62th international space flight day comrades! Slava to comrade gagarin!

  • @КосмонавтЛиквидатор

    Заправлены в планшеты
    Космические карты,
    И штурман уточняет
    В последний раз маршрут.
    Давайте-ка, ребята,
    Cпоёмте перед стартом,
    У нас еще в запасе
    Четырнадцать минут.
    Я верю, друзья,
    Караваны ракет
    Помчат нас вперед
    От звезды до звезды!
    На пыльных тропинках
    Далеких планет
    Останутся наши следы!
    Когда-нибудь с годами
    Припомним мы с друзьями,
    Как по дорогам звездным
    Вели мы первый путь,
    Как первыми сумели
    Достичь заветной цели
    И на родную Землю
    Со стороны взглянуть
    Я верю, друзья,
    Караваны ракет
    Помчат нас вперед
    От звезды до звезды!
    На пыльных тропинках
    Далеких планет
    Останутся наши следы!
    Давно нас ожидают
    Далекие планеты,
    Холодные планеты,
    Безмолвные поля.
    Но ни одна планета
    Не ждет нас так, как эта,
    Планета дорогая
    По имени Земля.
    Я верю, друзья,
    Караваны ракет
    Помчат нас вперед
    От звезды до звезды!
    На пыльных тропинках
    Далеких планет
    Останутся наши следы!
    ..........
    Я верю, друзья,
    Караваны ракет
    Помчат нас вперед
    От звезды до звезды!
    На пыльных тропинках
    Далеких планет
    Останутся наши следы!

    • @icommitedthefunny
      @icommitedthefunny Год назад +3

      i love this song; heres the romanzied/transliterated verison:
      Zapravleny v planshety kosmicheskie karty,
      I shturman utochnjaet v posledenij paz marshrut.
      Davajte-ka, rebjata,
      Spojomte pered startom,
      U nas eshjo v zaplase chetyrnadsat' minut!
      Ja verju, druz'ja, karavany raket,
      Pomchat nas vperjod [vpered] ot zvezdy do zvezdy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      Kogda-nibud' s godami pripomnim my s druz'jami,
      Kak po dorogam zvjozdiym veli my pervyj put'
      Kak pervymi sumeli dostich' zavetnoj celi,
      I na rodnuju Zemlju so storony vzgljanut'
      Ja verju, druz'ja, karavany raket,
      Pomchat nas vprejod [vpered] ot zvezdy do zvezdy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      Davno nas ozhidajut daljokie planety,
      Kholodnye planety, bezmolvnye polja.
      No ni odna planeta ne zhdjot nas tak, kak eta,
      Planeta dorogaja no imeni Zemlja.
      Ja verju, druz'ja, karavany raket,
      Pomchat nas vprejod [vpered] ot zvezdy do zvezdy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      Ja verju, druz'ja, karavany raket,
      Pomchat nas vperjod [vpered] ot zvezdy do zvezdy.
      Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,
      Ostanutsja nashi sledy.
      *Na pyl'nykh tropinkakh daljokikh planet,*
      *Ostanutsja nashi sledy!*
      Its not accurate but still
      By wikipedia pages, im using GSOT 16876-71(2)
      also wiki link abt it: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanization_of_Russian
      notes: "vperjod" could be "vpered" but its maybe just the subtitles

  • @АлександрКандауров-т8л

    Это была наша отрядная пионерская песня 1977-1981 годы. И пели мы закурим перед стартом.

  • @Geshiko-GuP
    @Geshiko-GuP Год назад +6

    Perfect

  • @frogsaup
    @frogsaup 6 месяцев назад +1

    A dream of which loss was to be incomprehensible.

  • @Comrade_Goose_Official
    @Comrade_Goose_Official 24 дня назад

    Sounds like it's being sung in a long corridor

  • @martianimperialcouncil9194
    @martianimperialcouncil9194 8 месяцев назад +2

    I hate communism with every fiber of my being, but I think anyone who wishes for a brighter future can gather around this song regardless of political affiliation.
    Well, except primitivists, I guess.

