Political Parties Must Be Subject To the Same Stringent Transparency Rules as NGOs
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
- This week Sucheta Dalal looks at the Supreme Court's decision on Electoral Bonds in India. These bonds allowed anonymous donations to political parties, raising concerns about transparency. The Court struck down the scheme, demanding to know who donated to whom. Watch the video as Sucheta Dalal argues that the same stringent rules transparency applied to NGOs should also be applicable to political parties.
For more read: www.moneylife....
#electoralbonds #suchetadalal #moneylife
For more information visit our website : www.moneylife.in/
Register : www.moneylife.i...
Follow us on Facebook : / moneylifedailyclinics
Follow us on Twitter : / moneylifef
Madam, you are absolutely correct. Yes, PM CARES Fund must be investigated throughly, and the PM should be jailed for life if found guilty of any misdeeds.Period.
Agree with you
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Absolutely right ma'am. Political Parties Accounts MUST be audited just as stringently as Finances of NGO'S.
Absolutely right. Why should political parties be able to whatever they want, but demand transparency from others? Our political parties are riddled with criminal elements and self serving strongmen.
The system itself especially india is made that way so many loophole yet common citizen has no way to defence themself from the system. Yes we do need a structural change in the constitution.
The governments (both central and states) have to be absolutely transparent on all their business. When we will see an end of the top down approach (mahi baap) sarkar? You are absolutely 💯 correct! 👌👍🙏
You have been crisp and logically clear on this important issue. To extend the argument, I think
that it is immoral for elected representatives (or public servants like our Administrative Services
folks) to lead regal lives at the cost of taxpayers money. Who gave the freedom and moral sanction
for the PM and co to live like kings? No accountability, no nothing ! Just think about the insane
benefits doled out to high up public servants - laws and rules they make that benefit only themselves !
This has to stop.
Are not shareholders of donor companies have been cheated by the respective Boards.
Is it not syphoning of company funds or embezzlement
interesting point. unfortunately no shareholder will question management or demand access to the board discussion when the decision to donate via electoral bonds was taken or quantum of funds was decided. Especially when repeated donations are made. The board is equally responsible and shareholders have a right to know
Was waiting for your video on this subject. Thanks
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Fully agree with Sucheta
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Thanks Madam.
Was waiting for your analysis.
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Absolutely correct. Why this special treatment
Why didn't the left parties receive bonds ? Is it because of their strong bonding with their fathers in the neighbourhood ?
If it is fundamental right of people of India to know everything about bonds what about their right to know about how their supreme gods are selected ?
Clear signs of our democracy strengthening, we need more electoral reforms
Excellent arguments in favour of transparency in governance.
Your point about PMCares is well taken. Political parties should be also subject to the same degree of audit.
I do pray that your tribe increases dear Sucheta❤. We could transform the whole system and how❤❤
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
@@MoneylifeNewsBites I agree. But the bitter truth is also that the majority doesn't care and goes about their living in their little bubble unaffected..
Not only political partie, big corporate companies also.
Completely agree with you madam
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
@@MoneylifeNewsBites I always share your videos as much as I can
Totally agree
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Blackmoney rerouted via these bonds to every party
Absolutely correct. Why two different yardsticks for the same issues. Let there be a level playing field in this matter
100%
Has to be
Thanks for this video 🙏🏻
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Why listed companies, which gave electoral bonds, didnt disclose the same to their shareholders? Isn't transparency required on part of the companies too?
Gud suggestion,strict monitoring,no exemption,and privilage,
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Let the accounts submitted by the various parties to the election commission come under RTI and/or be made public on the election commission's website. Let the public scrutinize these accounts.
A better way would be for the EC itself to appoint the auditors.
However, given how the EC is now selected, it would not make any difference 🙁
Very true.
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
@@MoneylifeNewsBites sure.
Absolutely
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Totally with yourself on this.
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Lost my job for filing RTI. Difficult for ordinary individuals to fight for rights. Wanted to file an RTI on Manipur situation, another on Ladakh, where Sonam Wangchuk is fasting ..... but backed off....😢😢....in fear of becoming a target
Madam, how the political parties in the western developed countries in Europe and in the USA are funded to fight the elections in their respective countries?
What are the best practices followed in this regard and in which country/countries?
What are the problems to follow those best practices in India??
Hello Mam, Huge fan of your channel and you. Good point raised.
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Excellent proposal. Modi however will not cut the branch he is sitting on. We the people have to cut it for him, and let the consequences be drastic for Modi. Who told him to choose such a rotten branch to sit on ?
