even if you dont like the games, sonic should have a chance at the music category, im still surprised sonic in all his existence never once appeared on that category
Ngl, it really does feels like he hates Sonic for some reason. As no matter how good these games end up for each category, Sonic is still less likely to get ominated than random no name game no one played or Blizzard game everyone shat on for months
A DLC being a contender is actually ridiculous. So many actually good games came out that could've had that spot. I wanted to vote for Silent Hill 2 as game of the year.
what picks are these??? i mean, as an atlus fan, i’ll choose metaphor, but i already know wukong’s gonna win edit: OH OH OH WHY THE HELL DID THEY NOT INCLUDE CINCORD?!
Comedy aside, I really don't think Elden Ring DLC, Balatro and Astro Bot should be there. DLC can't win GOTY because it's literally not a game. Balatro is just a card game it can't win GOTY, and if it does, make Marvels Spiderman take it over GOW2018 in... 2018. And Astro Bot isn't even a proper game it's literally made just to showcase the PS5's capabilities it was never intended as a serious GOTY competitor or anything like that
@@Sandwich-5-sand Both Astro's Playroom and Astrobot are made to show the Playstation's capabilities, Astrobot being a sequel to Playroom doesn't really change anything
the funny thing about a LITERALL DLC being a goty nominee is wild whats even wilder is that miyazaki said that elden ring still isnt the game he wants it to be
Pretty sure he emphasised the fact that he wasn't part of the group deciding the nominees, he really wanted to deflect as much backlash as possible away from himself
Dude you completely glazed over the points people are actually making about Shadow of the Erdtree. Its a DLC, it shouldnt be included in GAME of the year, because without the actual game, it wouldnt exist. Not to mention, they completely snubbed Phantom Liberty last eyar under the guise of it being a dlc and therefore not being eligible, uet here we are. Doesnt matter how good it is, it shouldnt be included in game of the year, because it isnt a game.
Hey there, I’m not calling you out directly, I’ve seen a lot of responses like this so I’m responding to you to address them all. This is a weak argument, Shadow of the Erdtree does exist as a game regardless of its status as a DLC. It’s a new experience that a majority of players enjoyed and achieved critical acclaim. Just because it requires a base game doesn’t make it unworthy of GOTY; games like Monster Hunter World: Iceborne or The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine are treated as standalone experiences, I don’t see why now this is such a big issue. Regardless even of these points, while in the past DLC was not accepted, they are now and they feel Shadow of the Erdtree deserves the spot. If you really don’t like that Shadow of the Erdtree is nominated for GOTY that much - don’t vote for it.
@@TheFlipsideShow I think shadow of the Erdtree deserves an award, it deserves to be recogniseed for how great of a dlc it is. But it is as good as it is because it is the dlc for elden ring. If it was the dlc for star wars outlaws, it'd be a terrible dlc because the game its based off is fundamentally bad.
It feels like they are include elden ring just to eliminate stellar blade, silent hill 2 or space marine 2. It became controversy and hopefully, the hate shift to fromsoft.
@@highlord2841 I don't think the poster wanted the hate shift at all, I think he just wanted to share a theory about what the process behind this decision [to include DLCs as GOTY contenders] was from the event organizers perspective. It's pretty funny to think they would think something like that. DLCs should belong in another category altogether.
No DLC belongs there and ER DLC was poorly made with empty land, repeat enemies from base game, and typical "GRRM" incest plot. Miyazaki sold his brain or what?
How dare he not include sonic
Hol up sonicxshadow generations is peak
Excuse ME!!!!!!! Do you really think that Sonic is gonna be on here after the disaster that was 06?!?!? SHAMEFUL!!!!!!!!
Hey wait a minute I know you you’re gonna be my wife
@@TheFlipsideShowhuh wait what?
"The year of Shadow... right?"
even if you dont like the games, sonic should have a chance at the music category, im still surprised sonic in all his existence never once appeared on that category
Ngl, it really does feels like he hates Sonic for some reason. As no matter how good these games end up for each category, Sonic is still less likely to get ominated than random no name game no one played or Blizzard game everyone shat on for months
Jeff did nothing, he said he wasnt included in the voting 😭
HE RUINED MY LIFE.
Calm down.
Next year's GOTY nominees are gonna be Doritos and MTN Dew
*Ruffles watching this from distance* 😮
Justice for Paper Mario.
A DLC being a contender is actually ridiculous. So many actually good games came out that could've had that spot. I wanted to vote for Silent Hill 2 as game of the year.
It came out to late next year it has a chance I think
@blazewarking sorry, what? Clarify please?
yes but that's a remake so if it got on the list people would complain about that instead
That's literal Flipside
even though this is great satire, the game (awards) was rigged from the start.