  • @luuminhhuy9459
    @luuminhhuy9459 Год назад +36

    Imagine the priority of the Cold War wasnt nuclear weapons and proxy wars but space exploration.
    We would've at least landed on mars and further

  • @nrotw9583
    @nrotw9583 Год назад +94

    Gorbachev traded this beauty for fucking Pizza Hut

    • @bandit4741
      @bandit4741 Год назад +11

      But nobody out Pizzas the Hut

    • @snownukitro-A
      @snownukitro-A Год назад +19

      @@bandit4741 false, even my local bakery outpizza'd the hut

    • @stolyartoad8640
      @stolyartoad8640 Год назад +6

      Gorbachev didn`t trade it, everyone did. Very few truly believed in communism in the last days of the USSR, it was inevitable

    • @snownukitro-A
      @snownukitro-A Год назад

      ​@@stolyartoad8640 gorbachev's policies lead to their popularity rather than the other way but even then they're popularity didn't last long, many people still believed in communism, even after the ussr's collapse, in russia usa had to rig the election just because the communist party was going to win

    • @personexists4520
      @personexists4520 Год назад +15

      @@stolyartoad8640there was an ultimatum in 1991 that showed the majority supported it

  • @counterdom
    @counterdom Год назад +150

    this is literally '14 минут до старта' doomer edition and i love it

    • @brenno923
      @brenno923 Год назад +1

      0.75x hits hard too

  • @Alue14
    @Alue14 Год назад +85

    This version sounds like this could be the last song aliens find about humanity...

  • @cykablyat123br9
    @cykablyat123br9 Год назад +44

    I not can stop listening to this version... this music gives me a feeling about human race progress.... i not can explain this feeling... this music is a future that we still not lived yet.

  • @Fali-Falido
    @Fali-Falido Год назад +133

    "This last record of mine as a cosmonaut... lost in the cold emesidad of deep space... without the warm embrace of my motherland..."

  • @PapaObamaPrism
    @PapaObamaPrism Год назад +47

    Why does this give me goosebumps and a horrid sense of dread

    • @euruskreacatoa2370
      @euruskreacatoa2370 Год назад +35

      a ghastly reminder of what was robbed from us, lost history of untold suffering now only seen in text from old books

  • @jolt9484
    @jolt9484 6 месяцев назад +31

    The original version of this song sounds loud, optimist and hopeful. This version sound a lot more quiet and distant, the feeling of hope is gone. Sadly it's a fitting parallel to the illegal dissolution of the USSR and the end of all the hope and dreams that once existed in the world. This song sounds like something you would hear in a dream. The dream is still there, slowly fading away.

    • @lcdream4213
      @lcdream4213 Месяц назад +1

      We got the bad ending 💀

  • @пидарасина_228
    @пидарасина_228 Год назад +72

    Happy Astronautic Day, my friends! Let's conquer new stars and planets together, without fighting ❤️

    • @williamdivay8544
      @williamdivay8544 Год назад +5

      I think every country should stop their new space race and work all together to colonize other planets and ensure the future of Human kind 🇪🇺❤🇷🇺❤🇺🇸❤🇨🇳❤🇮🇳❤🇯🇵❤🇧🇷❤🇨🇦❤🇦🇪❤🇬🇧

    • @saloona_
      @saloona_ 4 месяца назад +1

      @@williamdivay8544colonizing will be a problem.

  • @kgb-spy-369
    @kgb-spy-369 10 месяцев назад +23

    This anthem makes every man and lover of space and cosmology cry

  • @sedotialesorciercheate8693
    @sedotialesorciercheate8693 Год назад +76

    the soviet space epic a beautiful thing like the american space epic during the cold war at least he was in competition to surpass himself and dominate but there was progress, now there is nothing it is progress towards decadence .

    • @sedotialesorciercheate8693
      @sedotialesorciercheate8693 Год назад

      the end of spatial evolution began in 1980 since there is nothing, I think we will know it one day or another or it will be the following generations that they will know them or not.

