What happens when you cut a bone in half? [objection.lol]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 фев 2025
  • A discord debate among friends turned into an objection.lol
    I had a lot of fun making this so I hope you enjoy watching it.
    Add me on Discord: ♪ Salsa ♪#1413
    Follow me on Twitter: / salsaccino
    #aceattorney #objectionlol #phoenixwright #apollojustice #klaviergavin #godot #emaskye

Комментарии • 27

  • @firstrateduelist4377
    @firstrateduelist4377 2 года назад +20

    This entire video is logical math vs "1/10 = 1 whole"
    and I love it

  • @CadanL
    @CadanL 2 года назад +18

    One bone, two sandwich

  • @thehamtart9067
    @thehamtart9067 2 года назад +11

    Now hold up, by physical definition, a sandwich cut into two halfs makes two sandwiches, since each is still classified by definition to be a sandwich.

  • @breadisyummy_
    @breadisyummy_ 2 года назад +4

    Salsa’s tone is like dbz abridged goku

  • @arlo9754
    @arlo9754 Год назад

    it's one because if you cut a cellphone in half, you won't have 2 cellphones, you'll just have junk

  • @Endless-fire
    @Endless-fire 2 года назад +4

    There is an easier way to explain the subject. The differentiation between object and material.
    If you break both of your femurs in twain, you still have two femurs (object) but you have four shards of bone (material).
    So at the same time you have two bones (objects) and four bones (material).
    Same thing works with sandwiches and pizza, you can identify them by object (one whole) or by material (amount of fully disconnected pieces).
    It’s the difference between counting wholes and counting pieces, both are valid methods.

    • @sst4rscr34m
      @sst4rscr34m Год назад

      /femur breaker sound intensifies/

  • @Certez2
    @Certez2 2 года назад +2

    slice of pizza is pizza too but we used to call pizza the bigger one and slice of pizza the smaller ones

  • @occasionalsalem1
    @occasionalsalem1 2 года назад +5

    My dad could 100% answer this. He snapped his bone in half two days after my birthday (Feb 8th is when he broke his leg)

  • @লবণহানটারman
    @লবণহানটারman 2 года назад +2

    ur the most epik person on youtube

  • @d0nt.w0rry.ab0ut.1t
    @d0nt.w0rry.ab0ut.1t 2 года назад

    JOKES ON YOU, I HAVE AN EXTRA VERTEBRAE‼️ 207👍‼️‼️

  • @soulsmanipulatedinc.1682
    @soulsmanipulatedinc.1682 2 года назад +3

    Okay, but...how does cellular division fit into this?
    Cell divide themselves equally into two independently-evolving, initially identical, cells. Once division occurs, you cannot even say that they are two halves of one whole cell, since they both are entirely independent organisms at that point...right? So...what happens here?

    • @The_True_Mx_Pink
      @The_True_Mx_Pink 2 года назад

      They are two wholes derivative of a singular whole. If they were halves, they would be able to be put back together and recreate the original shape.

    • @soulsmanipulatedinc.1682
      @soulsmanipulatedinc.1682 2 года назад

      @@The_True_Mx_Pink No. I'm talking about the exact moment of their separation. At that point, they were ripped apart equally, but still ended up as completely independent organisms. However, if you mush together both parts together appropriately, you still would get the same cell with the same materials.
      By all accounts, you could use a knife to separate the cell and it still wouldn't make a difference. There is nothing uniquely different from cutting a sandwich in two and cell division, besides the end product. That's my point.
      You don't get two halves when you cut a cell in two, you get two wholes.

    • @The_True_Mx_Pink
      @The_True_Mx_Pink 2 года назад

      @@soulsmanipulatedinc.1682 Well if you cut a cell with a knife the cell fucking dies because that's not how mitosis works. Cellular fusion is not something that all cells can do, so if you tried to mush two cells together without properly combining them without the proper equipment then they'd just die, especially if they performed mitosis.

    • @soulsmanipulatedinc.1682
      @soulsmanipulatedinc.1682 2 года назад

      @@The_True_Mx_Pink Incorrect. If you cut a cell just before division (with a knife), then it can still live. And, in either case, that wasn't even the point of what I was saying. It was a hypothetical to better indicate how irrelevant a distinction between cellular division and cutting/tearing apart an object is. Cells litterally tear themselves in apart, mate!
      I also said "mushed together [..] appropriately", not just a random willy-nilly combination mind you; an "appropriately" controlled combination. I made that clear. Of course you need tools to reconstruct a cell from it's two children! ...however, what's your point?
      Are you claiming that you can reattach two halves of a sandwich too? How are you going to do that without an adhesive? Plus, even with an adhesive, you are technically adding to the structure, so you aren't exactly recreating the sandwich, in that case, either! You would need to somehow make the breads atoms reattach themselves to each other. Which is just...how?
      I don't see your point at all. You're needlessly nitpicking irrelevant details.

    • @The_True_Mx_Pink
      @The_True_Mx_Pink 2 года назад

      @@soulsmanipulatedinc.1682 First off, I'm glad I'm not the only one who needlessly edits and reedits my comments when I could've just revised what I said before I hit enter, that's good to see.
      Secondly, I didn't see the mush appropriately, I must've glanced over it, that is my bad. However, my point is something that requires additional explanation into further parts that I should've just done from the beginning.
      I think that the whole 'two bone' thing is separated into three categories. Things that are supposed to be separated, things that are supposed to be separated in a specific way, and things that are not supposed to be separated.
      Things that are supposed to be separated will create an additional whole when it is separated into fractions of itself. Playdough being a fine example of this.
      Things that are supposed to be separated in a specific way will become wholes if it's separated right, but will become fractions when separated wrong. Cells being a good example of this. Cells, when performing mitosis, separate into two cells.
      Things that are not supposed to be separated will always result in it being a "fraction". The bones being an example. 1 bone can be made into 2 bone pieces, but it cannot be 2 bones.
      Bread is all of these. Bread can be cut in anyway but still just be called bread. A loaf of bread, when cut right, makes slices of bread. If it's ripped apart, however, then it becomes pieces.
      A few rules do exist, though, and one of which is that all things can go through surgical separation, which is where you carefully make a smaller copy of the larger original, often by cutting pieces out of the bigger thing and mushing then back together. This can happen to anything with varying difficulty.
      The second rule is that if you separate too much, in size or quantity, then it will always become fragments.
      The third rule is that a fraction is something that can form the original shape.
      The last rule is there are always exceptions.
      So with all this in mind, yes. Sandwiches can be cut into wholes, fractions, and pieces.
      My point is convoluted, but maybe there.

  • @vanochristian7639
    @vanochristian7639 2 года назад

    I loved the thing at the end lol.

  • @AlphaPizzadog
    @AlphaPizzadog 2 года назад

    2 x ½ = 1