Analysis: Half Life 2 Episode 1 - The Forgotten One

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024

Комментарии • 103

  • @Jarekthegamingdragon
    @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад +4

    Play War Thunder now with my link, and get a massive, free bonus pack including vehicles, boosters and more: playwt.link/jarekgamingdragonwt
    Thanks to every one that joined me on twitch! Streaming VR is a pain but a ton of fun! If you want to hang out in the future, consider giving a follow! www.twitch.tv/jarek4gamingdragon

  • @EnclaveSOC-102
    @EnclaveSOC-102 Год назад +145

    Can't wait for you to mention how Episode Two fixed the whole flashlight situation by making it have a separate power supply rather than using more power whenever you sprint.

  • @CoolSs
    @CoolSs Год назад +71

    episode one got one of my favorite fps sequence of all time. that one elevator ride in the dark when you got flares and fast zombies are rushing you. it's such fun sequence. that i often realized that the elevator already arrived but i still keep fighting.

    • @morkgin2459
      @morkgin2459 Год назад +7

      That gave me nightmares

    • @KEA-1988
      @KEA-1988 Год назад +2

      I remenber this survival horror part too.

    • @southpaw117
      @southpaw117 Год назад +2

      I just wish Valve didn't make it easier. I enjoyed it most when I played it on launch.

    • @ulascelikbas4823
      @ulascelikbas4823 Год назад +3

      I was 11 when I first played ep1 and it gave me major nightmares for a month.

    • @stormhought
      @stormhought Год назад

      Honestly, the flashlight kinda ruins it. playing with a mod makes way better though

  • @brawler5760
    @brawler5760 Год назад +36

    Episode 1 being considered the “worst” really says a lot about the official Half Life games really.

  • @SplotchTheCatThing
    @SplotchTheCatThing Год назад +22

    I read a... thing... by Kelly Bailey a while back -- unfortunately haven't a clue where it was -- where he said that the guitar that comes in the music track that plays in the hospital was meant to feel like a Big Deal. In context, an "earth instrument" coming in over all those cold and impersonal digital synths, even kinda glitched-out as it was, represented the balance of power beginning to shift.
    Thought that was neat :)

    • @saltierdongs7760
      @saltierdongs7760 Год назад +3

      The soundtrack in ep1 had much more "human" instruments which was always cool to me

  • @t850terminator
    @t850terminator Год назад +19

    Episode 1 is still the peak of escort NPC design and still hasn't been matched since.

  • @electricindigoball1244
    @electricindigoball1244 Год назад +25

    If anyone is thinking about replaying this then I strongly suggest going for the One Free Bullet achievement as it makes a repeat playthrough a lot more fun. Otherwise it's hard to not notice how similar this feels to the late chapters of HL2 with a few exceptions.
    Regarding Barney while his model doesn't appear in EP2 and he isn't mentioned, one of his voice lines is used when you come back to White Forest after the battle with the Striders though it could be just a case of one of his voice lines being reused accidentally.

    • @rosskuhlman
      @rosskuhlman Год назад

      Yeah I did that last time I played it, to finally reach 100% achievements for the game. I enjoyed that a lot more than the gnome achievement in ep2 which was a chore and something I never want to do again.

  • @Roler42
    @Roler42 Год назад +65

    You can tell Valve was experimenting and throwing things at the wall when they made Episode 1, like they really wanted to show the spectacle of escaping City 17, including getting to see the Citadel blow up, but then they realized that would make a really short game, so everything leading to it just feels like filler.
    It still speaks well of Half-Life when their weakest game is only weak because of how forgettable it is compared to the main game and Episode 2.
    Man, I miss the days when Valve used to actually make games...

    • @AgentSmith-oh7sb
      @AgentSmith-oh7sb Год назад +8

      I think the biggest issue is they were doing the episodic thing. I think they, as you said, started throwing ideas at the wall then got to a point where they said, "hey, we have to at least release SOMETHING" and that's how we got Episode 1 and why 2 feels a lot stronger by comparison.

    • @dive_bomb3r
      @dive_bomb3r Год назад

      "Valve. We used to make games. Now, we make money."

  • @Hesoyam_009
    @Hesoyam_009 Год назад +20

    "What Kind Of Hospital Is This" is the best thing of Episode One tbh

    • @GregFurey98
      @GregFurey98 Год назад +3

      One of the best tracks in the series.

    • @ATP2555ify
      @ATP2555ify 16 дней назад

      I always try to get to the end before the song ends.