  • @Str3tchyL3gs
    @Str3tchyL3gs 7 месяцев назад +7

    Soviet space program was what first got me interested in astronomy and space exploration as a kid. Humanity could've landed on Mars and much more by now if only Americans and Russians could've gotten past their real and perceived differences with each other. Outside of political disagreements between the 2 nations I believe the average American and average Russian have far more in common then they realise. But the idea of a cold war created the illusion of being polar opposites to each other. Perhaps if both people's had more exposure to each others perspectives decades ago it could've been a much different story

  • @brastumobile2974
    @brastumobile2974 Год назад +407

    From an underdeveloped agrarian society to conquering the cosmos in 40 years... America's been around for 200 years and they're already cutting NASA funding. Imagine what we could've had if the union survived

    • @kartalkiss2571
      @kartalkiss2571 Год назад +42

      I mean in defense of the USA the USSR still was an underdeveloped agrarian society when they launched Vostok 1 so it’s clear which skill tree they speced into

    • @SoryRN
      @SoryRN Год назад +70

      ​@kartalkiss2571 The USSR was the second economical power and Stalin left the USSR with Nuclear Weapons and Nuclear Powerplants along with a strong industry and the first army
      The USSR was not underdeveloped

    • @kartalkiss2571
      @kartalkiss2571 Год назад +12

      @@SoryRN Well kinda, it had industry sure, but it was not quality unlike any other non-communist europian country near it. Also you were kinda forced into working in a factory because you didn’t have anything else to do.

    • @SoryRN
      @SoryRN Год назад +25

      @kartalkiss2571 In fact it was compared to nearby nations out of the Eastern block in the 70s
      So was every nation during industrialization and before that in Russia it was 14 hours of workday although now people are to spend 8 hours on a desk which isn't any better than a factory for many

    • @kartalkiss2571
      @kartalkiss2571 Год назад +1

      ⁠​⁠@@SoryRNPretty sure that just reinforces my point. Also that things are still not better for people even when they don’t have to inhale coal dust is kinda sad.

  • @mrmakhno3030
    @mrmakhno3030 Год назад +7

    Soviet Union at that time (and pretty much in any moment of its first half lifetime) was full of hope . Unlike the current Russian Federation.

  • @ThaGreatChemist
    @ThaGreatChemist Год назад +12

    If nothing happened to the ussr and the space race went on, we'd already be at mars and beyond by now

  • @pol-communist
    @pol-communist Год назад +71

    Есть такая пластинка, патефонная. Красивая песня. Навевает воспоминания..

    • @cortexradio
      @cortexradio  Год назад +11

      Рад, что тебе понравилось, товарищ!

  • @_janethtinta_5150
    @_janethtinta_5150 Год назад +25

    i imagine a cosmonaut Singing in the space alone but happy to see all the beauty of space

  • @waterisbased
    @waterisbased 2 месяца назад +2

    We were cave dwellers 300,000 years ago, and only recently have we become the pioneers of space.

  • @danielsantos7862
    @danielsantos7862 7 месяцев назад +4

    Hermosa Cansion !! El Arte y la cultura de la Union Sovietica fue muy fascinante! Cómo sus grandes avances tecnológicos en esa época !! Saludos a mis hermanos Rusos y de todas las demás naciones que formaron parte de la Unión Sovietica !

  • @gabzavrik1337
    @gabzavrik1337 Год назад +46

    Блин, из-за этого эха и лёгких шумов появляется ощущение ВЧС, можно сразу пихать в аналоговый хорор

  • @polskikolejarz5507
    @polskikolejarz5507 Год назад +18

    Great achievement of whole humanity!