HE DIDNT EVEN MENTION CALL OF DUTY BLACK OPS 627!! THAT GAME JUST SHINES WITH ITS ORIGINAL CONCEPT
Took me a solid 5 seconds to figure out what this was
what picks are these???
i mean, as an atlus fan, i’ll choose metaphor, but i already know wukong’s gonna win
edit: OH OH OH WHY THE HELL DID THEY NOT INCLUDE CINCORD?!
i didn't know about balatros existence before this
Comedy aside, I really don't think Elden Ring DLC, Balatro and Astro Bot should be there. DLC can't win GOTY because it's literally not a game. Balatro is just a card game it can't win GOTY, and if it does, make Marvels Spiderman take it over GOW2018 in... 2018. And Astro Bot isn't even a proper game it's literally made just to showcase the PS5's capabilities it was never intended as a serious GOTY competitor or anything like that
I think you're confusing the first astrobot with the new one, though yeah, the picks are quite weird
@@Sandwich-5-sand Both Astro's Playroom and Astrobot are made to show the Playstation's capabilities, Astrobot being a sequel to Playroom doesn't really change anything
@@diaryofarobotits still a full on game tho
When im in a shitty take contest and my opponent is diaryofarobot1
@@doomer3468 😭😭😭
the funny thing about a LITERALL DLC being a goty nominee is wild
whats even wilder is that miyazaki said that elden ring still isnt the game he wants it to be
Geoffrey how dare you not nominate epic mickey rebrushed for goty I will get you
That Gunky boy (@gunkyboysyt go subscribe)
thanks jeff
Pretty sure he emphasised the fact that he wasn't part of the group deciding the nominees, he really wanted to deflect as much backlash as possible away from himself
Never in my life have I heard of a game called 'Metaphor'. The only metaphor I know is the one you learn in English classes.
Dude you completely glazed over the points people are actually making about Shadow of the Erdtree. Its a DLC, it shouldnt be included in GAME of the year, because without the actual game, it wouldnt exist. Not to mention, they completely snubbed Phantom Liberty last eyar under the guise of it being a dlc and therefore not being eligible, uet here we are. Doesnt matter how good it is, it shouldnt be included in game of the year, because it isnt a game.
Hey there, I’m not calling you out directly, I’ve seen a lot of responses like this so I’m responding to you to address them all.
This is a weak argument, Shadow of the Erdtree does exist as a game regardless of its status as a DLC. It’s a new experience that a majority of players enjoyed and achieved critical acclaim. Just because it requires a base game doesn’t make it unworthy of GOTY; games like Monster Hunter World: Iceborne or The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine are treated as standalone experiences, I don’t see why now this is such a big issue. Regardless even of these points, while in the past DLC was not accepted, they are now and they feel Shadow of the Erdtree deserves the spot. If you really don’t like that Shadow of the Erdtree is nominated for GOTY that much - don’t vote for it.
@@TheFlipsideShow 100% most based take I’ve seen on this topic
@@TheFlipsideShow I think shadow of the Erdtree deserves an award, it deserves to be recogniseed for how great of a dlc it is. But it is as good as it is because it is the dlc for elden ring. If it was the dlc for star wars outlaws, it'd be a terrible dlc because the game its based off is fundamentally bad.
@@TheFlipsideShow just make dlc its own category
😂 they put Elden Ring there to get away with not putting Stellar Blade. DLCs shouldn’t be nominated for GOTY.
Batman Arkham shadow should win
To be serious I actually don’t know why they didn’t include Sonic x Shadow generations
how dare you 😡
What happened to all that talk about wukong being black listed from the games awards
Dont tell me anti woke grifters lied again
BRO WHERE IS WARHAMMER MARINES 2 DAWG
Eldren ring DLC dosent belong there
It feels like they are include elden ring just to eliminate stellar blade, silent hill 2 or space marine 2. It became controversy and hopefully, the hate shift to fromsoft.
@@FayN_ Why do you want the hate to shift from the people who made the bad decision to the people who made the peak game and it’s even more peak DLC
@@highlord2841 bro must have been fumbled so hard on soldier of Godrick
@@highlord2841 I don't think the poster wanted the hate shift at all, I think he just wanted to share a theory about what the process behind this decision [to include DLCs as GOTY contenders] was from the event organizers perspective.
It's pretty funny to think they would think something like that. DLCs should belong in another category altogether.
SOTE is unironically better than any of these games, it's not even close
No DLC belongs there and ER DLC was poorly made with empty land, repeat enemies from base game, and typical "GRRM" incest plot. Miyazaki sold his brain or what?
Nothin but an obvious bait. Although I agree about the dlc part
Unpopular opinion; Elden Ring sucks. Good lore and story, but it has the playability of Golden Eye for ps2.
nah, er is great, the playability is what made it win goty
@giganticmoon nah
I agree. It was the weakest Miyazaki game and the DLC sucks even bigger.
Golden Eye was for N64 and its gameplay was and still is goated what does any of this mean
@@TheFlipsideShow there's a PS2 version too
remeber who told you this GOTY will be Dragon age not cos its a good game but cos its woke.