  • @MatadorShifter
    @MatadorShifter Год назад +19

    I loved Episode 1. I replayed it like two years ago and it was much better than I remembered it from the 2000s. It's feels to be more of a technothriller than Half Life 2. The climatic moments at the Citadel with amazing music and mystery breathing down your neck are one of the best things that happened in Half Life's universe.

  • @danielferreira3573
    @danielferreira3573 Год назад +4

    Just got to episode 1 on my half life VR run, loving it so far

  • @insertusername9755
    @insertusername9755 Год назад +6

    Ep1 has one of the funniest achievements ever, 1 free bullet!

  • @sean_69
    @sean_69 Год назад +3

    Jarek just wanna say thank you for the consistency over the years and always making great videos. You’re the man brotha.

  • @R3AL-AIM
    @R3AL-AIM Год назад +2

    I have been on and off replaying the HL2 series for awhile now. I'm about a quarter way through this Episode... It was honestly very good imo. Many of some very notable moments in the entire story happened in that game.

  • @tziminadisnt
    @tziminadisnt Год назад +3

    When I saw the cover of episode 1, I thought you would play as Alyx and it would lead to different gameplay (as opposing forces shifted things up).
    Then I finally played and realized it was more Half-life 2 (which is not bad, I just was expecting bigger changes)

  • @mysterious_559
    @mysterious_559 Год назад +2

    Im glad they fixed the flashlight system

  • @idhalgox4883
    @idhalgox4883 Год назад +4

    Orange box is a game industry's peak. Period.

    • @R3AL-AIM
      @R3AL-AIM Год назад

      Yep. The Orange Box + GMod brought me to PC as a primary. Been a good 13 years 😁

  • @Gameprojordan
    @Gameprojordan Год назад +2

    That godawful escort mission at the end will never be forgotten. Going into the Citadel's core was an aesthetically pleasing moment though. Probably the sexiest looking area in the entire HL2 trilogy IMO.
    But yeah, this game is definitely the Blue Shift of HL2

    • @rosskuhlman
      @rosskuhlman Год назад +1

      I enjoyed the escort mission tbh. It was a nice change of pace from the constant forward progress of the rest of the games. You got a chance to become familiar with the path and they would change it up a bit during each subsequent attempt

  • @NKP723
    @NKP723 9 месяцев назад +1

    I have a serious issue with EP1 because I got into a softlock in Exit City 17 where the last citizens you escort keep reappearing. Basically you just keep escorting them again and again without getting new supplies. Yeah there's ammo but no health. And then that fight to the train is a complete slog

  • @ShootingStar1313
    @ShootingStar1313 Год назад +1

    Forgotten... but not gone. Wait, that doesn't even make sense! 😵‍💫
    Most memorable part for me was when Alyx freaks out after the train crashes and a stalker's bearing down on her. Genuine human reaction 💯

  • @KimFareseed
    @KimFareseed 8 месяцев назад +1

    The developer commentary of episode 1 and 2 are interesting. Wish there was one for HL2.

  • @thedylansang
    @thedylansang 6 месяцев назад

    I'm going to cut this short. We may have been spotted.
    "SHE'S GETTING AWAY!"

  • @abhaybhatt4286
    @abhaybhatt4286 Год назад +4

    Episode 1 was so forgettable. The only part remember in detail was the hospital fight. Seeing the citadel core is still visually impressive even today as well

  • @aruan7sp
    @aruan7sp Год назад +1

    Remember when Episode 1 was called Aftermath?

    • @denifnaf5874
      @denifnaf5874 3 дня назад

      Remember how episode 1 and 2 where meant to be the same game?

  • @Matt-md5yt
    @Matt-md5yt Год назад +1

    Sweet glad you talked about this episode

  • @FreemanBgTV
    @FreemanBgTV Год назад +1

    How its forgoten
    Episode 1 its short but prity cool

  • @casedistorted
    @casedistorted Год назад

    I always loved Episode 1 because it didn’t leave Half Life 2 on the cliffhanger I assumed we would get. But then I started to dislike Episode 2 because THAT gave us a cliffhanger we would never get a resolution to.
    Episode 3 I waited so long for, but considering I waited 5 years? Between half life 1 and 2, and 7 years between Super Metroid and Metroid Fusion, I wasn’t beyond waiting patiently.
    And 2007.. man we got orange box AND Halo 3! Such a fantastic year for me,
    It was just good all around

  • @wickdaline8668
    @wickdaline8668 Год назад +1

    Never knew there were VR versions of this if that's what this is?