    • @elenaegorova5216
      @elenaegorova5216 Год назад +2

      Не надо примазываться к успехам моей социалистической Родины! Человечество палец о палец не ударило, чтобы защитить своё будущее…

  • @georgeabreu6392
    @georgeabreu6392 20 дней назад +3

    Just came here to say, have revolutionary optimism comrades. This is not a sign of the past, it is the sign of a future that can still be. Let us grasp it together and continue where they left off for all future children of humanity to see. ✊🏽🚩🚀

  • @bulkysinetv6262
    @bulkysinetv6262 Год назад +173

    ''a magnificent future that the west stole from us'' this comes to my head when i listen to this

    • @polskikolejarz5507
      @polskikolejarz5507 Год назад

      Nah space race just became bad value for money no one needed it

    • @cozmoknot
      @cozmoknot Год назад

      It’s sad because it’s true.. the west didn’t just steal it from the East, it stole it from all peoples of the world..

    • @just_dmitri3192
      @just_dmitri3192 Год назад

      The Soviets stole it to themselves in their decadence

    • @osvaldifrancesco855
      @osvaldifrancesco855 Год назад +8

      Bro, everything good, but no, we did not stole anything from you

    • @RE-pl7nl
      @RE-pl7nl Год назад

      Not the West, common people in the West are unfortunately unconscious or marginalised just like in Russia or elsewhere. It’s a pity that war and imperialism of the elites right now steals our future

  • @明吴-t2d
    @明吴-t2d Год назад +11

    很喜欢苏联的歌,谢谢上传!

  • @ggkproductions1632
    @ggkproductions1632 10 месяцев назад +10

    The year is 2256
    The Neo-Soviet Union loses contact with a space station near Saturn.
    A small team is sent to investigate.
    The team arrives to find the station nearly abandoned.
    Oxygen levels are too low to be breathable so they must remain I space suits.
    The plants the station used to grow have withered and died.
    The team finds a sound coming from another room.
    They open the door, finding a single corpse and a device playing this exact song.
    All communications with the investigation team suddenly fail.

  • @8thguy633
    @8thguy633 Год назад +15

    Progress was done, progress was undone, such is the story of the Soviet Union.

    • @elenaegorova5216
      @elenaegorova5216 Год назад +1

      Товарищ, прогресс остановить нельзя. Советский Союз не остался в прошлом, он ушёл в будущее!

  • @StateofArrowstan
    @StateofArrowstan 10 месяцев назад +31

    I may not like the Soviet Union, but that fact that they managed to get a human into space and back safely will always make me proud of the human race

  • @Scourge1990
    @Scourge1990 Год назад +17

    This sounds like a perfect song for the fallout 3 Start scene

  • @ProjectMirai64
    @ProjectMirai64 7 месяцев назад +4

    I really love how this song sounds like its sung in space, epic atmospheric effect.

  • @carlstevens781
    @carlstevens781 10 месяцев назад +4

    „Na pyľnych tropinkach dalǒkich planet, ostanutsǎ naši sledy.“
    This song is one of my favorites, & it helped me with the Russian alphabet & learning the Cyrillic script more broadly. I’ve worked on & off on a custom romanization of Russian that’s totally reversible without ambiguity while adhering to Slavic orthographic conventions for a couple of years & use songs like this to test it. I need to come back at some point when I have more time & type out a full romanization for this.

    • @colmcmillan173
      @colmcmillan173 9 месяцев назад

      The Russian language does not need the Latin alphabet. It's too few characters. English language needs Cyrillic alphabet.

  • @One_Soldier64127
    @One_Soldier64127 Год назад +7

    they really said "if we cant spread communism in the world, then we spread it across space!"

    • @антонколокольцев-в8ы
      @антонколокольцев-в8ы Год назад

      Кто это сказал?

    • @One_Soldier64127
      @One_Soldier64127 Год назад +3

      ​@@антонколокольцев-в8ы no one did, just a thought of mine. but if someone really said it during those times it would be suprising.
      никто не делал, просто моя мысль. но если бы кто-то действительно сказал это в те времена, это было бы удивительно.

