Many thanks for this video!! You did a fascinating research, it feels very nice to realize that someone cares enough about us to do so. Good luck on your future videos!
Lots of thanks to you my friend. Great job! By this work you demonstrated an approach towards scientific research which deserves much appreciation. That kind of scrupulous collecting of many historical facts is really impressive (some of them even unknown to other locals of Caucasian region not saying about the rest of Russian Federation and other parts of the World). Subscribed and spread the word.
Long live inghuetia long live Pakistan long live inghuetians Pakistan brotherhood long live inghuetia police long live Pakistan police with love from Pakistan
It caught me out of the blue in the dead of night this upload of the nation that does not comprise that of Shota Rustavelli Dmitry Gulia and Kosta Khetagurov encouraged me to watch it from start to finish!
Case you are looking up to the replies Andrew Two great ideas for future videos would be the Kaliningrad oblast and the Komi Republic I picked the former considering the recent controversy on behalf of the Russian government of the recent transit ban imposed by Lithuania !
With Ingushetia just declaring it's independence from the russian federation, I think the chechnyan tik-tok "soldiers" will soon be committing crimes against humanity there.
I don't believe Ingushetia has declared any independence at all. Might you be thinking of the Idel-Ural batallion who pledged to liberate their homeland or the Chechen soldiers fighting under the banner of Ichkeria (which I think Ukraine has recognised)?
I live in Ingushetia in the Caucasus. How can a small nation with a population of 500,000 people and the smallest territory of 3,100 km2 separate from the vast Russia with a population of 146 million people? It's just nonsense.
of course some serious research needs to be done, Alania is the unified word for the people living in the Caucasus. Right now for example Russia calls all peoples in the Caucasus: Caucasians. Same way Greeks and Romans called them Alans-Al(b)ans, Scythians etc. RUclips: ruclips.net/video/ZNc54RT3YEY/видео.html
@AllAboutRussia Just like the word Caucasians nowadays includes many nations in the Caucasus (maybe even in the USA 🙂), Alania is the unified name for peoples living in the area. Besides Alans there were Regal Alans. Ingushetia (Gelia) itself was governed by direct military democracy, there was no hierarchy. John Lecarre wrote about it in his book "Our Game": "It happens to be the Ingush because I love their love of freedom, because they never had a feudal system or an aristocracy, no serfs, no slaves, no social superiors or inferiors." This is a very important point too and different from Chechnya where they had the power vertical (similar to Russia) like Mansur, Imam Shamil, Dudayev, Kadyrov. Besides the fact that Chechens didn't want underdeveloped Ingushetia [*] by the way one of the reasons the Ingush didn't join Chechnya in 1991 was this difference in governing power vertical vs. power horizontal. Even now we have people's parliament with elderly representatives. Chechens try to copy but they didn't succeeded. Mr.Putin was forced to change 4 "presidents" in Ingushetia: Aushev, Zyazikov, Evkurov, and now Kalimatov. Two of them Zyazikov and Evkurov very very unpopular and were removed due to high degree of war which Russia doesn't want for a known reason. [*] The USSR just like Russian Empire intentionally didn't develop Ingushetia and kept it under economic sanctions there were no factories, airfields, universities, TB hospital or a TB sanatorium, national schools, educated people etc. the moneys from the central government settled mainly in Chechen part of ChIASSR, land disputes with ossetia (ossi) (Chechens were not stupid they knew if Ingush stay with Chechnya Russians could use provocations to attack the future Chechen-Ingush republic, so they got rid of the Ingush. On top of that Chechnya gained Naurski, Schelkovski, Kargalinski districts from the Soviet government as "compensation" for Ingush territories in Prigorodny district. So the Chechens were on top: developed country with functioning economy and additional 30% of the land. They didn't want Ingushetia. Ingushetia was left alone and of course it couldn't form an independent state even if they wanted to (as you mentioned no power plants, developed infrasturcutre etc).
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Nice, very nice!
Али Сун а ф яздяд хац ну ну лайкам отег е хьун аз))))
I'm glad you found the very interesting!
nice find of a topic, super glad to see your are still finding time for content!
Oh yes, I'm still creating content - just at a much slower pace than yourself!
@@allaboutrussia2022 its can certainly be a grind
@@GeoPerspective I've been checking in occasionally to see how your channel is growing. Super pleased to see its doing so well!
Many thanks for this video!! You did a fascinating research, it feels very nice to realize that someone cares enough about us to do so. Good luck on your future videos!
Thank you, I'm gld you enjoyed the video. Do let me know if I've missed anything!
As always your work is PRICELESS... i may be late for this one but keep it up! (I never though Ingushetia would be so interesting seriously)
Ingushetia is very much an enigma wrapped in a puzzle put in a box (where the key was lost!).
What a great video, very informative and interesting
Thank you, I'm glad you found it informative!
Lots of thanks to you my friend. Great job! By this work you demonstrated an approach towards scientific research which deserves much appreciation. That kind of scrupulous collecting of many historical facts is really impressive (some of them even unknown to other locals of Caucasian region not saying about the rest of Russian Federation and other parts of the World). Subscribed and spread the word.
I'm glad you found the video useful. Do feel free to peruse some of my other content as well :)
Good job Andrew.
Thank you, I'm glad you found it useful!