Also the question arises why a company is allowed to contribute to a Political party, Party cannot Vote in the elections and hence should not be allowed to contribute to Political parties, as a individual their CEOs , MDs can contribute since they can Vote. Only individual contributions should be considered for Political Parties. Political Parties are about ideologies which citizen Vote for, so only citizens should be allowed to contribute.
How can we as citizens initiate this ??
Collection and disbursements under PM CARES is a blackbox as of now. Would this be cited as the 'gander' in the next PIL??
This debate is so widespread today after the black money deals of political parties for over seven decades was stopped the electoral bond scheme. So do not make the EBS the villain of the piece
Just as any ordinary citizen has to provide all forms of accountability there should be complete transparency and accountability for political funding as well.
Very true madam
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
I too demand why this special treatment to present govt, whereas we were deeply sleeping when illecit cash donations were funding govts during elections, to do control those elected govts and so their bombings in CST station, Taj hotel, Hospitals and even Cafes. How such anti-national activities could have carried out if white-money electoral bonds were inforce, in those days.
Even Pakisthan sponsered many bomb blasts in our beautiful city, having donated cash to then political parties in unaccountable, black money in cash and my favourite journalist was in deep sleep those days that could not raise this topic, when their OWN city was bombarded with same 'cash donations'.
We too demand not to special treat this present govt too, as like we slept in those national-security threatened times and allowed our loving Mumbaites became dead bodies, due to our deep-sleep.
Well said. However, I was hoping you would cover shareholder's losses/ potential dividend if not profits. Our rights have been compromised big time, by e.g Airtel, Aurobindo/ Healthcare cos. directly . Please talk about that part...taking further from Faye D'Souza and Quint conversations on her channel
Thank you for your thoughtful suggestion and willingness to support our efforts to scale. Your encouragement means a lot to us. Indeed, expanding our team could greatly enhance the quality and quantity of content we produce.Spread the word, connect us with talent, provide feedback, and engage with our content to help us scale.
💯 % agreement with you, Ma'am.
“Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos - but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions - so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Already subscribed
Can the shareholders of the companies sue the directors for donating without their consent?
this issue and several such issues is why this govt has to go all all wrong legislations and wrong doings are throughly investigated and set right
who will bell the cat on demanding political party transperancy?
When,
Google knows past & present of you, including your thoughts & emotions,
and so,
mould your future thinking & actions, then,
where's the place of democracy today ⁉️
What's it's meaning/worth ⁉️
All the foreign funds coming into the country must be allowed only after investigations irrespective of who receives it.
Ofcourse, how they are different than others?
Indirectly the money which can get to goverment for public good is transferred to party fund and utilised for only party gain.
Is it not more of a threat to national security for political parties to be financed by foreign entities than for NGOs to receive funds from abroad ❓️🤔
yes, stop this cheating by modi bjp rss
yes, but also for *all* parties, organizations including corporations.
Pl compare foreign contributions taken by political parties bypassing rules n later irregularities regularised by Modi cooperative govt for benefit of self n other political parties
Madam, so glad that you started this discussion in 2024. But were we sleeping before electoral bonds came into existence? You were in your most investigative mode before this issue, as well.
So, we didnot hear our favourite investigative journalist talked about 'cash donations to political parties' where no one troubled to investigate whether that illecit cash been donated by a terrorist group who funded party to allow them to bomb local trains or killing so many innocents on CST station and hospital. Why to bother, Madam. That time my govt was in full force and why investigating journalist need to bother about such 'illecit cash transactions and those donors control over govts and nation itself.
Now, suddenly our investigative journalists raised from their long sleep and started morning-hungama.
Atleast, now public knew that those donors are NOT ANANYMOUS and they had to buy electoral bonds from ONLY white money.
Suddenly wakening from deep sleep is not PURE JOURNALISM, a journalist would have raised same topic when parties were funded by illecit means like terrorist nations and witty forces, who tried to destabilize and control those govts.
Madam, we have only one life. Let us be true and principled so that atleast no one like me question the integrity of a investigative journalist's hipocritic human life.
Thankyou, Madam for understanding my point.
Sir, I will not respond to your rude and completely clueless comments about my extensive writing over 37 years, since you have made no effort to read, know or understand the issues i have written about. Please note that RUclips gives us the right to deal with such trolling.
Political parties n transparency are completely opposite to each other...can't happen in India😡
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
The British indeed played a role in the development of India, but unfortunately, some individuals took advantage of this opportunity and engaged in excessive looting under the guise of development. Loot india
Proverbial story - who will bell the cat. 😂
Lokayukta was for that
Rules apply only for non user of Modi washing powder sponsored by BJP. Join us - fully clean yourself of all sins instantly with Z plus security at free