  • @strayadoesgames
    @strayadoesgames 11 месяцев назад +4

    Sergei Korolev approves of this video

  • @YourOpponent
    @YourOpponent Год назад +11

    РСФСР

  • @globus8357
    @globus8357 Год назад +26

    Это одна из немногих песен и произведений искусства вообще,что вызывает у меня слёзы

  • @dangerousnoodle8779
    @dangerousnoodle8779 Год назад +7

    You can almost feel the missed potential of the Energia - Buran in this song

  • @AlbertZ637
    @AlbertZ637 7 месяцев назад +4

    Рай для ушей❤

  • @Feruh_151
    @Feruh_151 9 месяцев назад +2

    Can we make this the most popular video on the channel again?

  • @x6ga7f3qu
    @x6ga7f3qu Год назад +7

    Mood of this song is like Russian bioshock

    • @lowywer3044
      @lowywer3044 2 месяца назад +3

      Или же на утраченное светлое будущее, которое не настанет таким, каким мы его видели

  • @antoniusthe5th
    @antoniusthe5th 5 месяцев назад +3

    From Komi to the Stars

    • @cortexradio
      @cortexradio  5 месяцев назад +3

      TNO brainrot 😞

    • @jolt9484
      @jolt9484 4 месяца назад +2

      @@cortexradio The consequences of TNO just like the consequences of the illegal dissolution of the USSR have been a disaster for humanity.

  • @Compass.the.Jackal
    @Compass.the.Jackal 4 месяца назад +2

    haunting in a beautiful way

  • @foodchewer
    @foodchewer Год назад +12

    They still had a future then. Or at least, they still believed they had one.

  • @Taloar543
    @Taloar543 Год назад +9

    Когда же мы уже долетим до далëких планет?

    • @arpdadawg1536
      @arpdadawg1536 Год назад +2

      2030🙏

    • @СырАрбузов
      @СырАрбузов Год назад +1

      Мы никогда. Если ты про Россию или про пост советское пространство

    • @Chulya3546
      @Chulya3546 3 месяца назад

      Для начала должен совершится качественный скачок в обществе, а там дальше видно будет

  • @sebbeballrog6205
    @sebbeballrog6205 Год назад +7

    Very beautiful.

  • @trancogaming
    @trancogaming Год назад +19

    😢Really miss the USSR

    • @Therealshithead
      @Therealshithead Год назад +1

      Man you were born like 15 years after it fell. How can you miss it

    • @chadofsvitjod
      @chadofsvitjod Год назад +1

      You aren't even from that nations nor from that time, what is there to miss?

    • @zweihanderu
      @zweihanderu Год назад +13

      @@chadofsvitjod the fact that there is no longer a shining beacon of socialism in the world. The ideas remain, and another revolution will come, but for now we are left divided.

    • @zweihanderu
      @zweihanderu Год назад +8

      @@Therealshithead even though i was not born during the time, i miss the period of socialist global revolution. Thinking about it fills me with hope that i wish i could describe. I think this is what he meant, at least this is how i view past socialist expetiments, despite some of their wrongdoings. But if there is one thing i am certain of, it’s that revolution will come again, and my wish is to be there when it happens.

    • @Therealshithead
      @Therealshithead Год назад

      @@zweihanderu hope of what? Taking massive L’s?

  • @thecosmos729
    @thecosmos729 8 месяцев назад +2

    I'm happy to have returned to this masterpiece once again. 😊

  • @Firehusky
    @Firehusky 10 месяцев назад +2

    I remember listening to this a lot many years ago

  • @katherine9098
    @katherine9098 Год назад +4

    singer's name?

    • @_Lemash_
      @_Lemash_ Год назад +4

      Vladimir Troshin

  • @thenoobpenguin_4566
    @thenoobpenguin_4566 2 месяца назад

    whenever i hear this or soviet air force march, i think about modern soviet union, their fighter jets, spacecrafts and the baikonur cosmodrome. Amazing also how Yuri Gagarin went from a random poor little boy to the first man to be in space. This truly shows that you can become almost anything, you just need to put alot of effort to it

  • @osohooosko7753
    @osohooosko7753 5 дней назад

    Song of wholesome guy in Chelyabinsk instute

  • @mauriziotonarelli3067
    @mauriziotonarelli3067 Год назад +5

    Great

  • @Рыцарьсмерти58уровня-р4л
    @Рыцарьсмерти58уровня-р4л 3 месяца назад +1

    Вот это моя страна

  • @paulkellerman8936
    @paulkellerman8936 26 дней назад

    как так вышло что от космической цивилизации страна скатилась на дно такое?