    • @rosskuhlman
      @rosskuhlman Год назад +2

      Mods, not official releases. Looks pretty high quality though!

  • @CoolSs
    @CoolSs Год назад +1

    0:00 *cry with no VR*

  • @kirillholt2329
    @kirillholt2329 Год назад

    I fucking hate the fact that blue shift is always brought up in a negative tone. I love blue shift when you pair it in conjunction with OP4 more then the base game.

  • @HOTD108_
    @HOTD108_ Год назад +1

    I don't think people forget about this game at all. They just lump it in with episode 2 as if they were just one big expansion, which makes sense since most people played it through The Orange Box.

  • @Loopy1330
    @Loopy1330 Год назад +1

    That's what I noticed about Episode 1, it's not bad it's just not outstanding. Blue Shift gets a lot of shit for not being another Opposing Force but at least Gearbox still managed to do something interesting with it. Episode 1 doesn't introduce anything that new other than the flares (which I don't really care about) and the zombines which are a pretty good enemy type. Valve did add some extra touches though like how Alyx reacts to Gordon's flashlight in her eyes or when she hits a zombie. Episode 1 mainly just exists to peddle the story along between Half-Life 2 and Episode 2 which has all of the new interesting stuff. Most of Episode 1 pertains to things already done in Half-Life 2 like the ruined cities. Half-Life 2 is still a good game, so if being more of Half-Life 2 is the worst it gets, it's not that bad.
    There are some neat things about Episode 1 that I do like. I like the electrified water puzzle in the hospital, I like how you can snatch zombine grenades, I love songs like Disrupted Original, Self-Destruction and Penultimatum, the gunship battle in the attic, also the warehouse during the citizen escourt section which no one talks about. The rest of the section in the parking lot is a drag because it's pretty much the same with every pass, Combine soldiers and Civil Protection keep coming. In the warehouse meanwhile the layout changes with each pass. Everything gets more and more destroyed each time which changes the layout, whole trains get shifted and part of the catwalk breaks. Therefore, you have to change up your approach every time to take the new layout into account which keeps the gameplay a little fresh. Still nothing outstanding yet thinking back I appreciate it.

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад +2

      I didn't mention the warehouse bit because it's basically the same as the courtyard. The small changes aren't enough to make me feel like I'm not doing the same thing over and over.

    • @Loopy1330
      @Loopy1330 Год назад

      @@Jarekthegamingdragon I haven't touched Episode 1 in a good while so maybe I'm thinking back too fondly on it.
      An idea I've had for the parking lot is what if Gordon had the bugbait with him? The player could get it from that one antlion guardian by the mounted turret earlier on, then antlions could show up in the parking lot at the end to keep the Combine busy while citizens sneak past. It would be nothing new but it would be better than the retail version. Maybe have borrows in the parking lot that Gordon has to uncover with the gravity gun, allowing the player to break the rules.

  • @insertmemorableusernameher6795

    Ive always kinda wished valve kept the episodes as half life 2 aftermath, used more strider fights in city 17, and used the wasteland in place of the forest in episode 2

    • @TryHardCentral
      @TryHardCentral 2 месяца назад

      The forest was amazing and also they tried smth new

  • @DeadManSinging1
    @DeadManSinging1 Год назад

    The reason I never replay this one as much is because I fucking hate the opening bit. I just want a gun

  • @TohaZhirnij
    @TohaZhirnij Год назад +1

    I love hospital level in EP1

  • @zorgapb4691
    @zorgapb4691 Год назад +1

    I never understood the hate for Episode One. It was my favorite one, i really liked the C17 environment

  • @HQ_Default
    @HQ_Default Год назад

    My opinion of Episode 1 was always that the opening absolutely kicks ass, but everything after that ranges from "Yeah this is more Half Life 2" to "UUUUGH"

  • @Zack_Wester
    @Zack_Wester Год назад

    the 4 player escort was a partial engine limit (I think there was some effort to have a bunch of unarmed civilian come out whit the 4 you "escort").
    that would hide and follow the player between the rooms but did not work.
    so it become you escorting the 4 guards.
    and no the game did not like having more then 4 NPC following the player.
    Alex and Barney uses some weird tricks to work (reason why you can´t see there status in the HUD).