I HOPE THAT I SHALL BE ABLE TO SETTLE IN INGUSHETIA IN A NEAR FUTURE .
Thank you for your work ❤
You're very welcome, Ingushetia is a fascinating part of the world.
Good Video 👍
I'm glad you found it helpful!
Thx now I know more about my motherland
You're very welcome, I hope you found the video helpful!
Long live inghuetia long live Pakistan long live inghuetians Pakistan brotherhood long live inghuetia police long live Pakistan police with love from Pakistan
Assalam Alaikum to the Muslim brothers from Pakistan from the Muslim brothers of the Ingush from the Caucasus .
It caught me out of the blue in the dead of night this upload of the nation that does not comprise that of Shota Rustavelli Dmitry Gulia and Kosta Khetagurov encouraged me to watch it from start to finish!
I'm glad you found the video interesting!
@@allaboutrussia2022 Well I did!
What kind of food is from there?
Maybe you could talk about that in future videos?
Mostly MRE.
@@ingushkavkaz5835 why?
@@jimpennin9588 Constant wars shaped the menu: high energy and simple.
@@ingushkavkaz5835 similar to Georgian? I've been to a few Georgian restaurants.
Are you from that region of Russia?
@@jimpennin9588 I am from Ingushetia, and no it is not a region of Russia. Temporarily occupied country.
Thanks to Movsar Evloev
Case you are looking up to the replies Andrew Two great ideas for future videos would be the Kaliningrad oblast and the Komi Republic I picked the former considering the recent controversy on behalf of the Russian government of the recent transit ban imposed by Lithuania !
I will definately get to them, though I wouldn't hold your breathe...
@@allaboutrussia2022 Don't worry about that I am still holding it up until now in the meantime.
Андрей правильно будет ШОАН а не Шан.
Ah, apologies!
With Ingushetia just declaring it's independence from the russian federation, I think the chechnyan tik-tok "soldiers" will soon be committing crimes against humanity there.
I don't believe Ingushetia has declared any independence at all. Might you be thinking of the Idel-Ural batallion who pledged to liberate their homeland or the Chechen soldiers fighting under the banner of Ichkeria (which I think Ukraine has recognised)?
I live in Ingushetia in the Caucasus. How can a small nation with a population of 500,000 people and the smallest territory of 3,100 km2 separate from the vast Russia with a population of 146 million people? It's just nonsense.
of course some serious research needs to be done, Alania is the unified word for the people living in the Caucasus. Right now for example Russia calls all peoples in the Caucasus: Caucasians. Same way Greeks and Romans called them Alans-Al(b)ans, Scythians etc. RUclips: ruclips.net/video/ZNc54RT3YEY/видео.html
Yes, I had great difficulty in finding a map of 'Greater Ingushetia' as in the historic lands. Thank you for sharing your video :)
@AllAboutRussia Just like the word Caucasians nowadays includes many nations in the Caucasus (maybe even in the USA 🙂), Alania is the unified name for peoples living in the area. Besides Alans there were Regal Alans. Ingushetia (Gelia) itself was governed by direct military democracy, there was no hierarchy. John Lecarre wrote about it in his book "Our Game": "It happens to be the Ingush because I love their love of freedom, because they never had a feudal system or an aristocracy, no serfs, no slaves, no social superiors or inferiors." This is a very important point too and different from Chechnya where they had the power vertical (similar to Russia) like Mansur, Imam Shamil, Dudayev, Kadyrov. Besides the fact that Chechens didn't want underdeveloped Ingushetia [*] by the way one of the reasons the Ingush didn't join Chechnya in 1991 was this difference in governing power vertical vs. power horizontal. Even now we have people's parliament with elderly representatives. Chechens try to copy but they didn't succeeded. Mr.Putin was forced to change 4 "presidents" in Ingushetia: Aushev, Zyazikov, Evkurov, and now Kalimatov. Two of them Zyazikov and Evkurov very very unpopular and were removed due to high degree of war which Russia doesn't want for a known reason.
[*] The USSR just like Russian Empire intentionally didn't develop Ingushetia and kept it under economic sanctions there were no factories, airfields, universities, TB hospital or a TB sanatorium, national schools, educated people etc. the moneys from the central government settled mainly in Chechen part of ChIASSR, land disputes with ossetia (ossi) (Chechens were not stupid they knew if Ingush stay with Chechnya Russians could use provocations to attack the future Chechen-Ingush republic, so they got rid of the Ingush. On top of that Chechnya gained Naurski, Schelkovski, Kargalinski districts from the Soviet government as "compensation" for Ingush territories in Prigorodny district. So the Chechens were on top: developed country with functioning economy and additional 30% of the land. They didn't want Ingushetia. Ingushetia was left alone and of course it couldn't form an independent state even if they wanted to (as you mentioned no power plants, developed infrasturcutre etc).
Ничего не понял но было очень интересно.
Вы можете включить русские субтитры :)
Было бы хорошо если бы был перевод на русский❤❤❤
Вы можете включить русские субтитры :)
Рассказываешь про Ингушетию, а включаешь русскую музыку!!! Надо Ингушскую музыку включать
Разве вы не слышите повсюду музыку лезгинки?
В этом видео звучит смесь русской и ингушской музыки.