  • @sam-bf4lt
    @sam-bf4lt Год назад +1

    I feel hopeful for them , and i know how it ends

  • @uvb22
    @uvb22 Год назад +2

    Мегахарош

  • @pasthistory2058
    @pasthistory2058 Год назад +2

    dark edit song great

  • @andrihusainsudra
    @andrihusainsudra Месяц назад

    fallout vibe

  • @adolftarigan4732
    @adolftarigan4732 Год назад +1

    this song is really impressive

  • @lorenbaez
    @lorenbaez Год назад +1

    Eduard Khil singing i think...

  • @Chulya3546
    @Chulya3546 Месяц назад

    Юра, мы всё проебали...

  • @Kinard007
    @Kinard007 Год назад +1

    Nice

  • @148roach
    @148roach 10 месяцев назад +3

    "You may have won the space race, but you will not win the space war."

  • @유시은-z2d
    @유시은-z2d 11 месяцев назад

    0.85x speed is just perfect

  • @OSINT-MANAGEMENT
    @OSINT-MANAGEMENT 8 месяцев назад +2

    America ruined the progress.
    We must prioritize knowledge over capital!

  • @dalfokane
    @dalfokane Год назад +39

    As much as I don't like the bastardized soviet system of the USSR, their space future and culture was a good thing, which should be made great again, unlike romanticizing the past

    • @weefwaffer9034
      @weefwaffer9034 Год назад +23

      a lot of achievements from the soviet union should return, modern russia is in shambles from its own system's nearsighted ambitions

    • @LightCrasher
      @LightCrasher Год назад +15

      But the system was great. it produced all that great achivements. Its the individual people that fucked it up for their own sake.

    • @dalfokane
      @dalfokane Год назад +19

      @@LightCrasher A socialist society shouldn't be able to be fucked up by mere individuals.
      It is exactly the fact, that few individuals held so much power over the future of the soviet proletariat, whilst alienating it from the economical and political process, which, in the end, lead to its demise.
      People may blame Gorbachev, but I ask myself: How did he attain power? Why could a single individual cause the fall of ''socialism''? Why were the people so dissatisfied, to seek for capitalism as a solution?

    • @theyoungpaleo
      @theyoungpaleo Год назад

      @@dalfokane Please, translate my text.
      Не только Горбачев был виноват в развале СССР, а точнее он не был виноват, ряд экономических и социальных ошибок СССР привели у этому, а дальше по цепной реакции.
      Значительный вклад в это вложила афганская война, она сильно подорвала экономику СССР к 1989.
      Дальше начались митинги прибалтийских стран и их дальнейшее отделение.
      С началом распада Горбачев принял важное решение, подписать документ о создании ССР - Союза Суверенных Государств.
      Проект договора, который заменил бы Договор 1922 года об образовании СССР, чтобы спасти и реформировать Советский Союз. Церемония подписания договора между РСФСР и некоторыми другими союзными республиками была назначена на 20 августа 1991 года, но днём раньше ей помешал августовский путч.
      А так в любом случае капитализм состариться и надо будет искать ему замену как было это с феодализмом, и на смену капиталистического строя придет социализм, а за ним, возможно, когда нибудь, коммунизм.

    • @theyoungpaleo
      @theyoungpaleo Год назад +1

      А также Ельцин способствовал развалу СССР, он как либо поддерживал выход советских республик их состава.

  • @ВолодимирСуходуб-д6в

    What nonsense! Now this is not relevant at all. Yes, 1917 opened the way to the stars, but 1991 closed this way.

    • @polskikolejarz5507
      @polskikolejarz5507 Год назад +1

      No one needed to go to the moon it was too expansive

    • @avgsocialist
      @avgsocialist Год назад

      And with china, the last major socialist power, receding into state capitalism, will we ever settle the stars?