  • @Randomstuffs261
    @Randomstuffs261 Год назад +1

    Ah yes, HL2 Episode 1
    I remember liking it, I just don't remember anything about it

  • @ultgamercw6759
    @ultgamercw6759 Год назад +2

    I've got to be the asshole who points out that Half Life Alyx is actually the game that takes the longest to get the crowbar in. 😈

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад

      "This is the longest you go without a crowbar, *unless the Half-Life game didn't have a crowbar."* Nice try but you failed.

  • @AgentSmith-oh7sb
    @AgentSmith-oh7sb Год назад

    I 100% agree with everything you said. Even when it came out I hated playing the defense/escort part. I also didn't remember ANYTHING about the plot other than you get on a train and leave City 17.

  • @jopeteus
    @jopeteus Год назад

    Almost 20 years since Half Life 2 and we STILL don't have a conlusion to the story!!

  • @theguyinthere
    @theguyinthere Год назад

    I love the shorter half life games cause i'm always short on time and i like just jumping on listening to some music and vibing. i don't like stop and starts most of the time.

  • @tweezersalad4075
    @tweezersalad4075 Год назад

    By this point I was just done with City 17 location. I liked it in the beginning of 2 but it overstayed its welcome

  • @PVTC01
    @PVTC01 Год назад

    Love when youtubers say this "...First I have to mention the people who made this video possible..." ~Ad segment~ Isn't it your audience and viewers who make it possible along with the Ads?

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад

      RUclips revenue fluctuates WILDLY. Pay is as low as $600 some times. Sponsors are currently paying more than youtube does. I have to pay bills and rent. While I appreciate my viewers, sponsors are what allow me to make this my job or the videos wouldn't exist at all.

    • @PVTC01
      @PVTC01 Год назад

      ​@@Jarekthegamingdragon Oh? I thought RUclips pay went back up to a point where people could live and pay bills, if need be. I thought Ads were just a way to gain even more. What a shame.

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад

      @@PVTC01 RUclips pay has always been inconsistent. It just dips real hard any time the economy is struggling. It's also unreliable. Sponsors give financial security that we won't have other wise.

    • @PVTC01
      @PVTC01 Год назад

      ​@@Jarekthegamingdragon Hopefully the new CEO will change RUclips's income system, unlikely but you never know.

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад

      @@PVTC01 There's not really any way to fix that. When the economy is struggling, youtube gets less companies paying for ads on their site which is where youtube revenue comes from, when there's less ads to go around, you get less money whether you get views or not. On top of that, your views are at the whim of youtube's algorithm. It's a very unreliable source of income and it's why you'll see every youtuber accept sponsorships directly.

  • @FatfighterXD1
    @FatfighterXD1 Год назад

    ep 1 is fine outside of that awful escort section that i thought was bugged cos it just kept going on and on and on

  • @Lord_Deimos
    @Lord_Deimos Год назад +1

    Is it something kids do these days to dislike Opposing Force? I have never met anyone who didn't like it when it came out.

  • @TauGeneration
    @TauGeneration Год назад

    Funny story, Jarek. i recently finished Episode 1 recently. welp. i hope you talk about episode 2 a month later

  • @Foxtrop13
    @Foxtrop13 Год назад

    well I have episode one on steam, and I wanted o play episode one on VR, but it requires episode two, wtf vr modders

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад +2

      It's based on Episode 2's version of the source engine. Surprised you don't you have episode 2. I'm sure you'll end up playing both. It's pretty cheap and goes on sale often.

  • @sophiangkaborgohain401
    @sophiangkaborgohain401 7 месяцев назад

    I played episode 2 before episode 1

  • @co-mastah8149
    @co-mastah8149 Год назад +1

    Jarek, would you do HL2 beta mod like Raising The Bar Redux or Dark Interval?
    Kinda like to know your opinion

  • @kaos-vi7mf
    @kaos-vi7mf Год назад

    Jarek I did the same thing with halo reach, went to my local GameStop waited, and was told it was the same date next year 😢

  • @Viper-jr4sp
    @Viper-jr4sp Год назад

    HL2 EP1 I love I was just about to be 7 at the time EP1 released my dad and brother bought it I loved it I was a bit disappointed it was short but at the same time I expected it the soundtrack though was awesome my favourite is Guard Down and the Hospital one there was something about Episode One that I loved idk what but in the end from containing the reactor to fighting through the zombies underground to the combat in the streets and the icing on the cake was seeing the citidal explode that was another thing about ep1 I kept looking at the citidal worried on the state it was in going are we gonna make it? But overall? It was fun I’ve played it so many times combined with playing coop on synergy

  • @marrvynswillames4975
    @marrvynswillames4975 Год назад

    I was one of the guys who ended up liking it more than two. Idk, I think the overfocus in the Gravity Gun, as fun it is, reduces a bit from my enjoyment

  • @rosskuhlman
    @rosskuhlman Год назад

    I agree with your sentiment overall, but still think ep1 is good. It felt like a greatest hits highlight reel of HL2 which is both its strength and its weakness. Everything in it was well done IMO, but nothing was really new other than reprogramming the roller mines which was basically forgotten once you left the citadel. Despite those complaints I still enjoyed it when I replayed it a year or so ago

  • @Nacalal
    @Nacalal Год назад

    I still prefer EP1 over 2 to be honest.
    The start is a little rough, but once you get back into the city it gets way more fun.

  • @kellofkells6002
    @kellofkells6002 Год назад

    Love finding your videos on some of my favorite games over the years you’re one of the good ones

  • @dotcomgamingd5564
    @dotcomgamingd5564 Год назад

    sweet, the facecam is back

  • @nd_kui1772
    @nd_kui1772 Год назад +1

    In my opinion episode 1 is just kinda boring. It is full of gimmicks that you actually have to follow. The only good part was the zombie elevator sequence. But fighting zombies in general is kinda boring. But that was an amazing set piece nevertheless. Just wished it had more normal combat. It felt like a collection of gimmicks. Episode 2 was also kinda gimmicky. But at least it had way more normal combat.

  • @savitar7869
    @savitar7869 Год назад

    hey jarek i have a interesting request can you post your streams so i can rewatch them in case i miss a stream hopefully if it isn’t too much of a hassle for you #this is mostly me wanting to watch your halo streams

    • @savitar7869
      @savitar7869 Год назад

      also sorry for the weird link sorry about this was not meant to be there

    • @Jarekthegamingdragon
      @Jarekthegamingdragon  Год назад

      Streams get exported to my secondary channel. @JarekTheGamingDragonTV

    • @savitar7869
      @savitar7869 Год назад

      thanks so much! plus im a fan of your content keep doing what your doing!

  • @elHosed
    @elHosed Год назад

    I always think of Ep 1 and 2 as one game rather then two different ones. As such I have to agree, Ep 1 is just more of the same and rather mid. It's my least favorite.
    Personally I quite liked Blue Shift. It's considered the worst because it was short and didn't introduce much new game-play or gadgets/weapons. New hi res models in a low res environment isn't "new features". Also, Opposing Force raised the bar REALLY high for Half-life expansions especially coming from Gearbox at the time.
    I found the game-play and story of Blue Shift quite tight and fun though.

  • @ConkerTS
    @ConkerTS Год назад

    I was very disappointed by Episode 1, since it was so short and so uninventive compared to Half-Life 2. They could have at least let you command/use the Ant-Lions in Episode 1, since it was such an enjoyable game mechanic in HL2. Or brought back some of the weapons and enemies from Half-Life 1. Seeing the Snarks and Bull-squids from HL1 would have been great. Even better would have been if Episode 1 had some enemies and weapons from Opposing Force, but that was probably impossible for copyright reasons.

  • @Trevor6714
    @Trevor6714 6 месяцев назад

    I got bored of the citadel in og half-life 2, just felt really bland and boring. So it being the first chunk of episode one wasn’t doing it for me.
    I like fighting the ant lions cause it reminds me of starship troopers. But I DONT like having to close the holes with the gray gun and cars, thought it was kinda lame.

  • @YoJimBoHugabaJoe
    @YoJimBoHugabaJoe Год назад

    episode 1 was so bland, i barely remember any of it

  • @account2871
    @account2871 10 месяцев назад

    I never played the episodes, about to play episode two after finishing one. Underwhelming at best and frustrating at worst. That last fight with the strider was just a slog, mostly an environmental clusterf***.

  • @Uragan00829
    @Uragan00829 Год назад

    The part in the core was simply amazing. The rest? Meh.

  • @logannelson6429
    @logannelson6429 Год назад

    So weird they did this. I don’t like this since it’s basically dlc so and can’t be a new game just new maps and cutscenes

  • @arepasaxo
    @arepasaxo Год назад

    Hellloooou

  • @robdun6137
    @robdun6137 Год назад

    Episode 1 was alright i guess, nothing spectacular. Episode 2 on the other hand is my favourite Half-Life game.

  • @georgipavlov6881
    @georgipavlov6881 Год назад

    Worst HL game - Opposing Force by far lol